Cancer gene therapy: connecting basic research with clinical inquiry

Molecular genetics has spawned an impressive outpouring of insights into the biology of neoplastic transformation and the host-tumor relationship. This deeper understanding of cancer pathogenesis presents a rich opportunity to develop novel therapeutic agents with improved selectivity for cancer cells. One promising approach involves gene therapy, which is the introduction of genetic material into a patient's tissues with the intent to achieve therapeutic benefit. A number of gene transfer systems have been designed that enable the genetic modification of relevant target cells, albeit with varying strengths and limitations. Several strategies to exploit gene transfer as a tool to target specific molecular defects intrinsic to cancer cells, enhance tumor chemosensitivity, and augment tumor immunogenicity are under intensive investigation. A number of these approaches have entered initial clinical testing and already provide intriguing new information about the biology of cancer in patients. In this review, I will highlight the critical issues and controversies that underscore preclinical experiments in cancer gene therapy, discuss some of the preliminary findings from the first wave of clinical trials, and speculate about the prospects that cancer gene therapy will change the way that cancer medicine is practiced.     

Gene therapy for lung cancer

Gene therapy has received considerable attention and some speculation as to its value. Although few patients have been treated, the preliminary results of the phase I lung cancer gene therapy clinical trials are very promising. Clinically relevant basic research in the molecular pathogenesis and immunology of lung cancer is progressing. As improved vector technologies are developed, new opportunities will be available to initiate lung cancer gene therapy trials that are based on a more detailed understanding of lung cancer biology. In conclusion, although important biologic and technical questions remain unanswered, recent research suggests that gene therapy will have a profound impact on lung cancer treatment.     

Gene therapy: a primer for radiologists

Gene therapy is one of the most rapidly evolving areas in medicine. Radiologists should have an understanding of basic techniques used to identify and clone a gene and insert it into a vector capable of directing expression in mammalian tissues. DNA delivery systems include retroviral vectors (RNA viruses), adenoviral vectors (DNA viruses), and cationic liposomes, along with strategies that involve ultrasound-directed gene transfer, computed tomography-guided gene transfer, and transcatheter gene delivery, in particular via the hepatic artery. Genes being evaluated in preclinical and clinical trials include oncogenes, antioncogenes (tumor suppressor genes), suicide genes, conventional antimetabolites, antiangiogenesis factors, secreted immunostimulatory cytokines such as interleukins and interferons, and immunomodulatory cell surface proteins, including foreign HLA proteins and costimulatory molecules. A foundation in molecular biology is needed for the practicing radiologist interested in but unfamiliar with current gene therapy terminology and experimental strategies. Such a foundation will encourage the dissemination of basic biologic, diagnostic imaging, and interventional oncoradiologic developments and should facilitate integration of the radiologist into the gene therapy team.     

Gene therapy for colon cancer

The enormous number of newly diagnosed cases of colorectal cancer that occur each year and the lack of agents that are highly effective for all patients underscore the need for novel approaches to combating the disease. Gene therapy as a developing treatment modality is already well established, with a number of trials ongoing and a vast range of other approaches being assessed in animal and cell culture experiments. In this brief review, we have discussed five gene therapy trials in colon carcinoma that are ongoing or in the approval process in the United States. The gene therapy approaches being employed can be divided into three major categories: (1) enzyme/prodrug systems (HSVtk/ganciclovir; CD/5-fluorocytosine); (2) tumor suppressor gene replacement therapy with wild-type p53; and (3) immune-gene therapy which is based on cytokine or tumor antigen expression to induce tumor immunity (e.g., CEA). Replication-deficient recombinant adenoviral vectors are predominantly used for colon cancer gene therapy, because they can be produced at high titer and they readily infect a number of different cell types. One trial uses polynucleotide therapy for antitumor immunization with intramuscular injection. All of these studies are phase I trials, principally designed to evaluate safety, but they will also provide data on gene delivery. Some trials may provide some insight into potential therapeutic effects. We have alluded to some of the concerns on toxicity related to the use of adenovirus, risks and side effects from transgenes, lack of tumor-specificity of transgene expression, and potential problems with efficient gene delivery to solid tumors. The clinical trials, however, will provide insight that will inform design of future studies with respect to dose, form, and frequency of administration, as well as to the value of biologic and clinical endpoints. The molecular analysis of the fundamental basis of colon cancer has moved at a remarkable pace and that progress seems set to continue. Thus, the basic foundations for gene therapy are undoubtedly in place: a clinical need; growing understanding of basic tumor biology; and ever-improving delivery systems. The field is at a very early stage in its evolution, and one concern is that the considerable hurdles that must be overcome are seen as examples of the failure of cancer gene therapy; however, we believe these challenges will be overcome. The authors also believe that colon cancer gene therapy is likely to take new directions, such as use as adjuvant to radical surgery, rather than attempts to treat end-stage disease when the liver is replaced by metastases. Other new directions might include prophylactic gene-based immunization against a panel of well-characterized tumor antigens, at least for persons shown to be at high risk of colon cancer because of genetic or other predisposition. A marriage between gene therapy approaches and conventional anticancer treatments such as radiotherapy and chemotherapy also seems likely. There is already evidence of this move with demonstration of synergism between p53 replacement and radiotherapy and chemotherapy. It is also likely that therapies will be developed that combine elements from the cancer gene therapies discussed previously, namely, suicide gene transfer, immune modulation, and modulation of defective cancer genes. Perhaps one of the main concerns is not that researchers in cancer gene therapy want to walk before they can run, but that the public and government agencies believe they can. The next 10 years will be an interesting time in the development of novel treatments against colon cancer.     

A computer-controlled spraying-freezing apparatus for millisecond time-resolution electron cryomicroscopy

The application of gene therapy techniques to the clinical problem of coronary restenosis has generated tremendous attention and enthusiasm. Use of gene transfer technology to prevent a common intractable illness would represent a watershed event for human gene therapy. However, the time is not yet right to initiate gene therapy trials for restenosis. The biology of restenosis is incompletely understood, catheter-based gene delivery is poorly adapted to the coronary circulation, and current gene transfer vectors are ill-suited for safe and effective gene delivery to the coronary artery wall. Basic research designed to overcome these obstacles is currently more appropriate than the initiation of clinical trials.     

Lung cancer: therapeutic modalities and cytoprotection

Lung cancer is the leading cancer killer in the United States today. The current methods of treatment, radiation and various chemotherapies, have been used with some success; however, early detection remains the key to successful therapy. Current clinical trials indicate that an improvement of available therapies is needed. Consequently, the development of new approaches to treatment is foremost in the minds of researchers. Advances in molecular medicine have produced new drugs that can protect normal cells from chemotherapy-induced toxicities, resulting in enhanced drug delivery with few dose reductions. This review will discuss some of the advances that have been made in understanding the molecular biology of lung cancer as well as the current and most promising methods of treatment used for various forms of lung cancer. The potential contribution of cytoprotectors to enhance the safety and effectiveness of these therapies will be examined.     

Localization by immunoelectron microscopy of Schistosoma mansoni antigens in the glomerulus of the hamster (Mesocricetus auratus) kidney

Gene therapy has the potential to provide cancer treatments based on novel mechanisms of action with potentially low toxicities. This therapy may provide more effective control of loco-regional recurrence in diseases such as non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC), as well as systemic control of micrometastases. Despite current limitations, retroviral and adenoviral vectors can in certain circumstances provide an effective means of delivering therapeutic genes to tumour cells. Although multiple genes are involved in the process of carcinogenesis, mutations of the p53 gene are the most frequent abnormality identified in human tumours. Pre-clinical studies both in vitro and in vivo have shown that restoration of p53 function can induce apoptosis in cancer cells. Phase I clinical trials now show that p53 gene replacement therapy is feasible and safe using both retroviral and adenoviral vectors, and that it induces tumour regression in patients with advanced NSCLC and recurrent head and neck cancer. Other pre-clinical studies indicate that gene therapy may have useful synergy with cytotoxic and radiation therapy. This paper describes the different gene therapy strategies under investigation and the pre-clinical data that provides a rationale for the gene replacement approach, reviews clinical trial data and presents novel ideas for improving current vectors and gene delivery to tumours.     

Transcobalamin from cow milk: isolation and physico-chemical properties

Advances in molecular biology technologies have significantly facilitated the identification of functional genes which cause, promote or control a variety of human diseases. Through recombinant DNA and polymerase chain reaction technologies, individual genes responsible for specific diseases have been identified, and consequently, the prospect that these diseases might be "cured" through replacement of the defective genes by their normal counterparts become distinct possibilities. Therefore, the goal of gene therapy is to apply this technology to the treatment of human diseases. In addition to its logical role for the correction of inherited diseases caused by a missing or defective gene product, gene therapy also holds promise for treatment of acquired disorders such as human cancer through the introduction of genes whose products have been implicated in controlling the growth of cancer. In this report, we present our results on the introduction of allogeneic major histocompatibility complex genes into cancer cells as an approach to increase the host's immune response against cancer. Various gene delivery strategies have been optimized for the introduction of DNA into various human tumour cells and these data are presented.     

Cisatracurium--is the stereoisomer an "ideal" relaxant? Histamine liberation and tryptase determination after bolus administration of cistracurium: a comparison with vecuronium

Present therapy of head and neck cancer patients includes surgical procedures, radiotherapy and sometimes chemotherapy. Over recent decades no dramatic improvements have been obtained with these treatment modalities with respect to efficacy and associated morbidity. Of patients with early stage disease (stage I and II), about 25% cannot be cured, while for patients with advanced disease (stage III and IV) this percentage may be as high as 70%. However, owing to advances in our knowledge of molecular biology, immunology, (bio)chemistry and biology of head and neck squamous cell carcinoma (HNSCC), new perspectives on therapy are arising. After several years of optimization several new therapeutic approaches are leaving their infancy and are being evaluated in clinical trials with HNSCC patients. Among other approaches, photodynamic therapy, gene therapy and antibody-based therapy are attracting most attention. The basic concepts and the potential applications of these treatment modalities in the management of head and neck cancer are discussed in this paper.     

Noninfectious gene transfer and expression systems for cancer gene therapy

Gene therapy provides a significant opportunity to devise novel strategies for the control or cure of cancer. Success of this modality will ultimately depend on the ability to express a therapeutic gene of interest at high levels, and specific gene delivery to targeted tumor cells will minimize toxicities. Although current gene therapy trials typically use viral-based, infectious vectors to express suitable target genes in human cancer cells, these vectors have significant limitations in their expression characteristics, lack of specificity in targeting tumor cells for gene transfer, and safety concerns regarding induction of secondary malignancies and recombination to form replication-competent virus. These limitations have refocused efforts to develop noninfectious gene transfer technologies for in vivo gene delivery of plasmid-based expression vectors. This article reviews recent developments in non-infectious gene transfer techniques, including liposome and receptor-mediated methods, which can efficiently deliver plasmid vectors into tumor cells in vivo. Additionally, strategies are reviewed for efficiently expressing target genes in tumor cells, including use of tissue-specific promoters, inducible promoters, and replication-control sequences to regulate extrachromosomal amplification of vector DNA in human tumor cells. Optimal coupling of these noninfectious gene transfer and expression technologies have the potential to yield safe and effective gene therapies for patients with cancer.     

Molecular surgery for human colorectal cancer with tumor suppressor p53 gene transfer

Recent advances in molecular biology have demonstrated that multistep genetic alterations are involved in the carcinogenesis of human colorectal cancer and that alteration of the p53 gene by mutation, deletion, or rearrangement is a major factor in this process. Human gene therapy has become a reality with the development of effective techniques for delivering the gene to the target cells. The efficacy of gene therapy for various types of genetic disease now being evaluated in clinical trials. These findings led us to develop a novel gene therapeutic strategy for human colorectal cancer that could replace the abnormal p53 gene using a recombinant, replication-defective adenoviral vector (termed Adp53). Infection with Adp53 induced rapid apoptotic cell death in DLD-1 and LoVo human colorectal cancer cell lines differing in their p53 status. Treatment with cisplatin following infection with Adp53 significantly suppressed the growth of WiDr colorectal cancer cells compared to single treatments alone. Thus restoration of wild-type p53 function exhibited an antitumor effect by inducing apoptosis as well as by markedly enhancing the effect of common chemotherapeutic agents in human colorectal cancer cells. In addition, Adp53 infection was antiangiogenic in SW620 human colorectal cancer cells. The application of this technology to human cancer therapy is now in progress. The article reviews recent highlights in this rapidly evolving field.     

Impact of metyrapone on MK-801-induced alterations in the rat dopamine D1 receptors

The control of cytomegalovirus infection and disease continues to be a major problem in transplantation and different strategies have been developed to reduce its incidence. Early diagnosis of infection soon after transplantation, using molecular tools such as the polymerase chain reaction, have resulted in successful clinical trials using the strategy of pre-emptive therapy. Adoptive transfer of immune cells, which are predominantly the cytomegalovirus-specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes, into transplant recipients has been shown to restore effective immunity. A vaccine preparation has been in development aimed at preventing primary infections in allograft recipients though effective protection has yet to be shown. The mechanisms of viral pathogenesis in chronic graft rejection remain unclear; however, recent contributions from the field of cell biology have increased our understanding of possible processes which have the potential for application in the field of gene therapy for the treatment of disease.     

Gene therapy: ovarian carcinoma as the paradigm

The delineation of the molecular basis of cancer in general, and of ovarian carcinoma in particular, allows for the possibility of specific intervention at the molecular level for therapeutic purposes. To this end, three main approaches have been developed: mutation compensation, molecular chemotherapy, and genetic immunopotentiation. For each of these conceptual approaches, human clinical protocols, including those specific for ovarian carcinoma, have entered phase I clinical trials to assess dose escalation, safety, and toxicity issues. However, major problems remain to be solved before these approaches can become effective and commonplace strategies for the treatment of cancer. In this regard, an examination of the applications of gene therapy for ovarian carcinoma can exemplify the rationality and the problems observed in the development of gene therapy, and may illustrate prospects for their solution that are being refined, including current efforts in our laboratory. An overriding obstacle is the basic ability to deliver therapeutic genes quantitatively, and specifically, into tumor cells. As vector technology fulfills these requirements, it is anticipated that promising results already observed in preclinical studies will translate quickly into the clinical setting for amelioration of this life-threatening disease in women.     

Structural features of the combining site region of Erythrina corallodendron lectin: role of tryptophan 135

The last two decades have led to a greater understanding of the genetic basis of human malignancy. Although numerous genetic alterations have been detected in cancer, activation of oncogenes and inactivation of cell cycle regulators (e.g., tumor suppressor genes) are now known to play a critical role in the progression of the disease. Therapeutic strategies based on specific molecular alterations in cancer include reintroduction of wild-type tumor suppressor function to cells lacking the gene. p53 gene therapy provides an attractive strategy to test the potential clinical feasibility of this approach. Alterations in p53 function are present in approximately half of all malignancies, and expression of wild-type p53 can result in apoptosis in human tumor cells. This review summarizes current investigations with p53 gene therapy, highlighting the preclinical efforts with adenoviral, retroviral, and lipid-based gene delivery systems. A comprehensive review of the various clinical targets suggested for p53 gene therapy is presented together with challenges and prospects for future clinical investigation.     

Gene therapy of central nervous system tumors

Recently, remarkable advances have been achieved in molecular and genetic researches of different kinds of general diseases, as well as in basic and clinical studies using gene therapy for central nervous system diseases. For brain tumors, clinical trials have been already started in more than 10 clinical protocols and more than 100 patients with malignant brain tumors. Nevertheless, there are still major issues that remain to be resolved for achieving better clinical results, such as delivery system of genetic material, regulatory methods of the intracellular expression of the transgene, antitumor efficacy, and tumor selectivity. In this paper, molecular genetic studies and the current state of gene therapy for neurological diseases, especially brain tumors, are described, and the future direction of this fascinating approach is discussed.     

Gene-based strategies for the immunotherapy of cancer

T lymphocytes play a crucial role in the host's immune response to cancer. Although there is ample evidence for the presence of tumor-associated antigens on a variety of tumors, they are seemingly unable to elicit an adequate antitumor immune response. Modern cancer immunotherapies are therefore designed to induce or enhance T cell reactivity against tumor antigens. Vaccines consisting of tumor cells transduced with cytokine genes in order to enhance their immunogenicity have been intensely investigated in the past decade and are currently being tested in clinical trials. With the development of novel gene transfer technologies it has now become possible to transfer cytokine genes directly into tumors in vivo. The identification of genes encoding tumor-associated antigens and their peptide products which are recognized by cytotoxic T lymphocytes in the context of major histocompatibility complex class I molecules has allowed development of DNA-based vaccines against defined tumor antigens. Recombinant viral vectors expressing model tumor antigens have shown promising results in experimental models. This has led to clinical trials with replication-defective adenoviruses encoding melanoma-associated antigens for the treatment of patients with melanoma. An attractive alternative concept is the use of plasmid DNA, which can elicit both humoral and cellular immune responses following injection into muscle or skin. New insights into the molecular biology of antigen processing and presentation have revealed the importance of dendritic cells for the induction of primary antigen-specific T cell responses. Considerable clinical interest has arisen to employ dendritic cells as a vehicle to induce tumor antigen-specific immunity. Advances in culture techniques have allowed the generation of large numbers of immunostimulatory dendritic cells in vitro from precursor populations derived from blood or bone marrow. Experimental immunotherapies which now transfer genes encoding tumor-associated antigens or cytokines directly into professional antigen-presenting cells such as dendritic cells are under evaluation in pre-clinical studies at many centers. Gene therapy strategies, such as in vivo cytokine gene transfer directly into tumors as well as the introduction of genes encoding tumor-associated antigens into antigen-presenting cells hold considerable promise for the treatment of patients with cancer.     

From genes to gene medicines: recent advances in nonviral gene delivery

Over the last decade, research in somatic gene therapy has focused on selected approaches to deliver therapeutic genes to cells both ex vivo and in vivo. While most current gene therapy clinical trials are based on cell- and viral-mediated approaches, nonviral gene medicines are emerging as potentially safe and effective in the treatment of a wide variety of genetic and acquired diseases. Nonviral technologies consist of plasmid-based expression systems containing a gene encoding a therapeutic protein and synthetic gene delivery systems. In addition to the therapeutic gene, plasmid-based expression systems contain other genetic sequences to control the in vivo production and secretion of a protein. They may include elements that prolong extrachromosomal gene expression, cell-specific promoters and, optionally, gene switches for enabling drug-regulated gene therapy. Unique gene delivery systems will be required depending upon the biology and (patho)physiology of the target tissue. This review provides a critical view of gene therapy with a major focus on advanced nonviral technologies to control the in vivo location and function of administered genes.     

Effects of a new platelet-activating factor antagonist, UR-12670, on several endotoxic shock markers in rats

Chemical and pharmaceutical research have provided physicians with an array of drugs that have beneficial effects on a variety of diseases. Such drugs, however, mostly help in controlling the manifestations of the pathological condition but do not permanently modify the underlying cause. Hence the necessity of new forms of therapy that change drastically the current approach to medical treatment. Gene therapy, with its potential to correct the malfunctioning genes at the origin of variety of diseases, seems to fulfill the requirements of this therapeutic "revolution". The feasibility of such an approach is underscored by the improved knowledge of the molecular mechanism and/or gene defects at the origin of acquired diseases widely spread in the population, and of more rare congenital conditions. The technical advances in molecular biology and genetic engineering achieved in the last ten years, offer the tools necessary to implement such therapeutic interventions. Here we present the approaches currently employed for gene therapy in the context of recent clinical trials. The scientific, ethical and economical implications deriving from a prospective routine use of gene therapy in the clinical setting are discussed.