Experimental and numerical study of oblique impact on woven composite sandwich structure: Influence of the firing axis orientation

During flight, aircrafts can be submitted to complex loadings. The reliability of their structure is an essential aspect in ensuring passenger safety. In the specific case of helicopters, blades are subjected to impact loading. The following work will focus on the experimental and numerical study of an oblique impact on the skin of the blade. It is equivalent in a first approach to an impact on a sandwich panel comprising a foam core and a thin woven composite skin. This study aims to identify the mechanisms of damage to the skin for different orientations of the firing axis, and to develop a representative model of the damage kinetics adapted to the modeling of the complete structure. Thus, an F.E. semi-continuous explicit model has been developed. It relies on the development of a specific damageable element at the woven mesh scale. Numerical results obtained are accurate, allowing the identification of the damage mechanism of the woven skin for different firing orientations.     

Modelling of low-energy/low-velocity impact on Nomex honeycomb sandwich structures with metallic skins

In the aircraft industry, manufacturers have to decide quickly whether an impacted sandwich needs repairing or not. Certain computation tools exist at present but they are very time-consuming and they also fail to perfectly model the physical phenomena involved in an impact. In a previous publication, the authors demonstrated the possibility of representing the Nomex™ honeycomb core by a grid of nonlinear springs and have pointed out both the structural behaviour of the honeycomb and the influence of core-skin boundary conditions. This discrete approach accurately predicts the static indentation on honeycomb core alone and the indentation on sandwich structure with metal skins supported on rigid flat support. In this study, the domain of validity of this approach is investigated. It is found that the approach is not valid for sharp projectiles on thin skins. In any case, the spring elements used to model the honeycomb cannot take into account the transverse shear that occurs in the core during the bending of a sandwich. To overcome this strong limitation, a multi-level approach is proposed in the present article. In this approach, the sandwich structure is modelled by Mindlin plate elements and the computed static contact law is implemented in a nonlinear spring located between the impactor and the structure. Thus, it is possible to predict the dynamic structural response in the case of low-velocity/low-energy impact on metal-skinned sandwich structures. A good correlation with dynamic experimental tests is achieved.     

Hybrid processing of thick skins for honeycomb sandwich structures

Carbon-epoxy prepregs are generally used to form the skins of honeycomb sandwich structures used in aerospace or racing yachts. For some applications, it is desirable to increase the thickness of the skins. In order to achieve an ideal core pressure level during cure for maximal skin-core bonding, the issue of air extraction from the honeycomb cells through the skin during processing thus becomes critical, in particular if vacuum only processing is used. In the present work, partially impregnated prepregs, called semipregs, having high initial transverse permeability to air, are combined with traditional prepregs to form a hybrid skin. Results are presented on the pressure change inside the honeycomb cells and the skin permeability to air during cure, as well as on skin-core adhesion. The final sandwich quality is assessed and found to be comparable to that obtained with prepreg skins.     

Experimental and numerical investigation of fabric impact behavior

This paper presents experimental and numerical research regarding blunt trauma resistance of ten fabrics made of high strength fibers. Fabrics of various architecture were examined, including plain woven fabrics, unidirectional laminates and multiaxial fabrics. The fabrics were compared with respect to the depth of the depression formed and the amount of energy transferred to the backing during projectile impact. Absolute values of mentioned parameters were compared, as well as their values after normalization with respect to thickness and areal density of the fabrics. A numerical method for estimating the amount of energy transferred to the backing was proposed.Normalized results, obtained experimentally and numerically, proved that most of the analyzed fabrics provide a similar level of protection, but the best blunt trauma resistance is given by multiaxial fabrics and the least by plain woven fabrics. This study has also shown that the depth of the depression in the backing material is an insufficient parameter in describing protective properties of fabric against blunt trauma. It is possible that impacts into ballistic packages composed of different fabrics with the same depth of depression may cause completely dissimilar injuries because of the amount of energy transferred to the backing material.     

Homogenization of the core layer in stitched sandwich structures

After highlighting the improvement of the mechanical performances involved by transverse reinforcement implementation in previous several studies, the mechanical behavior of stitched sandwich structures is analytically approached in this paper. The final purpose of this work is a modeling of the elastic performances of these structures. To predict the in-plane behavior, the classical theory of sandwiches is adapted and used by treating the foam core strengthened by stitches as a homogenized volume. This approach leads to the creation of an orthotropic equivalent core material. Its elastic properties depend on each component and their volume participation. The comparison between simulated and experimental values is quite good. The main interest of the multi-scale approach concerns a predictive tool. Indeed, it becomes realistic to obtain the elastic properties of stitched sandwich according to the geometrical parameters of the stitches and the mechanical properties of the components.     

Experimental investigation of compression failure of sandwich specimens with face/core debond

An experimental study of the in-plane compressive failure mechanism of foam cored sandwich specimens with an implanted through-width face/core debond is presented. Tests were conducted on sandwich specimens with glass/vinylester and carbon/epoxy face sheets over various PVC foam cores. Observation of the response of the specimens during testing showed that failure occurred by buckling of the debonded face sheet, followed by rapid debond growth towards the ends of the specimen. The compression strength of the sandwich specimens containing a debond decreased quite substantially with increasing debond size. A high-density core resulted in less strength decrease at any given debond size. Examination of the failure surfaces after separation of the face sheet and core revealed traces of core material deposited on the face sheet evidencing cohesive core failure. The amount of core material adhered to the face sheet decreased with increasing foam density indicating increasing tendency for core/resin interfacial failure.     

Impact and compression after impact experimental study of a composite laminate with a cork thermal shield

The aim of this paper is to present an experimental study of impact and compression after impact (CAI) tests performed on composite laminate covered with a cork thermal shield (TS) intended for launchers fairing. Drop weight impact tests have been performed on composite laminate sheets with and without TS in order to study its effect on the impact damage. The results show the TS is a good mechanical protection towards impact as well as a good impact revealing material. Nevertheless, totally different damage morphology is obtained during the impact test with or without TS, and in particular at high impact energy, the delaminated area is larger with TS. Afterwards, CAI tests have been performed in order to evaluate the TS effect on the residual strength. The TS appears to increase the residual strength for a same impact energy, but at the same time, it presents a decrease in residual strength before observing delamination. In fact, during the impact tests with TS, invisible fibres’ breakages appear before delamination damage contrary to the impacts on the unshielded sheets.     

Core crush criterion to determine the strength of sandwich composite structures subjected to compression after impact

In this study a core crush criterion is proposed to determine the residual strength of impacted sandwich structures. The core of the sandwich is made of a Nomex Honeycomb core and the faces are laminated and remain thin. The mechanism of failure of this kind of structure under post-impact compressive loading is due to interaction between three mechanical behaviors: geometrical nonlinearity due to the skin’s neutral line off-set in the dent area, nonlinear response of the core and damages to the skins. For the type of sandwich analysed in this study, initially the core crushes at the apex of the damage. Using a finite element discrete modelling of the core previously proposed by the authors, the load corresponding to the crushing of the first cell can be computed and it gives the value of the residual strength for our criterion. Some geometric and material hypotheses are assumed in the damaged area mainly based on non-destructive inspection (NDI). The criterion is then applied to tests modelled by Lacy and Hwang [Lacy TE, Hwang Y. Numerical modelling of impact-damaged sandwich composites subjected to compression after impact loading. Compos Struct 2003;61:115–128]. It is shown that the criterion allows a good prediction of the tests except in the case of very small dents. Several sensitivity studies on the assumptions were made and it is shown that using this approach, the criterion is robust.     

Sensitivity of structurally loaded sandwich panels to localized ballistic penetration

This paper describes a series of tests focused on the combination of structural loading (bending, shear) and simultaneous penetrating impact on sandwich panels with thin GFRP face-sheets, with emphasis on the specific damage morphologies and developments depending on the type and magnitude of structural loading. The test specimens were sandwich panels, length 250 mm and width 150 mm, with carbon fibre prepreg face-sheets ([0°/90°], thickness t_f ≅ 0.5 mm) bonded to the faces of a foam core (density 80 kg/m³, thickness H = 10 mm). The impact velocity was approximately 420 m/s, using a spherical steel impactor, diameter 10 mm, with a mass of 4.1 g. A high-speed camera was used for registration of panel response. It was demonstrated, that, at preload levels above a specific limit, the impact would cause catastrophic failure, i.e., complete or near-complete loss of structural load carrying capacity. Developments of failure morphology, consistent with the observed evidence, were derived and outlined.     

New peel stopper concept for sandwich structures

The paper addresses the damage tolerance of sandwich structures, where the prevention and limitation of delamination failure are highly important design issues. Due to the layered composition of sandwich structures, face–core interface delamination is a commonly observed failure mode, often referred to as peeling failure. Peeling between the sandwich face sheets and the core material drastically diminishes the structural integrity of the structure. This paper presents a new peel stopper concept for sandwich structures. Its purpose is to effectively stop the development of debonding/delamination by rerouting the delamination, and to confine it to a predefined zone in the sandwich structure. The suggested design was experimentally tested for different material compositions of sandwich beams subjected to three-point bending loading. For all the tested sandwich configurations the suggested peel stopper was able to stop face–core delamination and to limit the delamination damage to restricted zones.     

Crack deflection analyses of different peel stopper designs for sandwich structures

This paper relates to a newly developed peel stopper concept for sandwich structures. The proposed concept is a specially designed core insert, which has the ability to confine face sheet debonding/delamination (peeling) by deflecting a delamination crack front away from the face/core interface into the bulk of the sandwich core, and thereby constraining the debonding/delamination to a limited prescribed area. In this paper various peel stopper designs are analysed for their ability to deflect cracks away from propagating along a face–core interface. The crack deflection ability of the studied peel stopper designs leads to design guidelines, which describes the minimum requirements regarding the relation between the two interface toughnesses. The analysis further reveals that compliant peel stopper wedges are preferred because they lead to the lowest interface toughness ratio requirement. This has been confirmed through an experiment with a sandwich beam subjected to three-point bending loading. The experiment has shown that the ability of a peel stopper to deflect cracks is highly dependent on the stiffness of the wedge.     

In-plane directional mechanical properties of carbon fabric skins in sandwich structures after thermoforming

In this paper, a representative unit volume finite element (RUV FE) model was employed to simulate thermoforming process of carbon fabric-polymeric foam sandwich structures. Thermoforming simulations, which capture crimp angles and amplitude changes of carbon fabric with respect to different operational pressure, were conducted with the help of RUV FE model. Micro-deformation of tow structures after thermoforming was rigorously reflected in the second stage FE model to determine the in-plane directional stiffness of skin parts. Tensile tests were carried out to investigate mechanical properties of skin parts in sandwich structures for the potential usage of automotives, electronic housings or the satellite structure design.     

Multiscale modelling of the composite reinforced foam core of a 3D sandwich structure

A key objective dealing with 3D sandwich structures is to maximize the through-thickness stiffness, the strength of the core and the core to faces adhesion. The Napco^® technology was especially designed for improving such material properties and is under investigation in this paper. In particular, the potential of the process is characterized using a micromechanical modelling combined to a parametric probabilistic model. An experimental analysis is further detailed and validates the theoretical estimates of the core-related elastic properties. It is readily shown that the technology is able to produce parts with significantly improved mechanical properties. Finally, thanks to the probabilistic aspect of the modelling, the study allows to establish a link between the randomness of the process and the uncertainties of the final mechanical properties. Thus, the present approach can be used to optimize the technology as well as to properly design structures.     

Sound radiation of orthogonally rib-stiffened sandwich structures with cavity absorption

A comprehensive theoretical model is developed for the radiation of sound from an infinite orthogonally rib-stiffened sandwich structure filled with fibrous sound absorptive material in the partitioned cavity, when excited by a time-harmonic point force. The vibrations of the rib-stiffeners are accounted for by considering all possible motions. Built upon the concepts of dynamic density and bulk modulus, both frequency dependent, an equivalent fluid model is employed to characterize the absorption of sound in the fibrous material. Given the periodicity of the sandwich structure, Fourier transform technique is employed to solve the series of panel vibration equations and acoustic equations. In the absence of fibrous sound absorptive material, the model can be favorably degraded to the case of an infinite rib-stiffened structure with air or vacuum cavity. Validation of the model is performed by comparing the present model predictions with previously published data, excellent agreements are achieved. The influences of air–structure coupling effect and cavity-filling fibrous material on the sound radiation are systematically examined. The physical features associated with sound penetration across these sandwich structures are interpreted by considering the combined effects of fiberglass stiffness and damping, the balance of which is significantly affected by stiffener separation. The proposed model provides a convenient and efficient tool for the factual engineering design of this kind of sandwich structures.     

Experimental and numerical study of the impact behavior of SMC plates

Steel components absorb impact energy by plastic deformation whilst composite materials absorbing it by damage mechanisms such as fiber debonding, fiber fracture, and matrix cracking. Therefore, in order to properly substitute metal components with composite ones in industrial applications, the impact property of composite materials must be well known. In this study, the impact behavior of sheet molding compounds (SMC), which is widely used in automobile industry due to its relatively low cost and high productivity, was examined both experimentally and numerically. In order to investigate the impact behavior of SMC, an experimental study was carried out by setting up a drop weight impact test system. Using this system, the dissipated impact energies of SMC flat plates were measured to investigate the influence of the mass and shape of impactor, initial velocity, and specimen thickness on the impact behavior.

For numerical predictions, a modified damage model for SMC was developed and adopted in the user defined material subroutine of the commercial simulation program LS-DYNA3D. For the sake of improving efficiency of impact simulations, the SMC material property was determined in consideration of the local differences of the fiber volume fractions. The dissipated impact energies under various conditions and the reliability of the developed impact simulation process were examined through comparisons of the predicted data with the experimental results.

From this comparison, it was found that, in the scope of current study, the specimen thickness is the most important parameter that should be considered in the design of SMC components for the aspect of impact behavior.     

Experimental investigation of impact on composite laminates with protective layers

This paper presents an experimental study of low energy impacts on composite plates covered with a protective layer. In service, composite materials are subjected to low energy impacts. Such impacts can generate damage in the material that results in significant reduction in material strength. In order to reduce the damage severity, one solution is to add a mechanical protection on composite structures. The protection layer is made up of a low density energy absorbent material (hollow spheres) of a certain thickness and a thin layer of composite laminate (Kevlar). Energy absorption ability of these protective layers can be deduced from the load/displacement impact curves. First, two configurations of protection are tested on an aluminium plate in order to identify their performance against impact, then the same are tested on composite plates. Test results from force–displacement curves and C-scan control are compared and discussed and finally a comparison of impact on composite plates with and without protection is made for different configurations.     

Effect of stitch density and stitch thread thickness on compression after impact strength and response of stitched composites

In this paper, the damage failure and behaviour of stitched composites under compression after impact (CAI) loading are experimentally investigated. This study focuses on the effect of stitch density and stitch thread thickness on the CAI strength and response of laminated composites reinforced by through-thickness stitching. Experimental findings show that stitched composites have higher CAI failure load and displacement, which corresponds to higher energy absorption during CAI damage, mainly attributed to greater energy consumption by stitch fibre rupture. The coupling relationships between CAI strength, impact energy, stitch density and stitch thread thickness are also revealed. It is understood that the effectiveness of stitching has high dependency on the applied impact energy. At low impact energy range, CAI strength is found to be solely dependent on stitch density, showing no influence of stitch thread thickness. It is however observed that stitch fibre bridging is rendered ineffective in moderately stitched laminates during compressive failure, as local buckling occurs between stitch threads, resulting in unstitched and moderately stitched laminates have similar CAI strength. The CAI strength of densely stitched laminates is much higher due to effective stitch fibre bridging and numerous stitch thread breakages. At high impact energy level, CAI strength is discovered to be intimately related to both stitch density and stitch thread thickness. Since CAI failure initiates from impact-induced delamination area, stitch fibre bridging is considerable for all specimens due to the relatively large delamination area present. Stitch threads effectively bridge the delaminated area, inhibit local buckling and suppress delamination propagation, thus leading to increased CAI strength for laminates stitched with higher stitch density and larger stitch thread thickness. Fracture mechanisms and crack bridging phenomenon, elucidated by X-ray radiography are also presented and discussed. This study reveals novel understanding on the effectiveness of stitch parameters for improving impact tolerance of stitched composites.     

Shock loading response of sandwich panels with 3-D woven E-glass composite skins and stitched foam core

Sandwich composite are used in numerous structural applications, with demonstrated weight savings over conventional metals and solid composite materials. The increasing use of sandwich composites in defense structures, particularly those which may be exposed to shock loading, demands for a thorough understanding of their response to suc highly transient loadings. In order to fully utilize their potential in such extreme conditions, design optimization of the skin and core materials are desirable. The present study is performed for a novel type of sandwich material, TRANSONITE^® made by pultrusion of 3-D woven 3WEAVE^® E-glass fiber composites skin preforms integrally stitched to polyisocyanurate TRYMER^TM 200L foam core. The effect of core stitching density on the transient response of three simply supported sandwich panels loaded in a shock tube is experimentally studied in this work. The experimental program is focused on recording dynamic transient response by high-speed camera and post-mortem evaluation of imparted damage. The obtained experimental results reveal new important features of the transient deformation, damage initiation and progression and final failure of sandwich composites with unstitched and stitched foam cores. The theoretical study includes full 3-D dynamic transient analysis of displacement, strain and stress fields under experimentally recorded surface shock pressure, performed with the use of 3-D MOSAIC analysis approach. The obtained theoretical and experimental results for the transient central deflections in unstitched and two stitched foam core sandwiches are mutually compared. The comparison results reveal large discrepancies in the case of unstitched sandwich, much smaller discrepancies in the case of intermediate stitching density, and excellent agreement between theoretical and experimental results for the sandwich with the highest stitching density. The general conclusion is that further comprehensive experimental and theoretical studies are required in order to get a thorough understanding of a very complex behavior of composite sandwiches under shock wave loading.