Fatigue Evaluation of Rib-to-Deck Welded Joints of Orthotropic Steel Bridge Deck

This study reported fatigue test results of 300-mm-wide specimens with three details: 80% partial joint penetration (80%PJP), weld melt-through (WMT), and both. The specimens were cut out from full-scale orthotropic deck specimens of 16-mm-thick deck plate. In the fatigue test, the deck plate was subjected to cyclic bending loading and the rib was free from loading. The fatigue fracture surfaces showed that the presence of WMT may affect the initiation of fatigue cracks. A propensity to root cracking rather than toe cracking was observed. Plotting fatigue test results in an S-N diagram showed that the specimens with WMT seemed to have slightly lower fatigue strengths than the 80%PJP specimens, but the difference is more likely to be within a usual scatter of test data, which means that both details have comparable fatigue strength. The present test results satisfied the S-N curves of JSSC-E (80?MPa at 2×106 cycles) or AASHTO-C (89?MPa at 2×106 cycles).     

Analysis of an Orthotropic Deck Stiffened with a Cement-Based Overlay

Over the past years, with increasing traffic volumes and higher wheel loads, fatigue damage in steel parts of typical orthotropic steel bridge decks has been experienced on heavily trafficked routes. A demand exists to find a durable system to increase the fatigue safety of orthotropic steel bridge decks. A solution might be to enhance the stiffness of the traditional orthotropic bridge deck by using a cement-based overlay. In this paper, an orthotropic steel bridge deck stiffened with a cement-based overlay is analyzed. The analysis is based on nonlinear fracture mechanics, and utilizes the finite-element method. The stiffness of the steel deck reinforced with an overlay depends highly on the composite action. The composite action is closely related to cracking of the overlay and interfacial cracking between the overlay and underlying steel plate (debonding). As an example, a real size structure, the Far? bridges located in Denmark, are analyzed. The steel box girders of the Far? bridges spans 80?m, and have a depth of 3.5?m, and a width of 19.5?m. The focus of the present study is the top part of the steel box girders, which is constructed as an orthotropic deck plate. Numerous factors can influence the cracking behavior of the cement-based overlay system. Both mechanical and environmental loading have to be considered, and effects such as shrinkage, temperature gradients, and traffic loading are taken into account. The performance of four overlay materials are investigated in terms of crack widths. Furthermore, the analysis shows that debonding is initiated for a certain crack width in the overlay. The load level where cracking and debonding is initiated depends on the stress-crack opening relationship of the material.     

Full-Scale Fatigue Tests of Steel Orthotropic Decks for the Williamsburg Bridge

Final design of the replacement orthotropic deck panels for the rehabilitation of the Williamsburg Bridge in New York City was based on laboratory fatigue tests of a full-scale prototype and an as-built orthotropic deck panel carried out at Lehigh University in the latter 1990s. The tests focused on determining and comparing the fatigue resistance of two different welded rib-to-diaphragm connection details that were recommended in the 1994 AASHTO LRFD Bridge Design Specifications and an alternative proposed by Steinman. The test on the prototype panel demonstrated that the fatigue resistance of the alternative detail was superior and influenced additional design changes that were incorporated into the replacement panels installed on the southern inner and outer roadways. Subsequent tests on the as-built panel further confirmed that the fatigue resistance of the alternative detail was superior and demonstrated that the additional design changes were also beneficial. Static and dynamic tests revealed the complex behavior of the orthotropic deck panels and demonstrated the effectiveness of retrofit and repair options at cracked connections. An assessment of fatigue resistance based on fracture mechanics models provided theoretical correlation. This research has led to the revision of design specifications for steel orthotropic decks first provided in the 2000 Interim AASHTO LRFD Specifications.     

Experimental Evaluation of Compressive Behavior of Orthotropic Steel Plates for the New San Francisco–Oakland Bay Bridge

Compression tests were conducted on two reduced-scale orthotropic plates to verify the design strength of steel box girders for the new San Francisco–Oakland Bay Bridge. The first specimen was composed of three longitudinal closed ribs and a top deck plate. It failed in global buckling, followed by local buckling in the deck plate and ribs. The second specimen, which was composed of four longitudinal T-shaped ribs and a bottom deck plate, experienced global buckling as well as local buckling in the ribs and the deck plate. The ultimate strength and failure mode of both specimens were evaluated by two bridge design specifications: the 1998 AASHTO load and resistance factor design specification and the 2002 Japanese JRA specification. Findings from code comparisons showed that: (1) Sufficient flexural rigidity of ribs were provided for both specimens; (2) the JRA specification slightly overestimated the ultimate strength of both specimens; and (3) neither specifications predicted the observed buckling sequence in Specimen 2. A general-purpose nonlinear finite element analysis program (ABAQUS) was used to perform correlation study. The analysis showed that the ultimate strength and postbuckling behavior of the specimens could be reliably predicted when both the effects of residual stresses and initial geometric imperfections were considered in the model.     

A Fractographical Investigation of Weld Toe Imperfections in Tandem Gas Metal Arc Welding

Prediction and control of flaws in welds play important roles in design of complex structures against fatigue and fracture failure. Cold laps ‐ outer lack of fusion ‐ are small geometrical imperfections at weld toes, which act as fatigue crack initiation sites and reduce the life of welded structures drastically. The aim of this work is to characterize and categorize different types of such imperfections in the tandem gas metal arc welding process and find the mechanisms of their formation. Tandem welding process with different welding parameters was used to produce bead‐on‐plate coupons. These coupons were then sliced to smaller specimens for further investigations. For studying the weld toes, all the specimens were hit in an impact test machine and then the fracture surfaces of welds and base materials were analysed by scanning electron microscopy (SEM). Two types of cold laps were observed at weld toes, namely overlap and spatter. Observation and measurement showed that these imperfections are in the form of micro cracks with depth between 0.1 to 1.5mm and length between 0.1 to 4 mm.     

High cycle fatigue of weld repaired cast Ti-6AI-4V

In order to determine the effects of weld repair on fatigue life of titanium-6Al-4V castings, a series of specimens was exposed to variations in heat treatment, weld procedure, HIP cycle, cooling rate, and surface finish. The results indicate that weld repair is not detrimental to HCF properties as fatigue cracks were located primarily in the base metal. Fine surface finish and large colony size are the primary variables improving the fatigue life. The fusion zone resisted fatigue crack initiation due to a basketweave morphology and thin grain boundary alpha. Multipass welds were shown not to affect fatigue life when compared with single pass welds. A secondary HIP treatment was not detrimental to fatigue properties, but was found to be unnecessary.     

Development and Evaluation of an Adhesively Bonded Panel-to-Panel Joint for a FRP Bridge Deck System

A fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) composite cellular deck system was used to rehabilitate a historical cast iron thru-truss structure (Hawthorne St. Bridge in Covington, Va.). The most important characteristic of this application is reduction in self-weight, which raises the live load-carrying capacity of the bridge by replacing the existing concrete deck with a FRP deck. This bridge is designed to HL-93 load and has a 22.86?m clear span with a roadway width of 6.71?m. The panel-to-panel connections were accomplished using full width, adhesively (structural urethane adhesive) bonded tongue and groove splices with scarfed edges. To ensure proper construction, serviceability, and strength of the splice, a full-scale two-bay section of the bridge with three adhesively bonded panel-to-panel connections was constructed and tested in the Structures Laboratory at Virginia Tech. Test results showed that no crack initiated in the joints under service load and no significant change in stiffness or strength of the joint occurred after 3,000,000 cycles of fatigue loading. The proposed adhesive bonding technique was installed in the bridge in August 2006.     

Performance of Overlays Placed Over Sealed Decks under Static and Fatigue Loading

In order to enhance the effectiveness of portland cement overlays placed over existing bridge decks, the deck may be sealed with an acceptable sealer before placing the overlay. The main purpose for such a treatment of the deck is to seal the existing cracks, and prevent penetration of chlorides into the deck if the overlay cracks. The presence of a sealer at the deck-overlay interface is expected to reduce the available bond strength. The reported research was carried out to investigate the performance of overlays placed over sealed bridge decks, examine the level of bond strength, and develop simple yet effective means to restore the bond strength as much as possible. Test results indicate that the sealer reduces the available bond strength by as much as 50%. Up to 85% of the bond strength can be restored if sand is broadcast over the sealer while it is curing or if the dried sealed surface is lightly sanded. These observations were validated through fatigue loading and loading to failure of a one-third-scale subassemblage of a steel stringer bridge.     

Moving-Wheel Fatigue for Bridge Decks Strengthened with CFRP Strips Subject to Negative Bending

This paper presents the negative bending of reinforced concrete slabs strengthened with near-surface mounted (NSM) carbon fiber-reinforced polymer (CFRP) strips. Six slab specimens, three of which are strengthened with CFRP strips, are tested in static and fatigue loads. A wheel-running fatigue test machine is used to simulate vehicular loads on a bridge deck. The effectiveness of CFRP strengthening for bridge decks in cantilever and pseudonegative bending is examined based on moment-carrying capacity and cyclic behavior under the wheel-running fatigue loads, including crack patterns and damage accumulation. The moment-carrying capacity (static) of the cantilever slab strengthened with the NSM CFRP strips is improved by 68.4% when compared to that of an unstrengthened slab. The damage accumulation rate of the strengthened cantilever slab owing to the fatigue load is significantly lower than that of the unstrengthened slab. The damage accumulation of the strengthened slab gradually increases and is irreversible when the fatigue cycles increase. The fatigue-induced flexural cracks of the slabs develop along the wheel-running direction. A simple predictive model is presented to estimate the fatigue life of the test slabs.     

Orthotropic Plate Model for Estimating Deflections in Filled Grid Decks

Concrete filled grid bridge decks exhibit orthogonal elastic properties and significant two-way bending action enabling orthotropic plate theory to determine structural response for these elements. Current American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials load and resistance factor design (LRFD) specifications employ an orthotropic plate model to predict live load moment in concrete filled grid bridge decks but provide no guidance for computing displacement, a potentially important serviceability consideration. This paper presents equations to approximate the maximum deflection in concrete filled grid bridge decks based on orthotropic plate theory, multiple patch loads, LRFD design truck and tandem load cases, the influence of multiple spans, and the two most common deck orientations.     

Dynamic Behavior of Orthotropic Rectangular Plates under Moving Loads

The dynamic behavior of an orthotropic plate simply supported on a pair of parallel edges and under a system of moving loads is analyzed based on Lagrange equation and modal superposition. Thin plate theory is assumed for the plate model and no restriction is placed on the type of loading. Parameters of the plate affecting its dynamic behavior are discussed, and a new classification of the plates for computing the mode shapes and natural frequencies is proposed. The impact factors and the dynamic responses of a typical bridge deck are studied using the proposed method. Preliminary results indicate that the effect of eccentric loads on the impact factor depends on the proportion ratio between the flexural and torsional rigidities of the bridge deck, and the multilane loading case is less critical than a single-lane loading case.     

LRFD Orthotropic Plate Model for Live Load Moment in Filled Grid Decks

Due to the orthogonal elastic properties and significant two-way bending action, orthotropic plate theory may best be used to describe the behavior of concrete filled grid bridge decks. The current AASHTO LRFD specification employs an orthotropic plate model with a single patch load to predict live load moment in concrete filled grid bridge decks, which may not be conservative. This paper presents alternative equations to predict maximum moments, based on classical orthotropic plate theory, which include multiple patch loads, both the LRFD design truck and tandem load cases, and the two most common deck orientations. The predicted moments are verified through finite-element analyses.     

Transverse Cracking of Concrete Bridge Decks: Effects of Design Factors

Early transverse cracking is one of the dominant forms of bridge deck defects experienced by a large number of transportation agencies. These cracks often initiate soon after the bridge deck is constructed, and they are caused by restrained shrinkage of concrete. Transverse cracks increase the maintenance cost of a bridge structure and reduce its life span. Most of the past efforts addressing transverse bridge deck cracking have focused on changes over the years in concrete material properties and construction practices. However, recent studies have shown the importance of design factors on transverse bridge deck cracking. This paper presents results of a comprehensive finite-element (FE) study of deck and girder bridge systems to understand and evaluate crack patterns, stress histories, as well as the relative effect of different design factors such as structural stiffness on transverse deck cracking. The results of this study demonstrate the development of transverse deck cracking and emphasize the importance of these design factors. They also recommend preventive measures that can be adopted during the design stage in order to minimize the probability of transverse deck cracking.     

Microstructural modification in full penetration and partial penetration electron beam welds in INCONEL-718 (IN-718) and its effect on fatigue crack initiation

Detailed microstructural analysis, as well as fatigue crack initiation evaluation, was carried out for electron beam (EB) welded IN-718. Fatigue test specimens were EB welded (full penetration) along their length, and a second weld pass, incorporating a slope-out from full to zero penetration along the gage length, was also applied. The specimens were fatigue tested at 523 °C and maximum stress (R=0) in the range 579 to 820 MPa. Early fatigue failure (<100,000 cycles at 0.25 Hz) was directly associated with the initiation at solidification porosity formed during “spiking” in the partial penetration weld metal at the start of the slope-out. The base metal, full penetration weld metal, and slope-out region were characterized using optical microscopy, scanning electron microscopy (SEM), and transmission electron microscopy (TEM), which indicated that the microstructures of the base metal and full penetration weld metal should give good fatigue resistance. The rapid solidification of the full penetration weld metal gave an interdendritic terminal solidification product consisting of γ+NbC+Laves phase instead of the usually reported eutectic γ+Laves phase. Microstructural and chemical heterogeneities in the full penetration weld metal, combined with the sharp perturbations in penetration and solidification conditions (spiking) in the partial penetration weld metal, resulted in locally embrittled regions and interdendritic regions containing large numbers of fine pores as well as a higher volume fraction of mixed, hard interdendritic phases. These features would be consistent with a lower resistance to fatigue crack propagation in the partial penetration weld metal.     

Fatigue Behavior of a Steel-Free FRP–Concrete Modular Bridge Deck System

This paper presents results of an evaluation of the fatigue performance of a novel steel-free fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP)–concrete modular bridge deck system consisting of wet layup FRP–concrete deck panels which serve as both formwork and flexural reinforcement for the steel-free concrete slab cast on top. A two-span continuous deck specimen was subjected to a total of 2.36 million cycles of load simulating an AASHTO HS20 design truck with impact at low and high magnitudes. Quasistatic load tests were conducted both before initiation of fatigue cycling and after predetermined numbers of cycles to evaluate the system response. No significant stiffness degradation was observed during the first 2 million cycles of fatigue service load. A level of degradation was observed during subsequent testing at higher magnitudes of fatigue load. A fairly elastic and stable response was obtained from the system under fatigue service load with little residual displacement. The system satisfied both strength and serviceability limit states with respect to the code requirements for crack width and deflection.     

Strengthening of Reinforced Concrete Bridge Decks Using Carbon Fiber-Reinforced Polymer Composite Materials

This paper presents the results of an investigation of the monotonic and fatigue behavior of one-way and two-way reinforced concrete slabs strengthened with carbon fiber-reinforced polymer (CFRP) materials. The five one-way slab specimens were removed from a decommissioned bridge in South Carolina. Three of the slabs were retrofitted with CFRP strips bonded to their soffits and the other two served as unretrofit, control specimens. Of the five one-way slab specimens, one unretrofit and two retrofit slabs were tested monotonically until failure. The remaining two specimens, one unretrofit and one retrofit, were tested under cyclic (fatigue) loading until failure. In addition, six half-scale, two-way slab specimens were constructed to represent a full-scale prototype of a highway bridge deck designed using the empirical requirements of the AASHTO LRFD Bridge Design Manual. Of the six square slabs, two were unretrofitted and served as the control specimens, two were retrofitted using CFRP strips bonded to their soffits making a grid pattern, and two were retrofitted with a preformed CFRP grid material bonded to their soffit. Three slabs, one unretrofit, one CFRP strip, and one CFRP grid retrofitted, were tested monotonically until failure and the remaining three slabs were tested under cyclic (fatigue) loading until failure.     

Characterization of a Low-Profile Fiber-Reinforced Polymer Deck System for Moveable Bridges

Moveable bridges in Florida typically use open steel grid decks due to weight limitations. However, these decks present rideability, environmental, and maintenance problems, as they are typically less skid resistant than a solid riding surface, create loud noises, and allow debris to fall through the grids. Replacing open steel grid decks with a lightweight fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) deck can improve rideability and reduce maintenance costs, simultaneously satisfying the strict weight requirement for such bridges. In this investigation, a new low-profile, pultruded FRP deck system successfully passed the preliminary strength and fatigue tests per AASHTO requirements. Two two-span deck specimens were tested, one with the strong direction of the deck placed perpendicular to the supporting girders, whereas the other had a deck placed with 30° skew. This paper also describes a simplified finite-element approach that simulates the load–deformation behavior of the deck system. The results from the finite-element model showed a good correlation with the deflection and strain values measured from the tests.     

Consistent Approach to Calculating Stresses for Fatigue Design of Welded Rib-to-Web Connections in Steel Orthotropic Bridge Decks

The current (2004) fatigue design provisions in the 3rd Ed. of the AASHTO LRFD Bridge Design Specifications identify and classify the rib-to-web (rib-to-diaphragm) connections commonly utilized in steel orthotropic bridge decks where cutouts are used. The fatigue resistance of these details has been established through full-scale laboratory testing. This paper examines how the fatigue stress range was defined and determined during the testing which established the fatigue resistance of the details. A procedure to calculate or measure stresses at the rib-to-diaphragm connection, which is consistent with the fatigue resistance published in the AASHTO LRFD Bridge Design Specifications, is presented.     

Fatigue Life Evaluation of Concrete Bridge Deck Slabs Reinforced with Glass FRP Composite Bars

Since bridge deck slabs directly sustain repeated moving wheel loads, they are one of the most bridge elements susceptible to fatigue failure. Recently, glass fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) composites have been widely used as internal reinforcement for concrete bridge deck slabs as they are less expensive compared to the other kinds of FRPs (carbon and aramid). However, there is still a lack of information on the performance of FRP–reinforced concrete elements subjected to cyclic fatigue loading. This research is designed to investigate the fatigue behavior and fatigue life of concrete bridge deck slabs reinforced with glass FRP bars. A total of five full-scale deck slabs were constructed and tested under concentrated cyclic loading until failure. Different reinforcement types (steel and glass FRP), ratios, and configurations were used. Different schemes of cyclic loading (accelerated variable amplitude fatigue loading) were applied. Results are presented in terms of deflections, strains in concrete and FRP bars, and crack widths at different levels of cyclic loading. The results showed the superior fatigue performance and longer fatigue life of concrete bridge deck slabs reinforced with glass FRP composite bars.     

A comparative evaluation of low-cycle fatigue behavior of type 316LN base metal, 316 weld metal,and 316LN/316 weld joint

A comparative evaluation of the low-cycle fatigue (LCF) behavior of type 316LN base metal, 316 weld metal, and 316LN/316 weld joints was carried out at 773 and 873 K. Total strain-controlled LCF tests were conducted at a constant strain rate of 3 × 10⁻³ s⁻¹ with strain amplitudes in the range ±0.20 to ±1.0 pct. Weld pads with single V and double V configuration were prepared by the shielded metal-arc welding (SMAW) process using 316 electrodes for weld-metal and weld-joint specimens. Optical microscopy, scanning electron microscopy (SEM), and transmission electron microscopy (TEM) of the untested and tested samples were carried out to elucidate the deformation and the fracture behavior. The cyclic stress response of the base metal shows a very rapid hardening to a maximum stress followed by a saturated stress response. Weld metal undergoes a relatively short initial hardening followed by a gradual softening regime. Weld joints exhibit an initial hardening and a subsequent softening regime at all strain amplitudes, except at low strain amplitudes where a saturation regime is noticed. The initial hardening observed in base metal has been attributed to interaction between dislocations and solute atoms/complexes and cyclic saturation to saturation in the number density of slip bands. From TEM, the cyclic softening in weld metal was ascribed to the annihilation of dislocations during LCF. Type 316LN base metal exhibits better fatigue resistance than weld metal at 773 K, whereas the reverse holds true at 873 K. The weld joint shows the lowest life at both temperatures. The better fatigue resistance of weld metal is related to the brittle transformed delta ferrite structure and the high density of dislocations at the interface, which inhibits the growth rate of cracks by deflecting the crack path. The lower fatigue endurance of the weld joint was ascribed to the shortening of the crack initiation phase caused by surface intergranular crack initiation and to the poor crack propagation resistance of the coarse-grained region in the heat-affected zone.