Techno-economic assessment of solar steam reforming of methane in a membrane reactor using molten salts as heat transfer fluid

This paper reports the results obtained in a techno-economic analysis of the Steam Methane Reforming (SMR) technology aided with solar heat, developed and demonstrated in the European FCH JU project CoMETHy: a compact membrane reformer heated with molten salt up to 550 °C allowed to simultaneously carry out methane steam reforming, water-gas-shift reaction and hydrogen separation. This reactor can be integrated with new generation Concentrating Solar Thermal (CST) systems to supply the process heat. Experimental validation of the technology has been successfully achieved in a pilot scale plant and the results recently published. In this paper, we introduce a fully-integrated scheme and operation strategies of a plant on the 1500 Nm³/h hydrogen production scale. Then, techno-economic analysis of this new solar-driven process is presented to evaluate its competitiveness. Considering a plant capacity of 1500 Nm³/h (pure hydrogen production) and today's costs for the methane feed and the CST technology, obtained Hydrogen Production Cost (HPC) are in the range of 2.8–3.3 €/kg for a “solar-hybrid” system with high capacity factor (8000 h/year operation) and 4.7 €/kg for a “solar-only” case, while HPC≅1.7 €/kg can be obtained with the conventional route under equivalent assumptions. However, a sensitivity analysis shows that the expected drop of the cost of the CST technology will bring the HPC around 2.4 €/kg for the “solar-hybrid” case and close to 3.4 €/kg for the “solar-only” case, thus making the cost of solar reforming closer to conventional SMR with CO₂ capture and with wind/solar electrolysis in the future. In the “solar-hybrid” case total CO₂ production can be reduced by 13–29% with 58–70% of produced CO₂ recovered as pure stream (at 1.3 bar); in the “solar-only” case total CO₂ production can be reduced by 52% and 100% of produced CO₂ recovered as pure stream (at 1.3 bar). However, compared to the conventional route, CO₂ avoidance costs are still relatively high (≥137 €/ton_CO2) and process optimization measures required. Therefore, optimization measures have been outlined to increase the overall process efficiency and further reduce the HPC.     

Exergy analysis of hydrogen production via steam methane reforming

The performance of hydrogen production via steam methane reforming (SMR) is evaluated using exergy analysis, with emphasis on exergy flows, destruction, waste, and efficiencies. A steam methane reformer model was developed using a chemical equilibrium model with detailed heat integration. A base-case system was evaluated using operating parameters from published literature. Reformer operating parameters were varied to illustrate their influence on system performance. The calculated thermal and exergy efficiencies of the base-case system are lower than those reported in literature. The majority of the exergy destruction occurs due to the high irreversibility of chemical reactions and heat transfer. A significant amount of exergy is wasted in the exhaust stream. The variation of reformer operating parameters illustrated an inverse relationship between hydrogen yield and the amount of methane required by the system. The results of this investigation demonstrate the utility of exergy analysis and provide guidance for where research and development in hydrogen production via SMR should be focused.     

Solar steam reforming for enriched methane production: Reactor configurations modeling and comparison

A solar low-temperature steam reforming process for the production of an Enriched Methane (EM) mixture composed by CH₄ and H₂ (20%vol) exploiting the solar energy stored in a Molten Salt stream heated up by a Concentrating Solar Plant (MS-CSP) is presented and simulated through a two-dimensional steam reforming reactor model.     

Hydrogen production by steam methane reforming in a membrane reactor equipped with a Pd composite membrane deposited on a porous stainless steel

With the aim of producing hydrogen at low cost and with a high conversion efficiency, steam methane reforming (SMR) was carried out under moderate operating conditions in a Pd-based composite membrane reactor packed with a commercial Ru/Al₂O₃ catalyst. A Pd-based composite membrane with a thickness of 4–5 μm was prepared on a tubular stainless steel support (diameter of 12.7 mm, length of 450 mm) using electroless plating (ELP). The Pd-based composite membrane had a hydrogen permeance of 2.4 × 10^?3 mol m^?1 s^?1 Pa^?0.5 and an H₂/N₂ selectivity of 618 at a temperature of 823 K and a pressure difference of 10.1 kPa. The SMR test was conducted at 823 K with a steam-to-carbon ratio of 3.0 and gas hourly space velocity of 1000 h^?1; increasing the pressure difference resulted in enhanced methane conversion, which reached 82% at a pressure difference of 912 kPa. To propose a guideline for membrane design, a process simulation was conducted for conversion enhancement as a function of pressure difference using Aspen HYSYS^®. A stability test for SMR was conducted for ～120 h; the methane conversion, hydrogen production rate, and gas composition were monitored. During the SMR test, the carbon monoxide concentration in the total reformed stream was <1%, indicating that a series of water gas shift reactors was not needed in our membrane reactor system.     

Hydrogen production by coupled catalytic partial oxidation and steam methane reforming at elevated pressure and temperature

Hydrogen production by coupled catalytic partial oxidation (CPO) and steam methane reforming of methane (OSMR) at industrial conditions (high temperatures and pressures) have been studied over supported 1 wt.% NiB catalysts. Mixture of air/CH₄/H₂O was applied as the feed. The effects of O₂:CH₄ ratio, H₂O:CH₄ ratio and the gas hourly space velocity (GHSV) on oxy-steam reforming (OSRM) were also studied. Results indicate that CH₄ conversion increases significantly with increasing O₂:CH₄ or H₂O:CH₄ ratio. However, the hydrogen mole fraction goes through a maximum, depending on reaction conditions, e.g., pressure, temperature and the feed gases ratios. Carbon deposition on the catalysts has been greatly decreased after steam addition. The supported 1 wt.% NiB catalysts exhibit high stability with 85% methane conversion at 15 bar and 800 °C during 70 h time-on-stream reaction (CH₄:O₂:H₂O:N₂ = 1:0.5:1:1.887). The thermal efficiency was increased from 35.8% by CPO (without steam) to 55.6%. The presented data would be useful references for further design of enlarged scale hydrogen production system.     

Production of enriched methane by a molten-salt concentrated solar power plant coupled with a steam reforming process: An LCA study

Enriched Methane is a gas mixture consisting of methane and a certain amount of hydrogen (10–30%vol) that finds out several applications such as fuel of Internal Combustion Engines (ICEs). To produce EM, a steam reforming reactor whose heat duty is supplied by a molten-salt stream heated up by a concentrating solar power (CSP) plant can be used, in order to generate the hydrogen steam by solar energy. In fact, molten salts at temperatures up to 550 °C can allow to reach the necessary thermal level inside the reactor to promote steam reforming reaction.     

Assessment of CO2 capture options from various points in steam methane reforming for hydrogen production

Steam methane reforming (SMR) is currently the main hydrogen production process in industry, but it has high emissions of CO₂, at almost 7 kg CO₂/kg H₂ on average, and is responsible for about 3% of global industrial sector CO₂ emissions. Here, the results are reported of an investigation of the effect of steam-to-carbon ratio (S/C) on CO₂ capture criteria from various locations in the process, i.e. synthesis gas stream (location 1), pressure swing adsorber (PSA) tail gas (location 2), and furnace flue gases (location 3). The CO₂ capture criteria considered in this study are CO₂ partial pressure, CO₂ concentration, and CO₂ mass ratio compared to the final exhaust stream, which is furnace flue gases. The CO₂ capture number (N_cc) is proposed as measure of capture favourability, defined as the product of the three above capture criteria. A weighting of unity is used for each criterion. The best S/C ratio, in terms of providing better capture option, is determined. CO₂ removal from synthesis gas after the shift unit is found to be the best location for CO₂ capture due to its high partial pressure of CO₂. However, furnace flue gases, containing almost 50% of the CO₂ in produced in the process, are of great significance environmentally. Consequently, the effects of oxygen enrichment of the furnace feed are investigated, and it is found that this measure improves the CO₂ capture conditions for lower S/C ratios. Consequently, for an S/C ratio of 2.5, CO₂ capture from a flue gas stream is competitive with two other locations provided higher weighting factors are considered for the full presence of CO₂ in the flue gases stream. Considering carbon removal from flue gases, the ratio of hydrogen production rate and N_cc increases with rising reformer temperature.     

Preparation of Ni-based egg-shell-type catalyst on cylinder-shaped alumina pellets and its application for hydrogen production via steam methane reforming

Nickel-based ‘egg-shell-type’ catalysts were prepared using cylinder-shaped alumina pellets as supports. In the egg-shell-type catalysts, nickel was selectively located in the outer region of the alumina pellets. Ethylene glycol or 1-octanol were used as hydrophobic solvents to retard internal penetration of the alumina pellets by the nickel nitrate solution. Without hydrophobic solvent, a ‘homo-type’ catalyst with even nickel distribution inside the alumina pellets was achieved. Cross-sectional images and SEM-EDS analysis of the cylinder-shaped alumina pellets showed that nickel concentration in the egg-shell-type catalyst was higher in the outer region and decreased towards the inner region of the alumina pellets. The egg-shell-type nickel distribution was maintained after subsequent magnesium impregnation and calcination processes. X-ray diffraction patterns and temperature programmed reduction profiles showed that the only difference between homo-type and egg-shell type catalysts, when their nickel loading was the same, was the nickel distribution inside pellets; and this was shown to cause significant difference in their catalytic activity in the steam methane reforming (SMR) reaction. For the homo-type catalyst, nickel loading of 3.5 wt% was insufficient for the SMR reaction, as metallic nickel particles were evenly distributed through the entire alumina pellet. However, nickel loading of 3.5 wt% was sufficient for the egg-shell-type catalyst, because active sites with metallic nickel particles were concentrated in the outer region of the pellets. These experimental results confirmed that the egg-shell-type nickel distribution is a favorable design for an SMR reaction catalyst.     

Evaluation of the economic impact of hydrogen production by methane decomposition with steam reforming of methane process

There has been considerable interest in the development of more efficient processes to generate hydrogen. Currently, steam methane reforming (SMR) is the most widely applied route for producing hydrogen from natural gas. Researchers worldwide have been working to invent more efficient routes to produce hydrogen. One of the routes is thermocatalytic decomposition of methane (TCDM) - a process that decomposes methane thermally to produce hydrogen from natural gas. TCDM has not yet been commercialized. However, the aim of this work was to conduct an economic and environmental analysis to determine whether the TCDM process is competitive with the more popular SMR process. The results indicate that the TCDM process has a lower carbon footprint. Further research on TCDM catalysts could make this process economically competitive with steam methane reforming.     

Hydrogen production by steam reforming of bio-oil/bio-ethanol mixtures in a continuous thermal-catalytic process

The feasibility of the steam reforming of bio-oil aqueous fraction and bio-ethanol mixtures has been studied in a continuous process with two in-line steps: thermal step at 300 °C (for the controlled deposition of pyrolytic lignin during the heating of the bio-oil/bio-ethanol feed) followed by steam reforming in a fluidized bed reactor on a Ni/α-Al₂O₃ catalyst. The effect of bio-ethanol content in the feed has been analyzed in both the thermal and reforming steps, and the suitable range of operating conditions (temperature and space-time) has been determined for obtaining a high and steady hydrogen yield. Higher ethanol content in the mixture feed improves the reaction indices and reduces coke deposition. Operating conditions of 700 °C and space-times higher than 0.23 g_catalyst h (g_bio-oil+EtOH)⁻¹ are suitable for attaining almost fully conversion of oxygenates (bio-oil and ethanol) and hydrogen yields above 93%, with low catalyst deactivation.     

Exergoenvironmental analysis of a steam methane reforming process for hydrogen production

Steam methane reforming (SMR) is one of the most promising processes for hydrogen production. Several studies have demonstrated its advantages from the economic viewpoint. Nowadays process development is based on technical and economical aspects; however, in the near future, the environmental impact will play a significant role in the design of such processes. In this paper, an SMR process is studied from the viewpoint of overall environmental impact, using an exergoenvironmental analysis. This analysis presents the combination of exergy analysis and life cycle assessment. Components where chemical reactions occur are the most important plant components from the exergoenvironmental point of view, because, in general, there is a high environmental impact associated with these components. This is mainly caused by the exergy destruction within the components, and this in turn is mainly due to the chemical reactions. The obtained results show that the largest potential for reducing the overall environmental impact is associated with the combustion reactor, the steam reformer, the hydrogen separation unit and the major heat exchangers. The environmental impact in these components can mainly be reduced by improving their exergetic efficiency. A sensitivity analysis for some important exergoenvironmental variables is also presented in the paper.     

Recent trends in the development of reactor systems for hydrogen production via methanol steam reforming

Hydrogen is currently receiving significant attention as an alternative energy resource, and among the various methods for producing hydrogen, methanol steam reforming (MSR) has attracted great attention because of its economy and practicality. Because the MSR reaction is inherently activated over catalytic materials, studies have focused on the development of noble metal-based catalysts and the improvement of existing catalysts with respect to performance and stability. However, less attention has been paid to the modification and development of innovative MSR reactors to improve their performance and efficiency. Therefore, in this review paper, we summarize the trends in the development of MSR reactor systems, including microreactors and membrane reactors, as well as the various structured catalyst materials appropriate for application in complex reactors. In addition, other engineering approaches to achieve highly efficient MSR reactors for the production of hydrogen are discussed.     

Integrated solar combined cycle system with steam methane reforming: Thermodynamic analysis

The present paper considers an integrated solar combined cycle system (ISCCS) with an utilization of solar energy for steam methane reforming. The overall efficiency was compared with the efficiency of an integrated solar combined cycle system with the utilization of solar energy for steam generation for a steam turbine cycle. Utilization of solar energy for steam methane reforming gives the increase in an overall efficiency up to 3.5%. If water that used for steam methane reforming will be condensed from the exhaust gases, the overall efficiency of ISCCS with steam methane reforming will increase up to 6.2% and 8.9% for β = 1.0 and β = 2.0, respectively, in comparison with ISCCS where solar energy is utilized for generation of steam in steam turbine cycle. The Sankey diagrams were compiled based on the energy balance. Utilization of solar energy for steam methane reforming increases the share of power of a gas turbine cycle: two-thirds are in a gas turbine cycle, and one-third is in a steam turbine cycle. In parallel, if solar energy is used for steam generation for a steam turbine cycle, than the shares of power from a gas and steam turbine are almost equal.     

Hydrogen production and carbon sequestration by steam methane reforming and fracking with carbon dioxide

An opportunity to sequester large amounts of carbon dioxide (CO₂) is made possible because hydraulic fracturing is used to produce most of America's natural gas. CO₂ could be extracted from natural gas and water using steam methane reforming, pressurized to its supercritical phase, and used instead of water to fracture additional hydrocarbon-bearing rock. The useful energy carrier that remains is hydrogen, with carbon returned to the ground. Research on the use of supercritical CO₂ is reviewed, with proppant entrainment identified as the major area where technical advances may be needed. The large potential for greenhouse-gas reduction through sequestration of CO₂ and avoidance of methane leakage from the natural gas system is quantified.     

Hydrogen production from ethanol steam reforming: energy efficiency analysis of traditional and membrane processes

The ethanol steam reforming reaction has been considered for producing pure hydrogen to be used for feeding a PEM fuel cell of power 4 kW. As an innovative technology, Pd–Ag thin wall membranes are proposed for building membrane reactors: accordingly, the energy efficiency analysis of the processes producing hydrogen from ethanol steam reforming has been carried out and, particularly, the comparison among a traditional process and different membrane processes is reported.     

Novel structured catalysts configuration for intensification of steam reforming of methane

Structured catalysts, using highly conductive carriers, can improve the heat transfer along the catalytic bed, affording high performance with a flattened radial temperature gradient. The effect of thermal conductivity of structured carriers on highly endothermic Steam Reforming reaction is investigated. The performance of the structured catalysts, obtained on Cordierite and Silicon Carbide (SiC) monoliths, demonstrates the direct correlation between the thermal conductivity of the carrier, the methane conversion and the hydrogen productivity. The evaluation of the monolith configuration shows that the SiC “wall flow” guarantees a better axial and radial thermal distribution, with respect to the SiC “flow through”, resulting in better catalytic activity up to a temperature reaction of 750 °C. The comparison among the performance of the structured catalysts and the commercial 57-4MQ, provided by Katalco-JM, highlights the choice of structured catalysts, which require a lower temperature outside of the reactor, increasing the process efficiency.     

Comparative exergy analysis of sorption enhanced and conventional methane steam reforming

Exergy efficiency analysis tool is used to evaluate sorption enhanced steam reforming in comparison with the industrial hydrogen production route, steam reforming. The study focuses on hydrogen production for use in high pressure processes. Thermodynamic sensitivity analysis (effect of reforming temperature on hydrogen yield and reforming enthalpy) was performed to indicate the optimum temperature (650 °C) for the sorption enhanced reforming. The pressure was selected to be, for both cases, 25 bar, a typical pressure used in the industrial (conventional) process. Atmospheric pressure, 1000 °C and CO₂ as inert gas were specified as the optimum operating parameters for the regeneration of the sorbent after performing exergy efficiency analysis of three realistic case scenarios. Aspen Plus simulation process schemes were built for conventional and sorption enhanced steam reforming processes to attain the mass and energy balances required to assess comparatively exergy analysis. Simulation results showed that sorption enhanced reforming can lead to a hydrogen purity increase by 17.3%, along with the recovery of pure and sequestration-ready carbon dioxide. The exergy benefit of sorption enhanced reforming was calculated equal to 3.2%. Analysis was extended by adding a CO₂ separation stage in conventional reforming to reach the hydrogen purity of sorption enhanced reforming and enable a more effective exergy efficiency comparison. Following that analysis, sorption enhanced reforming gained 10.8% in exergy efficiency.