The effects of electrical stimulation and ageing on beef tenderness

Seventeen beef carcasses from cattle with a range of breeds, ages and body conditions were used in this trial. The four treatments applied to each carcass were control (C), electrical stimulation (ES), ageing for 28 days (A) and electrical stimulation plus ageing for 28 days (ES + A). Post-mortem muscle pH was measured at 0, 0·5, 4 and 24h post-stimulation. Significantly lower muscle pH values (P < 0·01) were achieved by the stimulated carcass side sompared to the unstimulated side at 0·5 (pH 6·47 vs. 6·91) and 4 h (pH 5·96 vs. 6·44) post-stimulation.

Warner-Bratzler shear and taste panel methods were used to assess the tenderness of Longissimus dorsi muscle samples from each of the four treatments. The ES, A and ES + A treatments were significantly more tender (P < 0·01) than the control treatment. The ES and the A treatments resulted in a similar improvement in tenderness compared to the control. The ES + A treatment was significantly more tender (P < 0·01) than the ES treatment alone, but there was no significant difference in tenderness between the A and the ES + A treatments.     

Effect of electrical stimulation, high temperature conditions and ageing on muscle myofibrillar proteins

Electrical stimulation, when accompanied by high temperature incubation, was found to lower the extractability of myofibrillar proteins and increase their degradation, particularly that of the myosin component. Troponin T and myosin light chain 2 were similarly affected. Troponin T and troponins I and C were degraded earlier during ageing in electrically stimulated muscles incubated at high temperature than in conventionally chilled muscles.     

The influence of high temperature, type of muscle and electrical stimulation on the course of rigor, ageing and tenderness of beef muscles

The course of rigor mortis (rigor), ageing and tenderness has been evaluated for three beef muscles; M. biceps femoris (BF), M. semimembranosus (SM) and M. semitendinosus (ST), when entering rigor at constant temperatures of 15 and 37°C respectively, with and without electrical stimulation (ES/NS) (85 V, 14 Hz and 32 s). The course of post-mortem changes has been registered by isometric tension, by shortening of unrestrained muscle strips and by following the pH decline and the changes in metabolites, such as ATP and CP. Ageing at +4°C was recorded by measuring Warner-Bratzler (W-B) shear values 2, 8 and 15 days post mortem. On the last occasion, the sensory properties of the cooked meat were also evaluated. Maximum shortening and isometric tension were higher at 37°C as compared to 15°C, whereas ES did not reduce rigor shortening. A high correlation between maximum shortening and the ATP-level at the onset of the shortening rapid phase was found (r = 0·77(???)), which could explain the greater shortening obtained at 37°C compared to 15°C. Rigor shortening is an important phenomenon governing meat tenderness as tenderness is highly affected by rigor temperature but not by ES. This was the case for muscles SM and ST but not for BF muscle. Even though tenderness was measured after ageing (15 days post mortem), shortening during rigor seems to be more important for toughness when rigor mortis occurs at 37°C than any suggested tenderizing effect due to increased proteolysis in this temperature region.     

Effects of electrical stimulation and temperature on beef quality and tenderness

Beef carcasses were stimulated with either 50 or 500 V and exposed to three chilling temperatures during the first 3 to 9 h post mortem. Both high (HV) and low voltage (LV) electrical stimulation (ES) treatments improved lean maturity scores, lowered the pH values at 2 h through 12 h and reduced the time required for the ATP level to reach minimum values. Both HV-ES and LV-ES treatments influenced firmness, fragmentation and connective tissue (CT) residue as measured by sensory panel and reduced Instron shear value (ISV) of loin steaks. The 30°C temperature treatment had an adverse effect while the 20°C temperature treatment had a beneficial effect on ISV and panel ratings for firmness and CT residue. There was an interaction between conditioning treatments and ES for ISV and sensory panel traits. The LV-ES-20C treatment resulted in the lowest ISV and superior panel ratings; however, the LV-ES-30C treatment had ISV and sensory panel ratings that were similar to the NES-2C (control) group.     

The temperature coefficient of beef ageing

A study has been made of the effect of holding temperature on the ageing of beef sternomandibularis muscle. Ageing rate increased exponentially up to 40°C, rose more slowly to a maximum at 60°C, and then decreased sharply to approach zero at 75°C. The temperature coefficient of ageing was 2.4 and was constant over the range 0–40°C. This high Q₁₀ was reflected in the high positive enthalpy of activation, (61.5 kJ). The extent of ageing was also sensitive to holding temperature; maximal extent of ageing was achieved up to ～60°C, above this, the extent fell to a minimum at ～65°C, despite the fact that the initial ageing rate at this temperature was still quite high.     

High pre rigor temperature limits the ageing potential of beef that is not completely overcome by electrical stimulation and muscle restraining

Two simultaneous trials were conducted to determine the effects of electrical input [electrical stunning and stimulation (ES)], wrapping, pre rigor temperature (15 °C and 38 °C) and different post rigor chilling rates on beef quality using M. longissimus lumborum (n=100). The high pre rigor temperature induced a faster pH decline than ES. The loins at 38 °C had significantly greater protein denaturation, more purge and drip loss, higher shear force values and less desmin degradation compared with the loins at 15 °C. No difference in sarcomere length was determined between the pre rigor temperatures regardless of ES and wrapping. Different post rigor chilling rates did not play a substantial role in water-holding capacity, proteolysis, or shear force values during ageing. These results suggest that high pre rigor temperature induces temperature-related toughness of muscle due to protein denaturation with subsequent limitation of proteolysis by μ-calpain, regardless of ES and wrapping treatments.     

Effect of electrical stimulation and temperature on biochemical changes in beef muscle

The effect of low voltage electrical stimulation and storage temperatures of 2, 15 and 25°C on biochemical changes in M. sternocephalicus from beef carcasses was studied. It was shown that electrical stimulation accelerated the glycolytic processes resulting in an immediate increase in muscle lactate and about 30% reduction in ATP. Combination of stimulation and 15 or 25°C temperature further increased the changes with ATP, reaching 2 μM/g muscle in about 2 h post mortem. At 2°C, the biochemical changes were slow. By ensuring that the muscle temperatures in low voltage stimulated carcasses do not fall below 15°C for 2 to 3 h, this should provide favorable conditions for depletion of ATP and glycogen and the prevention of cold shortening at chilling.     

Quality of beef loin steaks as influenced by animal age, electrical stimulation and ageing

The tenderness of beef M. longissimus dorsi muscles from cattle about 1 8 months (0-2 tooth) and 54 months (8 tooth) old at the time of slaughter was investigated. The influence of electrical stimulation on the mechanical and sensory panel assessments obtained for loin steaks was examined at 24 h post slaughter and also after ageing three weeks. Effective electrical stimulation of the carcasses produced, at 24 h from slaughter, steaks from both age groups which were uniform, acceptable and predictable in tenderness. The colour of loin steaks from the younger animals was lighter than loin steaks from older animals, while the weep in the vacuum packages was less for meat from the older animals than that from the younger ones.     

The effect of high and low voltage electrical stimulation on beef quality

Meat bulls were assigned to three treatment groups—high voltage intermittent electrical stimulation, low voltage electrical stimulation and no stimulation.Both stimulation methods resulted in a significantly more rapid pH fall in the longissimus and adductor muscles during the first 8 h post mortem. Carcass cooling rates were relatively slow, since temperatures of the longissimus and adductor muscles were 15°C, respectively, at 8 h post mortem.Samples of stimulated longissimus, cut at 24h post mortem and vacuum stored at 3°C for 6 days, had a brighter red colour, higher drip and heating loss, lower shear force values and scored better in taste panels, compared with samples from control carcasses. No significant differences were observed between high and low voltage electrical stimulation in quality traits measured.Although the combined result of pH and temperature measurements during the first 8 h post mortem suggest an absence of cold shortening conditions in control carcasses, a lower sarcomere length was found in samples of the longissimus muscle taken from these carcasses at 24 h post mortem.     

The electrical stimulation of beef carcasses

Beef carcasses were stimulated shortly after slaughter at varying voltage, pulse frequency and duration, with the aim of accelerating the fall of pH, destruction of ATP and onset of rigor in the muscles, so that the meat could be chilled rapidly after slaughter without danger of cold-shortening. Optimal effects were produced at 700 V, 25 Hz for 2 min, to give a total of 3000 pulses. In undressed carcasses stimulation induced a pH fall to 6.0 within 1 h of slaughter and to 5.7 within 2.5 h in the major muscles of the forelimb, back and thigh, representing a gain of more than 8 h over the time required in unstimulated carcasses hanging at 16°C. Similar results were obtained with dressed carcasses and sides, after allowing for the 50 min or so lost in dressing. The apparently high rate of pH fall from 6.3 to 5.7 after stimulation had ceased, compared with that over the same pH range in unstimulated carcasses, can be attributed mainly to the different muscle temperatures in the two cases (38 and 26°C respectively, in four major muscles). The muscles of stimulated carcasses showed no deleterious effects of stimulation. The observed drip loss from the hindlimb jointed 6 days after slaughter was not significantly greater than that from unstimulated carcasses.     

Effects of electrical stimulation and ageing of beef on the gelation properties and protein extractability of isolated myofibrils

The gelation properties of bovine myofibrils, as evaluated by dynamic rheological measurements, were shown to be very sensitive to the variables investigated: stimulation and/or ageing of the meat used, presence of 5 mM pyrophosphate and 5 mM MgCl₂ (PP) and concentration of NaCl (0·3 or 0·M). Statistical evaluation of final gel storage moduli (determined at 70°C) revealed ageing to have a consistent detrimental effect. Fresh, stimulated processing of meat), gave gels of about 40% lower elasticity (storage modulus) than did non-stimulated myofibrils; when PP was included in the gel-forming mixture no effect from electrical stimulation was seen. In spite of the negative effects observed for gel elasticity, the myofibrils in question displayed enhanced protein extractability prior to heating. Electrophoretic results suggest myosin degradation to be partly responsible.     

The influence of low temperature, type of muscle and electrical stimulation on the course of rigor mortis, ageing and tenderness of beef muscles

The course of rigor mortis, ageing and tenderness have been evaluated for two beef muscles, M. semimembranosus (SM) and M. longissimus dorsi (LD), when entering rigor at constant temperatures in the cold-shortening region (1, 4, 7 and 10°C). The influence of electrical stimulation (ES) was also examined. Post-mortem changes were registered by shortening and isometric tension and by following the decline of pH, ATP and creatine phosphate. The effect of ageing on tenderness was recorded by measuring shear-force (2, 8 and 15 days post mortem) and the sensory properties were assessed 15 days post mortem. It was found that shortening increased with decreasing temperature, resulting in decreased tenderness. Tenderness for LD, but not for SM, was improved by ES at 1 and 4°C, whereas ES did not give rise to any decrease in the degree of shortening during rigor mortis development. This suggests that ES influences tenderization more than it prevents cold-shortening. The samples with a pre-rigor mortis temperature of 1°C could not be tenderized, when stored up to 15 days, whereas this was the case for the muscles entering rigor mortis at the other higher temperatures. The results show that under the conditions used in this study, the course of rigor mortis is more important for the ultimate tenderness than the course of ageing.     

Post-mortem glycolysis in rabbit Longissimus dorsi muscles following electrical stimulation

The effects of both high voltage and low voltage electrical stimulation were studied in rabbit Longissimus dorsi muscles. The rate of fall of pH as well as the activities of phosphorylase a, phosphorylase kinase, and phosphorylase phosphatase were measured. The effects on the yield, ATPase activities, and calcium permeability of the sarcoplasmic reticulum (SR) were also measured. Although only high voltage stimulation increased the post-stimulation rate of pH fall, both types of electrical stimulation increased the phosphorylase a activity, apparently by increasing the activity of phosphorylase kinase and destroying a large part of the phosphorylase phosphatase activity. Electrical stimulation reduced the yield of SR and increased its basal ATPase activity. It also increased the ability of the SR to retain accumulated calcium. We conclude that the different rates of pH fall observed following the two types of stimulation are due to the differential effects of these treatments on one of the ATPase activities, probably the myofibrillar ATPase.     

Hot deboning beef with and without electrical stimulation

Two hot deboning procedures for producing vacuum packed primal beef joints were compared with conventional side chilling followed by cold deboning. Cold shortening toughness was avoided in the hot procedures either by a delay before chilling or by electrical stimulation of the carcass. Overall evaporative losses were 0·6% with hot deboning and 1·9% with cold deboning. Hot deboning reduced drip loss but the effect was smaller after electrical stimulation. The colour of large muscles which cool unevenly on the side was more uniform after hot deboning, but again the improvement was smaller after electrical stimulation. There was no difference in bacterial contamination or growth on hot and cold deboned meat, and instrumental and sensory assessments confirmed that eating quality was similar for all three treatments.     

Effects of low-frequency electrical stimulation on beef tenderness

The application of 2 Hz, 500 V electrical stimulation to early post-mortem beef sides causes rapid muscle glycolysis, yet produces no trace of the extensive tissue rupture effected by 60 Hz current. By means of this low frequency technique, coupled with a mild or delayed-chill routine, we have examined the supposed tenderizing effect of rapid pH decline alone, without concurrent fiber fracture or cold-shortening intervention. Loin steaks from sides receiving this treatment were significantly tougher than those from paired control sides, an observation strongly suggesting that tenderization is hindered by rapid glycolysis. In other experiments, 60 Hz 500-V current was found to produce very extensive fracturing with breaks appearing (on average) every 6 mm of fiber length; this treatment resulted in a very significant tenderizing relative to that observed in the unstimulated control sides. It is concluded that, apart from its ability to prevent cold-shortening, normal-frequency high-voltage stimulation exerts its beneficial tenderizing action by fracturing the fibres; the accompanying acceleration of glycolysis actually causes a small, but definite, negative effect on eating quality.     

The protective effect of electrical stimulation and wrapping on beef tenderness at high pre rigor temperatures

A three factorial experimental design involving electrical stimulation (ES/NES), wrapping (wrapped/unwrapped) and pre rigor temperature (15 °C or 35 °C) was applied to 70 beef M. longissimus lumborum muscles to obtain a wide variation in shear force and drip loss. The shear force of all treatment groups decreased during ageing. As anticipated, wrapping and electrical stimulation had positive effects on shear force. However, high pre rigor temperature (35 °C) did not result in higher shear force values if the muscles were electrically stimulated, wrapped or both. The results suggested that electrical stimulation protects against the negative effects of high pre rigor temperatures. The drip loss of all treatment groups increased during ageing in a manner that was unrelated to treatment but was correlated to tenderness (r² = 0.70; p < 0.0001). It was concluded that the application of electrical stimulation, whatever the pre rigor temperature, protects beef from toughening through the prevention of rigor shortening and the avoidance of inhibition of ageing enzymes.     

Studies in electrical stimulation: Post-mortem decline in nervous response in lambs

A study has been made of the effects of electrical stimulation, either indirectly through the nerves or directly through the muscles, on glycolysis in lamb hind leg muscles. Responses were affected by delay before application and the stimulating voltage. At 5 min post mortem the same fall in pH during stimulation (ΔpH) and subsequent increased rate of pH fall (dp H/dt) occurred in muscles stimulated both directly and indirectly with 12 V. With 200V, ΔpH was 50% greater in muscles stimulated directly and 30% less if stimulated indirectly. At 30 min post mortem there was very little effect of stimulation at either voltage on glycolysis when muscles were indirectly stimulated, indicating that the nerves had lost their capacity to trigger muscles to contract. In contrast, if the legs were stimulated directly, maximum ΔpH and dpH/dt values were achieved with 200 V pulses. The significance of these findings to the application of electrical stimulation to commercial meat processing is discussed.     

The tenderising effect of electrical stimulation of beef carcasses

Electrical stimulation (ES) of beef carcasses soon after death has an accelerated tenderising effect on the musculature, under conditions of slow cooling (8 h at 16°C and then storage in still air at 1°C). The effect is large in the LD muscles, reducing the shear force on day 1 of storage from 11 to 6 kg; on day 14, the difference is still 3·3 kg. These differences would be detected by taste panels. The St muscles show a similar, but less pronounced, effect which would probably not be detected by taste panels. The accelerated tenderisation due to ES can be accounted for by the higher temperatures obtaining in stimulated muscles at the onset of rigor. Rapid cooling soon after death reduces the effect almost to zero. Hence, the extra tenderisation cannot be due to muscle damage during ES. Histological examination shows that stimulated muscles have longer sarcomeres than the controls; they do not exhibit damage. However, with slow cooling, irregular bands of denatured sarcoplasmic protein are deposited within the fibres of stimulated muscles, similar to those found in PSE pig muscles. There is also some shortening of sarcomeres in the region of the bands. The protein is deposited on the myofibrillar surfaces. In spite of the PSE-like appearance, there is no significant increase in drip from the stimulated muscles at 48 h after death.     

Singular and combined effects of electrical stimulation, post-mortem ageing and blade tenderisation on the palatability attributes of beef from young bulls

Thirty Santa Gertrudis bulls (approximately 15-18 months old) were slaughtered, dressed and split into siides. The right side of each carcass was electrically stimulated (ES) with seventeen impulses (1·8s impulse duration; 1·8s interval between impulses) of 550 V (AC) and 5 A while the left side served as a non-stimulated control (not-ES). At 24h post morten, USDA quality and yield grade data were obtained from each side. On the second day post mortem, all sides were fabricated and strip loins, top sirloin butts and ribeyes were obtained from each side for post-mortem ageing and blade tenderisation studies. Steaks were removed after a post-mortem ageing period of 4 or 18 days and before (not-BT) or after blade tenderisation (BT) for sensory panel evaluations or shear force determinations. ES sides had more youthful lean maturity (P < 0·0001), higher marbling (P < 0.·002), higher USDA quality grades (P < 0·0.0001) and finer-textured lean (P < 0·002) than did not-stimulated (not-ES) sides. ES significantly improved (P < 0·05) palatability traits in two of twenty-four comparisons; BT significantly improved palatability traits in twelve of twenty-four comparisons and 18-day post-mortem ageing significantly improved palatability traits in seven of twelve comparisons. No significant reductions (P < 0·05) in shear force values were observed for steaks from ES versus not-ES sides while significant reductions (P < 0·05) were observed for steaks from BT versus non-BT cuts (four of six comparisons) and for steaks from cuts aged for 18 versus 4 days (ten of twelve comparisons). BT and 18-day post-mortem ageing were more effective for increasing palatability or for decreasing shear force requirements than was ES; however, ES greatly improved lean colour of meat from bulls.     

Low voltage electrical stimulation and post-mortem energy metabolism in beef

In the present study, the influence of low voltage electrical stimulation on glycolysis, concentrations of creatine phosphate and adenine nucleotides, as well as the relationship between metabolic activity and tenderness, was examined in bovine M. longissimus dorsi. During stimulation, about 50% of the creatine phosphate was consumed and the immediate pH drop was, on average, 0·21 units. The increased energy consumption resulted in a decrease in the halftime of ATP from 10 h in non-stimulated muscles to 5 h in electrically stimulated muscles. The total high energy phosphate turnover was found to be 2400 μmol/h/g during stimulation and 18 μmol/h/g immediately following stimulation compared with 9 μmol/h/g for the non-stimulated counterpart. No obvious abnormalities were found in the course of changes during energy metabolism following stimulation, besides the increased metabolic rate. Significant relationships were found between the degradation of several of the energy metabolites during stimulation and improvements in tenderness. It is concluded that, within the variation found in this study, the better the effect of electrical stimulation in increasing the metabolic rate, the better the resulting meat tenderness. Results also showed that the higher the shear force in the non-stimulated part, the better was the effect of electrical stimulation in improving the meat tenderness.