Fatigue crack growth behavior of Ti-6Al-6V-2Sn in methanol and methanol-water solutions

Differences in the corrosion fatigue crack growth behavior of anα–β titanium alloy in chloride-containing aqueous and methanol environments are reported, and discussed in relation to differences in repassivation behavior for the two types of environments. Experiments have been conducted with various solution mixtures of water (a passive film-forming environment) and methanol (a nonfilm-forming environment) to define the role of repassivation in controlling fracture modes and crack growth rates at different frequencies. The critical event in determining whether the repassivation process can suppress environmental fatigue fracture is the interaction between the rate of exposure of fresh metal surfaces at the crack tip and the rate at which they can be repassivated. The out-come of this mechano-chemical interaction is shown to be dependent on the frequency and stress intensity(ΔK) level as well as the chemistry of the environment. As a result, differences in repassivation behavior for methanol-water solutions can be correlated with major differences in fatigue crack growth rates and fracture modes at low ΔK levels, whereas repassivation differences have little effect at high ΔK levels. Based on these low-ΔK corrosion fatigue characteristics, methanol solutions are concluded to be far more detrimental to titanium alloys than aqueous solutions.     

Intrinsic fatigue crack growth

The influences of microstructure and deformation mode on inert environment intrinsic fatigue crack propagation were investigated for Al-Li-Cu-Mg alloys AA2090, AA8090, and X2095 compared to AA2024. The amount of coherent shearable δ (Al₃Li) precipitates and extent of localized planar slip deformation were reduced by composition (increased Cu/Li in X2095) and heat treatment (double aging of AA8090). Intrinsic growth rates, obtained at high constantK _max to minimize crack closure and in vacuum to eliminate any environmental effect, were alloy dependent;da/dN varied up to tenfold based on applied ΔK or ΔK/E. When compared based on a crack tip cyclic strain or opening displacement parameter (ΔK/(σ_ys E)^1/2), growth rates were equivalent for all alloys except X2095-T8 which exhibited unique fatigue crack growth resistance. Tortuous fatigue crack profiles and large fracture surface facets were observed for each Al-Li alloy independent of the precipitates present, particularly δ, and the localized slip deformation structure. Reduced fatigue crack propagation rates for X2095 in vacuum are not explained by either residual crack closure or slip reversibility arguments; the origin of apparent slip band facets in a homogeneous slip alloy is unclear. Better understanding of crack tip damage accumulation and fracture surface facet crystallography is required for Al-Li alloys with varying slip localization.     

Effect of silicon particles on the fatigue crack growth characteristics of Al-12 Wt Pct Si-0.35 Wt Pct Mg-(0 to 0.02) Wt Pct Sr casting alloys

Fatigue crack growth (FCG) characteristics and mechanisms in Al-Si-Mg eutectic casting alloys containing 0.35 wt pct Mg and 0 to 0.02 wt pct Sr were investigated as a function of stress ratio,R, stress-intensity-factor range, ΔK, and silicon (Si) particle size. The fatigue crack propagation behavior was compared with that observed in commercial casting alloy A356. At the same applied ΔK level, the crack growth rate was found to increase with increasing stress ratio and Si particle size. Modified (fine Si morphology) and A356 alloys showed better FCG resistance than the unmodified (coarse Si morphology) ones, for a constant applied ΔK, due to increased closure. The effects of roughness-induced and plasticity-induced crack closures, crack branching, and crack meandering on the fatigue crack propagation observed in these alloys have been discussed. The fatigue crack propagation path is found to be dependent on the Si particle characteristics. The mechanisms of silicon particle decohesion and cracking are also discussed. Formerly Research Associate, Département des Sciences Appliquées, Université du Québec à Chicoutimi     

Fatigue crack growth behavior of an oxide dispersion strengthened MA 956 alloy

Fatigue crack growth behavior of oxide dispersion strengthened ferritic MA 956 alloy was studied at 25 °C and 1000 °C in air at 0.17 Hz. The growth rates were analyzed using the linear elastic parameter ΔK and the elastic-plastic parameter ΔJ. Crack growth, although transgranular at both temperatures, increased by nearly three orders of magnitude with increase in temperature from 25 to 1000 °C. The growth rates were essentially the same in terms of either ΔK or ΔJ parameters indicating that plasticity effects are small even at 1000 °C. Detailed fractographic analysis revealed the presence of ductile striations in the ΔK range of 25 to 40 MPa√m at 25 °C and in a much narrower range at 1000 °C. Presence of voids could be detected at 1000 °C. Using the measured load-displacement hysteresis energies for a unit increment in crack length, crack growth rates were calculated using cumulative damage models and were compared with the experimental data. At 1000 °C the predicted and the experimental values agree within a factor of two and it is concluded that the growth occurs essentially by a damage accumulation process except in a narrow range of ΔK where the plastic blunting process is superimposed, resulting in ductile striations that were observed. At 25 °C the predicted and the experimental value reasonably agree for ΔK values greater than 40 MPa√m, and below this value the two diverge with predicted values being much lower. This divergence is related to occurrence of the plastic blunting process in this ΔK range as confirmed by fractographic evidence. The cumulative damage process at 1000 °C was related to the environmentally assisted void formation at dispersoid-matrix interfaces. At 25 °C the damage is related to the formation of microcracks ahead of the crack tip. These results and interrelation between alloy microstructure and fatigue fracture path are discussed in detail.     

Influence of gaseous environments on rates of near-threshold fatigue crack propagation in nicrmov steel

The influence of hydrogen environment (448 kPa) on near-threshold fatigue crack propagation rates was examined in a 779 MPa yield strength NiCrMoV steel at 93 °C. An automatically decreasing and increasing stress intensity technique was employed to generate crack growth rates at three load ratios(R = 0.1, 0.5, and 0.8). Results show that the crack propagation rates in hydrogen are slower than those in air for levels of stress intensity range, ΔK, below about 12 MPa√m. The crack closure concept does not explain the slower crack growth rates in hydrogen than in air. Near-threshold growth rates appear to be controlled by the levels of residual moisture in the environments. In argon and air, the fracture morphology is transgranular, while in H₂ the amount of intergranularity varies with ΔK and achieves a maximum when the cyclic plastic zone is approximately equal to the prior austenite grain size.     

Effects of load ratio and temperature on the near-threshold fatigue crack propagation behavior in a CrMoV steel

The influence of temperature in the range of 24 to 260 °C and load ratio on the near-threshold fatigue crack growth rate behavior of a CrMoV steel was characterized. At all temperatures investigated, the threshold stress intensity range, ΔK _th, for fatigue crack growth decreased with increasing load ratio. The near-threshold crack growth rates increased significantly at 149 °C when compared with the rates at room temperature. However, the crack growth rates at 260 °C were comparable to those at 149 °C. These observations are rationalized in terms of the concepts of roughness and oxide-induced crack closure. Extensive fracture surface characterization using SEM, oxide thickness measurements by Auger spectroscopy, and roughness measurements by light-section-microscopy were conducted to substantiate the explanations.     

Fatigue crack propagation in martensitic and austenitic steels

Fatigue crack growth rates were measured in an annealed and in an aged maraging steel and in three different austenitic steels. Microhardness measurements were used to determine the plane strain plastic zone sizes as a function of ΔK and to evaluate the cyclic flow stress of the material near the crack tip. The presence of a reversed cyclic plastic zone within the monotonic plastic zone was confirmed. The two maraging steels work soften near the tip of the crack while the three austenitic steels work harden. The fatigue crack growth rates of the maraging steels are independent of the monotonic yield stress and are typical of the growth rates of steels with a bcc crystal structure. The crack growth rates in the stainless steels are an order of magnitude lower than for maraging steels for ΔK< 30 ksi √in. The excellent fatigue crack growth resistance of austenitic stainless steels is related to the de-formation induced phase transformations taking place in the plastic zone and to the low stacking fault energy of the alloys.     

Near-threshold fatigue crack growth properties at elevated temperature for 1Cr-1Mo-0.25V steel and 12Cr stainless steel

Near-threshold fatigue crack growth properties were investigated for a low-alloy steel 1Cr-1Mo-0.25V and a stainless steel SUS403 (13Cr) in the temperature range from 25 to 550°C. Fatigue tests were conducted at frequencies of 0.5, 5, and 50 Hz, in a manner designed to avoid crack closure. The effective value of threshold stress intensity range increased with increasing temperature and with decreasing frequency for the Cr−Mo−V steel, whereas the effective threshold stress intensity range was independent of temperature and frequency in the case of the SUS403 steel. At a given ΔK value, the fatigue crack growth rates accelerated with increasing temperature and with decreasing frequency for the Cr−Mo−V steel. However, although the rate of fatigue crack growth was independent of frequency at a given temperature for the SUS403 steel, the rate did increase with temperature. The observed threshold levels and crack growth behavior were closely related to the oxidation process of the bare surface formed at the crack tip during each load cycle.     

Influence of inclusion content on fatigue crack

Fatigue crack growth rates were measured at room temperature in dry air for three 7075-T6 aluminum alloys with different inclusion content. Volume fractions of inclusions were determined for each alloy by the point count method with two different automated systems. Plots of the fatigue crack growth rate (da/dN) vs the stress-intensity-factor range (ΔK) show a well defined change of slope at the transition between plane strain and plane stress fracture. This transition is associated with a marked increase in the amount of fracture by void growth around inclusions. The volume fraction and mean spacing of voids within the cyclic plastic zone have been determined as a function of ΔK by quantitative fractography. Fracture by voids is important when the mean spacing of such voids is approximately equal to the width of the cyclic plastic zone in the plane of the crack. It is concluded that the inclusion content increases the fatigue-crack growth rates only within the plane stress range, that is for values of the stress-intensity-factor range ΔK \s> 20 kpsi√in.     

Fatigue crack propagation in aluminum-base copper alloys

Fatigue crack propagation ratesda/dN in binary Al alloys with 3.6 wt pct Cu and 6.3 wt pct Cu and commercial 2024 aged at 21°C were compared with 99.95⁺ wt pct aluminum. Omitting an anomalous region at lowΔK, the extrapolated rates for “pure” aluminum are more than 100 times greater than those in the three alloys at the same ΔK. The data for the alloys fit into a single scatter band of a factor of three. It was suggested thatda/dN varies inversely with the square of the strength of the alloy but that another parameter related to the fatigue crack propagation energy per unit area is also important. Theda/dN vs ΔK curves were determined for 3.6 wt pct Cu single crystals aged seven days at 21°C which containGP zones and two and seven days at 160°C which contain mixtures ofθ′ andθ′’. No systematic variation of (da/dN _Δ with crystallographic orientation was discerned, but the naturally aged specimen had a strong orientation dependence on crack initiation. At low ΔK 21°C aged specimens gave the lowestda/dN while at high ΔK the warm aged specimens gave the lower values ofda/dN. Measurement ofda/dN vs ΔK curves were conducted on specimens of 3.6 wt pct Cu with 1 mm equiaxed grains aged for various times at 130°C, 160°C, and 190°C. All warm aged specimens experienced brittle intergranular fracture at sufficiently high ΔK. The transition ΔK where intergranular fracture first appears is inversely proportional to the aging temperature. The change of fracture mode from intra to intergranular occurs gradually over a broad range of ΔK which shifts to lower ΔK with increase in aging temperature. This research was supportd by U.S. Air Force Office of Scientific Research, Office of Aerospace REsearch, Grant No. AF-AFOSR-73-2431.     

Elevated-temperature fatigue crack growth

The fatigue crack growth behavior of MAR-M200 single crystals was examined at 982 °C. Using tubular specimens, fatigue crack growth rates were determined as functions of crystallographic orientation and the stress state by varying the applied shear stress range-to-normal stress range ratio. Neither crystallographic orientation nor stress state was found to have a significant effect on crack growth rate when correlated with an effective ΔK which accounted for mixed-mode loading and elastic anisotropy. For both uniaxial and multiaxial fatigue, crack growth generally occurred normal to the principal stress direction and in a direction along which ΔK _II vanished. Consequently, the effective ΔK was reduced to ΔK_I and the rate of propagation was controlled by ΔK _I only. The through-thickness fatigue cracks were generally noncrystallographic with fracture surfaces exhibiting striations in the [010], [011], and [111] crystals, but striation-covered ridges in the [211] specimen. These fracture modes are contrasted to crystallographic cracking along slip bands observed at ambient temperature. The difference in cracking behavior at 25 and 982 °C is explained on the basis of the propensity for homogeneous, multiple slip at the crack tip at 982 °C. The overall fracture mechanism is discussed in conjunction with Koss and Chan’s coplanar slip model.     

Influence of impurity segregation on temper em brittlement and on slow fatigue crack growth and threshold behavior in 300-M high strength steel

Interactions between hydrogen embrittlement and temper embrittlement have been examined in a study of fracture and low growth rate (near-threshold) fatigue crack propagation in 300-M high strength steel, tested in humid air. The steel was investigated in an unembrittled condition (oil quenched after tempering at 650°C) and temper embrittled condition (step-cooled after tempering at 650°C). Step-cooling resulted in a severe loss of toughness (approximately 50 pct reduction), without loss in strength, concurrent with a change in fracture mode from micr ovoid coalescence to inter granular. Using Auger spectroscopy analysis, the embrittlement was attributed to the cosegregation of alloying elements (Ni and Mn) and impurity elements (P and Si) to prior austenite grain boundaries. Prior temper embrittlement gave rise to a substantial reduction in resistance to fatigue crack propagation, particularly at lower stress intensities approaching the threshold for crack growth(x0394;K _o). At intermediate growth rates (10^-5 to 10^-3 mmJcycle), propagation rates in both unembrittled and embrittled material were largely similar, and only weakly dependent on the load ratio, consistent with the striation mechanism of growth observed. At near-threshold growth rates (<10⁻⁵ to 10⁻⁶ mmJcycle), embrittled material exhibited significantly higher growth rates, 30 pct reduction in threshold ΔK_o values and intergranular facets on fatigue fracture surfaces. Near-threshold propagation rates (and ΔK_o values) were also found to be strongly dependent on the load ratio. The results are discussed in terms of the combined influence of segregated impurity atoms (temper embrittlement) and hydrogen atoms, evolved from crack tip surface reactions with water vapor in the moist air environment (hydrogen embrittlement). The significance of crack closure concepts on this model is briefly described. ntmis]formerly with the Lawrence Berkeley Laboratory, University of California in Berkeley. Formerly with the Lawrence Berkeley Laboratery, University of California in Berkeley.     

Environmental fatigue crack propagation of aluminum alloys at low stress intensity levels

Environmental fatigue crack propagation in 2024-T3, 7075-T6, and 7178-T6 has been studied at low levels of cyclic amplitude of stress intensity, ΔK. Both wedge force loading and remote loading techniques were employed to achieve the desired ΔK levels, and preliminary experiments were designed to test their compatibility. Testing was carried out in humid air, distilled water, and 3.5 pct sodium chloride solution, and the observed crack growth rates compared with those in desiccated air. Later studies were also conducted in an inert reference environment with a total water content of less than 2 ppm. When the data are plotted as log ΔK vs log d2a /dN, alloy 2024-T3 exhibits a marked slope transition, alloy 7075-T6 a slight slope transition, and alloy 7178-T6 a rectilinear behavior throughout the whole range of ΔK studied. The basic shape of these curves is discussed in terms of state-of-stress conditions at the crack tip, frequency effects, environmental effects, strain rate sensitivity, and metallurgical structure. An attempt is also made to correlate the rate of fatigue crack propagation in a particular environment and at a particular ΔK level with the fracture topography.     

Effect of microstructure,strength, and oxygen content on fatigue crack growth rate of Ti-4.5AI-5.0Mo-1.5Cr (CORONA 5)

Fatigue crack growth rate behavior in CORONA 5, an alloy developed for applications requiring high fracture toughness, has been examined for eight material conditions. These conditions were designed to give differences in microstructure, strength level (825 to 1100 MPa [120 to 160 ksi]), and oxygen content (0.100 to 0.174 wt pct), in such a manner that the separate effects of these variables could be defined. For all eight conditions, fatigue crack growth rates (da/dN) are virtually indistinguishable over the full spectrum of stress-intensity range (ΔK) examined,viz., 8 to 40 MPa√m (7 to 36 ksi√in). Concomitantly, it is noted that over the sizable solution annealing range studied (830° to 915 °C [1525° to 1675 °F]), the primary α-phase morphology was substantially invariant. Eachda/dN curve exhibits a bilinear form with a transition point (ΔKT) between 16 and 19 MPa√m (15 and 17 ksi√in). A change in microfractographic appearance occurs at ΔKT, as extensive secondary cracking along α/β interfaces is observed at all hypertransitional levels ofAK, but not for AK < ΔKT. For each material condition, the mean length of primary α platelets is approximately the same as the cyclic plastic zone size at ΔKT. Accordingly, locations ofAKT (and their similarity for the different material conditions) are rationalized in conformance with a cyclic plastic zone model of fatigue crack growth. Finally, the difference in behavior of CORONA 5, as compared to conventional α/β alloys such as Ti-6A1-4V, is rationalized in terms of crack path behavior.     

Effects of temper level on the dependence of fatigue crack growth threshold and crack closure on the prior austenitic grain size

An attempt has been made to systematically investigate the effects of microstructural parameters, such as the prior austenite grain size (PAGS), in influencing the resistance to fatigue crack growth (FCG) in the near-threshold region under three different temper levels in a quenched and tempered high-strength steel. By austenitizing at various temperatures, the PAGS was varied from about 0.7 to 96 μm. The microstructures with these grain sizes were tempered at 200 °C, 400 °C, and 530 °C and tested for fatigue thresholds and crack closure. It has been found that, in general, three different trends in the dependence of both the total threshold stress intensity range, ΔK _th , and the intrinsic threshold stress intensity range, ΔK _{eff, th} , on the PAGS are observable. By considering in detail the factors such as cyclic stress-strain behavior, environmental effects on FCG, and embrittlement during tempering, the present observations could be rationalized. The strong dependence of ΔK _th and ΔK _{eff, th} on PAGS in microstructures tempered at 530 °C has been primarily attributed to cyclic softening and thereby the strong interaction of the crack tip deformation field with the grain boundary. On the other hand, a less strong dependence of ΔK _th and ΔK _{eff, th} on PAGS is suggested to be caused by the cyclic hardening behavior of lightly tempered microstructures occurring in 200 °C temper. In both microstructures, crack closure influenced near-threshold FCG (NTFCG) to a significant extent, and its magnitude was large at large grain sizes. Microstructures tempered at the intermediate temperatures failed to show a systematic variation of ΔK_th and ΔK_{eff, th} with PAGS. The mechanisms of intergranular fracture vary between grain sizes in this temper. A transition from “microstructure-sensitive” to “microstructure-insensitive” crack growth has been found to occur when the zone of cyclic deformation at the crack tip becomes more or less equal to PAGS. Detailed observations on fracture morphology and crack paths corroborate the grain size effects on fatigue thresholds and crack closure. K.S. RAVICHANDRAN, formerly Research Scholar, Department of Metallurgy, Indian Institute of Science     

Corrosion fatigue crack growth of titanium alloys in aqueous environments

The rate of fatigue crack propagation for Ti-6Al-6V-2Sn and Ti-6 A1-4V in aqueous environments has been measured as a function of solution chemistry, frequency, and stress wave form. Depending on the specific encironment, three types of fatigue crack growth rate behavior have been observed as a function of frequency. Crack growth rates increase with decreasing frequency in distilled water, while addition of Na₂SO₄ produces frequency-independent behavior. In solutions containing chloride or bromide ions, a reversal in frequency-dependence takes place at ΔK_scc. Below this transition ΔK level, crack growth rates decrease with decreasing frequency due to passive film formation at the crack tip. Above ΔK_scc corrosion fatigue crack growth is due to SCC under cyclic loading. The ΔK transition in fatigue is lower than the static stress corrosion threshold because of repeated rupture of the passive film at the crack tip, approaching K_Isco only for very slow cycling frequencies. This paper is based upon a thesis submitted by D. B. Dawson in partial fulfillment of the requirements of the degree of Doctor of Science at Massachusetts Institute of Technology.     

The influence of aqueous environments on low δK and high ΔK fatigue crack propagation behavior in low carbon structural steels

The influence of aqueous environments on fatigue crack propagation behavior was investigated for two types of structural steel (SB42 and HT80) in pure and 3 pct NaCl water under freely corroding conditions. In the intermediate to high ΔK region, fatigue crack propagation rates were higher in both aqueous environments and in 1 atm hydrogen than in air for both types of steel, and the acceleration effect increased power functionally with decreasing frequency from 5 to 0.0005 Hz. Such a crack growth acceleration property was explained by the mechanism of cyclically induced hydrogen embrittlement, as shown by the brittle striations formed on the fracture surfaces. On the other hand, in the lower ΔK region, both aqueous environments inversely suppressed crack growth and enhanced the threshold stress intensity factor range ΔK _th just above the ΔK _th in air, while only in aerated 3 pct NaCl water was the crack observed to grow even under the condition below the ΔK _th in air, not showing the threshold. Probable mechanisms for such fairly complex environmental effects were also suggested.     

Low cycle fatigue crack propagation in hastelloy-X at 25 and 760 °C

Fatigue crack propagation tests were conducted on Hastelloy-X in air, at 25 °C and at 760 °C under controlled plastic strain amplitudes in the fully plastic low cycle fatigue regime. The crack growth rate data for different strain levels were correlated with the range of theJ integral ΔJ. The ΔJ values were calculated from finite element numerical solutions. It was found that the assumption thatda/dN =A(Δε _ρ ) ^α a is only an approximation of the more general equationda/dN =B(ΔJ) ^α in a narrow range of crack lengths. It is shown that theoretical models predicting low cycle fatigue lives by integrating the fully plastic crack growth rates will be in error if the (da/dN, ΔJ) relationship is not used.     

Microstructural effects and crack closure during near

Near threshold fatigue crack growth behavior of a high strength steel under different tempered conditions was investigated. The important aspect of the study is to compare the crack growth behavior in terms of the closure-free component of the threshold stress intensity range, ΔK _th,eff While a systematic variation in the absolute threshold stress intensity range with yield strength was observed, the trend in the intrinsic ΔK _th or ΔK _th,eff exhibited a contrasting behavior. This has been explained as due to the difference in fracture modes during near threshold crack growth at different temper levels. It is shown that in a high strength and high strain hardening microstructure, yielding along crystallographic slip planes is difficult and hence it exhibited a flat transgranular fracture. In a steel with low strain hardening characteristics and relatively low strength, a tendency to crystallographic planar slip is observed consequently resulting in high ΔK _th. Occurrence of a predominantly intergranular fracture is shown to reduce intrinsic ΔK _th drastically and increase crack growth rates. Also shown is that crack closure can occur in high strength steels under certain fracture morphologies. A ‘transgranular planar slip’ during the inception of a ‘microstructure sensitive’ crack growth is essential to promote intergranular and faceted fracture. The occurrence of a maximum in the fraction of intergranular fracture during threshold crack growth corresponds to the ΔK value at which the cyclic plastic zone size becomes equal to the prior austenitic grain size.