Increased spontaneous recovery with increases in conditioned stimulus alone exposures.

A series of experiments used the compound test procedure (Rescorla, 2002) to measure the size of spontaneous recovery of freezing responses by rats to a latently inhibited and/or extinguished conditioned stimulus (CS). The size of recovery was greater: to a pre-exposed and conditioned CS than to a CS just conditioned or just pre-exposed; to an extensively pre-exposed or extinguished CS than to a moderately pre-exposed or extinguished CS; and to a pre-exposed and extinguished CS than to a CS just pre-exposed or just extinguished. These results show that the size of recovery is proportional to the size of the depression produced by CS-alone exposures regardless of whether they occurred before, after, or both before and after conditioning. The results are discussed in terms of some contemporary models of recovery and of the inferences permitted by the use of the compound assessment technique. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2010 APA, all rights reserved)     

Spontaneous recovery but not reinstatement of the extinguished conditioned eyeblink response in the rat.

Reinstatement—the return of an extinguished conditioned response (CR) after reexposure to the unconditioned stimulus (US)—and spontaneous recovery—the return of an extinguished CR with the passage of time—are 2 of 4 well-established phenomena that demonstrate that extinction does not erase the conditioned stimulus (CS)–US association. However, reinstatement of extinguished eyeblink CRs has never been demonstrated, and spontaneous recovery of extinguished eyeblink CRs has not been systematically demonstrated in rodent eyeblink conditioning. In Experiment 1, US reexposure was administered 24 hr prior to a reinstatement test. In Experiment 2, US reexposure was administered 5 min prior to a reinstatement test. In Experiment 3, a long, discrete cue (a houselight), present in all phases of training and testing, served as a context within which each trial occurred to maximize context processing, which in other preparations has been shown to be required for reinstatement. In Experiment 4, an additional group was included that received footshock exposure, rather than US reexposure, between extinction and test, and contextual freezing was measured prior to test. Spontaneous recovery was robust in Experiments 3 and 4. In Experiment 4, context freezing was strong in a group given footshock exposure but not in a group given eye shock US reexposure. There was no reinstatement observed in any experiment. With stimulus conditions that produce eyeblink conditioning and research designs that produce reinstatement in other forms of classical conditioning, we observed spontaneous recovery but not reinstatement of extinguished eyeblink CRs. This suggests that reinstatement, but not spontaneous recovery, is a preparation- or substrate-dependent phenomenon. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2011 APA, all rights reserved)     

The effect of yohimbine on the extinction of conditioned fear: A role for context.

Six experiments with rat subjects examined the effect of yohimbine, an alpha-2 adrenergic autoreceptor antagonist, on the extinction of conditioned fear to a tone. Experiments 1 and 2 demonstrated that systemic administration of yohimbine (1.0 mg/kg) facilitated a long-term decrease in freezing after extinction, and this depended on pairing drug administration with extinction training. However, Experiments 3 and 4 demonstrated that yohimbine did not eradicate the original fear learning: Freezing was renewed when the tone was tested outside of the extinction context. Experiments 5 and 6 found that the contextually specific attenuation of fear produced by yohimbine transferred to another extinguished conditional stimulus (CS) and not to a nonextinguished CS. The results suggest that yohimbine, when administered in the presence of a neutral context, creates a form of inhibition in that context that allows that specific context to reduce fear of an extinguished CS. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2010 APA, all rights reserved)     

Contextual control over conditioned responding in an extinction paradigm.

Four experiments studied contextual control over rats' freezing to conditioned stimuli (CSs) that had been paired with shock and were then extinguished. In Experiment 1, rats were exposed to a CS A–shock and a CS B–shock pairing in Context C. CS A was then extinguished in Context A, and CS B in Context B. Freezing was renewed when each CS was presented in the context where the other CS had been extinguished. In Experiments 2–4, rats were exposed to a CS A–shock pairing in A and a CS B–shock pairing in B. They were then exposed to Context C where one, both, or neither of the CSs were extinguished, or where both CSs continued to be reinforced. On test, the rats froze more to CS A than to CS B in Context A, and more to CS B than to CS A in Context B, but only if the CSs had been extinguished. Thus, after extinction, rats use contexts to regulate retrieval not only of their memory for extinction, but also of their memory for the original conditioning episode. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2010 APA, all rights reserved)     

Recent Exposure to a Dangerous Context Impairs Extinction and Reinstates Lost Fear Reactions.

Rats were shocked in a context and then exposed to that context in the absence of shock. Shorter intervals between these extinction trials produced more long-term freezing than did longer ones, and shorter intervals between the final extinction trial and test produced more freezing than did longer ones. A short interval between a context extinction trial and test with an extinguished conditioned stimulus (CS) produced more freezing than did a longer one, and a short interval between a nonreinforced context exposure and an extinguished CS reinstated freezing when the CS was tested 24 hr later. The results suggest that recent fear acts to favor subsequent retrieval of the memory formed at conditioning rather than extinction and to render the retrieved memory more salient. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2010 APA, all rights reserved)     

Additional exposures reverse the latent inhibitory effects of recent and remote exposures.

We studied the learning produced by simple exposures to a stimulus. Exposures depressed orienting and subsequent conditioned freezing in rats. A remotely preexposed conditioned stimulus (CS) conditioned better and overshadowed a novel CS more than a recently preexposed CS. Additional preexposures reversed these effects: a remotely preexposed CS elicited more orienting, conditioned worse and overshadowed less than a recently preexposed CS. Exposure to a compound composed of a novel CS and a remotely preexposed CS resulted in the novel CS subsequently conditioning better than a novel CS exposed in compound with a recently preexposed CS. The results were interpreted to mean that stimulus-alone exposures produce a loss in associability which recovers across time, that this restoration deepens the loss in associability, and that this deepening is regulated by a common error term. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2010 APA, all rights reserved)     

Inhibition as a "slave" process: Deactivation of conditioned inhibition through extinction of conditioned excitation.

In 4 experiments with 176 male albino Sprague-Dawley rats, a conditioned-suppression paradigm was used to investigate why a conditioned inhibition (CS–) does not extinguish when presented alone. Exp I assessed the role of blocking by excitatory contextual cues and/or an evoked representation of the conditioned excitor (CS+), which had been nonreinforced in conjunction with the CS–. When the CS+ and context were extinguished prior to presentations of the CS– alone, the CS– showed a retardation effect, reflecting latent inhibition, because no inhibition was detected in controls for which presentation of the CS– alone had been omitted. Exp II showed that the loss of conditioned inhibition (CI) was due to excitatory extinction and not to time since conditioning. When excitation was reconditioned to the extinguished CS+ (Exp I) or to a novel CS in the same context (Exp II), CI was restored. Exps III and IV evaluated whether the maintenance of CI depended on excitation that was generic in form or associatively tied to the training context. Results indicate no loss of CI when groups received CS+ extinction in that context, with concomitant presentations in a different context of the UCS by itself, for a novel CS, or correlated either positively or negatively with the original CS+. Overall findings suggest that CI is dependent on excitation: When excitation is extinguished, CI is deactivated; when excitation is reconditioned to the original or a new CS+ in the same or a different context, CI is restored. (41 ref) (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2011 APA, all rights reserved)     

Expression of renewal is dependent on the extinction-test interval rather than the acquisition-extinction interval.

A recent finding suggested that when extinction occurs shortly after acquisition, renewal of an extinguished fear response (fear-potentiated startle) to a light conditioned stimulus (CS) is diminished (Myers, Ressler, & Davis, 2006). The present study attempted to extend this finding using a white-noise CS and freezing as the behavioral measure of fear. In Experiments 1A and 1B, we observed renewal whether extinction occurred 10 min or 24 hr after acquisition. In contrast, renewal was not observed if test occurred 10 min after extinction (Experiment 2). Experiment 3 demonstrated that expression of extinction at the 10-min extinction-test interval was attenuated by a pretest subcutaneous injection of the γ-aminobutyric acid (GABA) inverse agonist FG7142. These findings suggest that renewal is influenced more by the extinction-test interval than the acquisition-extinction interval. Further, the failure to see renewal 10 min after extinction suggests that there is a separate context memory that undergoes a different consolidation function than the CS-no US memory formed during extinction. Finally, the expression of extinction appears to be GABA dependent regardless of the extinction-test interval or the test context. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2010 APA, all rights reserved)     

Time-specific extinction and recovery of the rabbit's (Oryctolagus cuniculus) conditioned nictitating membrane response using mixed interstimulus intervals.

Extinguishing a conditioned response (CR) has entailed separating the conditioned stimulus (CS) from the unconditioned stimulus (US). This research reveals that elimination of the rabbit nictitating membrane response occurred during continuous CS-US pairings. Initial training contained a mixture of 2 CS-US interstimulus intervals (ISIs), 150 ms and 500 ms. The CRs showed double peaks, one for each ISI. When the 150-ms ISI was removed, its CR peak showed 2 hallmarks of extinction: a decline across sessions and spontaneous recovery between sessions. When a further stage of training was introduced with a distinctive CS using the 150-ms ISI, occasional tests of the original, extinguished CS revealed another hallmark of extinction, specifically, strong recovery of the 150-ms peak. These results support both abstract and cerebellar models of conditioning that encode the CS into a cascade of microstimuli, while challenging theories of extinction that rely on changes in CS processing, US representations, and contextual control. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2010 APA, all rights reserved)     

The role of the rat hippocampal system in several effects of context in extinction.

The effect of fornix lesions on some effects of manipulating the context on performance in extinction were studied. In renewal, subjects' responding to an extinguished CS recovered when the CS was presented in the context in which it had been conditioned after extinction in a different context. In reinstatement, it recovered when the CS was tested after independent presentation of the unconditioned stimulus (UCS; an effect mediated by contextual conditioning.) In spontaneous recovery, it recovered after the passage of time, that is, when the CS was tested in a new temporal context. In the conditioned suppression method, fornix lesions had no effect on conditioning, extinction, renewal, or spontaneous recovery; however, they abolished the reinstatement effect. The results suggest that the hippocampal system may be important in the formation of context–UCS associations, but not in other types of learning about the context. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2010 APA, all rights reserved)     

Responses eliminated by noncontingent or negatively contingent reinforcement recover in extinction

Autoshaped key pecking in pigeons was eliminated by presenting reinforcers only during non-CS periods (negatively contingent reinforcement) or in both non-CS and CS periods (noncontingent reinforcement). In either case, when all reinforcers were subsequently removed (simple extinction), responding recovered strongly (Experiment 1). Recovery in extinction occurred only if the CS was in a conditioned state when non-CS reinforcers were introduced (Experiment 2). Recovery from noncontingent reinforcement was virtually complete, since total responding in extinction after response elimination was not less than in control groups extinguished without an intervening response-elimination phase (Experiment 3). Recovery also occurred for nonautoshapable, instrumentally reinforced key pecking (Experiment 4). The hypothesis that recovery is due to reinstatement of the non-CS stimulus conditions of acquisition (absence of food) was not supported (Experiments 5 and 6). Other accounts of recovery are considered.     

Retraining of extinguished Pavlovian stimuli.

Five Pavlovian magazine approach experiments with rat subjects examined the mechanism by which reconditioning restores extinguished responding. Experiments 1, 2, and 3 found that retraining did not destroy the spontaneous recovery with the passage of time that is characteristic of extinguished stimuli. Experiments 4 and 5 found evidence that retraining after extinction enhanced the strength of the originally trained associations. Together these results suggest that, just as extinction does not destroy original acquisition but superimposes some decremental process, so retraining does not destroy that decremental process but instead superimposes further associative learning. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2010 APA, all rights reserved)     

Opioid Receptors Regulate the Extinction of Pavlovian Fear Conditioning.

Rats received a single pairing of an auditory conditioned stimulus (CS) with a footshock unconditioned stimulus (US). The fear (freezing) that had accrued to the CS was then extinguished. Injection of naloxone prior to this extinction significantly impaired the development of extinction. This impairment was mediated by opioid receptors in the brain and was not observed when naloxone was injected after extinction training. Finally, an injection of naloxone on test failed to reinstate extinguished responding that had already accrued to the CS. These experiments show that opioid receptors regulate the development, but not the expression, of fear extinction and are discussed with reference to the roles of opioid receptors in US processing, memory, and appetitive motivation. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2010 APA, all rights reserved)     

Invasiveness of 2 selected strains of Toxoplasma gondii with respect to mice, rats and rabbits

In Experiment I, groups of 22-and 140+-day rats were trained in acquisition and extinction of 1-way avoidance with a CS that consisted of the opening of a guilotine door 5 sec before US onset or a combination of door-opening plus a tonal signal that remained on until the occurrence of the motor response. Under both CS conditions, avoidance acquistion was similar at each age level. The extinction date indicated comparable performance for the young subjects but differential performance and greater resistance to extinction for the adult subjects. Adults trained with the door-opening CS persisted in responding for an entire series of 100 extinction trials, whereas the adults trained with the compound CS extinguished well within the 100-trial, whereas the adults trained with the compound CS extinguished well within the 100-trial limit. A 2nd experiment included 10 pre-exposures of the simple or compound CS's prior to avoidance training. Although the pups were insensitive to pre-exposure effects, the adults that were pre-exposed and trained with identical CS's showed evidence of pre-exposure effects. Results of both experiments were interpreted as indicative of differential cue saliency between ages.     

Backward conditioning: Mediation by the context.

The information acquired in backward conditioning (i.e., outcome→cue) was assessed in 3 Pavlovian lick-suppression experiments with water-deprived rats as subjects. Experiment 1 confirmed previous research that few outcome→cue pairings made the cue into a conditioned excitor and additionally showed that massive posttraining extinction of the training context attenuated a backward-trained cue's excitatory value. Experiment 2 found that many outcome→cue pairings made the cue into a conditioned inhibitor and that the same context manipulation attenuated this inhibitory value. Experiment 3 confirmed the observations of Experiments 1 and 2 and demonstrated that these effects of context extinction were specific to backward-trained cues conditioned in the extinguished context. These results are interpreted in terms of cue→context and context→outcome associations. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2010 APA, all rights reserved)     

A developmental dissociation of context and GABA effects on extinguished fear in rats.

Although extinction has attracted considerable attention in recent years, there has been very little empirical work on extinction during development. Using Pavlovian fear conditioning, the authors provide evidence for developmental differences in extinction. Specifically, Postnatal Day (PND) 23 rats exhibited recovery of an extinguished freezing response to an auditory conditioned stimulus when tested in a context different from that in which extinction occurred (i.e., renewal) or when injected with the gamma-amino butyric acid (GABA) inverse agonist FG7142 prior to test. In contrast, PND 16 rats failed to exhibit either of these effects, although a subsequent experiment demonstrated that FG7142 alleviated spontaneous forgetting in PND 16 rats. Taken together, it appears that there are fundamental differences in the processes involved in extinction across development. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2010 APA, all rights reserved)     

A retrieval cue for extinction attenuates spontaneous recovery.

Four experiments with rats in an appetitive conditioned magazine entry preparation examined spontaneous recovery after extinction. Spontaneous recovery was obtained 6 days but not 5 hrs following extinction; recovery depended on the passage of time but not on the removal of a cue that was featured in extinction or on the reintroduction of early-session cues. A cue featured in extinction attenuated recovery when presented on the test. The attenuation effect depended on the cue's correlation with extinction; a cue featured in conditioning did not attenuate recovery. The extinction cue did not evoke responding on its own, suggesting that it was not a conditioned excitor. Retardation tests and a summation test did not reveal that it was a conditioned inhibitor. The cue might work by retrieving a memory of extinction. Spontaneous recovery thus occurs because the S fails to retrieve an extinction memory. Other accounts of spontaneous recovery are discussed. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2010 APA, all rights reserved)     

Potentiation of conditioned freezing following dorsomedial prefrontal cortex lesions does not interfere with fear reduction in mice.

In Experiment 1, an auditory conditioned stimulus (CS) was paired with footshock, except when it was preceded by another stimulus (a visual conditioned inhibitor [CI]). After conditioning, all mice displayed less CS-evoked freezing when the CI-CS compound was presented than when the CS was presented alone. However, lesions of the dorsomedial prefrontal cortex (dmPFC) potentiated CS-evoked freezing on each of the 2 sessions (i.e., CI-CS and CS alone). In Experiment 2, mice were submitted to fear extinction (CS-alone presentation for 3 days). Lesioned mice exhibited a higher level of freezing behavior than controls on each of the 3 sessions. However, lesioned mice and controls displayed the same rate of reduction of freezing over the 3 days of extinction. These data in mice support previous studies in rats, which suggests that the dmPFC is not critical for either conditioned inhibition or extinction of acquired freezing behavior. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2010 APA, all rights reserved)     

Deepened extinction from compound stimulus presentation.

Three experiments with rats and 2 with pigeons explored the effect of presenting 2 extinguished excitatory stimuli in compound. Four learning situations were used: Pavlovian magazine approach, Pavlovian fear conditioning, and instrumental discriminative instrumental learning in rats, as well as Pavlovian sign tracking in pigeons. All 5 experiments confirmed D. Reberg's (1972) observation that even after extinction of the individual stimuli, presenting them in compound evoked substantial responding. Moreover, nonreinforcement of that compound deepened extinction of an element more substantially than did additional presentation of that element alone. Such compound exposure reduced spontaneous recovery, reduced reinstatement, and slowed subsequent reconditioning. The primary determinant seemed to be the enhanced associative strength rather than the enhanced conditioned responding that occurred during the nonreinforced compound. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2010 APA, all rights reserved)     

A retrieval cue for extinction attenuates response recovery (renewal) caused by a return to the conditioning context.

When conditioning and extinction are conducted in different contexts, a return to the conditioning context causes a renewal of conditioned responding. The results of 4 experiments with rats in an appetitive conditioning preparation suggest that renewal results from a failure to retrieve extinction outside the extinction context. Presentation of a cue from extinction during renewal testing attenuated the renewal effect; attenuation depended on the cue's correlation with extinction. On its own, the cue did not elicit responding, suggesting it was not a conditioned excitor; it also failed tests for conditioned inhibition. The authors propose that it worked by retrieving a memory of extinction. The findings parallel previous results with spontaneous recovery and are thus consistent with the view that renewal and spontaneous recovery result from a common mechanism. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2010 APA, all rights reserved)