Current Developments in Malting and Brewing Trials with Sorghum in Nigeria: A Review

Initially, large‐scale lager beer brewing with sorghum malts proved highly intractable due to a number of biochemical problems including: high malting losses estimated at 10–30% as against 8–10% for barley; high gelatinisation temperatures which limited starch solubilisation/ hydrolysis by the amylolytic enzymes during mashing; low extract yield/low diastatic power (DP) due to inadequate hydrolytic enzyme activities especially β‐amylase; low free α‐amino nitrogen (FAN) due to inadequate proteolysis limiting yeast growth during fermentation; high wort viscosities/beer filtration problems due to low endo‐β‐1,3; 1–4‐glucanase activities on the endosperm cell walls causing the release of some β‐glucans. Strident research efforts using improved Nigerian sorghum malt varieties (SK5912, KSV8 and ICSV400) have reported some encouraging results. The knowledge of the biochemical integrity of the endo‐β‐glucanases of the sorghum malt is helping to elucidate their mode of activity in the depolymerisation of the β‐glucans. This is bound to ensure process efficiency in sorghum beer brewing, reduce beer production costs and ultimately, produce a Pilsner‐type of lager beer with 100% sorghum malt.     

Effect of malting time,mashing temperature and added commercial enzymes on extract recovery from a Nigerian malted yellow sorghum variety

Preliminary microbiological studies carried out on sorghum grains showed that the major microorganisms found were mainly bacteria and that aflatoxin‐producing fungi were not found. The effect of added commercial enzyme preparations and different infusion mashing temperatures on extract yield, from sorghum malted at 30 °C, was studied. The infusion mashing method (65 °C) developed for mashing well‐modified barley malt produces poor extract yields with sorghum malt. The extract yield from the sorghum malt in this study was very low with infusion mashing at 65 °C, without the addition of commercial enzyme preparations. A higher extract yield was obtained from the sorghum malt, without the commercial enzyme addition, when using infusion mashing at 85 °C. Both infusion mashing temperatures (65 and 85 °C) showed an improved extract yield over the control malt when commercial enzyme preparations were used during mashing of the sorghum malt. The added enzyme preparations resulted in a higher extract yield from the germinated sorghum when infusion mashing was performed at 65 °C over mashing at 85 °C. The use of individual commercial enzymes (α‐amylase, β‐glucanase, protease, xylanase, saccharifying enzyme and combinations of some hydrolytic enzyme) increased extract yields, when complemented with the enzymes that had developed in the sorghum malt. Copyright © 2016 The Institute of Brewing & Distilling     

α-GLUCOSIDASE ACTIVITY OF SORGHUM AND BARLEY MALTS

Sorghum malt α-glucosidase activity was highest at pH 3.75 while that of barley malt was highest at pH 4.6. At pH 5.4 employed in mashing sorghum malt α-glucosidase was more active than the corresponding enzyme of barley malt. α-Glucosidase was partly extracted in water but was readily extracted when L-cysteine was included in the extraction buffer, pH 8. Sorghum malt made at 30°C had higher α-glucosidase activities than the corresponding malts made at 20°C and 25°C. Nevertheless, the sorghum malts made at 20°C and 25°C produced worts which contained more glucose than worts of malt made at 30°C. Although barley malts contained more α-glucosidase activity than sorghum malts, the worts of barley had the lowest levels of glucose. The limitation to maltose production in sorghum worts, produced at 65°C, is due to inadequate gelatinization of starch and not to limitation to β-amylase and α-amylase activities. Gelatinization of the starch granules of sorghum malt in the decantation mashing procedure resulted in the production of sorghum worts which contained high levels of maltose, especially when sorghum malt was produced at 30°C. Although the β-amylase and α-amylase levels of barley malt was significantly higher than those of sorghum malted optimally at 30°C, sorghum worts contained higher levels of glucose and equivalent levels of maltose to those of barley malt. It would appear that the individual activities of α-glucosidase, α-amylase and β-amylase of sorghum malts or barley malts do not correlate with the sugar profile of the corresponding worts. In consequence, specifications for enzymes such as α-amylase and β-amylase in malt is best set at a range of values rather than as single values.     

Mashing Studies with Unmalted Sorghum and Malted Barley

The effects on wort quality when mashing with unmalted sorghum (0–100%) and malted barley (100–0%) in combination with industrial enzymes were evaluated. A mashing program with temperature stands at 50°C, 95°C and 60°C was used. Different combinations of commercial enzymes were evaluated. A heat stable α‐amylase was found to be essential for efficient saccharification. The inclusion of a fungal α‐amylase in mashes with a high sorghum content improved filtration rates to that of 100% malted barley mashes. Addition of a bacterial protease increased the amount of nitrogen solubilisation and peptide degradation. An increase of the relative proportion of sorghum in the grist resulted in decreases in wort filtration, colour, viscosity, attenuation limit, free amino nitrogen, high molecular weight nitrogen, and a corresponding increase in pH (p < 0.01). Overall the addition of malted barley in small proportions to unmalted sorghum mashes together with commercial enzymes was found to improve the potential for brewing a high quality lager beer from unmalted sorghum.     

ENZYMIC BREAKDOWN OF ENDOSPERM PROTEINS OF SORGHUM AT DIFFERENT MALTING TEMPERATURES

Enzymic breakdown of endosperm proteins of sorghum was more effective at 20°C than at 25°C and 30°C, as regards total protein solubilization, α-amino nitrogen and peptide production. Although the embryos (axes and scutella), of the three temperature treatments contained similar quantities of protein, it appeared that less proteins, in terms of amino acids and peptides, were transferred to the roots during malting at 30°C than at 25°C and 20°C. During mashing, higher levels of peptides but lower levels of α-amino nitrogen and total soluble nitrogen were released in an infusion mash at 65°C than in a decantation mash where enzymically active wort was decanted and used to mash gelatinized sorghum starch at 65°C. Although more of the maltose-producing enzyme—β—amylase was found in sorghum malts made at 25°C and 30°C than at 20°C, it would seem that, for sorghum, malting temperature of 20°C to 25°C were optimal as regards protein breakdown during malting. The protein breakdown produced when sorghum is malted at 20°C is comparable to that found in barley malt and should support similar levels of adjuncts and yeast growth during brewing.     

Influence of malted barley and exogenous enzymes on the glucose/maltose balance of worts with sorghum or barley as an adjunct

The sugar profile of wort from laboratory malted barley, malted sorghum, unmalted barley and unmalted sorghum grains mashed with commercial enzyme preparations were studied. Similar levels of glucose to maltose (1:7) were observed in wort of malted barley and malted sorghum. Mashing barley or sorghum grains with commercial enzymes changed the glucose to maltose ratio in both worts, with a greater change in wort from sorghum grains. Although hydrolysis with commercial enzymes released more glucose from maltose in sorghum wort, the same treatment retained more maltose in barley wort. Adding malted barley to sorghum grains mashed with commercial enzymes restored the glucose to maltose ratio in sorghum mash. Fermentation of wort produced from all barley malt (ABM) mash and commercial enzyme/barley malt/sorghum adjunct (CEBMSA) mash of similar wort gravity was also studied. ABM and CEBMSA worts exhibited similar glucose to maltose ratios and similar amino acid spectra. However, ABM released more individual amino acids and five times more proline than wort from commercial enzyme/barley malt/sorghum adjunct. ABM produced 27% more glucose and 7% more maltose than CEBMSA. After fermentation, ABM mash produced 9.45% ABV whilst commercial enzyme/barley malt/sorghum adjunct mash produced 9.06% ABV. Restoration of the glucose/maltose ratio in the CEBMSA mash produced wort with a sugar balance required for high gravity brewing. © 2020 The Institute of Brewing & Distilling     

Quality Assessment of a Sorghum Variety Malted Commercially under Tropical Conditions and Controlled Tropical Temperatures in the Laboratory

A sorghum variety was supplied as commercial malt and as an unmalted cereal by a maltster. The commercial sample had been malted in a tropical country. Sub‐samples of the unmalted cereal were malted in the laboratory under controlled germination temperatures of 28°C and 30°C. Laboratory and commercially malted sorghum were studied for their brewing qualities. The α‐amylase development in sorghum malt was enhanced when germination was carried out at the higher temperature of 30°C rather than at 28°C. Hot water extract (HWE) was more variable. With infusion mashing, results showed a significant difference for germination time (3–6 days), but no significant difference relating to germination temperature. With the decantation mashing method the reverse was observed. The low numerical values of HWE obtained from sorghum malt in the infusion mashing process confirmed that this process is not suitable to produce optimal extract development from malted sorghum. The 28°C germinated sorghum released more FAN products into the worts than the 30°C malt, using both the infusion and decantation methods. With regard to the parameters tested, commercially malted sorghum gave lower analytical values than laboratory malted sorghum. It was also observed that variations in malting temperatures and mashing processes can cause unexpected variations in the analyses of sorghum malt. These findings suggest that careful process control is required during the malting and mashing of sorghum.     

Properties of Three Sorghum Cultivars Used for the Production of Bili‐Bili Beverage in Northern Cameroon

The malting characteristics of sorghum malts produced locally in Cameroon for Bili‐Bili brewing were compared with those of malts produced in a laboratory. The analytical values of both malts were similar but the brewing potential of the laboratory malts were marginally better than those of the locally produced malts. Of the three cultivars examined, Madjeru had the lowest levels of β‐amylase, maltose levels and fermentability. The worts of the Madjeru filtered the slowest of the three malts. During malting β‐glucanase developed rapidly and development was temperature‐dependent.     

Validation and application of osmolyte concentration as an indicator to evaluate fermentability of wort and malt

The objective was to develop a new simple and quick approach to predict fermentability, based on osmolyte concentration (OC). Eight malts were assayed for diastatic power, starch‐degrading enzymes [α ‐amylase, β ‐amylase and limit dextrinase (LD)] and malt OC (MOC). All malts were mashed to determine wort OC (WOC), real degree of fermentation (RDF) and sugar contents in a small‐scale mashing protocol. The results showed that MOC was correlated with malt α ‐amylase, LD, the resultant WOC, RDF and fermentable sugar (r  = 0.813, 0.762, 0.795, 0.867, 0.744, respectively), suggesting that MOC was discriminating in predicting levels of malt amylolytic enzymes, wort sugar and RDF without the mashing and fermentation process. Moreover, WOC showed stronger correlations with malt α ‐amylase, LD, RDF and fermentable sugars (r  = 0.796, 0.841, 0.884, 0.982, respectively), suggesting that WOC can be used to quickly predict wort sugar contents and RDF without a fermentation step. Furthermore, the effects of mashing temperature and duration on WOC, RDF and sugar contents are discussed. Adjusting mash temperature to 65°C or extending the mash duration dramatically increased RDF and WOC, whereas malt extract was relatively stable. Similarly, WOC showed significant correlations with RDF and fermentable sugars (r  = 0.912 and 0.942, respectively), suggesting that WOC provides a simple and reliable tool to assist brewers to optimize mash parameters towards the production of ideal wort fermentability. In conclusion, the ability of OC to predict malt fermentability and sugar content allows brewers to keep better control of fermentability in the face of variation of malt quality, and to quickly adjust mashing conditions for the consistency of wort fermentability. Copyright © 2017 The Institute of Brewing & Distilling     

Sorghum β‐Amylase Production: Relationship With Grain Cultivar,Steep Regime,Steep Liquor Composition and Kilning Temperature

Steep regime, nature of alkaline liquor, and kilning conditions were studied for their effects on sorghum malt β‐amylase development in four Nigerian sorghum cultivars. Malt β‐amylase activity was markedly (p < .001) influenced by all the four factors as well as their various interactions. Overall, malts from KSV 8 variety were the most β‐amylolytic followed in sequence by those from Local Red (LR), SK 5912, and Local white (LW) respectively. The presence or absence of air rests in steep regimes was a significant (p < .001) determinant of sorghum β‐amylase response to final warm steeping, steep liquor and kilning condition. The nature of the alkaline steep liquor was also a major determinant of the pattern of malt β‐amylase response to the kilning condition. Steeping in Ca(OH)₂ enhanced malt β‐amylase activity at the higher temperature of kilning, while KOH produced the opposite effect. Ca(OH)₂ enhancement of β‐amylase development, at a kilning temperature of 50°C, was variety‐dependent suggesting that different sorghum cultivars may employ different biosynthesis models for β‐amylase synthesis. The regime‐dependence of β‐amylase response to kiln temperature suggests that this was an important modulator of sorghum germination physiology.     

DEVELOPMENT OF A MASHING PROFILE FOR THE USE OF MICROBIAL ENZYMES IN BREWING WITH RAW SORGHUM (80%) AND MALTED BARLEY OR SORGHUM MALT (20%)

Different time and temperature programmes were used to evaluate the production of hot water extract (HWE) and free amino nitrogen (FAN) from mashes containing raw sorghum and either malted sorghum or malted barley in the presence of microbial enzymes. Two malted varieties of sorghum (SK 5912 and Zaria) were used. The former gave higher HWE but lower FAN than the latter. Sorghum malts were unable to provide enzyme activity for starch extraction and exogenous enzymes were always needed. Seventeen commercially available enzyme preparations were assessed. A double-mash process was developed. Inclusion of calcium ions (200 ppm) was beneficial but adjustment of mash pH had little effect. Raw sorghum was gelatinised at 100°C for 30–40 min in the presence of a heat-stable α-amylase followed by mixing with a malt mash (started at B0°C) to give a temperature of 65°C with a total mash time of 167 min (127 min from mixing the mashes). The inclusion of a single commercial enzyme preparation (containing both proteolytic and amylolytic activities) was sufficient to achieve satisfactory HWE and FAN. Addition of different activities or combinations of activities gave no significant advantages. To obtain levels of FAN of 100–140 mg/l however excessive amounts of enzymes were required.     

Malting of Sorghum: Further Studies on Factors influencing α‐Amylase Activity

The effects of steep regime, nature of alkaline steeping agent, and kilning condition on α‐amylase development were studied for four Nigerian sorghum cultivars. Malt α‐amylase activity was highly significantly (p<.001) influenced by all the four factors as well as their various assortments of interaction. Generally malts from the Local Red (LR) variety produced the highest a‐amylase values, followed by those of SK 5912, Local White and KSV 8 in the above sequence. The presence/absence of air‐rest processes in steep regimes was a significant factor (p<.001) influencing malt α‐amylase response to final warm steeping as well as to the other factors under study. Similarly, the nature of the steeping agent was a very significant determinant of malt α‐amylase response to kilning condition and regime of steeping. Of significant interest was the observation that Ca (OH)₂ steeps enhanced malt α‐amylase activity at the higher temperature of kilning. The significantly lower α‐amylase values given under similar conditions by the other alkaline liquors suggest a possible increase in malt thermostability due to steeping in Ca (OH)₂. Additionally, the fact that the extent of enhancement of malt α‐amylase activity by Ca (OH)₂, at 50°C Kiln temperature, was regime‐dependent, suggests that the latter was an important modulator of sorghum germination physiology.     

Effect of varying starch properties and mashing conditions on wort sugar profiles

The aim of this research was to investigate the relationship between starch composition in barley and its malted counterpart alongside malt enzyme activity and determine how these factors contribute to the fermentable sugar profile of wort. Two Australian malting barley varieties, Commander and Gairdner, were sourced from eight growing locations alongside a commercial sample of each. For barley and malt, total starch and gelatinisation temperature were taken, and for malt, α‐ and β‐amylase activities were measured. Samples were mashed using two mashing profiles (infusion and Congress) and the subsequent wort sugar composition and other quality measures (colour, original gravity, soluble nitrogen) were tested. Variety had no significant (<0.05) effect on any barley, malt, enzyme or wort characteristics. However, growing location impacted gelatinisation temperature, colour, malt protein content and original gravity. The gelatinisation temperature in malt samples was higher, by ~0.8°C, than in the equivalent barley sample. Several malt samples, even with protein contents <12.0%, had gelatinisation temperature >65°C. The fermentable sugars measured in the malt prior to mashing showed a higher proportion of maltose than glucose or maltotriose. In addition, there were significant differences in the amount of sugar produced by each mashing method with the high temperature infusion producing a higher amount of sugar and proportionally more maltose. There is scope for further research on the effect of genetics and growing environment on gelatinisation temperature, mash performance and fermentable sugar development. Routinely measuring gelatinisation temperature and providing this information on malt specification sheets could help brewers optimise performance. © 2019 The Institute of Brewing & Distilling     

PROMOTING SORGHUM RESERVE PROTEIN MOBILISATION BY STEEPING IN ALKALINE LIQUOR

Mobilisation of sorghum storage reserve proteins by steeping in alkaline liquor for 48 h under four different regimes was evaluated. Germination was for 4 days at 30°C. Cold water soluble protein (CWS-protein), CWS-protein modification index, total non protein nitrogen (TNPN), peptide accumulation, FAN, endo- and exo-protease activities—all key indicators of protein mobilisation were highly significantly affected by steep regime, steep liquor and cultivar as well as their pairwise interactions. Mean FAN and TNPN were significantly higher (P < 0.0005) for malts derived from alkaline steep liquor except for KSV 8 which exhibited significant inhibition of TNPN development. Similarly, alkaline steeping promoted protein solubilisation and CWS-protein modification. While parallel improvements in amylolysis and proteolysis were recorded for ICSV 400, proteolysis in KSV 8 and SK 5912 seemed more enhanced except for SK 5912 exposed to air rest cycles. Steeping in alkaline liquor also caused significant repression of the proteases in KSV 8. Conversely, steeping SK 5912 under similar conditions promoted rather than inhibited development of these enzymes. Poor correlation between protein degradation products and enzyme development suggest major roles for factors other than proteolysis in sorghum reserve protein mobilisation.     

Variety and germination time effect on total β‐glucan,water‐insoluble β‐glucan,water‐soluble β‐glucan components and β‐glucanase levels in improved sorghum varieties SK5912, KSV8 and ICSV400 before and after malting and their relationships to wort viscosity

The effects of variety and germination time on β‐glucan components – total β‐glucan (TBG), water insoluble β‐glucan (WIBG) and water soluble β‐glucan (WSBG) and β‐glucanase (BG) levels – before and after malting in improved sorghum varieties SK5912, KSV8 and ICSV400 and their relationships to wort specific viscosity (SV) were studied. This study was part of efforts to aid local malting and brewing industries in the application of sorghum varieties that are abundantly available to reduce costs. At the fifth day of germination, variety ICSV400 had the lowest TBG, WIBG and WSBG levels in its raw and malt samples. Variety SK5912 had the highest TBG, WIBG and WSBG levels in its raw samples, while variety KSV8 had the highest levels of TBG, WIBG and WSBG in its malt samples. Similarly, variety ICSV400 malts developed the highest BG levels, while the KSV8 malts gave the lowest level. The effect of variety, germination time and variety × germination time interaction was significant (p < 0.05) on the TBG, WIBG and BG levels and was not significant on the WSBG levels. Weak and significant correlation of TBG levels with SV (0.25, p < 0.05 for SK5912; 0.24, p < 0.05 for KSV8; and 0.31, p < 0.05 for ICSV400) was observed in all the samples, suggesting that the low β‐glucan levels may not be primarily and solely responsible for any viscosity impediments associated with sorghum worts during run‐off. With improvement in the effective utilization of sorghum, ICSV400 appeared the most suitable variety for malting and brewing in Nigeria.Copyright © 2016 The Institute of Brewing & Distilling     

MALTING QUALITY OF SRI LANKAN VARIETIES OF SORGHUM

The malting quality of Sri Lankan sorghum was studied using seventeen varieties. These varieties represented four colour categories (brown, yellow, pink and white) of sorghum found in Sri Lanka. The main criteria used for the assessment of malting quality in this study were the malting loss, diastatic power, liquefying power and the quantity of extract. Malting losses of these varieties were somewhat higher than those encountered in malting barley. However, they appeared to depend partly on the malting conditions. The diastatic powers and liquefying powers observed in this study were inferior to those observed with barley malt. However, with some varieties they appeared to be adequate for the purpose of mashing, as indicated by the high extract values obtained, which were comparable with those of some barley malts. Extract values of the four colour categories varied considerably and the best values were observed with the yellow and pink varieties and some varieties of white. Brown varieties in spite of their comparatively high diastatic powers and liquefying powers gave very little or no extract on mashing.     

麦芽中SOD活性与麦汁还原力的关系以及糖化温度对它们的影响

研究了11种进口麦芽和18种国产麦芽中超氧化物歧化酶(SOD)活性的差异以及与协定麦汁还原力之间的关系。以甘啤-3号麦芽为对象,采用7种恒温糖化工艺考察了糖化温度对2者的影响。结果表明,不同品种麦芽中,SOD的差异比较明显(1205.6～2126.0U/g),而且麦芽的SOD活性与协定麦汁的还原力之间存在显著的正相关性(相关系数r=0.898,P<0.01);SOD活性随着糖化温度的升高而逐渐降低,55℃恒温糖化60min后有53.22%的酶活残存;当糖化温度升高到65℃时,SOD的活性大幅度下降,30min后仍有25.45%的酶活残存;糖化温度为70℃和80℃时SOD下降到极低的活性;麦汁的还原力随着糖化温度的升高而升高,80℃恒温糖化100min后麦汁的还原力高达3.75mmol/mL。     

THE EFFECTS OF MASHING TEMPERATURE AND MASH THICKNESS ON WORT CARBOHYDRATE COMPOSITION

Temperature and mash thickness are shown to affect both mash performance and enzyme activity. Alpha amylase was found to be considerably more resistant to heat inactivation than was beta amylase. This difference was reflected by changes in wort fermentability that were manifest at temperatures below those which affected levels of extract. Increasing the mashing temperature from 65°C to 80°C had only a slight effect on extract but reduced wort fermentability from over 70% to less than 30%. At 85°C and over, when temperature had a significant effect on alpha amylase, as well as on beta-amylase, extract was lost and starch was present in the wort. Diluting the mash with liquor had a similar effect to that of increasing temperature on both the amylolytic enzymes and on the mash performance. Thin mashes contained more starch and fewer fermentable sugars than did thick mashes at the same temperature. These changes can be related to the stability of the amylolytic enzymes.     

Optimizing red sorghum malt quality when Bacillus subtilis is used during steeping to control mould growth

Previous work has shown that Bacillus subtilis‐S499‐based biocontrol treatments applied without aeration at the steeping stage of red sorghum malting offer good mould reduction, but yield malts with low levels of key hydrolytic enzymes. Thus we attempted to raise these levels by aerating the steeping liquor, varying the steeping time (from 8 to 40 h) and temperature (from 25 to 35 °C), and combining a biocontrol treatment with prior steeping in 0.2% NaOH. Aeration proved particularly important whenever B. subtilis cells were present in the steep liquor. The optimal temperatures for α‐ and β‐amylase were 30 and 25 °C, respectively. By increasing the steeping time, it was possible to improve the α‐amylase activity, but the β‐amylase activity peaked sharply between 16 and 20 h, depending on the steeping medium. A good compromise was steeping in a biocontrol medium for 14–16 h at 30 °C. Combination steeping treatments (0.2% NaOH for 8 h followed by biocontrol for 8 h) yielded malts of a quality approaching that afforded by dilute alkaline treatment. Copyright © 2012 The Institute of Brewing & Distilling     

Optimisation of the Mashing Procedure for 100% Malted Proso Millet (Panicum miliaceum L.) as a Raw Material for Gluten‐free Beverages and Beers

Proso millet is a gluten‐free cereal and is therefore considered a suitable raw material for the manufacturing of foods and beverages for people suffering from celiac disease. The objective of this study was to develop an optimal mashing procedure for 100% proso millet malt with a specific emphasis on high amylolytic activity. Therefore, the influence of temperature and pH on the amylolytic enzyme activity during mashing was investigated. Size exclusion chromatography was used to extract different amylolytic enzyme fractions from proso millet malt. These enzymes were added into a pH‐adjusted, cold water extract of proso millet malt and an isothermal mashing procedure was applied. The temperatures and pH optima for amylolytic enzyme activities were determined. The α‐amylase enzyme showed highest activity at a temperature of 60°C and at pH 5.0, whereas the β‐amylase activity was optimum at 40°C and pH 5.3. The limit dextrinase enzyme reached maximum activity at 50°C and pH 5.3. In the subsequent mashing regimen, the mash was separated and 40% was held for 10 min at 68°C to achieve gelatinisation. The next step in the mashing procedure was the mixture of the part mashes. The combined mash was then subjected to an infusion mashing regimen, taking the temperature optima of the various amylolytic enzymes into account. It was possible to obtain full saccharification of the wort with this mashing regimen. The analytical data obtained with the optimised proso millet mash were comparable to barley wort, which served as a control.