Interrelations of cooling rate,microstructure, and mechanical properties in four HSLA steels

The present study was carried out on four steels containing 0.1 pct C-1.5 pct Mn-0.003 pct B* in common, with additions of 1 pct Cr, 0.5 pct Mo, 0.25 pct Mo + 1 pct Cr, 0.2 pct Ti + 1 pct Cr. They were designated, accordingly, as Cr, Mo, Mo-Cr, and Cr-Ti steels. All the steels exhibited a complete lath martensite microstructure with thin interlaths of retained austenite (≈0.05 pct) in the quenched condition. The normalized microstructures, granular bainite, contained massive areas of ferrite and granules of bainite laths. Both microconstituents contained a fine dispersion of cementite particles (size ≈50 Å) together with high dislocation densities. A mechanism explaining their for-mation has been given. The Cr steel, due to its low hardenability, showed in addition polygonal ferrite in the neighborhood of the so-called M-A constituent (twinned martensite and/or austenite). The annealed microstructure (using a cooling rate of 0.033 °C s^?1) of the Cr steel consisted of coarse ferrite-pearlite. Addition of 0.2 pct Ti to the Cr steel markedly refined the structure, whereas an addition of 0.25 pct Mo altered the microstructure to ferrite-lower bainite. In the 0.5 pct Mo steel, polygonal ferrite was found to be completely missing. The mechanical properties of the four steels after quenching, normalizing, and annealing were investigatedvia hardness and tensile test mea-surements. An empirical equation, relating the ultimate tensile strength to the steel composition, for steels that had granular bainite microstructures in the normalized condition, was proposed. The fracture surfaces exhibited cleavage and variable-size dimples depending on the microstructure and steel composition.     

Phase transformational kinetics and hardenability of low-carbon,boron-treated steels

The phase transformations and hardenability of 0.1 pct C boron-treated and boron-free steels containing Mn, Cr, Ni, or Cr plus Ni, and up to 1 pct Mo were studied. Continuous cooling transformation diagrams, hardenability characteristics, and diagrams of the ferrite start half-cooling time vs alloying were established. An unalloyed 0.1 pct C steel transforms diffusionally in the ferritic-pearlitic range when cooled from an austenitizing temperature, with a negligible contribution of the intermediate (bainitic) transformation occurring at very high rates of cooling. Molybdenum extends the range of the bainitic transformation and markedly delays the decomposition of austenite in the ferritic-pearlitic range. Boron treatment of the unalloyed (molybdenum-free) 0.1 pct C steel permits bainite formation over a wider range of fast cooling programs. At lower rates of cooling, the steel transforms diffusionally into ferrite and pearlite . Alloying additions of Mn, Cr, or Ni result in a slightly higher proportion of the bainitic transformation, which may occur over a wider range of cooling programs. When both nickel and chromium are present, a modest synergistic effect on the delay of the ferritic-pearlitic transformation may be noted. Introduction of molybdenum into all of the boron-treated 0.1 pct C steels strongly delays the decomposition of austenite into ferrite-pearlite structures and vastly expands the range of cooling programs that result in the formation of bainitic structures. In this important action, molybdenum is assisted to a smaller degree by alloying additions of manganese and chromium, and to a greater degree by nickel and chromium plus nickel. In all the steels studied, the alloying elements lower the temperatures of the bainitic transformation, thereby explaining, at least partly, the somewhat higher hardness for any specified cooling program. The observed beneficial effects of boron, molybdenum, and other alloying elements on the phase transformational behavior on continuous cooling are reflected in terms of higher hardenability.     

Microstructure-strength relations in a hardenable stainless steel with 16 pct Cr, 1.5 pct Mo,and 5 pct Ni

Metallographic studies have been conducted on a 0.024 pct C-16 pct Cr-1.5 pct Mo-5 pct Ni stainless steel to study the phase reactions associated with heat treatments and investigate the strengthening mechanisms of the steel. In the normalized condition, air cooled from 1010 °C, the microstructure consists of 20 pct ferrite and 80 pct martensite. Tempering in a temperature range between 500 and 600 °C results in a gradual transformation of martensite to a fine mixture of ferrite and austenite. At higher tempering temperatures, between 600 and 800 °C, progressively larger quantities of austenite form and are converted during cooling to proportionally increasing amounts of fresh martensite. The amount of retained austenite in the microstructure is reduced to zero at 800 °C, and the microstructure contains 65 pct re-formed martensite and 35 pct total ferrite. Chromium rich M₂₃C₆ carbides precipitate in the single tempered microstructures. The principal strengthening is produced by the presence of martensite in the microstructure. Additional strengthening is provided by a second tempering treatment at 400 °C due to the precipitation of ultrafine (Cr, Mo) (C,N) particles in the ferrite.     

Effect of phosphorus on the formation of retained austenite and mechanical properties in Si-containing low-carbon steel sheet

The effect of phosphorus and silicon on the formation of retained austenite has been investigated in a low-carbon steel cold rolled, intercritically annealed, and isothermally held in a temperature range of bainitic transformation followed by air cooling. The steel sheet containing phosphorus after final heat-treatment consisted of ferrite, retained austenite, and bainite or martensite. Phosphorus, especially in the presence of silicon, in steel was useful to assist the formation of retained austenite. Mechanical properties, such as tensile strength, uniform elongation, and the combination of tensile strength/ductility, were improved when phosphorus was increased up to 0.07 pct in 0.5 pct Si steel. This could be attributed to the strain-induced transformation of retained austenite during tensile deformation. Furthermore, two types of retained austenite were observed in P-containing steel. One is larger than about 1 μm in size and usually exists adjacent to bainite; the other one is of submicron size and usually exists in a ferrite matrix. High phosphorus content promotes the formation of stable (small size) austenites which are considered to be stabilized mainly by their small size effect and have a different formation mechanism from the coarser retained austenite in the lower P steels. The retained austenites of submicron size showed mechanical stability even after 10 pct deformation, suggesting that these small austenites have little effect on ductility. The 0.07 pct P-0.5 pct Si-1.5 pct Mn-0.12 pct C steel showed a high strength of 730 MPa and a total elongation of 36 pct.     

Effect of alloying elements on the microstructure‐property relationship in thermomechanically processed C‐Mn‐Si TRIP steels

The effect of additions of Nb, Al and Mo to Fe‐C‐Mn‐Si TRIP steel on the final microstructure and mechanical properties after simulated thermomechanical processing (TMP) has been studied. The laboratory simulations of discontinuous cooling during TMP were performed using a hot rolling mill. All samples were characterised using optical microscopy and image analysis. The volume fraction of retained austenite was ascertained using a heat tinting technique and X‐ray diffraction measurements. Room temperature mechanical properties were determined by a tensile test. From this a comprehensive understanding of the structural aspect of the bainite transformation in these types of TRIP steels has been developed. The results have shown that the final microstructures of thermomechanically processed TRIP steels comprise ~ 50 % of polygonal ferrite, 7 ‐12 % of retained austenite, non‐carbide bainitic structure and martensite. All steels exhibited a good combination of ultimate tensile strength and total elongation. The microstructure‐property examination revealed the relationship between the composition of TRIP steels and their mechanical properties. It has been shown that the addition of Mo to the C‐Si‐Mn‐Nb TRIP steel increases the ultimate tensile strength up to 1020 MPa. The stability of the retained austenite of the Nb‐Mo steel was degraded, which led to a decrease in the elongation (24 %). The results have demonstrated that the addition of Al to C‐Si‐Mn‐Nb steel leads to a good combination of strength (~ 940 MPa) and elongation (~ 30 %) due to the formation of refined acicular ferrite and granular bainite structure with ~7 ‐ 8 % of stable retained austenite. Furthermore, it has been found that the addition of Al increases the volume fraction of bainitic ferrite laths. The investigations have shown an interesting result that, in the Nb‐Mo‐Al steel, Al has a more pronounced effect on the microstructure in comparison with Mo. It has been found that the bainitic structure of the Nb‐Mo‐Al steel appears to be more granular than in the Nb‐Mo steel. Moreover, the volume fraction of the retained austenite increased (12 %) with decreasing bainitic ferrite content. The results have demonstrated that this steel has the best mechanical properties (1100 MPa and 28 % elongation). It has been concluded that the combined effect of Nb, Mo, and Al addition on the dispersion of the bainite, martensite and retained austenite in the ferrite matrix and the morphology of these phases is different than effect of Nb, Mo and Al, separately.     

Effect of Composition and Processing Parameters on the Formation of Nano-Bainite in Advanced High Strength Steels

The nano-bainitic microstructures were compared in a 0.79C-1.5Si-1.98Mn-0.24Mo-1.06Al (wt%) steel after isothermal heat-treatment and a Fe-0.2C-1.5Mn-1.2Si-0.3Mo-0.6Al-0.02Nb (wt%) steel after controlled thermomechanical processing.The microstructure for both steels consisted of bainite.The microstructural characteristics of bainite,such as the morphology of the nano-bainite and thicknesses of bainitic ferrite and retained austenite layers,as a function of steel composition and processing was studied using transmission electron microscopy (TEM).It was found that the nano-bainitic structure can be formed in the low alloy steel through thermomechanical processing.Atom probe tomography (APT) was employed as a powerful technique to determine local composition distributions in three dimensions with atomic resolution.The important conclusions from the APT research were that the carbon content of bainitic ferrite is higher than expected from paraequilibrium level of carbon in ferrite for both steels and that Fe-C clusters and fine particles are formed in the bainitic ferrite in both steels despite the high level of Si.     

Effects of Microalloying on the Impact Toughness of Ultrahigh-Strength TRIP-Aided Martensitic Steels

The effects of the addition of Cr, Mo, and/or Ni on the Charpy impact toughness of a 0.2 pct C-1.5 pct Si-1.5 pct Mn-0.05 pct Nb transformation-induced plasticity (TRIP)-aided steel with a lath-martensite structure matrix (i.e., a TRIP-aided martensitic steel or TM steel) were investigated with the aim of using the steel in automotive applications. In addition, the relationship between the toughness of the various alloyed steels and their metallurgical characteristics was determined. When Cr, Cr-Mo, or Cr-Mo-Ni was added to the base steel, the TM steel exhibited a high upper-shelf Charpy impact absorbed value that ranged from 100 to 120 J/cm² and a low ductile–brittle fracture appearance transition temperature that ranged from 123 K to 143 K (?150 °C to ?130 °C), while also exhibiting a tensile strength of about 1.5 GPa. This impact toughness of the alloyed steels was far superior to that of conventional martensitic steel and was caused by the presence of (i) a softened wide lath-martensite matrix, which contained only a small amount of carbide and hence had a lower carbon concentration, (ii) a large amount of finely dispersed martensite-retained austenite complex phase, and (iii) a metastable retained austenite phase of 2 to 4 vol pct in the complex phase, which led to plastic relaxation via strain-induced transformation and played an important role in the suppression of the initiation and propagation of voids and/or cleavage cracks.     

On the Low Temperature Strain Aging of Bainite in the TRIP Steel

The aging behavior of a thermomechanically processed Mo-Al-Nb transformation-induced plasticity steel with ultrafine microstructure was investigated using transmission electron microscopy and atom probe tomography (APT). Strain aging at 73 K (200 °C) for 1800 seconds led to a significant bake-hardening response (up to 222 MPa). Moreover, aging for 1800 seconds at room temperature after 4 pct pre-strain also revealed a bake-hardening response (~60 MPa). The experimental results showed the formation of carbon Cottrell atmospheres around dislocations and the formation of carbon clusters/fine carbides in the bainitic ferrite during aging. It is proposed that this is associated with the high dislocation density of bainitic ferrite with formation of a complex dislocation substructure after pre-straining and its high average carbon content (~0.35 at. pct). The segregation of carbon and substitutional elements such as Mn and Mo to the retained austenite/bainitic ferrite interface during aging was observed by APT. This segregation is likely to be the preliminary stage for Mo-C particles’ formation. The aging after pre-straining also induced the decomposition of retained austenite with formation of ferrite and carbides.     

The effect of an intercritical heat treatment on temper embrittlement of a Ni-Cr-Mo-V rotor steel

The effect of an intercritical heat treatment on tempor embrittlement has been investigated for a rotor steel containing 0.25 pct C, 3.5 pct Ni, 1.7 pct Cr, 0.5 pct Mo, 0.1 pct V, and deliberate additions of phosphorus, tin, or antimony. Both martensitic and bainitic steels were held at the intercritical temperature of 1380°F (750°C) for times up to 40 h and were then quenched or cooled to obtain martensitic or bainitic transformation. The steels were then tempered, followed by water quenching or step cooling from the tempering temperature. The residual ferrite maintained a fine plate-like shape even after 40 h at the intercritical temperature. Embrittlement induced by step cooling from the final tempering was mark edly reduced by the intercritical treatment as compared to the embrittlement observed after conventional heat treatment; for example, AFATT, the increase in the Charpy V-notch 50 pct shear fracture transition temperature caused by step cooling, was reduced by at least 80°F (45°C) as a result of the intercritical treatment of steels containing 0.02 pct P. Molybdenum effectively reduced AFATT in intercritlcally heat-treated steels as well as in conventionally treated steels. Possible mechanisms for reducing temper embrittlement with the intercritical treatment are discussed.     

Reversible temper embrittlement of rotor steels

The susceptibility to temper embrittlement of eight different rotor steels has been studied in terms of the effects of composition, of cooling rate from tempering temperature, of isothermal aging, of steel-making practice and of strength level and tempering temperature. The Ni Cr Mo V steels tested showed increasing susceptibility to temper embrittlement with increasing nickel content. The normally marked susceptibility of a high phosphorus 3 pct Cr Mo steel was eliminated by the removal of manganese. Embrittlement in a 3 pct Ni Cr Mo V steel was caused by the equilibrium segregation of solute atoms to the prior austenite grain boundaries. Two Cr Mo V steels tested were not susceptible to temper embrittlement. Electroslag remelting and refining had very little effect on the susceptibility of the steels tested. Strength level and tempering temperature had no effect on the degree of embrittlement of the 3 pct Ni Cr Mo V disc steel. The possibilities of remedial action include an adjustment of the post tempering cooling rate, to optimize the conflicting interests of minimum temper embrittlement and adequate stress relief, and the production of very low manganese rotor steels.     

Effect of alloying elements on the microstructure and properties of a hot-rolled low-carbon low-alloy bainitic steel

A two-level full factorial statistical experiment consisting of eight alloys was conducted to determine the effect of 2 pct cobalt, 1 pct nickel and 1 pct chromium on the hot-rolled microstructure and properties of a bainitic steel containing 0.2 pct C, 2 pct Mn, 1 pct Si, 0.75 pct Mo and 0.003 pct B. The results indicate that chromium induced the formation of the acicular bainitic structure while cobalt favored massive ferrite formation and resulted in islands of martensite and/or austenite. Nickel, when added singly, did not appear to influence the microstructure but in combination with chromium, enhanced the formation of the lower bainitic structure. The mechanical properties were statistically analyzed and statistical equations were obtained to predict optimized compositions. These equations indicate that chromium increased the toughness of these steels more than nickel. However, it was shown that with similar bainitic structures, nickel enhanced the toughness more than chromium. The results illustrate the short-coming of a pure statistical approach to the design of alloys.     

Effect of alloying elements on the microstructure and properties of a hot-rolled low-carbon low-alloy bainitic steel

A two-level full factorial statistical experiment consisting of eight alloys was conducted to determine the effect of 2 pct cobalt, 1 pct nickel and 1 pct chromium on the hot-rolled microstructure and properties of a bainitic steel containing 0.2 pct C, 2 pct Mn, 1 pct Si, 0.75 pct Mo and 0.003 pct B. The results indicate that chromium induced the formation of the acicular bainitic structure while cobalt favored massive ferrite formation and resulted in islands of martensite and/or austenite. Nickel, when added singly, did not appear to influence the microstructure but in combination with chromium, enhanced the formation of the lower bainitic structure. The mechanical properties were statistically analyzed and statistical equations were obtained to predict optimized compositions. These equations indicate that chromium increased the toughness of these steels more than nickel. However, it was shown that with similar bainitic structures, nickel enhanced the toughness more than chromium. The results illustrate the short-coming of a pure statistical approach to the design of alloys.     

Optimization of Fe/Cr/C base structural Steels for improved strength and toughness

Optimization of the composition and the heat treatments to provide a microduplex structure of dislocated-autotempered lath martensite and thin film retained austenite for good combinations of mechanical properties has been attained for Fe/Cr/C base steels. Substituting 0.5 wt pct Mo to reduce Cr from 4 pct to 3 pct did not affect the microstructures nor the properties. It was found that air melting as compared to vacuum melting does not cause deterioration of toughness in Mn containing alloys but does so in Ni containing alloys. Tempered martensite embrittlement was confirmed as being due to the decomposition of retained austenite. Further improvements in the fracture toughness are achieved by double heat treatments which provide grain refinement. These alloys are considered to be very promising for structural applications.     

Constitutive Modeling of the Mechanical Properties of V-added Medium Manganese TRIP Steel

In this study, medium Mn transformation-induced plasticity steel with the composition Fe-0.08 pct C-6.15 pct Mn-1.5 pct Si-2.0 pct Al-0.08 pct V was investigated. After intercritical annealing at 1013 K (740 °C), the steel contained coarse-grained ferrite and two ultrafine-grained (UFG) phases: ferrite and retained austenite. The material did not deform by localized Lüders band propagation: it did not suffer from this major problem as most UFG steels do. Localization of plastic flow was shown to be suppressed because of a combination of factors, including a bimodal grain size distribution, a multiphase microstructure, the presence of nanosized vanadium carbide precipitates, and the occurrence of the deformation-induced martensitic transformation of retained austenite. A constitutive model incorporating these effects was developed. The model was used to identify the factors which can lead to a further improvement of the mechanical properties of the UFG medium Mn TRIP steels.     

Effects of austenite grain size and cooling rate on Widmanstätten ferrite formation in low-alloy steels

Deformation dilatometry is used to simulate the hot rolling of 0.20 pct C-1.10 pct Mn steels over a product thickness range of 6 to 170 mm. In addition to a base steel, steels with additions of 0.02 pct Ti, 0.06 pct V, or 0.02 pct Nb are included in the study. The transformation behavior of each steel is explored for three different austenite grain sizes, nominally 30, 55, and 100 μm. In general, the volume fraction of Widmanst?tten ferrite increases in all four steels with increasing austenite grain size and cooling rate, with austenite grain size having the more significant effect. The Nb steel has the lowest transformation temperature range and the greatest propensity for Widmanst?tten ferrite formation, while the amount of Widmanst?tten ferrite is minimized in the Ti steel (as a result of intragranular nucleation of polygonal ferrite on coarse TiN particles). The data emphasize the importance of a refined austenite grain size in minimizing the formation of a coarse Widmanst?tten structure. With a sufficiently fine prior austenite grain size (e.g., ≤30 μm), significant amounts of Widmanst?tten structure can be avoided, even in a Nb-alloyed steel.     

The partitioning of alloying elements in vacuum arc remelted,Pd-modified PH 13-8 Mo alloys

The partitioning of alloying elements in as-solidified PH 13-8 Mo stainless steel containing up to 1.02 wt pct Pd has been investigated. The as-solidified structure is composed of two major phases, martensite and ferrite. Electron probe microanalysis reveals that Mo, Cr, and Al partition to the ferrite phase while Fe, Ni, Mn, and Pd partition to the martensite (prior austenite) during solidification and cooling from the solidus. In addition to bulk segregation between phases, precipitation of the intermetallic, PdAI, in the retained ferrite is observed. Precipitation of the normal hardening phase, β-NiAl, is also observed in the retained ferrite. Partition ratios of the various alloying elements are determined and are compared with those observed previously in duplex Fe-Cr-Ni stainless steel solidification structures. The martensite start temperature (M_s) was observed to decrease with increasing Pd concentration.     

Development of high strength low alloy TRIP‐aided steels with annealed martensite matrix

Formable high‐strength low‐alloy TRIP‐aided sheet steels with annealed martensite matrix or TRIP‐aided annealed martensitic steel were developed for automotive applications. The steels possessed a large amount of plate‐like retained austenite along annealed martensite lath boundary, the stability of which against the strain‐induced transformation was higher than that of the conventional TRIP‐aided dual‐phase steel with polygonal ferrite matrix. In a tensile strength range between 600 and 1000 MPa, the TRIP‐aided annealed martensitic steels exhibited superior large elongation and reduction of area. In addition, the steels possessed the same excellent stretch‐flangeability and bendability as TRIP‐aided bainitic steel with bainitic ferrite matrix. These properties were discussed by matrix structure, a strength ratio of second phase to matrix, retained austenite stability, internal stress in matrix and so on.     

Reciprocating Sliding Wear Behavior of Newly Developed Bainitic Steels

The present work discusses the mechanical properties and wear behavior of newly developed bainitic rail steels with nominal composition of 0.71 pct C, 0.35 pct Si, 1.15 pct Mn, 0.59 pct Cr, 0.40 pct Cu, and 0.20 pct Ni (all in wt pct)). Isothermal transformation has been carried out at different time and temperatures for obtaining different bainitic morphologies. Linearly reciprocating sliding wear behavior of the steels has been studied and compared with that of the conventional pearlitic rail steel. Considerable improvement in mechanical properties of the bainitic steels has been noticed. The hardness of the bainitic steels increases with decrease in isothermal transformation temperature. It leads to enhancement of wear resistance of the bainitic steels compared to the conventional rail steel. Finally, it clearly draws correlation between mechanical properties, wear resistance, and microstructural variation of a series of bainitic rail steels.     

Recrystallization kinetics of microalloyed steels deformed in the intercritical region

A plain carbon and two microalloyed steels were tested under interrupted loading conditions. The base steel contained 0.06 pct C and 1.31 pct Mn, and the other alloys contained single additions of 0.29 pct Mo and 0.04 pct Nb. Double-hit compression tests were performed on cylindrical specimens of the three steels at 820 °C, 780 °C, and 740 °C within the α + γ field. A’softening curve was determined at each temperature by the offset method. In parallel, the progress of ferrite recrystallization was followed on quenched specimens of the three steels by means of quantitative metallography. It was observed that, in the base steel, a recrystallizes more slowly thany. The addition of Mo retards recrystallization and has a greater influence on γ than on α recrystallization. This effect is in agreement with calculations based on the Cahn theory of solute drag. Niobium addition has an even greater effect on the recrystallization of the two phases. In this steel, the recrystallization of ferrite was incomplete at the three intercritical temperatures. Furthermore, the austenite remained completely unrecrystallized up to the maximum time involved in the experiments (1 hour). The metallographic results indicate that the nucleation of recrystallization occurs heterogeneously in the microstructure, the interface between ferrite and austenite being the preferred site for nucleation.     

In-Situ High-Energy X-ray Diffraction Study of Austenite Decomposition During Rapid Cooling and Isothermal Holding in Two HSLA Steels

In-situ high-energy X-ray diffraction experiments with high temporal resolution during rapid cooling (280 °C s⁻¹) and isothermal heat treatments (at 450 °C, 500 °C, and 550 °C for 30 minutes) were performed to study austenite decomposition in two commercial high-strength low-alloy steels. The rapid phase transformations occurring in these types of steels are investigated for the first time in-situ, aiding a detailed analysis of the austenite decomposition kinetics. For the low hardenability steel with main composition Fe-0.08C-1.7Mn-0.403Si-0.303Cr in weight percent, austenite decomposition to polygonal ferrite and bainite occurs already during the initial cooling. However, for the high hardenability steel with main composition Fe-0.08C-1.79Mn-0.182Si-0.757Cr-0.094Mo in weight percent, the austenite decomposition kinetics is retarded, chiefly by the Mo addition, and therefore mainly bainitic transformation occurs during isothermal holding; the bainitic transformation rate at the isothermal holding is clearly enhanced by lowered temperature from 550 °C to 500 °C and 450 °C. During prolonged isothermal holding, carbide formation leads to decreased austenite carbon content and promotes continued bainitic ferrite formation. Moreover, at prolonged isothermal holding at higher temperatures some degenerate pearlite form.