A new iterated fast local search heuristic for solving QAP formulation in facility layout design

In facility layout design, the problem of locating facilities with material flow between them was formulated as a quadratic assignment problem (QAP), so that the total cost to move the required material between the facilities is minimized, where the cost is defined by a quadratic function. In this paper, we propose a modification to iterated fast local search algorithm (IFLS) with a new recombination crossover operator and the modified IFLS is addressed as NIFLS. The ideas we incorporate in the NIFLS are iterated self-improvement with evolutionary based perturbation tool, which includes (i) recombination crossover as perturbation tool and (ii) self-improvement in mutation operation followed by a local search. Three schemes of NIFLS are proposed and the obtained solution qualities by the three schemes are compared. We test our algorithm on all the benchmark instances of QAPLIB, a well-known library of QAP instances. The performance of proposed recombination crossover with sliding mutation (RCSM) scheme of NIFLS is well superior to the other two schemes of NIFLS.     

An entropy-based algorithm to solve the facility layout design problem

This paper presents a new design approach used in order to solve the facility layout problem. The layout problem is viewed from the general perspective as a problem of the arrangement of elements within a system. The main attributes and relationships among the elements of the system are analyzed.     

An integrated synthetic value of fuzzy judgments and nonlinear programming methodology for ranking the facility layout patterns

In this paper, the goal is to incorporate qualitative criteria in addition to quantitative criteria to facility layout design (FLD) problem. To this end, we present an integrated methodology based on the synthetic value of fuzzy judgments and nonlinear programming (SVFJ-NLP). The facility layout patterns (FLPs) together with their performance measures of total cost of material handling are generated by a computer-aided layout-design tool, CRAFT. Also, the performance measures of second quantitative criterion (construction cost of width walls) are calculated by appraising these FLPs. The SVFJ is then applied to collect the performance measures related to qualitative criteria and finally, a non-linear programming (NLP) model is proposed to solve the FLD. Results obtained from a real case study validate the effectiveness of the proposed model.     

A hybrid multi-population genetic algorithm for the dynamic facility layout problem

Due to inherent complexity of the dynamic facility layout problem, it has always been a challenging issue to develop a solution algorithm for this problem. For more than one decade, many researchers have proposed different algorithms for this problem. After reviewing the shortcomings of these algorithms, we realize that the performance can be further improved by a more intelligent search. This paper develops an effective novel hybrid multi-population genetic algorithm. Using a proposed heuristic procedure, we separate solution space into different parts and each subpopulation represents a separate part. This assures the diversity of the algorithm. Moreover, to intensify the search more and more, a powerful local search mechanism based on simulated annealing is developed. Unlike the available genetic operators previously proposed for this problem, we design the operators so as to search only the feasible space; thus, we save computational time by avoiding infeasible space. To evaluate the algorithm, we comprehensively discuss the parameter tuning of the algorithms by Taguchi method. The perfectly tuned algorithm is then compared with 11 available algorithms in the literature using well-known set of benchmark instances. Different analyses conducted on the results, show that the proposed algorithm enjoys the superiority and outperformance over the other algorithms.     

A simulated annealing heuristic for the dynamic layout problem with budget constraint

Facility layout problem has been extensively studied in the literature because the total material handling cost can be a significant portion in the operational costs for a company and in the manufacturing cost of a product. Today’s severe global competition, rapid changes in technology and shortening life cycle of products force companies to evaluate and modify their facility layout in a periodic fashion. This type of layout problems is categorized as the dynamic facility layout problem (DFLP). As a realistic dimension of the problem, one has to consider also the limited budget to cover the cost of changing the layout. In this study, we propose a simulated annealing heuristic for the DFLP with budget constraint, and show the effectiveness of this heuristic on a set of numerical experiments.     

Solving the design of distributed layout problem using forecast windows: A hybrid algorithm approach

In today’s competitive environment, manufacturing facilities have to be more responsive to the frequent changes in product mix and demand by realigning their organizational structure for minimizing material handling cost. However, manufacturing firms are reluctant to modify the layout as it leads to operation disruption and excess rearrangement cost. In this paper, we present an alternative approach for designing a multi-period layout (i.e., distributed layout) that maintains a tradeoff between re-layout cost and cost of excess material handling. Obtaining an optimal solution to distributed layout problem is generally a difficult task, owing to larger size of quadratic assignment problem. In order to overcome the aforementioned drawback, a meta-heuristic, named ‘CSO-DLP’ (Clonal Symbiotic Operated-Distributed Layout Planning) is developed for designing a distributed layout that jointly determines the arrangement of department and flow allocation among them. It inherits its trait from Symbiotic algorithm and Clonal algorithm. In addition to these; the concept of ‘forecast window’ is used, which evaluates the layout for varying number of periods at a given time. The proposed meta-heuristic is applied on a benchmark dataset and the effect of system parameters, such as rearrangement cost, department disintegration, and duplication are investigated and benchmarked in this paper.     

Simulated annealing heuristics for the dynamic facility layout problem

In today's economy, manufacturing plants must be able to operate efficiently and respond quickly to changes in product mix and demand. Therefore, this paper considers the problem of arranging and rearranging (when there are changes between the flows of materials between departments) manufacturing facilities such that the sum of the material handling and rearrangement costs is minimized. This problem is known as the dynamic facility layout problem (DFLP). In this paper, two simulated annealing (SA) heuristics are developed for the DFLP. The first SA heuristic (SA I) is a direct adaptation of SA to the DFLP. The second SA heuristic (SA II) is the same as SA I with a look-ahead/look-back strategy added. To test the performance of the heuristics, a data set taken from the literature is used in the analysis. The results obtained show that the proposed heuristics are very effective for the dynamic facility layout problem.     

Integrating data envelopment analysis and analytic hierarchy for the facility layout design in manufacturing systems

Facility layout design (FLD) has a very important effect on the performance of a manufacturing system. The concept of FLD is usually considered as a multiobjective problem. For this reason, a layout generation and its evaluation are often challenging and time consuming due to their inherent multiple objectives in nature and their data collection process. In addition, an effective facility layout evaluation procedure necessitates the consideration of qualitative criteria, e.g., flexibility in volume and variety and quality related to the product and production, as well as quantitative criteria such as material handling cost, adjacency score, shape ratio, and material handling vehicle utilization in the decision process. This paper presents a decision-making methodology based on data envelopment analysis (DEA), which uses both quantitative and qualitative criteria, for evaluating FLD. The criteria that are to be minimized are viewed as inputs whereas the criteria to be maximized are considered as outputs. A computer-aided layout-planning tool, VisFactory, is adopted to facilitate the layout alternative design process as well as to collect quantitative data by using exact and vague data by means of fuzzy set theory. Analytic hierarchy process (AHP) is then applied to collect qualitative data related to quality and flexibility. The DEA methodology is used to solve the layout design problem by simultaneously considering both the quantitative and qualitative data. The purposed integrated procedure is applied to a real data set of a case study, which consists of 19 FLDs provided of the plastic profile production system.     

An LP-based heuristic procedure for the generalized assignment problem with special ordered sets

The generalized assignment problem with special ordered sets (GAPS2), is the problem of allocating n tasks to m time-periods, where each task must be assigned to a time-period, or shared between two consecutive time-periods. For reasonably large values of m and n the NP-hard combinatorial problem GAPS2 becomes intractable for standard mathematical programming software, hence there is a need for heuristic algorithms to solve such problems. It will be shown how an LP-based heuristic developed previously for the well-established generalized assignment problem can be modified and extended to solve GAPS2. Encouraging results, in terms of speed and accuracy, in particular when compared to an existing heuristic for GAPS2, are described.     

An alternative multiple attribute decision making methodology for solving optimal facility layout design selection problems

In the present work, a systematic and an alternative multiple attribute decision making methodology is presented for selection of facility layout design selection problems. The proposed methodology is based on Preference selection index (PSI) method. In the proposed methodology appropriate facility layout design is selected for a given application without considering relative importance between facility layout design selection attributes. Two different types of facility layout design selection problems are examined to demonstrate, validate, and to check the reliability of proposed methodology. In addition, subjective cost benefit analysis is performed to study the benefits to cost to the company. Finally, the study has concluded that the facility layout design selection methodology based on PSI method is simple, logical, and more appropriate for solving the facility layout design selection problems.     

A genetic algorithm with the heuristic procedure to solve the multi-line layout problem

The paper presents a genetic algorithm-based meta-heuristic to solve the facility layout problem (FLP) in a manufacturing system, where the material flow pattern of the multi-line layout is considered with the multi-products. The matrix encoding technique has been used for the chromosomes under the objective of minimizing the total material handling cost. The proposed algorithm produces a table with the descending order of the data corresponding to the input values of the flow and cost data. The generated table is used to create a schematic representation of the facilities, which in turn is utilized to heuristically generate the initial population of the chromosomes and to handle the heuristic crossover and mutation operators. The efficiency of the proposed algorithm has been proved through solving the two examples with the total cost less than the other genetic algorithms, CRAFT algorithm, and entropy-based algorithm.     

The heuristic concentration-integer and its application to a class of location problems

We propose a new metaheuristic called heuristic concentration-integer (HCI). This metaheuristic is a modified version of the heuristic concentration (HC), oriented to find good solutions for a class of integer programming problems, composed by problems in which p   elements must be selected from a larger set, and each element can be selected more than once. These problems are common in location analysis. The heuristic is explained and general instructions for rewriting integer programming formulations are provided, that make the application of HCI to these problems easier. As an example, the heuristic is applied to the maximal availability location problem (MALP), and the solutions are compared to those obtained using linear programming with branch and bound (LP+B&B)$(\mathrm{LP}+\mathrm{B}\&\mathrm{B})$. For one-third of the instances of MALP, LP+B&B$\mathrm{LP}+\mathrm{B}\&\mathrm{B}$ can be allowed to run until the computer is out of memory without termination, while HCI can find good solutions to the same instances in a reasonable time. In one such case, LP-IP was allowed to run for nearly 100 times longer than HCI and HCI still found a better solution. Furthermore, HCI found the optimal solution in 33.3% of cases and had an objective value gap of less than 1% in 76% of cases. In 18% of the cases, HCI found a solution that is better than LP+B&B. Therefore, in cases where LP+B&B$\mathrm{LP}+\mathrm{B}\&\mathrm{B}$ is unreasonable due to time or memory constraints, HCI is a valuable tool.     

A new optimization model to support a bottom-up approach to facility design

The facility layout problem is typically solved in what is referred to as a “top-down approach” of block layout design followed by detailed layout determination. However, a number of research efforts recently have challenged this approach, producing a reformulated bottom-up approach to the facility layout problem. In this paper we consider the bottom-up approach, applying a tighter formulation than prior efforts and investigating the solvability limits of the new model. Empirical testing of the new bottom-up layout model indicates that although this model produces more usable output, as judged by industry experts, it is approximately three times harder to solve. Valid inequalities and special cases are identified to help improve the formulation's solvability.     

A neuro-based expert system for facility layout construction

Motivated by the success of implementing expert systems (ESs) based on artificial neural networks (ANNs) to improved classical rule-based expert systems (RBESs), this paper reports on the development of a neuro-based expert system (NBES) for facility layout construction in a manufacturing system. In an artificial intelligence (AI) technique such as the NBES, the semantic structure of If-Then rules is preserved, while incorporating the learning capability of ANNs into the inference mechanism. Unlike implementing a popular back propagation network (BPN) as an ES, the proposed BAMFLO (Bidirectional Associative Memories for Facility LayOut) system is an intelligent layout consultant system consisting of pipeline BAM neural networks with simple, fast incremental learning and multiple bidirectional generalization characteristics. This incrementability makes BAMFLO effective at acquiring, adding or adapting learned layout knowledge; thus it is possible to memorize newly extended If-Then layout rules without retraining old ones. The multi-bidirectionality gives BAMFLO the ability to quickly and reliably generalize a layout solution, and to further infer unknown facts from known facts through a complex knowledge base (memorization) without losing information. The solution process of BAMFLO contains three essential steps: training example generation, incremental learning and solution generalization. The examples (layout knowledge) can be generated from practical experience and/or classical layout software solutions for incrementally training BAMFLO; the process then derives multiply bidirectionally generalized construction layout solutions. The experimental results show that the BAMFLO scheme outperforms five classical layout methods used to generate training examples.     

Solving an extended multi-row facility layout problem with fuzzy clearances using GA

Multi-row facility layout problem (MRFLP) is a class of facility layout problems, which decides upon the arrangement of facilities in some fixed numbers of rows in order to minimize material handling cost. Nowadays, according to the new layout requirements, the facility layout problems (FLPs) have many applications such as hospital layout, construction site layout planning and layout of logistics facilities. Therefore, we study an extended MRFLP, as a novel layout problem, with the following main assumptions: 1) the facilities are arranged in a two-dimensional area and without splitter rows, 2) multiple products are available, 3) distance between each pair of facilities, due to inaccurate and flexible manufacturing processes and other limitations (such as WIPs, industrial instruments, transportation lines and etc.), is considered as fuzzy number, and 4) the objective function is considered as minimizing the material handling and lost opportunity costs. To model these assumptions, a nonlinear mixed-integer programming model with fuzzy constraints is presented and then converted to a linear mixed-integer programming model. Since the developed model is an NP-hard problem, a genetic algorithm approach is suggested to find the best solutions with a minimum cost function. Additionally, three different crossover methods are compared in the proposed genetic algorithm and finally, a sensitivity analysis is performed to discuss important parameters.     

Application of the Analytic Network Process to facility layout selection

This paper applies the Analytic Network Process (ANP) method to the selection of the best facility layout plan based on multiple dependent and independent criteria. This is the first time that this method is used in such a context. An ANP model is built taking into account the interdependencies between criteria that are found based on experts’ opinions and fundamental equations. A network structure is built that shows all elements and clusters and their interactions that can be used to find the most effective layout. Limit priorities are computed which identify the most important factors in the selection process. A case study is conducted in a wood factory which represents a real demonstration of the developed model. A comparison is conducted between ANP and Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) which shows the differences between the two methods. Finally, sensitivity analysis shows the robustness of the model.     

Solving the uncapacitated facility location problem using tabu search

A tabu search heuristic procedure is developed to solve the uncapacitated facility location problem. Tabu search is used to guide the solution process when evolving from one solution to another. A move is defined to be the opening or closing of a facility. The net cost change resulting from a candidate move is used to measure the attractiveness of the move. After a move is made, the net cost change of a candidate move is updated from its old value. Updating, rather than re-computing, the net cost changes substantially reduces computation time needed to solve a problem when the problem is not excessively large. Searching only a small subset of the feasible solutions that contains the optimal solution, the procedure is computationally very efficient. A computational experiment is conducted to test the performance of the procedure and computational results are reported. The procedure can easily find optimal or near optimal solutions for benchmark test problems from the literature. For randomly generated test problems, this tabu search procedure not only obtained solutions completely dominating those obtained with other heuristic methods recently published in the literature but also used substantially less computation time. Therefore, this tabu search procedure has advantage over other heuristic methods in both solution quality and computation speed.     

基于Wang-Landau算法的动态设施布局方法

动态设施布局问题是设施在车间内多个阶段的布局规划问题。目前,针对动态设施布局问题,国内外学者对离散模型研究较多,而对连续模型的研究却较少。根据连续动态设施布局的特性与需求,构建了不等面积设施的动态设施布局连续模型。求解该模型的难点在于缺乏一种高效的布局优化方法。Wang-Landau算法是一种改进的蒙特卡罗算法。通过将Wang-Landau算法与空位点放置策略、外推移动策略、内压移动策略三种启发式策略相结合,提出一种基于Wang-Landau抽样的启发式算法,并以此求解该模型。使用文献中已有的测试算例对提出的算法进行测试,计算结果表明,所提出的算法在求解连续动态设施布局问题上是有效的。     

Solving dynamic double row layout problem via combining simulated annealing and mathematical programming

Double row layout problem (DRLP) is to allocate facilities on two rows separated by a straight aisle. Aiming at the dynamic environment of product processing in practice, we propose a dynamic double-row layout problem (DDRLP) where material flows change over time in different processing periods. A mixed-integer programming model is established for this problem. A methodology combining an improved simulated annealing (ISA) with mathematical programming (MP) is proposed to resolve it. Firstly, a mixed coding scheme is designed to represent both of sequence of facilities and their exact locations. Secondly, an improved simulated annealing algorithm is suggested to produce a solution to DDRLP. Finally, MP is used to improve this solution by determining the optimal exact location for each facility. Experiments show that this methodology is able to obtain the optimal solutions for small size problems and outperforms an exact approach (CPLEX) for problems of realistic size.     

An integrated model and a decomposition-based approach for concurrent layout and material handling system design

This paper presents an integer programming formulation that integrates decisions concerning the layout of the resource groups on the shop floor with the design of the material handling system. The model reflects critical practical concerns, including the capacity of the material flow network and of the handling transporters, as well as the tradeoff between fixed (construction and acquisition) and variable (operational) costs. For realistic industrial cases, the size of the problem prevents the solution using explicit or implicit enumeration methods. Instead, the global model is decomposed into standard optimization problems: quadratic assignment, fixed charge capacitated network design, and non-depot distance-constrained vehicle routing. An integrated solution method, guided by a simulated annealing scheme, solves the global shop design problem. The algorithm takes advantage of the proposed decomposition and converges to a final design which is feasible with respect to all problem constraints. The method is applied to redesign the facility of a large manufacturer of radar antennas. The resulting shop configuration exhibits substantially decreased material handling effort, and requires significantly smaller investment costs compared to the existing facility.