Geothermal development in Hungary—country update report 2000–2002

This paper describes the status of geothermal energy utilization—direct use—in Hungary, with emphasis on developments between 2000 and 2002. The level of utilization of geothermal energy in the world increased in this period and geothermal energy was the leading producer, with 70% of the total electricity production, of all the renewable energy sources (wind, solar, geothermal and tidal), followed by wind energy at 28%. The current cost of direct heat use from biomass is 1–5 US¢/kWh, geothermal 0.5–5 US¢/kWh and solar heating 3–20 US¢/kWh. The data relative to direct use in Hungary decreased in this period and the contribution of geothermal energy to the energy balance of Hungary, despite significant proven reserves (with reinjection) of 380 million m³/year, with a heat content of 63.5 PJ/a at ΔT=40 °C, remained very low (0.25%). Despite the fact that geothermal fluids with temperatures at the surface higher than 100 °C are available, no electricity has been generated. As of 31 December 2002, the geothermal capacity utilised in direct applications in Hungary is estimated to be 324.5 MW_t and to produce 2804 TJ/year. Geothermal heat pumps represent about 4.0 MW_t of this installed capacity. The quantity of thermal water produced for direct uses in 2002 was approximately 22 million m³, with an average utilization temperature of 31 °C. The main consumer of geothermal energy is agriculture (68% of the total geothermal heat dedicated to direct uses). The geothermal water is used only in five spas for space heating and sanitary hot water (SHW), although there are 260 spas in the country, and the thermal water produced has an average surface temperature of 68 °C. The total heat capacity installed in the spas is approximately 1250 MW_t; this is not provided by geothermal but could be, i.e., geothermal could provide more than three times the geothermal capacity utilized in direct uses by 31 December 2002 (324.5 MW_t).     

The Iceland Deep Drilling Project: a search for deep unconventional geothermal resources

The Iceland Deep Drilling Project (IDDP) is a long-term program to improve the economics of geothermal energy by producing supercritical hydrous fluids from drillable depths. Producing supercritical fluids will require the drilling of wells and the sampling of fluids and rocks to depths of 3.5–5 km, and at temperatures of 450–600 °C. The IDDP plans to drill and test a series of such deep boreholes in the Krafla, Nesjavellir and Reykjanes geothermal fields in Iceland. Beneath these three developed high-temperature systems frequent seismic activity continues below 5 km, indicating that, even at supercritical temperatures, the rocks are brittle and therefore likely to be permeable, even where the temperature is assumed to exceed 550–650 °C. Temperature gradients are greater and fluid salinities smaller at Nesjavellir and Krafla than at Reykjanes. However, an active drilling program is underway at Reykjanes to expand the existing generating capacity and the field operator has offered to make available one of a number of 2.5 km deep wells to be the first to be deepened to 5 km by the IDDP. In addition to its potential economic significance, drilling deep at this location, on the landward extension of the Mid-Atlantic Ridge, is of great interest to the international science community. This paper examines the prospect of producing geothermal fluids from deep wells drilled into a reservoir at supercritical temperatures and pressures. Since fluids drawn from a depth of 4000–5000 m may prove to be chemically hostile, the wellbore and casing must be protected while the fluid properties are being evaluated. This will be achieved by extracting the fluids through a narrow retrievable liner called the “pipe”. Modelling indicates that if the wellhead enthalpy is to exceed that of conventionally produced geothermal steam, the reservoir temperature must be higher than 450 °C. A deep well producing 0.67 m³/s steam (2400 m³/h) from a reservoir with a temperature significantly above 450 °C could, under favourable conditions, yield enough high-enthalpy steam to generate 40–50 MW of electric power. This exceeds by an order of magnitude the power typically obtained from a conventional geothermal well in Iceland. The aim of the IDDP is to determine whether utilization of heat from such an unconventional geothermal resource at supercritical conditions will lead to increased productivity of wells at a competitive cost. If the IDDP is an economic success, this same approach could be applied in other high-temperature volcanic geothermal systems elsewhere, an important step in enhancing the geothermal industry worldwide.     

An estimate of the resource potential of New Zealand geothermal fields for power generation

The basic similarity between most of the New Zealand geothermal fields suggests that the exploited fields of Wairakei and Broadlands can be used as indicators of the potential of other fields as resources for steam for power production. Assuming adequate permeability will be obtained in fields yet to be tested, the two parameters controlling this potential are areal extent (as defined by resistivity survey) and temperature at depth. As most field temperatures are bracketed by Wairakei (270°C maximum) and Broadlands (310°C maximum), field potential per unit area should also be bracketed by the field potentials per unit area of these two fields, i.e. Wairakei at 10–11 MWe/km² and Broadlands at 13–14 MWe/km².Based upon our present knowledge of the fields in question we may thus assess their proven, inferred and speculative reserves. Our totals for all fields of 450 MWe proven, 750 MWe inferred and 1300 MWe speculative suggests that New Zealand has some 1300–2500 MWe available from its geothermal resources should it desire to exploit these for electrical power.These figures can only be confirmed and improved by drilling and ultimately by exploitation. The most promising tool for a full assessment of a field potential, the reservoir model, can only really be set up once the field has been exploited sufficiently to have been disturbed. In future cases this may only be the case once a power station has been established and has been operating for some time.     

The feasibility of using geothermal energy in hydrogen production

A feasibility study exploring the use of geothermal energy in hydrogen production is presented. It is possible to use a thermal energy to supply heat for high temperature electrolysis and thereby substitute a part of the relatively expensive electricity needed. A newly developed HOT ELLY high temperature steam electrolysis process operates at 800 – 1000°C. Geothermal fluid is used to heat fresh water up to 200°C steam. The steam is further heated to 900°C by utilising heat produced within the electrolyser. The electrical power of this process is reduced from 4.6 kWh per normalised cubic meter of hydrogen (kWh/Nm³ H₂) for conventional process to 3.2 kWh/Nm³ H₂ for the HOT ELLY process implying electrical energy reduction of 29.5%. The geothermal energy needed in the process is 0.5 kWh/Nm³ H₂. Price of geothermal energy is approximately 8–10% of electrical energy and therefore a substantial reduction of production cost of hydrogen can be achieved this way. It will be shown that using HOT ELLY process with geothermal steam at 200°C reduces the production cost by approximately 19%.     

Chemical and isotope characteristics of the Chachimbiro geothermal fluids (Ecuador)

The parent geothermal water proposed for the Chachimbiro geothermal area has calculated values of 2250 mg/L Cl and approximately 5 bar P_CO2. It comes from a reservoir having an estimated temperature of 225–235 °C, although temperatures somewhat higher than 260 °C may be present at the roots of the system. The geothermal reservoir at Chachimbiro is recharged mainly by meteoric water (about 92%) and secondarily by arc-type magmatic water. Carbon and sulfur isotope data support a magmatic origin for the C and S species entering the geothermal system from below, consistent with indications provided by He isotopes.The thermal springs of Na–Cl to Na–Cl–HCO₃ type located in the Chachimbiro area originate through dilution of the parent geothermal water and have reached different degrees of re-equilibration with country rocks at lower temperatures.     

Research and development of geothermal energy production in Hungary

The basement of the Pannonian (Carpathian) basin is represented by Paleozoic metamorphic and Mesozoic dolomite and limestone formations. The Tertiary basin gradually subsided during the Alpine orogeny down to 6000 m and was filled by elastic sediments with several water horizons.A heat flow of 2.0 to 3.4 μcal/cm²s gives temperature gradients between 45 and 70 °C/km in the basin. At 2000 m depth the virgin rock temperature is between 110 and 150°C. 80 geothermal wells about 2000 m deep have shown the great geothermal potential of the basin.The main hot water reservoir is the Upper Pliocene (Pannonian) sandstone formation. Hot water is produced by wells from the blanket or sheet sand and sandstone, intercalated frequently by siltstone. Between a 100–300 m interval, 3 to 8 permeable layers are exploited resulting in 1–3 m³/min hot water at 80–99°C temperature.Wells at present are overflowing with shut-in pressures of 3–5 atm.The Pannonian basin is a conduction-dominated reservoir. Convection systems are negligible, hot igneous systems do not exist. The assessment of geothermal resources revealed that the content of the water-bearing rocks down to 3000 m amounts to 12,600 × 10¹⁸cal. In the Tertiary sediments 10,560 × 10¹⁸cal and in the Upper Pannonian, 1938 × 10¹⁸cal are stored. In the Upper Pannonian geothermal reservoir, below 1000 m, where the virgin rock temperature is between 70 and 140°C, the stored heat is 768 × 10⁸cal. A 10¹⁸ cal is equivalent to the combustion heat of 100 million tons of oil. The amount of recoverable geothermal energy from 768 × 10⁸cal is 7.42 × 10¹⁸cal, i.e. about 10,000 MW century, not considering reinjection.At present the Pannonian geothermal reservoir stores the greatest amount of identified heat which can be mobilized and used. Hungary has 496 geothermal wells with a nominal capacity of 428 m³/min, producing 1342 MW heat. 147 wells have an outflow temperature of more than 60°C producing 190 m³/min, that is, 845 MW. In 1974 290 MWyear of geothermal energy was utilized in agriculture, district heating and industry.     

Hydrogeological and isotopic survey of geothermal fields in the Buyuk Menderes graben, Turkey

The main high and low enthalpy geothermal fields in the Buyuk Menderes graben (Western Anatolia) and their reservoir temperatures are as follows: Kizildere (242 °C), Germencik (232 °C), Aydin-Ilicabasi (101 °C), Yılmazkoy (142 °C), Salavatli (171 °C), Soke (26 °C), Denizli -Pamukkale (36 °C), Karahayit (59 °C), Golemezli (101 °C) and Yenice (70 °C). The geothermal systems are controlled by active graben faults. The reservoir rocks in the geothermal fields are the limestone and conglomerate units within Neogene sediments and the marble-quartzite units within Paleozoic metamorphic formations. There are clear δ¹⁸O shifts from the Mediterranean Meteoric Water Line (MMWL) in the Kizildere, Germencik and Aydin fields, where a good relation between high temperatures and δ¹⁸O shift has also been observed, indicating deep circulation and water rock interactions. In the Pamukkale, Karahayit, Golemezli and Yenice fields and in Soke region, low temperatures, small isotope shifts, shallow circulations and mixing with shallow cold water have been noted.     

Isotopic and chemical composition of parbati valley geothermal discharges, North-West Himalaya, India

The isotopic compositions of the waters discharged from Parbati Valley geothermal areas indicate a higher altitude meteoric origin, with discharge temperatures reflecting variations in the depth of penetration of the waters to levels heated by the existence of a ‘normal’ geothermal gradient. On the basis of mixing models involving silica, tritium, discharge temperatures and chloride contents, deep equilibration temperatures of 120–140°C were obtained for Manikaran, possibly reaching 160°C at even greater depth. Geothermometers based on sulfate-water ¹⁸O exchange and gas reactions point to similar temperatures. Exceptionally high helium contents of the discharges correspond to apparent crustal residence times of the waters in the order of 10–100 Ma; relative nitrogen-argon contents support a largely meteoric origin of the waters with a possible fossil brine, but no detectable magmatic component.     

Deposition of amorphous silica in porous packed beds — predicting the lifetime of reinjection aquifers

Predicting deposition rates of dissolved silica in geothermal reinjection aquifers is difficult due to a lack of reliable scaling rates and the complexity of modelling fluid transport simultaneously with deposition. In order to develop techniques, understand the problems and improve our predictive capabilities, we have undertaken field experiments at Wairakei geothermal field, New Zealand, to determine amorphous silica deposition rates in 25 mm diameter pipes packed with 2 mm diameter zirconia beads. These pipes served as model aquifers. Five experiments using flashed fluid containing 530 ppm total silica were completed at temperatures between 71 and 129°C and at flowrates between 0.002 and 0.02 kg s⁻¹. The residence times in the pipes were shorter than the induction period required for silica polymerisation from solution. The scaling rates in the beds, measured over a month, were about 12 mg cm⁻² year⁻¹ and independent of flowrate between 80 and 129°C. Scaling at 129°C was unexpected, because the dissolved silica was expected to be undersaturated with respect to amorphous silica. At 71°C the rates were higher (up to 23 mg cm⁻² year⁻¹) and were proportional to flowrate. At Wairakei the 130°C fluid used in these experiments is disposed of by injection into a reservoir at 80°C. Using our field deposition rates, we estimate that 2.6×10⁵ kg of amorphous silica would precipitate in 10 years around the injection well, assuming an injection rate of 50 kg s⁻¹ into a 100 m thick reservoir of radius 500 m with permeability 100 mdarcy and a porosity of 0.2.     

Development and role of geothermal resources in India

The geothermal resources discovered in India consist of warm/hot water systems. Medium-temperature waters and reversal of temperature at depth were observed in Puga, Manikaran and the West Coast geothermal areas after exploratory drilling. Such resources can be utilized only for non-electrical applications after detailed technical—economic feasibility studies. The presence of medium-temperature (90–140°C) springs in the cold, remote and steep Himalayan terrains and of lower temperature springs (100°C) in the hot and variable climate of the Peninsular and Coastal regions further restrict full utilization of these resources, with the exception of Cambay, West Coast and Tatapani—Jhor areas. After careful study a list of direct utilizations is proposed for future consideration and the development of the main geothermal resources in India.     

Geoelectric study of some indian geothermal areas

The electrical resistivity technique has been used extensively in the Indian sub-continent for the exploration of geothermal areas. The first systematic application of the resistivity method for locating the geothermal reservoir was made in the Puga area, which is situated very close to the collision junction of the Indian and the Asian plates and has numerous hot springs with temperatures varying from 30 to 84°C (boiling point at that altitude). The resistivity depth probes indicated the presence of a conductive zone, with a value of 10–25 ohm·m and a thickness varying from 50 to 300 m over an area of 3 km², which was inferred to correspond to a shallow thermal reservoir. Thermal surveys also revealed a significant anomaly corresponding to this zone, which, when drilled, encountered a reservoir of wet steam with a temperature of up to 135°C, thus confirming the results of the resistivity surveys. Somewhat similar results have been obtained in the adjoining area, where much thicker zones with moderate electrical conductivity have been mapped.Another significant application of the electrical resistivity method has been made in the NNW-SSE extending West Coast geothermal belt of India, which is covered by Traps (Basalts) of the Cretaceous-Eocene. The area is characterized by the existence of a number of hot springs, with temperature up to 70°C, along a 400 km long alignment, associated with steep gravity gradients and an isolated occurrence of native mercury in the zone of a gravity “high”. The enigmatic geology of this area has been mapped, giving quantitative estimates of the thickness of the Traps and inferring the structural features. In addition, the electrical resistivity depth probes have also been used to identify the pre-Trappean geology, thereby locating the probable areas which could act as geothermal reservoirs.This paper presents the results of the electrical resistivity surveys in the form of geoelectric sections for some of the geothemal fields in the Indian sub-continent.     

Application of synthetic fluid inclusions to simultaneous temperature–pressure logging in high-temperature (sub- to supercritical) geothermal systems

Batch-autoclave experiments have been conducted to evaluate the potential use of synthetic fluid inclusions as a simultaneous temperature–pressure (and fluid sampling) logging tool in deep-seated, high-temperature (>350 °C) geothermal systems. The application of synthetic fluid inclusions allows us to obtain information about thermal-pressure conditions in deep-seated geothermal systems, where conventional tools cannot be used because of the extreme temperature conditions. Fluid inclusions, up to 50 μm long, have been readily synthesized during 5-day autoclave experiments (conducted at 375–475 °C and 39–62 MPa) in pre-fractured, inclusion- and impurity-free artificial quartz. Inferred fluid inclusion (temperature–pressure) trapping conditions are calculated by deducing the intersection of isochores derived from microthermometric data for three sets of simultaneously trapped synthetic fluid inclusions in healed microfractures. Synthetic fluid inclusion logging offers a precise borehole temperature measurement technique without need of any pressure correction. Pressure estimates are less precise, although the method may be improved by using a combination of H₂O–NaCl and H₂O–KCl solutions/salinities, and fluid/quartz/amorphous silica systems that facilitate crack healing but trap fluids that do not homogenize at near-critical conditions.     

Volcano–tectonic structures, gravity and helium in geothermal areas of Tuscany and Latium (Vulsini volcanic district), Italy

Since the early 1980s, geological and structural mapping, gravity, and helium soil–gas studies have been performed in the eastern sector of the Vulsini Volcanic District (Roman Magmatic Province) in an attempt to locate potential geothermal reservoirs. This area is characterised by an anomalous geothermal gradient of >100°C/km, and by widespread hydrothermal mineralization, thermal springs, high gas fluxes, and fossil and current travertine deposits. The results of these surveys indicate the existence of a number of fault systems, with N–S and E–W structures that appear to be superimposed on older NW–SE and NE–SW features. Comparison of the results of the various studies also reveals differences in permeability and potential reservoir structures at depth.     

Geothermal resources of the Beijing area, China

Hot water resources were discovered in 1970 at a fairly shallow depth below the city of Beijing. The total areal extent of the geothermal field is presently estimated at more than 100 km². The two known thermal aquifers are composed of fractured dolomites and the temperature of the aquifers ranges from 53 to 80°C. Based on the production-drawdown history of the Beijing geothermal field, for the period 1971–1981, the unit step response of the reservoir is obtained. Parameters of a simple lumped two-capacitor model, matched with the unit step response, furnish some information on dimensions and overall potential of the Beijing reservoir.     

Chilean geothermal resources and their possible utilization

Most of the hot spring areas in Chile are located along the Andean Cordillera, associated with Quaternary volcanism. The volcanic—geothermal activity is mainly controlled by the subduction processes of the Nazca and Antarctic oceanic plates under the South America continental plate, and occurs at three well-defined zones of the Chilean Andes: the northern zone (17°30′–28°S), the central—south zone (33φ–46°S) and the southern-most or Austral zone (48°–56°S).Some tested high temperature geothermal fields, and geological and geochemical surveys of many other hot spring areas, evidence a great potential of geothermal resources in this country. Both electrical and non-electrical applications of this potential are considered in this paper.Taking into account the potentially available geothermal resources, the development of natural resources, the geographic and social—economic conditions existing in the different regions of Chile, it is concluded that power generation, desalination of geothermal waters, recovery of chemicals from evaporite deposits and brines and sulfur-refining are the main possible applications of geothermal energy in northern Chile; in central—south Chile geothermal energy is suitable for agribusiness such as greenhouses, aquaculture and animal husbandry.     

Geothermal development in Romania

Exploration for geothermal resources began in Romania in the early 1960s, based on a detailed geological exploration program for hydrocarbon resources that had a capacious budget and enabled the identification of eight geothermal areas. Over 200 wells drilled to depths between 800 and 3500 m have indicated the presence of low-enthalpy geothermal resources (40–120 °C). Completion and experimental production from over 100 wells during the past 25 years has led to the evaluation of the exploitable heat resources of the geothermal reservoirs. The proven reserves, with the wells that have already been drilled, amount to about 200,000 TJ for 20 years. The main geothermal systems discovered on Romanian territory are in porous permeable formations such as sandstones and siltstones (Western Plain and the Olt Valley) or in fractured carbonate formations (Oradea, Bors, and north of Bucharest). The total thermal capacity of the existing wells is about 480 MW_t (for a reference temperature of 25 °C). Only 152 MW_t of this potential is currently being exploited, from 96 wells (35 of which are used for health and recreational bathing), producing hot water in the temperature range 45–115 °C. In 2002 the annual energy utilisation from these wells was about 2900 TJ, with a capacity factor of 0.6. More than 80% of the wells are artesian producers, 18 wells require anti-scaling chemical treatment and six are reinjection wells. During the period 1995–2002, 15 exploration-production geothermal wells were drilled and completed, two of which were dry holes. Drilling was financed by the geological exploration fund of the State Budget, to depths varying between 1500 and 3500 m. Progress in the direct utilisation sector of geothermal resources has been extremely slow because of the difficulties encountered during the transition period from a centrally planned to a free-market economy; geothermal production is at present far below the level that could be expected from its assessed potential, with geothermal operations lagging behind in technology. The main obstacle to geothermal development in Romania is the lack of domestic investment capital. In order to stimulate the interest of potential investors from developed countries and to comply with the requirements of the large international banks, an adequate legal and institutional framework has been created, adapted to a market-oriented economy.     

Hydrothermal alteration in the Aluto-Langano geothermal field, Ethiopia

The hydrothermal mineral assemblages found in eight wells (with a depth range of 1320–2500 m) of the active geothermal field of Aluto-Langano (Ethiopia) indicate a complex evolution of water-rock interaction processes. The zone of upflow is characterized by high temperatures (up to 335°C) and the presence of a propylitic alteration (epidote, calcite, quartz and chlorite, as major phases) coexisting with calcite and clay minerals. The zone of lateral outflow is characterized by mixing of deep and shallow waters and the occurrence of a calcite-clay alteration that overprints a previous propylitic assemblage. Clay minerals have a mushroom-shaped zonal distribution consistent with the present thermal structure of the field. Microprobe analyses have been carried out on chlorite and illite in order to apply several geothermometers. Most of the chlorite is iron-rich chlorite. It is found that the temperatures calculated from the chlorite geothermometer (159–292°C) after Cathelineau and Nieva [Contrib. Mineral. Petrol. 91, 235–244 (1985)] are in good agreement with in-hole measured temperatures (155–300°C). In the upflow zone, temperatures calculated from this geothermometer (217–292°C), together with fluid inclusion data of Valori et al. [Eur. J. Mineral. 4, 907–919 (1992)], and computed saturation indices of alteration minerals, indicate thermal stability or slight heating. On the other hand, evidence of a significant cooling process (up to 171°C) in the outflow zone is provided by the comparison between fluid inclusion homogenization temperature (240–326°C) and in-hole temperature (155–250°C). The apparent salinities (0.8–2.3 wt% NaCl eq.) of the fluid inclusions are generally higher than the salinity of the present reservoir fluid (0.29–0.36 wt% NaCl eq.). Clay minerals (illite, smectite, Ill/S mixed layers, vermiculite and chloritic intergrades) generally occur at temperatures consistent with their stability fields.     

Hydrogeochemical exploration of geothermal prospects in the Tecuamburro Volcano region, Guatemala

Chemical and isotopic analyses of thermal and nonthermal waters and of gases from springs and fumaroles are used to evaluate the geothermal potential of the Tecuamburro Volcano region, Guatemala. Chemically distinct geothermal surface manifestations generally occur in separate hydrogeologic areas within this 400 km² region: low-pressure fumaroles with temperatures near local boiling occur at 1470 m elevation in a sulfur mine near the summit of Tecuamburro Volcano; non-boiling acid-sulfate hot springs and mud pots are restricted to the Laguna Ixpaco area, about 5 km NNW of the sulfur mine and 350–400 m lower in elevation; steam-heated and thermal-meteoric waters are found on the flanks of Tecuamburro Volcano and several kilometers to the north in the andesitic highland, where the Infernitos fumarole (97°C at 1180 m) is the primary feature; neutral-chloride hot springs discharge along Rio Los Esclavos, principally near Colmenares at 490 m elevation, about 8–10 km SE of Infernitos. Maximum geothermometer temperatures calculated from Colmenares neutral-chloride spring compositions are 180°C, whereas maximum subsurface temperatures based on Laguna Ixpaco gas compositions are 310°C. An exploration core hole drilled to a depth of 808 m about 0.3 km south of Laguna Ixpaco had a bottom-hole temperature of 238°C but did not produce sufficient fluids to confirm or chemically characterize a geothermal reservoir. Hydrogeochemical data combined with regional geologic interpretations indicate that there are probably two hydrothermal-convection systems, which are separated by a major NW-trending structural boundary, the Ixpaco fault. One system with reservoir temperatures near 300°C lies beneath Tecuamburro Volcano and consists of a large vapor zone that feeds steam to the Laguna Ixpaco area, with underlying hot water that flows laterally to feed a small group of warm, chloriderich springs SE of Tecuamburro Volcano. The other system is located beneath the Infernitos area in the andesitic highland and consists of a lower-temperature (150–190°C) reservoir with a large natural discharge that feeds the Colmenares hot springs.     

Temperature evaluation of the Bugok geothermal system, South Korea

Using a variety of chemical geothermometers and statistical analysis, we estimate the temperature of a possible deeper geothermal reservoir at Bugok, Southern Korea. Shallow thermal aquifers (down to about 400 m depth) are under exploitation in this area; the temperatures (up to 78 °C) of the produced fluids are the highest found in South Korea. Based on hydrochemical data and occurrence, the groundwaters at Bugok can be classified under three groups: Na-SO₄ thermal groundwaters (CTGW) occurring in the central (about 0.24 km²) part of the area; Ca-HCO₃ cold groundwater (SCGW) found in shallow peripheral parts of the CTGW; the intermediate-type groundwater (STGW). The CTGW type is typical of the Bugok thermal waters; they have the highest discharge temperatures and contain very high concentrations of Na (75.1–101.0 mg/L), K (2.9–6.9 mg/L) and SiO₂ (62.0–84.5 mg/L) and are rich in sulfates.The major ion composition of the CTGW suggests that these waters are in partial equilibrium with rocks at depth. The application of various alkali-ion geothermometers yields temperature estimates in the 88–198 °C range for the thermal reservoir. Multiple-mineral equilibrium calculations indicate a similar but narrower temperature range (from about 100 to 155 °C). These estimates for CTGW are significantly higher than the measured discharge temperatures. Considering the heat losses occurring during the ascent of the waters, one can infer the presence of a deeper (around 1.8 km) thermal reservoir in the Bugok area that could be developed for district heating or other direct applications of geothermal heat.     

Partitioning of rare earths and some major elements in the Kizildere geothermal field, Turkey

Rare earth elements and yttrium (REY), Na⁺, K⁺, Cl⁻, and Ca²⁺ were determined in water, steam, mineral scale and rock samples from the Kizildere geothermal field, Turkey. The CO₂-rich parent fluid originates from a sequence of mica schists with marble intercalations. The chemistry of the parent fluid varies with location and time. The average REY composition of the fluids is derived by extrapolation to the lowest Ca concentrations. The apparent vapor–liquid partitioning factors for REY at 145 °C and 5 bar total absolute pressure are about 0.2, whereas for Ca²⁺, Na⁺, K⁺ and Cl⁻ they are <0.05, about 0.0005, 0.0005 and about 0.02, respectively. Apparent scale-liquid distribution coefficients for REY at 145 and 190 °C are about 0.15 and 0.55, whereas at 100 °C they increase from 0.3 (La) to 1.5 (Lu).