Laboratory and Field Performance of Cellular Fiber-Reinforced Polymer Composite Bridge Deck Systems

This paper addresses the laboratory and field performance of multicellular fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) composite bridge deck systems produced from adhesively bonded pultrusions. Two methods of deck contact loading were examined: a steel patch dimensioned according to the AASHTO Bridge Design Specifications, and a simulated tire patch constructed from an actual truck tire reinforced with silicon rubber. Under these conditions, deck stiffness, strength, and failure characteristics of the cellular FRP decks were examined. The simulated tire loading was shown to develop greater global deflections given the same static load. The failure mode is localized and dominated by transverse bending failure of the composites under the simulated tire loading as opposed to punching shear for the AASHTO recommended patch load. A field testing facility was designed and constructed in which FRP decks were installed, tested, and monitored to study the decks’ in-service field performance. No significant loss of deck capacity was observed after more than one year of field service. However, it was shown that unsupported edges (or free edges) are undesirable due to transitional stiffness from approach to the unsupported deck edge.     

Performance Evaluation of FRP Composite Deck Considering for Local Deformation Effects

We examine here the replacement of a deteriorated concrete deck in the historic Hawthorne Street Bridge in Covington, Va. with a lightweight fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) deck system (adhesively bonded pultruded tube and plate assembly) to increase the load rating of the bridge. To explore construction feasibility, serviceability, and durability of the proposed deck system, a two-bay section (9.45 by 6.7?m) of the bridge has been constructed and tested under different probable loading scenarios. Experimental results show that the response of the deck is linear elastic with no evidence of deterioration at service load level (HS-20). From global behavior of the bridge superstructure (experimental data and finite- element analysis), degree of composite action, and load distribution factors are determined. The lowest failure load (93.6?kips or 418.1?kN) is about 4.5 times the design load (21.3?kips or 94?kN), including dynamic allowance at HS-20. The failure mode is consistent in all loading conditions and observed to be localized under the loading patch at the top plate and top flange of the tube. In addition to global performance, local deformation behavior is also investigated using finite-element simulation. Local analysis suggests that local effects are significant and should be incorporated in design criteria. Based on parametric studies on geometric (thickness of deck components) and material variables (the degree of orthotropy in pultruded tube), a proposed framework for the sizing and material selection of cellular FRP decks is presented for future development of design guidelines for composite deck structures.     

FEA of Complex Bridge System with FRP Composite Deck

Innovative fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) composite highway bridge deck systems are gradually gaining acceptance in replacing damaged/deteriorated concrete and timber decks. FRP bridge decks can be designed to meet the American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials (AASHTO) HS-25 load requirements. Because a rather complex sub- and superstructure system is used to support the FRP deck, it is important to include the entire system in analyzing the deck behavior and performance. In this paper, we will present a finite-element analysis (FEA) that is able to consider the structural complexity of the entire bridge system and the material complexity of an FRP sandwich deck. The FEA is constructed using a two-step analysis approach. The first step is to analyze the global behavior of the entire bridge under the AASHTO HS-25 loading. The next step is to analyze the local behavior of the FRP deck with appropriate load and boundary conditions determined from the first step. For the latter, a layered FEA module is proposed to compute the internal stresses and deformations of the FRP sandwich deck. This approach produces predictions that are in good agreement with experimental measurements.     

Approximate Series Solution for Analysis of FRP Composite Highway Bridges

The design of a deck-and-stringer bridge system is usually reduced to the analysis of a T-beam section, loaded by concentrated loads corresponding to an equivalent fraction of the applied truck load. This equivalent load is defined by wheel load–distribution factors, which approximate the overall behavior of the bridge superstructure. In this paper, a one-term approximation of a macroflexibility series solution including deformations for fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) deck-and-stringer orthotropic bridge systems, is used to develop explicit expressions for symmetric and asymmetric load distribution factors. It is significant that the equations presented herein include important parameters that represent, as accurately as possible, the response characteristics of the super structure, such as the geometry and material properties of the FRP deck and stringers, bridge aspect ratio, and number and spacing of stringers. As an illustration in actual design applications, the formulation presented in this paper is used to develop an analytical method for FRP deck-and-stringer bridge systems, and the method is verified by predicting the response of an all FRP model bridge in the lab and an FRP deck on steel stringers in the field. The results of the present formulation compare well with experimental lab and field results. The simplified analysis presented in this paper can be used with sufficient accuracy for the design of composite FRP deck on stringers bridges.     

Analytical Solutions to General Orthotropic Plates under Patch Loading

Orthotropic plates are widely used in bridge deck systems. However, these are not commonly treated as such within design specifications, and semianalytical solutions are not presently available for all deck types. This paper develops deflection equations for infinitely wide and simply supported thin plates considering each of the three cases of orthotropy: (1)?relatively torsionally stiff, flexurally soft; (2)?uniformly thick plate; and (3)?torsionally soft, flexurally stiff; subjected to arbitrary patch loading. These are common boundary and loading conditions encountered for bridge deck applications. The reported analytical solutions enable rapid evaluation of multiple moving patch loads to determine maximum design load effects and permit validation of numerical and finite-element methods. Application of the solutions will produce guidelines that can prescribe design demands and establish practical design simplifications for treatment of different bridge deck and slab systems in a uniform and consistent manner.     

Performance Comparison of Four Fiber-Reinforced Polymer Deck Panels

In an effort to assess the constructability and performance of bridges with fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) composite decks, the short-term and long-term responses of a 207 m, five-span bridge retrofitted with four different FRP panel systems were monitored. The overall aspects of the panel systems, connection details, and construction techniques are presented prior to presentation of the observed and measured responses. Key design parameters (impact factors, girder distribution factors, and level of composite action) for FRP and reinforced concrete decks are evaluated. This paper demonstrates that FRP replacement decks are a viable alternative to reinforced concrete decks and identifies the differences in performances of various FRP deck systems. Two of the FRP panel systems were found to perform considerably better than the other deck systems. Issues that may reduce the service life of FRP deck systems are presented and discussed.     

Close Look at Construction Issues and Performance of Four Fiber-Reinforced Polymer Composite Bridge Decks

Four different fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) panel systems were installed in a 207 m, five-span, three-lane bridge in an effort to assess the constructability, performance, and applicability of bridges with fiber-reinforced polymer composite decks. This paper examines whether four common deck systems are able to realize many of the anticipated benefits of using FRP composites in lieu of conventional reinforced concrete bridge decks. Particular installation issues, connection details, and specific construction techniques for each deck system are described, along with a discussion of the shortcomings in terms of handling, performance, and serviceability. Other factors such as key design parameters (e.g., impact factor and thermal characteristics) and unexpected responses are used to further quantify the performance of four FRP representative deck systems under identical traffic and environmental constraints.     

Sustained-Load and Fatigue Performance of a Hybrid FRP-Concrete Bridge Deck System

The design and construction of bridge systems with long-term durability and low maintenance requirements is a significant challenge for bridge engineers. One possible solution to this challenge could be through the use of new materials, e.g., fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) composites, with traditional materials that are arranged as an innovative hybrid structural system where the FRP serves as a load-carrying constituent and a protective cover for the concrete. This paper presents the results of an experimental investigation designed to evaluate the performance of a 3/4 scale hybrid FRP-concrete (HFRPC) bridge deck and composite connection under sustained and repeated (fatigue) loading. In addition, following the sustained-load and fatigue portions of the experimental study, destructive testing was performed to determine the first strength-based limit state of the hybrid deck. Results from the sustained-load and fatigue testing suggest that the HFRPC deck system might be a viable alternative to traditional cast-in-place reinforced concrete decks showing no global creep behavior and no degradation in stiffness or composite action between the deck and steel girders after 2 million cycles of dynamic loading with a peak load of 1.26 times the scaled tandem load (TL). Furthermore, the ultimate strength test showed that the deck failed prior to the global superstructure at a load approximately six times the scaled TL.     

Structural Behavior of FRP Composite Bridge Deck Panels

Fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) composite bridge deck panels are high-strength, corrosion resistant, weather resistant, etc., making them attractive for use in new construction or retrofit of existing bridges. This study evaluated the force-deformation responses of FRP composite bridge deck panels under AASHTO MS 22.5 (HS25) truck wheel load and up to failure. Tests were conducted on 16 FRP composite deck panels and four reinforced concrete conventional deck panels. The test results of FRP composite deck panels were compared with the flexural, shear, and deflection performance criteria per Ohio Department of Transportation specifications, and with the test results of reinforced concrete deck panels. The flexural and shear rigidities of FRP composite deck panels were calculated. The response of all panels under service load, factored load, cyclic loading, and the mode of failure were reported. The tested bridge deck panels satisfied the performance criteria. The safety factor against failure varies from 3 to 8.     

Fatigue Life Evaluation of Concrete Bridge Deck Slabs Reinforced with Glass FRP Composite Bars

Since bridge deck slabs directly sustain repeated moving wheel loads, they are one of the most bridge elements susceptible to fatigue failure. Recently, glass fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) composites have been widely used as internal reinforcement for concrete bridge deck slabs as they are less expensive compared to the other kinds of FRPs (carbon and aramid). However, there is still a lack of information on the performance of FRP–reinforced concrete elements subjected to cyclic fatigue loading. This research is designed to investigate the fatigue behavior and fatigue life of concrete bridge deck slabs reinforced with glass FRP bars. A total of five full-scale deck slabs were constructed and tested under concentrated cyclic loading until failure. Different reinforcement types (steel and glass FRP), ratios, and configurations were used. Different schemes of cyclic loading (accelerated variable amplitude fatigue loading) were applied. Results are presented in terms of deflections, strains in concrete and FRP bars, and crack widths at different levels of cyclic loading. The results showed the superior fatigue performance and longer fatigue life of concrete bridge deck slabs reinforced with glass FRP composite bars.     

Development and Evaluation of an Adhesively Bonded Panel-to-Panel Joint for a FRP Bridge Deck System

A fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) composite cellular deck system was used to rehabilitate a historical cast iron thru-truss structure (Hawthorne St. Bridge in Covington, Va.). The most important characteristic of this application is reduction in self-weight, which raises the live load-carrying capacity of the bridge by replacing the existing concrete deck with a FRP deck. This bridge is designed to HL-93 load and has a 22.86?m clear span with a roadway width of 6.71?m. The panel-to-panel connections were accomplished using full width, adhesively (structural urethane adhesive) bonded tongue and groove splices with scarfed edges. To ensure proper construction, serviceability, and strength of the splice, a full-scale two-bay section of the bridge with three adhesively bonded panel-to-panel connections was constructed and tested in the Structures Laboratory at Virginia Tech. Test results showed that no crack initiated in the joints under service load and no significant change in stiffness or strength of the joint occurred after 3,000,000 cycles of fatigue loading. The proposed adhesive bonding technique was installed in the bridge in August 2006.     

Temporal Thermal Behavior and Damage Simulations of FRP Deck

The finite-element method (FEM) has been employed to study the structural behavior of the fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) bridge deck. The numerical results were verified with the field-test results provided by New York State Department of Transportation. Fully coupled thermal-stress analyses were conducted using the FEM to predict the failure mechanisms and the “fire resistance limit” of the superstructure under extreme thermal loading conditions. Furthermore, damage simulations of the FRP deck as a result of snow and ice plowing process were performed to investigate any possibility of bridge failure after damage occurs. Thermal simulations showed that FRP bridge decks are highly sensitive to the effect of elevated temperatures. The FRP deck approached the fire resistance limit at early stages of the fire incident under all cases of fire scenarios. The damage simulations due to the snow plowing showed minimal possibility of bridge failure to take place under the worst-case damage scenario when the top 5 mm of the FRP deck surface was removed. The results of both phases of simulations provide an insight into the safety and the reliability of the FRP systems after the stipulated damage scenarios were considered. Moreover, this paper provides discussions concerning the recommended immediate actions necessary to repair the damaged region of FRP deck panels and possible use of the bridge after the damage incident.     

Dynamic Response of Three Fiber Reinforced Polymer Composite Bridges

Fiber reinforced polymer (FRP) composite bridge decks are gaining the attention of bridge owners because of their light self-weight, corrosion resistance, and ease of installation. Constructed Facilities Center at West Virginia University working with the Federal Highway Administration and West Virginia Department of Transportation has developed three different FRP decking systems and installed several FRP deck bridges in West Virginia. These FRP bridge decks are lighter in weight than comparable concrete systems and therefore their dynamic performance is equally as important as their static performance. In the current study dynamic tests were performed on three FRP deck bridges, namely, Katy Truss Bridge, Market Street Bridge, and Laurel Lick Bridge, in the state of West Virginia. The dynamic response parameters evaluated for the three bridges include dynamic load allowance (DLA) factors, natural frequencies, damping ratios, and deck accelerations caused by moving test trucks. It was found that the DLA factors for Katy Truss and Market Street bridges are within the AASHTO 1998 LRFD specifications, but the deck accelerations were found to be high for both these bridges. DLA factors for Laurel Lick bridge were found to be as high as 93% against the typical design value of 33%; however absolute deck stress induced by vehicle loads is less than 10% of the deck ultimate stress.     

Field Performance of the Fiber-Reinforced Polymer Deck of a Truss Bridge

The MD 24 Bridge over Deer Creek in Harford County, Md., was one of the projects chosen by the Federal Highway Administration’s Innovative Bridge Research and Construction Program for bridge deck replacement by fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) composites. A thorough discussion is presented on Maryland State Highway Administration’s first bridge rehabilitation project utilizing a FRP deck. The discussion includes design details, installation procedure, construction methods and in situ load testing with a wireless monitoring system. The research team installed a monitoring system to record the effects of live loads on the bridge system, including truss members, steel stringers, and plate action of the FRP deck. Finite-element models were also used in this phase. Dynamic effects of the FRP system, composite action between steel stringers and the FRP deck as well as the effective width and distribution factors of stringers were obtained and compared with the AASHTO specifications. Recommendations are also offered on improving the design details based on this experience.     

Finite-Element Modeling and Development of Equivalent Properties for FRP Bridge Panels

Fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) composite materials are increasingly making their way into civil engineering applications. To reduce the self-weight and also achieve the necessary stiffness, sandwich panels are commonly used for FRP bridge decks. However, due to the geometric complexity of the FRP sandwich deck, convenient analysis and design methods for FRP bridge deck have not been developed. The present study aims at developing equivalent properties for a complicated sandwich panel configuration using finite-element modeling techniques. With equivalent properties, the hollowed sandwich panel can be transformed into an equivalent solid orthotropic plate, based on which deflection limits can be evaluated and designed. A procedure for the in-plane axial properties of the sandwich core has first been developed, followed by developing the out-of-plane panel properties for bending behavior of the panel. An application is made in the investigation of the stiffness contribution of wearing surface to the total stiffness of bridges with FRP panels. The wearing surface contribution is not usually accounted for in a typical design of bridges with traditional deck systems.     

Membrane-Based Forms for Innovative FRP Bridge Systems through Structural Optimization

The use of fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) composites for new construction is still limited primarily due to high costs and designs based on shapes best suitable to conventional materials. The layered and fiber dominated structure of FRP composites is most efficient when used under in-plane stress demands. Structural forms that most efficiently use tensile stress carrying capacity are membranes or thin shells. An analytical investigation is presented where an innovative optimization algorithm for the integrated shape and laminate optimization of free-form FRP shells was developed and used to generate two new bridge systems that efficiently use FRP composites in membrane-based forms. One concept makes use of a FRP membrane working compositely with a concrete slab to resist flexure while the second uses the FRP membrane in a dual suspension system supporting a deck through diaphragms. The resulting designs and a discussion on their performance under optimal and nonoptimal loading are presented. While practical issues are still to be resolved, the presented approach and concepts can promote and provide insight to efficient structural forms for FRP composites.     

Light-Weight Fiber-Reinforced Polymer Composite Deck Panels for Extreme Applications

Currently within the military there is a need for a universal light-weight bridge deck system capable of supporting extreme loads over a wide temperature range. This research presents the development, testing, and analysis of five different fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) webbed core deck panels. The performance of the FRP webbed decks are compared with an existing aluminum deck and with a baseline balsa core system, which has previously been tested as part of the development of the composite army bridge for the US Army. The study shows that for one-way bending, the FRP webbed core can exceed the shear strength of the baseline balsa core by a factor of 3.2 at a core’s density, which is 28% lighter than the balsa baseline. In addition, weight savings in excess of 30% are shown for using FRP decking in place of conventional aluminum decking. Based on test results and finite-element analysis, the failure modes of the different FRP webbed cores are discussed and design recommendations for FRP webbed core decks are provided.     

Evaluation of Composite Sandwich Bridge Decks with Hybrid FRP-Steel Core

A hybrid concept of composite sandwich panel with hybrid fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP)—steel core was proposed for bridge decks in order to not only improve stiffness and buckling response but also be cost efficient compared to all glass fiber-reinforced polymer (GFRP) decks. The composite sandwich bridge deck system is comprised of wrapped hybrid core of GFRP grid and multiple steel box cells with upper and lower GFRP facings. Its structural performance under static loading was evaluated and compared with the ANSYS finite element predictions. It was found that the presented composite sandwich panel with hybrid FRP-steel core was very efficient for use in bridges. The thickness of the hybrid deck may be decreased by 19% when compared with the all GFRP deck. The failure mode of the proposed hybrid deck was more favorable because of the yielding of the steel tube when compared with that of all GFRP decks.     

Connection of Concrete Railing Post and Bridge Deck with Internal FRP Reinforcement

The use of fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) reinforcement is a practical alternative to conventional steel bars in concrete bridge decks, safety appurtenances, and connections thereof, as it eliminates corrosion of the steel reinforcement. Due to their tailorability and light weight, FRP materials also lend themselves to the development of prefabricated systems that improve constructability and speed of installation. These advantages have been demonstrated in the construction of an off-system bridge, where prefabricated cages of glass FRP bars were used for the open-post railings. This paper presents the results of full-scale static tests on two candidate post–deck connections to assess compliance with strength criteria at the component (connection) level, as mandated by the AASHTO Standard Specifications, which were used to design the bridge. Strength and stiffness until failure are shown to be accurately predictable. Structural adequacy was then studied at the system (post-and-beam) level by numerically modeling the nonlinear response of the railing under equivalent static transverse load, pursuant to well-established structural analysis principles of FRP RC, and consistent with the AASHTO LRFD Bridge Design Specifications. As moment redistribution cannot be accounted for in the analysis and design of indeterminate FRP RC structures, a methodology that imposes equilibrium and compatibility conditions was implemented in lieu of yield line analysis. Transverse strength and failure modes are determined and discussed on the basis of specification mandated requirements.     

Durability of FRP Composite Bridge Deck Materials under Freeze-Thaw and Low Temperature Conditions

Fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) composites, especially lightweight sandwich structures, are rapidly finding their way into civil infrastructure application. FRP composite panels are particularly attractive as bridge deck systems due to their high strength, low density, and durability, which are of importance to the bridge industry. Most of the vast amount of durability data for FRP has been generated for aerospace and automotive applications, which involve very different service conditions than civil infrastructure. For civil engineering applications, it is essential to examine the durability performance of FRP materials under weathering conditions. The ultimate goal of this research is to develop a reliable framework for durability assessment of FRP decks, including laboratory testing procedure and finite-element simulation capability. Such a framework should be applicable to all types of FRP deck construction. In this paper, specimens of typical FRP bridge deck skin materials are subjected to freeze-thaw cycling between 4.4 and ?17.8°C in media of dry air, distilled water, and saltwater, and constant freeze at ?17.8°C . The selected deck is used as an example for demonstration purposes. In addition, selected specimens are subjected to simultaneous environmental exposure conditions and sustained loading of 25% ultimate strain. It should be emphasized that most of the environmental conditions reported in the literature produce minor deterioration of a single composite property, and the assessment of such effect on this single property becomes unreliable because of a large property variation. Therefore, in this paper we use multiple mechanical properties as performance indices for damage evaluation. Based on findings from this work, it is concluded that freeze-thaw cycling between 4.4 and ?17.8°C alone and up to 1,250 h and 625 cycles caused very insignificant or no change in the flexural strength, storage modulus, and loss factor of the FRP specimens conditioned in dry air, distilled water, and saltwater. Small reductions in storage modulus (about 1% or less) were observed when specimens were prestrained and subjected to 250 freeze-thaw cycles in distilled water and saltwater. Changes in flexural strength were statistically insignificant, since they were within the data scatter.