Evaluation of a new ultraviolet-emitting rare-earth film-screen combination

The performance of a 400 speed class DuPont Ultra Vision Rapid (UVR) film-screen combination has been evaluated and compared with that of DuPont Quanta Fast Detail screens with Cronex 10L film (QFD-200 speed class). The speed was calculated from the constructed characteristic curves (H&D) at different energies. Image quality was derived objectively using the Leeds test object TOR (CDR). An anthropomorphic phantom was then employed to determine image quality subjectively by means of radiologist appraisal. Lumbar spine and chest radiography of patients were performed to evaluate the potential for dose reduction in clinical conditions by measuring skin entrance doses with thermoluminescent dosimeters (TLDs). UVR provided better resolution (9 lp mm-1 as opposed to 8 lp mm-1) and contrast response than QFD. UVR has accommodated a wider exposure latitude than might be expected with conventional 400 speed class film-screen combinations. Use of UVR resulted in better image quality than use of QFD over a wide range of exposure factors. The use of UVR can result in a dose reduction of 50% with no loss in image quality.     

Use of computed radiography in the study of an historic painting

The authors demonstrate the use of radiography in the investigation of an historic painting and describe the potential benefits of computed radiography compared with conventional screen-film radiography. The subject for the comparison was a 16 x 19-foot oil-on-canvas painting, Scipio Africanus Freeing Massiva, by Giovanni Battista Tiepolo. Radiographs of the painting were obtained by using a portable, industrial radiographic unit and both conventional screen-film and photostimulable phosphor plate cassettes. For this investigation, computed radiography had a number of advantages over screen-film radiography, largely due to its wider dynamic range and its capabilities for enhancing the digital images with image processing tools such as magnification, edge enhancement, colorization, and airbrushing. The ability to electronically combine images from the large painting into a single composite image file was extremely valuable, as this technique was much less cumbersome and resulted in much higher quality composite images than could be achieved with conventional radiography. An additional advantage of computed radiography includes the capability to easily archive and transmit these images in a digital format for subsequent review.     

Digital radiography in paediatrics: radiation dose considerations and magnitude of possible dose reduction

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the radiation doses received by paediatric patients examined using a digital radiography unit, and to compare these doses with those received from conventional screen-film systems. In this way, guidelines could be drawn up concerning the magnitude of possible dose reductions achievable using digital radiography. The study was undertaken on approximately 900 patients undergoing abdomen, chest, pelvis and skull examinations. Patients were categorized into the following age groups: 0-1 month, 1-12 months, 1-5 years, 5-10 years and 10-15 years. Approximately half were X-rayed using a Fuji computed radiography system and half using a conventional screen-film system. Entrance surface dose was calculated from the recorded exposure parameters and measured X-ray tube outputs. Dose-area product was recorded directly. Image quality was assessed clinically using criteria recommended by a working group of the Commission of the European Communities. Apart from chest examinations, it was found possible to reduce doses by about 40% on average, by using a computed radiography system instead of a 600 speed screen-film combination. There was no significant difference in the dose for chest examinations. Satisfactory image quality can therefore be achieved by using computed radiography as a 1000 speed system for abdomen, pelvis and skull examinations, and as a 600 speed system for chests. Since very few departments appear to use screen-film systems of speeds greater than 400, then, for most departments, the use of computed radiography would result in dose reductions of at least 60%, or 33% for chests.     

Mottle on computed radiographs of the chest in pediatric patients

PURPOSE: To investigate the relationship between radiation exposure and perceived mottle at bedside pediatric chest examinations performed with screen-film and computed radiographic techniques. MATERIALS AND METHODS: In a pediatric intensive care unit, chest radiographs were obtained with both computed radiography (60 radiographs) and a 600-speed screen-film system (14 radiographs). The relative radiation exposure was estimated by using the sensitivity value obtained in the processing of each computed radiograph. Five radiologists assessed the mottle present in the computed radiographs and screen-film images. RESULTS: For computed radiographs, the perceived level of mottle was inversely related to radiation exposure. For the same radiation exposure, the perceived mottle on computed radiographs was significantly higher than that on screen-film images (P < .001 for small cassettes; P < .01 for large cassettes). CONCLUSION: Pediatric computed radiography of the chest requires approximately twice the exposure of a 600-speed screen-film system to attain the same level of mottle.     

ROC comparison of visualization of hand fractures using digital and conventional techniques

PURPOSE: To compare the accuracy of digital luminescence radiography (DLR) and conventional film-screen radiography (FSR) in diagnosing fractures. MATERIAL AND METHOD: Both conventional and digital radiographs were acquired from a consecutive series of 57 patients with suspected wrist or hand fractures. The digital images were obtained with a 30% dose reduction. A ROC-analysis (receiver-operating characteristics) was performed. RESULTS: The area under the curve was 0.89 for conventional FSR, 0.93 for DLR, "gray scale" and 0.94 for DLR, "edge enhanced". CONCLUSIONS: Although its spatial resolution is lower, DLR provided better results than conventional FSR, when contrast processing algorithms were optimised for the specific clinical question. The edge-enhanced version was superior to the non-edge enhanced version. The reason for this seems to be the higher contrast resolution of DLR compared to FSR.     

Evaluation of a new low-dose digital x-ray device: first dosimetric and clinical results in children

BACKGROUND: A new low-dose digital X-ray device, based on Charpak's Nobel prize-winning multiwire chamber, enables the production of images at very low doses. Objectives. To present the first dosimetric and clinical results. MATERIALS AND METHODS: The analysis was performed on 93 children with scoliosis and 47 undergoing pelvic radiography. The comparative study between conventional X-ray and the new technique focused on three points: (1) the dose delivered by each system (2) the diagnostic information provided by each system and (3) comparison of image quality criteria with European guidelines. RESULTS: The mean ratio of conventional dose to that of the low-dose technique was 13.1 for the spinal examination and 18.8 for the pelvis. There was no significant difference in diagnostic information available from each modality, but there was a slight difference in quality criteria in favour of the conventional technique. CONCLUSION: This new device allows spectacular dose reduction, consistent with adequate clinical information. Improvements of the prototype will lead to extension of potential indications and industrial development.     

Absorbed dose and image quality in examinations of the colon with digital and analogue techniques

PURPOSE: Image quality and the absorbed dose to the patient are issues of primary interest in the change-over from the conventional analogue technique to the digital technique in the examination of the colon by means of fluoroscopy. The aim of this study was to compare the incident radiation and to evaluate the image quality in two different X-ray equipment types, one digital and one analogue. MATERIAL AND METHODS: A kerma-area product meter was used to measure the incident radiation to the patient. Both fluoroscopy and total-examination times were measured as was the number of images. An evaluation of image quality was made and statistically analysed. RESULTS AND CONCLUSION: No significant difference in the irradiation dose was observed between the two techniques. The fluoroscopy time was significantly lower with the conventional technique but the total-examination time decreased by 18% with the digital technique. The total number of images taken was higher with the digital technique (25 images compared to 19) owing to the limited field of the image intensifier. Significantly more noise and less sharpness were observed with the digital system but there was no significant difference in contrast or image quality in the various anatomical structures. Although the change-over to the digital system produced a reduction in sharpness and an increase in noise, and no significant dose saving was measured, the digital system was faster to work with and could well be used for diagnostic purposes.     

Single-exposure conventional and computed radiography. The hybrid cassette revisited

RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES: The authors constructed and evaluated a hybrid cassette for single-exposure extremity imaging with storage-phosphor plates and conventional radiographic film. METHODS: A hybrid cassette was constructed using a fine radiographic screen and a storage-phosphor plate. Exposures of a Lucite step wedge and a line pair gauge were made with the hybrid cassette, a conventional radiographic cassette, and a storage-phosphor cassette. The spatial resolution and imaging speeds of the hybrid and standard systems were compared. RESULTS: Spatial resolution loss was less than 0.5 line pairs per mm with the hybrid cassette. Speed loss was characteristic of the hybrid cassette, requiring approximately 40% greater exposure to produce the same film density as standard cassettes. CONCLUSIONS: The speed difference between this and a previous study is probably due to differences in film-screen choice, kilovolt peak, and storage-phosphor plate generations. The sensitivity spectrum of our film and the emission spectrum of our screens were more closely matched than were the spectra in the previous study; we used lower kilovolt peak, and our storage-phosphor plates were a later, more efficient, generation. Despite slight speed losses, the hybrid cassette appears to be a better choice for obtaining matched images for clinical trials than the alternative of two separate exposures.     

A bimetal anode with tungsten or rhodium? Comparative studies on image quality and dosage requirement in mammography

PURPOSE: The impact of different anode materials (tungsten and rhodium) on spatial resolution, image contrast and radiation exposure was studied. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Two mammographic systems providing bimetal x-ray tubes (Mo/W and Mo/Rh) were compared by imaging a breast radiography phantom with additional acrylic plates from 3 to 8 cm thickness. Spatial resolution was evaluated using a line bar pattern. Image contrast was assessed by measuring the ratio of optical densities in a acrylic step-wedge. The entrance dose was measured with a low energy ionisation chamber. RESULTS: The spatial resolution was about 13 lp/mm regardless of the beam quality. The image contrast depended substantially on the thickness. A similar image contrast was found with Mo/Mo, Mo/Rh and Rh/Rh for simulated breast thicknesses of 4 to 6 cm and with Rh/Rh and W/Rh for 7 cm. In comparison to Mo/Mo the dose reduction was significant for Mo/Rh (35%), Rh/Rh (50%) and W/Rh (60%). CONCLUSIONS: Bimetal x-ray tubes provide optimal conditions for screen film mammography of both normal and dense breasts, allowing good contrast and dose reduction by using the adequate anode/filter-combination.     

Investigations of moving-slit radiography

The technique of moving-slit radiography for reduction of scattered radiation was investigated using a prototype moving-slit radiographic apparatus. Slit widths of 1-2 cm, when used in conjuction with an 8: 1 grid, were found to improve radiographic contrast by a factor of 2 in studies employing physical as well as anatomic phantoms. Use of the moving-slit technique at elevated kVp's was found to provide radiographic contrast as good as or better than that obtained in conventional low-kVp full-field techniques, but with a substantial reduction of patient exposure (factor of 2-4). Considerations in the design of an optimal multislit apparatus are discussed. Excessive tube loading is shown not to be a factor in such a system.     

Dose reduction in a paediatric X-ray department following optimization of radiographic technique

A survey of radiation doses to children from diagnostic radiography has been carried out in a dedicated paediatric X-ray room. Entrance surface dose (ESD) and dose-area product (DAP) per radiograph were simultaneously measured with thermoluminescent dosemeters (TLDs) and a DAP meter to provide mean dose values for separate age ranges. Results of ESD and DAP were lower than the mean values from other UK studies for all ages and radiographs, except for the infant pelvis AP radiograph. Comparison of ESD and radiographic technique with CEC quality criteria highlighted a need for reduction of dose to infants and implied an increase in tube filtration might overcome the limitations of the room's three-phase, 12-pulse generator, allowing higher tube potentials to be used on infants. Additional tube filtration of 3 mmA1 was installed following assessment of dose reduction and image quality with test objects and phantoms, and confirmation from the paediatric radiologist that clinical image quality was not-significantly altered. The tube potential was increased from 50 to 56 kVp for the infant pelvis AP radiograph. The resulting ESD and effective dose fell by 51% and 38%, respectively. The CEC quality criteria have proved useful as a benchmark against which technique in X-ray departments can be compared, and as such are a useful tool for optimizing radiographic technique and reducing patient dose.     

Advanced multiple beam equalization radiography (AMBER) combined with computed radiography. Preliminary evaluation

The combined use of AMBER (Advanced Multiple Beam Equalization Radiography) and a digital storage phosphor (SP) radiography system was evaluated for chest radiography in a pilot study with 4 patients. Four image modes with different dose levels were compared: the SP in combination with an AMBER equalized exposure (SP/AMBER) and 3 nonequalized exposures with dose levels corresponding to the respective calculated AMBER lung dose (SP/lung field dose), the calculated AMBER mediastinal dose (SP/mediastinal dose) and the calculated AMBER average dose (SP/average dose). All image modes were matched for Hurter and Driffield characteristics and subjectively rated according to visibility of details. The improved signal-to-noise (S/N) ratio of SP/AMBER resulted in a better visualization of structures in the mediastinum and the basal lung where SP/lung field dose scored lowest. For the central lung no quality differences were seen between techniques. The compressed dynamic range of the SP/AMBER images was more easily displayed on the hard-copy film. The combination of AMBER with SP radiography promises to overcome the dynamic range limitations of digital displays while, at moderate doses, giving better S/N and image quality than standard SP technique.     

Long-term outcome after sagittal synostosis operations

PURPOSE: Optimization of image quality by use of digital luminescence radiography (DLR) in voiding cystoureterography (VCU) instead of a conventional screen film system. PATIENTS AND METHODS: 53 patients with a suspected vesicouretral reflux were examined with a VCU in analogous and digital technique. The X-rays were taken in a sitting position while simultaneously measuring the bladder pressure. An intraindividual comparison was omitted for X-ray saving reasons. In the follow-up 3 patients were examined with the other system. Two radiologists and two urologists compared 60 VCU of 53 patients--30 VCU in conventional screen film and 30 in DLR technique presented in standard and edge-enhanced images--with regard to image quality according to 3-step score (A--good image quality, B--sufficient image quality, C--insufficient image quality). RESULTS: The 59 conventional films were scored 72 times with an A, 76 times with a B, and 72 times with a C, whereas the DLR films were scored 116 times with an A, 72 times with a B, and only 8 times with a C. Hereby the edge-enhanced images were the most useful for distinguishing the bladder shadow from the soft tissue of the thigh and for detecting reflux. Furthermore, the exposure dose when applying DLR could be decreased to 75% in grown-ups and to 57% in children without any significant loss of information. CONCLUSION: The DLR is highly superior to the conventional film screen system because of its relatively high tolerance towards wrong exposures, especially with respect of the sitting position during MCU. With the DLR we obtained 96% and with the conventional system only 63% films usable for diagnosis.     

Multiplanar imaging in the preoperative assessment of metallic intraocular foreign bodies. Helical computed tomography versus conventional computed tomography

OBJECTIVE: This study aimed to compare the effectiveness of helical computed tomography (CT) versus conventional CT in the preoperative assessment of metallic intraocular foreign bodies on axial, coronal, and multiplanar reconstruction images in clinical routine. DESIGN: Prospective comparative trial, alternate assignment of consecutive patients. PARTICIPANTS: Eighteen patients with penetrating eye injuries and suspected metallic intraocular foreign bodies were studied. INTERVENTION: Alternate patients were assigned to undergo either helical CT or conventional CT in the axial plane. Both the helical and the conventional data were transferred to a workstation, and reconstructions in the coronal and sagittal planes were performed. Additional direct coronal scanning was performed only when necessary for preoperative assessment. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: The quality of the directly obtained axial and coronal, as well as the reconstructed coronal and sagittal images, was assessed for each, imaging method based on the ability to detect and accurately localize foreign bodies. The size of the foreign bodies was measured and compared to the actual diameter. Total examination time and radiation dose delivered to the lens were measured for each imaging method. RESULTS: All foreign bodies were detected by each scanning method on the axial, the coronal, and on the reconstructed planes. The quality of the axial images was similar for helical and conventional CT. The helical technique provided high-quality reconstructed images comparable in quality to the directly obtained coronal planes in conventional CT. Reconstructions by conventional technique were not useful for preoperative assessment. The examination time for the total orbital volume was 18 seconds for helical CT examinations and 52 seconds for conventional CT examinations. Radiation dose delivered to the lens for the complete examination was 35 mGy for helical CT axial scanning, 56 mGy for conventional CT axial scanning, and 63 mGy for conventional CT coronal scanning. CONCLUSIONS: Helical CT multiplanar imaging offers several significant advantages for the preoperative assessment of metallic intraocular foreign bodies compared to the conventional CT technique in clinical practice, including short examination time, reduced motion artifacts, reduced radiation exposure, and the ability to obtain diagnostically useful coronal and sagittal reconstruction images without the need for additional scanning.     

Product update

OBJECTIVE: To compare fluoroscopic freeze-frame digital images with conventional 105-mm spot films during voiding cystourethrography (VCUG) with regard to diagnostic quality and radiation dose. MATERIALS AND METHODS: VCUG was performed on 57 consecutive children by a commercially available fluoroscopic digital system. Both freeze-frame digital images and conventional 105-mm spot films were obtained during 90 s of fluoroscopy. Skin radiation dose was assessed separately for spot films and for both fluoroscopy and spot films, employing thermoluminescent crystals on the anterior surface of the body. Patients were classified into three age groups: group A younger than 12 months, group B 1-5 years old and group C 5-12 years of age. RESULTS: Digital and conventional images provided diagnostically identical results in 108 out of 114 ureters examined (94.7%). Percentage reductions in skin radiation dose due to the fluoroscopic hard copies compared with the four 105-mm radiographs were 53.8%, 50.5% and 57.1% for groups A, B and C, respectively. CONCLUSION: Substitution of conventional 105-mm spot films during VCUG with digital fluoroscopic hard copies resulted in a substantial reduction in radiation dose. Digital images were as accurate as the conventional films in excluding vesicoureteric reflux (VUR). The two methods correlated well in diagnosing and grading VUR.     

Panoramic radiography using an intraoral tube. Method, anatomy, radiography and dosimetry

BACKGROUND: There are two techniques giving a panoramic view of the dental arch: orthopantomography and intraoral tube panoramic radiography. The last one is not very well known because images, with a characteristic and variable deformity if compared with orthopantomography are not useful for routinary use in dentistry. The poor radiographic and pathologic anatomy knowledge of intraoral tube panoramic radiography, and the slight improvements brought to the method particularly in order to reduce the dose, partly depend on the scant attention given to the method by investigators, and partly on the dyshomogeneous anatomic sites enlargement and overlapping with consequent deformity of all of them. With intraoral tube panoramic radiography, X-ray exposition is emitted using a miniaturized cylindrical source placed inside the oral cavity and the radiographic film is in contact with the skin of the face. Based on the orientation of the collimator and the inclination of the tube major axis in the oral cavity, a central technique (exposition of either superior or inferior dental arch) and a lateral technique (simultaneous exposition of the two hemiarches of the same side) are recognized. The aim of this study is to give a significative contribution to maxillo-facial characteristic appearance and dosimetry knowledge in intraoral tube panoramic radiography. METHODS: It consists of: a) a "laboratory" part concerning the evaluation of the enlargement, deformation and visibility of different structures, obtained by positioning about fifty different markers in different maxillary and mandibular anatomic sites, and b) an in vivo dosimetry part obtained with intraoral and extraoral termoluminiscent dosimeters. An original dispositive allowed the right positioning of the film and its adherence to the screen. Deformity characteristics are analitically described and discussed in relation with the different sites. RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS: The use of intensifying screens allowed a good reduction of dose, (mean absorbed doses ranging from 25 microGy in the intraoral sites to 1936 microGy in the extraoral sites) without reducing the image quality thanks to the device performed "ad hoc".     

Simultaneous multilayer arthrotomography of the temporomandibular joint using photostimulable phosphor computed radiography

OBJECTIVE: To compare the image quality of photostimulable phosphor computed radiography (CR) with that of a conventional screen-film system for simultaneous multilayer arthrotomography of the temporomandibular joint (TMJ). METHODS: X-ray attenuation, resolution and granularity was compared. Simultaneous multilayer tomography of TMJ was performed using a skull phantom and diagnostic quality of bone structures estimated. The clinical outcome is demonstrated in two typical cases. RESULTS: X-ray attenuation was larger with CR. Granularity was more prominent in edge-enhanced CR images and was associated with inferior diagnostic quality. However, it was improved by using a higher tube voltage. Clinical CR without edge enhancement showed a similar resolution to the conventional system but this decreased with enhancement. In an enhanced arthrotomogram, the boundary between contrast medium, bone and soft tissue were clearly defined and a fibrous adhesion also easily seen. CONCLUSION: Photostimulable phosphor CR is an acceptable alternative for simultaneous multilayer arthrotomography of the TMJ.     

Intensive care for patients with the human immunodeficiency virus]

RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES: The authors evaluate a new flat-panel x-ray detector (FD) with respect to foreign body detection and reduction of radiation dose compared with screen-film radiography. METHODS: Flat-panel x-ray detector is based on amorphous silicon technology and uses a 1 k x 1 k photo-detector matrix with a pixel size of 143 x 143 microns and 12-bit digital output. A thallium-dotted cesium iodide scintillation layer converts x-rays into light. An ex vivo experimental model was used to determine the detectability of foreign bodies. Foreign bodies with varying sizes were examined: glass with and without addition of lead, bone, aluminium, iron, copper, gravel fragments, and graphite. Four hundred observation fields were examined using conventional radiography (speed, 400; system dose: 2.5 microGy) as well as FD with a simulated speed of 400, 800, 1200, and 1600, corresponding to a detector dose of 2.5 microGy, 1.25 microGy, 0.87 microGy, and 0.625 microGy, respectively. Four independent radiologists performed receiver operating characteristic analysis of 8000 observations. RESULTS: Flat-panel x-ray detector with a simulated speed of 400 was significantly superior (P = 0.012) to screen-film radiography (speed, 400). At a simulated speed of 800 and 1200 FD yielded results equivalent to screen-film radiography. Flat-panel x-ray detector was significantly inferior to screen-film radiography at a simulated speed of 1600 (P = 0.012). CONCLUSIONS: Flat-panel x-ray detector technology allows significant reduction in radiation dose compared with screen-film radiography without loss of diagnostic accuracy.     

A large screen digitizer system for radiation therapy treatment planning

PURPOSE: This paper describes a new technique for manually drawing contours of anatomy over image data for the purposes of radiation therapy treatment planning. METHODS AND MATERIALS: A large area rear-projectible digitizer tablet is used together with a projection TV system to display computer graphics and image data. Large images of computed tomography or magnetic resonance cross-sections are displayed and the digitizer is used to directly trace outlines of important organs. Digitizer menus allow multiple functions for selecting images and structures, for changing the grayscale level and window, and for zooming and roaming the image. RESULTS: This device has been in clinical operation for many years and has proven to greatly increase the speed of entering cross-sectional outlines defined for serial computed tomography images sets. A small timing study of clinical usage demonstrates up to a factor of ten improvement in the speed of contour entry. CONCLUSION: For 3-dimensional radiation therapy, tumor, and target volumes, as well as important critical organs, must be delineated from serial sets of computed tomography or magnetic resonance images. Often 30 or more slices must be considered and the process of outlining structures on this number of slices can represent a significant fraction of the total treatment planning time. The device described in this paper greatly improve the ease and speed of manual contour entry for 3-dimensional radiation therapy planning.     

Occupational medicine aspects of nasal diseases]

PURPOSE: The relations between image quality in last image hold images and dose in grid controlled fluoroscopy in comparison to the continuous mode need to be characterised and recommendations for the clinical application of this technique should be given. MATERIAL AND METHODS: Spatial resolution, signal-noise ratio and, contrast-detail visibility were evaluated by phantom measurements in grid controlled pulsed and continuous fluoroscopy. Dose was measured at the image intensifier entrance. Image quality of last image hold (LIH) images of clinical examinations was graded in relation to single shot exposures. RESULTS: Signal-noise ratio and contrast-detail visibility depend on the dose per puls. Spatial resolution and contrast-detail visibility in grid controlled fluoroscopy are superior than to in the continuous mode. Image quality of the LIH images from the grid controlled fluoroscopy was improved. Radiation exposure could be reduced to 10-46%. CONCLUSIONS: Combinations of puls-dose and -frequency are recommended for achieving extensive dose reduction and improved image quality of LIH images.