A numerical simulation study of CO 2 injection for enhancing hydrocarbon recovery and sequestration in liquid-rich shales

Less than 10% of oil is usually recovered from liquid-rich shales and this leaves much room for improvement, while water injection into shale formation is virtually impossible because of the extremely low permeability of the formation matrix. Injecting carbon dioxide (CO₂) into oil shale formations can potentially improve oil recovery. Furthermore, the large surface area in organicrich shale could permanently store CO₂ without jeopardizing the formation integrity. This work is a mechanism study of evaluating the effectiveness of CO₂-enhanced oil shale recovery and shale formation CO₂ sequestration capacity using numerical simulation. Petrophysical and fluid properties similar to the Bakken Formation are used to set up the base model for simulation. Result shows that the CO₂ injection could increase the oil recovery factor from 7.4% to 53%. In addition, petrophysical characteristics such as in situ stress changes and presence of a natural fracture network in the shale formation are proven to have impacts on subsurface CO₂ flow. A response surface modeling approach was applied to investigate the interaction between parameters and generate a proxy model for optimizing oil recovery and CO₂ injectivity.     

Operation Parameters on CO2-Foam process

Abstract

Reducing the mobility of CO₂ by means of generating in situ foam is an effective method for improving the oil recovery in CO₂ flooding processes. Implementation of the CO₂-foam technique typically involves the co-injection of CO₂ and surfactant solution into the porous medium. The surfactant molecules form bubble films that trap the flowing CO₂ molecules. The effectiveness of the CO₂-foam process is measured in terms of foam mobility. The mobility of CO₂-foam is affected by different operation parameters, such as pressure, temperature, foam quality, and brine concentration. However, surfactant type governs the overall efficiency of the CO₂-foam process. This paper presents the results of a series of experiments conducted to study the effect of various parameters on the CO₂-foam process. Bottle tests were conducted for four commercially available surfactants and among them, Chaser CD-1045 was found to be the most effective surfactant for CO₂-foam flow under reservoir conditions. It was observed that an increase in pressure from 1, 200 psi to 1, 500 psi leads to increase of the mobility of CO₂-foam, and an increase in temperature from 72 to 122°F reduces the mobility. Also, as the foam quality increases from 20 to 80%, the mobility decreases. It was observed that there was no significant effect on the mobility with an increase in brine concentration from 1 to 3 wt%.     

Asphaltene Deposition under CO2 Injection: An Experimental Study of the Bangestan Reservoir of Ahwaz Oilfield,SW Iran

Abstract

It is essential that precipitation of asphaltenes is recognized early in the planning stage of any CO₂ enhanced oil recovery (EOR) project so that appropriate testing can be performed to evaluate whether there will be a negative impact on reservoir performance. This article presents detailed evaluations of slim tube data that were obtained during CO₂ injection using a medium-gravity Iranian crude oil.

A crude oil from Bangestan reservoir of Ahwaz oilfield containing 18.2% asphaltenes with ~31.5 °API gravity was flooded by purified CO₂ (>96% CO₂) in a slim tube apparatus under 2,700 psi at 110°C. We were going to determine the minimum miscibility pressure (MMP) of the sample oil under injection of CO₂ flood, but when a CO₂ slim tube test was performed for this oil at 2,700 psi, less than half of the saturated oil in the tube was recovered, which implied that the displacement process was immiscible. At this pressure, the asphaltene deposition in the slim tube apparatus was so severe that even a pressure gradient of 6,200 lb/in² was not able to displace any fluid through the capillary tube. Therefore, we abandoned MMP determination with this sample and investigated the problem.

Due to the high percentage of asphaltenes in the sample, using the slim tube MMP as an apparatus for determining minimum miscibility pressure of CO₂ and sample oil can be misleading.     

Prediction of Oil Recovery Factor in CO2 Injection Process

In this study, prediction of recovery factor (RF) for CO₂ injection into oil reservoirs based on artificial neural networks (ANNs) and mathematical models were investigated. To design the optimum ANN model, number of neurons, hidden layers, and training function were studied. Finally, efficiency of the models was evaluated using new data. As a result of this work, it can be concluded that it is possible to predict RF in CO₂ injection process by ANN and mathematical model. However, values that obtained from ANN were in the best agreement with the actual values than regression model. The proposed artificial neural network predicted RF during CO₂ injection with error about 0.396%.     

The Feasibility of Lab-scale Cyclic CO2 Injection in Fractured Porous Media

A comprehensive analysis of the CO₂ Huff-n-Puff process with application to representative light oil system contained within a fractured porous media is present in this article. To accomplish this work, a simulation model representative of the laboratory experimental model was built and constrained under similar laboratory conditions. Six sets of CO₂ Huff-n-Puff experiments were conducted at injection pressures of 1723–10342 kPa; moreover, additional sensitivity analysis was performed on the 5170 and 6894 kPa conditions for different permeability and porosity. Results of this study demonstrate that cyclic injection of CO₂ under miscible conditions performs more favorably than under immiscible injection conditions.     

Influence of injection pressure and injection volume of CO2 on asphaltene deposition

To further improve the oil displacement effect by CO₂ flooding, the trends and conditions of asphaltene deposition under different injection pressures and injection volumes of CO₂ were studied by SDS solid phase deposition testing system, high temperature and high pressure microscope, and P-X phase diagram. When the mole fraction of CO₂ in crude oil increases to a certain value, asphaltene deposition appears. The lower the pressure, the lower the mole fraction of CO₂ in crude oil causing the asphaltene deposition there is. After the onset of asphaltene deposition, the degree of deposition increases with an increase in pressure. The amount of the deposited asphaltene under miscible displacement is the highest, under near-miscible displacement is the second highest, and under immiscible displacement is the lowest. When the dissolution of CO₂ in crude oil reaches the saturation point, the asphaltene deposition becomes slow. Besides, it is feasible to prevent or reduce the asphaltene deposition by adjusting the thermodynamic parameters according to the phase behaviors of the CO₂-crude oil system. The experimental results can provide theoretical basis for optimization design of the parameters of CO₂ flooding.     

Scaled 3-D model studies of immiscible CO2 flooding using horizontal wells

In this study, a comprehensive laboratory investigation was conducted for the recovery of heavy oil from a scaled three-dimensional (3-D) physical model, packed with 18° API gravity crude oil, brine and crushed limestone. A total of 20 experiments were conducted using the scaled 3-D physical model with 30×30×6 cm³ dimensions. Basically, four different immiscible CO₂–water displacement processes were used for recovering heavy oil: (i) continuous CO₂ injection, (ii) waterflooding, (iii) simultaneous injection of CO₂ and water, and (iv) water alternating gas (WAG) process. Three groups of well configurations were mainly used: (1) vertical injection and vertical production wells, (2) vertical injection and horizontal production wells, and (3) horizontal injection and horizontal production wells. Base experiments were run with water only and carbon dioxide alone and optimum rates for WAG and simultaneous water–CO₂ injection were determined. In continuous CO₂ injection, highest recovery was obtained by vertical injection–horizontal production (VI–HP), followed by vertical injection–vertical production (VI–VP) and the least by horizontal injection–horizontal production (HI–HP). In VI–HP configuration, the best recovery was obtained as 15.1% OOIP. Higher oil recovery was obtained with a VI–HP wells than with a pair of vertical wells and horizontal wells. The WAG 1:5 ratio yielded a final recovery of 34.5% OOIP with VI–VP well configuration and 17.0% OOIP of additional recovery over waterflooding. In turn, the WAG 1:10 ratio was the best with a final recovery of 20.9% of OOIP with VI–HP well configuration. Oil production from WAG injection is higher than that obtained from the injection of continuous CO₂ or waterflooding alone.     

Performance Evaluation of Cyclic Pressure Pulsing in a Depleted,Naturally Fractured Reservoir with Stripper-Well Production

Abstract

We present a parametric study on the operational parameters of cyclic pressure pulsing with N₂ and CO₂. We aim to develop a better understanding of how operational parameters affect the process performance in a shallow, naturally fractured, and depleted reservoir of the Big Andy Field in eastern Kentucky. The study includes analyses of various design parameters such as the injection rate, lengths of injection and soaking periods, cycle rate limits, and number of cycles. Incremental oil production, peak oil rate, and net present value (NPV) are considered as the performance criteria. Analyses have been performed using a single-well, dual-porosity, compositional reservoir model.     

CO2 miscible flooding in low permeability sandstone reservoirs and its influence on crude oil properties

Miscible CO₂ injection process has become widely used technique for the enhanced oil recovery in low permeability reservoirs. Core flooding experiments and field test of CO₂ miscible flooding in low permeability sandstone reservoirs and its influence on crude oil properties was studied. The results showed that CO₂ miscible flooding in low permeability sandstone reservoirs can enhance oil recovery both in laboratory study and field test. The permeability of sandstone reservoirs decreased during CO₂ miscible flooding due to the precipitation of asphaltene of crude oil. The precipitation of asphaltene lead to a reduction of asphaltene content and the apparent viscosity of crude oil. A further study on inhibitors and removers for asphaltene deposits from crude oil should be investigated to prevent and remove asphaltene deposits in low permeability sandstone reservoirs.     

Economical Evaluation of CO2-EOR Projects in the Middle East

Abstract

Recently, there is a growing interest the in oil industry to utilize carbon dioxide (CO₂) to enhance oil production from mature reservoirs. Conversely, there is a rising global attention to reduce CO₂ emissions from burning fossil fuels due to environmental concerns. Synchronization between these two objectives is promising through CO₂ Capture and Storage (CCS) projects where CO₂ is captured from large emission sources and then storedin safe geological structures. Economical evaluation of CO₂-EOR projects is a crucial measure in order to ensure a project's viability.

In this study, an efficient model was developed to predict the economics of CO₂-EOR projects. The developed model consists of five modules that are linked together to allow for fast prediction of CO₂-EOR economics.

The model was used to predict the economics of a case study where CO₂-EOR application is considered for a Middle Eastern reservoir. Moreover, the case study was subjected to sensitivity analyses to evaluate the effects of several parameters on the various economical components of CO₂-EOR projects.     

An Investigation of Asphaltene Precipitation During Natural Production and the CO2 Injection Process

Some of Iranian oil reservoirs suffer from operational problems due to asphaltene precipitation during natural depletion, so widely investigation on asphaltene precipitation is necessary for these reservoirs. In this study, a reservoir that is candidate for CO₂ gas injection process is selected to investigate asphaltene precipitation with and without CO₂ injection. In this case, asphaltene precipitation is monitored at various pressures and reservoir temperature. Then, a series of experiments are carried out to evaluate the amount of precipitated asphaltene by injection different molar concentrations (25%, 50%, and 75%) of CO₂. The results show that during primary depletion the amount of precipitated asphaltene increases with pressure reduction until bubble point pressure. Below the bubble point the process is reversed (i.e., the amount of precipitated asphaltene at bubble point pressure is maximum). The behavior of asphaltene precipitation versus pressure for different concentrations of CO₂ is similar to primary depletion. Asphaltene precipitation increases with CO₂ concentration at each pressure step. In the modeling part, solid model and Peng-Robinson equation of state are employed which show a good match with experimental results.     

pH值响应性液流转向剂对自生CO2调驱效果优化研究与应用

针对渤海油田多轮次自生CO_2调驱效果逐渐递减的问题,通过室内物理模拟实验分析了原因,并提出一种利用pH值响应性深部液流转向剂优化自生CO_2调驱效果的方法。岩心驱替实验表明:一轮常规自生CO_2调驱采收率可在水驱基础上提高25.61%,二轮调驱已无增油效果;二轮调驱时加入0.1 PV凝胶,采收率可在一轮常规调驱基础上提高6.11%,但驱替压力由0.07 MPa增至0.7 MPa,表明凝胶体系能够改善调驱效果,但注入性差;二轮调驱时加入0.1 PV的pH值响应性堵剂,注入压力在0.05～0.35 MPa波动,最终采收率可在一轮常规调驱基础上增加12.33%,且调驱后注入压力无明显增加,表明堵剂具有良好的注入性,不影响后续注水。2015年和2018年,分别在渤海油田A区块开展了两轮次现场试验,一轮为常规自生CO_2调驱,措施后累计增油1 371 m~3;二轮为自生CO_2优化调驱,措施后累计增油2 317 m~3,较第一轮增油效果明显改善。     

Organic geochemical characterization of crude oils based on alkanes and acyclic isoprenoids distribution

A variety of biomarker and non-biomarker parameters has been used to geochemical characterization of seven crude oils from the Gulf of Suez region of Egypt. The carbon number distribution and the identities of specific compounds were determined by GC and GC–MS analysis of the saturated fraction obtained by liquid chromatography. n-Alkanes ranging from C₁₀ to C₃₅ were the major constituent series, while acyclic isoprenoids from C₁₃ to C₂₀ except C₁₇, iso- and anteiso-alkanes and cyclic alkanes were the minor constituent series. The close range of bulk property values and biomarker distribution indicated that the investigated oils are belong to only one type. Correlation plots between biomarker and non-biomarker parameters revealed that the oil samples are typical of crude oils generated from marine sediments deposited in suboxic conditions.     

Mutual Interactions of CO2/Oil and Natural Gas/Oil Systems and Their Effects on the EOR Process

Mutual interactions between oil and gas are critical factors affecting the gas enhancing oil recovery (EOR) process. Focusing on CO₂/oil and natural gas/oil systems, their interactions are researched and compared by extraction capacity and solubility measurement experiments. Core flood tests are also implemented to determine the effects of interactions on oil recovery. Results show that CO₂ can extract more light oil from the original and its extraction efficiency can reach 59.3% at 46 MPa, whereas that of natural gas is only 7.3%. However, heavy components content and viscosity of the residual oil processed by CO₂ increases significantly because of extraction, while natural gas does not affect the composition of the residual so remarkably. With increased pressure, solubility of CO₂ and natural gas in a light oil present a linear growth trend with similar rate, but the former is greater than the latter by about 130m³/m³. Core flood tests show that, for the continuous gas injection in the secondary oil recovery process, recovery of CO₂ flood is about 20% higher than that of natural gas due to the late breakthrough of CO₂, as most of the crude oil is produced before breakthrough.     

Hybrid connectionist model determines CO2–oil swelling factor

In-depth understanding of interactions between crude oil and CO₂ provides insight into the CO₂-based enhanced oil recovery (EOR) process design and simulation. When CO₂ contacts crude oil, the dissolution process takes place. This phenomenon results in the oil swelling, which depends on the temperature, pressure, and composition of the oil. The residual oil saturation in a CO₂-based EOR process is inversely proportional to the oil swelling factor. Hence, it is important to estimate this influential parameter with high precision. The current study suggests the predictive model based on the least-squares support vector machine (LS-SVM) to calculate the CO₂–oil swelling factor. A genetic algorithm is used to optimize hyperparameters (γ and σr2) of the LS-SVM model. This model showed a high coefficient of determination (R² = 0.9953) and a low value for the mean-squared error (MSE = 0.0003) based on the available experimental data while estimating the CO₂–oil swelling factor. It was found that LS-SVM is a straightforward and accurate method to determine the CO₂–oil swelling factor with negligible uncertainty. This method can be incorporated in commercial reservoir simulators to include the effect of the CO₂–oil swelling factor when adequate experimental data are not available.     

浅层油藏稠油热水/CO2驱油效率实验模拟研究

新疆油田九_6区齐古组浅层稠油油藏已进入蒸汽开采中后期,油藏开采经历了蒸汽吞吐、加密调整、蒸汽驱过程,采出程度为37%。现阶段单一蒸汽驱效果明显下降,地层亏空严重,蒸汽热利用效率低,吸汽不均,波及程度差异大,油水流度比大,采收率低。热水复合CO_2驱油充分利用热水热效应和发挥CO_2溶解降黏等作用,是提高原油采收率的有效方法。因此,针对九_6区稠油开展不同混合方式热水/CO_2驱油模拟实验,分别研究了纯热水驱、热水与CO_2混注、热水与CO_2段塞的驱油效率。结果表明,纯热水驱累积驱油效率为49.19%,热水/CO_2混注累积驱油效率最大为71.25%,段塞驱累积驱油效率高达85.96%。同时,分析了驱出原油及岩心残余油组分变化。     

含杂质超临界-密相CO2管道输送工艺参数优化

CO_2输送作为CCUS技术实现的中间环节,承担着将CO_2从捕获地输送到封存点的重要任务,结合原油、天然气管道的经验可知,由于管道输送具有输量大、安全可靠性高、连续性强等优势,是目前最主要的CO_2输送方式。根据国外40多年的CO_2管道输送经验,由于超临界-密相CO_2具有类似于液体的高密度和类似于气体的高扩散性与低黏度,被认为是最经济的管道输送方式。以国内某油田30×10~4 t/a CCUS项目为例,采用Pipephase模拟软件对不同管径的超临界-密相CO_2管道在相同入口参数下进行模拟计算,分析研究不同管径下的管道压力、温度、密度与输送距离之间的变化规律,得出含杂质超临界-密相CO_2最优管道输送工艺参数,为后续我国CCUS项目推广和发展提供理论依据。     

Simulation Study of Different Modes of Miscible Carbon Dioxide Flooding

Carbon dioxide flooding has been applied worldwide as a successful enhanced oil recovery. Carbon dioxide flooding may be applied as a continuous injection or as water-alternating-gas (WAG) process. Optimization of the injection mode of carbon dioxide is important for economical field application. This paper focuses on using a fully compositional simulation model for “AEB-3C” sandstone oil reservoir of one of the Western Desert oil fields in Egypt to predict the impact of CO₂ miscible flooding on the reservoir oil recovery and net present value (NPV), to define the best mode of operation that is straight CO₂ injection or water alternating gas (WAG) processes and to show the difference between pure and impure CO₂. Moreover, several sensitivity runs were done on the oil price to show minimum profitable value of oil price when applying such a tertiary method in the subject field.The reservoir under study has been producing under a successful water flooding project since May-2010. The recovery factor by the end of water flooding project is predicted as 32%. CO₂ flooding processes have started by the end of water flooding. A significant increase in the oil recovery factor was noticed due to applying this method; it reached up to 57%. Comparisons between different modes of operations were shown which showed better results when applying WAG process than that with straight CO₂ injection. Moreover; sensitivities were done on the cycle periods in WAG processes and showed increase in the recovery factor with shortening the cycle periods. In addition to a comparison between pure and impure CO₂ which showed very close results.     

Exploitation of fractured shale oil resources by cyclic CO2 injection

With shale oil reservoir pressure depletion and recovery of hydrocarbons from formations, the fracture apertures and conductivity are subject to reduction due to the interaction between stress effects and proppants. Suppose most of the proppants were concentrated in dominant fractures rather than sparsely allocated in the fracture network, the fracture conductivity would be less influenced by the induced stress effect. However, the merit of uniformly distributed proppants in the fracture network is that it increases the contact area for the injection gas with the shale matrix. In this paper, we address the question whether we should exploit or confine the fracture complexity for CO₂-EOR in shale oil reservoirs. Two proppant transport scenarios were simulated in this paper: Case 1—the proppant is uniformly distributed in the complex fracture system, propagating a partially propped or un-propped fracture network; Case 2—the proppant primarily settles in simple planar fractures. A series of sensitivity studies of the fracture conductivity were performed to investigate the conductivity requirements in order to more efficiently produce from the shale reservoirs. Our simulation results in this paper show the potential of CO₂ huff-n-puff to improve oil recovery in shale oil reservoirs. Simulation results indicate that the ultra-low permeability shales require an interconnected fracture network to maximize shale oil recovery in a reasonable time period. The well productivity of a fracture network with a conductivity of 4 mD ft achieves a better performance than that of planar fractures with an infinite conductivity. However, when the conductivity of fracture networks is inadequate, the planar fracture treatment design maybe a favorable choice. The available literature provides limited information on the relationship between fracture treatment design and the applicability of CO₂ huff-n-puff in very low permeability shale formations. Very limited field test or laboratory data are available on the investigation of conductivity requirements for cyclic CO₂ injection in shale oil reservoirs. In the context of CO₂ huff-n-puff EOR, the effect of fracture complexity on well productivity was examined by simulation approaches.     

Black Oil and Compositional Reservoir Simulation for Increasing the Recovery Performance of an Iranian Fractured Carbonate Reservoir

Abstract

Naturally fractured reservoirs contain a significant amount of world oil reserves. Accurate and efficient reservoir simulation of naturally fractured reservoirs is one of the most important, challenging, and computationally intensive problems in reservoir engineering. Black oil and compositional reservoir simulators have been used to determine the reservoir management and production strategies to increase the oil recovery from a low-porosity, low-permeability fractured carbonate reservoir, with an average matrix permeability of 0.8 md, average fracture permeability of 500 md, and an average matrix porosity of 10%. This reservoir is a candidate for an enhanced oil recovery (EOR) process, because the reservoir production rate has been declined due to increasing the water cut as a result of rising the water oil contact. The injection techniques that have been considered in this study for black oil model include (a) gas injection, (b) water injection, and (c) simultaneous water alternating gas injection and for the compositional model include (a) dry gas injection, (b) CO₂ injection, and (c) N₂ injection. Simulation results show that CO₂ injection has the maximum oil recovery between the EOR scenarios.