Site-specific mass tagging with stable isotopes in proteins for accurate and efficient protein identification

Proteolytic peptide mass mapping as measured by mass spectrometry provides a major approach for the identification of proteins. A protein is usually identified by the best match between the measured and calculated m/z values of the proteolytic peptides. A unique identification is, however, heavily dependent upon the mass accuracy and sequence coverage of the fragment ions generated by peptide ionization. Without ultrahigh instrumental accuracy, it is possible to increase the specificity of the assignments of particular proteolytic peptides by the incorporation of selected amino acid residue(s) enriched with stable isotope(s) into the protein sequence. Here we report this novel method of generating residue-specific mass-tagged proteolytic peptides for accurate and efficient protein identification. Selected amino acids are labeled with 13C/15N/2H and incorporated into proteins in a sequence-specific manner during cell culturing. Each of these labeled amino acids carries a defined mass change encoded in its monoisotopic distribution pattern. Through their characteristic patterns, the peptides with mass tags can then be readily distinguished from other peptides in mass spectra. This method of identifying unique proteins can also be extended to protein complexes and will significantly increase data search specificity, efficiency, and accuracy for protein identifications.     

Single peptide-based protein identification in human proteome through MALDI-TOF MS coupled with amino acids coded mass tagging

Identification of proteins with low sequence coverage using mass spectrometry (MS) requires tandem MS/MS peptide sequencing. It is very challenging to obtain a complete or to interpret an incomplete tandem MS/MS spectrum from fragmentation of a weak peptide ion signal for sequence assignment. Here, we have developed an effective and high-throughput MALDI-TOF-based method for the identification of membrane and other low-abundance proteins with a simple, one-dimensional separation step. In this approach, several stable isotope-labeled amino acid precursors were selected to mass-tag, in parallel, the human proteome of human skin fibroblast cells in a residue-specific manner during in vivo cell culturing. These labeled residues can be recognized by their characteristic isotope patterns in MALDI-TOF MS spectra. The isotope pattern of particular peptides induced by the different labeled precursors provides information about their amino acid compositions. The specificity of peptide signals in a peptide mass mapping is thus greatly enhanced, resolving a high degree of mass degeneracy of proteolytic peptides derived from the complex human proteome. Further, false positive matches in database searching can be eliminated. More importantly, proteins can be accurately identified through a single peptide with its m/z value and partial amino acid composition. With the increased solubility of hydrophobic proteins in SDS, we have demonstrated that our approach is effective for the identification of membrane and low-abundant proteins with low sequence coverage and weak signal intensity, which are often difficult for obtaining informative fragment patterns in tandem MS/MS peptide sequencing analysis.     

Subtyping botulinum neurotoxins by sequential multiple endoproteases in-gel digestion coupled with mass spectrometry

Botulinum neurotoxin (BoNT) is one of the most toxic substances known. BoNT is classified into seven distinct serotypes labeled A-G. Among individual serotypes, researchers have identified subtypes based on amino acid variability within a serotype and toxin variants with minor amino acid sequence differences within a subtype. BoNT subtype identification is valuable for tracing and tracking bacterial pathogens. A proteomics approach is useful for BoNT subtyping since botulism is caused by botulinum neurotoxin and does not require the presence of the bacteria or its DNA. Enzymatic digestion and peptide identification using tandem mass spectrometry determines toxin protein sequences. However, with the conventional one-step digestion method, producing sufficient numbers of detectable peptides to cover the entire protein sequence is difficult, and incomplete sequence coverage results in uncertainty in distinguishing BoNT subtypes and toxin variants because of high sequence similarity. We report here a method of multiple enzymes and sequential in-gel digestion (MESID) to characterize the BoNT protein sequence. Complementary peptide detection from toxin digestions has yielded near-complete sequence coverage for all seven BoNT serotypes. Application of the method to a BoNT-contaminated carrot juice sample resulted in the identification of 98.4% protein sequence which led to a confident determination of the toxin subtype.     

MultiTag: multiple error-tolerant sequence tag search for the sequence-similarity identification of proteins by mass spectrometry

The characterization of proteomes by mass spectrometry is largely limited to organisms with sequenced genomes. To identify proteins from organisms with unsequenced genomes, database sequences from related species must be employed for sequence-similarity protein identifications. Peptide sequence tags (Mann, 1994) have been used successfully for the identification of proteins in sequence databases using partially interpreted tandem mass spectra of tryptic peptides. We have extended the ability of sequence tag searching to the identification of proteins whose sequences are yet unknown but are homologous to known database entries. The MultiTag method presented here assigns statistical significance to matches of multiple error-tolerant sequence tags to a database entry and ranks alignments by their significance. The MultiTag approach has the distinct advantage over other sequence-similarity approaches of being able to perform sequence-similarity identifications using only very short (2-4) amino acid residue stretches of peptide sequences, rather than complete peptide sequences deduced by de novo interpretation of tandem mass spectra. This feature facilitates the identification of low abundance proteins, since noisy and low-intensity tandem mass spectra can be utilized.     

Use of performic acid oxidation to expand the mass distribution of tryptic peptides

Significant identification of proteins by mass fingerprinting and partial sequencing of tryptic peptides is central to proteomics. However, peptide masses cluster with distances of approximately 1 Da. Expanding these clusters will give more peptides of unique masses, thereby identifying proteins with a higher significance. The mass clusters can be expanded downward by including more oxygen atoms in the peptides. Classic performic acid oxidation modifies three residues, Cys to CysO(3), Met to MetO(2), and Trp to TrpO(2). In this study, we compare the mass distributions of tryptic peptides computed from the predicted proteomes of Bacillus subtilis, Drosophila melanogaster, Arabidopsis thaliana, and Homo sapiens modified by oxidation, reduction, and reduction followed by carboxymethylation, carboxamidomethylation, or pyridylethylation. Forty to 46% of the eukaryotic tryptic peptides contain Cys, Met, or Trp. Additionally, the importance of mass accuracy of differentially modified tryptic peptides for significant protein identification by database searches was analyzed. The results show that performic acid oxidation gives markedly extended mass distributions at mass accuracies from +/-0.002 to +/-0.25 Da for the eukaryotes. The effect of the expanded mass distribution on significant protein identification was illustrated by searching simulated mass peak lists against the databases containing oxidized and reduced tryptic peptides. The specificity of formic acid oxidation was tested experimentally, and no general adverse effects were detected. Tryptic peptides provided a 100% sequence coverage of oxidized barley grain peroxidase by LC-MS, and the sequence coverages of oxidized and carboxymethylated bovine serum albumin were similar by MALDI-TOF MS analyses.     

Residue-specific mass signatures for the efficient detection of protein modifications by mass spectrometry

Currently available mass spectrometric (MS) techniques lack specificity in identifying protein modifications because molecular mass is the only parameter used to characterize these changes. Consequently, the suspected modified peptides are subjected to tandem MS/MS sequencing that may demand more time and sample. We report the use of stable isotope-enriched amino acids as residue-specific "mass signatures" for the rapid and sensitive detection of protein modifications directly from the peptide mass map (PMM) without enrichment of the modified peptides. These mass signatures are easily recognized through their characteristic spectral patterns and provide fingerprints for peptides containing the same content of specific amino acid residue(s) in a PMM. Without the need for tandem MS/MS sequencing, a peptide and its modified form(s) can readily be identified through their identical fingerprints, regardless of the nature of modifications. In this report, we demonstrate this strategy for the detection of methionine oxidation and protein phosphorylation. More interestingly, the phosphorylation of a histone protein, H2A.X, obtained from human skin fibroblast cells, was effectively identified in response to low-dose radiation. In general, this strategy of residue-specific mass tagging should be applicable to other posttranslational modifications.     

Suppression of matrix clusters and enhancement of peptide signals in MALDI-TOF mass spectrometry using nitrilotriacetic acid

Matrix clusters and their alkali metal ion adducts suppress peptide signals in the 500-1400 Da range and compromise MALDI-TOF mass spectrometric peptide mass fingerprinting and protein identification. Addition of 7 mM nitrilotriacetic acid to the matrix solution significantly reduced matrix clusters and increased signal-to-noise ratio of peptide signals approximately 5 to 20-fold. As a result, reliability in the identification of femtomole amounts of proteins based on peptide mass fingerprinting and database search was significantly enhanced, leading to a higher score and sequence coverage.     

Shotgun protein sequencing by tandem mass spectra assembly

The analysis of mass spectrometry data is still largely based on identification of single MS/MS spectra and does not attempt to make use of the extra information available in multiple MS/MS spectra from partially or completely overlapping peptides. Analysis of MS/MS spectra from multiple overlapping peptides opens up the possibility of assembling MS/MS spectra into entire proteins, similarly to the assembly of overlapping DNA reads into entire genomes. In this paper, we present for the first time a way to detect, score, and interpret overlaps between uninterpreted MS/MS spectra in an attempt to sequence entire proteins rather than individual peptides. We show that this approach not only extends the length of reconstructed amino acid sequences but also dramatically improves the quality of de novo peptide sequencing, even for low mass accuracy MS/MS data.     

Comprehensive comparison of collision induced dissociation and electron transfer dissociation

Electron transfer dissociation (ETD) is a recently introduced mass spectrometric technique which has proven to be an excellent tool for the elucidation of labile post-translational modifications such as phosphorylation and O-GlcNAcylation of serine and threonine residues. However, unlike collision induced dissociation (CID), which has been studied for decades, the intricacies of ETD-based fragmentation have not yet been firmly established or systematically addressed. In this analysis, we have systematically compared the CID and ETD fragmentation patterns for the large majority of the peptides that do not contain such labile modifications. Using a standard 48 protein mix, we were able to measure false-positive rates for the experiments and also assess a large number of peptides for a detailed comparison of CID and ETD fragmentation pattern. Analysis of approximately 19,000 peptides derived from both standard proteins and complex protein samples revealed that (i) CID identified 50% more peptides than ETD; (ii) ETD resulted in approximately 20% increase in amino acid sequence coverage over CID; and (iii) combining CID and ETD fragmentation increased the sequence coverage for an average tryptic peptide to 92%. Interestingly, our analysis revealed that nearly 60% of all ETD-identified peptides carried two positive charges, which is in sharp contrast to what has been generally accepted. We also present a novel strategy for automatic validation of peptide assignments based on identification of a peptide by consecutive CID and ETD fragmentation in an alternating mode.     

Thermal denaturation: a useful technique in peptide mass mapping

The use of thermal denaturation of proteins prior to in-solution digestion and mass spectral peptide mass mapping is reported. Thermal denaturation is preferred over chemical denaturation because it does not require purification/concentration prior to mass spectral analysis. Enzymatic digestions of proteins that are resistant to proteolysis are significantly enhanced by thermal denaturation. Native proteins that are sensitive to proteolysis show similar or slightly lower digestion yields following thermal denaturation. Proteins that are resistant to digestion become more susceptible to digestion, independent of protein size, following thermal denaturation. For example, amino acid sequence coverage from digest fragments increases from 15 to 86% in myoglobin and from 0 to 43% in ovalbumin. This leads to more rapid and reliable protein identification by MALDI peptide mass mapping. Although some proteins aggregate upon thermal denaturation, the protein aggregates are easily digested by trypsin and generate sufficient numbers of digest fragments for protein identification.     

Alkylating tryptic peptides to enhance electrospray ionization mass spectrometry analysis

A major limitation of mass spectrometry-based proteomics is inefficient and differential ionization during electrospray ionization (ESI). This leads to problems such as increased limits of detection and incomplete sequence coverage of proteins. Incomplete sequence coverage is especially problematic for analyses that require the detection and identification of specific peptides from a protein, such as the analysis of post-translational modifications. We describe here the development and use of aldehyde-based chemistry for the alkylation of peptide primary amines to increase peptide hydrophobicity, providing increased ionization efficiency and concomitant signal enhancement. When employed to modify the peptide products of protein tryptic digests, increased sequence coverage is obtained from combined modified and unmodified digests. To evaluate the utility of alkylation of peptides for selected reaction monitoring (SRM) assays, we alkylated a peptide from the protein Oct4, known to play a role in regulating stem cell differentiation. Increased chromatographic retention and ionization efficiency is observed for the alkylated Oct4 peptide compared to its unmodified form.     

MALDI MS peptide mapping performance by in-gel digestion on a probe with prestructured sample supports

Matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization (tandem) mass spectrometry (MALDI MS) is widely used in protein chemistry and proteomics research for the identification and characterization of proteins isolated by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. In an effort to minimize sample handling and increase sample throughput, we have developed a novel in-gel digestion protocol where sample preparation is performed directly on a MALDI probe with prestructured sample support. The protocol consists of few sample-handling steps and has minimal consumption of reagents, making the protocol sensitive, timesaving, and cost-efficient. Performance of the on-probe sample preparation protocol was demonstrated by analysis of a set of rat liver proteins obtained from a fluorescently stained (Cy3 and SyproRuby) two-dimensional polyacrylamide gel. The success rate of protein identification by on-probe tryptic digestion and MALDI peptide mass mapping was 89%. The on-probe in-gel digestion procedure provided superior sensitivity and peptide mass mapping performance as compared to our standard in-gel digestion protocol. The on-probe digestion technique resulted in significantly improved amino acid sequence coverage of proteins, mainly due to efficient recovery and detection of large (>1.5 kDa) hydrophobic peptides. These observations indicate that numerous tryptic peptides are lost when using the standard in-gel digestion methods and sample preparation techniques for MALDI MS. This study also demonstrates that the on-probe digestion protocol combined with MALDI tandem mass spectrometry provides a robust platform for proteomics research, including protein identification and determination of posttranslational modifications.     

Improving protein identification sensitivity by combining MS and MS/MS information for shotgun proteomics using LTQ-Orbitrap high mass accuracy data

We investigated and compared three approaches for shotgun protein identification by combining MS and MS/MS information using LTQ-Orbitrap high mass accuracy data. In the first approach, we employed a unique mass identifier method where MS peaks matched to peptides predicted from proteins identified from an MS/MS database search are first subtracted before using the MS peaks as unique mass identifiers for protein identification. In the second method, we used an accurate mass and time tag method by building a potential mass and retention time database from previous MudPIT analyses. For the third method, we used a peptide mass fingerprinting-like approach in combination with a randomized database for protein identification. We show that we can improve protein identification sensitivity for low-abundance proteins by combining MS and MS/MS information. Furthermore, "one-hit wonders" from MS/MS database searching can be further substantiated by MS information and the approach improves the identification of low-abundance proteins. The advantages and disadvantages for the three approaches are then discussed.     

Proteolysis in mixed organic-aqueous solvent systems: applications for peptide mass mapping using mass spectrometry

The rate of protein digestion imposes significant limitations on high-throughput protein identification using mass spectrometry. In this report, we demonstrate that proteins are readily digested by trypsin in the presence of organic solvents such as methanol, acetone, 2-propanol, and acetonitrile. The rates of protein digestion in organic solvents, as indicated by the abundances of digest fragment ions in the mass spectrum, are increased relative to aqueous solution. In addition, amino acid coverage for the analyzed proteins increases in the presence of the organic solvents, and proteins that are resistant to proteolysis are readily digested. For example, a 68% amino acid sequence coverage was attained from a tryptic digest of myoglobin in < 5 min from an 80% acetonitrile solution, whereas no digest fragments were detected from a 5 min digestion in an aqueous solution. Moreover, the tryptic digestion of a complex protein mixture in an organic-aqueous solvent system showed significantly enhanced digestion for nearly all of the protein components. Enzymatic digestion in an organic-aqueous solvent system is a rapid, simple, and effective peptide mass-mapping technique.     

C-terminal sequence analysis of peptides and proteins using carboxypeptidases and mass spectrometry after derivatization of Lys and Cys residues

C-Terminal sequence analysis of peptides and proteins using carboxypeptidase digestion in combination with matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization mass spectrometry (MALDI-MS) is convenient for protein and peptide characterization. After a short digestion, a sequence up to 20 residues can be identified, but the total number depends on the individual sequence. Due to the accuracy limits of the MALDI time-of-flight arrangement, the assignment of several residues with close mass values, including Lys/Glx, may remain ambiguous. We have used derivatization of lysine residues by guanidination to overcome the problem of Lys identification. The reaction is rapid and specific and results in full derivatization. In the case of Cys-containing peptides, problems arise from the fact that carboxypeptidases Y and P do not cleave peptides that contain nonderivatized cystine, cysteic acid, or (carboxymethyl)cysteine. Successful identification of Cys residues within the sequence is instead achieved by conversion of Cys to 4-thialaminine by (trimethylamino)-ethylation. The two derivatizations of Lys and Cys side chains provide opportunities for proton attachment and therefore facilitate the analysis by MALDI-MS. This C-terminal sequence analysis method is also useful for large proteins after fragmentation with specific enzymes.     

Identification of phosphoserine and phosphothreonine as cysteic acid and beta-methylcysteic acid residues in peptides by tandem mass spectrometric sequencing

Tandem mass spectrometry has long been an intrinsic tool to determine phosphorylation sites in proteins. However, loss of the phosphate moiety from both phosphoserine and phosphothreonine residues in low-energy collision-induced dissociation is a common phenomenon, which makes identification of P-Ser and P-Thr residues complicated. A method for direct sequencing of the Ser and Thr phosphorylation sites by ESI tandem mass spectrometry following beta-elimination/sulfite addition to convert -HPO4 to -SO3 has been studied. Five model phosphopeptides, including three synthetic P-Ser-, P-Thr-, or P-Ser- and P-Thr-containing peptides; a protein kinases C-phosphorylated peptide; and a phosphopeptide derived from beta-casein trypsin digests were modified and then sequenced using an ESI-quadrupole ion trap mass spectrometer. Following incubation of P-Ser- or P-Thr-containing peptides with Na2SO3/NaOH, 90% P-Ser and 80% P-Thr was converted to cysteic acid and beta-methylcysteic acid, respectively, as revealed by amino acid analysis. The conversion can be carried out at 1 microM concentration of the peptide. Both cysteic acid and beta-methylcysteic acid residues in the sequence were shown to be stable and easily identifiable under general conditions for tandem mass spectrometric sequencing applicable to common peptides.     

Comparison of electrokinetics-based multidimensional separations coupled with electrospray ionization-tandem mass spectrometry for characterization of human salivary proteins

The foundation for saliva-based diagnostics is the development of a complete catalog of secreted proteins detectable in saliva. Besides protein complexity, the greatest bioanalytical challenge facing comprehensive analysis of saliva samples is related to the large variation of protein relative abundances including the presence of high-abundance proteins such as amylases, mucins, proline-rich proteins (PRPs), and secretory IgA complex. Among a number of electrokinetic separation techniques, transient capillary isotachophoresis/capillary zone electrophoresis (CITP/CZE) specifically targets trace amounts of proteins and thus reduces the range of relative protein abundances for providing unparallel advantages toward the identification of low-abundance proteins. By employing a CITP/CZE-based multidimensional separation platform coupled with electrospray ionization-tandem mass spectrometry (ESI-tandem MS), a total of 6112 fully tryptic peptides are sequenced at a 1% false discovery rate (FDR), leading to the identification of 1479 distinct human SwissProt protein entries. By comparing with capillary isoelectric focusing (CIEF) as another electrokinetics-based stacking approach, CITP/CZE not only offers a broad field of application but also is less prone to protein/peptide precipitation during the analysis. The ultrahigh resolving power of CITP/CZE is evidenced by the large number of distinct peptide identifications measured from each CITP fraction together with the low peptide fraction overlapping among identified peptides. Furthermore, when evaluating the protein sequence coverage by the number of distinct peptides mapping to each protein identification, the CITP-based proteome technology similarly achieves the superior performance with 674 proteins (46%) having three or more distinct peptides, 288 (19%) having two distinct peptides, and 517 (35%) having a single distinct peptide.     

Studies of histidine as a suitable isoelectric buffer for tryptic digestion and isoelectric trapping fractionation followed by capillary electrophoresis-mass spectrometry for proteomic analysis

The use of histidine as a protein digestion buffer followed by isoelectric trapping separations using "membrane separated wells for isoelectric focusing and trapping" (MSWIFT) and mass spectrometry (MS) analysis is described. Tryptic digestion of bovine serum albumin (BSA) performed in histidine buffered solutions yields similar amino acid sequence coverage values to those obtained using ammonium bicarbonate buffer. Time course studies suggest that histidine buffers provide faster migration of peptides from the loading compartment compared to digestions prepared in ammonium bicarbonate due to differences in conductivities of the two buffers. In addition, this sample preparation method and MSWIFT separations have been coupled with capillary electrophoresis (CE) and matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization-mass spectrometry (MALDI-MS) as an alternative separation approach for proteomic studies. Tryptic peptides of ribosomal proteins in histidine are fractionated using MSWIFT followed by CE-MALDI-MS, which further illustrates the ability to couple fractions from a pI based separation device to CE-MS. Specifically, two-dimensional CE-MS plots provide a direct correlation between the numbers of basic residues within the peptide sequence displayed in charge-state trend lines. Combining MSWIFT and CE-MS provides added information regarding peptide sequence, specifically pI and in-solution charge state. Post-translational modifications can also be identified using this method.     

Characterization of a variant of the spinach PSII type I light-harvesting protein using kinetically controlled digestion and RP-HPLC-ESI-MS

A previously unknown isoform of the type I major antenna protein of photosystem II of spinach was identified, and its amino-terminal sequence was characterized by a novel kinetic digestion approach, in which sequential tryptic digestion was followed by analysis of both released peptides and truncated proteins by reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography-electrospray ionization mass spectrometry. Using nonpolar, monolithic, 200-microm-i.d. separation columns based on poly(styrene/divinylbenzene) copolymer and applying gradients of acetonitrile in 0.05% aqueous trifluoroacetic acid, released peptides and truncated proteins could be separated and mass analyzed in a single chromatographic run. This enabled a straightforward identification of the fragments removed from the amino-terminal ends of the protein, which was essential for the characterization of the antenna isomers showing the most significant sequence variation in the amino-terminal region. The sequences of the amino termini were derived from the differences in molecular mass between intact and truncated proteins and were corroborated by sequencing using tandem mass spectrometry and database searching. The sequence of the 23 amino-terminal residues of the previously unknown isoform differed from that of the other two known isoforms only in one and three amino acids, respectively. Such subtle changes in amino acid sequence are supposed to play an important role in the supramolecular organization of photosynthetic antenna proteins.     

Rapid online nonenzymatic protein digestion combining microwave heating acid hydrolysis and electrochemical oxidation

We report an online nonenzymatic method for site-specific digestion of proteins to yield peptides that are well suited for collision-induced dissociation tandem mass spectrometry. The method combines online microwave heating acid hydrolysis at aspartic acid and online electrochemical oxidation at tryptophan and tyrosine. The combined microwave/electrochemical digestion is reproducible and produces peptides with an average sequence length of 10 amino acids. This peptide length is similar to the average peptide length of 9 amino acids obtained by digestion of proteins with the enzyme trypsin. As a result, the peptides produced by this novel nonenzymatic digestion method, when analyzed by electrospray ionization mass spectrometry, produce protonated molecules with mostly +1 and +2 charge states. The combination of these two nonenzymatic methods overcomes shortcomings with each individual method in that (i) peptides generated by the microwave-hydrolysis method have an average amino acid length of 16 amino acids and (ii) the electrochemical-cleavage method is unable to reproducibly digest proteins with molecular masses above 4 kDa. Preliminary results are presented on the application and utility of this rapid online digestion (total of 6 min of digestion time) on a series of standard peptides and proteins as well as an Escherichia coli protein extract.