Exposure of agricultural pilots to occupational whole-body vibration: The effects of runway maintenance and the stages of flight

BackgroundAgricultural pilots fly inside rural areas, usually, in runways without proper maintenance. Neglected runway maintenance contributes to increased exposure to shocks and vibrations. On the other hand, during cruise and spraying, the pilot is not exposed to the effect of the runway surface, and thus the exposure may be different.ObjectiveThe aim of this study is to investigate the factors that may increase occupational exposure to WBV in agricultural pilots.MethodThe methodology used in this study consisted of evaluating the exposure of WBV according to the runway surface quality and the stages of flight for a sample of four different agricultural aircraft models.ResultsThe results confirmed that the magnitude of the vibration is significantly influenced by the runways surface quality and the stages of flight. This suggests the possibility to decrease the exposure to WBV improving runway maintenance and managing flight time.Relevance for the industryBased on the results of the present study, it was possible to define strategies to reduce whole-body vibration exposure and thus improve the working conditions of agricultural pilots.     

Whole body vibration exposure patterns in Canadian prairie farmers

Abstract

Whole body vibration is a significant physical risk factor associated with low back pain. This study assessed farmers’ exposure to whole body vibration on the Canadian prairies according to ISO 2631-1. Eighty-seven vibration measurements were collected with a triaxial accelerometer embedded in a rubber seat pad at the operator-seat interface of agricultural machinery, including tractors, combines, pickup trucks, grain trucks, sprayers, swathers, all-terrain vehicles, and skid steers. Whole body vibration was highest in the vertical axis, with a mean (range) frequency-weighted root mean squared acceleration of 0.43 m/s² (0.19?1.06 m/s²). Mean crest factors exceeded 9 in all 3 axes, indicating high mechanical shock content. The vertical axis vibration dose value was 7.55 m/s^1.75 (2.18?37.59 m/s^1.75), with 41.4% of measurements within or above the health guidance caution zone. These high exposures in addition to an ageing agricultural workforce may increase health risks even further, particularly for the low back.

Practitioner Summary: Agricultural workers are frequently exposed to whole body vibration while operating farm equipment, presenting a substantial risk to musculoskeletal health including the low back. Assessing vibration exposure is critical in promoting a safe occupational environment, and may inform interventions to reduce farmer’s exposure to vibration.     

Experimental analysis of occupational whole-body vibration exposure of agricultural tractor with large square baler

This study investigates longitudinal whole-body vibration in agricultural tractors powering a large square baler. The aim is to test the hypothesis that four-wheel drive has an influence on the longitudinal dynamic response. A number of experimental measurements are carried out on a specific vehicle combination driving uphill and downhill. The whole-body vibration exposure is measured at the operator seat under different conditions.The statistic results show a significant difference on the whole-body vibration exposure depending on operating conditions. Driving uphill and downhill with four-wheel drive activated showed the highest difference with increased vibration level at downhill driving.The results indicate that four-wheel drive influences the longitudinal dynamics and hence the whole-body vibration exposure on tractors with large square balers.Relevance to industryThe findings of this work are highly relevant to the manufacturers of agricultural tractors and machinery as well advisers within occupational health. The paper demonstrates potential in reducing damaging vibrations by simple manual or automatic control of four-wheel drive.     

Back pain and exposure to whole body vibration in helicopter pilots

Abstract

In a questionnaire survey the prevalence of back pain in 163 helicopter pilots was compared to that in a control group of 297 non-flying air force officers who underwent the same pre-employment medical examination. Since pilots document their hours of flight in a personal flight log, an accurate estimate of the duration of exposure could be made. In addition, vibration levels of the helicopters were measured and an accumulative vibration dose was calculated for each pilot. 'Transient' back pain of a short duration was more frequent amongst the pilots compared to the control group, and the prevalence of 'chronic' back pain of a persistent nature was also higher amongst the helicopter pilots. Transient back pain seemed to be most strongly related to the average hours of flight per day, whereas chronic back pain was more closely related to total hours of flight or the accumulative vibration dose. A significant higher prevalence of this chronic back pain was observed only after 2000 hours of flight or a vibration dose of 400 m^h/s. The observed health effects may be due to vibration or constrained posture but are most likely due to concomitant exposure to both factors.     

An optimal sampling approach to modelling whole-body vibration exposure in all-terrain vehicle driving

Abstract

Exposure to whole-body vibration (WBV) presents an occupational health risk and several safety standards obligate to measure WBV. The high cost of direct measurements in large epidemiological studies raises the question of the optimal sampling for estimating WBV exposures given by a large variation in exposure levels in real worksites. This paper presents a new approach to addressing this problem. A daily exposure to WBV was recorded for 9–24 days among 48 all-terrain vehicle drivers. Four data-sets based on root mean squared recordings were obtained from the measurement. The data were modelled using semi-variogram with spectrum analysis and the optimal sampling scheme was derived. The optimum sampling period was 140 min apart. The result was verified and validated in terms of its accuracy and statistical power. Recordings of two to three hours are probably needed to get a sufficiently unbiased daily WBV exposure estimate in real worksites. The developed model is general enough that is applicable to other cumulative exposures or biosignals.

Practitioner Summary: Exposure to whole-body vibration (WBV) presents an occupational health risk and safety standards obligate to measure WBV. However, direct measurements can be expensive. This paper presents a new approach to addressing this problem. The developed model is general enough that is applicable to other cumulative exposures or biosignals.     

Self-reported musculoskeletal problems amongst professional truck drivers

Occupational driving has often been associated with a high prevalence of back pain. The factors that contribute to cause the pain are diverse and might include prolonged sitting, poor postures, exposure to whole-body vibration and other non-driving factors such as heavy lifting, poor diet or other psychosocial factors. In Europe, truck drivers are likely to be considered an ‘at risk’ group according to the Physical Agents (Vibration) Directive and therefore risks will need to be reduced. This questionnaire-based study set out to examine the relationship between musculoskeletal problems and possible risk factors for HGV truck drivers to help prioritize action aimed at risk reduction. Truck drivers (n = 192) completed an occupational questionnaire with two measures of vibration exposure (weekly hours and distance driven). Items on manual handling, relevant ergonomics factors and musculoskeletal problems were also included. Reported exposures to vibration ranged from 12 to 85 h per week, with a mean of 43.8 h. Distances driven ranged from 256 to 6400 km (mean 2469 km). Most of the respondents (81%) reported some musculoskeletal pain during the previous 12 months and 60% reported low back pain. Contrary to expectations, vibration exposures were significantly lower among those who suffered musculoskeletal symptoms when distance was used as an exposure measure. Manual handling and subjective ratings of seat discomfort were associated with reported musculoskeletal problems.     

Self-reported musculoskeletal problems amongst professional truck drivers

Occupational driving has often been associated with a high prevalence of back pain. The factors that contribute to cause the pain are diverse and might include prolonged sitting, poor postures, exposure to whole-body vibration and other non-driving factors such as heavy lifting, poor diet or other psychosocial factors. In Europe, truck drivers are likely to be considered an 'at risk' group according to the Physical Agents (Vibration) Directive and therefore risks will need to be reduced. This questionnaire-based study set out to examine the relationship between musculoskeletal problems and possible risk factors for HGV truck drivers to help prioritize action aimed at risk reduction. Truck drivers (n = 192) completed an occupational questionnaire with two measures of vibration exposure (weekly hours and distance driven). Items on manual handling, relevant ergonomics factors and musculoskeletal problems were also included. Reported exposures to vibration ranged from 12 to 85 h per week, with a mean of 43.8 h. Distances driven ranged from 256 to 6400 km (mean 2469 km). Most of the respondents (81%) reported some musculoskeletal pain during the previous 12 months and 60% reported low back pain. Contrary to expectations, vibration exposures were significantly lower among those who suffered musculoskeletal symptoms when distance was used as an exposure measure. Manual handling and subjective ratings of seat discomfort were associated with reported musculoskeletal problems.     

Helicopter pilots’ views of air traffic controller responsibilities: a mismatch

Abstract

Controllers and pilots must work together to ensure safe and efficient helicopter flight within the London control zone. Subjective ratings of pilot perception of controller responsibility for five key flight tasks were obtained from thirty helicopter pilots. Three types of airspace were investigated. Results indicate that there is variation in pilot understanding of controller responsibility compared to the formal regulations that define controller responsibility. Significant differences in the perception of controller responsibility were found for the task of aircraft separation in class D airspace and along helicopter routes. Analysis of the patterns of response suggests that task type rather than the airspace type may be the key factor. Results are framed using the concept of a shared mental model. This research demonstrates that pilots flying in complex London airspace have an expectation of controller responsibility for certain flight tasks, in certain airspace types that is not supported by aviation regulation.

Practitioner Summary: The responsibility for tasks during flight varies according to the flight rules used and airspace type. Helicopter pilots may attribute responsibility to controllers for tasks when controllers have no responsibility as defined by regulation. This variation between pilot perceptions of controller responsibility could affect safety within the London control zone.     

Use of Highways in the Sky and a virtual pad for landing Head Up Display symbology to enable improved helicopter pilots situation awareness and workload in degraded visual conditions

Abstract

Flight within degraded visual conditions is a great challenge to pilots of rotary-wing craft. Environmental cues typically used to guide interpretation of speed, location and approach can become obscured, forcing the pilots to rely on data available from in-cockpit instrumentation. To ease the task of flight during degraded visual conditions, pilots require easy access to flight critical information. The current study examined the effect of ‘Highways in the Sky’ symbology and a conformal virtual pad for landing presented using a Head Up Display (HUD) on pilots’ workload and situation awareness for both clear and degraded conditions across a series of simulated rotary-wing approach and landings. Results suggest that access to the HUD lead to significant improvements to pilots’ situation awareness, especially within degraded visual conditions. Importantly, access to the HUD facilitated pilot awareness in all conditions. Results are discussed in terms of future HUD development.

Practitioner Summary: This paper explores the use of a novel Heads Up Display, to facilitate rotary-wing pilots’ situation awareness and workload for simulated flights in both clear and degraded visual conditions. Results suggest that access to HUD facilitated pilots’ situation awareness, especially when flying in degraded conditions.     

Fore-and-aft and dual-axis vibration of the seated human body: Nonlinearity,cross-axis coupling,and associations between resonances in the transmissibility and apparent mass

This study examined how the apparent mass and transmissibility of the human body depend on the magnitude of fore-and-aft vibration excitation and the presence of vertical vibration. Fore-and-aft and vertical acceleration at five locations along the spine, and pitch acceleration at the pelvis, were measured in 12 seated male subjects during fore-and-aft random vibration excitation (0.25–20 Hz) at three vibration magnitudes (0.25, 0.5 and 1.0 ms⁻² r.m.s.). With the greatest magnitude of fore-and-aft excitation, vertical vibration was added at 0.25, 0.5, or 1.0 ms⁻² r.m.s. Forces in the fore-and-aft and vertical directions on the seat surface were measured to calculate apparent masses. Transmissibilities and apparent masses during fore-and-aft excitation showed a principal resonance around 1 Hz and a secondary resonance around 2–3 Hz. Increasing the magnitude of fore-and-aft excitation, or adding vertical excitation, decreased the magnitudes of the resonances. At the primary resonance frequency, the dominant mode induced by fore-and-aft excitation involved bending of the lumbar spine and the lower thoracic spine with shear deformation of tissues at the ischial tuberosities. The relative contributions to this mode from each body segment (especially the pelvis and the lower thoracic spine) varied with vibration magnitude. The nonlinearities in the apparent mass and transmissibility during dual-axis excitation indicate coupling between the principal mode of the seated human body excited by fore-and-aft excitation and the cross-axis influence of vertical excitation.Relevance to industryUnderstanding movements of the body during exposure to whole-body vibration can assist the optimisation of seating dynamics and help to control the effects of the vibration on human comfort, performance, and health. This study suggests cross-axis nonlinearity in biodynamic responses to vibration should be considered when optimising vibration environments.     

The influence of low frequency vibration on pilot performance (as measured in a fixed base simulator)

This report describes a study on the effects of low frequency vibration on pilot performance. Army pilots acted as subjects and flew simulated helicopter missions in a realistic fixed base simulator environment. While flying the two-hour missions pilots were exposed to vibration stimuli varying in frequency from 6 to 12 Hz and in amplitude from ±0·1 to ±0·3g (measured at the floor). Measurements were taken of the vibration tramsmissibility of the pilot's seat so that the vibration actually felt by the subject could be determined.

Missions involved transporting external loads in a simulated logistics environment. Performance was evaluated by measuring flight path deviations from prescribed en route, approach, and hover parameters.

The vibration stimuli used did not degrade performance. In fact, performance tended to improve with increased stress. It is hypothesized that this trend was due to motivation, i.e. as subjects felt the onset of fatigue they compensated by working harder and thus tended to improve their performance.

On about 6% of their scores pilots exhibited sudden lapses in their ability to respond to display indications. This resulted in poor scores in the midst of otherwise normal data. These lapses are probably of very short duration (seconds in length) and seem to occur randomly. This same effect was also observed in a previous study by the author. It may be possible that lapses of this type are related to so called ‘pilot error’ accidents. Further research is needed to verify this.     

The Biodynamic Aspects of Low Altitude,High Speed Flight

Abstract

The physical forces encountered by an aircraft in low altitude, high speed flight can be particularly stressful to the aviator. The gross physical elements which make up this envelope are the dynamic profile of the aircraft, the flight pattern, and the dynamic profile of the atmospheric environment. The specific dynamic factors, whose application results in a physiological response in the pilot, are vibration, buffeting, angular acceleration, and gross acceleration of operator origin. The physiological systems of the aviator that are primarily responsive to the overall dynamic stresses are the cardiovascular, respiratory, neurohormonal, labyrinthine, visual and skeletal systems. The physiological variations observed in pilots in actual low altitude, high speed flight both in-flight and po3t-flight suggest the application of the general adaptation syndrome. Comparative results from in-flight observations and simulator studies demonstrate differences in physiological recordings which suggest the absence of apprehension as being a major defect in simulation as an indicator of pilot performance in low altitude, high speed flight. Protective systems for the pilot in the low altitude, high speed flight profile are those of good restraints, antibuffeting helmets, possible use of positioning and the use of an aeroplane which is ‘ least demanding ’ of the pilot. The need for more experimentation both in flight and in suitable simulators is apparent.     

Air-to-Air Combat Tactics Synthesis and Analysis Program Based on an Adaptive Maneuvering Logic

Abstract

Two digital computer programs synthesizing optimal maneuvers in one-on-one air-to-air combat situations are described. The method develops intelligently interactive maneuvers without relying on human pilot experience. One program drives one of the interacting aircraft, thus replacing one of the human pilots on the NASA Langley Research Center's Differential Maneuvering Simulator, this in real time. The other program operates in a normal batch processing mode. Both programs use the same technique which maps the physical situation of the two aircraft into a quantized, abstract situation space. The outcome in this situation space is predicted for several trial maneuvers, a value is associated with the outcome of each trial maneuver, and finally, the maneuver with the highest predicted value is executed.

These programs, operating with six degrees of freedom and realistic aerodynamic representation for both aircraft, provide a means for objective evaluation of weapons systems and pilot performance.     

The impact of different seats and whole-body vibration exposures on truck driver vigilance and discomfort

Laboratory studies have shown that exposure to whole-body vibration (WBV) increases physical and mental fatigue, which are common issues professional drivers face. The objective of this study was to determine whether altering WBV exposures had any effect on driver vigilance and discomfort. A repeated measures crossover design of five truck drivers with regular 10-h routes was used. Active and passive suspension truck seats were evaluated. For each seat, WBV exposures were measured. Participants completed a discomfort questionnaire and a reaction time task before and after their shift for two weeks, one week per seat. Compared with the passive seat, the active seat significantly reduced WBV exposures, decrements in the optimal and mean reaction times (p = 0.02, 0.047, respectively), and discomfort in the lower back and wrist(s)/forearm(s) (p < 0.01, 0.01, respectively). Study results indicated that reducing WBV helps reduce discomfort and maintain vigilance, which may improve drivers’ health and reduce the risk of truck collisions.

Practitioner Summary: The active suspension seat used in this study reduced truck drivers’ exposure to whole-body vibration (WBV) by over 33% in relation to their current industry standard passive suspension seat. This study demonstrated that reducing truck drivers’ exposure to WBV reduced fatigue and discomfort development over a workday.     

Combined exposures of whole-body vibration and awkward posture: a cross sectional investigation among occupational drivers by means of simultaneous field measurements

Abstract

Objective: Multifactorial workloads such as whole-body vibration (WBV), awkward posture and heavy lifting are potential predictors for low back pain (LBP). In this study, we investigate the association between LBP and these exposures among 102 professional drivers. Methods: The combined exposures of WBV and posture are measured at different workplaces. Health and personal data as well as information about lifting tasks are collected by a questionnaire. Results: The daily vibration exposure value (odds ratio 1.69) and an index for awkward posture (odds ratio 1.63) show significant association with the occurence of LBP. Awkward posture and heavy lifting appear to be more strongly associated with sick leave than WBV exposure. Furthermore, a combination of the measurement results of WBV and awkward posture into one quantity also shows significant correlation to LBP. Conclusion: The combined exposure of WBV and awkward posture can be described in terms of the daily vibration exposure and the index for awkward posture. This facilitates work place assessments and future research in this area.

Practitioner Summary: For the first time, quantitative measures combining whole-body vibration and awkward posture exposures have shown to correlate with the occurrence of low back pain significantly. This validates the proposed quantities and measurement methods, which facilitate workplace assessments and assist in the design of further studies which are necessary to establish a causal exposure–response relationship.     

Factors affecting the perception of whole-body vibration of occupational drivers: an analysis of posture and manual materials handling and musculoskeletal disorders

Due to the high cost of conducting field measurements, questionnaires are usually preferred for the assessment of physical workloads and musculoskeletal disorders (MSDs). This study compares the physical workloads of whole-body vibration (WBV) and awkward postures by direct field measurements and self-reported data of 45 occupational drivers. Manual materials handling (MMH) and MSDs were also investigated to analyse their effect on drivers' perception. Although the measured values for WBV exposure were very similarly distributed among the drivers, the subjects' perception differed significantly. Concerning posture, subjects seemed to estimate much better when the difference in exposure was significantly large. The percentage of measured awkward trunk and head inclination were significantly higher for WBV-overestimating subjects than non-overestimators; 77 and 80% vs. 36 and 33%. Health complaints in terms of thoracic spine, cervical spine and shoulder–arm were also significantly more reported by WBV-overestimating subjects (42, 67, 50% vs. 0, 25, 13%, respectively). Although more MMH was reported by WBV-overestimating subjects, there was no statistical significance in this study.     

Reducing whole-body vibration and musculoskeletal injury with a new car seat design

A new car seat design, which allows the back part of the seat (BPS) to lower down while a protruded cushion supports the lumbar spine, was quantitatively tested to determine its effectiveness and potentials in reducing whole-body vibration (WBV) and musculoskeletal disorders in automobile drivers. Nine subjects were tested to drive with the seat in: 1) the conventional seating arrangement (Normal posture); and 2) the new seating design (without BPS (WO-BPS) posture). By reducing contact between the seat and the ischial tuberosities (ITs), the new seating design reduced both contact pressure and amplitude of vibrations transmitted through the body. Root-mean-squared values for acceleration along the z-axis at the lumbar spine and ITs significantly decreased 31.6% (p < 0.01) and 19.8% (p < 0.05), respectively, by using the WO-BPS posture. At the same time, vibration dose values significantly decreased along the z-axis of the lumbar spine and ITs by 43.0% (p < 0.05) and 34.5% (p < 0.01). This reduction in WBV allows more sustained driving than permitted by conventional seating devices, by several hours, before sustaining unacceptable WBV levels. Such seating devices, implemented in large trucks and other high-vibration vehicles, may reduce the risk of WBV-related musculoskeletal disorders among drivers.     

Autonomous flight cycles and extreme landings of airliners beyond the current limits and capabilities using artificial neural networks

We describe the Intelligent Autopilot System (IAS), a fully autonomous autopilot capable of piloting large jets such as airliners by learning from experienced human pilots using Artificial Neural Networks. The IAS is capable of autonomously executing the required piloting tasks and handling the different flight phases to fly an aircraft from one airport to another including takeoff, climb, cruise, navigate, descent, approach, and land in simulation. In addition, the IAS is capable of autonomously landing large jets in the presence of extreme weather conditions including severe crosswind, gust, wind shear, and turbulence. The IAS is a potential solution to the limitations and robustness problems of modern autopilots such as the inability to execute complete flights, the inability to handle extreme weather conditions especially during approach and landing where the aircraft’s speed is relatively low, and the uncertainty factor is high, and the pilots shortage problem compared to the increasing aircraft demand. In this paper, we present the work done by collaborating with the aviation industry to provide training data for the IAS to learn from. The training data is used by Artificial Neural Networks to generate control models automatically. The control models imitate the skills of the human pilot when executing all the piloting tasks required to pilot an aircraft between two airports. In addition, we introduce new ANNs trained to control the aircraft’s elevators, elevators’ trim, throttle, flaps, and new ailerons and rudder ANNs to counter the effects of extreme weather conditions and land safely. Experiments show that small datasets containing single demonstrations are sufficient to train the IAS and achieve excellent performance by using clearly separable and traceable neural network modules which eliminate the black-box problem of large Artificial Intelligence methods such as Deep Learning. In addition, experiments show that the IAS can handle landing in extreme weather conditions beyond the capabilities of modern autopilots and even experienced human pilots. The proposed IAS is a novel approach towards achieving full control autonomy of large jets using ANN models that match the skills and abilities of experienced human pilots and beyond.

     

Hand-arm and whole-body vibrations induced in cross motorcycle and bicycle drivers

Generally, and particularly at sports, the human body is constantly exposed to physical requests and to tests in many different situations. Although the practice of sports is considered a healthy act, there are limits and, when these limits are reached, the benefits of sport can turn into problems. Thus, the biodynamic response method is increasingly being used to study the human injuries induced by external vibrations. Moreover, the European Directive 2002/44/EC on the minimum health and safety requirements, regarding worker exposure to risks from physical agents (e.g. vibration), limit the exposure to vibrations. The aim of this study is to analyze the exposure level of cross motorcycle and of cycling drivers to hand-arm vibration (HAV) and to whole-body vibration (WBV). For this research, vibration levels of a common 200 cc cross motorcycle were experimentally measured and the maximum driving time that could be safely used in a stone road was established. Moreover, bicycle vibration measurements were performed using two different bicycles: a road cycling bike; a bike for track cycling. The road bike was evaluated at three road scenarios: asphalt; paved; and stone road pavement. The track bike was evaluated in track cycling and rollers. In the case of cycling the results indicate that impacts and transient vibrations lead to a higher musculoskeletal request particularly in what concerns shoulders, arms, wrists, knees and spine.