Diet and growth effects in panel assessment of sheepmeat odour and flavour

The effects of sheep age and diet on several odours and flavours are described. Ram lambs raised on ewe's milk then a corn-based diet were compared with lambs raised on milk and a pasture of grass/clover, six treatments in all. A seventh treatment comprised very old ewes maintained on pasture. Fat and lean from forequarters was minced and cooked together. Cooked lean was assessed for intensity by a sensory panel for 10 flavour attributes. Four showed significant (P < 0.01) treatment effects: 'sheepmeat', 'animal', 'liver', and 'poultry'. Sheepmeat flavour was highest in the slow-grown pasture-fed lambs. Animal flavour-the flavour associated with the odour of confined livestock-showed a similar pattern with treatment. Liver flavour was highest in ewe meat, and the biochemical origin of this flavour is discussed. Eleven related odour attributes were assessed on the rendered fat with a novel olfactometer. Five attributes showed highly significant treatment effects for intensity (P < 0.001): animal and sheepmeat odours showed a similar distribution to the equivalent flavours; likewise cabbage and rancid odours were associated with the two slow-grown pasture treatments. A comparison of the odour and flavour statistics showed that the sense of smell was the more discriminating in sheepmeat assessment, and also confirmed that fat was the true source of sheepmeat odour/flavour. In respect of sheepmeat production for effective marketing, the data showed that at 90 days, a pastoral diet resulted in slightly enhanced odours when compared with a corn-based diet. By 215 days, however, many undesirable odours were exacerbated. Since these older rams were more sexually developed, a sex rather than an age effect could not be excluded. Rendered fat from this work was further used in a companion study (Yang et al., 1997. Meat Sci., 45, 183-200) in an attempt to link individual volatile compounds to odour attributes.     

Sensory evaluation of young goat meat

Loins from 12 young goats (three extensively reared-entire males, EE; three extensively reared-castrated males, EC; three intensively reared-entire males, IE; four intensively reared-castrated males, IC) were assessed by a trained panel of eight assessors for odour, flavour and texture using 100 mm unstructured scales. Procrustes analysis was used to produce the spatial configuration of the samples. The first principal axis explained 44.9% of the variation and was mainly based on textural attributes. The second principal axis accounted for 21.3% of the variation and was mainly related to odour and flavour. Samples obtained from groups EE and EC were more tender and juicy, whereas, IE animals produced a more cohesive meat. Groups IE and IC produced a more stringy meat, with a higher meaty odour and flavour. The rearing system affected texture more than odour and flavour, whereas sex had little effect on textural attributes compared with odour and flavour.     

Effect of Brussels sprouts and inulin/rape seed cake on the sensory profile of pork M. longissimus dorsi

The objective of the present study was to evaluate the influence of two diets containing either Brussels sprouts or inulin/rape seed cake, compared with a standard diet (control) for slaughter pigs on flavour and odour attributes and sensory profile of cooked pork. Three weeks prior to slaughter 24 female pigs were allocated to three diets: (1) a standard grower-finishing diet (control) for slaughter pigs containing barley, wheat and soy-bean meal, (2) the control diet containing 11 energy percent Brussels sprouts and (3) a diet containing 25% inulin and 55% rape seed cake. The odour and flavour of the cooked meat from inulin/rape seed cake-fed pigs differed significantly from the other two diets, showing reduced meat odour, increased pig and acrid odour, increased pig flavour, reduced fresh flavour and total impression. Meat from the Brussels sprouts-fed pigs deviated only slightly from the control-fed pigs.     

Effect of transport time on sensorial aspects of beef meat quality

Forty-eight slaughter bulls were transported by road in groups of eight for approximately 30 min, 3 h and 6 h in two replicates. After slaughter and an ageing time of 7 days, steaks from the longissimus dorsi thoracis were tasted by a trained sensory panel in terms of odour, tenderness, residue, juiciness, flavour intensity, flavour quality, and overall liking. Transport time had a significant effect (P<0.05) on meat tenderness and overall liking. The panel preferred meat from animals given the 3-h journey as opposed to the 30 min or 6-h journey and found it was more tender and had a better overall liking.     

Effect of breed and ageing time on meat quality and sensory attributes of veal calves of the "Ternera de Aliste" Quality Label

The effect of breed, sex and ageing time on carcass, meat and eating quality were examined in 32 calves of the "Ternera de Aliste" Spanish Quality Label. Swiss Brown×Alistano-Sanabresa heifers were mated with Charolais or Limousin bulls in order to study the effect of breed. Bull and heifer calves were slaughtered when they were 6-7 months old. Samples of the M. longissimus dorsi were aged for 3, 5 or 7 days and chemical and sensory analyses were done. The results showed no differences due to sex but Charolais sires produced meat which was more tender, juicier and had more odour intensity with a darker colour than meat of the Limousin sired animals. Ageing influenced both sensory and instrumental hardness, colour and odour intensity. After seven days of maturation the meat from such young animals achieved a high quality.     

Effect of grass or concentrate feeding systems on lamb carcass and meat quality

Thirty-two male Ile de France lambs were divided into four equal groups at age 37 days. Two groups were allowed to graze a natural pasture in France each at a different growth rate (grass high and grass low groups). The other two groups were raised in stalls and fed concentrates to achieve the same growth rates (stall high and stall low groups, respectively) as from the grass groups. The animals were slaughtered when they attained 35 kg and their carcass and meat quality were evaluated. Animals from the two high growth rate groups were slaughtered at an average age of 129 days while those from the low growth rate groups were slaughtered at 163 days. Carcasses from stall-fed lambs were heavier than those from grass-fed lambs as the digestive tract percentage was higher in the grass lambs. Carcasses from stall lambs had better muscular conformation score (P <0.05) and were fattier than those from grass-fed animals. Subcutaneous fat was more yellow and harder in grass-fed lambs (P <0.05). Meat from grass-fed lambs was darker (P <0.05) in colour (lower L*) than meat from stall animals up to 24 h of display. Meat from stall fed animals was more tender and juicier than meat from grass-fed animals (P <0.01), as judged by a trained panel of assessors. Typical lamb flavour was higher in stall-fed lambs (P <0.01). Meat from grass-fed animals had more pronounced liver flavour (P <0.05) and less fatty flavour (P <0.01) than stall-fed lambs. Overall the difference in meat quality between the two different growth rates was minimal.     

Assessment of commercial lamb meat quality by British and Spanish taste panels

Trained sensory panels in Britain and Spain assessed loin meat from commercial lambs purchased in Spain, which included Welsh lamb (imported from Britain) and two Spanish breeds (Merino and Rasa Aragonesa). The British panel also assessed British lamb purchased in local butcher shops and supermarkets. Sensory panels, in each country, received meat from the same lambs and used their local methods of cooking and assessment. Spanish panels used unstructured line scales to measure lamb odour intensity, tenderness, juiciness, lamb flavour intensity and two hedonic scales of flavour liking and overall liking. The British panel used 8 point category scales with the same attributes. Results from both panels in objective parameters were in agreement, hence showing that different trained sensory panels may arrive at the same conclusion. However, when panellists were allowed to make hedonic judgements (preference), the British panel preferred British lamb and the Spanish panel preferred Spanish lamb. This finding has important consequences for lamb producers who export their lambs and demonstrates that the underlying reasons for different preferences should be investigated. Production variables are discussed in relation to their influence on lamb eating quality and as a way to tailor lamb eating quality attributes familiar to consumers in the importing country.     

A comparative study of boar taint in cooked and dry-cured meat

A comparative study of boar taint in cooked and dry-cured pig meat products was performed. Forty-eight cooked loins and 48 dry-cured hams from entire males and castrates were studied. The samples were classified according to the androstenone (AN) and skatole (SK) fat content determined using HPLC. A trained sensory panel evaluated taste, aroma, boar odour, boar flavour, juiciness, tenderness and fatness in cooked and dry-cured samples. Threshold levels of AN and SK to separate (P<0.05) entire and castrate samples according to their boar odour and flavour were determined. The effects of castration and processing on the eating quality were studied. Finally, the relationships among boar taint and other sensory attributes in cooked and dry-cured meat were compared. Results from these studies show that the eating quality of processed meat was affected negatively by boar taint. Threshold values were higher in dry-cured ham (2 μg g(-1) AN and 0.12 SK) than cooked loin (0.5 AN and 0.1 SK). AN and SK had a synergistic effect on boar odour and flavour in both products. AN had a greater influence than SK on the aroma and taste, especially in cooked meat. Boar odour was perceived more intensely than boar flavour in both of the products studied. Castration favoured fatness and improved the aroma and taste of cooked and dry-cured meat. The loss of aroma and taste due to boar taint was more noticeable in cooking than drying and curing. In dry-cured meat boar taint was associated with less aroma, taste, juiciness and tenderness. However, in cooked meat, boar taint affected the aroma and taste more strongly, but was not related with juiciness and tenderness, probably because these attributes are influenced by cooking.     

Characterisation of young bulls of the Bruna dels Pirineus cattle breed (selected from old Brown Swiss) in relation to carcass, meat quality and biochemical traits

Seventy-four young bulls of the Bruna dels Pirineus beef cattle breed were reared in a typical production system and slaughtered at an average age of 381 days and live weight of 541 kg. The animals were evaluated for productive traits, carcass quality, meat quality, eating quality and biochemical characteristics of m. longissimus thoracis (LT). Biochemical measurements included intramuscular fat (IMF) and collagen proportion, haem pigment concentration, lactate dehydrogenase and isocitrate dehydrogenase activities and type I (MHC I) fibre percentage determined by ELISA. Bruna dels Pirineus bulls achieved high growth rates during the fattening period (1.63 kg/day) and showed good carcass quality, with a high dressing-out proportion (607 g/kg, hot carcass), a good conformation score (U; EUROP) and a moderate fatness score (3;1-5). Carcass composition was estimated from the sixth rib joint dissection (682 g/kg lean proportion, 127 g/kg total dissectable fat and 163 g/kg bone). IMF (24.3 g/kg) and MHC I (27.9%) showed high variabilities (CV>30%). Sensory analysis of LT included beef and livery odour and flavour intensity, and overall tenderness and juiciness assessment of loin samples (14-day ageing). Beef odour and flavour were slightly positively correlated with IMF and carcass fatness score (P<0.05). Fatness, MHC I, insoluble collagen and cooking losses tended to affect the livery flavour intensity positively. This variable was significantly higher in meat from bulls of lower carcass quality (i.e. lower conformation score, lower lean proportion; P<0.05) and higher type I fibre percentage. Loin overall tenderness and juiciness were not affected by the biochemical traits studied, however, they were negatively affected by cooking loss (P<0.05).     

The effects of castration on the eating quality of dry-cured ham

The influence of the castration of entire male pigs on the eating quality of dry-cured ham was evaluated. Forty-eight dry-cured hams (435-day aged) were studied from entire and castrated males of two different crossbreeds. The proximate composition of the meat and the androstenone, indole and skatole fat content were determined. The entire hams were classified according to the androstenone and skatole content. Sensory analysis was carried out by a trained panel, evaluating marbling, juiciness, saltiness, graininess, toughness, overall flavour, boar odour and boar flavour. Also carried out was a preference and acceptability paired test by consumers. Castration increased meat fattening and reduced the androstenone and skatole levels of the fat. Significant differences (P<0.05) were found between entires and castrates for the average values given in all the sensory attributes studied. The dry-cured ham from castrates was scored as more flavoured, more marbled and softer. It was also perceived as less grainy, less salty and having less boar odour and flavour. The sensory perception of boar odour was more intense than that of flavour in dry-cured ham and appears to be related to the level of androstenone and skatole in fat. Dry-cured ham from castrated males was also more accepted and more preferred by consumers, especially women and habitual consumers. Castration of male pigs contributes to improve the quality of dry-cured ham. The rejection caused by boar odour and flavour is reduced, improving the overall flavour, texture and juiciness. In addition, the saltiness is less pronounced in ham from castrates. For this reason, the production of high quality dry-cured ham will have to shoulder the extra costs associated with processing castrated pigs.     

Sensory panel consistency during development of a vocabulary for warmed-over flavour

A sensory vocabulary of 20 terms each with a corresponding reference material was developed over 7 sessions using pork patties derived from the meat of carriers and non-carriers of the RN⁻ gene. Patties were oven-cooked at 150 and 170°C and chill-stored for up to 5 days to facilitate warmed-over flavour development. Generalised Procrustes Analysis (GPA) was used to investigate sensory terms and their individual use by panellists over the sessions. GPA explained variance indicated that the final vocabulary displayed a similar amount of information to that of the initial vocabulary of 42 terms. Individual panellists scale use was found to converge over the sessions. Panel agreement on many odour and flavour terms appeared to be enhanced as term synonyms were removed in vocabulary development. Sample discriminability decreased from sessions 1–4, where term concepts were verbally communicated to the panel. Term reference introduction in session 5 caused a levelling in sample discriminability and a reduction in agreement, most likely related to perceptual confusion. Subsequently, references enhanced both discriminability and agreement. Thus, it may be more useful to introduce reference materials earlier, if not in the first session, of the vocabulary development process.     

Sensory characterization of meat from pigs vaccinated against gonadotropin releasing factor compared to meat from surgically castrated,entire male and female pigs

Boar taint is a sensory defect mainly due to androstenone and skatole. The most common method to control boar taint is surgical castration at an early age. Vaccination against gonadotropin releasing factor (also known as immunocastration) is an alternative to surgical castration to reduce androstenone content. In this experiment, loins from 24 female (FE), 24 entire male (EM), 24 vaccinated males (IM) and 23 surgically castrated males (CM) were evaluated by eight trained panellists in 24 sessions. Loins were cooked in an oven at 180 °C for 10 min. Furthermore loins were evaluated by consumers and its androstenone and skatole content were also chemically determined. Meat from EM had higher androstenone and skatole odour and flavour than meat from FE, IM and CM and lower sweetness odour scores. High correlations were found between androstenone and skatole levels assessed by trained panelists, chemical analysis and consumers’ acceptability. Moreover meat from EM is mainly related to androstenone and skatole attributes.     

Carcass measurements and meat quality characteristics of dairy suckling kids compared to an indigenous genotype

Effects of genotype on carcass measurements and meat quality were investigated by using 24 suckling kids from Turkish Saanen, Gokceada and Maltese breeds. Carcass quality characteristics of indigenous kids (Gokceada) were lower than those of dairy type (Turkish Saanen and Maltese) kids. Breed effect on ultimate meat pH, cooking loss, drip loss and Warner Bratzler shear force values were not significant. Meat samples from Turkish Saanen kids had higher redness (at 0, 1 and 24 h) and yellowness (at 24 h) values than Gokceada kids (P < 0.05). Breed had no significant effect on sensory characteristics except flavour intensity. Flavour intensity scores given to meat samples of Maltese kids were higher than those of Turkish Saanen and Gokceada kids (P < 0.01). In conclusion, dairy type breeds should be considered for meat production as well, with meat from Maltese kids potentially offering better colour and flavour intensity than that of Turkish Saanen kids.     

Fatty acid composition and sensory characteristics of lamb carcasses from Britain and Spain

Fatty acid composition of intramuscular fat in M. Longissimus was measured in four groups of lambs representing two Spanish breeds: Rasa Aragonesa (RA) and Merino (ME) and two British lamb types: the Welsh Mountain breed (WM), whose carcasses were purchased in Spain and typical early lambs (EL) purchased in Britain. The lambs grown in Spain were concentrate fed and slaughtered at a lighter weight and lower age than those grown in Britain. The British lamb carcasses purchased in Spain were of a similar weight to the Spanish lambs but were lighter than the lamb carcasses purchased in Britain. The British lambs were grass fed. Relationships between fatty acid (FA) composition and sensory attributes were examined following sensory testing of all lambs by both British and Spanish taste panels. The production system was shown to be more important than breed in determining FA composition. British lambs had higher percentages, within total fatty acids, of 18:0, 18:3 (n-3) and long chain polyunsaturated n-3 FA and lower percentages of 18:2 (n-6) and long chain polyunsaturated n-6 FA than Spanish lambs. These differences were due to the different feeding systems used. The amounts of these FA in muscle (mg/100 g) were also different between the British and Spanish groups, not only because the British lambs had more total fat. For both taste panels, odour and flavour intensity were positively correlated with the amounts and percentages of 18:0 and 18:3 and negatively correlated with those of 18:2. This was explained by the fact that both panels gave higher odour and flavour intensity scores to the grass-fed British lamb with high 18:3 levels and lower scores to the concentrate-fed Spanish lamb with high 18:2 levels. However, 18:0 and 18:3 were positively correlated with flavour quality and overall appraisal for the British panel and negatively for the Spanish panel. Conversely, 18:2 was a positive contributor to flavour and overall preference for the Spanish panel and was negative for the British panel. The results show that the production system affects muscle fatty acid composition and the flavour of lamb. However, people's preference is determined to a large extent by their past experience.