Multicast protection scheme in survivable WDM optical networks

The protection design is a key issue in survivable wavelength division multiplexing (WDM) optical networks. Most researches focused on protecting unicast traffic against the failure of a single network component such as a link or a node. In this paper, we investigate the protection scheme for multicast traffic in meshed WDM optical networks under dual-link failure consideration, and propose a novel protection algorithm called shared segment protection with reprovisioning (SSPR). Through dynamically adjusting link-cost according to the current network state, SSPR establishes a primary light-tree and corresponding link-disjoint backup segments for each multicast connection request. A backup segment can efficiently share wavelength capacity of its working tree or the common resource of other backup segments. Capacity reprovisioning establishes new segments for the vulnerable connections after a link failure and tolerates following link failures. The simulation results show that SSPR not only can make good use of wavelength resources and protect multicast sessions against any single-link failure, but also can greatly improve the traffic restorability in the event of dual-link breakdown.     

Multilayer Protection with Availability Guarantees in Optical WDM Networks

Survivability is a key concern in modern network design. This paper investigates the problem of survivable dynamic connection provisioning in general telecom backbone networks, that are mesh structured. We assume differentiated services where connections may have different availability requirements, so they may be provisioned differently with protection (if needed) based on their availability requirements and current network state. The problem of effectively provisioning differentiated-service requests, that has been widely investigated for connections routed at the physical layer, assumes peculiar features if we consider sub-wavelength requests at the logical layer that have to be protected (or more generically, whose availability target has to be guaranteed), but also have to be groomed for an efficient use of network resources. An integrated multilayer approach is necessary that considers requirements and grooming of connections at the logical layer as well as their routing and availability at the physical layer. Joint availability-guaranteed routing and traffic grooming may lead to a negative interaction, since the objective of the first problem (guaranteeing a given level of availability to the connections) clashes with the objective of the other problem (minimizing resource consumption). For a multilayer WDM mesh network, we propose new multilayer routing strategies that perform effective availability-guaranteed grooming of sub-wavelength connections. These strategies jointly considers connection availability satisfaction and resource optimization and are developed under two different practical hypotheses: guaranteed target, i.e., a connection is routed only if its availability target is satisfied, and best-effort target, a connection is always routed and, when the availability target cannot be guaranteed, the path with the best possible availability is provisioned. Numerical results are reported and discussed for the two approaches mentioned above. In both cases, the results show high effectiveness of our provisioning strategy.     

Rerouting schemes for dynamic traffic grooming in optical WDM networks

Traffic grooming in optical WDM mesh networks is a two-layer routing problem to effectively pack low-rate connections onto high-rate lightpaths, which, in turn, are established on wavelength links. The objective of traffic grooming is to improve resource efficiency. However, resource contention between lightpaths and connections may result in inefficient resource usage or even the blocking of some connections. In this work, we employ a rerouting approach to alleviate resource inefficiency and improve the network throughput under a dynamic traffic model. We propose two rerouting schemes, rerouting at lightpath level (RRLP) and rerouting at connection level (RRCON) and a qualitative comparison is made between the two. We also propose two heuristic rerouting algorithms, namely the critical-wavelength-avoiding one-lightpath-limited (CWA-1L) rerouting algorithm and the critical-lightpath-avoiding one-connection-limited (CLA-1C) rerouting algorithm, which are based on the two rerouting schemes. Simulation results show that rerouting reduces the blocking probability of connections significantly.     

Traffic grooming, routing, and wavelength assignment in WDM transport networks with sparse grooming resources

While a single fiber strand in wavelength division multiplexing (WDM) has over a terabit-per-second bandwidth and a wavelength channel has over a gigabit-per-second transmission speed, the network may still be required to support traffic requests at rates that are lower than the full wavelength capacity. To avoid assigning an entire lightpath to a small request, many researchers have looked at adding traffic grooming to the routing and wavelength assignment (RWA) problem. In this work, we consider the RWA problem with traffic grooming (GRWA) for mesh networks under static and dynamic lightpath connection requests. The GRWA problem is NP-Complete since it is a generalization of the RWA problem which is known to be NP-Complete. We propose an integer linear programming (ILP) model that accurately depicts the GRWA problem. Because it is very hard to find a solution for large networks using ILP, we solve the GRWA problem by proposing two novel heuristics. The strength of the proposed heuristics stems from their simplicity, efficiency, and applicability to large-scale networks. Our simulation results demonstrate that deploying traffic grooming resources on the edge of optical networks is more cost effective and results in a similar blocking performance to that obtained when distributing the grooming resources throughout the optical network domain.     

A new approach for designing fault-tolerant WDM networks

In recent years, path protection has emerged as a widely accepted technique for designing survivable WDM networks. This approach is attractive, since it is able to provide bandwidth guarantees in the presence of link failures. However, it requires allocating resources for backup lightpaths, which remain idle under normal fault-free conditions. In this paper, we introduce a new approach for designing fault-tolerant WDM networks, based on the concept of survivable routing. Survivable routing of a logical topology ensures that the lightpaths are routed in such a way that a single link failure does not disconnect the network. When a topology is generated using our approach, it is guaranteed to have a survivable routing. We further ensure that the logical topology is able to handle the entire traffic demand after any single link failure. We first present an ILP that optimally designs a survivable logical topology, and then propose a heuristic for larger networks. Experimental results demonstrate that this new approach is able to provide guaranteed bandwidth, and is much more efficient in terms of resource utilization, compared to both dedicated and shared path protection.     

Differentiated survivability with improved fairness in IP/MPLS-over-WDM optical networks

This paper addresses the priority-fairness problem inherent in provisioning differentiated survivability services for sub-lambda connections associated with different protection-classes in IP/MPLS-over-WDM networks. The priority-fairness problem arises because, high-priority connections requiring high quality of protection such as lambda level pre-configured lightpath protection are more likely to be rejected when compared to low-priority connections which may not need such a high quality of protection. A challenging task in addressing this problem is that, while improving the acceptance rate of high-priority connections, low-priority connections should not be over-penalized. We propose two solution-approaches to address this problem. In the first approach, a new inter-class backup resource sharing (ICBS) technique and a differentiated routing scheme (DiffRoute) are adopted. The ICBS is investigated in two methods: partial- and full-ICBS (p-ICBS and f-ICBS) methods. The DiffRoute scheme uses different routing criteria for the traffic classes. In the second approach, two rerouting schemes are developed. The rerouting schemes are applied with the DiffRoute and ICBS. The rerouting schemes employ inter-layer backup resource sharing and inter-layer primary-backup multiplexing for the benefit of high-priority connections, thus improving fairness. Our findings are as follows. (1) The application of p-ICBS and DiffRoute yields improved performance for high-priority connections. However, it shows penalized performance for low-priority connections. On the other hand, the collective application of f-ICBS and DiffRoute yields significantly improved performance for high-priority connections with no penalized performance as the performance of low-priority connections is also improved. (2) The rerouting schemes, when applied with the DiffRoute and ICBS methods, further improve the performance of high-priority traffic without significantly affecting the performance of other traffic.     

Ant-based survivable routing in dynamic WDM networks with shared backup paths

In this paper, we consider the problem of survivable routing in dynamic WDM networks with single link failure model. Our work mainly concerns in how to dynamically determine a protection cycle (i.e., two link-disjoint paths between a node pair) to establish a dependable lightpath with backup paths sharing. This problem is identified as NP-complete, thus a heuristic for finding near optimal solution with reasonable computation time is usually preferred. Inspired from the principle of ant colony optimization, we propose in this paper an ant-based mobile agents algorithm for this problem with improved blocking performance. To enable the new ant-based algorithm, we propose to use on each network node both a routing table that contains a set of feasible protection cycles between source destination nodes and also a pheromone table for mobile agents. By keeping a suitable number of mobile agents in a network to continually and proactively update the routing tables based on the current network congestion state, the routing solution of a connection request can be obtained with a reasonable computation time. Extensive simulation results upon the ns-2 network simulator and two typical network topologies show that our new algorithm can achieve a significantly lower blocking probability than the promising algorithm for dynamic lightpath protection proposed in [11] with a comparable computation complexity.     

Segment Routing体系结构中的域内路由保护方案

学术界和工业界提出利用路由保护方案来提高域内路由协议应对故障的能力，从而加速网络故障恢复，降低由于网络故障引起的网络中断时间。目前互联网普遍采用的路由保护方案包括LFA和U-turn，由于它们的简单和高效，受到了互联网服务提供商的支持，但是这两种方案的单链路故障保护率较低。因此，段路由（Segment Routing，SR）被提出解决上述两种方案存在的问题，已有的针对SR的研究主要集中在其体系结构和应用场景。研究如何在SR中计算segments，将该问题表述为一个整数线性规划问题，提出一种两阶段的启发式算法（Two Phase Heuristic Algorithm，TPHA）求解该问题，将算法在不同网络拓扑中进行了模拟。模拟结果表明，TPHA的单链路故障保护率远远高于LFA和U-turn的单链路故障保护率。     

Survivable power efficiency oriented integrated grooming in green networks

The wide interests in the power savings of IP over wavelength-division-multiplexing (WDM) optical networks have recently risen in both academic and industrial communities. In an effort to tackle this problem, the hybrid grooming (traffic grooming along with an optical bypass) approach has been presented to reduce the power consumed by the entire network infrastructure, including the transmission ports of routers and optical-electrical-optical (OEO) conversions. However, the related works pay little or no attention to the power consumed to ensure the resiliency of the overall network. Meanwhile, the power consumed by components used for establishing lightpaths is not simultaneously taken into account. One survivable network with the higher power efficiency thereby save more power with hybrid grooming, require the lower power consumption of establishing lightpaths and exhibit the shorter recovery time. For the first time, this paper proposes the evaluating models of both survivable power ratio and protection switching time. We subsequently compare two green and survivable grooming heuristics, known as Single-hop Survivable Grooming with considering Power Efficiency (SSGPE) and Multi-hop Survivable Grooming with considering Power Efficiency (MSGPE). Simulation results demonstrate that, MSGPE obtains the higher power efficiency and resiliency although it has the slightly higher time complexity in comparison to SSGPE. Furthermore, it is effective to exploiting waveband merging in our MSGPE to form integrated grooming for further port savings.     

Graph transformation approaches for diverse routing in shared risk resource group (SRRG) failures

Failure resilience is a desired feature of the Internet. Most traditional restoration architectures assume single failure assumption, which is not adequate in present day WDM optical networks.Multiple link failure models, in the form of shared risk link groups (SRLG’s) and shared risk node groups (SRNG’s) are becoming critical in survivable optical network design. We classify both of these form of failures under a common scenario of shared risk resource groups (SRRG) failures. We develop graph transformation techniques for tolerating multiple failures arising out of shared resource group (SRRG) failures.Diverse routing in such multi-failure scenario essentially necessitates finding out two paths between a source and a destination that are SRRG disjoint. The generalized diverse routing problem has been proved to be NP-Complete. The proposed transformation techniques however provides a polynomial time solution for certain restrictive failure sets. We study how restorability can be achieved for dependent or shared risk link failures and multiple node failures and prove the validity of our approach for different network scenarios. Our proposed technique is capable of improving the diverse route computation by around 20–30% as compared to approaches proposed in the literature.     

Realization strategies of dedicated path protection: A bandwidth cost perspective

Communication networks have to provide a high level of availability and instantaneous recovery after failures in order to ensure sufficient survivability for mission-critical services. Currently, dedicated path protection (or 1 + 1) is implemented in backbone networks to provide the necessary resilience and instantaneous recovery against single link failures with remarkable simplicity. However, in order to satisfy strict availability requirements, connections also have to be resilient against Shared Risk Link Group (SRLG) failures. In addition, switching matrix reconfigurations have to be avoided after a failure in order to guarantee instantaneous recovery. For this purpose, there are several possible realization strategies improving the characteristics of traditional 1 + 1 path protection by lowering reserved bandwidth while conserving all its favorable properties. These methods either utilize diversity coding, network coding, or generalize the disjoint-path constraint of 1 + 1.In this paper, we consider the cost aspect of the traditional and the alternative 1 + 1 realization strategies. We evaluate the bandwidth cost of different schemes both analytically and empirically in realistic network topologies. As the more complex realizations lead to NP-complete problems even in the single link failure case, we propose both Integer Linear Programming (ILP) based optimal methods, as well as heuristic and meta-heuristic approaches to solve them. Our findings provide a tool and guidelines for service providers for selecting the path protection method with the lowest bandwidth cost for their network corresponding to a given level of reliability.     

Two-link failure protection in WDM mesh networks with p-cycles

In WDM networks, it is important to protect connections against link failures due to the high bandwidth provided by a fiber link. Although many p-cycle based schemes have been proposed for single-link failure protection, protection against two-link failures have not received much attention. In this paper, we propose p-cycle based protection schemes for two-link failures. We formulate an ILP model for the p-cycle design problem for static traffic. We also propose two protection schemes for dynamic traffic, namely SPPP (Shortest Path Pair Protection) and SFPP (Short Full Path Protection). Simulation results show that SFPP is more capacity efficient than SPPP under incremental traffic. Under dynamic traffic, SPPP has lower blocking than SFPP when the traffic load is low and has higher blocking than SFPP when the traffic load is high.     

网络可存活生成树的快速恢复算法

如何应对网络链接失效是具有挑战性的问题之一,通常采用包含两棵生成树的可存活连接来预防链接失效。由于网络数据传输速率的高速增长,当两棵生成树的共享链接失效时,可存活连接中的生成树将全部失效。针对可存活连接中共享链接的失效提出了一种快速恢复算法,该算法通过搜索失效链接的可替换链接集,将失效概率最小的链接加入原可存活连接中的生成树,生成新的可存活连接。实验结果表明,该算法能够在显著降低恢复时间和时间复杂度的情形下,同时保证可存活连接的存活度接近当前网络的最优存活度。当网络节点数在10～100变化时,提出的算法比现有算法在恢复时间上的平均优化高达34.42%,同时在存活度上的误差不超过1%。     

Network protection codes: Providing self-healing in autonomic networks using network coding

Agile recovery from link failures in autonomic communication networks is essential to increase robustness, accessibility, and reliability of data transmission. However, this must be done with the least amount of protection resources, while using simple management plane functionalities. Recently, network coding has been proposed as a solution to provide agile and cost efficient self-healing against link failures, in a manner that does not require data rerouting, packet retransmission, or failure localization, hence leading to simple control and management planes. To achieve this, separate paths have to be provisioned to carry encoded packets, hence requiring either the addition of extra links, or reserving some of the resources for this purpose.In this paper we introduce self-healing strategies for autonomic networks in order to protect against link failures. The strategies are based on network coding and reduced capacity, which is a technique that we call network protection codes (NPC). In these strategies, an autonomic network is able to provide self-healing from various network failures affecting network operation. Also, network protection codes are extended to provide self-healing from multiple link failures in autonomic networks. Although this leads to reducing the network capacity, the network capacity reduction is asymptotically small in most cases of practical interest. We provide implementation aspects of the proposed strategies, derive bounds and show how to construct network protection code. The paper also develops an Integer Linear Program formulation to evaluate the cost of provisioning connections using the proposed strategies, and uses results from this formulation to show that it is more resource efficient than 1 + 1 protection. A simulation study to evaluate the recovery times, and the buffering requirements due to network coding is also conducted using the OPNET simulator.     

Protecting multicast services in optical internet backbones

Many applications in the future Internet will use the multicasting service mode. Since many of these applications will generate large amounts of traffic, and since users expect a high level of service availability, it is important to provision multicasting sessions in the future Internet while also providing protection for multicast sessions against network component failures. In this paper we address the multicast survivability problem of using minimum resources to provision a multicast session and its protection paths (trees) against any single-link failure. We propose a new, and a resource efficient, protection scheme, namely, Segment-based Protection Tree (SPT). In SPT scheme, a given multicast session is first provisioned as a primary multicast tree, and then each segment on the primary tree is protected by a multicast tree instead of a path, as in most existing approaches. We also analyze the recovery performance of SPT and design a reconfiguration calculation algorithm to compute the average number of reconfigurations upon any link failure. By extending SPT to address dynamic traffic scenarios, we also propose two heuristic algorithms, Cost-based SPT (CB_SPT) and Wavelength-based SPT (WB_SPT). We study the performance of the SPT scheme in different traffic scenarios. The numerical results show that SPT outperforms the best existing approaches, optimal path-pair-based shared disjoint paths (OPP_SDPs). SPT uses less than 10% extra resources to provision a survivable multicast session over the optimal solution and up to 4% lower than existing approaches under various traffic scenarios and has an average number of reconfigurations 10–86% less than the best cost efficient approach. Moreover, in dynamic traffic cases, both CB_SPT and WB_SPT achieves overall blocking probability with 20% lower than OPP_SDP in most network scenarios.     

A multi-objective approach for solving the survivable network design problem with simultaneous unicast and anycast flows

In this paper, we consider the survivable network design problem for simultaneous unicast and anycast flow requests. We assume that the network is modeled by a connected and undirected graph. This problem aims at finding a set of connections with a minimized network cost in order to protect the network against any single failure. The cost is computed using the all capacities modular cost (ACMC) model and a set of flow demands. We name it as ACMC-based survivable network design problem (A-SNDP). It is proved that the problem is NP-hard. We introduce a multi-objective approach to solve A-SNDP. The objectives are to minimize the network cost (NCost) and the network failure (NFail). Extensive simulation results on instances of Polska, Germany and Atlanta networks showed the efficiency of the multi-objective approach for solving A-SNDP.     

基于拥塞及内存感知的SD-WAN故障恢复

在软件定义广域网(SD-WAN)中, 链路故障会导致大量丢包, 严重时会引起部分网络瘫痪. 现有的流量工程方法通过在数据平面提前安装备份路径能够加快故障恢复过程, 但在资源受限的情况下难以适应各种网络故障情况, 从而使恢复后的网络性能下降. 为了保证网络在故障恢复之后的性能并减少备份资源的消耗, 本文提出一种基于拥塞及内存感知的主动式故障恢复方案(CAMA), 不仅能够将受影响数据流进行快速重定向, 还能实现负载均衡避免恢复后潜在的链路拥塞. 实验结果表明, 与已有方案相比, CAMA能有效利用备份资源, 在负载均衡上有较好的性能, 且仅需少量备份规则即可覆盖所有单链路故障情况.     

Forward-Looking WDM Network Reconfiguration with Per-Link Congestion Control

We study reconfigurations of wavelength-routed Wavelength Division Multiplexing (WDM) networks in response to lightpath demand changes, with the objective of servicing more lightpath demands without additional network resources from a long-term network operation point of view. For the reconfiguration problem under study, we assume WDM network operators are provided with lightpath demands in batches. With limited network resources, our problem has two unique challenges: balancing network resource allocations between current and future lightpath demands, and modeling future lightpath demands. The first challenge implies making tradeoffs between accepting as many current immediate lightpath demands as possible and reserving a certain amount of network resources for near future predicted lightpath demands. The second challenge implies modeling future predicted lightpath demands, which are not exactly known or certain as the current lightpath demands. Our proposed model allows a natural separation between the operation of the optical layer and the user traffic layer (predominantly the IP-layer), while supporting their interactions, for which we propose a new formulation for per-link congestion control, associated with a mathematical solution procedure. Our simulation results reveal that by properly controlling resource allocations in the current session using our proposed mechanism, rejections in future sessions are greatly reduced.     

互联网无中断转发的生存性路由协议

互联网逐渐成为通信基础设施并承载了更多的关键业务流量,即使瞬时中断也会对某些应用造成巨大损失.然而,传统路由协议在出现链路/节点故障等拓扑变化时存在收敛时间长、瞬时不可达以及环路的问题.实际测量发现,路由瞬时失效相当普遍.因此,研究人员提出多种能够保证流量无中断转发和快速恢复的路由协议.在分析瞬时失效现象以后,提出了生存性路由协议的分类方法,重点对一些重要的路由协议的核心路由机制进行深入分析,并比较其特点、性能、开销等.最后,结合该领域研究现状以及存在的问题,指出未来生存性路由的研究重点.     

互联网无中断转发的生存性路由协议

互联网逐渐成为通信基础设施并承载了更多的关键业务流量,即使瞬时中断也会对某些应用造成巨大损失.然而,传统路由协议在出现链路/节点故障等拓扑变化时存在收敛时间长、瞬时不可达以及环路的问题.实际测量发现,路由瞬时失效相当普遍.因此,研究人员提出多种能够保证流量无中断转发和快速恢复的路由协议.在分析瞬时失效现象以后,提出了生存性路由协议的分类方法,重点对一些重要的路由协议的核心路由机制进行深入分析,并比较其特点、性能、开销等.最后,结合该领域研究现状以及存在的问题,指出未来生存性路由的研究重点.