Verifying apple cider plant sanitation and hazard analysis critical control point programs: choice of indicator bacteria and testing methods.

The objectives of this study were (i) to evaluate the survival of coliforms, Escherichia coli, and enterococci in refrigerated apple cider; (ii) to develop simple and inexpensive presumptive methods for detection of these bacteria; (iii) to perform a field survey to determine the prevalence of these bacteria on apples and in apple cider; and (iv) based on our results, to recommend the most useful of these three indicator groups for use in verifying apple cider processing plant sanitation and hazard analysis critical control point (HACCP) programs. Eight of 10 coliform strains (5 E. coli, 1 Enterobacter aerogenes, and 2 Klebsiella spp.) inoculated into preservative-free apple cider (pH 3.4, 13.3(o) Brix) survived well at 4 degrees C for 6 days (< or = 3.0 log10 CFU/ml decrease). Of 21 enterococci strains (Enterococcus faecalis, E. faecium, and E. durans), only 2 E. durans and 3 E. faecium strains survived well. Simple broth-based colorimetric methods were developed that detected the presence of approximately 10 cells of coliforms or enterococci. In three field studies, samples of unwashed apples (drops and picked), washed apples, and freshly pressed cider were presumptively analyzed for total coliforms, E. coli, and enterococci using qualitative and/or quantitative methods. Drop apples were more likely than picked apples to be contaminated with E. coli (26.7% vs. 0%) and enterococci (20% vs. 0%). Washing had little effect on coliform populations and in one field study was associated with increased numbers. Total coliform populations in cider ranged from < 1 CFU/ml to > 738 most probable number/ml, depending on the enumeration method used and the sample origin. E. coli was not recovered from washed apples or cider, but enterococci were present on 13% of washed apple samples. The qualitative coliform method successfully detected these bacteria on apples and in cider. Based on its exclusively fecal origin, good survival in apple cider, and association with drop apples, we conclude that E. coli is the most useful organism for verifying apple cider sanitation and HACCP programs.     

Use of hazard analysis critical control point and alternative treatments in the production of apple cider.

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the practices of Maryland cider producers and determine whether implementing hazard analysis critical control point (HACCP) would reduce the microbial contamination of cider. Cider producers (n = 11) were surveyed to determine existing manufacturing practices and sanitation. A training program was then conducted to inform operators of safety issues, including contamination with Escherichia coli O157:H7, and teach HACCP concepts and principles, sanitation procedures, and good manufacturing practice (GMP). Although all operators used a control strategy from one of the model HACCP plans provided, only one developed a written HACCP plan. None developed specific GMP, sanitation standard operating procedures, or sanitation monitoring records. Six operators changed or added production controls, including the exclusion of windfall apples, sanitizing apples chemically and by hot dip, and cider treatment with UV light or pasteurization. Facility inspections indicated improved sanitation and hazard control but identified ongoing problems. Microbiological evaluation of bottled cider before and after training, in-line apples, pomace, cider, and inoculated apples was conducted. E. coli O157:H7, Salmonella, or Staphylococcus aureus were not found in samples of in-line apple, pomace, and cider, or bottled cider. Generic E. coli was not isolated on in-coming apples but was found in 4 of 32 (13%) in-line samples and 3 of 17 (18%) bottled fresh cider samples, suggesting that E. coli was introduced during in-plant processing. To produce pathogen-free cider, operators must strictly conform to GMP and sanitation procedures in addition to HACCP controls. Controls aimed at preventing or eliminating pathogens on source apples are critical but alone may not be sufficient for product safety.     

Influence of fruit variety, harvest technique, quality sorting, and storage on the native microflora of unpasteurized apple cider

Apple variety, harvest, quality sorting, and storage practices were assessed to determine their impact on the microflora of unpasteurized cider. Seven apple varieties were harvested from the tree or the ground. The apples were used fresh or were stored at 0 to 4 degrees C for < or = 5 months and were pressed with or without quality selection. Cider yield, pH, Brix value, and titratable acidity were measured. Apples, postpressing apple pomace, and cider samples were analyzed for aerobic bacteria, yeasts, and molds. Aerobic bacterial plate counts (APCs) of ciders from fresh ground-picked apples (4.89 log CFU/ml) were higher than those of ciders made from fresh, tree-picked apples (3.45 log CFU/ml). Quality sorting further reduced the average APC to 2.88 log CFU/ml. Differences among all three treatment groups were significant (P < 0.0001). Apple and pomace microbial concentrations revealed harvest and postharvest treatment-dependent differences similar to those found in cider. There were significant differences in APC among apple varieties (P = 0.0001). Lower counts were associated with varieties exhibiting higher Brix values and higher titratable acidity. Differences in APC for stored and fresh apples used for cider production were not significant (P > 0.05). Yeast and mold counts revealed relationships similar to those for APCs. The relationship between initial microbial load found on incoming fruit and final cider microbial population was curvilinear, with the weakest correlations for the lowest apple microflora concentrations. The lack of linearity suggests that processing equipment contributed to cider contamination. Tree-picked quality fruit should be used for unpasteurized cider production, and careful manufacturing practices at cider plants can impact both safety and quality of the final product.     

Efficacy of sanitation and cleaning methods in a small apple cider mill

The efficacy of cleaning and sanitation in a small apple cider processing plant was evaluated by surface swab methods as well as microbiological examination of incoming raw ingredients and of the final product. Surface swabs revealed that hard-to-clean areas such as apple mills or tubing for pomace and juice transfer may continue to harbor contaminants even after cleaning and sanitation. Use of poor quality ingredients and poor sanitation led to an increase of approximately 2 logs in aerobic plate counts of the final product. Reuse of uncleaned press cloths contributed to increased microbiological counts in the finished juice. Finally, using apples inoculated with Escherichia coli K-12 in the plant resulted in an established population within the plant that was not removed during normal cleaning and sanitation. The data presented in this study suggest that current sanitary practices within a typical small cider facility are insufficient to remove potential pathogens.     

Isolation and characterization of Escherichia coli recovered from Maryland apple cider and the cider production environment

Contaminated apple cider has been implicated in several Escherichia coli O157:H7 outbreaks. In an attempt to investigate sources and modes of entry of E. coli into apple cider, samples of fresh apple, pomace, and cider and equipment and mill floor swabs were analyzed for standard plate counts (SPC), total coliforms (TC), fecal coliforms (FC), and E. coli. E. coli was isolated from 14 (33%) of 42 samples of bottled fresh cider, from food equipment in 6 (67%) of 9 mills, and from apples, pomace, or cider in 7 (78%) of 9 mills. Seventy-five E. coli isolates were further characterized for Shiga toxin-producing E. coli (STEC)-associated virulence factors, antimicrobial susceptibility, and pulsed-field gel electrophoresis (PFGE) type. No E. coli O157:H7 or other STEC was identified. Serotyping and PFGE revealed 64 distinct profiles, suggesting that recovered E. coli arose from multiple independent sources. However, on one occasion, E. coli isolated from the source apple sample was closely related to the E. coli identified in the finished cider sample. E. coli isolates were further tested for antimicrobial susceptibility to 17 antimicrobial agents of human and veterinary importance. Fourteen (19%) of the 75 isolates were resistant to at least one of the antimicrobial agents tested, and 9 (12%) were resistant to at least two of these agents. Of the resistant isolates recovered, 64% were resistant to tetracycline and 57% were resistant to streptomycin. Overall, the level of E. coli contamination in source apple samples did not differ significantly from those in samples of pomace, cider at the press, and cider entering the bottling tank; therefore, source apples cannot be dismissed as a potential contributor of E. coli to the cider-making process.     

Food Safety Interventions to Control Listeria monocytogenes in the Fresh Apple Packing Industry: A Review

Listeria monocytogenes, in fresh and ready‐to‐eat produce such as whole fresh apples, is of concern as there is no “kill step” in their packing process that would eliminate the pathogenic bacteria. Recent listeriosis outbreaks revealed that insufficient cleaning and sanitation practices in fresh apple packing houses may lead to contamination of fruit with L. monocytogenes. This article discusses three fundamental aspects for ensuring microbiological safety of fresh apples: protection of fresh apples from microbial contamination during the packing process, decontamination intervention techniques, and the challenges in removal of L. monocytogenes from fresh apples. Currently used and novel methods of fresh produce decontamination are discussed and evaluated on their usefulness for the apple packing process. Additionally, present regulatory requirements, possible routes of produce contamination, and bacteria attachment and survival mechanisms are described. Optimum methods for microbial decontamination of whole fresh apples are still to be determined. Critical aspects that should be considered in developing the interventions include apple morphology, conditions and scale of the packing process, and influence of the interventions on apple quality. Evaluation of the currently used and emerging decontamination methods indicated that the hurdle technology and rotating use of sanitizers to avoid development of bacterial biofilm resistance may give the best results, although not conclusively.     

Microbial levels in Michigan apple cider and their association with manufacturing practices

In recent decades, apple cider has been implicated in a series of outbreaks of foodborne illness. The objective of this study was to determine the presence and concentrations of pathogenic and indicator microorganisms in apple cider processed in Michigan and to evaluate the impact of thermal pasteurization, UV light radiation, and implementation of hazard analysis critical control point (HACCP) plans on these microbes. Cider samples were obtained from Michigan mills between 1997 and 2004 and analyzed for Escherichia coli O157:H7, Salmonella, generic E. coli, total coliforms, and aerobic bacteria. Neither E. coli O157:H7 nor Salmonella were detected in any tested cider samples, suggesting a very low frequency of pathogens in Michigan apple cider. The persistent and relatively high frequency of generic E. coli observed in samples obtained in all years indicates a continued risk of pathogen contamination in Michigan apple cider, especially when it is untreated. The use of thermal pasteurization or UV light radiation and reported implementation of HACCP plans were associated with lower frequency and counts of generic E. coli, total coliforms, and aerobic microorganisms. However, the relatively high counts of indicator organisms in some cider samples that were claimed to be treated according to these pathogen reduction measures indicates that some processors had inadequate practices, facilities, or equipment for pathogen reduction or did not consistently or adequately apply practices or pathogen-reduction equipment in an effective manner.     

MICROBIAL QUALITY OF FRESH‐CUT ICEBERG LETTUCE WASHED IN WARM OR COLD WATER AND IRRADIATED IN A MODIFIED ATMOSPHERE PACKAGE*

ABSTRACT

The microbial keeping quality of fresh‐cut iceberg lettuce was determined after being washed in either cold water (5C) for 3 min or warm water (47C) for 2 min followed by a cold water rinse (5C) and packaged in a modified atmosphere film bag. The lettuce samples were treated with gamma radiation to 0, 1 or 2 kGy while maintaining a refrigerated temperature (4C). The samples were analyzed for total aerobic, total coliform and Enterobacteriaceae counts after refrigerated storage up to 12 days. No difference in aerobic counts was observed between the hot‐ and cold‐washed samples immediately after washing. The coliform and Enterobacteriaceae counts were reduced by 2 log after the warm water wash and no difference for the cold water‐washed sample. The irradiation treatment at 1 kGy reduced the aerobic, coliform and Enterobacteriaceae counts by 2 log for the warm‐washed samples. At the 2‐kGy treatment level, the aerobic and coliform counts were reduced by 3 log for the cold‐washed lettuce, whereas the Enterobacteriaceae counts were reduced by only 2 log. The observed log reductions in bacterial counts after irradiation were maintained for 12 days when stored at 4C. The combination of a cold water wash and irradiation to 2 kGy had the best microbial keeping quality.

PRACTICAL APPLICATIONS

Fresh‐cut lettuce, when washed in either cold or warm water, shows neither an appreciable removal of the microbial load nor a significant increase in the keeping quality when compared with unwashed fresh‐cut controls. Placing the washed lettuce into modified atmosphere packaging (MAP) did not lessen the overall bacteriologic load, and after 12 days of storage at 4C, the microbial counts increased. However, gamma irradiation of the washed, MAP‐stored lettuce to a dose of 2 kGy significantly reduces the overall microbe count, thereby increasing both the shelf life and the safety of the produce. A 2‐kGy dose of gamma irradiation provides a pathogen‐free, long shelf life, fresh‐cut lettuce that is bacteriologically safer and sensorially indistinguishable from bagged, nonirradiated, fresh‐cut lettuce.     

SURVEY OF APPLE GROWING, HARVESTING, AND CIDER MANUFACTURING PRACTICES IN WISCONSIN: IMPLICATIONS FOR SAFETY

To evaluate the safety of current apple growing, harvesting and cider manufacturing practices in Wisconsin, cider manufacturers were contacted in a three-phase survey. Results revealed that seasonal, small-scale production was characteristic of the industry. Most cider mills produced less than 5,000 gal/year; only 6% produced more than 20,000 gal/year. Most cider makers used only tree picked apples (86%), inspected apples before washing (94%), washed (93%) and brushed (87%) apples, but only 16% of mills sanitized washed apples. Most mills (92%) sanitized cider making equipment after each use; however, only a few sanitized between custom pressing apples from different customers. Respondents reported that they strived to improve cider safety by pasteurization (43% of all cider), UV light treatment (4%), use of preservatives (30%), and HACCP (17%). For 31% of all cider, however, processors relied solely on refrigeration and/or freezing. These results show that most cider mills practice many steps believed to enhance cider safety, but results also identify procedures that must be addressed to further improve cider safety.     

Apple quality,storage, and washing treatments affect patulin levels in apple cider

Patulin is a mycotoxin produced primarily by Penicillium expansum, a mold responsible for rot in apples and other fruits. The growth of this fungus and the production of patulin are common in fruit that has been damaged. However, patulin can be detected in visibly sound fruit. The purpose of this project was to determine how apple quality, storage, and washing treatments affect patulin levels in apple cider. Patulin was not detected in cider pressed from fresh tree-picked apples (seven cultivars) but was found at levels of 40.2 to 374 microg/liter in cider pressed from four cultivars of fresh ground-harvested (dropped) apples. Patulin was not detected in cider pressed from culled tree-picked apples stored for 4 to 6 weeks at 0 to 2 degrees C but was found at levels of 0.97 to 64.0 microg/liter in cider pressed from unculled fruit stored under the same conditions. Cider from controlled-atmosphere-stored apples that were culled before pressing contained 0 to 15.1 microg of patulin per liter, while cider made from unculled fruit contained 59.9 to 120.5 microg of patulin per liter. The washing of ground-harvested apples before pressing reduced patulin levels in cider by 10 to 100%, depending on the initial patulin levels and the type of wash solution used. These results indicate that patulin is a good indicator of the quality of the apples used to manufacture cider. The avoidance of ground-harvested apples and the careful culling of apples before pressing are good methods for reducing patulin levels in cider.     

A study of U.S. orchards to identify potential sources of Escherichia coli O157:H7

The association of unpasteurized apple cider with Escherichia coli O157:H7 foodborne illness has led to increased interest in potential reservoirs of this pathogen in the orchard. Fourteen U.S. orchards were surveyed in autumn 1999 to determine the incidence and prevalence of E. coli O157:H7, E. coli, total aerobic microflora, and yeasts and molds. Fruit samples (n = 63) (eight apple and two pear varieties) and soil, water, and fecal samples were collected. Samples were plated on (i) tryptic soy agar for total mesophilic aerobic count, (ii) E. coli and coliform Petrifilm for total coliforms and E. coli, and (iii) yeast and mold Petrifilm. Samples positive for coliforms and E. coli were enriched and tested for E. coli O157:H7. Fruit was also tested for internalization of microflora by aseptically removing the core, stem, and calyx areas, and the individual sections were assessed for the categories of microflora listed above. E. coli was detected in soil and water and in 6% of fruit samples (three pear samples and one apple sample), generally collected from areas previously designated as high risk in this study. However, no E. coli O157:H7 was found. Coliforms were found in 74% of fruit samples and were internalized in the cores of 40% of fruit tested. Yeasts and molds were internalized in 96.7% of samples and aerobic bacteria in 89.6%. E. coli was not found to be internalized. Total aerobic counts and total coliforms were higher in dropped and damaged fruit (P < 0.05). Findings suggest that dropped or damaged fruit should not be included in fruit designated for the production of unpasteurized juice or for the fresh or fresh-cut market. In addition, orchards should be located away from potential sources of contamination, such as pastures.     

Location of Escherichia coli O157:H7 on and in apples as affected by bruising, washing, and rubbing

Confocal scanning laser microscopy (CSLM) was used to determine the location of Escherichia coli O157:H7 cells on the surface and in tissue of bruised Red Delicious cv. apples. Undamaged and bruised apples were inoculated by immersing in a suspension of E. coli O157:H7 cells transformed with a plasmid that encodes for the production of a green fluorescent protein. Apples were then washed in 0.1% (wt/vol) peptone water and/or rubbed with a polyester cloth and examined to determine if these treatments removed or introduced cells into lenticels, cutin, and cracks on the skin surface. Optical slices of the apples obtained using CSLM were examined to determine the depth at which colonization or attachment of cells occurred. Populations of E. coli O157:H7 on the surface of apples were determined to assess the effectiveness of washing and rubbing in physically removing cells. The location of cells on or in undamaged and bruised areas of apples that were not washed or rubbed did not differ significantly. However, washing apples resulted in an approximate 2-log reduction in CFU of E. coli O157:H7 per cm2 of apple surface. On unwashed apples, cells were detected at depths up to 30 microm below the surface. No E. coli O157:H7 cells were detected at locations more than 6 microm below the surface of washed apples. Cells that remained on the surface of rubbed apples appeared to be sealed within naturally occurring cracks and crevices in waxy cutin platelets. These cells may be protected from disinfection and subsequently released when apples are eaten or pressed for cider production.     

Microbial Populations and Malolactic Fermentation of Apple Cider using Traditional and Modified Methods

The evolution of yeasts and lactic acid bacteria was examined during two methods of cider making: the traditional employed unwashed apples of different varieties and the modified used a sole washed acidic apple variety with temperature control during the cider making process. The alcoholic fermentation was carried out mainly by Kloeckera apiculata and Sacharomyces cerevisiae species, and their distributions were similar in the two methods. In the traditional, the malolactic fermentation proceeded at the same time as alcoholic fermentation and the “piqure lactique” occurred. In the modified method, no malolactic fermentation took place. In all musts, a fundamentally heterofermentative lactic flora was found, with Lactobacillus species most abundant in the traditional process.     

传统豆腐微生物污染途径的研究

为了解豆腐制作全过程的微生物污染情况,在实验室模拟了市售豆腐制作工艺的各个加工工序和操作环节,通过对各个工序进行微生物检测,来描述各个工序对成品豆腐的污染情况。经研究发现,大豆经清洗后细菌总数比未清洗的大豆减少了70%,大肠菌群总数下降了75%。得出最佳的浸泡参数为:自来水清洗并浸泡,浸泡温度控制在12～15℃之间,浸泡时间为10h。检测并对比了豆浆煮浆前后的微生物变化情况,同时发现凝固剂中含有大量的微生物,这是造成豆浆二次污染的主要污染源。     

苹果酒中酚酸、黄烷-3-醇的检测

以小国光(Ralls)和富士(Fuji)及其所酿制的新鲜苹果酒为试验材料,采用反相高效液相色谱法测定分析苹果原汁、发酵中酒样和苹果成品酒中11种酚酸、5种黄烷-3-醇的含量。结果表明:苹果和苹果酒中存在4种酚酸(原儿茶酸、绿原酸、咖啡酸、对-香豆酸)、2种黄烷-3-醇(儿茶素和表儿茶素);不同品种的苹果原汁和苹果成品酒中酚类物质的含量都存在显著差异。其中,小国光苹果和小国光苹果酒中的酚类物质总含量较高;对于每个品种,绿原酸都是最主要的酚酸类物质,含量最高的黄烷-3-醇类物质都是表儿茶素。随着发酵过程的进行,苹果酒中酚类物质的含量有不同程度的增加。其增加趋势为S型曲线,即先平缓再较快再平缓。     

Characterization of Apples and Apple Cider Produced by a Guelph Area Orchard

Thermal stability of food-borne pathogens in apple cider is influenced by the composition of the product. As a preliminary step to determine the effect of pasteurization of apple cider on the survival of Escherichia coli O157:H7, a study was carried out to characterize apples and unpasteurized apple cider produced by a Guelph area orchard. Samples of commercial unpasteurized cider and the constituent apples were collected over 13 wk from August to November 1998, and unpasteurized laboratory cider was made from the individual apple varieties. pH, titratable acidity, turbidity, total microbial counts, total solids and °Brix for filtered and unfiltered samples were measured. The maximum, minimum, and average values for all unpasteurized commercial cider samples were found as follows: pH, 3.71, 3.17, and 3.43; titratable acidity, 93.47, 49.46, and 69.95 mL of 0.1 N NaOH/100 mL; total solids, 13.21, 10.93, and 11.90%; °Brix, 13.01, 11.17, and 12.02; turbidity, 238.1, 145.1, and 204.9 nephelometric turbidity units; and total plate count, 4.91, 2.61, 3.75 log cfu/mL. There were no significant differences (P>0.05) between filtered and unfiltered samples. In addition, in commercial unpasteurized cider, there were no significant differences (P>0.05) with respect to any of the factors with the time of processing. The composition of the unpasteurized laboratory cider made from individual apple varieties was dependent on the variety, but was generally within the ranges from the published literature values. McIntosh apples showed a significant (P\le0.05) decrease in titratable acidity with time of harvest. The results suggest that it is necessary to take the composition of commercial apple cider into account when developing thermal inactivation models for food-borne pathogens.     

Short communication: Snapshot of industry milk hauling practices in the western United States

The Pasteurized Milk Ordinance (PMO) mandates milk hauling sanitation and operational practices; however, the use of vague language (i.e., “as needed”) and gaps in processes lead to variability in industry practices. Our aim was to characterize industry milk hauling practices and identify areas that may be an unexplained source of contamination in the dairy processing continuum, and communicate this information with industry to cultivate best practices. The objectives of this study were to (1) survey industry hauling sanitation and operation practices in the Pacific Northwest region of the United States, and (2) quantify microbial populations [aerobic plate count (APC), lactic acid bacteria, coliforms] on the internal surfaces of transfer hoses (tanker and receiving bay) to determine their potential contribution to the microbiological quality of raw milk. Eleven facilities (78% response rate) participated in our survey. All facilities surveyed were compliant with the PMO; however, overall milk reception layout, sanitation practices, and routine maintenance greatly varied between facilities. Farm hose samples (n = 115) had significantly higher microbial loads (APC: mean 4.7 log cfu/100 cm²; median 5.1 log cfu/cm²) than receiving hose samples (n = 57; APC: mean: 2.1 log cfu/100 cm²; median 1.9 log cfu/100 cm²). Microbial populations on transfer hose surfaces did not correlate with time since last cleaning for either tanker or receiving bay hoses. Microbial content of farm hoses is likely to reflect the microbial quality of the previous milk transferred through the hose, making on-farm management practices the primary consideration to maintain low microbiological counts downstream. Upon arrival at the processor, 10% of farm hoses were missing caps. Although this did not correlate with elevated microbiological counts, uncapped farm hoses are exposed to the farm environment, provide opportunity for contamination, and are in violation of the PMO. Through observations made during our studies, manual cleaning procedures appear to be a major weakness in hauling practices and need more attention. Recognizing and communicating variability and areas of weakness allows industry to elevate their hauling sanitation and operational practices to maintain optimum milk microbiological quality.     

Characterization of Apples and Apple Cider Produced by a Guelph Area Orchard

Thermal stability of food-borne pathogens in apple cider is influenced by the composition of the product. As a preliminary step to determining the effect of pasteurization of apple cider on survival of E. coli O157:H7, a study was carried out to characterize apples and unpasteurized apple cider produced by a guelph area orchard. Samples of commercial unpasteurized cider and the constituent apples were collected over 13 wk from August to November 1998, and unpasteurized laboratory cider was made from the individual apple varieties. pH, titratable acidity (TA), turbidity, total microbial counts, total solids and °brix for filtered and unfiltered samples were measured. The maximum, minimum, and average values for all unpasteurized commercial cider samples were found to be: pH, 3.71, 3.17, and 3.43; TA, 93.47, 49.46, and 69.95 mL of 0.1 N NaOH/100 mL; total solids, 13.21, 10.93, and 11.90%; °brix, 13.01, 11.17, and 12.02; turbidity, 238.1, 145.1, and 204.9 NTU; and total plate count, 4.91, 2.61, 3.75 log cfu·mL⁻¹. There were no significnat differences (P>0.05) between filtered and unfiltered samples. In addition, in commercial unpasteurized cider, there were no significant differences (P>0.05) with respect to any of the factors with time of processing. The composition of the unpasteurized laboratory cider made form individual apple varieties was dependent on the variety, but was generally within the ranges from published literature values. Mclntosh apples showed a significant (P≤0.05) decrease in TA with time of harvest. The results suggest that it is necessary to take the composition of commercial apple cider into account when developing thermal inactivation models for food-borne pathogens.     

Efficacy of home washing methods in controlling surface microbial contamination on fresh produce

Much effort has been focused on sanitation of fresh produce at the commercial level; however, few options are available to the consumer. The purpose of this study was to determine the efficacy of different cleaning methods in reducing bacterial contamination on fresh produce in a home setting. Lettuce, broccoli, apples, and tomatoes were inoculated with Listeria innocua and then subjected to combinations of the following cleaning procedures: (i) soak for 2 min in tap water, Veggie Wash solution, 5% vinegar solution, or 13% lemon solution and (ii) rinse under running tap water, rinse and rub under running tap water, brush under running tap water, or wipe with wet/dry paper towel. Presoaking in water before rinsing significantly reduced bacteria in apples, tomatoes, and lettuce, but not in broccoli. Wiping apples and tomatoes with wet or dry paper towel showed lower bacterial reductions compared with soaking and rinsing procedures. Blossom ends of apples were more contaminated than the surface after soaking and rinsing; similar results were observed between flower section and stem of broccoli. Reductions of L. innocua in both tomatoes and apples (2.01 to 2.89 log CFU/g) were more than in lettuce and broccoli (1.41 to 1.88 log CFU/g) when subjected to same washing procedures. Reductions of surface contamination of lettuce after soaking in lemon or vinegar solutions were not significantly different (P > 0.05) from lettuce soaking in cold tap water. Therefore, educators and extension workers might consider it appropriate to instruct consumers to rub or brush fresh produce under cold running tap water before consumption.