On the Tritium Breeding Capability of Flibe, Flinabe, and Li20Sn80 in a Fusion-Fission (Hybrid) Reactor

In a commercial (DT) driven fusion reactor, the tritium breeding ratio per incident fusion neutron must be greater than 1.05 to maintain tritium self-sufficiency for the driver. In this study tritium breeding capability of three different coolants, namely Flibe (LiF·BeF₂), Flinabe (LiF·NaF·BeF₂), and Li₂₀Sn₈₀ in a (DT) driven fusion-fission (hybrid) reactor was investigated for different refractory alloys (W-5Re, TZM, T111, and Nb-1Zr) as structural material. Neutron transport calculations were conducted with the help of SCALE 4.3 SYSTEM by solving the Boltzmann transport equation with code XSDRNPM. The contribution of Flibe, Flinabe, and Li₂₀Sn₈₀ with respect to ⁶Li enrichment in their lithium content to overall TBR was investigated. In addition, the effect of structural material type on TBR was examined.     

Radiation Damage Study on Various Structural Refractory Alloys of a Multi-Purpose Reactor

Radiation damage properties of structural materials play a key role in design of a fusion–fission (hybrid) reactor. Refractory alloys offer a significant advantage of high neutron wall load capability under fusion neutron environment. In this study, main radiation damage parameters (displacement per atom (DPA) and helium production) on three different refractory alloys, namely W-5Re, TZM (Mo alloy) and Nb–1Zr used as structural material in a hybrid reactor were found. Neutron transport calculations were conducted with the aid of SCALE4.3 System by solving the Boltzmann transport equation with code XSDRNPM. The lowest radiation damage values were obtained for W-5Re alloy. Moreover, all investigated materials will require to be replaced frequently due to their radiation damage values during reactor life (~ 30 years).     

Neutronic performance of HYLIFE-II fusion reactor using various thorium molten salts

HYLIFE-II is one of the major inertial fusion energy reactor design concepts in which a thick molten salt layer (Flibe = Li₂BeF₄) is injected between the reaction chamber walls and the explosions. Molten salt coolant eliminates the frequent replacement of solid first wall structure during reactors lifetime by decreasing intense neutron flux. This study presents the neutronic analysis of HYLIFE-II fusion reactor using various liquid wall coolants, namely, 75% LiF–25% ThF₄, 75% LiF–24% ThF₄–1% ²³³UF₄ or 75% LiF–23% ThF₄–2% ²³³UF₄. Neutron transport calculations for the evaluation of neutron spectra were conducted with the help of Scale 4.3 by solving the Boltzmann transport equation in S₈–P₃ approximation. The effects of flowing liquid wall thickness and type of coolant on the neutronic performance of the reactor were investigated. Furthermore, radiation damage calculations at the first wall structure with respect to type and thickness of liquid wall were carried out. Numerical results showed that using the flowing liquid wall containing the molten salt, 75% LiF–23% ThF₄–2% UF₄ with a thickness of 70 cm maintained tritium self-sufficiency of the (DT) fusion driver and extended the first wall lifetime to the reactors lifetime (30 full power years). In addition significant amount of high quality fissile fuel was bred through (n, γ) reaction of ²³²Th. Moreover, energy multiplication factor (M) was increased to 12 by high rate fission reactions of ²³³U occurring in the flowing wall. On the other hand, it was concluded that using the other two coolants, 75% LiF–25% ThF₄ or 75% LiF–24% ThF₄–1% ²³³UF₄, as liquid wall did not satisfy the radiation damage and the tritium sufficiency criteria together at any thickness, so that these two coolants were not suitable to improve neutronic performance of HYLIFE-II reactor.     

Investigation on the Neutronic Performance of a Fusion Reactor Using Flibe with Heavy Metal Fluorides

Using liquid wall between the plasma and solid first wall in a fusion reactor allows to use high neutron wall loads and could eliminate frequent replacement of the first wall structure during reactor’s lifetime. Liquid wall should have a certain effective or optimum thickness to extend solid first wall lifetime to reactor’s lifetime and supply sufficient tritium for deuterium–tritium (DT) fusion driver. This study presents the effect of thickness of flowing liquid wall containing 90 mol % Flibe+10 mol % UF₄ or ThF₄ on the neutronic performance of a magnetic fusion reactor design called APEX. Neutron transport calculations were carried out with the aid of code Scale4.3. Numerical results brought out that optimum liquid wall thickness of ∼38 cm was found for the blankets using Flibe+10% UF₄ whereas, 56 cm for that with Flibe+10% ThF₄. Significant amount of high quality fissile fuel was produced by using heavy metal salt.     

Effect of Different Structural Materials on Neutronic Performance of a Hybrid Reactor

Selection of structural material for a fusion–fission (hybrid) reactor is very important by taking into account of neutronic performance of the blanket. Refractory metals and alloys have much higher operating temperatures and neutron wall load (NWL) capabilities than low activation materials (ferritic/martensitic steels, vanadium alloys and SiC/SiC composites) and austenitic stainless steels. In this study, effect of primary candidate refractory alloys, namely, W-5Re, T111, TZM and Nb–1Zr on neutronic performance of the hybrid reactor was investigated. Neutron transport calculations were conducted with the help of SCALE4.3 System by solving the Boltzmann transport equation with code XSDRNPM. Among the investigated structural materials, tantalum had the worst performance due to the fact that it has higher neutron absorption cross section than others. And W-5Re and TZM having similar results showed the best performance.     

Radiation Damage and Tritium Breeding Study in a Fusion Reactor Using a Liquid Wall of Various Thorium Molten Salts

A new magnetic fusion reactor design, called APEX uses a liquid wall between fusion plasma and solid first wall to reach high neutron wall loads and eliminate the replacement of the first wall structure during the reactor’s operation due to the radiation damage. In this paper, radiation damage behavior of the inboard and outboard first walls made of a ferritic steel, 9Cr-2WVTa, in the APEX blanket using various thorium molten salts, 75% LiF-25% ThF₄, 75% LiF-24% ThF₄-1% ²³³UF₄ and 75% LiF-23% ThF₄-2% ²³³UF₄ was investigated. Furthermore, tritium breeding potential of these salts in such a blanket was also examined. Computations were carried out using the code Scale 4.3 by solving Boltzmann neutron transport equation. Numerical results brought out that only the liquid wall containing the molten salt, 75% LiF-23% ThF₄-2% ²³³UF₄ and having a thickness of ≥38 cm would be suitable to be used in the APEX reactor with respect to radiation damage criteria for the first wall structures and tritium self-sufficiency for the (DT) fusion driver.     

Hydrogen Permeation through Incoloy-800

The poloidal distribution of the first wall 14 MeV neutron flux and the tritium breeding ratio in a Tokamak fusion reactor were calculated using Monte Carlo method. The poloidal distribution of the 14 MeV neutron flux in the first wall was found to be quite different from that of the primary incident flux. The tritium breeding ratio calculated by the Monte Carlo method became about 5% larger than the value obtained from S_N transport calculations.     

On the radiation damage characterization of candidate first wall materials in a fusion reactor using various molten salts

Evaluating radiation damage characteristics of structural materials considered to be used in fusion reactors is very crucial. In fusion reactors, the highest material damage occurs in the first wall because it will be exposed to the highest neutron, gamma ray and charged particle currents produced in the fusion chamber. This damage reduces the lifetime of the first wall material and leads to frequent replacement of this material during the reactor operation period. In order to decrease operational cost of a fusion reactor, lifetime of the first wall material should be extended to reactor’s lifetime. Using a protective flowing liquid wall between the plasma and first wall can decrease the radiation damage on first wall and extend its lifetime to the reactor’s lifetime. In this study, radiation damage characterization of various low activation materials used as first wall material in a magnetic fusion reactor blanket using a liquid wall was made. Various coolants (Flibe, Flibe + 4% mol ThF₄, Flibe + 8% mol ThF₄, Li₂₀Sn₈₀) were used to investigate their effect on the radiation damage of first wall materials. Calculations were carried out by using the code Scale4.3 to solve Boltzmann neutron transport equation. Numerical results brought out that the ferritic steel with Flibe based coolants showed the best performance with respect to radiation damage.     

Neutronics Calculations in Pellets and Blankets of Laser Fusion Reactor Concept SENRI-I

The neutronic properties of SENRI-I, a reference design of laser fusion reactor proposed by Institute of Engineering, Osaka University, are discussed on the basis of the one-dimensional neutron transport calculations in burning DT plasmas and blankets. The softening of the fusion neutron energy spectrum, the neutron heating and the neutron multiplication are studied and discussed for the compressed DT pellets with various thickness of fuel plasmas and lead or lead-polyethylene tampers.

The neutronic and thermal features in the blanket of the SENRI-I design are also examined. The tritium breeding ratio is high enough (~1.6), depending on the neutron energy spectrum from a pellet. The maximum temperature increase per 1,000 MJ DT fusion reactions is ~3°C in the inner liquid Li layer and ~1.5°C in the stainless steel first wall. A parametric study is also presented on the effect of varying the thickness of the inner Li blanket ΔRⁱ to examine the thickness required for the enough tritium breeding ratio and energy deposition.     

Study on (n,t) Reactions of Zr, Nb and Ta Nuclei

The world faces serious energy shortages in the near future. To meet the world energy demand, the nuclear fusion with safety, environmentally acceptability and economic is the best suited. Fusion is attractive as an energy source because of the virtually inexhaustible supply of fuel, the promise of minimal adverse environmental impact, and its inherent safety. Fusion will not produce CO₂ or SO₂ and thus will not contribute to global warming or acid rain. Furthermore, there are not radioactive nuclear waste problems in the fusion reactors. Although there have been significant research and development studies on the inertial and magnetic fusion reactor technology, there is still a long way to go to penetrate commercial fusion reactors to the energy market. Because, tritium self-sufficiency must be maintained for a commercial power plant. For self-sustaining (D-T) fusion driver tritium breeding ratio should be greater than 1.05. And also, the success of fusion power system is dependent on performance of the first wall, blanket or divertor systems. So, the performance of structural materials for fusion power systems, understanding nuclear properties systematic and working out of (n,t) reaction cross sections are very important. Zirconium (Zr), Niobium (Nb) and Tantal (Ta) containing alloys are important structural materials for fusion reactors, accelerator-driven systems, and many other fields. In this study, (n,t) reactions for some structural fusion materials such as ^{88,90,92,94,96}Zr, ^93,94,95Nb and ^179,181Ta have been investigated. The calculated results are discussed andcompared with the experimental data taken from the literature.     

Advanced Power Conversion Efficiency in Inventive Plasma for Hybrid Toroidal Reactor

Apex hybrid reactor has a good potential to utilize uranium and thorium fuels in the future. This toroidal reactor is a type of system that facilitates the occurrence of the nuclear fusion and fission events together. The most important feature of hybrid reactor is that the first wall surrounding the plasma is liquid. The advantages of utilizing a liquid wall are high power density capacity good power transformation productivity, the magnitude of the reactor’s operational duration, low failure percentage, short maintenance time and the inclusion of the system’s simple technology and material. The analysis has been made using the MCNP Monte Carlo code and ENDF/B–V–VI nuclear data. Around the fusion chamber, molten salts Flibe (LI₂BeF₄), lead–lithium (PbLi), Li–Sn, thin-lityum (Li₂₀Sn₈₀) have used as cooling materials. APEX reactor has modeled in the torus form by adding nuclear materials of low significance in the specified percentages between 0 and 12 % to the molten salts. In this study, the neutronic performance of the APEX fusion reactor using various molten salts has been investigated. The nuclear parameters of Apex reactor has been searched for Flibe (LI₂BeF₄) and Li–Sn, for blanket layers. In case of usage of the Flibe (LI₂BeF₄), PbLi, and thin-lityum (Li₂₀Sn₈₀) salt solutions at APEX toroidal reactors, fissile material production per source neutron, tritium production speed, total fission rate, energy reproduction factor has been calculated, the results obtained for both salt solutions are compared.     

Monte Carlo calculations of the nuclear effects of certain fluids in a hybrid reactor

This study analyzes the effects of certain heavy-metal-salt fluids on nuclear parameters in a fusion–fission hybrid reactor. Calculated parameters include the tritium breeding ratio (TBR), energy multiplication factor (M), heat deposition rate, fission reaction rate, and fissile fuel breeding in the reactor's liquid first wall, blanket, and shield zones; gas production rates in the structural material of the reactor were calculated, as well. The fluid mixtures consisted of 93–85% Li₂₀Sn₈₀ + 5% SFG-PuO₂ and 2–10% UO₂, 93–85% Li₂₀Sn₈₀ + 5% SFG-PuO₂ and 2–10% NpO₂, and 93–85% Li₂₀Sn₈₀ + 5% SFG-PuO₂ and 2–10% UCO. The fluids were used in the liquid first wall, blanket, and shield zones of a fusion–fission hybrid reactor system. A 3 cm wide beryllium (Be) zone was used for neutron multiplier between the liquid first wall and the blanket. The structural material used was 9Cr2WVTa ferritic steel, measuring 4 cm in width. Three-dimensional analyses were performed using the Monte Carlo code MCNPX-2.7.0 and the ENDF/B-VII.0 nuclear data library.     

3D Neutronic Analysis in MHD Calculations at ARIES-ST Fusion Reactors Systems

In this study, we developed new models for liquid wall (FW) state at ARIES-ST fusion reactor systems. ARIES-ST is a 1,000 MWe fusion reactor system based on a low aspect ratio ST plasma. In this article, we analyzed the characteristic properties of magnetohydrodynamics (MHD) and heat transfer conditions by using Monte-Carlo simulation methods (ARIES Team et al. in Fusion Eng Des 49–50:689–695, 2000; Tillack et al. in Fusion Eng Des 65:215–261, 2003) . In fusion applications, liquid metals are traditionally considered to be the best working fluids. The working liquid must be a lithium-containing medium in order to provide adequate tritium that the plasma is self-sustained and that the fusion is a renewable energy source. As for Flibe free surface flows, the MHD effects caused by interaction with the mean flow is negligible, while a fairly uniform flow of thick can be maintained throughout the reactor based on 3-D MHD calculations. In this study, neutronic parameters, that is to say, energy multiplication factor radiation, heat flux and fissile fuel breeding were researched for fusion reactor with various thorium and uranium molten salts. Sufficient tritium amount is needed for the reactor to work itself. In the tritium breeding ratio (TBR) >1.05 ARIES-ST fusion model TBR is >1.1 so that tritium self-sufficiency is maintained for DT fusion systems (Starke et al. in Fusion Energ Des 84:1794–1798, 2009; Najmabadi et al. in Fusion Energ Des 80:3–23, 2006).     

Utilization of Ceramic Uranium Fuels in ARIES-RS Fusion Reactor

This study presents the neutronic performance of the ARIES-RS fusion reactor design using different natural ceramic uranium fuels, namely UO₂, UN or U₃Si₂, dispersed in graphite matrix. These fissionable fuels inserted as micro spheres into the first range quadratic channels at the immediate neighborhood of the first wall in the inboard blanket to amplify fusion power and breed fissile fuel. Neutron transport calculations were performed with the help of the SCALE4.3 system by solving the Boltzmann transport equation with the XSDRNPM code in 238 neutron groups and a S₈–P₃ approximation. Among the investigated fuels, UN showed the best neutronic performance while UO₂ and U₃Si₂ had similar performances. Numerical results pointed out that inserting fissionable fuel zone even with a small thickness (10 cm) in a pure fusion reactor increased fusion power from 2170 MW to 4500, 5250 and 4150 MW depending on the fuel type. Furthermore significant amount of fissile fuel was produced to be charged to light water reactors.     

Some Comments on First Flight Collision Probability for a Finite Cylinder

The corrosion behaviors of SUS 316, PE 16, Nb-1%Zr,:-25%Mo, Mo and TZM in the He containing O₂ of 0.1:pm and N₂ of 5vpm at temperatures from 700 to 1,000°C were studied. The intergranular oxidation was observed for SUS 316 and PE 16 in the range of test temperatures. The rate of intergranular oxidation obeyed parabolic rate law and it is estimated that oxygen diffusion in the metal determined the penetration rate. Nb-1%Zr andv-25%Mo extremely absorbed oxygen and nitrogen from the atmosphere at test temperatures. The oxygen content of TZM also increased with time of exposure. The absorption rate of nitrogen in Nb-1%Zr and oxygen in TZM can be explained with the adsorption model of the active gas on the metal surface. Molybdenum did not show any change in microhardness, oxygen and nitrogen contents and microstructure after exposure to He at temperatures from 700 to 1,000°C.     

Effect of Nuclear Data Libraries on Tritium Breeding in a (D–T) Fusion Driven Reactor

In design a Deuterium–Tritium (D–T) fusion driven hybrid reactor, neutronics and nuclear data libraries have an essential role for reliable neutronics calculations. Therefore, nuclear data libraries are very important to calculate of the neutronic parameters and selection of tritium breeder materials to be used in the blanket. In this study tritium breeding performances of candidate tritium breeding materials, namely, Li₂O, LiH, Li₂TiO₃, Li₂ZrO₃ and Li₄SiO₄ in a (D–T) driven fusion–fission (hybrid) reactor is investigated based on three dimensional (3-D) and one dimensional (1-D) neutronic calculations. 3-D and 1-D neutron transport calculations are performed with Monte Carlo transport code (MCNP 4C), SCALE 5 and ANISN nuclear data codes to determine the tritium breeding ratio (TBR) of the blanket. The effects of different nuclear data libraries on TBR are examined and TBR calculation results are comparatively investigated.     

Tritium breeding control within liquid metal blankets

A key requirement for DEMO is the on-site breeding of tritium. In order to do this, a robust control system must be employed to ensure enough tritium is being bred to sustain the fusion reactor, whilst not breeding an amount which would exceed the plant's tritium inventory license. A tritium breeding method which is cost effective and reduces radioactive waste for disposal is that of the liquid metal breeder such as those based around LiPB and FLiBe. This paper focuses on the modeling of a simplified fusion reactor design with a LiPb blanket with linked radiation transport, nuclide burn-up and control theory. Two simple models were simulated using the FATI code which incorporated a PID (proportional integral derivative) controller that adjusted the Li6/Li7 ratio in order to increase/decrease tritium production based on the difference between the measured excess tritium inventory and the desired excess inventory. The modelling has initially demonstrated that a linear PID controller has the capability to manage tritium production within a LiPb liquid blanket.     

Utilization of TRISO Fuel with LWR Spent Fuel in Fusion-Fission Hybrid Reactor System

HTRs use a high performance particulate TRISO fuel with ceramic multi-layer coatings due to the high burn up capability and very neutronic performance. TRISO fuel because of capable of high burn up and very neutronic performance is conducted in a D-T fusion driven hybrid reactor. In this study, TRISO fuels particles are imbedded body-centered cubic (BCC) in a graphite matrix with a volume fraction of 68%. The neutronic effect of TRISO coated LWR spent fuel in the fuel rod used hybrid reactor on the fuel performance has been investigated for Flibe, Flinabe and Li₂₀Sn₈₀ coolants. The reactor operation time with the different first neutron wall loads is 24 months. Neutron transport calculations are evaluated by using XSDRNPM/SCALE 5 codes with 238 group cross section library. The effect of TRISO coated LWR spent fuel in the fuel rod used hybrid reactor on tritium breeding (TBR), energy multiplication (M), fissile fuel breeding, average burn up values are comparatively investigated. It is shown that the high burn up can be achieved with TRISO fuel in the hybrid reactor.     

Effect of water adsorption on tritium release from Li4SiO4

As a ceramic material proposed for tritium breeding in a fusion reactor blanket, lithium orthosilicate (Li₄SiO₄) is being examined in view of the influence of water uptake on tritium release behavior. In this work, out-of-pile tritium release experiments were performed on Li₄SiO₄ samples that were transferred and stored under different moisture environments. The water content was measured on the samples that were treated in similar conditions. Effects of water adsorption on the chemical form and temperature of released tritium were investigated. It is found that with the water content increases, the gaseous tritium fraction decreases and the proportion of low-temperature desorption of HTO increases. The results of this study can be used later for engineering and design activities for fusion reactor blankets.     

Different Mechanisms for Establishing Liquid Walls in Advanced Reactor Systems

The APEX study is investigating the use of free flowing liquid surfaces to form the inner surface of the chamber around a fusion plasma. In this study the modeling of APEX hybrid reactor produced by using ARIES-RS hybrid reactor technology, was performed by using the Monte Carlo code and ENF/B–V–VI nuclear data. The most important feature of APEX hybrid reactor is that the first wall surrounding the plasma is liquid. The advantages of utilizing a liquid wall are high power density capacity, good power transformation productivity the magnitude of the reactor’s operational duration, low failure percentage, short maintenance time and the inclusion of the system’s simple technology and material. Around the fusion chamber, molten salt Li₂BeF₄ and natural lithium were used as cooling materials. The result of the study indicated that fissile material production UF₄ and ThF₄ heavy metal salt increased nearly at the same percentage.