Modelling of a fluidized bed carbonator reactor to capture CO2 from a combustion flue gas

In recent years several processes incorporating a carbonation-calcination loop in an interconnected fluidized bed reactor have been proposed as a way to capture CO₂ from flue gases. This paper is a first approximation to the modelling of a fluidized bed carbonator reactor. In this reactor the flue gas comes into contact with an active bed composed of particles with very different activities, depending on their residence time in the bed and in the carbonation-calcination loop. The model combines the residence time distribution functions with existing knowledge about sorbent deactivation rates and sorbent reactivity. The fluid dynamics of the solids (CSTR) and gases (PF) in the carbonator are based on simple assumptions. The carbonation rates are modelled defining a characteristic time for the transition between a fast reaction regime to a regime with a zero reaction rate. On the basis of these assumptions the model is able to predict the CO₂ capture efficiency for the flue gas depending on the operating and design conditions. Operating windows with high capture efficiencies are discussed, as well as those conditions where only modest capture efficiencies are possible.     

Economical assessment of competitive enhanced limestones for CO2 capture cycles in power plants

CO₂ capture systems based on the carbonation/calcination loop have gained rapid interest due to promising carbonator CO₂ capture efficiency, low sorbent cost and no flue gases treatment is required before entering the system. These features together result in a competitively low cost CO₂ capture system. Among the key variables that influence the performance of these systems and their integration with power plants, the carbonation conversion of the sorbent and the heat requirement at calciner are the most relevant. Both variables are mainly influenced by CaO/CO₂ ratio and make-up flow of solids. New sorbents are under development to reduce the decay of their carbonation conversion with cycles. The aim of this study is to assess the competitiveness of new limestones with enhanced sorption behaviour applied to carbonation/calcination cycle integrated with a power plant, compared to raw limestone. The existence of an upper limit for the maximum average capture capacity of CaO has been considered. Above this limit, improving sorbent capture capacity does not lead to the corresponding increase in capture efficiency and, thus, reduction of CO₂ avoided cost is not observed. Simulations calculate the maximum price for enhanced sorbents to achieve a reduction in CO₂ removal cost under different process conditions (solid circulation and make-up flow). The present study may be used as an assessment tool of new sorbents to understand what prices would be competitive compare with raw limestone in the CO₂ looping capture systems.     

Sorbent attrition in a carbonation/calcination pilot plant for capturing CO2 from flue gases

There is increasing interest in CO₂ looping cycles that involve the repeated calcination and carbonation of the sorbent as a way to capture CO₂ from flue gases during the carbonation step and the generation of a pure stream of CO₂ in the oxyfired calcination step. In particular, attrition of the material in these interconnected fluidized bed reactors is a problem of general concern. Attrition of limestone derived materials has been studied in fluidized bed systems by numerous authors. In this work, we have investigated the attrition of two limestones used in a system of two interconnected circulating fluidized bed reactors operating in continuous mode as carbonation and calciner reactors. We observed a rapid initial attrition of both limestones during the calcination step which was then followed by a highly stable period (up to 140 h of added circulation for one of the limestones) during which particle size changes were negligible. This is consistent with previous observations of attrition in other systems that employ these materials. However, a comparison of the attrition model constants with the data reported in the literature showed the two limestones to be particularly fragile during the initial calcination and the first few hours of circulation. Thus, a careful choice of limestone based on its attrition properties must be taken into account in designing future carbonate looping systems.     

Investigation into a gas–solid–solid three-phase fluidized-bed carbonator to capture CO2 from combustion flue gas

A two-dimensional (2D) transient model was developed to simulate the local hydrodynamics of a gas (flue gas)–solid (CaO)–solid (CaCO₃) three-phase fluidized-bed carbonator using the computational fluid dynamic method, where the chemical reaction model was adopted to determine the molar fraction of CO₂ at the exit of carbonator and the partial pressure of CO₂ in the carbonator. This investigation was intended to improve an understanding of the chemical reaction effects of CaO with CO₂ on the CO₂ capture efficiency of combustion flue gases. For this purpose, we had utilized Fluent 6.2 to predict the CO₂ capture efficiency for different operation conditions. The adopted model concerning the reaction rate of CaO with CO₂ is joined into the CFD software. Model simulation results, such as the local time-averaged CO₂ molar fraction and conversion of CaO, were validated by experimental measurements under varied operating conditions, e.g., the fraction of active CaO, chemical reaction temperature, particle size, and cycle number at different locations in a gas–solid–solid three-phase fluidized bed carbonator. Furthermore, the local transient hydrodynamic characteristics, such as gas molar fraction and partial pressure were predicted reasonably by the chemical reaction model adopted for the dynamic behaviors of the gas–solid–solid three-phase fluidized bed carbonator. On the basis of this analysis, capture CO₂ strategies to reduce CO₂ molar fraction in exit of carbonator reactor can be developed in the future. It is concluded that a fluidized bed of CaO can be a suitable reactor to achieve very effective CO₂ capture from combustion flue gases.     

烟气中水蒸气对钙基吸收剂碳酸化的影响特性

在循环煅烧/碳酸化反应系统上考察煅烧气氛和碳酸化气氛中水蒸气含量以及CO₂分压对钙基吸收剂成型颗粒碳酸化的影响,通过对钙基吸收剂微观结构分析(扫描电镜、氮吸附分析)以理解水蒸气影响碳酸化特性的机理。结果表明,煅烧气氛和碳酸化气氛中的水蒸气均可提高钙基吸收剂的碳酸化转化率,水蒸气含量分别为10%和5%时,吸收剂的碳酸化性能较好;水蒸气在碳酸化气氛中对高铝水泥改性吸收剂的改善作用较石灰石显著。煅烧气氛中的CO₂分压越高,烧结现象越严重,降低钙基吸收剂的捕集效率;碳酸化气氛CO₂分压提高,有利于提高钙基吸收剂的碳酸化转化率。烟气中水蒸气丰富了吸收剂的微观孔隙,使得吸收剂捕集CO₂性能得到改善。     

Sulfation Rates of Particles in Calcium Looping Reactors

The sulfation reaction rate of CaO particles in three reactors comprising a post‐combustion calcium looping system is discussed: a combustion chamber generating flue gases, a carbonator reactor to capture CO₂ and SO₂, and an oxy‐fired calciner to regenerate the CO₂ sorbent. Due to its strong impact on the pore size distribution of CaO particles, the number of carbonation/calcination cycles arises as a new important variable to understand sulfation phenomena. Sulfation patterns change as a result of particle cycling, becoming more homogeneous with higher number of cycles. Experimental results from thermogravimetric tests demonstrate that high sulfation rates can be measured under all conditions tested, indicating that the calcium looping systems will be extremely efficient in SO₂ capture.     

NO removal performance of CO in carbonation stage of calcium looping for CO2 capture

Calcium looping realizes CO2 capture via the cyclic calcination/carbonation of CaO.The combustion of fuel supplies energy for the calciner.It is unavoidable that some unburned char in the calciner flows into the carbonator,generating CO due to the hypoxic atmosphere in the carbonator.CO can reduce NO in the flue gases from coal-fired power plants.In this work,NO removal performance of CO in the carbonation stage of calcium looping for CO2 capture was investigated in a bubbling fluidized bed reactor.The effects of carbonation temperature,CO concentration,CO2 capture,type of CaO,number of CO2 capture cycles and presence of char on NO removal by CO in carbonation stage of calcium looping were discussed.CaO possesses an efficient catalytic effect on NO removal by CO.High temperature and high CO concen-tration lead to high NO removal efficiency of CO in the presence of CaO.Taking account of better NO removal and CO2 capture,the optimal carbonation temperature is 650 ℃.The carbonation of CaO reduces the catalytic activity of CaO for NO removal by CO due to the formation of CaCO3.Besides,the catalytic performance of CaO on NO removal by CO gradually decreases with the number of CO2 capture cycles.This is because the sintering of CaO leads to the fusion of CaO grains and blockage of pores in CaO,hin-dering the diffusion of NO and CO.The high CaO content and porous structure of calcium-based sorbents are beneficial for NO removal by CO.The presence of char promotes NO removal by CO in the carbonator.CO2/NO removal efficiencies can reach above 90％.The efficient simultaneous NO and CO2 removal by CO and CaO in the carbonation step of the calcium looping seems promising.     

Enhancement of Ca‐Based Sorbent Multicyclic Behavior in Ca Looping Process for CO2 Separation

The Ca‐based sorbent looping cycle represents an innovative way of CO₂ capture for power plants. However, the CO₂ capture capacity of the Ca‐based sorbent decays sharply with calcination/carbonation cycle number increasing. In order to improve the CO₂ capture capacity of the sorbent in the Ca looping cycle, limestone was modified with acetic acid solution. The cyclic carbonation behaviors of the modified and original limestones were investigated in a twin fixed‐bed reactor system. The modified limestone possesses better cyclic carbonation kinetics than the original limestone at each cycle. The modified limestone carbonated at 640–660 °C achieves the optimum carbonation conversion. The acetic acid modification improves the long‐term performance of limestone, resulting in directly measured conversion as high as 0.4 after 100 cycles, while the original limestone remains at a conversion of less than 0.1 at the same reaction conditions. Both the pore volume and pore area distributions of the calcines derived from the modified limestone are better than those derived from the original limestone. The CO₂ partial pressure for carbonation has greater effect on conversion of the original limestone than on that of the modified sorbent because of the difference in their pore structure characteristics. The carbonation conversion of the original limestone decreases with the increase in particle size, while the change in particle size of the modified sorbent has no clear effect on cyclic carbonation behavior.     

Experimental investigation of a circulating fluidized‐bed reactor to capture CO2 with CaO

Calcium looping processes for capturing CO₂ from large emissions sources are based on the use of CaO particles as sorbent in circulating fluidized‐bed (CFB) reactors. A continuous flow of CaO from an oxyfired calciner is fed into the carbonator and a certain inventory of active CaO is expected to capture the CO₂ in the flue gas. The circulation rate and the inventory of CaO determine the CO₂ capture efficiency. Other parameters such as the average carrying capacity of the CaO circulating particles, the temperature, and the gas velocity must be taken into account. To investigate the effect of these variables on CO₂ capture efficiency, we used a 6.5 m height CFB carbonator connected to a twin CFB calciner. Many stationary operating states were achieved using different operating conditions. The trends of CO₂ capture efficiency measured are compared with those from a simple reactor model. This information may contribute to the future scaling up of the technology. © 2010 American Institute of Chemical Engineers AIChE J, 57: 000–000, 2011     

CO2 Capture Behavior of Shell during Calcination/Carbonation Cycles

The cyclic carbonation performances of shells as CO₂ sorbents were investigated during multiple calcination/carbonation cycles. The carbonation kinetics of the shell and limestone are similar since they both exhibit a fast kinetically controlled reaction regime and a diffusion controlled reaction regime, but their carbonation rates differ between these two regions. Shell achieves the maximum carbonation conversion for carbonation at 680–700 °C. The mactra veneriformis shell and mussel shell exhibit higher carbonation conversions than limestone after several cycles at the same reaction conditions. The carbonation conversion of scallop shell is slightly higher than that of limestone after a series of cycles. The calcined shell appears more porous than calcined limestone, and possesses more pores > 230 nm, which allow large CO₂ diffusion‐carbonation reaction rates and higher conversion due to the increased surface area of the shell. The pores of the shell that are greater than 230 nm do not sinter significantly. The shell has more sodium ions than limestone, which probably leads to an improvement in the cyclic carbonation performance during the multiple calcination/carbonation cycles.     

The combined effect of H2O and SO2 on the simultaneous calcination/sulfation reaction in CFBs

The combined effect of H₂O and SO₂ on the reaction kinetics and pore structure of limestone during simultaneous calcination/sulfation reactions under circulating fluidized bed (CFB) conditions was first studied in a constant-temperature reactor. H₂O can accelerate the sulfation reaction rate in the slow-sulfation stage significantly but has a smaller effect in the fast-sulfation stage. H₂O can also accelerate the calcination of CaCO₃, and should be considered as a catalyst, as the activation energy for the calcination reaction was lower in the presence of H₂O. When the limestone particles are calcining, SO₂ in the flue gas can react with CaO on the outer particle layer and the resulting CaSO₄ blocks the CaO pores, increases the diffusion resistance of CO₂, and, in consequence, decreases the calcination rate of CaCO₃. Here, gases containing 15% H₂O and 0.3% SO₂ are shown to increase the calcination rate. This means that the accelerating effect of 15% H₂O on CaCO₃ decomposition is stronger than the impeding effect caused by 0.3% SO₂. The calcination rate of limestone particles was controlled by both the intrinsic reaction and the CO₂ diffusion rate in the pores, but the intrinsic reaction rate played a major role as indicated by the effectiveness factors determined in this work. This may explain the synergic effect of H₂O and SO₂ on CaCO₃ decomposition observed here. Finally, the effect of H₂O and SO₂ on sulfur capture in a 600 MWe CFB boiler burning petroleum coke is also analyzed. The sulfation performance of limestone evaluated by simultaneous calcination/sulfation is shown to be much higher than that by sulfation of CaO. Based on our calculations, a novel use of the wet flue gas recycle method was put forward to improve the sulfur capture performance for high-sulfur low-moisture fuels such as petroleum coke. © 2019 American Institute of Chemical Engineers AIChE J, 65: 1256–1268, 2019     

CO2 capture capacity of CaO in long series of pressure swing sorption cycles

One promising method for the capture of CO₂ from point sources is through the usage of a lime-based sorbent. Lime (CaO) acts as a CO₂ carrier, absorbing CO₂ from the flue gas (carbonation) and releasing it in a separate reactor (calcination) to create a pure stream of CO₂ suitable for sequestration. One of the challenges with this process is the decay in calcium utilization (CO₂ capture capacity) during carbonation/calcination cycling. The reduction in calcium utilization of natural limestone over large numbers of cycles (>250) was studied. Cycling was accomplished using pressure swing CO₂ adsorption in a pressurized thermogravimetric reactor (PTGA). The effect of carbonation pressure on calcium utilization was studied in CO₂ with the reactor operated at 1000 °C. The pressure was cycled between atmospheric pressure for calcination, and 6, 11 or 21 bar for carbonation. Over the first 250 cycles, the calcium utilization reached a near-asymptotic value of 12.5-27.7%, depending on the cycling conditions. Pressure cycling resulted in improved long-term calcium utilization compared to temperature swing or CO₂ partial pressure swing adsorption under similar conditions. An increased rate of de-pressurization caused an increase in calcium utilization, attributed to fracturing of the sorbent particle during the rapid calcination, as observed via SEM analysis.     

Modified CaO-based sorbent looping cycle for CO2 mitigation

CaO-based sorbent looping cycle, i.e. cyclic calcination/carbonation, is one of the most interesting technologies for CO₂ capture during coal combustion and gasification processes. In order to improve the durability of limestone during the multiple calcination/carbonation cycles, modified limestone with acetic acid solution was proposed as an CO₂ sorbent. The cyclic carbonation conversions of modified limestone and original one were investigated in a twin fixed bed reactor system. The modified limestone shows the optimum carbonation conversion at the carbonation temperature of 650 °C and achieves a conversion of 0.5 after 20 cycles. The original limestone exhibits the maximum carbonation conversion of 0.15 after 20 cycles. Conversion of the modified limestone decreases slightly as the calcination temperature increases from 920 °C to 1100 °C with the number of cycles, while conversion of the original one displays a sharp decay at the same reaction conditions. The durability of the modified limestone is significantly better than the original one during the multiple cycles because mean grain size of CaO derived from the modified limestone is lower than that from the original one at the same reaction conditions. The calcined modified limestone shows higher surface area and pore volume than the calcined original one with the number of cycles, and pore size distribution of the modified limestone is superior to the original one after the same number of calcinations.     

Simulation of a calcium looping CO2 capture process for pressurized fluidized bed combustion

The Canadian regulations on carbon dioxide emissions from power plants aim to lower the emissions from coal-fired units down to those of natural gas combined cycle (NGCC) units. Since coal is significantly more carbon intensive than natural gas, coal-fired plants must operate at higher net efficiencies and implement carbon capture to meet the new regulations. Calcium looping (CaL) is a promising post-combustion carbon capture (PCC) technology that, unlike other capture processes, generates additional power. By capturing carbon dioxide at elevated temperatures, the energy penalty that carbon capture technologies inherently impose on power plant efficiencies is significantly reduced. In this work, the CO₂ capture performance of a calcium-based sorbent is determined via thermogravimetric analysis under relatively high carbonation and low calcination temperatures. The results are used in an aspenONE™ simulation of a CaL process applied to a pressurized fluidized bed combustion (PFBC) system at thermodynamic equilibrium. The combustion of both natural gas and coal are considered for sorbent calcination in the CaL process. A sensitivity analysis on several process parameters, including sorbent feed rate and carbonator operating pressure, is undertaken. The energy penalty associated with the capture process ranges from 6.8–11.8 percentage points depending on fuel selection and operating conditions. The use of natural gas results in lower energy penalties and solids circulation rates, while operating the carbonator at 202 kPa(a) results in the lowest penalties and drops the solids circulations rates to below 1000 kg/s.     

Sulfation rates of cycled CaO particles in the carbonator of a Ca‐looping cycle for postcombustion CO2 capture

Calcium looping is an energy‐efficient CO₂ capture technology that uses CaO as a regenerable sorbent. One of the advantages of Ca‐looping compared with other postcombustion technologies is the possibility of operating with flue gases that have a high SO₂ content. However, experimental information on sulfation reaction rates of cycled particles in the conditions typical of a carbonator reactor is scarce. This work aims to define a semiempirical sulfation reaction model at particle level suitable for such reaction conditions. The pore blocking mechanism typically observed during the sulfation reaction of fresh calcined limestones is not observed in the case of highly cycled sorbents (N > 20) and the low values of sulfation conversion characteristic of the sorbent in the Ca‐looping system. The random pore model is able to predict reasonably well, the CaO conversion to CaSO₄ taking into account the evolution of the pore structure during the calcination/carbonation cycles. The intrinsic reaction parameters derived for chemical and diffusion controlled regimes are in agreement with those found in the literature for sulfation in other systems. © 2011 American Institute of Chemical EngineersAIChE J, 2012     

Simultaneous Carbonation and Sulfation of CaO in Oxy‐Fuel CFB Combustion

For anthracites and petroleum cokes, the typical combustion temperature in a circulating fluidized bed (CFB) is > 900 °C. At CO₂ concentrations of 80–85 % (typical of oxy‐fuel CFBC conditions), limestone still calcines. When the ash which includes unreacted CaO cools to the calcination temperature, carbonation of fly ash deposited on cool surfaces may occur. At the same time, indirect and direct sulfation of limestone also will occur, possibly leading to more deposition. In this study, CaO was carbonated and sulfated simultaneously in a thermogravimetric analyzer (TGA) under conditions expected in an oxy‐fuel CFBC. It was found that temperature, and concentrations of CO₂, SO₂, and especially H₂O are important factors in determining the carbonation/sulfation reactions of CaO.     

Synthetic Ca‐based solid sorbents suitable for capturing CO2 in a fluidized bed

Coprecipitation and hydrolysis of CaO have been employed to produce Ca‐based synthetic sorbents suitable for capturing CO₂ in a fluidized bed. Their composition, CO₂ uptake, volume in small pores (2–200 nm) and resistance to attrition were measured and compared to those of limestone and dolomite. Sorbents produced by hydrolysis showed the highest uptake and resistance to attrition. After 20 cycles of carbonation and calcination, two sorbents exceeded the uptake of both limestone and dolomite, when subjected to the same regimes of reaction. A sorbent's uptake of CO₂ was shown to be determined by the volume in pores narrower than ～200 nm.     

CO2 Capture Using CaO Modified with Ethanol/Water Solution during Cyclic Calcination/Carbonation

The calcium‐based sorbent cyclic calcination/carbonation reaction is an effective technique for capturing CO₂ from combustion processes. The CO₂ capture capacity for CaO modified with ethanol/water solution was investigated over long‐term calcination/carbonation cycles. In addition, the SEM micrographs and pore structure for the calcined sorbents were analyzed. The carbonation conversion for CaO modified with ethanol/water solution is greater than that for CaO hydrated with distilled water and is much higher than that for calcined limestone. Modified CaO achieves the highest conversion for carbonation at the range of 650–700 °C. Higher values of ethanol concentration in solution result in higher carbonation conversion for modified CaO, and lead to better anti‐sintering performance. After calcination, the specific surface area and pore volume for modified CaO are higher than those for hydrated CaO, and are much greater than those for calcined limestone. The ethanol molecule enhances H₂O molecule affinity and penetrability to CaO in the hydration reaction so that the pores in CaO modified are obviously expanded after calcination. CaO modified with ethanol/water solution can act as a new and promising type of calcium‐based regenerable CO₂ sorbent for industrial applications.     

Sulphation and carbonation properties of hydrated sorbents from a fluidized bed CO2 looping cycle reactor

Sulphation and carbonation have been performed on hydrated spent residues from a 75 kW_th dual fluidized bed combustion (FBC) pilot plant operating as a CO₂ looping cycle unit. The sulphation and carbonation tests were done in an atmospheric pressure thermogravimetric analyzer (TGA), with the sulphation performed using synthetic flue gas (0.45% SO₂, 3% O₂, 15% CO₂ and N₂ balance). Additional tests were carried out in a tube furnace (TF) with a higher SO₂ concentration (1%) and conversions were determined by quantitative X-ray diffraction (QXRD) analyses. The morphology of the sulphated samples from the TF was examined by scanning electron microscopy (SEM). Sulphation tests were performed at 850 °C for 150 min and carbonation tests at 750 °C, 10 cycles for 15 min (7.5 min calcination + 7.5 min carbonation). Sulphation conversions obtained for the hydrated samples depended on sample type: in the TGA, they were ～75–85% (higher values were obtained for samples from the carbonator); and in the TF, values around 90% and 70% for sample from carbonator and calciner, respectively, were achieved, in comparison to the 40% conversion seen with the original sample. The SEM analyses showed significant residual porosity that can increase total conversion with longer sulphation time. The carbonation tests showed a smaller influence of the sample type and typical conversions after 10 cycles were 50% – about 10% higher than that for the original sample. The influence of hydration duration, in the range of 15–60 min, is not apparent, indicating that samples are ready for use for either SO₂ retention, or further CO₂ capture after at most 15 min using saturated steam. The present results show that, upon hydration, spent residues from FBC CO₂ capture cycles are good sorbents for both SO₂ retention and additional CO₂ capture.     

Natural Calcium‐Based Sorbents Doped with Sea Salt for Cyclic CO2 Capture

The calcium‐looping process for post‐combustion carbon dioxide capture, an economically and technically feasible method suitable for large‐scale use, has recently gained much attention. However, the capture capacity of calcium‐based sorbents rapidly decreases after only a few cycles. Herein, calcium‐based sorbents with enhanced cyclic CO₂‐capture capacity have been derived from cheap, natural raw materials by using a simple impregnation method. Limestone and shells were used as the calcium‐based raw materials, with sea salt as dopant. Modified limestone had the highest CO₂‐capture capacity after multiple carbonation‐calcination cycles. Sea‐salt‐doped sorbent showed a relatively stable porous surface during cycles, which resulted in a higher CO₂‐capture capacity.