Selection of single domain binding proteins by covalent DNA display

Selection technologies such as phage and ribosome display, which provide a physical linkage between genetic information and encoded polypeptide, are important tools for the engineering of proteins for diagnostic and therapeutic applications. We have recently described a selection strategy called covalent DNA display, in which individual proteins are covalently linked to the cognate encoding DNA template in separate droplets of a water-in-oil emulsion. We here report on the optimization of several experimental steps in covalent DNA display technology, such as the elution conditions and the PCR strategy used for the amplification of selected DNA templates. A PCR assembly strategy was developed, which allows the amplification of the DNA templates over repeated rounds of selection. In addition, we could demonstrate that approximately 50% of the DNA templates form a covalent adduct with the corresponding proteins in the compartments of a water-in-oil emulsion. In model selection experiments, differences in recovery efficiency <100 000 per round of selection could be observed when comparing a specific binding polypeptide with a binder of irrelevant specificity. Furthermore, the optimized protocol was successfully applied for the selection of single domain proteins, capable of specific binding to mouse serum albumin (MSA). A mutant derived from the SH3 domain of the Fyn kinase, with millimolar affinity to MSA, was affinity matured using covalent DNA display and yielded several MSA binding FynSH3 variants with dissociation constants in the 100 nM range.     

Rapid isolation of high-affinity protein binding peptides using bacterial display

A robust bacterial display methodology was developed that allows the rapid isolation of peptides that bind to arbitrarily selected targets with high affinity. To demonstrate the utility of this approach, a large library (5 x 10(10) clones) was constructed composed of random 15-mer peptide insertions constrained within a flexible, surface exposed loop of the Escherichia coli outer membrane protein A (OmpA). The library was screened for binding to five unrelated proteins, including targets previously used in phage display selections: human serum albumin, anti-T7 epitope mAb, human C-reactive protein, HIV-1 GP120 and streptavidin. Two to four rounds of enrichment (2-4 days) were sufficient to enrich peptide ligands having high affinity for each of the target proteins. Strong amino acid consensus sequences were apparent for each of the targets tested, with up to seven consensus residues. Isolated peptide ligands remained functional when expressed as insertional fusions within a monomeric fluorescent protein. This bacterial display methodology provides an efficient process for identifying peptide affinity reagents and should be useful in a variety of molecular recognition applications.     

Biased mutation-assembling: an efficient method for rapid directed evolution through simultaneous mutation accumulation

We have developed an efficient optimization technique, 'biased mutation-assembling', for improving protein properties such as thermostability. In this strategy, a mutant library is constructed using the overlap extension polymerase chain reaction technique with DNA fragments from wild-type and phenotypically advantageous mutant genes, in which the number of mutations assembled in the wild-type gene is stochastically controlled by the mixing ratio of the mutant DNA fragments to wild-type fragments. A high mixing ratio results in a mutant composition biased to favor multiple-point mutants. We applied this strategy to improve the thermostability of prolyl endopeptidase from Flavobacterium meningosepticum as a case study and found that the proportion of thermostable mutants in a library increased as the mixing ratio was increased. If the proportion of thermostable mutants increases, the screening effort needed to find them should be reduced. Indeed, we isolated a mutant with a 1200-fold longer activity half-life at 60 degrees C than that of wild-type prolyl endopeptidase after screening only 2000 mutants from a library prepared with a high mixing ratio. Our results indicate that an aggressive accumulation of advantageous mutations leads to an increase in the quality of the mutant library and a reduction in the screening effort required to find superior mutants.     

Binding of the globular domain of linker histones H5/H1 to the nucleosome: a hypothesis

The amino acid sequence of the central globular domain of histoneH1/H5 family members is highly homologous. Twenty-four suchsequences have been compared to establish the conserved andvariable residues. Fitting this to the tertiary structure ofthe H5 globular domain shows which of the conserved and variableresidues are peripheral and which internal. Particular attentionis paid to conserved basic residues on the surface, which wetake to be DNA binding. Variable regions and conserved acidicresidues are assumed not to be sites of contact with DNA. Weconclude that one face of the domain, containing a cluster ofbasic residues, is the principal DNA binding site whilst twoopposing faces, orthogonal to the principal site and also containingconserved basic residues, are subsidiary DNA binding sites.Since the DNA binding surface of the domain covers a full 180°arc, we propose that it contacts a ‘cage’ of threeDNA strands on the 2-fold axis of the chromatosome.     

An intein-based genetic selection allows the construction of a high-quality library of binary patterned de novo protein sequences

Combinatorial libraries of synthetic DNA are increasingly being used to identify and evolve proteins with novel folds and functions. An effective strategy for maximizing the diversity of these libraries relies on the assembly of large genes from smaller fragments of synthetic DNA. To optimize library assembly and screening, it is desirable to remove from the synthetic libraries any sequences that contain unintended frameshifts or stop codons. Although genetic selection systems can be used to accomplish this task, the tendency of individual segments to yield misfolded or aggregated products can decrease the effectiveness of these selections. Furthermore, individual protein domains may misfold when removed from their native context. We report the development and characterization of an in vivo system to preselect sequences that encode uninterrupted gene segments regardless of the foldedness of the encoded polypeptide. In this system, the inserted synthetic gene segment is separated from an intein/thymidylate synthase (TS) reporter domain by a polyasparagine linker, thereby permitting the TS reporter to fold and function independently of the folding and function of the segment-encoded polypeptide. TS-deficient Escherichia coli host cells survive on selective medium only if the insert is uninterrupted and in-frame, thereby allowing selection and amplification of desired sequences. We demonstrate that this system can be used as a highly effective preselection tool for the production of large, diverse and high-quality libraries of de novo protein sequences.     

Defining topologigical equivalences in macromolecules

We describe a completely automated and objective method fordefining topological equivalents in macromolecules. The methodis based on well established techniques for identifying topologicallyand topographically equivalent atoms in small molecules andhas been used in structural alignment of proteins and RNA molecules,and to extract fragments of molecules (protein secondary structuresand RNA and DNA double helices) from structural databases consistentwith some specified template structure.     

Rapid selection of specific MAP kinase-binders from designed ankyrin repeat protein libraries

We describe here the rapid selection of specific MAP-kinase binders from a combinatorial library of designed ankyrin repeat proteins (DARPins). A combined in vitro/in vivo selection approach, based on ribosome display and the protein fragment complementation assay (PCA), yielded a large number of different binders that are fully functional in the cellular cytoplasm. Ribosome-display selection pools of four successive selection rounds were examined to monitor the enrichment of JNK2-specific DARPins. Surprisingly, only one round of ribosome display with subsequent PCA selection of this pool was necessary to isolate a first specific binder with micromolar affinity. After only two rounds of ribosome-display selection followed by PCA, virtually all DARPins showed JNK2-specific binding, with affinities in the low nanomolar range. The enrichment factor of ribosome display thus approaches 10(5) per round. In a second set of experiments, similar results were obtained with the kinases JNK1 and p38 as targets. Again, almost all investigated DARPins obtained after two rounds of ribosome display showed specific binding to the targets used, JNK1 or p38. In all three selection experiments the identified DARPins possess very high specificity for the target kinase. Taken together, the combination of ribosome display and PCA selections allowed the identification of large pools of binders at unparalleled speed. Furthermore, DARPins are applicable in intracellular selections and immunoprecipitations from the extract of eukaryotic cells.     

Improved mutants from directed evolution are biased to orthologous substitutions

We have engineered human epidermal growth factor (EGF) by directed evolution through yeast surface display for significantly enhanced affinity for the EGF receptor (EGFR). Statistical analysis of improved EGF mutants isolated from randomly mutated yeast-displayed libraries indicates that mutations are biased towards substitutions at positions exhibiting significant phylogenetic variation. In particular, mutations in high-affinity EGF mutants are statistically biased towards residues found in orthologous EGF species. This same trend was also observed with other proteins engineered through directed evolution in our laboratory (EGFR, interleukin-2) and in a meta-analysis of reported results for engineered subtilisin. By contrast, reported loss-of-function mutations in EGF were biased towards highly conserved positions. Based on these findings, orthologous mutations were introduced into a yeast-displayed EGF library by a process we term shotgun ortholog scanning mutagenesis (SOSM). EGF mutants with a high frequency of the introduced ortholog mutations were isolated through screening the library for enhanced binding affinity to soluble EGFR ectodomain. These mutants possess a 30-fold increase in binding affinity over wild-type EGF to EGFR-transfected fibroblasts and are among the highest affinity EGF proteins to be engineered to date. Collectively, our findings highlight a general approach for harnessing information present in phylogenetic variability to create useful genetic diversity for directed evolution. Our SOSM method exploits the benefits of library diversity obtained through complementary methods of error-prone PCR and DNA shuffling, while circumventing the need for acquisition of multiple genes for family or synthetic shuffling.     

Directing phage selections towards specific epitopes

It is possible to direct selections from antibody repertoiresdisplayed on filamentous phage towards unique epitopes on proteinantigens by competing with related molecules. A phage displayrepertoire of human single chain Fvs (scFvs) was panned threetimes against foetal haemoglobin (HbF). The selection was dominatedby one clone with a K_d of 10 nM but yielded at least 17 others,all of which bound HbF but crossreacted with adult haemoglobin(HbA). To direct selection towards HbF-specific epitopes, therepertoire was preincubated with HbA in solution before eachpanning. Crossreactive scFvs can form complexes with the solubleHbA and thereby be prevented from binding the immobilized HbF.Four clones with preferential binding to HbF emerged under theseconditions. One of these (Hb-1), with a K_d of 6 µM, hadexquisite specificity for HbF and could distinguish cells expressingHbF from those expressing HbA by immunocytochemistry and flowcytometry. This antibody has an affinity that is 600-fold lowerthan the dominant crossreactive clone, and so only emerged underconditions of ‘competitive deselection’. Thus, competitivedeselection is a viable means for directing selections towardsuseful epitopes. It permits a more effective ‘search’of phage display repertoires and allows the emergence of loweraffinity clones with useful specificities. These clones maybe useful in themselves or may serve as leads for in vitro affinitymaturation.     

Laboratory evolution of P450 BM3 for mediated electron transfer yielding an activity-improved and reductase-independent variant

One of the main obstacles in employing P450 monooxygenases for preparative chemical syntheses in cell-free systems is their requirement for cofactors such as NAD(P)H. In order to engineer P450 BM3 from Bacillus megaterium for cost-effective process conditions in vitro, a validated medium throughput screening system based on cheap Zn dust as an electron source and Cobalt(III)sepulchrate (Co(III)sep) as a mediator was reported. In the current study, the alternative cofactor system Zn/Co(III)sep was used in a directed evolution experiment to improve the Co(III)sep-mediated electron transfer to P450 BM3. A variant, carrying five mutations (R47F F87A V281G M354S D363H, Table I), P450 BM3 M5 was identified and characterized with respect to its kinetic parameters. P450 BM3 M5 achieved for mediated electron transfer a 2-fold higher k(cat) value and a 3-fold higher catalytic efficiency compared with the starting point mutant P450 BM3 F87A (k(cat): 62 min(-1) compared with 28 min(-1); k(cat)/K(m): 62 microM(-1)min(-1) compared to 19 microM(-1)min(-1)). For obtaining first insights on electron transfer contributions, three reductase-deficient variants were generated. The reductase-deficient mutant of P450 BMP M5 exhibited a catalytic efficiency of 69% and a k(cat) value of 89% of the values obtained for P450 BM3 M5.     

Monovalent antibody scFv fragments selected to modulate T-cell activation by inhibition of CD86-CD28 interaction

Beside the interaction of the antigen-presenting major histocompatibility complex with the T-cell receptor, a co-stimulatory signal is required for T-cell activation in an immune response. To reduce immune-mediated graft rejection in corneal transplantation, where topical application of drugs in ointments or eye-drops may be possible, we selected single-chain antibody fragments (scFv) with binding affinity to rat CD86 (B7.2) that inhibit the co-stimulatory signal. We produced the IgV-like domain of rat CD86 as a fusion protein in Escherichia coli by refolding from inclusion bodies. This protein was used as a target for phage display selection of scFv from HuCAL-1, a fully artificial human antibody library. Selected binding molecules were shown to specifically bind to rat CD86 and inhibit the interaction of CD86 with CD28 and CTLA4 (CD152) in flow cytometry experiments. In an assay for CD86-dependent co-stimulation, the selected scFv fragment successfully inhibited the proliferation of T-cells induced by CD86-expressing P815 cells.     

Site-directed protein recombination as a shortest-path problem

Protein function can be tuned using laboratory evolution, in which one rapidly searches through a library of proteins for the properties of interest. In site-directed recombination, n crossovers are chosen in an alignment of p parents to define a set of p(n + 1) peptide fragments. These fragments are then assembled combinatorially to create a library of p(n+1) proteins. We have developed a computational algorithm to enrich these libraries in folded proteins while maintaining an appropriate level of diversity for evolution. For a given set of parents, our algorithm selects crossovers that minimize the average energy of the library, subject to constraints on the length of each fragment. This problem is equivalent to finding the shortest path between nodes in a network, for which the global minimum can be found efficiently. Our algorithm has a running time of O(N(3)p(2) + N(2)n) for a protein of length N. Adjusting the constraints on fragment length generates a set of optimized libraries with varying degrees of diversity. By comparing these optima for different sets of parents, we rapidly determine which parents yield the lowest energy libraries.     

Emulsifying performance of modular beta-sandwich proteins: the hydrophobic moment and conformational stability

Our understanding of protein emulsifying properties is largely based on analysis of emulsifiers found in milk and seed. The 9th-10th type III fibronectin domain pair retains full biological activity following emulsification-encapsulation into polyester microspheres, for controlled delivery, but the conformational criteria determining emulsification efficiency (EE) are unknown. Here, we have generated a series of mutants of this beta-sandwich protein, changing the hydrophobic moment and conformational stability, to investigate the structure-emulsification relationship. Predictive modelling of the hydrophobic moment of beta-strands and mutations known to increase conformational stability were used to generate the series. The proteins were tested for their emulsion stability and EE for oil-in-water mixtures. We show that the stabilization of emulsions by beta-sandwich proteins is best predicted by conformational stability during equilibrium denaturation in ionic surfactant. In contrast, the EE of these proteins is inversely related to an increase in their surface hydrophobicity following unfolding in surfactant. We also describe a novel beta-sandwich emulsifier with strong EE. The requirement for interdomain flexibility to achieve maximum emulsion stability and EE is also shown. This work increases our understanding of the mechanisms involved in protein emulsification and will be of use to the microencapsulation of proteins into polyester microspheres via emulsion-extraction protocols.     

Engineering of the Escherichia coli Im7 immunity protein as a loop display scaffold

Protein scaffolds derived from non-immunoglobulin sources are increasingly being adapted and engineered to provide unique binding molecules with a diverse range of targeting specificities. The ColE7 immunity protein (Im7) from Escherichia coli is potentially one such molecule, as it combines the advantages of (i) small size, (ii) stability conferred by a conserved four anti-parallel alpha-helical framework and (iii) availability of variable surface loops evolved to inactivate members of the DNase family of bacterial toxins, forming one of the tightest known protein-protein interactions. Here we describe initial cloning and protein expression of Im7 and its cognate partner the 15 kDa DNase domain of the colicin E7. Both proteins were produced efficiently in E.coli, and their in vitro binding interactions were validated using ELISA and biosensor. In order to assess the capacity of the Im7 protein to accommodate extensive loop region modifications, we performed extensive molecular modelling and constructed a series of loop graft variants, based on transfer of the extended CDR3 loop from the IgG1b12 antibody, which targets the gp120 antigen from HIV-1. Loop grafting in various configurations resulted in chimeric proteins exhibiting retention of the underlying framework conformation, as measured using far-UV circular dichroism spectroscopy. Importantly, there was low but measurable transfer of antigen-specific affinity. Finally, to validate Im7 as a selectable scaffold for the generation of molecular libraries, we displayed Im7 as a gene 3 fusion protein on the surface of fd bacteriophages, the most common library display format. The fusion was successfully detected using an anti-Im7 rabbit polyclonal antibody, and the recombinant phage specifically recognized the immobilized DNase. Thus, Im7 scaffold is an ideal protein display scaffold for the future generation and for the selection of libraries of novel binding proteins.     

Directed evolution for the development of conformation-specific affinity reagents using yeast display

Yeast display is a powerful tool for increasing the affinity and thermal stability of scFv antibodies through directed evolution. Mammalian calmodulin (CaM) is a highly conserved signaling protein that undergoes structural changes upon Ca(2+) binding. In an attempt to generate conformation-specific antibodies for proteomic applications, a selection against CaM was undertaken. Flow cytometry-based screening strategies to isolate easily scFv recognizing CaM in either the Ca(2+)-bound (Ca(2+)-CaM) or Ca(2+)-free (apo-CaM) states are presented. Both full-length scFv and single-domain VH only clones were isolated. One scFv clone having very high affinity (K(d) = 0.8 nM) and specificity (>1000-fold) for Ca(2+)-CaM was obtained from de novo selections. Subsequent directed evolution allowed the development of antibodies with higher affinity (K(d) = 1 nM) and specificity (>300-fold) for apo-CaM from a parental single-domain clone with both a modest affinity and specificity for that particular isoform. CaM-binding activity was unexpectedly lost upon conversion of both conformation-specific clones into soluble fragments. However, these results demonstrate that conformation-specific antibodies can be quickly and easily isolated by directed evolution using the yeast display platform.     

Affinity maturation of a Taq DNA polymerase specific affibody by helix shuffling

The possibility of increasing the affinity of a Taq DNA polymerasespecific binding protein (affibody) was investigated by an -helixshuffling strategy. The primary affibody was from a naive combinatoriallibrary of the three-helix bundle Z domain derived from staphylococcalprotein A. A hierarchical library was constructed through selectivere-randomization of six amino acid positions in one of the two-helices of the domain, making up the Taq DNA polymerase bindingsurface. After selections using monovalent phage display technology,second generation variants were identified having affinities(K_D) for Taq DNA polymerase in the range of 30–50 nM asdetermined by biosensor technology. Analysis of binding dataindicated that the increases in affinity were predominantlydue to decreased dissociation rate kinetics. Interestingly,the affinities observed for the second generation Taq DNA polymerasespecific affibodies are of similar strength as the affinitybetween the original protein A domain and the Fc domain of humanimmunoglobulin G. Further, the possibilities of increasing theapparent affinity through multimerization of affibodies wasdemonstrated for a dimeric version of one of the second generationaffibodies, constructed by head-to-tail gene fusion. As comparedwith its monomeric counterpart, the binding to sensor chip immobilizedTaq DNA polymerase was characterized by a threefold higher apparentaffinity, due to slower off-rate kinetics. The results showthat the binding specificity of the protein A domain can bere-directed to an entirely different target, without loss ofbinding strength.     

The role of tyrosine residues in the DNA-binding site of the Pf1 gene 5 protein

The 144 amino acid gene 5 protein of bacteriophage Pf1 bindstightly and cooperatively to single-stranded DNA during replicationof the phage genome. It has been suggested that aromatic aminoacid side chains are important for this interaction, probablythrough base stacking with the DNA. We have analysed the accessibilityof tyrosine residues in the DNA—protein complex, and theirimportance to the DNA-binding activity of the protein, by chemicalmodification and protection experiments using tetranitromethane.Tyrosines 21, 30 and 55 are surface accessible in the free proteinbut are protected from modification in the complex with phageDNA. Moreover, modification of these residues in the free proteinabolishes the ability to bind to DNA or oligonucleotides, asjudged by fluorescence spectroscopy and gel retardation analysis.Modification of the protein also results in the formation ofan intersubunit covalent cross-link between Tyr55 and Phe76,suggesting that Phe76 is located within the DNA-binding cleftof the protein. It is proposed that residues 17–34 ofthe Pf1 gene 5 protein form a beta-hairpin analogous to the‘DNA-binding wing’ of the fd and Ike gene 5 proteins.We suggest the existence of a single-stranded DNA binding motif,in which Tyr30 of the Pf1 protein is equivalent to the functionallyimportant Tyr26 of the fd gene 5 protein.     

Polarity as a criterion in protein design

Hypothetical proteins can be tested computationally by determiningwhether or not the designed sequence-structure pair has thecharacteristics of a typical globular protein. We have developedsuch a test by deriving quantities with approximately constantvalue for all globular proteins, based on empirical analysisof the exposed and buried surfaces of 128 structurally knownproteins. The characteristic quantities that best appear tosegregate badly designed or deliberately misfolded proteinsfrom their properly folded natural relatives are the polar fractionof side chains on the protein surface and, independently, inthe protein interior. Three of the seven hypothetical structurestested here can be rejected as having too many polar side-chaingroups in the interior or too few on the protein surface. Inaddition, a recently designed nutritional protein is identifiedas being very much unlike globular proteins. These database-derivedcharacteristic quantities are useful in screening designed proteinsprior to experiment and may be useful in screening experimentallydetermined (X-ray, NMR) protein structures for possible errors.     

A combinatorial library of an {alpha}-helical bacterial receptor domain

The construction and characterization of a combinatorial libraryof a solvent-exposed surface of an -helical domain derived froma bacterial receptor is described. Using a novel solid-phaseapproach, the library was assembled in a directed and successivemanner utilizing single-stranded oligonucleotides containingmultiple random substitutions for the variegated segments ofthe gene fragment The simultaneous substitution of 13 residuesto all 20 possible amino acids was carried out in a region spanning81 nucleotides. The randomization was made in codons for aminoacids that were modelled to be solvent accessible at a surfacemade up from two of the three a-helices of a monovalent Fc-bindingdomain of staphylococcal protein A. After cloning of the PCR-amplifiedlibrary into a phagemid vector adapted for phage display ofthe mutants, DNA sequencing analysis suggested a random distributionof codons in the mutagenized positions. Four members of thelibrary with multiple substitutions were produced in Escherichiacoli as fusions to an albumin-binding affinity tag derived fromstreptococcal protein G. The fusion proteins were purified byhuman serum albumin affinity chromatography and subsequentlycharacterized by SDSelectrophoresis, CD spectroscopy and biosensoranalysis. The analyses showed that the mutant protein A derivativescould all be secreted as soluble full-length proteins. Furthermore,the CD analysis showed that all mutants, except one with a prolineintroduced into helix 2, have secondary structures in closeagreement with the wild-type domain. These results proved thatmembers of this -helical receptor library with multiple substitutionsin the solvent-exposed surface remain stable and soluble inE.coli. The possibility of using this library for a phenotypicselection strategy to obtain artificial antibodies with novelfunctions is discussed.