Creep Rupture Strength and Microstructure of Low C-10Cr-2Mo Heat-Resisting Steels with V and Nb

The new ferritic heat-resisting steels of 0.05C-10Cr-2Mo-0.10V-0.05Nb (Cb) composition with high creep rupture strength and good ductility have already been reported. The optimum amounts of V and Nb that can be added to the 0.05C-10Cr-2Mo steels and their effects on the creep rupture strength and microstructure of the steels have been studied in this experiment. The optimum amounts of V and Nb are about 0.10 pct V and 0.05 pct Nb at 600 °C for 10,000 h, but shift to 0.18 pct V and 0.05 pct Nb at 650 °C. Nb-bearing steels are preferred to other grades on the short-time side, because NbC precipitation during initial tempering stages delays recovery of martensite. On the long-time side, however, V-bearing steels have higher creep rupture strength. By adding V to the steels, electron microscopic examination reveals a stable microstructure, retardation during creep of the softening of tempered martensite, fine and uniform distribution of precipitates, and promotion of the precipitation of Fe₂Mo.     

The effect of Nb,V, N and Al on the creep rupture strength of 9–12 % Cr steel

The creep resistance of advanced chromium steels can be significantly increased due to precipitation of very small particles of vanadium nitride VN. The solubility and precipitation of VN, Nb(C,N) and AIN in austenite and ferrite was analysed using relevant solubility products. The calculated values of nitrogen in solid solution were used for assessment of creep rupture strength of chromium steel (mean considered chemical composition, mass contents in %: 0.18 C; 10.5 Cr; 1.0 Mo; 0.2 V; 0.07 Nb; 0.05 N; 0.01 Al). Increasing N mass contents from 0.03 to 0.07 % leads to increasing creep rupture strength in 100 000 h at 600°C of about 60 %. Lowering AI mass contents from 0.045 to 0.005 % produces higher creep rupture strength of about 30 %.     

Effect of titanium,niobium and zirconium on creep rupture strength and ductility of cobalt base superalloys

An attempt has been made to develop a cobalt base casting superalloy (30Cr-10Ni-7W-Co) having high creep rupture strength and ductility for first stage nozzles of gas turbines. In cobalt base superalloys, there was found to exist a close correlation between the creep rupture strength and MC type carbide forming elements such as Ti, Nb and Zr. In cobalt base alloys with 0.25 wt pct C, precipitation and coarsening of carbides can be reduced by addition of Ti, Nb and Zr. Therefore, by adding the optimum amount of Ti, Nb and Zr, precipitation of carbides in the alloy reaches such an amount as to give the highest creep rupture strength. Excess addition of Ti, Nb and Zr does not improve the creep rupture strength. By adding C, creep rupture strength of the cobalt alloy with Ti, Nb and Zr can be improved and becomes the highest at 0.40 wt pct. C. According to the experimental results, the creep rupture strength becomes the highest at a value of (Ti + Nb + Zr)/C (atomic ratio) of about 0.3. Contrary to the expectation, it was found in this experiment that the ductility in creep rupture tests increases with increasing carbon content up to 0.6 wt pct.     

Unidirectionally solidified Ti−TiB and Ti−Ti5Si3 eutectic composites

Induction melting and electron beam melting techniques were employed in the production of unidirectionally solidified eutectic composites of Ti-1.7 wt pct B and Ti-8.5 wt pct Si. The grown eutectics were reinforced by 7.7 volume pct of TiB fibers and 31 volume pct of Ti₅Si₃ fibers respectively. Controlled dendritic solidification of a hypereutectic composition of Ti-12 wt pct Si was also accomplished. Tensile, compressive, creep, and stress rupture specimens were cut from the eutectic composites and tested with reinforcing fibers parallel to the load axis. Ti?TiB eutectic was found to have less than the critical volume fraction of fibers necessary for reinforcement, while Ti?Ti₅Si₃ composite attained a compressive yield strength of 275,000 psi and a compressive Young's modulus of 30×10⁸ psi after heat treatment. The 500 and 4000 hr stress rupture properties of Ti?Si eutectic were superior to commercial titanium alloys at 1000° and 1200°F. The minimum creep rate of Ti?Ti₅Si₃ eutectic composite was lower than all other titanium alloys at 1000°F. Tensile, compressive, and creep properties of the Ti-8.5 wt pct Si eutectic are discussed in terms of the current theories of composite behavior.     

Creep deformation and fracture of a Cr/Mo/V bolting steel containing selected trace-element additions

The article reports the creep behavior, at 565 °C, of 1Cr1Mo0.75V (Ti, B) (Durehete D1055) steel, in each of two grain sizes and doped with individual trace elements such as P, As, and Sn, in comparison to a reference cast of the base material containing 0.08 wt pct Ti. The addition of the trace elements P, As, or Sn (each <0.045 wt pct) appears to produce no significant effect on creep strength or creep crack-growth resistance at 565 °C. The fine-grained material shows low creep strength but notch strengthening, while the coarse-grained material shows higher creep strength and exhibits notch weakening for test times up to 2750 hours. From creep crack-growth tests, it appears that the C* parameter is not appropriate for correlating the creep crack-growth rate under the present test conditions. The parameters K _I or σ _net are found to correlate better, but, from the present data, it is not possible to judge which of these parameters is more appropriate for general use. It is suggested that the presence of Ti in CrMoV steels has an inhibiting effect on trace-element embrittlement.     

Precipitation and Recrystallization in Some Vanadium and Vanadium-Niobium Microalloyed Steels

Static precipitation and recrystallization following hot compression of austenite and the interactions between the two processes have been studied in a set of aluminum-killed HSLA steels containing 0.1 pct carbon, [0.016 - 0.026] pct nitrogen and 0.1 or 0.2 pct vanadium. Two steels containing both vanadium (0.1 and 0.2 pct) and niobium (0.03 pct) were included for purposes of comparison. The compression and the static tests were all carried out isothermally at temperatures between 800 and 900 °C. The course of recrystallization was followed by measurements of the rate of softening and by optical metallography of specimens quenched from the test temperature after different times. Precipitation was studied by measurements of the rate of hardening, by transmission electron microscopy of thin foils, carbon and aluminum extraction replicas, and by X-ray dispersion and energy-loss spectroscopy from individual precipitates. The temperature of the nose of theC-curve for precipitation in vanadium steels is much lower than that in niobium steels, as is the temperature, T_R, below which no recrystallization occurs in short times. Precipitation occurs both at austenite grain boundaries and in the grains (matrix precipitation). The former starts early and the precipitates grow rapidly to an approximately constant size; the matrix precipitates grow more slowly and are responsible for the observed hardening of the austenite. The relevance of various models proposed for the retardation and arrest of recrystallization of austenite are discussed. In the steels containing vanadium and niobium the precipitates contain both heavy elements: (V,Nb) (C,N). The Nb/V ratio in the matrix precipitates is different than in the parent austenite. The grain-boundary precipitates, however, contain the same Nb/V ratio as the parent austenite. The rate of hardening exhibits a reverseC-curve behavior, being more rapid than in the corresponding vanadium steels at higher temperatures and about the same at lower temperatures. Formerly Research Associate at MIT     

Deposits of excess carbonitride phase in microalloyed steel coils and sheet with different cooling conditions

Deposits of the carbonitrides (Ti, Nb)(C, N), Nb(C, N), and (Nb, V)(C, N) in the austenite and ferrite phases of X70 steel sheet after thermomechanical treatment are investigated. Nb(C, N) particles measuring up to 10 nm are seen in austenite in the final stage of rolling and after its conclusion prior to accelerated cooling of thick sheet. After intense accelerated cooling, most of the niobium and vanadium is retained in the solid solution, as confirmed by the vigorous deposition of (Nb, V)(C, N) particles measuring ∼2–4 nm in ferrite after tempering at 600°C. In coil production, the particles observed may be the result of general deposition or interphase deposition, depending on the cooling of the strip on the output roller conveyer of the continuous broad-strip mill. Carbonitride particles measuring 2–8 nm are deposited at winding temperatures of 550–570°C in steel with niobium and vanadium and at 590°C in steel without vanadium.     

Delta ferritic heat-resistant chromium-molybdenum steels with improved rupture strength

Nine experimental delta-ferritic steels have been examined as potential low expansion heat-resistant steels for use in fossil fuel power generation, nuclear power generation, nuclear process heat plants and coal gasification plants. The steels contain 10 to 14 pct Cr and 2 to 6 pct Mo, with additions of columbium, titanium, vanadium, aluminum and boron. Room-temperature tensile properties and oxidation resistance of all steels were determined. Selected steels were aged for 1000 h at 760 °C (1400 °F) and subjected to elevated temperature tensile tests at the aging temperature. Creep-rupture properties of selected steels were determined at 760 and 815 °C (1400 and 1500 °F). Extensive metallographic and phase identification studies were conducted. Of the two steels tested for creep-rupture strength, the 10Cr-6Mo-0.5Cb steel, with good room-temperature ductility, has rupture strength exceeding that of martensitic 12Cr-1Mo-V steel. The 14Cr-3Mo-0.5Cb-lTi-2Al steel exhibits an even higher rupture strength, but has only marginal ductility at room temperature.     

The effect of titanium on creep strength in 2.25 Pct Cr-1 Pct Mo steels

The effect of a low level of titanium on the microstructure and creep properties of 2.25 pct Cr-1 pct Mo steels has been examined as a function of carbon content and austenitizing temperature. The addition of 0.04 wt pct titanium resulted in a dramatic increase in creep strength at 565 °C, and this was found to be associated with the presence in the microstructure of very small (50 to 100 Å) titanium-bearing precipitates based upon both TiC and Mo₂C. The variation of the minimum creep rate with carbon content and austenitizing treatment was explained in terms of the solubility of TiC in austenite. The titanium-bearing carbides have an important effect on microstructural stability and on the maintenance of creep strength, but it is also apparent that solid solution strengthening by molybdenum can make a significant contribution to creep strength at low carbon levels (0.02 wt pct).     

Effect of Sb, P, Sn and B on the microstructure and creep properties of normalized and tempered 1.25 Cr-0.5 Mo steels

A program to study the effect of Sb, P, Sn and B on creep properties of four normalized and tempered 1.25 Cr-0.5 Mo steels at 538°C (1000°F) has been completed. Results show that even a combined addition of large amounts of Sb, P and Sn does not affect short time creep strength or ductility of the steel at 538°C (1000°F). Addition of B resulted in an increase or decrease of creep strength depending on the nature of the impurity species present, presumably due to B-impurity interactions. Regardless of the effect on creep strength, B additions caused sharp reductions in rupture ductility in all cases. Comparison of the present results on the four laboratory steels (100 pct bainite) with results of a previous study on a commercial steel (60 pct bainite + 40 pct ferrite) show that the effect of microstructure becomes negligible and rupture strength values of the various steels at 538°C (1000°F) approach each other at rupture times in excess of 10⁴ h.     

Effect of Sb,P, Sn and B on the microstructure and creep properties of normalized and tempered 1.25 Cr−0.5 Mo Steels

A program to study the effect of Sb, P, Sn and B on creep properties of four normalized and tempered 1.25 Cr−0.5 Mo steels at 538°C (1000°F) has been completed. Results show that even a combined addition of large amounts of Sb, P and Sn does not affect short time creep strength or ductility of the steel at 538°C (1000°F). Addition of B resulted in an increase or decrease of creep strength depending on the nature of the impurity species present, presumably due to B-impurity interactions. Regardless of the effect on creep strength, B additions caused sharp reductions in rupture ductility in all cases. Comparison of the present results on the four laboratory steels (100 pct bainite) with results of a previous study on a commercial steel (60 pct bainite + 40 pct ferrite) show that the effect of microstructure becomes negligible and rupture strength values of the various steels at 538°C (1000°F) approach each other at rupture times in excess of 10⁴ h.     

Effects of vanadium and nitrogen on recovery and recrystallization during and after hot-working some HSLA steels

The effects of vanadium/nitrogen additions on dynamic and static recovery and recrystallization have been studied in a set of aluminum-killed HSLA steels containing 0.1 pct carbon, 0.01 to 0.02 pct nitrogen, and either vanadium (0.1 or 0.2 pct), niobium (Cb) (0.03 pct), or vanadium and niobium together. Most, but not all, of the tests were carried out at 1173 K (900°C), a temperature at which precipitation of VN might be expected under some conditions. The net effect of dynamic recovery, recrystallization, and precipitation was monitored by measuring the change in compressive flow stress with strain at a constant temperature. Static changes were followed by measuring the change in compressive flow stress on isothermally holding unloaded specimens after a hot precompression. These kinetic data were supplemented by metallographic and electron-microscopic examinations of quenched specimens and of carbon extraction replicas taken from them. Evidence is presented which indicates that, at a holding temperature of 1173 K (900°C), static recrystallization occurs in vanadium steels containing 0.1 pct vanadium before any precipitation is detected. The progress of this recrystallization is arrested by the precipitation of vanadium nitride. At a higher vanadium concentration, 0.2 pct, recrystallization does not start. The effects of V/N ratio, austenitizing temperature (between 1373 K (1100°C) and 1523 K (1250°C), and isothermal holding temperature (between 1173 K (900°C) and 1273 K (1000°C)) on the kinetics of static softening and hardening are compared in some vanadium steels and plain-carbon and niobium steels of similar base-composition.     

Structure and elevated temperature properties of carbon-free ferritic alloys strengthened by a laves phase

A Laves phase, Fe₂Ta, was utilized to obtain good elevated temperature properties in a carbon-free iron alloy containing 1 at. pct Ta and 7 at. pct Cr. Room temperature embrittlement resulting from the precipitation of the Laves phase at grain boundaries was overcome by spheroidizing the precipitate. This was accomplished by thermally cycling the alloys through theα →γ transformation. The short-time yield strength of the alloys decreased very slowly with increase in test temperature up to 600°C, but above this temperature, the strength decreased rapidly. Results of constant load creep and stress rupture tests conducted at several temperatures and stresses indicated that the rupture and creep strengths of spheroidized 1 Ta−7 Cr alloy were higher than those of several commercial steels containing chromium and/or molybdenum carbides but lower than those of steels containing substantial amounts of tungsten and vanadium. When molybdenum was added to the base FeTa-Cr alloy, the rupture and creep strengths were considerably increased. Formerly with Lawrence Berkeley Laboratory.     

Structure and elevated temperature properties of carbon-free ferritic alloys strengthened by a laves phase

A Laves phase, Fe₂Ta, was utilized to obtain good elevated temperature properties in a carbon-free iron alloy containing 1 at. pct Ta and 7 at. pct Cr. Room temperature embrittlement resulting from the precipitation of the Laves phase at grain boundaries was overcome by spheroidizing the precipitate. This was accomplished by thermally cycling the alloys through the α→γ transformation. The short-time yield strength of the alloys decreased very slowly with increase in test temperature up to 600°C, but above this temperature, the strength decreased rapidly. Results of constant load creep and stress rupture tests conducted at several temperatures and stresses indicated that the rupture and creep strengths of spheroidized 1 Ta-7 Cr alloy were higher than those of several commercial steels containing chromium and/or molybdenum carbides but lower than those of steels containing substantial amounts of tungsten and vanadium. When molybdenum was added to the base Fe-Ta-Cr alloy, the rupture and creep strengths were considerably increased. M. Dilip Bhandarkar, formerly with Lawrence Berkeley Laboratory.     

Effect of molybdenum,niobium, and vanadium on static recovery and recrystallization and on solute strengthening in microalloyed steels

The effect of molybdenum, niobium, and vanadium on the occurrence of static recovery and recrystallization after high temperature deformation was investigated in a series of microalloyed steels. The steels had a base composition of 0.05 pct C and 1.40 pct Mn. To this, single additions of 0.30 pct Mo, 0.035 pct Nb, and 0.115 pct V were made. Interrupted hot compression tests were performed at 900 and 1000 °C, and at a constant true strain rate of 2 s^-1. The load-free time was decreased from 5000 s to 50 ms, and the degree of static softening during this period was determined. Both graphite and glass were used as lubricants. Percent softeningvs delay time curves are presented and the retarding effect of molybdenum, niobium, and vanadium addition on the rate of static recovery and recrystallization is discussed. The greatest solute retardation of static recovery and recrystallization is produced by niobium addition, followed by that of molybdenum, vanadium leading to the smallest delay. Although the rank order of this effect is the same as found under dynamic softening conditions, the relative contribution of niobium is more profound for the static condition. The solute strengthening attributable to each element was also assessed, and found to follow the same order as for the recovery and recrystallization results. At 900 °C, the onset of the static precipitation of Nb (CN) was detected at approximately 10 seconds, somewhat earlier than previously reported. Formerly Graduate Student at McGill University, Montreal, Quebec.     

Effects of micro-alloying and production process on precipitation behaviors and mechanical properties of HRB600

Effects of micro-alloying elements and production process on microstructure,mechanical properties and precipitates of 600 MPa grade rebars were studied by using pilot test,metallographic observation,tensile test,thermodynamic calculation and transmission electron microscopy. The results show that the tested steels are composed of ferrite and pearlite,in which the content range of pearlite is 33%-45%. For vanadium microalloyed steel,interphase precipitation strengthening effect of V can be promoted and the yield strength of tested steels can be increased with increasing V content and decreasing finishing rolling temperature. The temperature of terminated cooling should be more than 700 °C when the water cooling is used. When niobium is added to the steel,more coarse( Nb,V) C,N precipitates are generated at high temperature,so that the solid solubility of precipitated phases of vanadium is reduced and the precipitation strengthening effect of vanadium is weakened.     

Microstructures and High-Temperature Mechanical Properties of a Martensitic Heat-Resistant Stainless Steel 403Nb Processed by Thermo-Mechanical Treatment

Thermo-mechanical treatments (TMT) at different rolling deformation temperatures were utilized to process a martensitic heat-resistant stainless steel 403Nb containing 12 wt pct Cr and small additions of Nb and V. Microstructures and mechanical properties at room and elevated temperatures were characterized by scanning electron microscopy, transmission electron microscopy, and hardness, tensile, and creep tests. The results showed that high-temperature mechanical behavior after TMT can be greatly improved and microstructures with refined martensitic lath and finely dispersed nanosized MX carbides could be produced. The particle sizes of M₂₃C₆ and MX carbides in 403Nb steel after conventional normalizing and tempering (NT) treatments are about 50 to 160 and 10 to 20 nm, respectively, while those after TMT at 1123 K (850 °C) and subsequent tempering at 923 K (650 °C) for 2 hours reach about 25 to 85 and 5 to 10 nm, respectively. Under the condition of 260 MPa and 873 K (600 °C), the tensile creep rupture life of 403Nb steel after TMT at 1123 K (850 °C) is 455 hours, more than 3 times that after conventional NT processes. The mechanisms for improving mechanical properties at elevated temperature were analyzed in association with the existence of finely dispersed nanosized MX particles within martensitic lath. It is the nanosized MX particles having the higher stability at elevated temperature that assist both dislocation hardening and sub-grain hardening for longer duration by pinning the movement of dislocations and sub-grain boundary migration.     

An investigation of the fracture and fatigue crack growth behavior of forged damage-tolerant niobium aluminide intermetallics

The results of a recent study of the effects of ternary alloying with Ti on the fatigue and fracture behavior of a new class of forged damage-tolerant niobium aluminide (Nb₃Al-xTi) intermetallics are presented in this article. The alloys studied have the following nominal compositions: Nb-15Al-10Ti (10Ti alloy), Nb-15Al-25Ti (25Ti alloy), and Nb-15Al-40Ti (40Ti alloy). All compositions are quoted in atomic percentages unless stated otherwise. The 10Ti and 25Ti alloys exhibit fracture toughness levels between 10 and 20 MPa√m at room temperature. Fracture in these alloys occurs by brittle cleavage fracture modes. In contrast, a ductile dimpled fracture mode is observed at room-temperature for the alloy containing 40 at. pct Ti. The 40Ti alloy also exhibits exceptional combinations of room-temperature strength (695 to 904 MPa), ductility (4 to 30 pct), fracture toughness (40 to 100 MPa√m), and fatigue crack growth resistance (comparable to Ti-6Al-4V, monolithic Nb, and inconnel 718). The implications of the results are discussed for potential structural applications of the 40Ti alloy in the intermediate-temperature (∼700 °C to 750 °C) regime.     

Improved Creep Behavior of a High Nitrogen Nb-Stabilized 15Cr-15Ni Austenitic Stainless Steel Strengthened by Multiple Nanoprecipitates

Austenitic stainless steels are expected to be a major material for boiler tubes and steam turbines in future ultra-supercritical (USC) fossil power plants. It is of great interest to maximize the creep strength of the materials without increasing the cost. Precipitation strengthening was found to be the best and cheapest way for increasing the creep strength of such steels. This study is concerned with improving creep properties of a high nitrogen Nb-stabilized 15Cr-15Ni austenitic alloy through introducing a high number of nanosized particles into the austenitic matrix. The addition of around 4 wt pct Mn and 0.236 wt pct N into the 15Cr-15Ni-0.46Si-0.7Nb-1.25Mo-3Cu-Al-B-C matrix in combination with a special multicycled aging-quenching heat treatment resulted in the fine dispersion of abundant quantities of thermally stable (Nb,Cr,Fe)(C,N) precipitates with sizes of 10 to 20 nm. Apart from the carbonitrides, it was found that a high number of coherent copper precipitates with size 40 to 60 nm exist in the microstructure. Results of creep tests at 973 K and 1023 K (700 °C and 750 °C) showed that the creep properties of the investigated steel are superior compared to that of the commercial NF709 alloy. The improved creep properties are attributed to the improved morphology and thermal stability of the carbonitrides as well as to the presence of the coherent copper precipitates inside the austenitic matrix.     

Response of Phase Transformation Inducing Heat Treatments on Microstructure and Mechanical Properties of Reduced Activation Ferritic-Martensitic Steels of Varying Tungsten Contents

Microstructure and mechanical properties of 9Cr-W-0.06Ta Reduced Activation Ferritic-Martensitic (RAFM) steels having various tungsten contents ranging from 1 to 2 wt pct have been investigated on subjecting the steels to isothermal heat treatments for 5 minutes at temperatures ranging from 973 K to 1473 K (700 °C to 1200 °C) (below Ac₁ to above Ac₃) followed by oil quenching and tempering at 1033 K (760 °C) for 60 minutes. The steels possessed tempered martensite structure at all the heat-treated conditions. Prior-austenitic grain size of the steels was found to decrease on heating in the intercritical temperature range (between Ac₁ and Ac₃) and at temperatures just above the Ac₃ followed by increase at higher heating temperatures. All the steels suffered significant reduction in hardness, tensile, and creep strength on heating in the intercritical temperature range, and the reduction was less for steel having higher tungsten content. Strength of the steels increased on heating above Ac₃ and was higher for higher tungsten content. Transmission Electron Microscopy (TEM) investigations of the steels revealed coarsening of martensitic substructure and precipitates on heating in the intercritical temperature range, and the coarsening was relatively less for higher tungsten content steel, resulting in less reduction in tensile and creep strength on intercritical heating. Tensile and creep strengths of the steels at different microstructural conditions have been rationalized based on the estimated inter-barrier spacing to dislocation motion. The study revealed the uniqueness of inter-barrier spacing to dislocation motion in determining the strength of tempered martensitic steels subjected to different heat treatments.