Ingredients and pH are Key to Clear Beverages that Contain Whey Protein

ABSTRACT:  A challenge of shelf stable beverages that contain whey protein is that a small portion of protein can be denatured and aggregated during thermal processing, resulting in a turbid solution or white precipitate that consumers perceive as a defect. In this study, 3 approaches were taken to reduce turbidity in heat-treated beverages that contain whey protein: (1) centrifugation to remove insoluble protein aggregates, (2) addition of ingredients, and (3) alteration of pH in the range from 3.0 to 4.0. At pH 3.6 and below, all samples were essentially clear both before and after heating for all ingredients. At a pH of 3.8 and above, ingredient selection was crucial to solution clarity after heat treatment. At a pH of 4.0, addition of salts at both 10 and 50 mM increased the turbidity significantly compared to the control, which contained only whey protein in water. Neither addition of sugars at 25, 50, and 100 g/L, nor addition of sugar alcohols at 25 g/L significantly affected turbidity after heat treatment compared to the control. However, sugar alcohols added at 50 or 100 g/L significantly reduced turbidity after heat treatment compared to the control. Removal of insoluble protein aggregates by centrifugation prior to heat treatment resulted in a statistically significant decrease in turbidity after heat treatment. Understanding these results at the molecular level will assist food scientists in selecting processing treatments, ingredients, and pH in the development of shelf stable clear beverages that contain whey protein.     

Pilot-scale formation of whey protein aggregates determine the stability of heat-treated whey protein solutions—Effect of pH and protein concentration

Denaturation and consequent aggregation in whey protein solutions is critical to product functionality during processing. Solutions of whey protein isolate (WPI) prepared at 1, 4, 8, and 12% (wt/wt) and pH 6.2, 6.7, or 7.2 were subjected to heat treatment (85°C × 30 s) using a pilot-scale heat exchanger. The effects of heat treatment on whey protein denaturation and aggregation were determined by chromatography, particle size, turbidity, and rheological analyses. The influence of pH and WPI concentration during heat treatment on the thermal stability of the resulting dispersions was also investigated. Whey protein isolate solutions heated at pH 6.2 were more extensively denatured, had a greater proportion of insoluble aggregates, higher particle size and turbidity, and were significantly less heat-stable than equivalent samples prepared at pH 6.7 and 7.2. The effects of WPI concentration on denaturation/aggregation behavior were more apparent at higher pH where the stabilizing effects of charge repulsion became increasingly influential. Solutions containing 12% (wt/wt) WPI had significantly higher apparent viscosities, at each pH, compared with lower protein concentrations, with solutions prepared at pH 6.2 forming a gel. Smaller average particle size and a higher proportion of soluble aggregates in WPI solutions, pre-heated at pH 6.7 and 7.2, resulted in improved thermal stability on subsequent heating. Higher pH during secondary heating also increased thermal stability. This study offers insight into the interactive effects of pH and whey protein concentration during pilot-scale processing and demonstrates how protein functionality can be controlled through manipulation of these factors.     

Characterization of cold-set gels produced from heated emulsions stabilized by whey protein

This paper reports the cold gelation of preheated emulsions stabilized by whey protein, in contrast to, in previous reports, the cold gelation of emulsions formed with preheated whey protein polymers. Emulsions formed with different concentrations of whey protein isolate (WPI) and milk fat were heated at 90 °C for 30 min at low ionic strength and neutral pH. The stable preheated emulsions formed gels through acidification or the addition of CaCl₂ at room temperature. The storage modulus (G′) of the acid-induced gels increased with increasing preheat temperature, decreasing size of the emulsion droplets and increasing fat content. The adsorbed protein denatures and aggregates at the surface of the emulsion droplets during heat treatment, providing the initial step for subsequent formation of the cold-set emulsion gels, suggesting that these preheated emulsion droplets coated by whey protein constitute the structural units responsible for the three-dimensional gel network.     

Stability and mechanism of whey protein soluble aggregates thermally treated with salts

The formation of whey protein aggregates, often termed soluble aggregates, with specific physicochemical properties has been shown to result in improved functionality in gels, foams, emulsions, encapsulation, films and coatings. This work evaluated the potential of whey protein soluble aggregates to improve thermal stability in the presence of salts and determine the mechanism of improved thermal stability. Solutions of whey protein isolate (WPI) or β-lactoglobulin (β-lg) (7% w/w, pH 6.8) were heated for 10 min at 90 °C to form soluble aggregates. Native proteins and soluble aggregates were diluted to 3% w/w in solutions containing 0–108 mM NaCl and thermally treated (90 °C, 5 min). Turbidity, solubility, and viscosity were evaluated, in addition to ζ-potential and S_o (surface hydrophobicity). Size exclusion chromatography coupled with multi-angle laser light scattering (SEC-MALLS) and dynamic light scattering were used to determine aggregate size and transmission electron microscopy (TEM) was used to evaluate aggregate shape. Use of soluble aggregates improved thermal stability due to their altered aggregate shape and higher charge, and resulted in final aggregates that were smaller and less dense, leading to reduced viscosity and turbidity, and increased solubility compared to native proteins. It is concluded that soluble aggregates formed under the appropriate conditions to produce the desirable physicochemical properties can be used to improve whey protein thermal stability with a possible application in beverages.     

Influence of heat and pH on structure and conformation of whey proteins

The aim of this study was to understand the fundamental interactions responsible for aggregation of whey proteins (WPs) at pH 6 and 3 during heating at 140 °C for 30 s in the presence of different acidulants. The conformational changes in the various heat-treated WP dispersions were studied using chemical bond blockers and analysed using differential scanning calorimeter thermograms, polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and turbidity measurements. Overall, the results indicated that WPs were denatured mainly by disruption of hydrophobic interactions, and that the extent of WP denaturation at pH 3 was affected by the type of acidulant used. The type of acidulant affected the extent of formation of additional high or medium molecular weight aggregates during heating at pH 3, while the types of interactions involved in the formation of such aggregates were affected by the pH at heating.     

Effect of Whey Pretreatment on Composition and Functional Properties of Whey Protein Concentrate

The effect of pretreatment upon the composition and physicochemical and functional properties of whey, ultrafiltration (UF) retentate and freeze-dried and spray-dried whey protein concentrates (WPC) was investigated. Pretreatment was by cooling cheese whey to 0-5°C, adding calcium chloride, adjusting to pH 7.3, warming to 50°C, and removing the insoluble precipitate that formed by centrifugation or decantation. UF permeation flux rate of pretreated whey was about double that for control whey. Pretreated whey was essentially turbidity free, contained 85% less milkfat, 37% more calcium and 40% less phosphorus than whey. Pretreated whey WPC proteins were slightly more soluble at pH 3, but less functional for emulsification than whey WPC proteins. Neither whey WPC proteins nor pretreated whey WPC proteins was functional for foaming at 6% protein concentration.     

Effects of gamma radiation on microbial,physicochemical, and structural properties of whey protein model system

Gamma radiation has been used in food processing for many years, though it has certain effects on food components. Whey protein solutions (10%/30%, wt/vol) were treated with gamma radiation at various dosages (10–25 kGy) and evaluated for microbial changes in the solutions and physicochemical and structural changes of whey proteins. Whey protein solutions after gamma radiation showed substantially lower populations of all viable microorganisms than those of controls. The 10% whey protein solution treated at radiation of 20 or 25 kGy remained sterile for up to 4 wk at room temperature. Gamma radiation increased viscosity and turbidity and decreased soluble nitrogen of whey protein solutions compared to nonradiated control samples regardless of radiation dosage. Nonreducing sodium dodecyl sulfate-PAGE suggested that whey proteins under gamma radiation treatment formed aggregates with high molecular weights. Reducing sodium dodecyl sulfate-PAGE showed that disulfide bonds played a role in gamma radiation-induced whey protein cross-linking. Scanning and transmission electron microscopy micrographs exhibited large aggregates of whey proteins after gamma radiation treatment. Results suggested that gamma radiation could be applied to whey protein solution for purposes of reducing microbial counts and cross-linking protein molecules.     

Use of Whey Protein Soluble Aggregates for Thermal Stability—A Hypothesis Paper

Forming whey proteins into soluble aggregates is a modification shown to improve or expand the applications in foaming, emulsification, gelation, film‐formation, and encapsulation. Whey protein soluble aggregates are defined as aggregates that are intermediates between monomer proteins and an insoluble gel network or precipitate. The conditions under which whey proteins denature and aggregate have been extensively studied and can be used as guiding principles of producing soluble aggregates. These conditions are reviewed for pH, ion type and concentration, cosolutes, and protein concentration, along with heating temperature and duration. Combinations of these conditions can be used to design soluble aggregates with desired physicochemical properties including surface charge, surface hydrophobicity, size, and shape. These properties in turn can be used to obtain target macroscopic properties, such as viscosity, clarity, and stability, of the final product. A proposed approach to designing soluble aggregates with improved thermal stability for beverage applications is presented.     

Influence of pH on the dry heat-induced denaturation/aggregation of whey proteins

The effect of pH on the heat-induced denaturation/aggregation of whey protein isolate (WPI) in the dry state was investigated. WPI powders at different pH values (6.5, 4.5, and 2.5) and controlled water activity (0.23) were dry heated at 100 °C for up to 24 h. Dry heating was accompanied by a loss of soluble proteins (native-like β-lactoglobulin and α-lactalbumin) and the concomitant formation of aggregated structures that increased in size as the pH increased. The loss of soluble proteins was less when the pH of the WPI was 2.5; in this case only soluble aggregates were observed. At higher pH values (4.5 and 6.5), both soluble and insoluble aggregates were formed. The fraction of insoluble aggregates increased with increasing pH. Intermolecular disulphide bonds between aggregated proteins predominated at a lower pH (2.5), while covalent cross-links other than disulphide bonds were also formed at pH 4.5 and 6.5. Hence, pH constitutes an attractive tool for controlling the dry heat-induced denaturation/aggregation of whey proteins and the types of interactions between them. This may be of great importance for whey ingredients having various pH values after processing.     

天然和热处理大豆蛋白稳定乳液的性质研究

热处理(901、20℃)修饰的大豆分离蛋白用于制备水包油(O/W)乳液,并对天然和热处理蛋白乳液的粒径、微结构、絮凝率和分层稳定性进行表征。热处理蛋白的水力学半径随蛋白浓度和加热温度的增加而增加,证实了可溶性聚集体的产生。乳液粒径和分层稳定性受离子强度、聚集体粒径影响。低离子强度下(0 mmol/L),与天然蛋白相比,热处理蛋白乳液粒径较大,20 d放置后未发生分层。离子强度的增加(100mmol/L)导致天然蛋白乳液粒径明显增大;而热处理蛋白乳液则表现出较高耐盐性,体现在更小的粒径、絮凝率和分层指数。与90℃热处理相比1,20℃热处理减小了乳液液滴的粒径和絮凝。     

Dynamic Rheological Properties and Microstructure of Partially lnsolubilized Whey Protein Concentrate Gels

Viscoelasticity and microstructure of gels prepared with four whey protein concentrates (WPC) with solubilities from 27.5 to 98.1% in 0.1M NaCl, pH 7.0 were evaluated. Dynamic moduli were determined while 16% (w/w protein) WPC in 0.6M NaCl, pH 7.0, was heated isothermally at 90°C for 15 min. Storage moduli (G′) increased and tangent δ decreased when 80.0 and 98.1% soluble WPC were heated, whereas G' and tangent δ of 27.5 and 41.0% soluble WPC did not change. The 27.5% soluble WPC had the highest G' throughout the heating period. Rheological measurements suggested that globular aggregates observed in 80.0% and 98.1% soluble WPC were formed during heating, whereas aggregates in 27.5 and 41.0% WPC were present prior to heating.     

Whey protein aggregate formation during heating in the presence of κ-carrageenan

The effect of a negatively charged polymer, κ-carrageenan, on the aggregation behaviour of whey proteins during heating was studied. Aqueous solutions of whey protein isolate (WPI) at 0.5% were heated in the presence of κ-carrageenan (0.1%) at pH 7.0. This concentration was chosen as optimal in the detection of the intermediate aggregates during chromatographic analysis. The residual unaggregated protein, the intermediate aggregates and the soluble aggregates were all examined as a function of heating time and temperature, using size-exclusion chromatography coupled with light scattering detection. The presence of κ-carrageenan did not affect the aggregation of whey proteins heated at 75 °C; however, a change in the mechanism of aggregation seemed to occur at higher temperatures, and intermediates with higher molecular mass formed at 85 °C. At 90 °C, in the presence of κ-carrageenan, the extent of WPI aggregation was much larger, as soluble aggregates were no longer present and less residual protein was recovered in the unaggregated peak.     

pH-Dependent behaviour of soluble protein aggregates formed during heat-treatment of milk at pH 6.5 or 7.2

The pH-dependent behaviour of soluble protein aggregates produced by the pre-heating of reconstituted skim milk at 90 degrees C for 10 min was studied, in order to understand the role of these aggregates in acid gelation of heated milk. The following milk samples were prepared: (1) control (unheated reconstituted milk, pH 6.5); (2) milk heat-treated at pH 6.5 (mHtd6.5) and (3) milk heat-treated at pH 7.2 (mHtd7.2). They were centrifuged and the supernatants (SPNT 1) pH-adjusted to yield a series of pH values ranging from 6.5 or 7.2 to 4.6 using HCl at 20 degrees C or GDL at 20 and 38 degrees C. pH-Adjusted SPNTs 1 were re-centrifuged. The resulting supernatants (SPNTs 2) were analysed by OD (at 600 and 280 nm) and SDS-PAGE in order to characterise proteins still soluble as a function of pH. Particle size in SPNTs 1 was analysed by Steric Exclusion Chromatography. The OD600 nm revealed that during acidification soluble casein in both control and heat-treated samples exhibits variations in its optical properties or size as previously shown with micellar casein. In heat-treated samples, soluble casein and heat-induced covalent soluble aggregates precipitate at the same pH value. A progressive acidification of the soluble phase did not separate them. Increasing the temperature of acidification from 20 to 38 degrees C resulted in an increase in the precipitation pH of the proteins. However choice of acidifier did not have a significant effect on OD profiles. The soluble covalent aggregates from mHtd7.2 were smaller, more numerous, and had a higher content of kappa-casein than mHtd6.5. Both types of aggregates began to precipitate at the same pH value but precipitation occurred over a narrower pH-range for soluble aggregates prepared from mHtd7.2. This may explain the higher gelation pH of mHtd7.2 compared with mHtd6.5.     

Aggregation and Dissociation of Milk Protein Complexes in Heated Reconstituted Concentrated Skim Milks

Heating milk at 120°C at pH 6.55 or pH 6.85 caused the denaturation of whey proteins and increased their association with the casein micelles. The dissociation of K -, β-, and α_s-caseins (in that order by extent) from the casein micelles increased with severity of heat treatment. The effect was greater at higher pH. Gel filtration chromatography followed by gel electrophoresis of fractions showed the dissociated protein was composed of disulfide-linked k -casein/β-lactoglobulin complexes of varying composition, casein aggregates of varying sizes and some monomeric protein. When reconstituted concentrate was prepared from NFDM made from heated milk the non-sedimentable (88,000 ± g for 90 min) caseins or whey proteins/heating time profiles were altered and the rate of aggregation, as measured by turbidity of heated milks, was significantly reduced.     

乳清分离蛋白/阿拉伯胶复合物纳米颗粒制备及其pH稳定性

本实验对乳清分离蛋白(WPI)和阿拉伯胶(GA)分子内复合物进行热处理,旨在固化WPI/GA,使其形成稳定的纳米复合物颗粒并研究其pH稳定性。结果表明,当WPI/GA混合物浓度为1%,85℃加热15 min,可形成稳定分散的纳米复合物颗粒,并呈现出良好的pH稳定性。WPI/GA纳米复合物颗粒具有良好的乳化活性,1%浓度下的纳米复合物颗粒可制备含20%中链甘油三酯(MCT)的分散均一的水包油型乳液。结论:通过对WPI/GA分子内复合物进行热处理,使蛋白在聚集过程中与GA缠绕,形成稳定的WPI/GA纳米复合物颗粒,改善了WPI/GA分子内复合物的pH敏感性。并呈现出良好的乳化活性,为其作为纳米载体荷载功能因子方面的应用提供了很好的前景。     

Gelation of casein-whey protein mixtures

Heated milk consists of a mixture of whey protein-coated casein micelles and soluble whey protein aggregates. The acid-induced gelation properties of heated milk are consistently different from those of unheated milk—i.e., a shift in gelation pH, stronger gels, and a different microstructure of the gels. In this study we investigated the role of the different fractions of denatured whey proteins on the acid-induced gelation, the gel hardness, and the microstructure. Both whey protein fractions contribute to the observed shift in gelation pH, although by a different mechanism. Obtaining gels with high gel hardness occurs most effectively when all denatured whey proteins are present as whey protein aggregates. It was observed that disulfide bridge exchange reactions during the acid-induced gelation at ambient temperature play an important role for both whey protein fractions. Additionally, disulfide interactions seem to occur between the aggregates and the casein micelles during the gel state. In this study, we show the development of a new approach for confocal scanning laser microscopy measurements—i.e., separate staining of the proteins in milk. By using this method, we were able to determine that, although whey protein aggregates are not linked to the casein micelles, they nevertheless gel at the same moment. This work adds to a better understanding of the role of denatured whey proteins during acid-induced gelation and could improve the effective use of whey proteins.     

Thermal Aggregation of Whey Proteins in Model Solutions as Affected by Casein/Whey Protein Ratios

Model solutions (32.5 g protein/L) prepared from milk, ultrafiltration permeate, and whey protein isolate were adjusted at pH 6.7 to casein:whey protein (C:W) ratios of 80:20, 60:40, 40:60,20:80, and 0:100. Heating was performed in test tubes at 95 °C for 5 min. Observations of the heated suspensions revealed the occurrence of heterogeneous particulates from the existing casein micelles complexed with denatured whey proteins and from aggregates essentially consisting of denatured whey proteins. The proportion of whey protein aggregates increased as C:W was changed from 80:20 to 20:80. The results from this study confirmed that heat-induced aggregates were formed not only from casein micelles but also from heat-denatured whey proteins.     

Effect of pH and heat treatment conditions on physicochemical and acid gelation properties of liquid milk protein concentrate

Milk protein concentrates (MPC) are typically dried high-protein powders with functional and nutritional properties that can be tailored through modification of processing conditions, including temperature, pH, filtration, and drying. However, the effects of processing conditions on the structure-function properties of liquid MPC (fluid ultrafiltered milk), specifically, are understudied. In this report, the pH of liquid MPC [13% protein (70% protein DM basis), pH 6.7] was adjusted to 6.5 or 6.9, and samples at pH 6.5, 6.7, and 6.9 were subjected to heat treatment at either 85°C for 5 min or 125°C for 15 s. Sodium dodecyl sulfate PAGE was used to determine the distribution of caseins and denatured whey proteins in the soluble and micellar phases, and HPLC was used to quantify native whey proteins as a measure of denaturation, based on the processing conditions. Both heat treatments resulted in substantial whey protein denaturation at each pH, with β-lactoglobulin denatured more extensively than α-lactalbumin. Changes in liquid MPC physicochemical properties were monitored at d 1, 5, and 8 during storage at 4°C. Viscosity increased after heat treatment and also over time, regardless of pH and heating conditions, suggesting the role of whey protein denaturation and aggregation, and their interactions with casein micelles. The MPC samples processed at pH 6.9 had a significantly higher viscosity than those heated at pH 6.5 or 6.7, for both temperature and time conditions; and samples processed at 85°C for 5 min had higher viscosity than those heated at 125°C for 15 s. Particle size analysis indicated the presence of larger particles after 5 and 8 d of MPC storage after heating at pH 6.9. Acid-induced gelation of the liquid MPC led to significantly higher gel firmness after processing at 85°C for 5 min, compared with 125°C for 15 s. Also, gels made from MPC adjusted to pH 6.5 had higher storage moduli, with both time and temperature combinations, demonstrating the role of pH-dependent association of denatured whey proteins with casein micelles in gel network formation. These findings enable a better understanding of the processing factors contributing to structural and functional properties of liquid MPC and can be helpful in tailoring milk protein ingredient functionality for a variety of food products.     

pH Induced Aggregation and Weak Gel Formation of Whey Protein Polymers

Whey protein polymers were formed by heating (80 °C) a 4% (w/v) whey protein (WP) isolate dispersion at pH 8.0 for 15, 25, 35, 45, or 53 min. Dispersions were adjusted to pH 6.0, 6.5, 7.0, 7.5, or 8.0 after heating and the rheological properties were determined. Viscosity increased with increased heating time and decreased pH. At pH 7.0 and 7.5, high-viscosity dispersions with pseudoplastic and thixotropic flow behavior were formed, while weak gels were formed at pH 6.0 and 6.5. The storage (elastic) and loss (viscous) moduli of pH-induced gels increased when temperature was increased from 7 °C to 25 °C, suggesting that hydrophobic forces are responsible for gelation. Key Words: weak-gels, whey proteins, polymers, gelation, functionality     

Heat-induced whey protein isolate fibrils: Conversion,hydrolysis, and disulphide bond formation

Fibril formation of individual pure whey proteins and whey protein isolate (WPI) was studied. The heat-induced conversion of WPI monomers into fibrils at pH 2 and low ionic strength increased with heating time and protein concentration. Previous studies, using a precipitation method, size-exclusion method, or proton NMR spectroscopy, reported a wide range of values for the conversion. An alternative method was developed, namely centrifugal filtration, giving a consistent picture of the conversion. The present results help to explain the disparities reported in literature. No fibrils formed upon heating pure α-lactalbumin or pure BSA at pH 2, whereas fibrils formed in pure β-lactoglobulin (β-lg) and WPI solutions. Experiments indicate that β-lg was the only whey protein involved in fibril formation. In all whey protein samples, hydrolysis occurred during heating at pH 2, as determined by HPLC and SDS-PAGE. When WPI fibrils formed at pH 2 were stored at pH 7 or 10, disulphide bonds were formed in the samples.