Analysis of industry-generated data. Part 1: A baseline for the development of a tool to assist the milk industry in designing sampling plans for controlling aflatoxin M1 in milk

The presence of aflatoxin M₁ (AFM1) in milk was assessed in Italy in the framework of designing a monitoring plan actuated by the milk industry in the period 2005–10. Overall, 21 969 samples were taken from tankers collecting milk from 690 dairy farms. The milk samples were representative of the consignments of co-mingled milk received from multiple (two to six) farms. Systematic, biweekly sampling of consignments involved each of the 121 districts (70 in the North, 17 in the Central and 34 in the South regions of Italy). AFM1 concentration was measured using an enzyme-linked immunoassay method (validated within the range of 5–100 ng kg^?1) whereas an HPLC method was used for the quantification of levels in the samples that had concentrations higher than 100 ng kg^?1. Process control charts using data collected in three processing plants illustrate, as an example, the seasonal variation of the contamination. The mean concentration of AFM1 was in the range between 11 and 19 ng kg^?1. The 90th and 99th percentile values were 19–34 and 41–91 ng kg^?1, respectively, and values as high as 280 ng kg^?1 were reached in 2008. The number of non-compliant consignments (those with an AFM1 concentration above the statutory limit of 50 ng kg^?1) varied between 0.3% and 3.1% per year, with peaks in September, after the maize harvest season. The variability between different regions was not significant. The results show that controlling the aflatoxins in feed at farm level was inadequate, consequently screening of raw milk prior to processing was needed. The evaluation of the AFM1 contamination level observed during a long-term period can provide useful data for defining the frequency of sampling.     

Aflatoxin M1 in fresh milk collected from local markets of Karachi,Pakistan

During 2016–2017, 156 samples of fresh milk samples were collected from local markets of Karachi, Pakistan and analysed for aflatoxin M₁ (AFM₁) contamination using ELISA technique. AFM₁ was detected in 143 (91.7%) samples, ranged from 20 to 3090 ng L^?1 with a mean level of 346.2 ng L^?1. In 125 (80.1%) samples, the AFM₁ contamination was greater than the maximum limit (ML = 50 ng L^?1) set by EU. However, in 51 (32.7%) samples, the AFM₁ level was higher than the ML of 500 ng L^?1 as assigned by the USA. Statistical analysis showed that the AFM₁ level in milk samples from summer was significantly (p < 0.05) higher than that obtained in winter. It was concluded that the AFM₁ levels in the tested samples appear to be a serious public health problem. Therefore, immediate measures should be taken and re-evaluation done for the procedures for farming, transportation, refrigeration, and storage for the control of AFM₁ level in milk samples.     

Validation of a lateral flow test (MRLAFMQ) for the detection of aflatoxin M1 at 50 ng l−1 in raw commingled milk

Aflatoxin M₁ contamination in dairy products is a risk when feedstuff contaminated with aflatoxin B₁ produced by moulds is consumed by milk-producing animals. Milk can be screened for aflatoxin M₁ at the European Union maximum limit of 50 ng l^?1 by a lateral flow test, the MRLAFMQ (Aflatoxin M1) Test. The method takes 15 min with no milk dilution or a sample preparation step. The lateral flow assay was validated at the Technology and Food Science Unit of the Institute for Agricultural and Fisheries Research (ILVO-T&V) according to European Union guidelines using fortified raw milk samples. A detection capability of 50 ng l^?1 was demonstrated with a false negative rate lower than 2% at 50 ng l^?1 and a false positive rate of less than 0.3%. Quantitative readings had a mean bias of +2 to 6 ng l^?1 at 50 ng l^?1 with a standard deviation of 5–8 ng l^?1. Based on the validation results, the test could be considered appropriate for milk screening prior to milk unload at dairies.     

Occurrence of perfluoroalkyl substances (PFASs) in various food items of animal origin collected in four European countries

This study summarises the results of the levels of 21 perfluoroalkyl substances (PFASs) in 50 selected pooled samples representing 15 food commodities with the special focus on those of animal origin, as meat, seafood, fish, milk, dairy products and hen eggs, which are commonly consumed in various European markets, e.g. Czech, Italian, Belgian and Norwegian. A new, rapid sample preparation approach based on the QuEChERS extraction procedure was applied. Ultra-performance liquid chromatography (UHPLC) coupled to tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) employing electrospray ionisation (ESI) in negative mode was used for the quantification of target analytes. Method quantification limits (MQLs) were in the range of 1–10 ng kg^?1 (ng l^?1) for fish, meat, hen eggs, cheese and milk, and in the range of 2.5–125 ng kg^?1 for butter. Only 16 of the group of 21 PFASs were found in at least one analysed sample. From 16 PFASs, perfluorooctane sulfonate (PFOS) was the most frequently detected analyte present in approximately 50% of samples (in the range of 0.98–2600 ng kg^?1). PFCAs with C8–C14 carbon chain were presented in approximately 20% of samples. The concentration ranges of individual compounds in the respective groups of PFASs were: 2.33–76.3 ng kg^?1 for PFSAs (without PFOS), 4.99–961 ng kg^?1 for PFCAs, 10.6–95.4 ng kg^?1 for PFPAs, and 1.61–519 ng kg^?1 for FOSA. The contamination level in the analysed food commodities decreased in the following order: seafood > pig/bovine liver >> freshwater/marine fish > hen egg > meat >> butter. When comparing the total contamination and profiles of PFASs in food commodities that originated from various sampling countries, differences were identified, and the contents decreased as follows: Belgium >> Norway, Italy > Czech Republic.     

Analysis of industry-generated data. Part 2: Risk-based sampling plan for efficient self-control of aflatoxin M1 contamination in raw milk

Aflatoxin M₁ (AFM1) contamination in 21 969 milk samples taken in Italy during 2005–08 and 2010 provided the basis for designing an early warning self-control plan. Additionally, 4148 AFM1 data points from the mycotoxin crisis (2003–04) represented the worst case. No parametric function provided a good fit for the skewed and scattered AFM1 concentrations. The acceptable reference values, reflecting the combined uncertainty of AFM1 measured in consignments consisting of milk from one to six farms, ranged from 40 to 16.7 ng kg^?1, respectively. Asymmetric control charts with these reference values, 40 and 50 ng kg^?1 warning and action limits are recommended to assess immediately the distribution of AFM1 concentration in incoming consignments. The moving window method, presented as a worked example including 5 days with five samples/day, enabled verification of compliance of production with the legal limit in 98% of the consignments at a 94% probability level. The sampling plan developed assumes consecutive analyses of samples taken from individual farms, which makes early detection of contamination possible and also immediate corrective actions if the AFM1 concentration in a consignment exceeds the reference value. In the latter case different control plans with increased sampling frequency should be applied depending on the level and frequency of contamination. As aflatoxin B₁ increases in feed at about the same time, therefore a coordinated sampling programme performed by the milk processing plants operating in a confined geographic area is more effective and economical then the individual ones. The applicability of the sample size calculation based on binomial theorem and the fast response rate resulting from the recommended sampling plan were verified by taking 1000–10 000 random samples with replacement from the experimental databases representing the normal, moderately and highly contaminated periods. The efficiency of the control plan could be substantially enhanced if the dairy farms used feed with a tolerable level of AFB1.     

Determination of aflatoxin M1 in breast milk as a biomarker of maternal and infant exposure in Colombia

Chronic exposure to aflatoxins, and especially to aflatoxin B₁ (AFB1), causes hepatocellular carcinoma with prevalence 16–32 times higher in developing compared with developed countries. Aflatoxin M₁ (AFM1) is a monohydroxylated metabolite from AFB1 that is secreted in milk and which can be used as a biomarker of AFB1 exposure. This study aimed to determine AFM1 levels in human breast milk using immunoaffinity column clean-up with HPLC and fluorescence detection. Breast milk samples were obtained from 50 nursing mothers. Volunteers filled in a questionnaire giving their consent to analyse their samples as well as details of their socioeconomic, demographic and clinical data. The possible dietary sources of aflatoxins were assessed using a food frequency questionnaire. A total of 90% of the samples tested positive for AFM1, with a mean of 5.2 ng l^?1 and a range of 0.9–18.5 ng l^?1. The study demonstrated a high frequency of exposure of mothers and neonates to AFB1 and AFM1 in Colombia, and it points out the need to regulate and monitor continuously the presence of aflatoxins in human foods. Further research is needed in order to determine the presence of other mycotoxins in foods and in human samples as well as to devise protection strategies in a country where mycotoxins in human foods are commonly found.     

Hollow Fiber Liquid Phase Microextraction Method Combined with High-Performance Liquid Chromatography for Simultaneous Separation and Determination of Ultra-Trace Amounts of Naproxen and Nabumetone in Cow Milk,Water, and Biological Samples

A simple and highly sensitive method based on hollow fiber liquid phase microextraction combined with high-performance liquid chromatography and fluorescence detection has been developed for simultaneous separation, preconcentration, and determination of naproxen and nabumetone from water, wastewater, milk, and biological samples. Parameters affecting the microextraction efficiency were evaluated and optimized. Under optimum conditions (extractant (14 μL of 1-undecanol), sample pH (3.0), extraction time (20 min), stirring rate (600 rpm), temperature (45 °C), potassium chloride concentration (4.0 %) and sample volume (9 mL)), the limits of detection based on (S/N?=?3) were 1.3 ng L^?1 for naproxen and 2.9 ng L^?1 for nabumetone. The intra- and inter-assay relative standard deviations for naproxen and nabumetone were in the ranges of 3.2–6.1 % and 6.5–9.5 %, respectively. The calibration curves were linear in concentration ranges of 4.0–300.0 ng L^?1 and 9.0–300.0 ng L^?1 for naproxen and nabumetone, respectively, with good coefficient of determination (r ²?>?0.999). The method was successfully applied to the determination of naproxen and nabumetone in cow milk, water, wastewater, human plasma, and urine samples.     

Determination of free and total bisphenol A in human milk samples from Canadian women using a sensitive and selective GC-MS method

A sensitive and selective GC-MS method was developed and used to analyse human milk samples for both free and total bisphenol A (BPA). Total BPA was detected in 72 of the 278 human milk samples (25.9%) at concentrations from < 0.036 to 2.5 ng g^–1 with a geometric mean (GM) of 0.13 ng g^–1 and median of 0.11 ng g^–1, while free BPA was detected in fewer samples, 46 of the 278 samples (16.5%) at concentrations ranging from < 0.036 to 2.3 ng g^–1 with a GM of 0.11 ng g^–1 and median of 0.10 ng g^–1. Ratios of [free BPA]/[total BPA] for the positive samples ranged from 7.9% to 100% with a GM of 57.2% and median of 70.3%. Concentrations of free and total BPA in most samples were low with 0.39 and 0.65 ng g^–1 at the 95th percentile for free and total BPA, respectively, and they are also lower than those reported in other countries. Based on the low frequency of detection of free BPA in human milk samples, in general, dietary exposure to BPA for Canadian breast-fed infants is expected to be somewhat lower compared with exposure among formula-fed infants.     

Survey of aflatoxin M1 in cow's milk for human consumption in Kerman Province of Iran

The aim of this study was to assess levels of aflatoxin M₁ (AFM1) in milk samples from Kerman, Iran. AFM1 was detected in 72 samples, ranging in concentration from <0.01 to 0.41?µg?l^?1. The samples were analyzed using immunoaffinity column for clean-up and HPLC for determining AFM1. Milk samples were collected from six dairy farms. AFM1 was found in ～50% of the milk samples. The average level of AFM1 was below the tolerance limit (0.05?µg?l^?1), but 50% of the samples had greater levels than the maximum tolerance limit accepted by EU and the Iranian national standard. The method detection limit and limit of quantification were 0.01 and 0.03?µg?l^?1, respectively, and recovery of the method was 87%. The results showed that AFM1 contamination is a serious problem for public health. To achieve a low level of AFM1 in milk, cattle feed must be monitored regularly for aflatoxin contamination and protected from fungal contamination as much as possible.     

Aflatoxins in dairy cow feed,raw milk and milk products from Turkey

This study aims to detect aflatoxins (AFs) in dairy cow feed, milk and milk products using a high-performance liquid chromatography coupled with fluorescence detection (HPLC-FLD) method. All the validation parameters met the method performance criteria of the European Union. The samples comprised 76 dairy cow feeds and 205 milk and milk products (including yoghurt and yoghurt-based beverage, ayran). AFs were present in 26.3% of the feed samples. Two feed samples exceeded the maximum limit (ML) of 5 µg kg^?1 for AFB₁ as established by the EU. Nineteen milk samples (21.1%) contained aflatoxin M₁ (AFM₁) of which three exceeded the EU ML of 0.05 µg l^?1. In addition, only two yoghurt samples and one ayran sample contained AFM₁, but the levels were lower than the EU ML.     

Aflatoxin M1 in processed milk and infant formulae and corresponding exposure of adult population in Serbia in 2013–2014

Aflatoxin M₁ (AFM1) occurrence was analysed in 80 samples of milk and 21 samples of infant formulae on the Serbian market, using high-performance liquid chromatography with fluorescence detection. All milk samples collected in 2013 showed AFM1 contamination in the range 0.02–0.32 μg kg^?1, with a mean level of 0.13 μg kg^?1. The EU maximum level for AFM1 in milk (0.05 μg kg^?1) was exceeded in 75% of the samples. In 2014, AFM1 was found in 83%, 70%, 80% and 58% of the samples collected in April, July, September and December, respectively, exceeding the limit in 5% of the samples taken in July. The additional number of liver cancer cases per year associated with exposure to AFM1 was estimated to be 0.004 in the adult population. Regarding infant formulae, AFM1 was found in only one sample.     

Occurrence of pyrrolizidine alkaloids in animal- and plant-derived food: results of a survey across Europe

Pyrrolizidine alkaloids (PAs) are secondary metabolites of plant families such as Asteraceae or Boraginaceae and are suspected to be genotoxic carcinogens. Recent investigations revealed their frequent occurrence in honey and particularly in tea. To obtain a comprehensive overview of the PA content in animal- and plant-derived food from the European market, and to provide a basis for future risk analysis, a total of 1105 samples were collected in 2014 and 2015. These comprised milk and milk products, eggs, meat and meat products, (herbal) teas, and (herbal) food supplements collected in supermarkets, retail shops, and via the internet. PAs were detected in a large proportion of plant-derived foods: 91% of the (herbal) teas and 60% of the food supplements contained at least one individual PA. All types of (herbal) teas investigated were found to contain PAs, with a mean concentration of 460 µg kg^?1 dry tea (corresponding to 6.13 µg L^?1 in [herbal] tea infusion). The highest mean concentrations were found in rooibos tea (599 µg kg^?1 dry tea, 7.99 µg L^?1 tea infusion) and the lowest in camomile tea (274 µg kg^?1 dry tea, 3.65 µg L^?1 tea infusion). Occurrence of PAs in food supplements was found to be highly variable, but in comparable ranges as for (herbal) tea. The highest concentrations were present in supplements containing plant material from known PA-producing plants. In contrast, only 2% of the animal-derived products, in particular 6% of milk samples and 1% of egg samples, contained PAs. Determined levels in milk were relatively low, ranged between 0.05 and 0.17 µg L^?1 and only trace amounts of 0.10–0.12 µg kg^?1 were found in eggs. No PAs were detected in the other animal-derived products.     

Aflatoxin M1 in raw milk and aflatoxin B1 in feed from household cows in Singida,Tanzania

Aflatoxin M₁ (AFM₁) contamination in raw milk from household cows fed with sunflower seedcakes or sunflower-based seedcake feeds was determined in 37 milk samples collected randomly from different locations in Singida region, Tanzania. Aflatoxin B₁ (AFB₁) contamination in sunflower-based seedcake feed was determined in 20 feed samples collected from the same household dairy farmers. The samples were analysed by RP-HPLC using fluorescent detection after immunoaffinity column clean-up. Recoveries were 88.0% and 94.5%, while the limits of detection (LOD) were 0.026 ng mL^?1 and 0.364 ng g^?1 for AFM₁ and AFB₁, respectively. Of the analysed cow’s milk samples, 83.8% (31/37) contained AFM₁, with levels ranging from LOD to 2.007 ng mL^?1, exceeding both the European Commission (EC) and Tanzania Food and Drug Authority (TFDA) limit of 0.05 ng mL^?1. Of the contaminated samples, 16.1% exceeded the Codex Alimentarius limit of 0.5 ng mL^?1. AFB₁ was present in 65% (13/20) of the feed samples with levels ranging from LOD to 20.47 ng g^?1, 61.53% exceeding the TFDA and EC maximum limits of 5 ng g^?1 for complete dairy animal feed. The observed AFM₁ and AFB₁ contamination necessitates the need to raise awareness to dairy farmers in Tanzania to safeguard the health of the end-users.     

An effective self-control strategy for the reduction of aflatoxin M1 content in milk and to decrease the exposure of consumers

The study reports the results of testing the sensitivity of an early warning sampling plan for detecting milk batches with high aflatoxin AFM₁ concentration. The effectiveness of the method was investigated by the analysis of 9017 milk samples collected in Italian milk processing plants that applied control plans with different action limits (AL). For those milk processing plants where 30 ng kg^?1 AL has been applied, the AFM₁ contamination was significantly lower at or above the 95th percentile of the milk samples when compared with plants that used 40 ng kg^?1 AL. The results show that the control plan can be used effectively for early warning of occurrence of high AFM₁ contamination of milk and to carry out pro-active measures to limit the level of contamination. Estimation of dietary exposure was also carried out, based on the aflatoxin M₁ content of the milk samples and on Italian food consumption data. Estimated Daily Intakes (EDI) and Hazard Indices (HI) were calculated for different age groups of the population. HIs show that no adverse effects are expected for the adult population, but in the case of children under age three, the approximate HI values were considerably higher. This underlines the importance of the careful monitoring and control of aflatoxin M₁ in milk and dairy products.     

Occurrence of Aflatoxin M1 in raw and processed milk and assessment of daily intake in Lahore,Multan cities of Pakistan

In this survey aflatoxin, M₁ was quantified in raw and processed milk from various areas of two big cities of Punjab province, i.e. Lahore and Multan. The results indicated that approximately 90% of the raw milk samples collected from Lahore city was contaminated with aflatoxin M₁. Similarly, around 92% of the raw milk samples collected from Multan city was contaminated with aflatoxin M₁. All samples of processed milk and tea whiteners were contaminated and 56% of the contaminated processed milk samples and 66% of the contaminated tea whitener samples were violating the maximum limits. The dietary exposure data of AFM₁ among six different groups was calculated, which indicated that the male children population was the most vulnerable group to AFM₁, up to 6.68 ng L^?1 per day and the least affected one was the female group above 20 years of age with 1.13 ng L^?1 per day.     

Development of an ELISA and Immunochromatographic Assay for Tetracycline,Oxytetracycline, and Chlortetracycline Residues in Milk and Honey Based on the Class-Specific Monoclonal Antibody

A sensitive class-specific monoclonal antibody against tetracyclines (TCs) was generated and used to develop an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) and an immunochromatographic assay for TC, oxytetracycline (OTC), and chlortetracycline (CTC) detection in milk and honey samples. The dynamic range of detection for TC in ELISA was 0.26–2.00 μg L^?1 with an IC₅₀ of 0.72 μg L^?1. The IC₅₀ value of OTC and CTC was 3.2 and 6.4 μg L^?1, respectively. The recovery of TC, OTC, and CTC in milk samples was 82–102, 91–105, and 90–101 %, respectively, and 88–101, 89–101, and 89–95 % in honey samples, respectively. In the immunochromatographic assay, the cutoff values for TC, OTC, and CTC were 15, 15, and 50 μg L^?1 in milk, respectively, and 40, 40, and 40 μg L^?1 in honey, respectively. The results revealed that ELISA and the immunochromatographic assay can be applied for the rapid and sensitive detection of TC, OTC, and CTC in milk and honey samples.     

Nitrofurazone quantification in milk at the European Union minimum required performance limit of 1 ng g−1: circumventing the semicarbazide problem

Nitrofurazone is an antibiotic with carcinogenic properties. Efforts by regulatory authorities to control nitrofurazone from agricultural foods are an important public health measure that have, to some extent, been undermined by widespread use amongst laboratories of the unreliable marker metabolite semicarbazide. This work confirms what has long been suspected, namely that powdered dairy products that are initially free of semicarbazide develop semicarbazide under storage conditions such as occur normally across commercial supply chains. The low ng g^?1 levels of semicarbazide formed in this way are insufficient to present any food safety hazard. That such development of a marker metabolite is demonstrated to occur by innocent means effectively invalidates the use of semicarbazide as a marker metabolite for powdered dairy products, and exacerbates the regulatory need for a more suitable analytical methodology. In milk, unlike meat, nitrofurazone is known to remain stable and thus available for analysis in the intact form, rather than necessitating any use of a metabolite or fragment. However, no previous methodology that was capable of achieving the stringent European minimum required performance limit of 1 ng g^?1 when using intact nitrofurazone had been described for milk. This work describes a specific methodology using LC-MS/MS for milk and milk powder; it achieves detection of intact nitrofurazone (as well as furazolidone, furaltadone and nitrofurantoin) to levels well below 1 ng g^?1. Laboratories will no longer need to use semicarbazide as an unreliable marker metabolite for the analysis of nitrofurazone in dairy products, paving the way for regulatory authorities to better control nitrofurazone abuse with greater confidence.     

Determination of Major Sialic Acids in Dairy Products by Electrophoretic Stacking Technology with Contactless Conductivity Detection

Synergistic stacking technique by combining field-amplified sample injection with moving chemical reaction boundary was developed for the sensitive determination of two major sialic acids, N-acetylneuraminic acid (NANA) and N-glycolylneuraminic acid (NGNA) based on capillary electrophoresis with capacitively coupled contactless conductivity detection. A series of experimental parameters affecting electrophoretic separation, detection sensitivity, and hydrolysis efficiency of sialic acids were investigated. Under the optimum conditions, NANA and NGNA could be well separated from the common monosaccharides and disaccharides as well as other potential coexisting inorganic and organic anions in a running buffer of 30 mmol L^?1 NaOH–10 mmol L^?1 Na₂HPO₄/0.8 mmol L^?1 CTAB. This developed method has been applied to determine the target analytes in dairy products. In terms of its high sensitivity (LODs 1.7–2.2 ng mL^?1, namely, 5.5–7.2 nmol L^?1), good linearity (r > 0.999), acceptable recovery (93–107%), and reliability of acid hydrolysis step, this proposed method provides a simple, rapid, sensitive, and environmentally friendly alternative for the analyses of the main sialic acids in dairy products without derivatization.     

Novel Binary Solvents-Dispersive Liquid—Liquid Microextraction (BS-DLLME) Method for Determination of Patulin in Apple Juice Using High-Performance Liquid Chromatography

A simple and rapid binary solvents-based dispersive liquid–liquid microextraction (BS-DLLME) method has been developed for determination of patulin (PAT) in apple juice followed by high-performance liquid chromatography. This method involves the use of an appropriate mixture of miscible binary extraction solvents and disperser solvent to form fine droplets of extractant in a sample solution. Parameters affecting extraction efficiency such as the type and volume of high-density extraction solvent, the volume of ethyl acetate, the kind and volume of disperser solvent, and salt addition were investigated and optimized. The detection and quantification limits were 2.0 and 10.0 μg L^?1, respectively. The relative standard deviation for five measurements of 25 μg L^?1 of PAT was 3.8 %. The relative recoveries of PAT from apple juice samples at spiking levels of 25, 50, and 75 ng mL^?1 were in the range of 91.3–95.2 %.     

Quantification of oxytocin residues in dairy milk from Sindh,Pakistan

In this study, a total of 84 milk samples (60 nonbranded and 24 branded) were analysed for occurrence of oxytocin (OT) residues by ELISA. OT level was detected in the range of 39.29–456.55 pg mL^?1 with mean value of 138.53 ng L^?1. In branded milk samples, OT residues were minimal as compared to nonbranded milk samples. Nonbranded milk samples had higher prevalence of OT residues; 16.67% had OT level in the range of ≤500 ng L^?1. The average daily intake of OT was found 0.087 μg day^?1 per person. It was concluded that the OT concentration was relatively higher in samples obtained from dairy farm, dairy shop and milk man than that in ultra‐high temperature (UHT) and powder milk samples. In addition, there are no reports subjected to standardising a permissible OT level in dairy milk category, although OT is considered detrimental to both human and animal life.