Untangling the alliance-outcome correlation: Exploring the relative importance of therapist and patient variability in the alliance.

Although the therapeutic alliance is a consistent predictor of psychotherapy outcomes, research has not distinguished between the roles of patient and therapist variability in the alliance. Multilevel models were used to explore the relative importance of patient and therapist variability in the alliance as they relate to outcome among 331 patients seen by 80 therapists (therapist average caseload was 4.1). Patients rated both the alliance and outcome and all models adjusted for baseline psychological functioning. The results indicated that therapist variability in the alliance predicted outcome, whereas patient variability in the alliance was unrelated to outcome. Reasons why therapist variability as opposed to patient variability predicted outcome are discussed. Clinical implications include therapists monitoring their contribution to the alliance, clinics providing feedback to therapists about their alliances, and therapists receiving training to develop and maintain strong alliances. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2010 APA, all rights reserved)     

A-B therapist status, patient diagnosis, and psychotherapy outcome in a psychiatric outpatient population.

Previous research generally has supported the hypothesis that A therapists obtain better therapy outcomes with schizophrenics, while B therapists do better with neurotics. Based on recent evidence, a 2nd hypothesis (super A) has been advanced which predicts that A therapists do at least as well with neurotic patients as do B therapists and that As obtain significantly more positive outcomes with schizophrenics. To examine these hypotheses, the therapy outcomes of 7 A and 4 B therapists, differentiated by their scores on the 23-item Whitehorn and Betz (1957) A-B scale, with their 18 schizophrenic and 18 neurotic patients were examined. A multivariate ANOVA computed for the 2 outcome measures, therapists' ratings of patient improvement and number of therapy sessions, clearly supported the super-A hypothesis. Separate ANOVAs demonstrated further support for the super-A hypothesis with therapists' ratings as the dependent variable, whereas the interaction hypothesis received support with number of sessions attended as the dependent measure. Of considerable importance was the fact that the addition of ataractic medication to the treatment of schizophrenics did not attenuate the effect of the A-B therapist distinction on therapeutic outcome. (32 ref) (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2010 APA, all rights reserved)     

Racial/ethnic disparities in therapist effectiveness: A conceptualization and initial study of cultural competence.

As a result of mental health disparities between White and racial/ethnic minority clients, researchers have argued that some therapists may be generally competent to provide effective services but lack cultural competence. This distinction assumes that client racial/ethnic background is a source of variability in therapist effectiveness. However, there have been no direct tests of the therapist as a source of health disparities. We provided an initial test of the distinction between general and cultural competence by examining client racial/ethnic background as a source of variability in therapist effectiveness. We analyzed cannabis use outcomes from a psychotherapy trial (N = 582) for adolescent cannabis abuse and dependence using Bayesian multilevel models for count outcomes. We first tested whether therapists differed in their effectiveness and then tested whether disparities in treatment outcomes varied across therapist caseloads. Results suggested that therapists differed in their effectiveness in general and that effectiveness varied according to client racial/ethnic background. Therapist effectiveness may depend partially on client racial/ethnic minority background, providing evidence that it is valid to distinguish between general and cultural competence. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2011 APA, all rights reserved)     

Differences in the effectiveness of psychodynamic therapists: A process-outcome study.

Using data from a study (e.g., H. H. Strupp; see record 1993-38424-001) on the effect of therapist training on psychotherapy outcome, 16 therapists were identified as either more effective or less effective based on patients' outcome scores and length of stay (LOS) in treatment. Measures were completed by patients, therapists, independent observers, and therapists' supervisors. In-session behaviors were assessed at Sessions 3, 8, 16, and 22. More effective therapists displayed more positive behaviors (e.g., warmth), fewer negative behaviors (e.g., attacking), and more self-criticism than did less effective therapists. All therapists, however, showed some negative behavior. Significant results were almost entirely relationship-oriented. LOS was related to therapist behavior more often than were outcome scores. Only supervisors were largely unable to make the distinction between more or less effective therapists. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2010 APA, all rights reserved)     

Client and therapist variability in clients' perceptions of their therapists' multicultural competencies.

This study examined therapist differences in their clients' ratings of their therapists' multicultural competencies (MCCs) as well as tested whether therapists' who were rated as exhibiting more MCCs also had clients who had better therapy outcomes (N = 143 clients and 31 therapists). All clients completed at least 3 sessions. Results demonstrated that therapists accounted for less than 1% of the variance in their clients' Cross-Cultural Counseling Inventory–Revised (CCCI-R; T. D. LaFromboise, H. L. K. Coleman, & A. Hernandez, 1991) scores, suggesting that therapists did not differ in terms of how clients rated their MCCs. Therapists accounted for approximately 8.5% of the variance in therapy outcomes. For each therapist, their clients' CCCI-R scores were aggregated to provide an estimate of therapists' MCCs. Therapists' MCCs, based on aggregate CCCI-R scores, did not account for the variability in therapy outcomes that were attributed to them. Additionally, clients' race/ethnicity, therapists' race/ethnicity, or the interaction of clients'–therapists' race/ethnicity were not significantly associated with clients' perceptions of their therapists' MCCs. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2010 APA, all rights reserved)     

"Graduate training in psychotherapy: Are therapy outcomes enhanced?": Comment on Stein and Lambert (1995).

Comments on the article by D. M. Stein and M. J. Lambert (Journal of Consulting & Clinical Psychology, 1995[Apr], Vol 63[2], 182–296). The authors misunderstood the meta-analysis of P. Crits-Cristoph et al (see record 1992-20595-001) as examining the relation of therapist experience to "therapist effects" (i.e., differences between therapists in their average outcomes). The Crits-Cristoph et al results did not show that experienced therapists had better outcomes than less experienced therapists. It is also noted that the data in Table 3 are, in fact, correct. However, these 2 errors do not affect the main findings of Stein and Lambert's article. (The following abstract of this article originally appeared in PA, Vol 82:26915.) Several sources of indirect evidence supporting the value of graduate training in psychotherapy are reviewed here. Training protocols that are known to enhance trainees' skills are briefly discussed, as are conclusions of meta-analytic reviews examining relationships between therapist experience and training, and therapy outcome. An updated meta-analysis of therapy outcome studies involving within-study comparisons of psychotherapists of different levels of training and experience is summarized.… (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2010 APA, all rights reserved)     

Therapist sexual orientation, gender, and counseling practices as they relate to ratings on helpfulness by gay and lesbian clients.

Three hundred ninety-two lesbian and gay volunteers described their experiences with 923 therapists, reporting therapist sexual orientation, therapist gender, and perceived helpfulness of the therapist in each case. Gay, lesbian, and bisexual therapists of both genders and heterosexual female therapists were all rated more helpful than heterosexual male therapists. Participants also reported whether each therapist exhibited 9 negative and 4 positive practices. Relative risk ratios indicated that 8 of the 9 negative therapist practices were significantly associated with (a) client designation of a therapist as unhelpful and (b) termination after 1 session. All 4 of the positive practices were inversely associated both with unhelpful ratings and with termination after 1 session. Therapist practices accounted for more of the variance in ratings of helpfulness than did therapist demographic characteristics. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2010 APA, all rights reserved)     

Characteristics of effective therapists: Further analyses of data from the National Institute of Mental Health Treatment of Depression Collaborative Research Program.

Analyses of the data of the National Institute of Mental Health-sponsored Treatment of Depression Collaborative Research Program have primarily examined the effects of types of treatment and patient characteristics on outcome, but scant attention has been directed toward evaluating the contributions of the therapist. With an aggregate of residualized therapeutic change scores of the 5 primary outcome measures for each patient at termination as an overall measure of improvement, an average therapeutic effectiveness measure was derived for each of the 28 therapists based on the outcome of the patients they saw in active treatment. The distribution of the therapists was divided into thirds, and comparisons indicate that more effective therapists are more psychological minded, eschew biological interventions (i.e., medication and electroconvulsive therapy) in their ordinary clinical practice, and expect outpatient treatment of depression to take longer than did moderately and less effective therapists. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2010 APA, all rights reserved)     

Therapists, therapist variables, and cognitive-behavioral therapy outcome in a multicenter trial for panic disorder.

The relationship between therapists and treatment outcome was examined in 14 highly trained therapists who participated in the Multicenter Collaborative Study for the Treatment of Panic Disorder. Overall, therapists yielded positive outcomes in their caseloads; yet, therapists significantly differed in the magnitude of change among caseloads. Effect sizes for therapist impact on outcome measures varied from 0% to 18%. Overall experience in conducting psychotherapy was related to outcome on some measures, whereas age, gender, gender match, and experience with cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) were not. Therapists with above- and below-average outcomes were rated similarly on measures of adherence and competency. The results suggest that therapists make a contribution to outcome in CBT for panic disorder, even when patients are relatively uniform, treatment is structured, and outcome is positive. Implications for future clinical outcome studies and for training clinicians are discussed. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2010 APA, all rights reserved)     

From in-session behaviors to drinking outcomes: A causal chain for motivational interviewing.

Client speech in favor of change within motivational interviewing sessions has been linked to treatment outcomes, but a causal chain has not yet been demonstrated. Using a sequential behavioral coding system for client speech, the authors found that, at both the session and utterance levels, specific therapist behaviors predict client change talk. Further, a direct link from change talk to drinking outcomes was observed, and support was found for a mediational role for change talk between therapist behavior and client drinking outcomes. These data provide preliminary support for the proposed causal chain indicating that client speech within treatment sessions can be influenced by therapists, who can employ this influence to improve outcomes. Selective eliciting and reinforcement of change talk is proposed as a specific active ingredient of motivational interviewing. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2010 APA, all rights reserved)     

Some gender effects in a brief psychotherapy.

Two studies investigated the influence of therapist gender as well as patient age and pretreatment distress level on process and outcome in a brief 12-session psychodynamic psychotherapy. Pre- and posttherapy assessments disclosed that patients treated by female therapists experienced more symptomatic improvement and reported more satisfaction with treatment than those treated by male therapists. However, patient age accounted for twice, and patient pretreatment level of disturbance more than three times, the outcome variance contributed by gender. In Study 2 female therapists were judged to arouse less negative affect in women patients and to arouse fewer interpersonal difficulties. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2010 APA, all rights reserved)     

Racial/ethnic matching of clients and therapists in mental health services: A meta-analytic review of preferences, perceptions, and outcomes.

Across several decades the effects of matching clients with therapists of the same race/ethnicity have been explored using a variety of approaches. We conducted a meta-analysis of 3 variables frequently used in research on racial/ethnic matching: individuals' preferences for a therapist of their own race/ethnicity, clients' perceptions of therapists across racial/ethnic match, and therapeutic outcomes across racial/ethnic match. Across 52 studies of preferences, the average effect size (Cohen's d) was 0.63, indicating a moderately strong preference for a therapist of one's own race/ethnicity. Across 81 studies of individuals' perceptions of therapists, the average effect size was 0.32, indicating a tendency to perceive therapists of one's own race/ethnicity somewhat more positively than other therapists. Across 53 studies of client outcomes in mental health treatment, the average effect size was 0.09, indicating almost no benefit to treatment outcomes from racial/ethnic matching of clients with therapists. These 3 averaged effect sizes were characterized by substantial heterogeneity: The effects of racial/ethnic matching are highly variable. Studies involving African American participants demonstrated the highest effect sizes across all 3 types of evaluations: preferences, perceptions, and outcomes. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2011 APA, all rights reserved)     

Termination, appointment use, and outcome patterns associated with intake therapist discontinuity.

Psychotherapy clients often experience intake therapist discontinuity: meeting first with an intake therapist, then entering therapy with a different treating therapist. The authors compared such discontinuity clients at a university’s counseling center (55.6% of 15,137 clients) with continuity clients, who continued therapy with their intake therapists. Discontinuity clients were twice as likely as continuity clients to terminate by missing the appointment after intake. Improvement among discontinuity clients lagged behind improvement among continuity clients at Sessions 2 and 3. Though more likely to terminate by missing Session 2, discontinuity clients attended 2 sessions more than continuity clients, on average, making treatment of discontinuity clients 19% more expensive than treatment of continuity clients in terms of sessions attended. The extra sessions attended by discontinuity clients did not yield overall better outcomes. Intake therapist discontinuity appeared to disrupt the beginning of psychotherapy, dissuading some clients from returning after intake, slowing early improvement among those who did return, and unproductively lengthening their treatment. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2010 APA, all rights reserved)     

Effects of therapist and patient mood on the therapeutic functioning of high- and low-facilitative therapists.

Determined the effects of presession moods of 12 therapists and their patients on level of therapist empathy, warmth, and genuineness. Results of an intensively designed study indicate that high- and low-facilitative therapists were differentially affected by therapist moods. High-facilitative therapists functioned more facilitatively under dysphoric moods than under positive, while the opposite was true of low-facilitative. There were no differences in tape-rated therapist facilitativeness under different patient moods for either group, yet patients of low-facilitative therapists did perceive such a difference. It is concluded that the therapist feelings preceding the facilitative therapy hour were not the same for high- and low-facilitative therapists. The use of the intensive design in psychotherapy process research is discussed. (44 ref.) (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2010 APA, all rights reserved)     

Attachment to the therapist.

This study examines the ways in which therapists function as attachment figures for patients. Patients in long-term psychoanalytic therapy answered questionnaires about their feelings about their therapists and their closest personal relationships. Components of attachment prominent in the therapeutic relationships were looking up to the therapist and feeling the therapist was responsive to emotional needs. Stronger attachment to therapists was associated with greater frequency and duration of therapy, a stronger working alliance, and greater security of the patients' attachment style, as well as with the gender of the patient and therapist. Using attachment theory to understand psychoanalytic relationships emphasizes the unique importance of a therapist to a patient and can offer new perspectives on both therapeutic and attachment processes. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2010 APA, all rights reserved)     

Graduate training in psychotherapy: Are therapy outcomes enhanced?

Several sources of indirect evidence supporting the value of graduate training in psychotherapy are reviewed here. Training protocols that are known to enhance trainees' skills are briefly discussed, as are conclusions of meta-analytic reviews examining relationships between therapist experience and training, and therapy outcome. An updated meta-analysis of therapy outcome studies involving within-study comparisons of psychotherapists of different levels of training and experience is summarized. It is concluded that a variety of outcome sources are associated with modest effect sizes favoring more trained therapists. In many outpatient settings, therapists with more training tend to suffer fewer therapy dropouts than less trained therapists. Shortcomings of available research and speculations about possible variables influencing outcomes are discussed. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2010 APA, all rights reserved)     

Do Psychotherapists Have Better Marriages Than Nonpsychotherapists? Do Therapeutic Skills and Experience Relate to Marriage Adjustment?

Couples in which 1 or both members were psychotherapists were compared with nontherapist couples for marriage adjustment (MA). The authors predicted higher MA scores for the therapists and a positive correlation between the MA of therapists and years of therapy training, years of practice, rating of therapeutic ability, length of marital therapy training, number of marital therapy clients, experience as a marital therapist, and self-rating as a marital therapist. Therapist and nontherapist couples did not differ on MA. Only self-rated ability as a marital therapist correlated positively with MA. For men, ability as a therapist, as a marital therapist, and marital therapist experience correlated significantly with MA. For female therapists only self-rated ability as a marital therapist correlated significantly with MA. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2010 APA, all rights reserved)     

Biased reporting of therapist–patient sexual intimacy.

To investigate bias in reports of therapist–patient sexual intimacy, information about 559 patients who were sexually intimate with their previous therapists was collected via questionnaire from 318 psychologists who subsequently saw these patients in therapy. Psychologists, the experimental Ss in the present study, were predominantly aged 40–49 yrs, and 64% were male. It was found that Ss who reported that no harm occurred to patients as a result of therapist–patient sexual intimacy (SI) admitted twice the prevalence of SI between patients and themselves than did Ss in general. Those Ss who had experienced SI with patients were less likely to report adverse effects of SI either for patients or for therapy. Fewer Ss with a history of SI than those without reported anger toward offending therapists, and fewer recommended punishment. A higher percentage of female than male Ss reported anger toward offenders and recommended punishment, yet women did not rate the effects of SI as more harmful than did men. In general, anger toward offending therapists and recommendations for punishment were associated with the degree to which patients were thought to have been harmed. Ss who had been consultants to a greater number of other therapists about sexual contact with patients reported relatively more cases in which therapy ended soon after SI began than did Ss who were consulted by fewer therapists. (18 ref) (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2010 APA, all rights reserved)     

Conditional loss-of-myosin-II-function mutants reveal a position in the tail that is critical for filament nucleation

AIMS: The current study was conducted to (a) replicate previous findings regarding the effect of patient/therapist race and sex-matching as this relates to the early dropout rate of substance abusers, and (b) to extend previous work by examining the impact of such matching on treatment retention and 9-month outcome. DESIGN: Patient and therapist characteristics were crossed in a 2 x 2 factorial design. Matching effects were then tested using retrospective data. PARTICIPANTS: Participants were 967 African-American cocaine-dependent people. SETTING: The study site was a university sponsored outpatient treatment facility located in an economically depressed section of a large Northeastern US city. MEASUREMENTS: Follow-up data were drawn from the Addiction Severity Index, the Risk for AIDS Behavior Inventory, and a questionnaire measuring post-discharge need for treatment, employment and education. Retention was defined as the number of days inclusive between the last date of service and the date of admission. FINDINGS: No significant differences in early dropout rates were found after initial contact with 10 different therapists. Matching therapist and patients with respect to gender and race did not decrease the premature dropout rate, but partial support for gender matching was noted. CONCLUSION: Matching therapist and substance abusing patients on gender and race may not be essential to improving retention and outcome.