Effects of electrical stimulation, chilling temperature and hot-boning on the tenderness of bovine muscles

The objective of this study was to determine the effects of hot-boning, low voltage electrical stimulation (ES) and chilling temperature on the tenderness of bovine M. longissimus dorsi (LD) and M. semimembranosus (SM) muscles. LD (n=32) and SM (n=32) muscles were subjected to different post-mortem treatments; hot-boning (before 90min post-mortem), cold-boning (at 48h post-mortem), low voltage ES and rapid or slow chilling. Hot-boned muscles which were not electrically stimulated (NES) had higher Warner Bratzler shear force (WBSF) values (P<0.001) and shorter sarcomeres (P<0.001) than cold-boned muscles. Hot-boned muscles subjected to ES had lower pH values (P<0.001) post-stimulation and up to 8h post-mortem than NES muscles. At both chilling temperatures WBSF values were lower in ES hot-boned LD and SM muscles at days 2, 7 and 14 post-mortem than NES muscles. Hot-boned muscles subjected to slow chilling had longer sarcomeres (P<0.001) than those subjected to fast chilling. In hot-boned SM muscles, ES resulted in longer sarcomere lengths (P<0.001). However, ES did not have a significant effect on the sarcomere length of LD muscles. As indicated by WBSF values all muscles tenderised during ageing, including muscles which were 'cold shortened'. Proteolysis was not the main reason for differences in WBSF values between ES and NES muscles as judged by qualitative sodium dodecyl sulphate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE). A combination of slow chilling and ES had a positive effect on hot-boned muscles with respect to WBSF values.     

High voltage electrical stimulation enhances muscle tenderness, increases aging response, and improves muscle color from cabrito carcasses

Our study examined high and low voltage electrical stimulation and postmortem storage as strategies to improve tenderness and lean color in cabrito carcasses. Boer cross (n=60) kids were assigned to either high (550 V), low (20 V), or no electrical stimulation treatments. No differences in muscle temperature were observed between treatments at any time measured. Muscle pH declined fastest in high voltage treated carcasses. High voltage electrical stimulation slightly increased (P<0.05) b^* and a^* in the M. gluteus medius and tended to increase L^* and b^* (P=0.06 and 0.11, respectively) values in the M. longissimus thoracis. Electrical stimulation had no effect on myofibril fragmentation at 1-, 3-, or 14-d postmortem or sarcomere length. High voltage electrical stimulation increased (P<0.05) tenderness at 1- and 3-d postmortem, but not at 14-d postmortem. Aging for 3 d did not affect tenderness regardless of stimulation treatment, but aging time for 14 d improved (P<0.05) tenderness. These data indicate that high voltage electrical stimulation and 14 d aging were effective in improving the tenderness of meat from cabrito carcasses.     

The protective effect of electrical stimulation and wrapping on beef tenderness at high pre rigor temperatures

A three factorial experimental design involving electrical stimulation (ES/NES), wrapping (wrapped/unwrapped) and pre rigor temperature (15 °C or 35 °C) was applied to 70 beef M. longissimus lumborum muscles to obtain a wide variation in shear force and drip loss. The shear force of all treatment groups decreased during ageing. As anticipated, wrapping and electrical stimulation had positive effects on shear force. However, high pre rigor temperature (35 °C) did not result in higher shear force values if the muscles were electrically stimulated, wrapped or both. The results suggested that electrical stimulation protects against the negative effects of high pre rigor temperatures. The drip loss of all treatment groups increased during ageing in a manner that was unrelated to treatment but was correlated to tenderness (r² = 0.70; p < 0.0001). It was concluded that the application of electrical stimulation, whatever the pre rigor temperature, protects beef from toughening through the prevention of rigor shortening and the avoidance of inhibition of ageing enzymes.     

Alternating frequency to increase the response to stimulation from medium voltage electrical stimulation and the effect on objective meat quality

The use of alternating frequencies during stimulation can increase stimulation response of a medium voltage electrical stimulation unit (MVS) by increasing the rate of pH decline. Various combinations of frequency modulation were tested in experiment 1 to determine the treatment resulting in the greatest stimulation response; the lowest initial pH, fastest rate of pH decline, highest temperature at pH 6 and the highest number of carcasses with a pH of 6 by 25(o)C and the treatment achieving the highest number of carcasses in the pH temp window (temperature at pH 6 between 18-25(o)C). The objective meat quality of these treatments compared to an unstimulated treatment was tested in experiment 2. Modulating the frequency (Hz) across the 6 segmented electrodes of the MVS by 10, 15, 25, 10, 15, 25Hz (Treatment 6, using a pulse width: 2.5ms, current: 1A) resulted in the greatest stimulation response. This treatment may be suitable for abattoirs that hot bone sheepmeat and require fast pH declines to ensure minimal cold shortening of meat. However, this treatment did not result in the tenderer meat despite the higher stimulation response. This treatment may have induced a greater number of contractions overall and therefore a greater pH decline response but resulted in less myofibrillar disruption compared to the other treatments due to a concomitant decreased force of contraction thus reducing potential tenderisation. Maintaining a constant frequency of 15Hz (Treatment 1; pulse width: 2.5ms, current: 1A) resulted in a higher number of carcasses in the pH temp window required (temperature at pH 6 between 18-25(o)C) in part A (P<0.05) and in addition to the higher tenderness levels this treatment may be more appropriate to satisfy the overall demands of abattoirs using these systems. This paper has also demonstrated electrical stimulation results in tenderer meat compared to unstimulated meat even after 30d of ageing (2.53±0.4 compared to 2.85±0.1 for the loin (M. longissimus thoracis et lumborum) (P<0.01) possibly due to a protective benefit of stimulation on meat tenderness. Overall, no detrimental effects of modulating frequency were observed on drip loss or retail colour display despite a greater rate of colour change observed with the modulated frequency treatment and the longer aged product.     

Reassessing the principles of electrical stimulation

The mechanisms by which electrical stimulation (ES) of carcasses can be used to modulate meat quality are reviewed. Evidence to support an effect of ES on tenderness (and other meat quality attributes) based solely on changes in the pH/temperature profile within carcass muscles are presented. The interactions between electrical parameters and the contraction responses of carcass muscles are described to provide generalised principles to guide the design of electrical stimulation technology. The commercial risks to meat quality of inappropriate use of electrical stimulation, particularly excessive stimulation to produce PSE-like conditions, are considered.     

Effect of low voltage electrical stimulation on protein and quality changes in bovine muscles during postmortem aging

This experiment was conducted to determine the influence of low voltage electrical stimulation (ES) on the tenderness development of beef round muscles. Eight steers were slaughtered, and ES applied to one side of each carcass within 90 min of exsanguination. Steaks from M. longissimus dorsi, semimembranosus, adductor, and gracilis were vacuum packaged and aged at 4 °C for 9 d. Star probe, sensory evaluation, Western blot assays of troponin-T and μ-calpain autolysis and 2D-DIGE were conducted. ES resulted in accelerated (P < 0.05) pH decline of the longissimus in the first 24 h postmortem. ES did not influence (P > 0.05) proteolysis and tenderness, but did alter the predominance of metabolic proteins in the soluble fraction of muscle. Aging for 9 d improved tenderness (P < 0.05). The data confirmed that low voltage ES at 90 min of exsanguination had no effect on proteolysis and tenderness development in the longissimus dorsi, semimembranosus, adductor or gracilis in beef.     

The impact of new generation pre-dressing medium-voltage electrical stimulation on tenderness and colour stability in lamb meat

Previous work identified that a large number of domestic lamb carcases processed in Australia do not meet the recommended pH/temperature window during chilling. New medium voltage electrical stimulation technology has been developed to alleviate this problem. This study used an optimised setting (800mA with a pulse width 0.5ms) to evaluate the effects on meat quality with a focus on tenderness and meat colour. In total 40 (electrically stimulated) and 40 (non electrically stimulated) lambs from 11 lots killed over 2 days were evaluated. There was a significant difference (P<0.05) between stimulation treatments for initial pH, rate of pH decline and the predicted temperature at pH 6.0. There was also a large difference in the number of carcases that met the recommended window (pH of 6.0, between 18 and 25°C), with an average 67.5% of stimulated carcases and 25% of unstimulated carcases meeting or falling just above the recommended window. The stimulation treatment had no significant (P>0.05) effect on sarcomere length or myofibrillar fragmentation index (MFI) of the m. longissimus (LL). After 1day of ageing LL samples from stimulated carcases had a significantly lower (P<0.05) shear force than non stimulated samples, but there was no difference between stimulation treatments after 5 days ageing. However, ageing period did have a significant effect (P<0.001) on both MFI and shear force, such that 5days aged product had higher MFI and lower shear force values. There were minimal effects of stimulation on colour stability.     

Effect of age and cut on tenderness of South African beef

The tenderness characteristics of 15 primal cuts of beef of three different age groups were assessed, and the most reliable cut to predict carcass tenderness was determined. Fifteen wholesale cuts from each age group, representing the full variation in fatness, were aged, cooked and underwent sensory evaluation, shear force resistance and proximate analysis. Collagen content and solubility was determined. Percentage fat was used as a covariant during statistical analyses. Tenderness, residue and collagen solubility of all cuts decreased significantly with animal age. Collagen solubility was the largest discriminant between the three age groups, while animal age had no significant effect on collagen content. Tenderness of primal cuts from the same carcass varied considerably, with collagen content and shear force resistance as the largest discriminants between the cuts. Cuts most representative of total carcass tenderness were M. vastus lateralis, M. semimembranosus, M. gluteobiceps, M. semitendinosus and M. triceps brachii caput longum.     

Rapid chilling has no detrimental effect on the tenderness of low-voltage electrically stimulated M. longissimus in Chinese bulls

This study investigated the effect of pre-rigor rapid chilling (RC) on the rate of pH and temperature decline, shear force values and ultrastructure of M. longissimus from beef carcasses exposed to electrical stimulation (ES). Chinese bull carcasses were electrically stimulated, and the alternate sides of the carcasses either were chilled conventionally (CC, 0-4°C, air speed 0.5 m/s for 24 h) or they underwent RC (-14±1°C, air speed 3 m/s for 2 h and then cooled under CC conditions until 24 h post-mortem). The results showed that RC increased the rate of temperature decline (P<0.05) and decreased the rate of pH decline (P<0.05). There were no significant differences in the shear force value and sarcomere length of M. longissimus between the two treatments (P>0.05). The results of this study indicate that RC has no detrimental impact on the tenderness of beef carcasses exposed to ES.     

National beef tenderness survey - 2006: Assessment of Warner-Bratzler shear and sensory panel ratings for beef from US retail and foodservice establishments

Beef from retail and foodservice establishments in 11 US cities was evaluated using Warner-Bratzler shear (WBS) and consumer evaluation panels. Postmortem aging times ranged from 3 to 83d for retail and 7 to 136d for foodservice with mean aging times of 22.6d and 30.1d, respectively. For retail, the three cuts from the round - top round, bottom round, and eye of round - had the highest (P<0.05) WBS values compared to cuts from the chuck, rib, and loin. Top loin steaks had the lowest (P<0.05) WBS value compared to ribeye and top sirloin foodservice steaks. Retail bone-in top loin, top loin, ribeye, T-bone, and porterhouse received the highest (P<0.05) ratings by consumers for overall like and like tenderness. Quality grade had little or no effect on foodservice sensory evaluations. Improvements in round tenderness are needed to increase consumer acceptability.     

Tenderness enhancement of beef from Bos indicus and Bos taurus cattle following electrical stimulation

High voltage electrical stimulation (1130 V peak, 14.28 bidirectional half sinusoidal pulses/s) or low voltage stimulation (45 V peak, 36 alternating square wave pulses/s) was used on cattle: (1) low voltage stimulation applied for 10 or 40 s with fast and slow chilling or high voltage stimulation for 60 s with normal chilling, applied to 100% Bos taurus cattle, (2) low voltage stimulation (40 s) and high voltage stimulation (60 s) with normal chilling applied to mixed Bos indicus and B.taurus cattle, (3) high voltage stimulation (54 s) with normal chilling applied to B. taurus and B. indicus cattle of 0–100% B. indicus composition, and (4) high voltage stimulation (60 s) applied to 100% B. taurus and 100% B. indicus cattle. All stimulation parameters enhanced the tenderness of steaks from M. longissimus thoracis et lumborum (LTL) aged at 1 °C up to 28 days compared with non stimulated LTL. Short low voltage stimulation of 10 s was marginally more effective than no stimulation and longer durations of 40 s were very effective and high voltage stimulation was most effective.     

Heat shock and structural proteins associated with meat tenderness in Nellore beef cattle,a Bos indicus breed

Nellore beef cattle, a Bos indicus (Zebu) breed, is well adapted to tropical conditions and has allowed Brazil to become one of the largest producers of red meat. Nevertheless, B. indicus breeds are reported to have less tender meat than Bos taurus. This study was designed to identify genes associated with meat tenderness and thus provides important information for breeding programs. A group of 138 animals was evaluated for longissimus thoracis muscle shear force (SF). Animals with the highest and lowest SF values (six animals each) were then selected for protein abundance studies. Samples were subjected to two-dimensional gel electrophoresis (2-DE) followed by peptide sequencing through mass spectrometry (MS) to identify differentially expressed proteins associated with SF values. Seventeen differentially expressed spots were observed (p < 0.05) between the two groups. The 13 proteins identified included structural proteins (alpha actin-1, MLC1, MLC3, MLC2F and tropomyosin), related to cell organization (HSPB1 and HSP70), metabolism (beta-LG, ACBD6 and Complex III subunit I) and some uncharacterized proteins. Results confirm the existence of differentially expressed proteins associated with SF, which can lead to a better understanding of mechanisms involved in meat tenderness.     

Effect of electrical stimulation on quality of tenderstretched chevon sides

Thirty male Black Bengal goats 5-8 years of age, slaughtered at the Kolkata slaughter house, India, by the traditional 'halal' method, were used to assess the effect of electrical stimulation on tenderstretched sides of chevon carcasses. Five groups (T1, T2, T3, T4 and T5) were treated with variable voltages of 35, 110, 330, 550, 1100 with fixed 50Hz and 10pulses/s for a duration of 3min. Different quality parameters, such as, fibre diameter, sarcomere length, water holding capacity (WHC), pH, microbial content and taste panel score were studied at 24 and 48h post-stimulation. pH, WHC and fibre diameter decreased whereas sarcomere length showed an increasing trend in electrically stimulated meat, which was also microbiologically more stable. The non-stimulated control meat was tougher than the electrically stimulated chevon as evident through taste panel scoring. Treatment 3 (T3), i.e. 330V, 50Hz and 10pulses/s, showed superiority over the other four treatments in the majority of the important meat quality parameters.     

Application of constant current, low voltage electrical stimulation systems to pig carcasses and its effects on pork quality

This study examined the effectiveness of a constant current, low voltage electrical stimulation system on improving pork quality when applied to pigs at 2 min post-exsanguination. A total of 48 female Duroc×Large White/Landrace pigs of 85–90 kg liveweight were randomly allocated immediately prior to slaughter to one of four constant current electrical stimulation treatments: control (no electrical stimulation), 50, 200 and 400 mA. Stimulation was applied to pig carcasses at 2 min post-exsanguination for 30 s. No differences (P>0.05) in WB shear force values, muscle lightness or PSE incidence of pork M. longissimus lumborum (LL) was found due to electrical stimulation treatment. Muscle pH of the LL muscle was lower (P<0.001) in carcasses in the 200 and 400 mA treatments compared to those from carcasses in both the 50 mA and control treatment groups, when measured at the various time points from 40 min to 8 h post-slaughter. Although carcasses stimulated with 200 and 400 mA had higher percentage drip loss (P<0.05) and purge (P<0.001), this was not found to impact WB shear force values, muscle lightness or PSE incidence.     

Linear correlation between pH value of stimulated beef and electrical current intensity

The aim of the present study was to determine mathematical relationships between pH changes in beef 24 h post-slaughter and changes in the intensity of electrical current flowing through bull and heifer carcasses during high-voltage electrical stimulation. The electrical stimulation was applied 40 min postmortem for 120 s. The pH values of m. longissimus thoracis et lumborum were analyzed in the function of electrical current intensity changes and its change during electrical stimulation. Mathematical linear correlations of the y = ax ± b type were demonstrated between pH values at 2, 6, and 24 h postmortem and the initial (I_i) and ultimate (I_u) electrical current intensity values, the difference between them and the initial pH values determined before electrical stimulation. High multiple correlation coefficients (R² = 0.416, α ≤ 0.001) between I_u and pH values 24 h post-slaughter enabled concluding that there is a possibility to predict a pH value of stimulated carcass with high accuracy, and thus also beef quality, based merely on the ultimate electrical current intensity values.     

High pre rigor temperature limits the ageing potential of beef that is not completely overcome by electrical stimulation and muscle restraining

Two simultaneous trials were conducted to determine the effects of electrical input [electrical stunning and stimulation (ES)], wrapping, pre rigor temperature (15 °C and 38 °C) and different post rigor chilling rates on beef quality using M. longissimus lumborum (n=100). The high pre rigor temperature induced a faster pH decline than ES. The loins at 38 °C had significantly greater protein denaturation, more purge and drip loss, higher shear force values and less desmin degradation compared with the loins at 15 °C. No difference in sarcomere length was determined between the pre rigor temperatures regardless of ES and wrapping. Different post rigor chilling rates did not play a substantial role in water-holding capacity, proteolysis, or shear force values during ageing. These results suggest that high pre rigor temperature induces temperature-related toughness of muscle due to protein denaturation with subsequent limitation of proteolysis by μ-calpain, regardless of ES and wrapping treatments.     

The effect of nutritional supplements on growth rate, stress responsiveness, muscle glycogen and meat tenderness in pastoral lambs

Nutritional supplements and a magnesium bolus and were used in lambs in a 2×2 factorial design to investigate the effect on growth, preslaughter stress measurements, muscle glycogen, and meat quality. In total, 64 Perendale lambs were used (32.7±0.53 kg, mean±SEM). Feed supplemented animals received 150 g feed pellets day⁻¹ in addition to pasture grazing, and this increased growth from 183 to 207 g day⁻¹. Mean delivery of Mg from the boluses was 0.17 g day⁻¹ for 28 days, with no effect on growth rates, or any other of the variables measured. Urinary noradrenaline, adrenaline and cortisol did not differ between groups in the immediate pre-slaughter period. The meat ultimate pH was not different between groups and had a mean range of 5.47–5.53. Muscle residual glycogen did not differ between groups and had a mean range of 42–43 mmol kg⁻¹. Finally there were no differences in shear force values at all ageing times. The final shear force value of 2.5 kg F after 72 h ageing at 15 °C was a low value representing tender meat. These studies indicate that if nutrition is adequate and stress levels are low, there are no differences in meat tenderness of pasture fed lambs compared with those having feed supplements to increase growth rate.     

SmartStretch™ technology. III. The impact of medium voltage stimulation and SmartStretch™ technology on sheep topside (m. semimembranosus) meat quality traits under commercial processing conditions

This study evaluated the interaction between medium voltage electrical stimulation, SmartStretch™ stretching and ageing treatments on key meat quality traits of hot boned sheep m. semimembranosus. Medium voltage stimulation reduced initial pH (P < 0.001), but did not impact on other meat quality traits. There was a significant interaction between stretch treatment and ageing (P < 0.001) for shear force such that samples which were both stretched and aged were the most tender. Sarcomere length was significantly (P < 0.001) increased by SmartStretch™ treatment. Control (no stretching) resulted in greater (P < 0.05) cooking loss, but there was significantly less purge loss (P < 0.05). The ratio 630/580 nm and a* colour values at 0 and 5 days decreased at a significantly (P < 0.05) slower rate when SmartStretch™ was applied. Overall medium voltage stimulation did not inhibit the effectiveness of the SmartStretch™ treatment. The SmartStretch™ treatment provided significant improvement in tenderness and the potential to increase meat display time.     

电刺激对宰后牦牛肉成熟过程中肌钙蛋白-T和肌间线蛋白及嫩度的影响

为研究电刺激对宰后牦牛肉成熟过程中Troponin-T和Desmin降解及嫩度的影响,本实验利用聚丙烯酰胺凝胶电泳（SDS-PAGE）、剪切力法及肌原纤维小片化指数法分别对比测定并动态监测宰后不同处理（电刺激、未电刺激）对牦牛的冈上肌、背阔肌和半腱肌3个部位肉在成熟0,1,2,3,5,7,14 d时Troponin-T、Desmin、剪切力及MFI影响的变化特点。结果表明:电刺激组牦牛三个部位肉Troponin-T和Desmin的降解速度和降解程度均较高,且两个处理组背阔肌Troponin-T 28 k Da、Desmin 38 k Da和36 k Da特征降解产物出现的时间较其他两个部位均早,降解程度也较高;成熟14 d后,电刺激组牦牛冈上肌、背阔肌和半腱肌的剪切力值下降百分率较未电刺激组分别显著高2.93%、9.47%、5.08%（p<0.05）,但电刺激对MFI值无显著影响。由此可见,电刺激处理能显著加快宰后牦牛肉肌原纤维骨架蛋白Troponin-T和Desmin的降解程度及剪切力的下降速度,且背阔肌的宰后嫩化较其他两个部位快。