High Performance Liquid Chromatography–Size Exclusion Chromatography for Rapid Analysis of Total Polar Compounds in Used Frying Oils

Analysis of used frying oil samples by high performance liquid chromatography–size exclusion chromatography (HPLC–SEC or HPSEC) was compared to AOCS Official Method Cd 20-91 (silica gel column chromatography) for the purpose of developing a rapid analysis of total polar compounds (TPC). In a direct comparison of the two analytical methods using four different sets of used frying oils (21 total oil samples) ranging from fresh to discard quality (4.3 to 35.4% TPC by column chromatography), the weight percent total polar compounds (%TPC) determined by HPLC–SEC averaged 0.71% higher than the values by silica gel column chromatography. Reproducibility of the HPLC–SEC method of s _r = 0.30 and RSD_r% = 1.22 compares to the variability of s _r = 0.29 and RSD_r = 1.3 for samples of approximately the same %TPC, reported in AOCS Method Cd 20-91. Because the rapid method does not separate pure (non-polar) triacylglycerol (TAG) and polar, oxidized TAG (OX-TAG), a high concentration of OX-TAG will quantitatively affect the results. This places practical limits on the types of studies to which the method may be applied if a separate analysis for the OX-TAG is not performed. Advantages of the HPLC–SEC method include the following. It uses about 75% less solvent than standard column chromatography methods for determination of %TPC. This HPLC–SEC method is very similar to AOCS Official Method Cd 22-91, and thus, also separates and quantifies polymerized triacylglycerols. The HPLC–SEC method determines both TAG polymer concentration and %TPC of used frying oils in about 1 h.     

A modified method for determining free fatty acids from small soybean oil sample sizes

A modification of the AOCS Official Method Ca 5a-40 for determination of free fatty acids (FFA) in 0.3 to 6.0-g samples of refined and crude soybean oil is described. The modified method uses only about 10% of the weight of oil sample, alcohol volume, and alkali strength recommended in the Official Method. Standard solutions of refined and crude soybean oil with FFA concentrations between 0.01 and 75% were prepared by adding known weights of oleic acid. The FFA concentrations, determined from small sample sizes with the modified method, were compared with FFA percentages determined from larger sample sizes with the Official Method. Relationships among determinations obtained by the modified and official methods, for both refined and crude oils, were described by linear functions. The relationship for refined soybean oil had an R ² value of 0.997 and a slope of 0.99±0.031. The values for crude soybean oil are defined by a line with R ²=0.9996 and a slope of 1.01±0.013.     

A new spectrophotometric method for the rapid assessment of deep frying oil quality

A new and quick spectrophotometric method was developed to assess deep-frying oil quality. The scanned spectrophotometric curves of the frying oil samples from 350 and 650 nm wavelength changed systematically with the duration of deep frying. The absorbances of the frying oil samples, especially those measured at 490 nm, increased significantly during frying and were significantly correlated to frying time (r ≥0.95, P<0.001). There was a strong correlation between the absorbances of a set of oil samples taken from 0 to 80 h of deep frying and total polar compound contents in the same set of oil samples analyzed using the American Oil Chemists' Society official method (r=0.974, P<0.001). The equation for conversion of the absorbances to total polar compound contents is y=−2.7865x ² +23.782x+1.0309. The absorbances of 10 different types of frying oils with samples taken from 0 to 80 h of deep frying in duplicate were also strongly correlated to total polar compounds in the same oil samples (r=0.953, P<0.001, n=220). The results show that this method is fast, simple, convenient, and reliable.     

Adaptation of the AOCS official method for measuring hydroperoxides from small-scale oil samples

An adaptation of the American Oil Chemists' Society Official Method Cd 8–53 for determining peroxides in fats and oils using a 0.5-g sample is described. Comparisons of the Official Method and the small-scale method were performed by analyzing soybean oil samples spiked with t-butyl hydroperoxide and autoxidized soybean oil samples. A linear relationship between the Official Method and the small-scale method was obtained with an R ² of 0.998. The small-scale method is sensitive, precise, and suitable for small sample sizes and uses only about 10% of the chemicals necessary for the Official Method.     

Collaborative test of determination of iodine value in fish oils. 1. Reaction time and carbon tetrachloride or cyclohexane as solvents

Twenty-two laboratories participated in a collaborative test to determine the iodine value (IV) of eight samples of fish oil (four with IV<150, four with IV>150) with either carbon tetrachloride (AOCS Official Method Cd 1–25) or cyclohexane (AOCS Recommended Practice Cd 1b-87) as solvent and either 1 or 2 h of reaction time. Laboratories received coded duplicate samples (hidden duplicates) and carried out duplicate determinations on each oil by each solvent-time combination (open duplicates). Replacing carbon tetrachloride with cyclohexane resulted in a lower IV (P<0.001). The decrease averaged 1.6 IV units for low-IV oils and 3.8 IV units for high-IV oils; this difference in response of 2.2 IV units between low- and high-IV oils was significant (P<0.001). Increasing the reaction time had a relatively small effect (0.34±0.18). There was no interaction of reaction time with solvent or oil type. Cyclohexane caused emulsions, which made it difficult to titrate residual iodine and thus increased the variability of the determination. The repeatability standard deviations (s _r ), based on hidden duplicates, for 1-h reaction time with carbon tetrachloride and cyclohexane were 2.17 and 3.35, respectively. The corresponding reproducibility standard deviations were 2.73 and 4.53.     

A modified VERI-FRY® quick test for measuring total polar compounds in deep-frying oils

The AOCS official method for the determination of total polar compounds in deep-frying oils is often used to estimate frying oil degradation. It can be accurate and reliable, but with sacrifices of time and expense. The TPM VERI-FRY® PRO (Libra Technologies, Inc., Metuchen, NJ) quick test provides a quick and easy way to measure polar compounds in frying oils. The modified quick test measured at 490 nm has a good correlation with the AOCS official method (r=0.975, P<0.001) and provides a good estimate of polar compound accumulation in oils over 80 h of deep-frying. Using the quick test to measure polar compounds is fast, convenient, economical and reliable.     

Comparison of four analytical methods for the determination of peroxide value in oxidized soybean oils

Previous work in our laboratory demonstrated that soybean oil oxidation, expressed as PV, can be determined using NIR transmission spectroscopy as an alternative to the official AOCS iodometric titration method. In the present study, a comparison of four peroxide analytical methods was conducted using oxidized soybean oil. The methods included the official AOCS iodometric titration, the newly developed NIR method, the PeroxySafe^™ kit, and a ferrous xylenol orange (FOX) method, the latter two being colorimetric methods based on oxidation of iron. Five different commercially available soybean oils were exposed to fluorescent light to obtain PV levels of 0–20 meq/kg; periodic sampling was done to ensure having representative samples throughout the designated range. A total of 46 oil samples were analyzed. Statistical analysis of the data showed that the correlation coefficient (r) and standard deviation of differences (SDD) between the standard titration and NIR methods were r=0.991, SDD=0.72 meq/kg; between titration and the PeroxySafe^™ kit were r=0.993, SDD=0.56 meq/kg; and between the standard titration and FOX method were r=0.975, SDD=2.3 meq/kg. The high correlations between the titration, NIR, and PeroxySafe^™ kit data indicated that these methods were equivalent.     

Collaborative test of determination of iodine value in fish oils. 2. Carbon tetrachloride or cyclohexane/acetic acid as solvents

Nine laboratories participated in a collaborative test to determine the iodine value (IV) of eight samples of fish oil (four with IV<150; four with IV>150) with either carbon tetrachloride (AOCS Official Method Cd 1–25) or cyclohexane/acetic acid (AOCS Recommended Practice Cd 1d-92) as solvent and 1 h of reaction time. Laboratories received coded duplicate samples (hidden duplicates) and carried out duplicate determinations on each oil by each method (open duplicates). Replacing carbon tetrachloride with cyclohexane/acetic acid resulted in similar mean values for both low- and high-IV oils and similar estimates of repeatability and reproducibility. The repeatability standard deviation (s _r ), based on hidden duplicates, with carbon tetrachloride and cyclohexane/acetic acid were 1.71 and 1.55, respectively. The corresponding reproducibility standard deviations were 1.81 and 1.98.     

A Greener Alternative Titration Method for Measuring Acid Values of Fats,Oils, and Grease

A greener alternative method is proposed for measuring acid values (AV) of fats, oils, and grease (FOG) based on visual titration. Compared with Official Method Cd 3d-63 of the American Oil Chemists' Society (AOCS), this greener alternative method can eliminate the use of toluene, which in turn reduces toxicity and cost. A total of 44 samples of yellow and brown grease with AV ranging from 0.13 to 170.37 (mg KOH) g⁻¹ were titrated using both methods. The alternative titration method can provide accurate and reliable results to determine the AV of FOG by various statistical analyses including repeatability, linear regression, f-test, t-test, and method accuracy calibration with AOCS Cd 3d-63. This low-cost method can be recommended for routine titration in research and development, and in biodiesel plants for most FOG samples.     

Evaluation of the CP-Sil 88 and SP-2560 GC columns used in the recently approved AOCS official method Ce 1h-05: Determination of cis-, trans-, saturated, monounsaturated, and polyunsaturated fatty acids in vegetable or non-ruminant animal oils and fats by capillary GLC method

The AOCS Official Method Ce 1h-05 was recently approved at the 96th AOCS Annual Meeting (2005) by the Uniform Methods Committee as the official method for determining cis and trans FA in vegetable or non-ruminant fats and oils. A series of experiments was undertaken using a margarine (hydrogenated soybean oil) sample containing approximately 34% total trans FA (28% 18∶1 trans, 6% 18∶2 trans, and 0.2% 18∶3 trans), a low-trans oil (ca. 7% total trans FA), and a proposed system suitability mixture (12∶0, 9c−18∶1, 11c−18;1, 9c,12c,15c−18∶3, 11c−20∶1, and 21∶0) in an effort to evaluate and optimize the separation on the 100-m SP-2560 and CP-Sil 88 flexible fused-silica capillary GC columns recommended for the analysis. Different carrier gases and flow rates were used during the evaluation, which eventually lead to the final conditions to be used for AOCS Official Method Ce 1h-05.     

Total fatty acid analysis of vegetable oil soapstocks by supercritical fluid extraction/reaction

Soapstock from vegetable oil refining operations is a value-added by-product that finds further industrial use based on its fatty acid content. Since the fatty acid content of soapstock can vary according to its vegetable oil source or method of refining, determination of its total fatty acid (TFA) by an accurate analytical method is of key importance to purchasers of this refinery by-product. Traditionally, the TFA content of soapstock has been determined by the AOCS Official Method G3-53 based on a gravimetric assay. Unfortunately, this gravimetric-based assay requires considerable time and incorporates a considerable quantity of organic solvent per assay. In this study, the authors have applied supercritical fluid extraction (SFE) with an enzymatic-based reaction (SFR), in the presence of supercritical carbon dioxide (SC-CO₂), to determine the TFA content of soapstocks. The SFE/SFR sequence was conducted using two commercially available extractors using an in situ supported lipase in the extraction cell to form fatty acid methyl esters (FAME). Gas chromatographic (GC) determination of the individual FAME, followed by quantitation based on the calculated sum of all the fatty acids from the GC analysis, allowed a precise determination to be made of the soapstock’s TFA content. The TFA contents of three different soapstocks determined by this method were slightly higher than the values derived from Official Method G3-53. The reported method takes less than one-half of the time of Official Method G3-53 and reduces organic solvent use from 575 mL to under 2 mL of solvent by using SC-CO₂.     

The Use of Fast Methodologies (Kits) in Evaluating Deep-Frying Oils

Fried foods are frequently served by fast food establishments but the evaluation of the oil used is quite laborious, expensive, and requires a well-structured laboratory with sophisticated equipment. Moreover, p-anisidine, used as the reagent in the traditional test for monitoring the alkenal concentration of frying oils, is carcinogenic. The DiaMed F.A.T.S. kits for the determination of alkenal (AlkalSafe™ STD) and malonaldehyde (AldelSafe™ STD), equivalent to the p-anisidine and TBA tests, respectively, are safe, fast and accurate, using compact equipment and generating fewer residues than the official methods. The results obtained using these kits were compared with those obtained using the official methods for determining alkenal (AOCS Cd 18b-90) and malonaldehyde (AOCS Cd 19b-90), in 20 samples collected from an institutional restaurant. Based on the least squares regression analysis, the AlkalSafe kit results were highly correlated with the p-anisidine values (r = 0.74), but there was a lack of correlation between the results of the AldeSafe™ kit and the TBA test. Both kits were significantly more sensitive than the official methods, as revealed by the results of the Tukey test. Although the TBA values for the samples investigated were minimal, suggesting the inadequacy of the test for monitoring frying oils, the greater sensitivity of the kit makes it a relatively feasible option.     

Cyclic FA monomers in high-oleic acid sunflower oil and extra virgin olive oil used in repeated frying of fresh potatoes

The measurement of FA profile, polar material, oligomers, oxidized triacylglycerols (OTG), total polyphenols, and cyclic FA monomers (CFAM) was used to evaluate the alteration of a high-oleic sunflower oil (HOSO) and an extra virgin olive oil (EVOO) used in 75 domestic fryings of fresh potatoes with frequent replenishment (FR) of unused oil. CFAM were absent in the unused EVOO but appeared in small amounts in the unused HOSO. Although polar material, oligomers, OTG, and CTAM contents increased and linoleic acid and polyphenols content decreased in both oils during repeated frying, the changes produced should be considered small and related to the use of very stable oils and FR. Throughout the 75 fryings, the total CFAM concentration was higher in HOSO than in EVOO. OTG increased more quickly in EVOO, whereas oligomers increased more quickly in HOSO. Polar material and oligomer content appear significantly correlated (r=0.9678 and r=0.9739, respectively; for both, P<0.001) with the CFAM content. A 25% polar material and 12% oligomer content would correspond to about 1 mg·kg⁻¹ oil of CFAM. Data suggest that both oils, particularly EVOO, perform very well in frying, with a low production of oligomers, polar materials, and CFAM.     

Effects of repeated frying on physicochemical characteristics,oxidative stress,and free radical scavenging potential of canola oil and ghee

The repeated use of cooking oils and ghee for the deep frying of food materials may affect their nutritional quality. The present study evaluated the effect of repeated frying on the physicochemical characteristics and antiradical potential of canola oil and ghee. The oil and ghee were used for frying of fish and chicken for 2, 4, 6, 8, and 10 frying cycles followed by the analysis of physicochemical, oxidative stress, and antiradical parameters. Regression analysis of the data showed a frying cycle-dependent significant linear increase in saponification (R² = 0.9507–0.9748), peroxide and acid values (R² = 0.956–0.9915), and malondialdehyde (MDA) production (R² = 0.9058–0.9557) of canola oil and ghee subjected to fish and chicken frying but exponential increase in saponification value (R² = 0.9778) and MDA production (R² = 0.7407) of canola oil and ghee used for fish frying. The increase in the number of frying cycles linearly decreased the iodine value (R² = 0.9781–0.9924), and 1, 1-diphenyl-2-picrylhydrazyl, hydroxyl, and 2, 2′-azino-bis(3-ethylbenzthiazoline-6-sulfonic acid) radical scavenging potential (R² = 0.9089–0.9979) of canola oil and ghee. Repeated frying in cooking oil and ghee increases oxidative stress and decreases their physicochemical and antioxidant qualities. Canola oil was comparatively more oxidative resistant than canola ghee. The regression equations derived from regression analysis will guide researchers to conduct similar types of univariate studies.     

Application of a Novel,Heated, Nine-Reflection ATR Crystal and a Portable FTIR Spectrometer to the Rapid Determination of Total <Emphasis Type="Italic">Trans</Emphasis> Fat

Since trans fat labeling requirements became mandatory in the US and many other countries, there has been a need for rapid and accurate analytical methodologies that can facilitate compliance with the various regulations. The determination of total trans fatty acids by mid-infrared (IR) spectroscopy is a widely used procedure that was standardized and validated as AOCS Official Method Cd 14e-09 (negative second derivative infrared spectroscopic method for the rapid (5 min) determination of total isolated trans fat) in 2009. The C–H out-of-plane deformation mid-IR band observed at 966 cm⁻¹ is uniquely characteristic of isolated (non-conjugated) double bonds with trans configuration. AOCS Official Method Cd 14e-09, the most recent attenuated total reflection-Fourier transform IR (ATR-FTIR) official method, entails the measurement of the height of the negative second derivative of the trans absorption band. In the present study, the performance of a novel, portable FTIR system equipped with a heated 9-bounce diamond ATR crystal was evaluated and compared to that of a conventional benchtop single-bounce ATR-FTIR spectrometer. The introduction of the 9-bounce diamond ATR crystal resulted in the lowering of the limit of quantification of trans fat, as a percentage of the total fat, from approximately 2 to 0.34%. The data collected from accurately weighed gravimetric standards and 28 unknown test samples ranging in trans fat content from about 0.5 to 54%, as a percentage of the total fat, indicated that this IR official method and the use of the new 9-bounce portable ATR-FTIR instrumentation could lead to a five-fold enhancement in sensitivity relative to single-bounce systems. Implementing these changes would facilitate regulatory compliance and verification of fat and oil samples for trans fat content in the US and other countries, since all of the published regulations (e.g., “0 g trans fat per serving”) have levels of trans fat, as percentage of total fat, that exceed 0.34%.     

Comparison of FTIR and capillary gas chromatographic methods for quantitation oftrans unsaturation in fatty acid methyl esters

A computer-assisted method has been developed for estimation of isolatedtrans unsaturation using the peak area of thetrans absorbance band at 966 cm-1from FTIR spectra of fatty acid methyl esters. Peak areas were used to determine thetrans content of weighed standards containing from 0 to 100% methyl elaidate and of hydrogenated soybean oil samples containing up to 36%trans unsaturation. These data for percenttrans by FTIR were compared to corresponding data obtained by capillary gas chromatography and the AOCS Official Method 14-61. Determination of isolatedtrans composition in oils using peak areas gave values with the smallest standard deviation for weighed standards and values within 4% of those obtained by capillary gas chromatography and the AOCS Official Method for hydrogenated samples. Presented at the AOCS meeting in Phoenix, AZ in May 1988. To whom correspondence should be addressed.     

Sterols and Stanols in Foods and Dietary Supplements Containing Added Phytosterols: A Collaborative Study

An international, multilaboratory collaborative study was carried out to evaluate the performance of Official Method Ce 12‐16 of the American Oil Chemists’ Society (AOCS) for the determination of plant sterols and stanols, collectively referred to as phytosterols, in foods and dietary supplements containing added phytosterols and in the phytosterol food additive concentrates used to prepare such products. AOCS Official Method Ce 12‐16 involves the extraction of free sterols/stanols and saponified steryl/stanol esters followed by the gas chromatographic separation and flame ionization detection of phytosterol trimethylsilyl ether derivatives. A total of 14 laboratories from six countries successfully completed the analysis of collaborative samples of foods (e.g., baked goods, beverages, margarines; n = 9), dietary supplements (n = 5), and phytosterol concentrates (n = 4). Study results for the contents of total phytosterols (weight/weight) were 0.19–8.4% for foods, 8.7–49% for dietary supplements, and 57–97% for concentrates. AOCS Official Method Ce 12‐16 showed acceptable performance for total and individual phytosterols, indicating that this method was suitable for the determination of added phytosterols in a wide variety of market products and concentrates. AOCS Official Method Ce 12‐16 is appropriate for the determination of the five major phytosterols (i.e., campesterol, stigmasterol, β‐sitosterol, campestanol, and sitostanol) that are the subject of the United States Food and Drug Administration's health claim for phytosterols and the reduced risk of coronary heart disease.     

Matrix Extension Validation of AOCS Ce 2c-11 for Omega-3 Polyunsaturated Fatty Acids in Conventional Foods and Dietary Supplements Containing Added Marine Oil

Marine oils are commonly added to conventional foods and dietary supplements to enhance their contents of omega-3 polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFA), including eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA; 20:5n-3) and docosahexaenoic acid (DHA; 22:6n-3), which have been associated with numerous potential health benefits. This study compared American Oil Chemists’ Society (AOCS) Official Methods Ce 2b-11 and Ce 2c-11 for determining EPA and DHA in foods and dietary supplements and found that AOCS Ce 2c-11 produces significantly higher analyzed values, which could be attributed to a more comprehensive breakdown of the sample matrix and derivatization of fatty acids. Our subsequent food matrix extension validation of AOCS Ce 2c-11 demonstrated that the method produces true, accurate, sensitive, and precise determinations of EPA, DHA, and total omega-3 PUFA in foods and dietary supplements containing added marine oil, including those formulated with emulsified and microencapsulated oils. The method detection limits for EPA and DHA were 0.012 ± 0.002 and 0.011 ± 0.003 mg g⁻¹, respectively (means ± SD). The analyzed contents of EPA (1.26–386 mg serving⁻¹), DHA (1.37–563 mg serving⁻¹), and total omega-3 PUFA (2.69–1270 mg serving⁻¹) were reported for 27 conventional food and dietary supplement products. Eighteen products declared contents of DHA, EPA + DHA, or total omega-3 PUFA on product labels, and the analyzed contents of those fatty acids varied from 95 to 162% of label declarations for all but two of the products.     

The evaluation of frying oils with the p-Anisidine value

This study was conducted to examine the relationship of p-anisidine value with headspace volatiles, sensory evaluation, and polymers. Partially hydrogenated soybean frying oil was used to fry shoestring potatoes. The oil was evaluated by p-anisidine value, headspace volatile analysis, sensory evaluation, and polymer analysis. p-Anisidine value was found to be correlated with hexanal (r=0.81), heptanal (r=0.66), t-2-hexenal (r=0.81), t-2-heptenal (r=0.71), t-2-octenal (r=0.92), and t,t-2,4-decadienal (r=0.86) contents. p-Anisidine value was correlated with overall odor intensity (r=0.82) and correlated with fried food odor (r=0.53) and burnt odor (r=0.43). p-Anisidine value and polymers were also correlated (r=0.84).     

FTIR estimation of free fatty acid content in crude oils extracted from damaged soybeans

A user-interactive computer-assisted Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) method has been developed for estimation of free fatty acids (FFA) in vegetable oil samples by deconvolution of the infrared (IR) absorbances corresponding to the triglyceride ester and FFA carbonyl bonds. Peak areas were used to determine FFA as a percentage of the total carbonyl areas in weighed standards of refined, bleached, deodorized soybean oil containing from 0 to 5% added oleic acid. These data for percent FFA by FTIR were compared to corresponding FFA data obtained by two titration methods-the AOCS Official Method Ca 5a-40 and the Official Method with a slight modification. Correlation coefficients were 0.999 for the Ca 5a-40, 0.999 for the modified and 0.989 for the FTIR methods. FFA in samples of crude soybean oils extracted from damaged beans (0.5 to 2.1% FFA) were measured by FTIR and compared to data obtained by titration of the same samples (correlation coefficient, 0.869). To whom correspondence should be addressed at National Center for Agricultural Utilization Research, Agriculture Research Service, U.S. Department of Agriculture, 1815 North University Street, Peoria, IL 61604. ¹The mention of firm names or trade products does not imply that they are endorsed or recommended by the U.S. Department of Agriculture over other firms or similar products not mentioned.