Synergy between Readthrough and Nonsense Mediated Decay Inhibition in a Murine Model of Cystic Fibrosis Nonsense Mutations

Many heritable genetic disorders arise from nonsense mutations, which generate premature termination codons (PTCs) in transcribed mRNA. PTCs ablate protein synthesis by prematurely terminating the translation of mutant mRNA, as well as reducing mutant mRNA quantity through targeted degradation by nonsense-mediated decay (NMD) mechanisms. Therapeutic strategies for nonsense mutations include facilitating ribosomal readthrough of the PTC and/or inhibiting NMD to restore protein function. However, the efficacy of combining readthrough agents and NMD inhibitors has not been thoroughly explored. In this study, we examined combinations of known NMD inhibitors and readthrough agents using functional analysis of the CFTR protein in primary cells from a mouse model carrying a G542X nonsense mutation in Cftr. We observed synergy between an inhibitor of the NMD component SMG-1 (SMG1i) and the readthrough agents G418, gentamicin, and paromomycin, but did not observe synergy with readthrough caused by amikacin, tobramycin, PTC124, escin, or amlexanox. These results indicate that treatment with NMD inhibitors can increase the quantity of functional protein following readthrough, and that combining NMD inhibitors and readthrough agents represents a potential therapeutic option for treating nonsense mutations.     

Partial Rescue of F508del-CFTR Stability and Trafficking Defects by Double Corrector Treatment

Deletion of phenylalanine at position 508 (F508del) in the CFTR chloride channel is the most frequent mutation in cystic fibrosis (CF) patients. F508del impairs the stability and folding of the CFTR protein, thus resulting in mistrafficking and premature degradation. F508del-CFTR defects can be overcome with small molecules termed correctors. We investigated the efficacy and properties of VX-445, a newly developed corrector, which is one of the three active principles present in a drug (Trikafta^®/Kaftrio^®) recently approved for the treatment of CF patients with F508del mutation. We found that VX-445, particularly in combination with type I (VX-809, VX-661) and type II (corr-4a) correctors, elicits a large rescue of F508del-CFTR function. In particular, in primary bronchial epithelial cells of CF patients, the maximal rescue obtained with corrector combinations including VX-445 was close to 60–70% of CFTR function in non-CF cells. Despite this high efficacy, analysis of ubiquitylation, resistance to thermoaggregation, protein half-life, and subcellular localization revealed that corrector combinations did not fully normalize F508del-CFTR behavior. Our study indicates that it is still possible to further improve mutant CFTR rescue with the development of corrector combinations having maximal effects on mutant CFTR structural and functional properties.     

Rare Trafficking CFTR Mutations Involve Distinct Cellular Retention Machineries and Require Different Rescuing Strategies

Most of the ~2100 CFTR variants so far reported are very rare and still uncharacterized regarding their cystic fibrosis (CF) disease liability. Since some may respond to currently approved modulators, characterizing their defect and response to these drugs is essential. Here we aimed characterizing the defect associated with four rare missense (likely Class II) CFTR variants and assess their rescue by corrector drugs. We produced CFBE cell lines stably expressing CFTR with W57G, R560S, H1079P and Q1100P, assessed their effect upon CFTR expression and maturation and their rescue by VX-661/VX-445 correctors. Results were validated by forskolin-induced swelling assay (FIS) using intestinal organoids from individuals bearing these variants. Finally, knock-down (KD) of genes previously shown to rescue F508del-CFTR was assessed on these mutants. Results show that all the variants preclude the production of mature CFTR, confirming them as Class II mutations. None of the variants responded to VX-661 but the combination rescued H1079P- and Q1100P-CFTR. The KD of factors that correct F508del-CFTR retention only marginally rescued R560S- and H1079P-CFTR. Overall, data evidence that Class II mutations induce distinct molecular defects that are neither rescued by the same corrector compounds nor recognized by the same cellular machinery, thus requiring personalized drug discovery initiatives.     

Capturing the Direct Binding of CFTR Correctors to CFTR by Using Click Chemistry

Cystic fibrosis (CF) is a lethal genetic disease caused by the loss or dysfunction of the CF transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) channel. F508del is the most prevalent mutation of the CFTR gene and encodes a protein defective in folding and processing. VX‐809 has been reported to facilitate the folding and trafficking of F508del‐CFTR and augment its channel function. The mechanism of action of VX‐809 has been poorly understood. In this study, we sought to answer a fundamental question underlying the mechanism of VX‐809: does it bind CFTR directly in order to exert its action? We synthesized two VX‐809 derivatives, ALK‐809 and SUL‐809, that possess an alkyne group and retain the rescue capacity of VX‐809. By using Cu^I‐catalyzed click chemistry, we provide evidence that the VX‐809 derivatives bind CFTR directly in vitro and in cells. Our findings will contribute to the elucidation of the mechanism of action of CFTR correctors and the design of more potent therapeutics to combat CF.     

The L467F-F508del Complex Allele Hampers Pharmacological Rescue of Mutant CFTR by Elexacaftor/Tezacaftor/Ivacaftor in Cystic Fibrosis Patients: The Value of the Ex Vivo Nasal Epithelial Model to Address Non-Responders to CFTR-Modulating Drugs

Loss-of-function mutations of the CFTR gene cause cystic fibrosis (CF) through a variety of molecular mechanisms involving altered expression, trafficking, and/or activity of the CFTR chloride channel. The most frequent mutation among CF patients, F508del, causes multiple defects that can be, however, overcome by a combination of three pharmacological agents that improve CFTR channel trafficking and gating, namely, elexacaftor, tezacaftor, and ivacaftor. This study was prompted by the evidence of two CF patients, compound heterozygous for F508del and a minimal function variant, who failed to obtain any beneficial effects following treatment with the triple drug combination. Functional studies on nasal epithelia generated in vitro from these patients confirmed the lack of response to pharmacological treatment. Molecular characterization highlighted the presence of an additional amino acid substitution, L467F, in cis with the F508del variant, demonstrating that both patients were carriers of a complex allele. Functional and biochemical assays in heterologous expression systems demonstrated that the double mutant L467F-F508del has a severely reduced activity, with negligible rescue by CFTR modulators. While further studies are needed to investigate the actual prevalence of the L467F-F508del allele, our results suggest that this complex allele should be taken into consideration as plausible cause in CF patients not responding to CFTR modulators.     

Differential CFTR-Interactome Proximity Labeling Procedures Identify Enrichment in Multiple SLC Transporters

Proteins interacting with CFTR and its mutants have been intensively studied using different experimental approaches. These studies provided information on the cellular processes leading to proper protein folding, routing to the plasma membrane, recycling, activation and degradation. Recently, new approaches have been developed based on the proximity labeling of protein partners or proteins in close vicinity and their subsequent identification by mass spectrometry. In this study, we evaluated TurboID- and APEX2-based proximity labeling of WT CFTR and compared the obtained data to those reported in databases. The CFTR-WT interactome was then compared to that of two CFTR (G551D and W1282X) mutants and the structurally unrelated potassium channel KCNK3. The two proximity labeling approaches identified both known and additional CFTR protein partners, including multiple SLC transporters. Proximity labeling approaches provided a more comprehensive picture of the CFTR interactome and improved our knowledge of the CFTR environment.     

Targeting of the Cystic Fibrosis Transmembrane Conductance Regulator (CFTR) Protein with a Technetium‐99m Imaging Probe

Cystic fibrosis (CF) is caused by mutations in the gene that encodes the CF transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) protein. The most common mutation, F508del, leads to almost total absence of CFTR at the plasma membrane, a defect potentially corrected via drug‐based therapies. Herein, we report the first proof‐of‐principle study of a noninvasive imaging probe able to detect CFTR at the plasma membrane. We radiolabeled the CFTR inhibitor, CFTR_inh‐172a, with technetium‐99m via a pyrazolyl‐diamine chelating unit, yielding a novel ^99mTc(CO)₃ complex. A non‐radioactive surrogate showed that the structural modifications introduced in the inhibitor did not affect its activity. The radioactive complex was able to detect plasma membrane CFTR, shown by its significantly higher uptake in wild‐type versus mutated cells. Furthermore, assessment of F508del CFTR pharmacological correction in human cells using the radioactive complex revealed differences in corrector versus control uptake, recapitulating the biochemical correction observed for the protein.     

Discovery of Natural Products Possessing Selective Eukaryotic Readthrough Activity: 3‐epi‐Deoxynegamycin and Its Leucine Adduct

Herein we report the first discovery of natural readthrough products that do not display antimicrobial activity. Two natural negamycins, 3‐epi‐deoxynegamycin and its leucine adduct, isolated 37 years ago, were found to be potent readthrough agents against nonsense mutations of eukaryotes, but not prokaryotes, without displaying antimicrobial activity. These results suggest that the compounds are valuable leads for the development of readthrough drugs against nonsense‐mediated genetic diseases without the potential for contributing to the emergence of drug‐resistant bacteria.     

Emerging Concepts in Defective Macrophage Phagocytosis in Cystic Fibrosis

Cystic fibrosis (CF) is caused by mutations of the cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) gene. Chronic inflammation and decline in lung function are major reasons for morbidity in CF. Mutant CFTR expressed in phagocytic cells such as macrophages contributes to persistent infection, inflammation, and lung disease in CF. Macrophages play a central role in innate immunity by eliminating pathogenic microbes by a process called phagocytosis. Phagocytosis is required for tissue homeostasis, balancing inflammation, and crosstalk with the adaptive immune system for antigen presentation. This review focused on (1) current understandings of the signaling underlying phagocytic mechanisms; (2) existing evidence for phagocytic dysregulation in CF; and (3) the emerging role of CFTR modulators in influencing CF phagocytic function. Alterations in CF macrophages from receptor initiation to phagosome formation are linked to disease progression in CF. A deeper understanding of macrophages in the context of CFTR and phagocytosis proteins at each step of phagosome formation might contribute to the new therapeutic development of dysregulated innate immunity in CF. Therefore, the review also indicates future areas of research in the context of CFTR and macrophages.     

KDM2A and KDM3B as Potential Targets for the Rescue of F508del-CFTR

Cystic fibrosis (CF) is caused by mutations in the gene encoding of the cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR), an anion-selective plasma membrane channel that mainly regulates chloride transport in a variety of epithelia. More than 2000 mutations, most of which presumed to be disease-relevant, have been identified in the CFTR gene. The single CFTR mutation F508del (deletion of phenylalanine in position 508) is present in about 90% of global CF patients in at least one allele. F508del is responsible for the defective folding and processing of CFTR, failing to traffic to the plasma membrane and undergoing premature degradation via the ubiquitin–proteasome system. CFTR is subjected to different post-translational modifications (PTMs), and the possibility to modulate these PTMs has been suggested as a potential therapeutic strategy for the functional recovery of the disease-associated mutants. Recently, the PTM mapping of CFTR has identified some lysine residues that may undergo methylation or ubiquitination, suggesting a competition between these two PTMs. Our work hypothesis moves from the idea that favors methylation over ubiquitination, e.g., inhibiting demethylation could be a successful strategy for preventing the premature degradation of unstable CFTR mutants. Here, by using a siRNA library against all the human demethylases, we identified the enzymes whose downregulation increases F508del-CFTR stability and channel function. Our results show that KDM2A and KDM3B downregulation increases the stability of F508del-CFTR and boosts the functional rescue of the channel induced by CFTR correctors.     

Identification of Potential Leukocyte Biomarkers Related to Drug Recovery of CFTR: Clinical Applications in Cystic Fibrosis

The aim of this study was the identification of specific proteomic profiles, related to a restored cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) activity in cystic fibrosis (CF) leukocytes before and after ex vivo treatment with the potentiator VX770. We used leukocytes, isolated from CF patients carrying residual function mutations and eligible for Ivacaftor therapy, and performed CFTR activity together with proteomic analyses through micro-LC–MS. Bioinformatic analyses of the results obtained revealed the downregulation of proteins belonging to the leukocyte transendothelial migration and regulation of actin cytoskeleton pathways when CFTR activity was rescued by VX770 treatment. In particular, we focused our attention on matrix metalloproteinase 9 (MMP9), because the high expression of this protease potentially contributes to parenchyma lung destruction and dysfunction in CF. Thus, the downregulation of MMP9 could represent one of the possible positive effects of VX770 in decreasing the disease progression, and a potential biomarker for the prediction of the efficacy of therapies targeting the defect of Cl⁻ transport in CF.     

The Effect of CFTR Modulators on Airway Infection in Cystic Fibrosis

The advent of Cystic fibrosis transmembrane receptor (CFTR) modulators in 2012 was a critical event in the history of cystic fibrosis (CF) treatment. Unlike traditional therapies that target downstream effects of CFTR dysfunction, CFTR modulators aim to correct the underlying defect at the protein level. These genotype-specific therapies are now available for an increasing number of CF patients, transforming the way we view the condition from a life-limiting disease to one that can be effectively managed. Several studies have demonstrated the vast improvement CFTR modulators have on normalization of sweat chloride, CFTR function, clinical endpoints, and frequency of pulmonary exacerbation. However, their impact on other aspects of the disease, such as pathogenic burden and airway infection, remain under explored. Frequent airway infections as a result of increased susceptibility and impaired innate immune response are a serious problem within CF, often leading to accelerated decline in lung function and disease progression. Current evidence suggests that CFTR modulators are unable to eradicate pathogenic organisms in those with already established lung disease. However, this may not be the case for those with relatively low levels of disease progression and conserved microbial diversity, such as young patients. Furthermore, it remains unknown whether the restorative effects exerted by CFTR modulators extend to immune cells, such as phagocytes, which have the potential to modulate the response of people with CF (pwCF) to infection. Throughout this review, we look at the potential impact of CFTR modulators on airway infection in CF and their ability to shape impaired pulmonary defences to pathogens.     

Properties of Non-Aminoglycoside Compounds Used to Stimulate Translational Readthrough of PTC Mutations in Primary Ciliary Dyskinesia

Primary ciliary dyskinesia (PCD) is a rare disease with autosomal recessive inheritance, caused mostly by bi-allelic gene mutations that impair motile cilia structure and function. Currently, there are no causal treatments for PCD. In many disease models, translational readthrough of premature termination codons (PTC-readthrough) induced by aminoglycosides has been proposed as an effective way of restoring functional protein expression and reducing disease symptoms. However, variable outcomes of pre-clinical trials and toxicity associated with long-term use of aminoglycosides prompt the search for other compounds that might overcome these problems. Because a high proportion of PCD-causing variants are nonsense mutations, readthrough therapies are an attractive option. We tested a group of chemical compounds with known PTC-readthrough potential (ataluren, azithromycin, tylosin, amlexanox, and the experimental compound TC007), collectively referred to as non-aminoglycosides (NAGs). We investigated their PTC-readthrough efficiency in six PTC mutations found in Polish PCD patients, in the context of cell and cilia health, and in comparison to the previously tested aminoglycosides. The NAGs did not compromise the viability of the primary nasal respiratory epithelial cells, and the ciliary beat frequency was retained, similar to what was observed for gentamicin. In HEK293 cells transfected with six PTC-containing inserts, the tested compounds stimulated PTC-readthrough but with lower efficiency than aminoglycosides. The study allowed us to select compounds with minimal negative impact on cell viability and function but still the potential to induce PTC-readthrough.     

A monoclonal antibody prevents aggregation of the NBD1 domain of the cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator

The homozygous deletion of the phenylalanine at position 508 (DeltaPhe508) in the first nucleotide-binding domain (NBD1) of the cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) is the most common CF-causing genetic defect. It has been proposed that the propensity of NBD1 to aggregate may lead to a lower display of the CFTR chloride channel to the cell membrane and to the disease, thus opening an avenue for the pharmacological development of CFTR folding correctors. Here, we show that a human monoclonal antibody fragment specific to the folded conformation of NBD1 inhibits the aggregation of NBD1 in vitro. However, in contrast to the previously published observations, we proved experimentally that NBD1 of wild-type and DeltaPhe508 version of CFTR display comparable propensities to aggregate in vitro and that the corresponding full-length CFTR protein reaches the cell membrane with comparable efficiency in mammalian cell expression systems. On the basis of our results, the 'folding defect' hypothesis seems unlikely to represent the causal mechanism for the pathogenesis of CF. A solid understanding of how the DeltaPhe508 deletion leads to the disease represents an absolute requirement for the development of effective drugs against CF.     

An Epilepsy-Associated Mutation of Salt-Inducible Kinase 1 Increases the Susceptibility to Epileptic Seizures and Interferes with Adrenocorticotropic Hormone Therapy for Infantile Spasms in Mice

Six mutations in the salt-inducible kinase 1 (SIK1) have been identified in developmental and epileptic encephalopathy (DEE-30) patients, and two of the mutations are nonsense mutations that truncate the C-terminal region of SIK1. In a previous study, we generated SIK1 mutant (SIK1-MT) mice recapitulating the C-terminal truncated mutations using CRISPR/Cas9-mediated genome editing and found an increase in excitatory synaptic transmission and enhancement of neural excitability in neocortical neurons in SIK1-MT mice. NMDA was injected into SIK1-MT males to induce epileptic seizures in the mice. The severity of the NMDA-induced seizures was estimated by the latency and the number of tail flickering and hyperflexion. Activated brain regions were evaluated by immunohistochemistry against c-fos, Iba1, and GFAP. As another epilepsy model, pentylenetetrazol was injected into the adult SIK1 mutant mice. Seizure susceptibility induced by both NMDA and PTZ was enhanced in SIK1-MT mice. Brain regions including the thalamus and hypothalamus were strongly activated in NMDA-induced seizures. The epilepsy-associated mutation of SIK1 canceled the pharmacological effects of the ACTH treatment on NMDA-induced seizures. These results suggest that SIK1 may be involved in the neuropathological mechanisms of NMDA-induced spasms and the pharmacological mechanism of ACTH treatment.     

Synergy in Cystic Fibrosis Therapies: Targeting SLC26A9

SLC26A9, a constitutively active Cl⁻ transporter, has gained interest over the past years as a relevant disease modifier in several respiratory disorders including Cystic Fibrosis (CF), asthma, and non-CF bronchiectasis. SLC26A9 contributes to epithelial Cl⁻ secretion, thus preventing mucus obstruction under inflammatory conditions. Additionally, SLC26A9 was identified as a CF gene modifier, and its polymorphisms were shown to correlate with the response to drugs modulating CFTR, the defective protein in CF. Here, we aimed to investigate the relationship between SLC26A9 and CFTR, and its role in CF pathogenesis. Our data show that SLC26A9 expression contributes to enhanced CFTR expression and function. While knocking-down SLC26A9 in human bronchial cells leads to lower wt- and F508del-CFTR expression, function, and response to CFTR correctors, the opposite occurs upon its overexpression, highlighting SLC26A9 relevance for CF. Accordingly, F508del-CFTR rescue by the most efficient correctors available is further enhanced by increasing SLC26A9 expression. Interestingly, SLC26A9 overexpression does not increase the PM expression of non-F508del CFTR traffic mutants, namely those unresponsive to corrector drugs. Altogether, our data indicate that SLC26A9 stabilizes CFTR at the ER level and that the efficacy of CFTR modulator drugs may be further enhanced by increasing its expression.     

CFTR Lifecycle Map—A Systems Medicine Model of CFTR Maturation to Predict Possible Active Compound Combinations

Different causative therapeutics for CF patients have been developed. There are still no mutation-specific therapeutics for some patients, especially those with rare CFTR mutations. For this purpose, high-throughput screens have been performed which result in various candidate compounds, with mostly unclear modes of action. In order to elucidate the mechanism of action for promising candidate substances and to be able to predict possible synergistic effects of substance combinations, we used a systems biology approach to create a model of the CFTR maturation pathway in cells in a standardized, human- and machine-readable format. It is composed of a core map, manually curated from small-scale experiments in human cells, and a coarse map including interactors identified in large-scale efforts. The manually curated core map includes 170 different molecular entities and 156 reactions from 221 publications. The coarse map encompasses 1384 unique proteins from four publications. The overlap between the two data sources amounts to 46 proteins. The CFTR Lifecycle Map can be used to support the identification of potential targets inside the cell and elucidate the mode of action for candidate substances. It thereby provides a backbone to structure available data as well as a tool to develop hypotheses regarding novel therapeutics.     

Structural and Functional Characterization of Four Novel Fibrinogen Mutations in FGB Causing Congenital Fibrinogen Disorder

Congenital fibrinogen disorders are caused by mutations in genes coding for fibrinogen and may lead to various clinical phenotypes. Here, we present a functional and structural analysis of 4 novel variants located in the FGB gene coding for fibrinogen Bβ chain-heterozygous missense BβY416C and BβA68S, homozygous nonsense BβY345*, and heterozygous nonsense BβW403* mutations. The cases were identified by coagulation screening tests and further investigated by various methods. Fibrin polymerization had abnormal development with decreased maximal absorbance in all patients. Plasmin-induced fibrin degradation revealed different lytic phases of BβY416C and BβW403* than those of the control. Fibrinopeptide cleavage measured by reverse phase high pressure liquid chromatography of BβA68S showed impaired release of fibrinopeptide B. Morphological properties, studied through scanning electron microscopy, differed significantly in the fiber thickness of BβY416C, BβA68S, and BβW403*, and in the fiber density of BβY416C and BβW403*. Finally, homology modeling of BβA68S showed that mutation caused negligible alternations in the protein structure. In conclusion, all mutations altered the correct fibrinogen function or structure that led to congenital fibrinogen disorders.     

Acting on the CFTR Membrane-Spanning Domains Interface Rescues Some Misfolded Mutants

ABC transporters are large membrane proteins sharing a complex architecture, which comprises two nucleotide-binding domains (NBDs) and two membrane-spanning domains (MSDs). These domains are susceptible to mutations affecting their folding and assembly. In the CFTR (ABCC7) protein, a groove has been highlighted in the MSD1 at the level of the membrane inner leaflet, containing both multiple mutations affecting folding and a binding site for pharmaco-chaperones that stabilize this region. This groove is also present in ABCB proteins, however it is covered by a short elbow helix, while in ABCC proteins it remains unprotected, due to a lower position of the elbow helix in the presence of the ABCC-specific lasso motif. Here, we identified a MSD1 second-site mutation located in the vicinity of the CFTR MSD1 groove that partially rescued the folding defect of cystic fibrosis causing mutations located within MSD1, while having no effect on the most frequent mutation, F508del, located within NBD1. A model of the mutated protein 3D structure suggests additional interaction between MSD1 and MSD2, strengthening the assembly at the level of the MSD intracellular loops. Altogether, these results provide insightful information in understanding key features of the folding and function of the CFTR protein in particular, and more generally, of type IV ABC transporters.     

Redefining Hypo- and Hyper-Responding Phenotypes of CFTR Mutants for Understanding and Therapy

Mutations in CFTR cause misfolding and decreased or absent ion-channel function, resulting in the disease Cystic Fibrosis. Fortunately, a triple-modulator combination therapy (Trikafta) has been FDA-approved for 178 mutations, including all patients who have F508del on one allele. That so many CFTR mutants respond well to modulators developed for a single mutation is due to the nature of the folding process of this multidomain protein. We have addressed the question ‘What characterizes the exceptions: the mutants that functionally respond either not or extremely well’. A functional response is the product of the number of CFTR molecules on the cell surface, open probability, and conductivity of the CFTR chloride channel. By combining biosynthetic radiolabeling with protease-susceptibility assays, we have followed CF-causing mutants during the early and late stages of folding in the presence and absence of modulators. Most CFTR mutants showed typical biochemical responses for each modulator, such as a TMD1 conformational change or an increase in (cell-surface) stability, regardless of a functional response. These modulators thus should still be considered for hypo-responder genotypes. Understanding both biochemical and functional phenotypes of outlier mutations will boost our insights into CFTR folding and misfolding, and lead to improved therapeutic strategies.