Experimental validation of a pilot membrane reactor for hydrogen production by solar steam reforming of methane at maximum 550 °C using molten salts as heat transfer fluid

An innovative steam reformer for hydrogen production at temperatures lower than 550 °C has been developed in the EU project CoMETHy (Compact Multifuel-Energy To Hydrogen converter). The steam reforming process has been specifically tailored and re-designed to be combined with Concentrating Solar plants using “solar salts”: a low-temperature steam reforming reactor was developed, operating at temperatures up to 550 °C, much lower than the traditional process (usually > 850 °C). This result was obtained after extensive research, going from the development of basic components (catalysts and membranes) to their integration in an innovative membrane reformer heated with molten salts, where both hydrogen production and purification occur in a single stage. The reduction of process temperatures is achieved by applying advanced catalyst systems and hydrogen selective Pd-based membranes. Process heat is supplied by using a low-cost and environmentally friendly binary NaNO₃/KNO₃ liquid mixture (60/40 w/w) as heat transfer fluid; such mixture is commonly used for the same purpose in the concentrating solar industry, so that the process can easily be coupled with concentrating solar power (CSP) plants for the supply of renewable process heat. This paper deals with the successful operation and validation of a pilot scale reactor with a nominal capacity of 2 Nm³/h of pure hydrogen from methane. The plant was operated with molten salt circulation for about 700 h, while continuous operation of the reactor was achieved for about 150 h with several switches of operating conditions such as molten salts inlet temperature, sweep steam flow rate and steam-to-carbon feed ratio. The results obtained show that the membrane reformer allows to achieve twice as high a conversion compared to a conventional reformer operating at thermodynamic equilibrium under the same conditions considered in this paper. A highly pure hydrogen permeate stream was obtained (>99.8%), while the outlet retentate stream had low CO concentration (<2%). No macroscopic signs of reactor performance loss were observed over the experimental operation period.     

Fabrication & performance study of a palladium on alumina supported membrane reactor: Natural gas steam reforming,a case study

In this work, a synthetic mixture of natural gas is considered in a steam reforming process for generating hydrogen by using a membrane reactor housing a composite membrane constituted of a Pd-layer (13 μm) supported on alumina. The Pd/Al₂O₃ membrane separates part of the produced hydrogen through its selective permeation, although it shows a relatively low H₂/N₂ ideal selectivity (>200 at 0.5 bar of trans-membrane pressure and T = 425 °C).The steam reforming reaction is performed at 420 °C, by varying the gas hourly space velocity between 4400 h^?1 and 6900 h^?1 and by using two different mixtures containing some common impurities found within natural gas pipeline. Specifically, the effect of N₂ and CO₂ as impurities in the feed line is analyzed. The reaction pressure and steam-to-carbon ratio (S/C) are kept constant at 3.0 bar (abs.) and 3.5/1, respectively.The best performance of the Pd-based membrane reactor is obtained at 420 °C, 3.0 bar and 100 mL/min of sweep-gas, yielding a methane conversion of 55% and hydrogen recovery >90%.     

Oxidative steam reforming of ethanol over a Pt/Al2O3 catalyst in a Pd-based membrane reactor

In this study, the ability of a Pd-Ag membrane reactor of producing ultrapure hydrogen via oxidative steam reforming of ethanol has been evaluated. A self supported Pd-Ag tube of wall thickness 60 μm has been filled with a commercial Pt-based catalyst and assembled into a membrane module in a finger-like configuration. In order to evaluate the hydrogen yield behavior under different operating conditions, experimental tests have been performed at temperatures of 400 and 450 °C and pressures of 150 and 200 kPa. The oxidative steam reforming of ethanol has been carried out by feeding the membrane reactor with a gas stream containing a dilute water-ethanol mixture and air. Different water/ethanol feed flow rates (5, 10, 15 g h⁻¹), several water/ethanol (4, 10, 13) and oxygen/ethanol (0.3, 0.5, 0.7) feed molar ratios have been tested. The results pointed out that the highest hydrogen yield (moles of permeated hydrogen per mole of ethanol fed) corresponding to almost 4.1 has been attained at 450 °C and 200 kPa of lumen pressure by using a water/ethanol/oxygen feed molar ratio of 10/1/0.5.The results of these tests have been compared with those reported for the ethanol steam reforming in a Pd-Ag membrane reactor filled with the same Pt-based catalyst. This comparison has shown a positive effect on the hydrogen yield of small oxygen addition in the feed stream.     

H2 production by low pressure methane steam reforming in a Pd–Ag membrane reactor over a Ni-based catalyst: Experimental and modeling

Nowadays, there is a growing interest towards pure hydrogen production for proton exchange membrane fuel cell applications. Methane steam reforming reaction is one of the most important industrial chemical processes for hydrogen production. This reaction is usually carried out in fixed bed reactors at 30–40 bar and at temperatures above 850 °C. In this work, a dense Pd–Ag membrane reactor packed with a Ni-based catalyst was used to carry out the methane steam reforming reaction between 400 and 500 °C and at relatively low pressure (1.0–3.0 bar) with the aim of obtaining higher methane conversion and hydrogen yield than a fixed bed reactor, operated at the same conditions. Furthermore, the Pd–Ag membrane reactor is able to produce a pure, or at least, a CO and CO₂ free hydrogen stream. A 50% methane conversion was experimentally achieved in the membrane reactor at 450 °C and 3.0 bar whereas, at the same conditions, the fixed bed reactor reached a 6% methane conversion. Moreover, 70% of high-purity hydrogen on total hydrogen produced was collected with the sweep-gas in the permeate stream of the membrane reactor. From a modeling point of view, the mathematical model realized for the simulation of both the membrane and fixed bed reactors was satisfactorily validated with the experimental results obtained in this work.     

Study on a catalytic membrane reactor for hydrogen production from ethanol steam reforming

Ethanol steam reforming in a membrane reactor with catalytic membranes was investigated to achieve important aims in one process, such as improvement in ethanol conversion and hydrogen yield, high hydrogen recovery and CO reduction. In order to confirm the efficiency of reaction and CO reduction, an ethanol reforming-catalytic membrane reactor with water–gas shift reaction (ECRW) in the permeate side was compared with a conventional reactor (CR) and an ethanol reforming-catalytic membrane reactor (ECR). In comparison with the CR, ethanol conversion improvement of 11.9–19% and high hydrogen recovery of 78–87% were observed in the temperature range of 300–600 °C in the ECRW. Compared with CR and ECR, the hydrogen yield of ECRW increased up to 38% and 30%, respectively. Particularly, the ECRW showed higher hydrogen yield at high temperature, because Pt/Degussa P25 loaded in the permeate side showed catalytic activity for the methane steam reforming as well as WGS reaction. Moreover, CO concentration was reduced under 1% by the WGS reaction in the permeate side in the temperature range of 300–500 °C.     

Steam reforming of propane in a fluidized bed membrane reactor for hydrogen production

Steam reforming of propane was carried out in a fluidized bed membrane reactor to investigate a feedstock other than natural gas for production of pure hydrogen. Close to equilibrium conditions were achieved inside the reactor with fluidized catalyst due to the very fast steam reforming reactions. Use of hydrogen permselective Pd₇₇Ag₂₃ membrane panels to extract pure hydrogen shifted the reaction towards complete conversion of the hydrocarbons, including methane, the key intermediate product. Irreversible propane steam reforming is limited by the reversibility of the steam reforming of this methane. To assess the performance improvement due to pure hydrogen withdrawal, experiments were conducted with one and six membrane panels installed along the height of the reactor. The results indicate that a compact reformer can be achieved for pure hydrogen production for a light hydrocarbon feedstock like propane, at moderate operating temperatures of 475–550 °C, with increased hydrogen yield.     

Dry reforming of methane has no future for hydrogen production: Comparison with steam reforming at high pressure in standard and membrane reactors

The methane dry-reforming and steam reforming reactions were studied as a function of pressure (1–20 atm) at 973 K in conventional packed-bed reactors and a membrane reactors. For the dry-reforming reaction in a conventional reactor the production yield of hydrogen rose and then decreased with increasing pressure as a result of the reverse water-gas shift reaction in which the hydrogen reacted with the reactant CO₂ to produce water. For the steam reforming reaction the production yield of hydrogen kept increasing with pressure because the forward water-gas shift reaction produced additional hydrogen by the reaction of CO with water. In the membrane reactors the methane conversion and the hydrogen production yields were higher for both the dry-reforming and steam reforming reactions, but for the dry reforming at high pressure half of the hydrogen was transformed into water. Thus, the dry-reforming reaction is not practical for producing hydrogen.     

Methane steam reforming in a Pd-Ag membrane reformer: An experimental study on reaction pressure influence at middle temperature

In this experimental work, methane steam reforming (MSR) reaction is performed in a dense Pd-Ag membrane reactor and the influence of pressure on methane conversion, CO_x-free hydrogen recovery and CO_x-free hydrogen production is investigated. The reaction is conducted at 450 °C by supplying nitrogen as a sweep gas in co-current flow configuration with respect to the reactants. Three experimental campaigns are realized in the MR packed with Ni-ZrO catalyst, which showed better performances than Ni-Al₂O₃ used in a previous paper dealing with the same MR system. The first one is directed to keep constant the total pressure in both retentate and permeate sides of the membrane reactor. In the second case study, the total retentate pressure is kept constant at 9.0 bar, while the total permeate pressure is varied between 5.0 and 9.0 bar. As the best result of this work, at 450 °C and 4.0 bar of total pressure difference between retentate and permeate sides, around 65% methane conversion and 1.2 l/h of CO_x-free hydrogen are reached, further recovering 80% CO_x-free hydrogen over the total hydrogen produced during the reaction. Moreover, a study on the influence of hydrogen-rich gas mixtures on the hydrogen permeation through the Pd-Ag membrane is also performed and discussed.     

Methane membrane steam reforming: Heat duty assessment

Membrane reactors are an innovative technology with huge application potentialities for equilibrium limited endothermic reactions. Assembling a membrane selective to a reaction product avoids the equilibrium conditions to be achieved, supporting the reactions at lower operating temperatures. Taking as an example the natural gas steam reforming, a methane conversion around 98% can be reached imposing an operating temperature of 823 K, much lower than that of the traditional process. In the present paper, a stringent analysis of heat power requirement needed to carry out the natural gas steam reforming process by applying a membrane reactor is made. The simulations allows to understand how the main operating parameters (inlet temperature, inlet methane flow-rate, steam to carbon ratio, ratio between sweeping steam and inlet methane, operating reaction pressure) influence the total heat power required by the process, divided among power contributions for the reaction heat duty, reactant steam and permeation steam generation and preheating. Moreover, the specific thermal energy per mole of pure H₂ is computed and assessed. Optimizing the operating conditions set, a specific thermal energy per mole of pure hydrogen of 92.3 kWh kmol⁻¹ is obtained corresponding to a total thermal power of 687.4 kW required to convert, in a single membrane reactor, a methane flow-rate of 2 kmol h⁻¹ (GHSV = 9.590 h⁻¹) with a conversion around 98%.     

The performance evaluation of an industrial membrane reformer with catalyst-deactivation for a domestic methanol production plant

Methane reforming is the most important and economical process for hydrogen and syngas generation. In this work, the dynamic simulation of methane steam reforming in an industrial membrane reformer for synthesis gas production is developed. A novel deactivation model for commercial Ni-based catalysts is proposed and the monthly collected data from an existing reformer in a domestic methanol plant is used to optimize the model parameters. The plant data is also employed to check the model accuracy. It was observed that the membrane reformer could compensate for the catalyst deactivating effect.In order to assure the long membrane lifetime and decrease the unit price, the membrane reformer with 5 μm thick Pd on stainless steel supports is modeled at the temperature below the maximum operating temperature of Pd based membranes (around 600 °C). The dynamic modeling showed that the methane conversion of 76% could be achieved at a moderate temperature of 600 °C for an industrial membrane reformer. The cost-effective generation of syngas with an appropriate H₂/CO ratio of 2.6 could be obtained by membrane reformer. This is while the conventional reformer exhibits a maximum conversation of 64 at 1200 °C challenging due to its high syngas ratio (3.7). On the other hand, the pure hydrogen from membrane reformer can supply part of the ammonia reactor feed in an adjacent ammonia plant.     

Methanol steam reforming over PdZn/ZnAl2O4/Al2O3 in a catalytic membrane reactor: An experimental and modelling study

A catalytic membrane reactor equipped with Pd–Ag metallic membranes and loaded with PdZn/ZnAl₂O₄/Al₂O₃ catalytic pellets was tested for the methanol steam reforming reaction (S/C = 1) aimed at producing a pure hydrogen stream for PEM fuel cell feeding. The catalyst was prepared in two steps. First, commercial γ-Al₂O₃ pellets were impregnated with ZnCl₂ and calcined at 700 °C to obtain a ZnAl₂O₄ shell, and subsequently impregnated with PdCl₂ and reduced at 600 °C to obtain PdZn alloy nanoparticles. The catalyst was tested both in a conventional packed bed reactor and in a catalytic membrane reactor. A 3D CFD non-isothermal model with mass transfer limitations was developed and validated with experimental data. The reactions of methanol steam reforming, reverse water-gas shift and methanation were modeled under different pressure, temperature and feed load values. The model was used to study and simulate the CMR under different operation conditions.     

Numerical and experimental study on hydrogen production via dimethyl ether steam reforming

This work presents the characteristics of catalytic dimethyl ether (DME)/steam reforming based on a Cu–Zn/γ-Al₂O₃ catalyst for hydrogen production. A kinetic model for a reformer that operates at low temperature (200 °C–500 °C) is simulated using COMSOL 5.2 software. Experimental verification is performed to examine the critical parameters for the reforming process. During the experiment, superior Cu–Zn/γ-Al₂O₃catalysts are manufactured using the sol-gel method, and ceramic honeycombs coated with this catalyst (1.77 g on each honeycomb, five honeycombs in the reactor) are utilized as catalyst bed in the reformer to enhance performance. The steam, DME mass ratio is stabilized at 3:1 using a mass flow controller (MFC) and a generator. The hydrogen production rate can be significantly affected depending on the reactant's mass flow rate and temperature. And the maximum hydrogen yield can reach 90% at 400 °C. Maximum 8% error for the hydrogen yield is achieved between modeling and experimental results. These experiments can be further explored for directly feeding hydrogen to proton exchange membrane fuel cell (PEMFC) under the load variations.     

Enhancement of pure hydrogen production through the use of a membrane reactor

Pure hydrogen production is of great interest as it is an energy carrier which can be used in PEM fuel cells for power production. Methane Steam Reforming (MSR) is commonly used for hydrogen production although the produced hydrogen is not free of other components. Membrane Reactors (MR) enable a pure hydrogen product stream and allows the reaction to take place at significantly lower temperatures (lower than 550 °C) than in conventional reactors (greater than 800 °C) with comparable methane conversion. This is achieved by hydrogen removal through a permselective Pd–Ag based membrane that cause a favorable shift in chemical equilibrium towards hydrogen production. In the present study, a two-dimensional, nonlinear, and pseudo-homogeneous mathematical model of a catalytic fixed-bed membrane reactor for methane steam reforming over a nickel-based foam supported catalyst is presented. Simulated results referring to the distribution of species, methane conversion, temperature and hydrogen flowrate along the reactor for different radial positions are obtained and analyzed. The performance of structured catalyst and catalyst supported on foam configurations under the same operating conditions is also studied. Experimental results for the membrane facilitate the identification of suitable operating conditions.     

Optimization of two bio-oil steam reforming processes for hydrogen production based on thermodynamic analysis

Thermodynamics of hydrogen production from conventional steam reforming (C-SR) and sorption-enhanced steam reforming (SE-SR) of bio-oil was performed under different conditions including reforming temperature, S/C ratio (the mole ratio of steam to carbon in the bio-oil), operating pressure and CaO/C ratio (the mole ratio of CaO to carbon in the bio-oil). Increasing temperature and S/C ratio, and decreasing the operating pressure were favorable to improve the hydrogen yield. Compared to C-SR, SE-SR had the significant advantage of higher hydrogen yield at lower desirable temperature, and showed a significant suppression for carbon formation. However excess CaO (CaO/C > 1) almost had no additional contribution to hydrogen production. Aimed to achieve the maximum utilization of bio-oil with as little energy consumption as possible, the influences of temperature and S/C ratio on the reforming performance (energy requirements and bio-oil consumption per unit volume of hydrogen produced, Q_D/H2 (kJ/Nm³) and Y_Bio-oil/H2 (kg/Nm³)) were comprehensively evaluated using matrix analysis while ensuring the highest hydrogen yield as possible. The optimal operating parameters were confirmed at 650 °C, S/C = 2 for C-SR; and 550 °C, S/C = 2 for SE-SR. Under their respective optimal conditions, the Y_Bio-oil/H2 of SE-SR is significant decreased, by 18.50% compared to that of C-SR, although the Q_D/H2 was slightly increased, just by 7.55%.     

Membrane reformer module with Ni-foam catalyst for pure hydrogen production from methane: Experimental demonstration and modeling

Results of experiments and modeling of a compact (800 cm³) membrane reformer module for the production of 0.25–0.30 Nm³/h hydrogen by methane steam reforming are reported. The module consists of a two-sided composite membrane disc with a 50 μm PdAg layer and two adjacent 4 mm thick Ni foam discs (60 ppi). A nickel catalyst and a porous support were deposited on the foam discs to give the final composition of 10%Ni/10%MgO/Ni-foam. Membrane permeability by pure hydrogen was investigated, and coefficients of transverse hydrogen transport across the Ni foam to the membrane in the case of inlet binary N₂H₂ mixture were refined in order to account for concentration polarization effect into the model. Activity of the catalytic discs was measured in a differential laboratory scale reactor at a pressure of 1 bar and temperature of 400–600 °C. Modules were tested at a 8–13 bar pressure of the mixture in the reforming zone and at 1 bar of pure hydrogen under the membrane, H₂O/C = 2.5–3 and a module temperature of 550–680 °C (with and without hydrogen removal). Two modifications of the module were tested: consecutive (I-type) and parallel (II-type) flow of the reaction mixture around two sides of the membrane disc. In order to optimize construction of the module, calculations were made for revealing the effect of thickness of the PdAg membrane layer (5–50 μm), thickness of the Ni foam discs (0.5–8 mm) and temperature (600–700 °C) on the hydrogen output of the module. A comparison of the values obtained in our experiments (>1 MW/m³ and >0.7 kg(H₂)/h/m²) with the literature data reported by other authors showed that the developed modules are promising for practical application as components of a fuel processor section for mobile applications.     

Design and operational considerations of packed-bed membrane reactor for distributed hydrogen production by methane steam reforming

Methane steam reforming will still account for most of hydrogen production in the coming decades. Membrane reactor can play a key role in both energy saving and process/equipment compactness, particularly for its decentralized applications. Here we design a particles-based packed-bed membrane reactor and explore the operational window and design challenges by conducting systematic study experimentally and computationally, particularly emphasizing geometrical scale of membrane reactor and catalyst activity. The results show that membrane reactor presents maximum hydrogen flux by consuming unit methane under the optimized operation conditions of GHSV (i.e., 1134 hr^?1) and steam-to-carbon ratio (i.e., 2), and computational study shows that optimal operation window is around 30 atm and 773.15 K. Moreover, the design criteria of “Catalyst activity – Membrane performance – Radial depth” is revealed quantitatively and catalyst activity is identified as the key limiting factor for further process intensification. Briefly, these results shed some lights on operation, optimal design, and further improvement of membrane reactor in methane steam reforming.     

Application of aspen plus to renewable hydrogen production from glycerol by steam reforming

Steam reforming is the most favored method for the production of hydrogen. Hydrogen is mostly manufactured by using steam reforming of natural gas. Due to the negative environmental impact and energy politics, alternative hydrogen production methods are being explored. Glycerol is one of the bio-based alternative feedstock for hydrogen production. This study is aimed to simulate hydrogen production from glycerol by using Aspen Plus. First of all, the convenient reactor type was determined. RPlug reactor exhibited the highest performance for the hydrogen production. A thermodynamic model was determined according to the formation of byproduct. The reaction temperature, water/glycerol molar feed ratio as reaction parameters and reactor pressure were investigated on the conversion of glycerol and yield of hydrogen. Optimum reaction parameters are determined as 500 °C of reaction temperature, 9:1 of water to glycerol ratio and 1 atm of pressure. Reactor design was also examined. Optimum reactor diameter and reactor length values were determined as 5 m and 50 m, respectively. Hydrogen purification was studied and 99.9% purity of H₂was obtained at 25 bar and 40 °C. The obtained results were shown that Aspen Plus has been successfully applied to investigate the effects of reaction parameters and reactor sizing for hydrogen production from glycerol steam reforming.     

Methanol steam reforming reaction in a Pd–Ag membrane reactor for CO-free hydrogen production

A dense tubular Pd–Ag membrane reactor was used to carry out the methanol steam reforming reaction for producing a CO-free hydrogen stream. A Cu/Zn/Mg-based catalyst was packed in the lumen side of the membrane reactor and the experimental tests were performed at a reaction temperature of 300 °C and at a H₂O/methanol feed molar ratio of 3/1. The effects of the different flow configurations, as well as the sweep factor and the reaction pressure were analysed. Experimental results in terms of CO-free hydrogen recovery, hydrogen yield, CO-free hydrogen yield and hydrogen selectivity are presented. Moreover, a comparison between the performances of the membrane reactor and a traditional reactor working at the same operative conditions is proposed and discussed.     

Hydrogen-rich syngas production and carbon dioxide formation using aqueous urea solution in biogas steam reforming by thermodynamic analysis

Biogas is a renewable biofuel that contains a lot of CH₄ and CO₂. Biogas can be used to produce heat and electric power while reducing CH₄, one of greenhouse gas emissions. As a result, it has been getting increasing academic attention. There are some application ways of biogas; biogas can produce hydrogen to feed a fuel cell by reforming process. Urea is also a hydrogen carrier and could produce hydrogen by steam reforming. This study then employes steam reforming of biogas and compares hydrogen-rich syngas production and carbon dioxide with various methane concentrations using steam and aqueous urea solution (AUS) by Thermodynamic analysis. The results show that the utilization of AUS as a replacement for steam enriches the production of H₂ and CO and has a slight CO₂ rise compared with pure biogas steam reforming at a temperature higher than 800 °C. However, CO₂ formation is less than the initial CO₂ in biogas. At the reaction temperature of 700 °C, carbon formation does not occur in the reforming process for steam/biogas ratios higher than 2. These conditions led to the highest H₂, CO production, and reforming efficiency (about 125%). The results can be used as operation data for systems that combine biogas reforming and applied to solid oxide fuel cell (SOFC), which usually operates between 700 °C to 900 °C to generate electric power in the future.     

Methane steam reforming using a membrane reactor equipped with a Pd-based composite membrane for effective hydrogen production

Herein, a methane steam reforming (MSR) reaction was carried out using a Pd composite membrane reactor packed with a commercial Ru/Al₂O₃ catalyst under mild operating conditions, to produce hydrogen with CO₂ capture. The Pd composite membrane was fabricated on a tubular stainless steel support by the electroless plating (ELP) method. The membrane exhibited a hydrogen permeance of 2.26 × 10^?3 mol m² s^?1 Pa^?0.5, H₂/N₂ selectivity of 145 at 773 K, and pressure difference of 20.3 kPa. The MSR reaction, which was carried out at steam to carbon ratio (S/C) = 3.0, gas hourly space velocity (GHSV) = 1700 h^?1, and 773 K, showed that methane conversion increased with the pressure difference and reached 79.5% at ΔP = 506 kPa. This value was ～1.9 time higher than the equilibrium value at 773 K and 101 kPa. Comparing with the previous studies which introduced sweeping gas for low hydrogen partial pressure in the permeate stream, very high pressure difference (2500–2900 kPa) for increase of hydrogen recovery and very low GHSV (<150) for increase hydraulic retention time (HRT), our result was worthy of notice. The gas composition monitored during the long-term stability test showed that the permeate side was composed of 97.8 vol% H₂, and the retentate side contained 67.8 vol% CO₂ with 22.2 vol% CH₄. When energy was recovered by CH₄ combustion in the retentate streams, pre-combustion carbon capture was accomplished using the Pd-based composite membrane reactor.