Analytical design of proportional-integral controllers for the optimal control of first-order processes with operational constraints

A novel analytical design method of industrial proportional-integral (PI) controllers was developed for the optimal control of first-order processes with operational constraints. The control objective was to minimize a weighted sum of the controlled variable error and the rate of change in the manipulated variable under the maximum allowable limits in the controlled variable, manipulated variable and the rate of change in the manipulated variable. The constrained optimal servo control problem was converted to an unconstrained optimization to obtain an analytical tuning formula. A practical shortcut procedure for obtaining optimal PI parameters was provided based on graphical analysis of global optimality. The proposed PI controller was found to guarantee global optimum and deal explicitly with the three important operational constraints.     

基于高斯模型的聚乙烯过程设计与控制集成优化

聚乙烯反应过程中物流-能流剧烈交叠、反应-传递相互耦合,使得过程具有强非线性以及多重稳态。传统的顺序设计方法不能保证系统有足够的控制自由度,当存在扰动和过程参数不确定性时,仅依靠设计控制器很难提高产品质量。提出一种聚乙烯工艺稳态设计与运行控制的集成优化方案,创造性地引入Kriging高斯模型同时预测模型动态和模型不确定性。另一个重要的贡献是在聚乙烯工艺设计阶段,设计性能指标,定量描述过程稳态设计对闭环动态的影响。所提出的方法已经通过对气相聚乙烯工艺设计和运行控制的集成优化进行了验证,并在参数不确定性和扰动存在情况下仿真证实了集成优化设计方案的高效性。     

Optimization‐Based Nonlinear Centralized Controller Tuning of Liquid‐Liquid Extraction Processes

Abstract

The control problem of an agitated contactor is considered in this work. A Scheibel extraction column is modeled using the non‐equilibrium backflow mixing cell model. Model dynamic analysis shows that this process is highly nonlinear, thus the control problem solution of such a system needs to tackle the process nonlinearity efficiently. The control problem of this process is solved by developing a multivariable nonlinear control system implemented in MATLAB?. In this control methodology, a new controller tuning method is adopted, in which the time‐domain control parameter‐tuning problem is solved as a constrained optimization problem. A MIMO (multi‐input multi‐output) PI controller structure is used in this strategy. The centralized controller uses a 2×2 transfer function and accounts for loops interaction. The controller parameters are tuned using an optimization‐based algorithm with constraints imposed on the process variables reference trajectories. Incremental tuning procedure is performed until the extractor output variables transient response satisfies a preset uncertainty which bounds around the reference trajectory. A decentralized model‐based IMC (internal model control) control strategy is compared with the newly developed centralized MIMO PI control one. Stability and robustness tests are applied to the two algorithms. The performance of the MIMO PI controller is found to be superior to that of the conventional IMC controller in terms of stability, robustness, loops interaction handling, and step‐change tracking characteristics.     

Inferential Control of Reactive Destillation Columns – An Algorithmic Approach

Decentralized control system design comprises the selection of a suitable control structure and controller parameters. Here, mixed integer optimization is used to determine the optimal control structure and the optimal controller parameters simultaneously. The process dynamics is included explicitly into the constraints using a rigorous nonlinear dynamic process model. Depending on the objective function, which is used for the evaluation of competing control systems, two different formulations are proposed which lead to mixed‐integer dynamic optimization (MIDO) problems. A MIDO solution strategy based on the sequential approach is adopted in the present paper. Here, the MIDO problem is decomposed into a series of nonlinear programming (NLP) subproblems (dynamic optimization) where the binary variables are fixed, and mixed‐integer linear programming (MILP) master problems which determine a new binary configuration for the next NLP subproblem. The proposed methodology is applied to inferential control of reactive distillation columns as a challenging benchmark problem for chemical process control.     

ENHANCED IMC-PID CONTROLLER DESIGN WITH LEAD-LAG FILTER FOR UNSTABLE AND INTEGRATING PROCESSES WITH TIME DELAY

In this article, a design method for a PID controller is proposed based on IMC principles for control of open loop integrating and unstable first-order processes with time delay. The design is based on H₂ optimal closed-loop transfer function for set point changes and step input disturbances. The method has one tuning parameter, and systematic guidelines are provided for the selection of this tuning parameter based on peak value of the sensitivity function. The performance of the designed controller is verified on various integrating and unstable processes, and it is observed that nominal and robust control performance is achieved with the proposed design method. Improved closed-loop performance was obtained when compared to other methods recently reported in the literature. Further, the proposed method provides good closed-loop performance even when there are large uncertainties in the process parameters.     

A Simplified Numerical Approach to Feedback Controller Design

A generalized parameter optimization method for computing feedback controller parameters is proposed. The method utilizes the downhill simplex method (DSM), a pattern search algorithm, to determine the optimal parameters that minimize an objective function or performance index. The system model, expressed in terms of state‐space equations is integrated with respect to time at each DSM iteration in order to determine the states. A fourth‐order Runge‐Kutta scheme is used for integrating the state equations. A penalty function approach is used for problems with inequality constraints on the state variables or controls. Though relatively inefficient in terms of the number of function evaluations, DSM requires only that the user provide the model equations, and not their derivatives. Additionally, the DSM code is very compact. Thus, a small and straightforward program allows for controller parameter determination for a variety of state‐space and classical PID feedback control design problems.     

An LMI Method to Robust Iterative Learning Fault-tolerant Guaranteed Cost Control for Batch Processes

Based on an equivalent two-dimensional Fornasini-Marchsini model for a batch process in industry, a closed-loop robust iterative learning fault-tolerant guaranteed cost control scheme is proposed for batch processes with actuator failures. This paper introduces relevant concepts of the fault-tolerant guaranteed cost control and formulates the robust iterative learning reliable guaranteed cost controller （ILRGCC）. A significant advantage is that the proposed ILRGCC design method can be used for on-line optimization against batch-to-batch process uncertainties to realize robust tracking of set-point trajectory in time and batch-to-batch sequences. For the convenience of implementation, only measured output errors of current and previous cycles are used to design a synthetic controller for iterative learning control, consisting of dynamic output feedback plus feed-forward control. The proposed controller can not only guarantee the closed-loop convergency along time and cycle sequences but also satisfy the H∞ performance level and a cost function with upper bounds for all admissible uncertainties and any actuator failures. Sufficient conditions for the controller solution are derived in terms of linear matrix inequalities （LMIs）, and design procedures, which formulate a convex optimization problem with LMI constraints, are presented. An example of injection molding is given to illustrate the effectiveness and advantages of the ILRGCC design approach.     

鲁棒模型预测控制系统的评估基准

在控制系统的性能评估中,基准的设计是个重要问题。将基本设计极限理论推广到模型预测控制系统(MPC),建立性能评估基准。直接考虑多输入多输出系统的频域扰动,建立输出反馈鲁棒模型预测控制器。此控制器仅仅依赖于过程参数,也是令闭环系统达到控制性能极限的基准控制器。建立了用于评估的性能指标,提出基于此基准的性能评估程序,用以评价其他模型预测控制系统的性能。数学算例证实了这一评估程序的有效性。     

全流程卷式反渗透海水淡化系统操作优化

在对反渗透海水淡化系统流程和实际应用分析的基础上,提出了一种旨在降低总体操作费用的全流程反渗透海水淡化系统优化方法。首先根据系统变参数特点并充分利用蓄水池的缓冲能力,建立了反渗透过程机理模型、蓄水池动态过程模型以及变参数方程模型,实现了整个流程的方程描述。然后根据工艺流程和操作过程费用组成情况建立了总的操作费用模型,得到了全流程单位产水费用指标。在此基础上建立了以总体操作费用最低为目标、以开放方程描述的各模型方程为约束、以设备和产品质量限制为边界的优化命题,采用联立求解技术将该微分代数方程组成的优化（DAOP）问题转化为NLP问题后进行求解。最后对某海水淡化系统进行了实例研究。优化求解结果不仅表明本优化方法可以大幅降低实际操作费用,而且通过求解还可得到各种变参数条件下最优操作费用组成,以及实现费用最低的最优操作压力和流量变化曲线。本研究对优化海水淡化系统操作、降低总体操作费用具有重要意义。     

Integrated control and process design during optimal polymer grade transition operations

In this work we address the simultaneous process control and design problem of polymerization reactors during dynamic grade transition operation. The problem is cast as a Mixed-Integer Dynamic Optimization (MIDO) formulation and, by using the full discretization approach for solving dynamic optimization problems [Kameswaran, S., & Biegler, L. T. (2006). Simultaneous dynamic optimization strategies: Recent advances and challenges. Computers & Chemical Engineering, 30 (10–12), 1560–1575], is transformed into a Mixed-Integer Nonlinear Program (MINLP). The resulting MINLP is solved using a full space nonconvex optimization formulation [Flores-Tlacuahuac, A., & Biegler, L. T. (2007). Simultaneous Mixed-Integer Dynamic Optimization for integrated design and control. Computers & Chemical Engineering, 31, 588–600]. The control and design formulation has been applied to two polymerization reactors featuring highly nonlinear behavior. In both cases, the proposed MIDO formulation was capable of finding optimal solutions. This amounts to finding optimal steady states, reactor designs, as well as open-loop and closed-loop dynamic optimal trajectories, control structures and controller parameters by specifying either the polymer molecular weight distribution or monomer conversion. Because CPU solution time tends to increase with system complexity, some strategies for lowering CPU time are discussed.     

PID参数优化算法

PID参数优化是自动控制领域研究的一个重要问题。为了实现最优PID控制,PID参数优化算法已成为国内外控制理论研究的一个热点。随着计算机技术的发展,一些新的智能算法得到了迅速发展和广泛应用,并在理论和应用方面都有重要的意义。主要介绍了PID参数优化算法以及近年来在此方面取得的研究成果,并对未来PID参数优化的研究方向作了展望。     

Decentralized Control System Design under Uncertainty Using Mixed‐Integer Optimization

Decentralized control system design comprises the selection of a suitable control structure and controller parameters. In this contribution, the optimal control structure and the optimal controller parameters are determined simultaneously using mixed‐integer dynamic optimization (MIDO) under uncertainty, to account for nonlinear process dynamics and various disturbance scenarios. Application of the sigma point method is proposed in order to approximate the expectation and the variance of a chosen performance index with a minimum number of points to solve the MIDO problem under uncertainty. The proposed methodology is demonstrated with a benchmark problem of an inferential control for a reactive distillation column. The results are compared with established heuristic design methods and with previous deterministic approaches.     

PARAMETER IDENTIFICATION AND THE SELF-TUNING ADAPTIVE CONTROL BY A SENSITIVITY APPROACH

Parameter deviation identification and optimal controller tuning are derived by the sensitivities of the parameters. There are non-iterative and iterative algorithms which can be used for parameter identification, no matter the data come from an open-loop test or from a closed-loop operation. The controller tuning is based on the parameter sensitivities of an optimal regulator. The same tuning algorithm has been proved satisfactory for the PID control of the first order process with delay. By sequential implementations of both the identification and tuning, a self-tuning adaptive control system can be obtained. Numerical examples show the feasibility of such algorithms.     

PARAMETER IDENTIFICATION AND THE SELF-TUNING ADAPTIVE CONTROL BY A SENSITIVITY APPROACH

Parameter deviation identification and optimal controller tuning are derived by the sensitivities of the parameters. There are non-iterative and iterative algorithms which can be used for parameter identification, no matter the data come from an open-loop test or from a closed-loop operation. The controller tuning is based on the parameter sensitivities of an optimal regulator. The same tuning algorithm has been proved satisfactory for the PID control of the first order process with delay. By sequential implementations of both the identification and tuning, a self-tuning adaptive control system can be obtained. Numerical examples show the feasibility of such algorithms.     

A path constrained method for integration of process design and control

Integration of process design and control (IPDC) has been the holy grail of process systems engineering since the introduction of heat and mass integration. A proper combination of these separate yet connected tasks carries the promise of achieving superior designs that cannot be realized with conventional procedures. In this work, a bi-level dynamic optimization approach is introduced for achieving IPDC in its true sense. The principal idea proposed here is to utilize an optimal controller (a modified linear quadratic regulator) to practically evaluate the best achievable control performance for each candidate design during process design. The evaluation of complete, closed-loop system dynamics can then be meshed with a superstructure-based process design algorithm, thus enabling considering both cost and controllability in design of a process. The practicality of the introduced approach enables a solution of this complex dynamic optimization problem within reasonable computational requirements, as demonstrated in an evaporator case study.     

Differential-geometric model-based control (DGMBC): A software package for controller design

This paper presents a new software package, called differential-geometric model-based control (DGMBC), which carries out symbolic manipulations to automatically generate differential-geometric, model-based controllers and subsequently tests the designed controller. This prototype software was developed to simplify the industrial implementation and testing of differential-geometric, model-based controllers on lumped-parameter processes. DGMBC has a user-friendly interface that allows a user to enter process model equations and parameters easily. The user interface was developed using Visual Basic and linked to MATHEMATICA using MathLink. The user enters the process model (set of ordinary differential equations), and the software generates an analytical model-based controller, if an analytical solution exists. The resulting analytical model-based controller (set of ordinary differential and algebraic equations) can be in FORTRAN, C, or MATLAB format. DGMBC can also simulate the closed-loop process responses. The application and implementation of DGMBC 1.0 are shown using three chemical and biochemical process examples with varying levels of complexity. An analytical model-based controller is designed for each of the processes, and simulation results showing the closed-loop process responses are presented.     

Analytical design of enhanced PID filter controller for integrating and first order unstable processes with time delay

An analytical design for a proportional-integral derivative (PID) controller cascaded with a first order lead/lag filter is proposed for integrating and first order unstable processes with time delay. The design algorithm is based on the internal model control (IMC) criterion, which has a single tuning parameter to adjust the performance and robustness of the controller. A setpoint filter is used to diminish the overshoot in the servo response. In the simulation study, the controllers were tuned to have the same degree of robustness by measuring the maximum sensitivity, Ms, in order to obtain a reasonable comparison. Furthermore, the robustness of the controller was investigated by inserting a perturbation uncertainty in all parameters simultaneously to obtain the worst case model mismatch, and the proposed method showed more robustness against process parameter uncertainty than the other methods. For the selection of the closed-loop time constant, λ, a guideline is also provided over a broad range of time-delay/time-constant ratios. The simulation results obtained for the suggested method were compared with those obtained for other recently published design methods to illustrate the superiority of the proposed method.     

分批补料反应过程的非固定终端经济优化控制

针对批次生产周期不确定问题,提出一种非固定终端的经济优化控制方法。首先采用经济模型预测控制方法,用收益最大化的经济型目标函数代替终端约束,并将批次生产周期纳入被优化变量,建立动态经济优化问题,并通过对每个控制变量进行有差异的参数化,将动态优化问题转化为非线性规划（NLP）问题;然后使用内点罚函数法求解含非线性约束的优化问题,得到的最优控制序列和最佳批次生产周期,可将不确定扰动带来的损失降低到最小。其次采用非固定预测时域的滚动时域控制方法,不仅提高多变量系统的协同控制能力,而且根据实时预测终端产品产量不断优化更新关键操纵变量的控制分段函数的分割数及控制序列,从而可灵活优化操纵变量和操作时间的轨迹。最后在苯胺加氢过程上进行了批次优化控制性能测试,测试结果表明,非固定终端的经济优化控制从批次的总生产效益角度来优化每个批次生产的操作条件,实现批次反应过程生产时间与经济效益的最优化管理。     

Optimal grade transition and selection of closed-loop controllers in a gas-phase olefin polymerization fluidized bed reactor

To satisfy the diverse product quality specifications required by the broad range of polyolefin applications, polymerization plants are forced to operate under frequent grade transition policies. Commonly, the optimal solution to this problem is based on the minimization of a suitable objective function defined in terms of the changeover time, product quality specifications, process safety constraints and the amount of off-spec polymer, using dynamic optimization methods. However, considering the great impact that a given control structure configuration can have on the process operability and product quality optimization, the time optimal grade transition problem needs to be solved in parallel with the optimal selection of the closed-loop control pairings between the controlled and manipulated variables. In the present study, a mixed integer dynamic optimization approach is applied to a catalytic gas-phase ethylene-1-butene copolymerization fluidized bed reactor (FBR) to calculate both the “best” closed-loop control configuration and the time optimal grade transition policies. The gPROMS/gOPT computational tools for modelling and dynamic optimization, and the GAMS/CPLEX MILP solver are employed for the solution of the combined optimization problem. Simulation results are presented showing the significant quality and economic benefits that can be achieved through the application of the proposed integrated approach to the optimal grade transition problem for a gas-phase polyolefin FBR.     

Koopman Lyapunov-based model predictive control of nonlinear chemical process systems

In this work, we propose the integration of Koopman operator methodology with Lyapunov-based model predictive control (LMPC) for stabilization of nonlinear systems. The Koopman operator enables global linear representations of nonlinear dynamical systems. The basic idea is to transform the nonlinear dynamics into a higher dimensional space using a set of observable functions whose evolution is governed by the linear but infinite dimensional Koopman operator. In practice, it is numerically approximated and therefore the tightness of these linear representations cannot be guaranteed which may lead to unstable closed-loop designs. To address this issue, we integrate the Koopman linear predictors in an LMPC framework which guarantees controller feasibility and closed-loop stability. Moreover, the proposed design results in a standard convex optimization problem which is computationally attractive compared to a nonconvex problem encountered when the original nonlinear model is used. We illustrate the application of this methodology on a chemical process example.