Chloride transport in fly ash and glass powder modified concretes – Influence of test methods on microstructure

This paper discusses the influence of rapid chloride transport test methods on the microstructure and the measured chloride penetration resistance of concretes containing fly ash or fine glass powder as partial cement replacement materials. Rapid chloride permeability (RCP), non-steady-state migration (NSSM), and steady state conduction (SSC) tests are performed on plain and modified concretes. The glass powder modified concretes demonstrate similar or lower RCP values as compared to the fly ash modified concretes of the same cement replacement level whereas the steady state conductivities are lower for the fly ash modified mixtures. The NSSM coefficients are lower for the fly ash modified concretes even when the initial conductivities are similar to those of plain or glass powder modified concretes. Chloride binding under the conditions of NSSM test, that influence the microstructure and the transport parameter, is quantified using thermal analysis and XRD patterns as well as an electrical circuit model for the impedance response. The resistance of connected pores (R_c) extracted from the model adequately captures the changes in microstructure with time and with chloride transport. The changes in R_c between the start and finish of the NSSM test also indicate microstructural alteration in fly ash modified concretes.     

Concrete durability presented by acceptable chloride level and chloride diffusion coefficient in concrete: 10-year results in marine site

Generally, concrete with high resistance to the marine environment should have high compressive strength, a low chloride diffusion coefficient (D _C), and a high acceptable chloride level (Ac). Considering all parameters simultaneously, this study evaluated the degree of fly ash concrete durability based on 10-year results in a marine site. Based on the concrete durability (Ac/D _C, as compared to cement concrete with a W/B ratio of 0.45) and compressive strength, the degree of concrete durability proposed in this study indicates that fly ash concretes with a W/B ratio of 0.45 and 15–35 wt % fly ash replacement exhibit high-quality performance in a marine site.     

Use of natural zeolite as a supplementary cementitious material

Natural zeolite, a type of frame-structured hydrated aluminosilicate mineral, is used abundantly as a type of natural pozzolanic material in some regions of the world. In this work, the effectiveness of a locally quarried zeolite in enhancing mechanical and durability properties of concrete is evaluated and is also compared with other pozzolanic admixtures. The experimental tests included three parts: In the first part, the pozzolanic reactivity of natural zeolite and silica fume were examined by a thermogravimetric method. In this case, the results indicated that natural zeolite was not as reactive as silica fume but it showed a good pozzolanic reactivity. In the second part, zeolite and silica fume were substituted for cement in different proportions in concrete mixtures, and several physical and durability tests of concrete were performed. These experimental tests included slump, compressive strength, water absorption, oxygen permeability, chloride diffusion, and electrical resistivity of concrete. Based on these results, the performance of concretes containing different contents of zeolite improved and even were comparable to or better than that of concretes prepared with silica fume replacements in some cases. Finally, a comparative study on effect of zeolite and fly ash on limiting ASR expansion of mortar was performed according to ASTM C 1260 and ASTM C 1567. Expansion tests on mortar prisms showed that zeolite is as effective as fly ash to prevent deleterious expansion due to ASR.     

Moisture and ionic transport in concretes containing coarse limestone powder

Concretes containing a coarse limestone powder (median particle size of 72 μm) as a partial cement replacement material are proportioned so as to attain similar 7-day compressive strengths as a 0.40 water-to-cement ratio (w/c) control concrete. The moisture and chloride ion transport behavior of the concretes containing limestone powder with and without small amounts of silica fume are evaluated in this paper. It is shown that a 15% cement replacement with coarse limestone powder at a water-to-powder ratio (w/p) of 0.34 results in concretes of better or comparable compressive strengths, porosities, moisture transport parameters (overall moisture intake, and sorptivity), and rapid chloride permeability (RCP) as that of a 0.37 w/c plain concrete. However, the non-steady state migration coefficients (D_nssm) of concretes containing limestone powder are found to be higher than those of plain concretes of even higher w/c. A microstructural parameter (?β – product of porosity and pore connectivity) is used to relate the pore structure to the moisture and ionic transport. Relationships between ?β and the moisture and ionic transport parameters are provided, which shed light on the combined influence of w/p and a highly reactive cement replacement material such as silica fume on the different transport properties of concretes containing a coarse limestone powder.     

Effect of ground fly ash and ground bagasse ash on the durability of recycled aggregate concrete

This research aims to study the effect of ground fly ash (GFA) and ground bagasse ash (GBA) on the durability of recycled aggregate concrete. Recycled aggregate concrete was produced with recycled aggregate to fully replace crushed limestone in the mix proportion of conventional concrete (CON) and GFA and GBA were used to partially replace Portland cement type I at the rate of 20%, 35%, and 50% by weight of binder. Compressive strength, water permeability, chloride penetration depth, and expansion by sulfate attack on concretes were investigated.The results reveal that the use of GFA and GBA to partially replace cement in recycled aggregate concrete was highly effective in improving the durability of recycled aggregate concrete. The suitable replacement of GFA or GBA in recycled aggregate concrete to obtain the suitable compressive strength, low water permeability, high chloride penetration resistance, and high sulfate resistance is 20% by weight of binder.     

Use of ultrafine rice husk ash with high-carbon content as pozzolan in high performance concrete

Rice husk ash (RHA) has been generated in large quantities in rice producing countries. This by-product can contain non-crystalline silica and thus has a high potential to be used as cement replacement in mortar and concrete. However, as the RHA produced by uncontrolled burning conditions usually contains high-carbon content in its composition, the pozzolanic activity of the ash and the rheology of mortar or concrete can be adversely affected. In this paper the influence of different grinding times in a vibratory mill, operating in dry open-circuit, on the particle size distribution, BET specific surface area and pozzolanic activity of the RHA is studied, in order to improve RHA’s performance. In addition, four high-performance concretes were produced with 0%, 10%, 15%, and 20% of the cement (by mass) replaced by ultrafine RHA. For these mixtures, rheological, mechanical and durability tests were performed. For all levels of cement replacement, especially for the 20%, the ultra-fine RHA concretes achieved superior performance in the mechanical and durability tests compared with the reference mixture. The workability of the concrete, however, was reduced with the increase of cement replacement by RHA.     

Durability aspect of concretes composed of cold bonded and sintered fly ash lightweight aggregates

This study reports the finding of an experimental study carried out on the durability related properties of the lightweight concretes (LWCs) including either cold bonded (CB) or sintered (S) fly ash aggregates. CB aggregate was produced with cold bonding pelletization of class F fly ash (FA) and Portland cement (PC) while S aggregate was produced by sintering the fresh aggregate pellets manufactured from FA and bentonite (BN). Two concrete series with water-to-binder (w/b) ratios of 0.35 and 0.55 were designed. Moreover, silica fume (SF) with 10% replacement level was also utilized for the purpose of comparing the performances of LWCs with and without ultrafine SF. The durability properties of concretes composed of CB and S aggregates were evaluated in terms of water sorptivity, rapid chloride ion permeability, gas permeability, and accelerated corrosion testing after 28 days of water curing period. The compressive strength test was also applied to observe the strength level at the same age. The results revealed that S aggregate containing LWCs had relatively better performance than LWCs with CB aggregates. Moreover, the incorporation of SF provided further enhancement in permeability and corrosion resistance of the concretes.     

Optimization of concrete mixture with hybrid blends of metakaolin and fly ash using response surface method

This paper presents the experimental results of a research carried out on the strength and permeability related properties of high performance concretes made with binary and ternary cementitious blends of fly ash (FA) and metakaolin (MK). The replacement ratios for FA were 10% and 20% by weight of Portland cement and those for MK were 5% and 10%. Compressive strength, chloride permeability, water sorptivity, and water absorption properties of concretes were obtained in this study for different testing ages up to 90 days. The influences of fly ash, metakaolin, and testing age on the properties of concretes have been identified using the analysis of variance. The statistical based regression models and the response surface method with the backward stepwise techniques were employed in the multi-objective optimization analysis. That is carried out by maximizing compressive strength while minimizing chloride permeability, water sorptivity, and water absorption. It was observed that fly ash and especially metakaolin were very effective on the aforementioned properties of the concretes, depending mainly on replacement levels and duration of curing. The results indicated that the ternary use of fly ash and metakaolin with the approximate cement replacement values of 13.3% and 10% respectively has provided the best results for the testing age of 90 days, when the optimized strength and permeability based durability properties of the concretes are concerned.     

Effect of mix design inputs,curing and compressive strength on the durability of Na2SO4-activated high volume fly ash concretes

This paper aims to advance research on the use in concrete of a high volume of fly ash, with a high loss on ignition value, aiding in sustainable low carbon footprint construction. To this end, the work explores the benefits that may be achieved in terms of long-term concrete performance from the incorporation of fly ash along with a chemical activator. Durability tests are performed on concrete with an activated hybrid cementitious system: Portland cement (PC) and high volume fly ash with sodium sulfate. The chloride diffusion coefficient significantly decreased over time for the activated system (50% PC - 50% fly ash with added sodium sulfate) compared to the control samples (100% PC and 80% PC - 20% fly ash) at the same water to cementitious material ratio. This behavior is particularly evident in samples cured under controlled laboratory conditions (100% RH and 23 °C). However, outdoor curing increases the permeability for all concretes. Long term carbonation is also investigated under natural exposure conditions, and samples that are cured outdoors exhibit a significant carbonation depth. The compressive strength is correlated with the durability parameters: the durability performance improves as the compressive strength increases, indicating that as is the case for Portland cement (but not always for alkali-activated binders), the microstructural factors which yield high strength are also contributing to durability properties.     

Sustainability-based decision support framework for choosing concrete mixture proportions

A framework is proposed, along with two objective indices, for the selection of concrete mixture proportions based on sustainability criteria. The indices combine energy demand and long-term strength as energy intensity, and carbon emissions and durability parameters as A-indices, which represent the apathy toward these essential features of sustainability. The decision support framework is demonstrated by considering a set of 30 concretes with different binders, including ordinary portland cement (OPC), fly ash, slag and limestone calcined clay cement (LC3). In addition to the experimental data on compressive strength, chloride diffusion and carbonation, life cycle assessment has been performed for the concretes considering typical situations in South India. The most sustainable of the concretes studied here, for service life limited by chloride ingress, are those with LC3, OPC replaced by 50% slag, and ternary blends with 20% each of slag and fly ash. In the case of applications where carbonation is critical, the appropriate concretes are those with OPC replaced by 15–30% slag or 15% fly ash, or with ternary blends having 20% slag and 20% Class F fly ash.     

Strength development of fly ash concretes

Compressive strength developed by concretes containing fly ash up to 80% of the cementitious fraction is presented. The effects of mix design technique, quantity of cement in the mix and the curing period on the strength development of fly ash concrete are also included. A comparison of the rate of strength development of the control and fly ash concretes is also provided. It is concluded that the optimum level of replacement of cement by fly ash depends on the actual amount of cement in the mix.     

Compressive strength and chloride resistance of self-compacting concrete containing high level fly ash and silica fume

The influence of high-calcium fly ash and silica fume as a binary and ternary blended cement on compressive strength and chloride resistance of self-compacting concrete (SCC) were investigated in this study. High-calcium fly ash (40–70%) and silica fume (0–10%) were used to replace part of cement at 50, 60 and 70 wt.%. Compressive strength, density, volume of permeable pore space (voids) and water absorption of SCC were investigated. The total charge passed in coulombs was assessed in order to determine chloride resistance of SCC. The results show that binary blended cement with high level fly ash generally reduced the compressive strength of SCC at all test ages (3, 7, 28 and 90 days). However, ternary blended cement with fly ash and silica fume gained higher compressive strength after 7 days when compared to binary blended fly ash cement at the same replacement level. The compressive strength more than 60 MPa (high strength concrete) can be obtained when using high-calcium fly ash and silica fume as ternary blended cement. Fly ash decreased the charge passed of SCC and tends to decrease with increasing fly ash content, although the volume of permeable pore space (voids) and water absorption of SCC were increased. In addition when compared to binary blended cement at the same replacement level, the charge passed of SCC that containing ternary blended cement was lower than binary blended cement with fly ash only. This indicated that fly ash and silica fume can improve chloride resistance of SCC at high volume content of Portland cement replacement.     

Properties of high volume glass powder concrete

Mechanical and durability properties of concrete with cement replaced by finely grounded glass powder in high volume up to 60% were investigated. XRD and TGA analyses indicated that the fine glass powder reacted with calcium hydroxide to form calcium-silicate-hydrates. As such, the microstructures of concrete were more compact and homogeneous, especially at the interfacial transition zone. Concrete with cement replaced by 15% and 30% glass powder exhibited the highest strength increase and correspondingly the lowest porosity. Beyond a replacement of 30%, calcium hydroxide became insufficient for the pozzolanic reaction of glass powder. However, the high volume glass powder concrete retained distinct resistance against water and chloride ingress, due to the reduction in pore size and connectively. Reductions of 77%, 83%, 96%, 91% and 92% were observed respectively for water penetration depth, sorptivity, conductivity, chloride diffusion and migration coefficients in concrete with cement replaced by glass powder by 60%.     

Effect of supplementary cementitious materials on shrinkage and crack development in concrete

The autogenous and drying shrinkage of Portland cement concrete, and binary and ternary binder concretes, were measured and compared. The binary and ternary binder concretes were formed by replacing part of the cement with fly ash, very fine fly ash and/or silica fume. Restrained shrinkage test was also performed to evaluate the effect of binder type on early age cracking. After the cracking of the restrained ring samples, crack widths were measured and compared with the results of an R-curve based model, which takes post-peak elastic and creep strains into account.The incorporation of fly ash and very fine fly ash decreased the autogenous shrinkage strain but increased the drying shrinkage strain. Since the total shrinkage strains of both the ternary and the binary concrete mixtures were similar, the strength development became an important factor in the cracking. The lower strength of the concrete with ternary binders led to earlier cracking compared to the binary binder concrete. Portland cement concrete cracked the earliest and had the greatest crack width. Measured crack widths were in accordance with the crack widths calculated with the R-curve model.     

Performance characteristics of concrete based on a ternary calcium sulfoaluminate–anhydrite–fly ash cement

This paper reports an assessment of the performance of concrete based on a calcium sulfoaluminate–anhydrite–fly ash cement combination. Concretes were prepared at three different w/c ratios and the properties were compared to those of Portland cement and blast-furnace cement concretes. The assessment involved determination of mechanical and durability properties. The results suggest that an advantageous synergistic effect between and ettringite and fly ash (Ioannou et al., 2014) was reflected in the concrete’s low water absorption rates, high sulfate resistance, and low chloride diffusion coefficients. However, carbonation depths, considering the dense ettringite-rich microstructure developed, were higher than those observed in Portland cement concretes at a given w/c ratio. It was concluded that the amount of alkali hydroxides present in the pore solution is as important factor as the w/c ratio when performance of this type of concrete is addressed.     

Comparison of ground waste glass with other supplementary cementitious materials

Finely ground glass has pozzolanic properties that make attractive its recycling as supplementary cementitious material. This paper compares the behaviour of waste glass powders of different fineness with that of natural pozzolana, coal fly ash and silica fume. Chemical analysis, compressive strength measurements and durability tests were carried out to investigate the effect of ground glass on strength and durability performances of mortars. Blended both with Portland cement and lime, ground glass improved strength, resistance to chloride penetration and resistance to sulphate attack of mortars more than natural pozzolana and similarly to fly ash. Mortars with ground glass immersed in water for seven years did not show any sign of degradation and increased their compressive strength. The ranking of ground glass with respect to the other mineral additions was not affected by fineness.     

Heat deformations of fly ash concrete

When dealing with concrete resistance to high temperatures it is important for design purposes to know the elastic parameters, such as the temperature–strain curves and the modulus of elasticity.Concretes containing a high volume of fly ash differ from conventional mixes in the cementitious phase. This results in a different behaviour under heating compared to plain Portland cement concretes. To find the elastic response of fly ash concrete four series of concrete mixtures were manufactured: one with cement only, another with 30% by mass partial replacement of cement by fly ash, and two with 30% and 40% by mass replacement of cement by ground fly ash. Tests were carried out on cylinders (150 × 300 mm). A high-calcium fly ash was used.The conditions were selected so that the applied level of stress corresponded to 25% or to 40% of the ultimate compressive strength of concrete, and a transient type of temperature regime was followed. Based on the experiments the critical temperature, the residual deformation and the modulus of elasticity were determined.The results indicate that concretes containing a high volume of fly ash are more sensitive to high temperatures, since they developed greater deformations. The fineness of the fly ash used also seems to influence the degree of deformation in an adverse way.     

Portland cement-fly ash-silica fume systems in concrete

Laboratory flow, strength, and ultrasnic pulse velocity tests were performed on mortars made with 70% (by weight) of portland cement and 30% of pozzolanic materials where the pozzolanic materials consisted of various combinations of fly ash and silica fume. In addition to these ternary systems, binary blends, such as Portland cement and fly ash, and Portland cement and silica fume, along with 100% Portland cement mortars, were investigated for comparison. The purpose of the investigation, preliminary in nature, was to see under what circumstances, if any, would be a synergistic action when a ternary system of Portland cement-fly ash-silica fume is used in a mortar or concrete.Mortars were made with two cements of type I and two cements of type III along with class F and class C fly ashes. One silica fume was used. Standard flow tests were performed on the fresh mortars, and compressive strength as well as ultrasonic pulse velocity tests were performed with each hardened mortar at various ages up to 28 days. It is expected that the results and conclusions obtained here on mortars will be transferable to concretes.There are several novel, or at least lesser known, results of the investigation. For instance, a new explanation is offered for the plasticizing effect of fly ash which is based on the optimum particle-size distribution concept. Another such result is that ground fly ash produced greater flow increases with type I cement than with type III. A third finding is that the superplasticizer is more effective in increasing the flow as well as strength when the mortars contain fly ash and/or silica fume than in the case of mortars without mineral admixture. Also, it appears that when type I cement is used, the silica fume in the quantity of 5% of the weight of the cement produces relatively greater strength increase in the presence of fly ash than without fly ash.These promising results are preliminary in nature. Therefore, further research is justified with ternary systems in concrete. The presented work is a portion of a larger investigation.     

Mechanical and durability properties of ternary concretes containing silica fume and low reactivity blast furnace slag

In this study, the effect of incorporation of silica fume in enhancing strength development rate and durability characteristics of binary concretes containing a low reactivity slag has been investigated. Binary concretes studied included mixes containing slag at cement replacement levels of 15%, 30% and 50% and mixes containing silica fume at cement replacement levels of 2.5%, 5%, 7.5% and 10%. Ternary concretes included combinations of silica fume and slag at various cement replacement levels. The w/b ratio and total cementitious materials content were kept constant for all mixes at 0.38 and 420 kg/m³ respectively. Concrete mixes were evaluated for compressive strength, electrical resistance, chloride permeability (ASTM C1202 RCPT test) and chloride migration (AASHTO TP64 RCMT test), at various ages up to 180 days.The results show that simultaneous use of silica fume has only a moderate effect in improving the slow rate of strength gain of binary mixes containing low reactivity slag. However it improves their durability considerably. Using appropriate combination of low reactivity slag and silica fume, it is possible to obtain ternary mixes with 28 day strength comparable to the control mix and improve durability particularly in the long term. Ternary mixes also have the added advantage of reduced water demand.     

Transport properties of high volume fly ash roller compacted concrete

This paper describes research on the transport properties of high-volume fly ash roller compacted concrete (RCC). The mixes were developed through incorporating 50–260 kg/m³ cement and high volumes of fly ash ranging from 40% to 85% by mass of the total cementitious material. The concretes were investigated for permeability, absorption, sorption and chloride diffusion. The study showed that RCCs of moderate cement and moderate fly ash contents had lower values of permeability, absorption, sorption and chloride diffusivity.