Application of dielectric response measurement on power cable systems

Water treeing is one of the factors leading to failure of medium voltage XLPE cables in long-term service. Increased moisture content inside oil-paper insulated cable is not desirable. To identify water tree degraded XLPE cables or oil-paper cables with high moisture content, diagnostic tests based on dielectric response (DR) measurement in time and frequency domain are used. Review of individual DR measurement techniques in the time and frequency domains indicates that measurement of one parameter in either domain may not be sufficient to reveal the status of the cable insulation. But a combination of several DR parameters can improve diagnostic results with respect to water trees present in XLPE cables or increased moisture content in oil-paper cables. DR measurement is a very useful tool that reveals average condition of cable systems. However, it is unlikely that DR measurement will detect few, but long water trees. In addition, DR cannot locate the defect or water tree site within the cable system. Combination of DR and partial discharge (PD) measurements can improve diagnostic results with respect to global and local defects. However, it is doubtful whether PD test can identify the presence of water trees inside a cable in a nondestructive manner. Further research is needed for more detailed conclusions regarding the status of a particular insulation and for predicting the remaining life of the insulation system.     

Investigation of Water Tree Degradation in Dry‐Cured and Extruded Three‐Layer (E‐E Type) 6.6‐kV Removed XLPE Cables

Dry‐cured and extruded three‐layer (E‐E type) 6.6‐kV cross‐linked polyethylene (XLPE) cables were introduced into electric power systems more than 30 years ago, but they do not experience failures because of water tree degradation. Also, the degradation index of water treeing for these cables has not been established. Therefore, investigating results of residual breakdown voltage and water tree degradation of these cables will help us plan for cable replacement and determine water tree degradation diagnosis scheduling, and will be fundamental data for cable lifetime evaluation. In this study, the authors measured the ac breakdown voltages of dry‐cured and E‐E type 6.6‐kV XLPE cables removed after 18 to 25 years of operation and observed the water trees in their XLPE insulation. As a result, it was observed that breakdown voltages were larger than the maximum operating voltage (6.9 kV) and the ac voltage for the dielectric withstanding test (10.3 kV). Water trees were mainly bow‐tie water trees and their maximum length was approximately 1 mm. Although the number of measured cables was limited, the lifetime of this type of cable was estimated to be approximately 40 years, even experiencing water immersion.     

一种基于分形的XLPE电缆在线绝缘诊断方法

通过建立水树精确数字仿真模型,提出一种新的在线绝缘诊断方法:即高频信号叠加法.在电缆屏蔽层叠加高频低幅电压信号,以凸现损耗电流波形,利用分形方法对采集到的损耗电流信号进行分析.XLPE电缆的水树的劣化使得损耗电流中谐波分量增加.谐波分量主要由于水树的非线性电压-电流特性引起.谐波分量的出现使损耗电流信号的分形维数增加.分别计算了容量、信息、关联三种维数,分析了各种维数和水树劣化之间的内在联系.分形维数很好的反映了电缆中水树劣化的程度,可以作为在线绝缘水树劣化的诊断依据.     

Dielectric spectroscopy for diagnosis of water tree deteriorationin XLPE cables

An HV dielectric spectroscopy system has been developed for diagnostics of water tree deteriorated extruded medium voltage cables. The technique is based on the measurement of nonlinear dielectric response in the frequency domain. Today's commercially available systems are capable of resolving low loss and small variations of permittivity as a function of frequency and voltage. Experience from more than 200 field measurements was combined with laboratory investigations. Small samples were used in an accelerated aging test to elucidate the correlation between water tree growth and dielectric response. Furthermore, field aged cables were investigated in the laboratory. It has been shown that the dielectric response of water tree deteriorated crosslinked polyethylene (XLPE) cables can be recognized and classified into different types of responses related to the aging status and breakdown strength. The influence of termination and artifacts such as surface currents was investigated. The measurement method enables us to separate the response of the cable from the influence of accessories. Finally, two different field studies of the implementation of the diagnostic method are presented. The field studies show that the fault rate decreased significantly when replacement strategy was based on the diagnostic criteria formulated     

Application of the AC Superposition Method to Degradation Diagnosis of 22/33‐kV Class XLPE Cables

Water trees in the insulator of XLPE cable may considerably reduce the dielectric breakdown voltage, thus being an important lifetime‐governing factor. The ac superposition method we have investigated is a new technique for hot‐line diagnosis of 6.6‐kV XLPE cables, and the diagnostic apparatus using this technique is now widely used in the distribution line field. In order to study the application of the ac superposition method to degradation diagnosis of 22/33‐kV class XLPE cables, we measured deterioration signals of the cables with water trees by a modification of the above diagnostic apparatus. The deterioration signals, hereafter called “ac superposition current”, were generated by an amplitude modulation effect due to the nonlinear resistance of water trees. Moreover, we evaluated the relationship between the ac superposition current and the ac breakdown voltage. It is difficult to judge whether a correlation between then is present or not because of the uneven distribution of the measured data. However, the ac superposition current tends to increase linearly with a decrease in the residual thickness of the insulator. For example, the ac superposition current was about 40 nA when the residual thickness decreased to 3 mm. Thus, we consider that the ac superposition method is effective for degradation diagnosis of 22/33‐kV class XLPE cables.     

Statistical evaluation of water tree lengths in XLPE cables at different temperatures

Accelerated aging of two types of commercially produced medium voltage XLPE insulated cables was carried out under the combined stresses of three types consisting of ionic aqueous species, elevated electrical stress and temperature cycling. After 1000 h of aging, the water tree parameters were evaluated. Results show that external ionic species exert profound impact on the generation of bow tie and vented water trees, while impurities inherently present in the cable components also contribute significantly. Temperature cycling increases the bow tie trees by an order of magnitude, while morphology of insulation influences the level of water tree degradation. The water tree population and their lengths were subjected to Weibull and log-normal models of statistical distributions and the data were found to fit better on the log-normal model. For a better statistical inference, a computer based Monte Carlo simulation was devised and used to precisely discriminate the two models. Simulation results further confirm that both types of water trees fit better on the log-normal model. The most likely mechanism for water tree degradation is fatigue based and hence mechanistic by nature.     

交联聚乙烯电缆水树缺陷的修复方法研究

采用硅氧烷修复液修复交联聚乙烯电缆老化试样中的水树,进而分析修复效果及机理。将介质损耗因数为4%～6%,绝缘电阻7 500～10 000 MΩ的短电缆在7.5 kV 450 Hz交流电压下老化至介质损耗因数达到20%左右,绝缘电阻3 500～5 000 MΩ。然后用压力注入式修复装置把修复液注入缆芯对水树缺陷进行修复。以介质损耗因数、绝缘电阻和击穿电压为指标对修复效果进行评判;通过显微镜切片观察修复前后水树微观形态;通过仿真修复前后水树附近电场分布来分析和验证水树的修复机理。实验结果证明,修复液可以充分与电缆水树中的水发生反应生成胶状聚合物填充水树通道;修复后电缆介质损耗因数、绝缘电阻和击穿电压恢复到新电缆水平;改善了绝缘层电场分布;有效地抑制了水树生长。实验表明,该修复液可有效修复电缆中的水树缺陷,提高电缆绝缘水平。     

Diagnostic dielectric spectroscopy methods applied to water-treedcable

Considerable effort has gone into developing polymer formulations and cable designs to minimize failures through water tree growth. However, diagnostic techniques still are required to enable the estimation of the level of damage present within a service cable. This paper reports on progress regarding the application of dielectric spectroscopy to cable diagnostics. A 40 kV, crosslinked polyethylene (XLPE) insulated coaxial cable was used as a model power cable. Sample lengths were immersed in a potassium chloride solution and some of these were subjected to AC electrical stress. After an 8 week duration, a high density of tress was found in the electrically stressed cable. Dielectric spectra have been measured for both sample types in the frequency range of 10^-5 to 10⁵ Hz. Insertion loss measurements were also carried out in the frequency range of 3×10 ⁵ to 3×10⁹ Hz. From both types of measurement, it was possible to distinguish between the cables containing water trees and those that were free from water tree structures. These approaches could therefore be developed in order to provide diagnostics for the detection of water tree damage in electrical power cables     

The ac superposition method,a new hot‐line diagnostic method for 6‐kV XLPE power cables

Water trees are the most hazardous factor affecting the life of XLPE distribution cables and the major cause of insulation failure. It is well known that insulation failure causes stoppages in electrical service and requires extensive repair work. Up to now, deterioration of cable insulation has been diagnosed mainly by the dc leakage current method. However, application of this method for diagnostic measurements requires interruption of electrical service. Several types of hot‐line diagnostic methods (including the dc component current and dc superposition methods) were developed to detect water tree deterioration. However, these methods have some shortcomings, such as being subject to effects of stray currents and the accuracy of measurements not being sufficiently high. Therefore, we have attempted to develop a new hot‐line diagnostic method. We investigated whether the signals produced by superposition of voltages of various frequencies to the cover layer of energized cables were correlated with deterioration by the water treeing. As a result, we found that a deterioration signal of 1 Hz was observed when we superposed an ac voltage (commercial frequency × 2 +1 Hz) on the cover layer of cable where the water tree had occurred in the insulation. © 1999 Scripta Technica, Electr Eng Jpn, 130(2): 49–58, 2000     

Condition assessment of distribution PILC cables from electrical, chemical, and dielectric measurements

A study was conducted to evaluate some new diagnostic techniques enabling users to effectively manage their paper-insulated, lead-covered (PILC) cable assets. The objective is to present the results obtained with four diagnostic techniques designed for use on in-service cables, but used only to a limited extent on PILC cables. These techniques are LIpATEST leakage current test method, isothermal relaxation current (IRC), return voltage method (RVM), and dielectric spectroscopy. In addition, the AC breakdown strength of the cable was also measured. The differences between the titration measurements and the predictions made by AC breakdown and the non-destructive techniques, such as RVM and dielectric spectroscopy, were noted with specific reference to moisture content in the cables. The different diagnostic techniques used in the study gave a reasonably consistent and coherent evaluation of the insulation condition of several field-aged PILC cables. The moisture content deduced from RVM and dielectric spectroscopy does not agree with Karl-Fischer titration of the same samples. It is suggested that aging induces more detrimental polarization processes in the cable oil, whose impact on electrical properties is still unknown but appears to be much more influential than moisture for the cables tested. The results confirm a previous suggestion that PILC cables kept under load are not significantly affected by water ingress.     

高压交流电缆用交联聚乙烯绝缘料性能对比实验研究

中国高电压等级交流电缆用交联聚乙烯（XPLE）绝缘料研发较晚,目前国产220 kV电压等级绝缘料暂未获得工程应用。以3种国内外高压电缆XLPE绝缘料为研究对象,对比分析绝缘料热压试样的工频击穿场强、介电常数、介质损耗正切、熔融和结晶性能、拉伸强度、断裂伸长率、微观形貌和交联度等参数。实验测试结果表明：国产XLPE绝缘料的宏观性能参数已经和进口XLPE绝缘料相差不大,甚至国产绝缘料试样的击穿场强和力学性能参数优于进口X1#试样,但同时也能够发现国产绝缘料的不足之处,例如击穿场强的稳定性较差、介质损耗角正切值偏大等。研究结论可为国产电缆绝缘料的研发与性能提升提供数据支撑。     

Extending the service life of 15 kV polyethylene URD cable usingsilicone liquid

The authors describe methods and materials used to extend the useful life of extruded polyethylene insulated cables rated at 15 kV that have developed electrochemical trees in the insulation of sufficient severity to cause service failures. Earlier rehabilitation methods treated extruded dielectric cables with both gases and insulating liquids. This new method fills the cable and impregnates the insulation with a silicone liquid. This liquid, which is reactive, significantly improves the voltage breakdown strength of the cables, which had been reduced by electrochemical trees, and extends the useful service life of the cable. A review of the criteria used to develop the silicone liquid for this application and the methodology used to inject it into the cable are presented. An assessment of the costs for this life extension indicates a significantly lower cost than conventional cable replacement with little disturbance to the service and property of the customer     

Development of a hot-line diagnostic method for XLPE cables and themeasurement results

Hot-line diagnosis is needed to avoid breakdowns of XLPE (cross-linked polyethylene) cables due to water trees. The authors superposed a low DC voltage on an AC commercial voltage, measured the DC component of the current which passed through the insulation, and discovered that the DC component had a close relationship with the degradation caused by water trees. A hot-line diagnostic measurement system based on this DC superposition method was developed. The old cables that were removed and cables now in use were measured with the system; the results are reported     

Approach for wide use of diagnostic method for XLPE cables using harmonics in AC loss current

A water tree is one aspect of the degradation of XLPE cables used for underground distribution or transmission lines. We have developed the loss current method using the third harmonic in AC loss current for cable diagnosis. The harmonic components in loss current arise as a result of the nonlinear voltage– current characteristics of water trees. We confirmed that the third harmonic in the AC loss current has good correlation with respect to water tree growth and breakdown strength. After that, we applied this method to the actual 66‐kV XLPE cable lines. Up to now, results on over 130 lines have been obtained. In the case of cable lines terminated at gas‐insulated switchgear (GIS), we have to remove the lightning arrestor (LA) and the potential transformer (PT) from the test circuit. The reason is that we are afraid that each LA and PT disturbs the degradation signal from cable lines. It requires extra time (1 or 2 days) and costs more to remove the LA and PT in GIS from a circuit. In order to achieve easy and reasonable diagnosis, we have developed a new method for cable lines terminated at GIS by utilizing a technique that enables one to cancel the signal of the LA and PT from disturbed signal of the cable lines. We confirmed the effect of the new method through experiments with actual cables. © 2008 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Electr Eng Jpn, 165(4): 52–59, 2008; Published online in Wiley InterScience ( www.interscience.wiley.com ). DOI 10.1002/eej.20510     

A study of the actual failure situation of XLPE cable and the order of priority of degradation diagnosis

We analyzed statistical data on failures due to dielectric breakdowns caused by water tree degradation in 6‐kV XLPE cables using the Hazard Analysis. The data used in this report reflect actual conditions of XLPE cables. The data are classified by the conductor size of the cables. Calculated failure rates were different for cables having different conductor sizes. In this report, the failure rates were calculated based on the information regarding conductor size, cable length, and cable age. The results obtained make it possible to quantitatively establish the order of the priority of degradation diagnosis. © 2004 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Electr Eng Jpn, 148(4): 50–58, 2004; Published online in Wiley InterScience ( www.interscience.wiley.com ). DOI 10.1002/eej.10301     

电力电缆绝缘监测中的低频交流电压叠加法研究

电力电缆绝缘损坏主要由水树枝劣化引起,对电力电缆进行带电检测是非常必要的,低频交流电压叠加法是目前比较好的一种检测方法,本文对该方法的原理和软硬件设计方法作了介绍。     

Comparative laboratory evaluation of TR-XLPE and XLPE cables with Super-smooth conductor shields

This paper provides data on four commercial tree retardant crosslinked polyethylene (TR-XLPE) and one cross-linked polyethylene (XLPE) insulated 15 kV cables supplied by three manufacturers. The cables have "super-smooth" conductor shields and "extra-clean" insulation and insulation shields. AC and impulse voltage breakdown and selected other characterization data are presented for cables that were aged immersed in room temperature water (15-30/spl deg/C) up to 24 months of a planned 48 months aging program. The five cables have high ac voltage breakdown strength, three of the TR-XLPE cables, actually increased in breakdown strength during aging. The one TR-XLPE cable that had the lowest ac voltage breakdown had vented trees at the insulation shield and high dissipation factor, which the other cables did not have. The impulse voltage breakdown strength of all cables decreased during aging; the cable with the lowest ac voltage breakdown also has the lowest impulse voltage breakdown. The dissimilar performance of the TR-XLPE cables and the excellent performance of the XLPE cable indicates evaluations at longer times are required to differentiate between modern TR-XLPE and XLPE insulated cables.     

硅氧化焼注入后水树老化交联聚乙烯电缆电气特性和微观结构（英文）

To evaluate the effect of using siloxane liquid to rejuvenate water tree defects in cross-linked polyethylene(XLPE)cables,we investigated the electrical properties and micro-structures of water-tree aged XLPE cables after siloxane liquid injection treatment.The water-tree aged samples were prepared by performing accelerated aging experiment using water-needle electrodes,and the siloxane liquid is injected into the aged cable through a pressurized injection system.Dielectric loss factors of the samples before and after the rejuvenation were compared.The water trees and the internal filler were observed using scanning electron microscope(SEM).Electrical properties of the reactants are measured.Electric field simulation is conducted to verify the rejuvenation effect by finite element method.The results show that the siloxane liquid diffused into the insulation layer in a short time and reacted with water in the water trees.The electrical properties of the formed organic filler are in accord with that of XLPE.Therefore,the action between siloxane and water can inhibit the growth of water trees and reduce electric field distortion of the water tree areas.As a result,insulation performance of the cable is enhanced.A 70 m long cable was aged and rejuvenated in laboratory and an on-site rejuvenation experiment was conducted,and in both cases the dielectric loss factor and leakage current halved after rejuvenation.     

An application of the residual voltage for diagnoses for detecting irradiated degradation of insulating materials

Electrical cables in nuclear power generating stations must be highly reliable. For further improvement of reliability, the development of nondestructive diagnoses seems desirable for cable maintenance. The authors have been studying residual voltage for developing a diagnosis of electrical cables. The purpose of this paper is to give a foundation for development of diagnostic technology for detecting the irradiated degradation; the relations between γ-irradiation dose and the leakage current, the discharge current, and the residual voltage were studied and attempts made to calculate the amount of polarized charge and characteristic dielectric relaxation times by using data on the residual voltage. The calculated results agreed with the results obtained from the leakage current and the discharge current. These results suggest that the residual voltage in diagnostic technology for detecting the irradiated degradation can be employed.     

压力注入电压稳定剂对热氧老化电缆绝缘性能的增强机理

为了研究压力注入电压稳定剂对热氧老化电缆的修复效果,通过配置修复液对电缆样本进行注入修复,研究修复液对电缆绝缘性能的增强效果及作用机理。选取抗氧剂300和二茂铁配置不同添加浓度的7种硅氧烷修复液,对热氧老化电缆样本进行注入式修复,测试修复前后XLPE绝缘的电树引发电压、直流电导率和介质损耗因数,对部分样本进行二次老化,并测试不同老化时间的氧化诱导期和电树引发电压。结果表明,注入2种类型的电压稳定剂均能够大幅提高热氧老化电缆的电树引发电压,但也会在一定程度上增大电导率和介质损耗因数;注入抗氧剂300能够提高热氧老化电缆的氧化诱导时间,并在较长时间内提升其抗热氧老化和抗电树能力。由扩散公式与实验结果可知,通过增大注入压力,升高扩散温度,选择有效浓度区间更大的电压稳定剂,选取较为保守的添加含量等措施,使电压稳定剂在绝缘层中的浓度分布处于有效浓度区域,是保证修复效果的有效措施。