Design, synthesis and analysis of novel bicyclic and bifunctional protease inhibitors

Two novel synthetic inhibitors were designed to combine the advantageous properties of Bowman Birk inhibitor (BBI) and sunflower trypsin inhibitor-1 (SFTI-1). As is the case for BBI, the novel inhibitors have two active sites that give dual independent protease inhibition. However, they also possess a small bicyclic structure, reminiscent of the single-site SFTI-1. It is found that the synthetic inhibitors retain the potent inhibitory properties of the parent structures; they are also found to be relatively resistant to proteolysis. Their inhibition properties and a comparison of their stability to proteolysis relative to SFTI-1 are described. It is found that the new inhibitors do indeed allow bifunctional inhibition, although, unlike BBI, the small size of the inhibitor prevents the simultaneous inhibition of two proteases at the same time.     

Development and Characterization of New Peptidomimetic Inhibitors of the West Nile Virus NS2B–NS3 Protease

A series of new substrate analogue inhibitors of the WNV NS2B–NS3 protease containing decarboxylated arginine mimetics at the P1 position was developed. Among the various analogues, trans‐(4‐guanidino)cyclohexylmethylamide (GCMA) was identified as the most suitable P1 residue. In combination with dichloro‐substituted phenylacetyl groups at the P4 position, three inhibitors with inhibition constants of <0.2 μM were obtained. These GCMA inhibitors have a better selectivity profile than the previously described agmatine analogues, and possess negligible affinity for the trypsin‐like serine proteases thrombin, factor Xa, and matriptase. A crystal structure in complex with the WNV protease was determined for one of the most potent inhibitors, 3,4‐dichlorophenylacetyl‐Lys‐Lys‐GCMA (K_i=0.13 μM ). The inhibitor adopts a horseshoe‐like conformation, most likely due to a hydrophobic contact between the P4 phenyl ring and the P1 cyclohexyl group, which is further stabilized by an intramolecular hydrogen bond between the P1 guanidino group and the P4 carbonyl oxygen atom. These inhibitors are stable, readily accessible, and have a noncovalent binding mode. Therefore, they may serve as suitable lead structures for further development.     

Effect on inhibitory activity of mutation at reaction site P4 of the Streptomyces subtilisin inhibitor, SSI

The protein Streptomyces subtilisin inhibitor, SSI, efficientlyinhibits a bacterial serine protease, subtilisin BPN'. We recentlydemonstrated that functional change in SSI was possible simplyby replacing the amino acid residue at the reactive P1 site(methionine 73) of SSI. The present paper reports the additionaleffect of replacing methionine 70 at the P4 site of SSI(Lys73)on inhibitory activity toward two types of serine proteases,trypsin (or lysyl endopeptidase) and subtilisin BPN'. Conversionof methionine 70 at the P4 site of SSI(Lys73) to glycine oralanine resulted in increased inhibitory activity toward trypsinand lysyl endopeptidase, while replacement with phenylalanineweakened the inhibitory activity toward trypsin. This suggeststhat steric hindrance at the P4 site of SSI(Lys73) is an obstaclefor its binding with trypsin. In contrast, the same P4 replacementshad hardly any effect on inhibitory activity toward subtilisinBPN'. Thus the subsite structure of subtilisin BPN' is tolerantto these replacements. This contrast in the effect of P4 substitutionmight be due to the differences in the S4 subsite structuresbetween the trypsin-like and the subtilisin-like proteases.These findings demonstrate the importance of considering structuralcomplementarity, not only at the main reactive site but alsoat subsites of a protease, when designing stronger inhibitors.     

Inhibitors of Matriptase‐2 Based on the Trypsin Inhibitor SFTI‐1

A series of 17 new analogues of trypsin inhibitor SFTI‐1 were designed and synthesized to obtain matriptase‐2 inhibitors. A number of the modified bicyclic peptides displayed much higher affinity towards matriptase‐2 than towards the highly homologous matriptase‐1. Replacement of Lys5 by Arg in the wild‐type SFTI‐1 led to an 11‐fold increase in the matriptase‐2 inhibitory activity. Replacement of Arg2 by its enantiomer (D ‐arginine) slightly lowered the inhibition of matriptase‐2, but almost completely abolished the affinity towards matriptase‐1, thus yielding the most selective matriptase‐2 inhibitor. This is the first report describing inhibitors of the recently discovered matriptase‐2 based on the SFTI‐1 structure. The results showed that SFTI‐1 is a promising scaffold for the design of potent and selective inhibitors of this enzyme.     

Engineering a Constrained Peptidic Scaffold towards Potent and Selective Furin Inhibitors

We report the engineering of the monocyclic sunflower trypsin inhibitor (SFTI‐1[1,14]) into a potent furin inhibitor. In a rational approach, we converted the native scaffold of this trypsin‐like serine protease inhibitor into a subtilisin‐like one by substitutions in the canonical and, particularly, in the substrate‐binding loop. Although the substrate sequence for furin is Arg‐X‐Arg/Lys‐Arg↓, the most potent inhibitor had a lysine at position P1. C‐terminally truncated versions demonstrated the strongest activity, thus suggesting a lack of interaction between this motif and the surface of furin. This observation was further supported by molecular modeling. With an inhibition constant of 0.49 nm , the engineered peptide H‐KRCKKSIPPICF‐NH₂ is a promising compound for further development of furin inhibitors aimed at controlling the activity of this protease in vitro and in vivo.     

Design of HIV protease inhibitors targeting protein backbone: an effective strategy for combating drug resistance

The discovery of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) protease inhibitors (PIs) and their utilization in highly active antiretroviral therapy (HAART) have been a major turning point in the management of HIV/acquired immune-deficiency syndrome (AIDS). However, despite the successes in disease management and the decrease of HIV/AIDS-related mortality, several drawbacks continue to hamper first-generation protease inhibitor therapies. The rapid emergence of drug resistance has become the most urgent concern because it renders current treatments ineffective and therefore compels the scientific community to continue efforts in the design of inhibitors that can efficiently combat drug resistance. The present line of research focuses on the presumption that an inhibitor that can maximize interactions in the HIV-1 protease active site, particularly with the enzyme backbone atoms, will likely retain these interactions with mutant enzymes. Our structure-based design of HIV PIs specifically targeting the protein backbone has led to exceedingly potent inhibitors with superb resistance profiles. We initially introduced new structural templates, particulary nonpeptidic conformationally constrained P 2 ligands that would efficiently mimic peptide binding in the S 2 subsite of the protease and provide enhanced bioavailability to the inhibitor. Cyclic ether derived ligands appeared as privileged structural features and allowed us to obtain a series of potent PIs. Following our structure-based design approach, we developed a high-affinity 3( R),3a( R),6a( R)-bis-tetrahydrofuranylurethane (bis-THF) ligand that maximizes hydrogen bonding and hyrophobic interactions in the protease S 2 subsite. Combination of this ligand with a range of different isosteres led to a series of exceedingly potent inhibitors. Darunavir, initially TMC-114, which combines the bis-THF ligand with a sulfonamide isostere, directly resulted from this line of research. This inhibitor displayed unprecedented enzyme inhibitory potency ( K i = 16 pM) and antiviral activity (IC 90 = 4.1 nM). Most importantly, it consistently retained is potency against highly drug-resistant HIV strains. Darunavir's IC 50 remained in the low nanomolar range against highly mutated HIV strains that displayed resistance to most available PIs. Our detailed crystal structure analyses of darunavir-bound protease complexes clearly demonstrated extensive hydrogen bonding between the inhibitor and the protease backbone. Most strikingly, these analyses provided ample evidence of the unique contribution of the bis-THF as a P 2-ligand. With numerous hydrogen bonds, bis-THF was shown to closely and tightly bind to the backbone atoms of the S 2 subsite of the protease. Such tight interactions were consistently observed with mutant proteases and might therefore account for the unusually high resistance profile of darunavir. Optimization attempts of the backbone binding in other subsites of the enzyme, through rational modifications of the isostere or tailor made P 2 ligands, led to equally impressive inhibitors with excellent resistance profiles. The concept of targeting the protein backbone in current structure-based drug design may offer a reliable strategy for combating drug resistance.     

Design,Synthesis and X-Ray Structural Studies of Potent HIV-1 Protease Inhibitors Containing C-4 Substituted Tricyclic Hexahydro-Furofuran Derivatives as P2 Ligands

The design, synthesis, X-ray structural, and biological evaluation of a series of highly potent HIV-1 protease inhibitors are reported herein. These inhibitors incorporate novel cyclohexane-fused tricyclic bis-tetrahydrofuran as P2 ligands in combination with a variety of P1 and P2′ ligands. The inhibitor with a difluoromethylphenyl P1 ligand and a cyclopropylaminobenzothiazole P2′ ligand exhibited the most potent antiviral activity. Also, it maintained potent antiviral activity against a panel of highly multidrug-resistant HIV-1 variants. The corresponding inhibitor with an enantiomeric ligand was significantly less potent in these antiviral assays. The new P2 ligands were synthesized in optically active form using enzymatic desymmetrization of meso-diols as the key step. To obtain molecular insight, two high-resolution X-ray structures of inhibitor-bound HIV-1 protease were determined and structural analyses have been highlighted.     

Screening of protease inhibitors as antiplasmodial agents. Part I: Aziridines and epoxides

A broad protease-based and cell-based screening of protease inhibitors yielded the aziridine-2-carboxylic acid derivative 2 a and the N-acylated aziridine-2,3-dicarboxylic acid derivatives 32 a and 34 b as the most potent inhibitors of falcipain-2 and falcipain-3 (IC(50) falcipain-2: 0.079-5.4 microM, falcipain-3: 0.25-39.8 microM). As the compounds also display in vitro activity against the P. falciparum parasite in the submicromolar and low micromolar range, these compound classes are leads for new antiplasmodial falcipain inhibitors.     

Challenges in modern drug discovery: a case study of boceprevir, an HCV protease inhibitor for the treatment of hepatitis C virus infection

More than 170 million people worldwide are affected by the hepatitis C virus (HCV). The disease has been described as a "silent epidemic" and "a serious global health crisis". HCV infection is a leading cause of chronic liver disease such as cirrhosis, carcinoma, or liver failure. The current pegylated interferon and ribavirin combination therapy is effective in only 50% of patients. Its moderate efficacy and apparent side effects underscore the need for safer and more effective treatments. The nonstructural NS3 protease of the virus plays a vital role in the replication of the HCV virus. The development of small molecule inhibitors of NS3 protease as antiviral agents has been intensively pursued as a viable strategy to eradicate HCV infection. However, it is a daunting task. The protease has a shallow and solvent-exposed substrate binding region, and the inhibitor binding energy is mainly derived from weak lipophilic and electrostatic interactions. Moreover, lack of a robust in vitro cell culture system and the absence of a convenient small animal model have hampered the assessment of both in vitro and in vivo efficacy of any antiviral compounds. Despite the tremendous challenges, with access to a recently developed cell-based replicon system, major progress has been made toward a more effective small molecule HCV drug. In our HCV program, facing no leads from our screening effort, a structure-based drug design approach was carried out. An alpha-ketoamide-type electrofile was designed to trap the serine hydroxyl of the protease. Early ketoamide inhibitors mimicked the structures of the peptide substrates. With the aid of X-ray structures, we successfully truncated the undecapeptide lead that had a molecular weight of 1265 Da stepwise to a tripeptide with a molecular weight of 500 Da. In an attempt to depeptidize the inhibitors, various strategies such as hydrazine urea replacement of amide bonds and P2 to P4 and P1 to P3 macrocyclizations were examined. Further optimization of the tripeptide inhibitors led to the identification of the best moieties for each site: primary ketoamide at P', cyclobutylalanine at P1, gem-dimethylcyclopropylproline at P2, tert-leucine at P3, and tert-butyl urea as capping agent. The combination of these led to the discovery of compound 8 (SCH 503034, boceprevir), our clinical candidate. It is a potent inhibitor in both enzyme assay (Ki* = 14 nM) and cell-based replicon assay (EC 90 = 0.35 microM). It is highly selective (2200x) against human neutrophil elastase (HNE). Boceprevir is well tolerated in humans and demonstrated antiviral activity in phase I clinical trials. It is currently in phase II trials. This Account details the complexity and challenges encountered in the drug discovery process.     

Cis-Configured aziridines are new pseudo-irreversible dual-mode inhibitors of Candida albicans secreted aspartic protease 2

A series of cis-configured epoxides and aziridines containing hydrophobic moieties and amino acid esters were synthesized as new potential inhibitors of the secreted aspartic protease 2 (SAP2) of Candida albicans. Enzyme assays revealed the N-benzyl-3-phenyl-substituted aziridines 11 and 17 as the most potent inhibitors, with second-order inhibition rate constants (k(2)) between 56,000 and 121,000 M(-1) min(-1). The compounds were shown to be pseudo-irreversible dual-mode inhibitors: the intermediate esterified enzyme resulting from nucleophilic ring opening was hydrolyzed and yielded amino alcohols as transition-state-mimetic reversible inhibitors. The results of docking studies with the ring-closed aziridine forms of the inhibitors suggest binding modes mainly dominated by hydrophobic interactions with the S1, S1', S2, and S2' subsites of the protease, and docking studies with the processed amino alcohol forms predict additional hydrogen bonds of the new hydroxy group to the active site Asp residues. C. albicans growth assays showed the compounds to decrease SAP2-dependent growth while not affecting SAP2-independent growth.     

Potent HIV-1 Protease Inhibitors Containing Carboxylic and Boronic Acids: Effect on Enzyme Inhibition and Antiviral Activity and Protein-Ligand X-ray Structural Studies

We report the synthesis and biological evaluation of phenylcarboxylic acid and phenylboronic acid containing HIV-1 protease inhibitors and their functional effect on enzyme inhibition and antiviral activity in MT-2 cell lines. Inhibitors bearing bis-THF ligand as P2 ligand and phenylcarboxylic acids and carboxamide as the P2′ ligands, showed very potent HIV-1 protease inhibitory activity. However, carboxylic acid containing inhibitors showed very poor antiviral activity relative to carboxamide-derived inhibitors which showed good antiviral IC₅₀ value. Boronic acid derived inhibitor with bis-THF as the P2 ligand showed very potent enzyme inhibitory activity, but it showed lower antiviral activity than darunavir in the same assay. Boronic acid containing inhibitor with a P2-Crn-THF ligand also showed potent enzyme K_i but significantly decreased antiviral activity. We have evaluated antiviral activity against a panel of highly drug-resistant HIV-1 variants. One of the inhibitors maintained good antiviral activity against HIV_DRV^R_P20 and HIV_DRV^R_P30 viruses. We have determined high resolution X-ray structures of two synthetic inhibitors bound to HIV-1 protease and obtained molecular insight into the ligand-binding site interactions.     

Boroleucine-Derived Covalent Inhibitors of the ZIKV Protease

The Zika virus (ZIKV) remains a potential threat to the public health due to the lack of both an approved vaccination or a specific treatment. In this work, a series of peptidic inhibitors of the ZIKV protease with boroleucine as P1 residue was synthesized. The highest affinities with K_i values down to 8 nM were observed for compounds with basic residues in both P2 and P3 position and at the N-terminus. The low potency of reference compounds containing leucine, leucine-amide or isopentylamide as P1 residue suggested a covalent binding mode of the boroleucine-derived inhibitors. This was finally proven by crystal structure determination of the most potent inhibitor from this series in complex with the ZIKV protease.     

Pentacycloundecane-diol-based HIV-1 protease inhibitors: biological screening, 2D NMR, and molecular simulation studies

Novel compounds incorporating a pentacycloundecane (PCU) diol moiety were designed, synthesized, and evaluated as inhibitors of the wild-type C-South African (C-SA) HIV-1 protease. Seven compounds are reported herein, three of which displayed IC(50) values in the 0.5-0.6 μM range. The cytotoxicity of PCU cage peptides toward human MT-4 cells appears to be several orders of magnitude less toxic than the current antiviral medications ritonavir and lopinavir. NMR studies based on the observed through-space (1)H,(1)H distances/contacts in the EASY-ROESY spectra of three of the considered PCU peptide inhibitors enabled us to describe their secondary solution structure. Conserved hydrogen bonding interactions were observed between the hydroxy group of the PCU diol inhibitors and the catalytic triad (Asp25, Ile26, Gly27) of HIV protease in docking and molecular dynamics simulations. The biological significance and possible mode of inhibition by PCU-based HIV protease inhibitors discussed herein facilitates a deeper understanding of this family of inhibitors and their potential application to a vast number of alternative diseases related to proteases.     

The potential of P1 site alterations in peptidomimetic protease inhibitors as suggested by virtual screening and explored by the use of C-C-coupling reagents

A synthetic concept is presented that allows the construction of peptide isostere libraries through polymer-supported C-acylation reactions. A phosphorane linker reagent is used as a carbanion equivalent; by employing MSNT as a coupling reagent, the C-acylation can be conducted without racemization. Diastereoselective reduction was effected with L-selectride. The reagent linker allows the preparation of a norstatine library with full variation of the isosteric positions including the P1 side chain that addresses the protease S1 pocket. Therefore, the concept was employed to investigate the P1 site specificity of peptide isostere inhibitors systematically. The S1 pocket of several aspartic proteases including plasmepsin II and cathepsin D was modeled and docked with approximately 500 amino acid side chains. Inspired by this virtual screen, a P1 site mutation library was designed, synthesized, and screened against three aspartic proteases (plasmepsin II, HIV protease, and cathepsin D). The potency of norstatine inhibitors was found to depend strongly on the P1 substituent. Large, hydrophobic residues such as biphenyl, 4-bromophenyl, and 4-nitrophenyl enhanced the inhibitory activity (IC50) by up to 70-fold against plasmepsin II. In addition, P1 variation introduced significant selectivity, as up to 9-fold greater activity was found against plasmepsin II relative to human cathepsin D. The active P1 site residues did not fit into the crystal structure; however, molecular dynamics simulation suggested a possible alternative binding mode.     

Targeting the open-flap conformation of HIV-1 protease with pyrrolidine-based inhibitors

HIV protease is a well-established drug target in antiviral chemotherapy. Immense research efforts have been made to discover effective inhibitors, thus making the enzyme one of the most studied and best characterized proteins. Although the protease exhibits high flexibility, all approved drugs target virtually the same protein conformation. The development of viral cross-resistance demands the generation of inhibitors with novel scaffolds and deviating modes of binding. Herein we report the design and the short, high-yielding stereoselective synthesis of a series of chiral, symmetric pyrrolidine-based inhibitors targeting the open-flap conformation of the protease. The obtained co-crystal structure with one derivative provides a valuable starting point for further inhibitor design.     

Effects of deletion in the flexible loop of the protease inhibitor SSI (Streptomyces subtilisin inhibitor) on interactions with proteases

The Streptomyces subtilisin inhibitor (SSI) is a proteinaceousprotease inhibitor which inhibits serine proteases by forminga stable Michaelis complex. The flexible loop region (Thr64–Val69)is a very flexible region in an SSI molecule and its importancein interactions with proteases has been suggested, since conformationalchange of this loop was found to occur for the smooth bindingof SSI with various proteases. In this study, mutated SSIs lackingone or two residues in this region were generated and the effectsof deletions on the interaction with proteases were investigated.Deletion was introduced into mutated SSI(Lys73) and SSI(Gly70Lys73)both known to be trypsin inhibitors, to examine the effectsof deletion on interactions with subtilisin BPN' or trypsin.The deletion of one residue (Gly66) caused increased inhibitoryactivity toward trypsin, indicating the protruding flexibleloop hinders binding with trypsin. Reduction of such hindranceby one-residue shortening in this loop is shown to be effectivefor the interaction of SSI(Lys73) with trypsin. In contrast,one-residue shortening had virtually no effect on inhibitiontoward subtilisin BPN'. Differences in the subsite structuresof these proteases may have been the reason for this contrast.The deletion of two residues (Thr64 and Gly66) in this regionconverted SSI into a temporary inhibitor. Structural analysisof the degradation intermediate showed that the peptide bondat the reactive site of doubly deleted SSI was cleaved by subtilisinBPN' after its binding with protease. Thus, the irreversibilityof the cleaved peptide bond at the reactive site of mutatedSSI in the complex with protease may possibly be the cause forits temporary inhibition. Irregular conformation around thereactive site caused by the deletion of two residues in theflexible loop would convert SSI into a temporary inhibitor.Thus, moderate flexibility in the flexible loop region may possiblybe a structural requirement for SSI to function.     

The substrate specificity of a recombinant cysteine protease from Leishmania mexicana: application of a combinatorial peptide library approach

The substrate specificity of CPB2.8DeltaCTE, a recombinant cysteine protease from Leishmania mexicana, was mapped by screening a fluorescence-quenched combinatorial peptide library. Results from library screening indicated a preference for Arg or Lys in the S(3) subsite and for hydrophobic residues, both aliphatic and aromatic, in S(2). The S(1) subsite exhibited a specificity for the basic residues Arg and Lys. Generally, the specificity of the primed subsites was less strict compared with the non-primed side which showed preference for Arg, Lys and Ala in S'(1), Arg, Pro and Gly in S'(2) and Lys, Arg and Ser in S'(4). By contrast, a strict preference for the basic residues Arg and Lys was found for S'(3). Overall, there was a trend for basic residues in alternating subsites and smaller residues in the primed sites compared with the non-primed sites. In addition, there were strict requirements for the amino acids in subsites S(3)--S(1). Fluorescence-quenched peptides from the library with the highest on-resin cleavage were resynthesised and their kinetics of hydrolysis by CPB2.8DeltaCTE assessed in solution phase assays. Several good substrates containing the quintessential dipeptide particular to cathepsin-L-like enzymes, -F-R/K-, in P(2) and P(1) were identified (e.g. Y(NO(2))-EKFR down arrow RGK-K(Abz)G, Abz=2-aminobenzoyl; k(cat)K(m)(-1)=4298 mM(-1)s(-1)). However, novel substrates containing the dipeptide -L/I-Q- in P(2) and P(1) were also well hydrolysed (e.g. Y(NO(2))-YLQ down arrow GIQK-K(Abz)G; k(cat)K(m)(-1)=2583 mM(-1)s(-1)). The effect of utilising different fluorescent donor--quencher pairs on the value of k(cat)K(m)(-1) was examined. Generally, the use of the Abz/Q-EDDnp donor--quencher pair (EDDnp=N-(2,4-dinitrophenyl)ethylenediamine) instead of K(Abz)/Y(NO(2)) resulted in higher k(cat)K(m)(-1) values for analogous substrates.     

Modified solvent accessibility free energy prediction analysis of cyclic urea inhibitors binding to the HIV-1 protease

One of the most successful drug targets against AIDS in thelast decade has been the HIV-1 protease (HIV-1 PR), an enzymethat processes the polyprotein gene products into active replicativeviral proteins. In our quest for a wide-ranging, binding freeenergy function we have extended the solvent accessibility freeenergy predictor (SAFE_p) method, recently developed for peptidicHIV-1 PR inhibitors, to the study of the binding of cyclic urea(CU) HIV-1 PR inhibitors. Our results show that there is a needfor a specific term depicting polar contacts to be added tothe original SAFE_p analytical expression, an outcome not seenin our studies of HIV-1 PR peptidic inhibitors. Nevertheless,despite the higher profile of the electrostatic interactionsin the binding of the CU inhibitors, our analysis indicatesthat CU inhibitor binding is still driven by the hydrophobicentropic contribution, as much as for the peptidic inhibitors.     

Affinity selection of a camelized V(H) domain antibody inhibitor of hepatitis C virus NS3 protease

The HCV genome encodes, within the NS3 gene, a serine protease whose activity specifically cleaves the viral polyprotein precursor. Proteolytic processing of HCV polyprotein precursor by the viral NS3 proteinase is essential for virion maturation and designing specific inhibitors of this protease as possible anti-viral agents is a desirable and practical objective. With a view to studying both the function of HCV NS3 protease and to designing inhibitors of this enzyme, we directed our interest towards engineering macromolecular inhibitors of the viral protease catalytic activity. We describe here the affinity-selection and biochemical characterization of one inhibitor, cV(H)E2, a 'camelized' variable domain antibody fragment, isolated from a phage displayed synthetic repertoire, which is a potent and selective inhibitor of proteolysis by the NS3 enzyme. In addition to being useful as a biological probe to study the function of HCV protease, this inhibitor can serve as a potential pharmacophore model to design antivirals. Moreover, the results suggest a way of engineering improved human-derived small recognition units tailored for enzyme inhibition.