The difference in the active sites for CO2 and CO hydrogenations on Cu/ZnO-based methanol synthesis catalysts

The effect of Zn in copper catalysts on the activities for both CO₂ and CO hydrogenations has been examined using a physical mixture of Cu/SiO₂+ZnO/SiO₂ and a Zn-containing Cu/SiO₂ catalyst or (Zn)Cu/SiO₂. Reduction of the physical mixture with H₂ at 573–723 K results in an increase in the yield of methanol produced by the CO₂ hydrogenation, while no such a promotion was observed for the CO hydrogenation, indicating that the active site is different for the CO₂ and CO hydrogenations. However, the methanol yield by CO hydrogenation is significantly increased by the oxidation treatment of the (Zn)Cu/SiO₂ catalyst. Thus it is concluded that the Cu–Zn site is active for the CO₂ hydrogenation as previously reported, while the Cu–O–Zn site is active for the CO hydrogenation.     

An in situ high pressure FT-IR study of CO2/H2 interactions with model ZnO/SiO2, Cu/SiO2 and Cu/ZnO/SiO2 methanol synthesis catalysts

In situ FT-IR spectroscopy allows the methanol synthesis reaction to be investigated under actual industrial conditions of 503 K and 10 MPa. On Cu/SiO₂ catalyst formate species were initially formed which were subsequently hydrogenated to methanol. During the reaction a steady state concentration of formate species persisted on the copper. Additionally, a small quantity of gaseous methane was produced. In contrast, the reaction of CO₂ and H₂ on ZnO/SiO₂ catalyst only resulted in the formation of zinc formate species: no methanol was detected. The interaction of CO₂ and H₂ with Cu/ZnO/SiO₂ catalyst gave formate species on both copper and zinc oxide. Methanol was again formed by the hydrogenation of copper formate species. Steady-state concentrations of copper formate existed under actual industrial reaction conditions, and copper formate is the pivotal intermediate for methanol synthesis. Collation of these results with previous data on copper-based methanol synthesis catalysts allowed the formulation of a reaction mechanism.     

Spectroscopic and Kinetic Analysis of a New Low-Temperature Methanol Synthesis Reaction

The spectroscopy and kinetics of a new low-temperature methanol synthesis method were studied by using in situ DRIFTS on Cu/ZnO catalysts from syngas (CO/CO₂/H₂) using alcohol promoters. The adsorbed formate species easily reacted with ethanol or 2-propanol at 443 K and atmospheric pressure, and the reaction rate with 2-propanol was faster than that with ethanol. Alkyl formate was easily reduced to form methanol at 443 K and 1.0 MPa, and the hydrogenation rate of 2-propyl formate was found to be faster than that of ethyl formate. 2-Propanol used as promoter exhibited a higher activity than ethanol in the reaction of the low-temperature methanol synthesis.     

Methanol synthesis and reverse water-gas shift kinetics over clean polycrystalline copper

The kinetics of simultaneous methanol synthesis and reverse water-gas shift from CO₂/H₂ mixtures have been measured at low conversions over a clean polycrystalline Cu foil at pressures of 5 bar. An absolute rate of 1.2 × 10^–3 methanol molecules produced per second per Cu surface atom was observed at 510 K, with an activation energy of 77 ± 10 kJ/mol. The rate of CO production was 0.12 molecules per second per Cu surface atom at this temperature, with an activation energy of 135 ± 5 kJ/mol. The rates, normalized to the metallic Cu surface area, are equal to those measured over real, high-area Cu/ZnO catalysts. The surface after reaction was examined by XPS and TPD. It was covered by almost a full monolayer of adsorbed formate, but no other species like carbon or oxygen in measurable amounts. These results prove that a highly active site for methanol synthesis on real Cu/ZnO catalysts is metallic Cu, and suggest that the rate-determining step in methanol synthesis is one of the several steps in the further hydrogenation of adsorbed formate to methanol.     

Methanol synthesis over Cu/SiO2 catalysts

The rates of CO and CO/CO₂ hydrogenation at 4.2 MPa and 523 K are reported for a series of Cu/SiO₂ catalysts containing 2 to 88 wt.% Cu. These catalysts were prepared on a variety of silica sources using several different Cu deposition techniques. In CO/CO₂ hydrogenation, the rate of methanol formation is proportional to the exposed Cu surface area of the reduced catalyst precursor, as determined by N₂O frontal chromatography. The observed rate, 4.2×10^–3 mole CH₃OH/Cu site-sec, is within a factor of three of the rates reported by others over Cu/ZnO and Cu/ZnO/Al₂O₃ catalysts under comparable conditions. These results suggest that the ZnO component is only a moderate promoter in methanol synthesis. Hydrogenation of CO over these catalysts also gives methanol with high selectivity, but the synthesis rate is not proportional to the Cu surface area. This implies that another type of site, either alone or in cooperation with Cu, is involved in the synthesis of methanol from CO.     

On the Issue of the Active Site and the Role of ZnO in Cu/ZnO Methanol Synthesis Catalysts

The problem concerning the active site and the role of ZnO in Cu/ZnO-based methanol synthesis catalysts can be consistently explained based on the literature results by distinguishing CO₂ and CO hydrogenations. Although only metallic copper has some activities for methanol synthesis by the hydrogenation of CO₂, Cu-Zn alloying in Cu particles is responsible for the major promotional role of ZnO in industrial Cu/ZnO-based catalysts. The morphology effect reported in the literature will probably appear for the system of highly dispersed Cu particles supported on ZnO. As for the hydrogenation of CO, Cu⁺ species or Cu-O-Zn sites are the active sites for methanol synthesis. The spillover effect of the Cu-ZnO system is not significant compared to the effect of ZnO on the creation of the Cu-O-Zn site.     

Support and additive effects in the synthesis of methanol over copper catalysts

Catalysts containing copper and ZnO in various combinations have been prepared, the copper surface areas have been measured by nitrous oxide frontal chromatography, and the activities in the reaction of CO/CO₂/H₂ and CO/H₂ mixtures to methanol have been determined at 250°C and 10 bar pressure. The results show that there is a strong synergy between copper and ZnO with the area specific rate of Cu/ZnO catalysts being about one order of magnitude larger than that of a Cu/SiO₂ catalyst. The synergy between copper and ZnO is observed both in the presence and absence of carbon dioxide. It is also observed that physical mixtures of Cu/SiO₂ and ZnO/SiO₂ catalysts are significantly more active than either of the components alone. The results are discussed in terms of possible interactions between copper and ZnO in the most active catalysts.     

Synergy at a distance in the synthesis of methanol over copper catalysts

Physical mixtures of Cu/SiO₂ and ZnO/SiO₂ catalysts have been studied for the synthesis of methanol from CO/CO₂/H₂ at 250 °C and 10 bar pressure. It is found that the activities are very much higher for the physical mixtures than would be expected from the activities of either of these two catalysts in isolation. The results suggest that the high activity of conventional Cu/ZnO/Al₂O₃ catalysts may arise from a synergy between the Cu and ZnO phases.     

Spectroscopic evidence for adsorption sites located at Cu/ZnO interfaces

FTIR spectra are reported of CO and formic acid adsorption on a series of Cu/ZnO/SiO₂ catalysts. Peaks due to linear CO adsorbed on copper diminished in intensity as the loading of ZnO was increased. This behaviour was explained in terms of ZnO island growth on the copper surface. Similarly, reduction of the copper concentration while maintaining a constant ZnO loading also resulted in further attenuation in bands ascribed to CO chemisorbed on copper. Formic acid exposure to a Cu/SiO₂ sample produced a formate species displaying a _as(COO) mode at 1585 cm^–1. Addition of a small quantity of ZnO to the catalyst resulted in substantial promotion of formate growth, which was accompanied by a shift (and broadening) of the _as(COO) vibration to 1660–1600 cm^–1. Since further ZnO incorporation poisoned formate creation it was concluded that formate species bonded to Cu and Zn sites located at interfacial positions had been formed. The role of such species in methanol synthesis is discussed.     

The effect of ZnO in methanol synthesis catalysts on Cu dispersion and the specific activity

The effect of ZnO in Cu/ZnO catalysts prepared by the coprecipitation method has been studied using measurements of the surface area of Cu, the specific activity for the methanol synthesis by hydrogenation of CO₂, and XRD. Although the Cu surface area increases with increasing ZnO content (0–50 wt%) as is generally known, the specific activity of the Cu/ZnO catalysts with various weight ratios of Cu:ZnO is greater than that of a ZnO-free Cu catalyst. These facts clearly indicate that the role of ZnO in Cu/ZnO catalysts can be ascribed to both increases in the Cu dispersion and the specific activity. The XRD results indicate the formation of a Cu–Zn alloy in the Cu particles of the Cu/ZnO catalysts, leading to the increase in specific activity. It is thus considered that the Cu–Zn surface alloy or a Cu–Zn site is the active site for methanol synthesis in addition to metallic copper atoms that catalyze several hydrogenation steps during the methanol synthesis. Furthermore, the advantage of the coprecipitation method through a precursor of aurichalcite is ascribed to both improvements in the Cu surface area and the specific activity. This revised version was published online in July 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

The effect of ageing time on co-precipitated Cu/ZnO/ZrO2 catalysts used in methanol synthesis from CO2 and H2

The effect of suspension ageing time during the catalyst precipitation process on the performance of co-precipitated Cu/ZnO/ZrO₂ catalysts in methanol synthesis from CO₂ and H₂ has been studied. The ageing time influenced greatly the physical and chemical characteristics of the catalysts as well as their activity in the methanol synthesis. Prolonged ageing was advantageous, mainly due to both lower sodium contents and enhanced crystallinity of the catalysts.     

Methanol synthesis over a Zn-deposited copper model catalyst

Methanol synthesis by the hydrogenation of CO₂ over Zn-deposited polycrystalline Cu was studied using surface science techniques. The Zn sub-monolayer was oxidized by the reaction mixture during the reaction at 523 K, leading to the formation of ZnO species. The kinetic results definitely showed that the ZnO species on the Cu surface promoted the catalytic activity of methanol formation, where the activity of Cu increased by a factor of 6 at the Zn coverage of 0.17. A volcano-shaped curve was obtained for the correlation between the Zn coverage and the catalytic activity, which was very similar to the correlation curve between the oxygen coverage and the specific activity for methanol formation previously obtained for the Cu powder catalysts. The role of ZnO in Cu/ZnO based catalysts was ascribed to the stabilization of Cu⁺ species by the ZnO moieties on the Cu surface.     

The synergy between Cu and ZnO in methanol synthesis catalysts

The hydrogenation of CO₂ over physically-mixed Cu/SiO₂ and ZnO/SiO₂ was carried out to clarify the synergetic effect between Cu and ZnO in Cu/ZnO methanol synthesis catalysts. The activity of the physical mixtures significantly increased with increasing reduction temperature in the range of 573–723 K. TEM-EDX results definitely showed that ZnO_x moieties migrated from ZnO/SiO₂ particles onto the surface of Cu particles when the physical mixtures were reduced at high temperatures above 573 K. Upon the migration of the ZnO_x species, the oxygen coverage on the surface of Cu, measured after the hydrogenation of CO₂, increased with the reduction temperature. The results clearly showed that the synergetic effect of ZnO in the physical mixtures can be ascribed to the creation of active sites such as Cu⁺ which the ZnO_x moieties stabilize on the Cu surface. Further, XRD results showed that the migrated ZnO_x species partly dissolved into the Cu particles to form a Cu—Zn alloy.     

A new method of low-temperature methanol synthesis on Cu/ZnO/Al2O3 catalysts from CO/CO2/H2

A new synthesis method of low-temperature methanol proceeded on Cu/ZnO/Al₂O₃ catalysts from CO/CO₂/H₂ using 2-butanol as promoters. The Cu/ZnO/Al₂O₃ catalysts were prepared by co-impregnation of r-Al₂O₃ with an aqueous solution of copper nitrate and zinc nitrate. The total carbon turnover frequency (TOF), the yield and selectivity of methanol were the highest by using the Cu/ZnO/Al₂O₃ catalyst with copper loading of 5% and the Zn/Cu molar ratio of 1/1, which precursor were not calcined, and reduced at 493 K. The activity of the catalysts increased due to the presence of the CuO/ZnO phase in the oxidized form of impregnation Cu/ZnO/Al₂O₃ catalysts. The active sites of the Cu/ZnO/Al₂O₃ catalyst for methanol synthesis are not only metallic Cu but also special sites such as the Cu–Zn site, i.e. metallic Cu and the Cu–Zn site work cooperatively to catalyze the methanol synthesis reaction.     

Methanol Synthesis

Methanol, like ammonia, is one of the key industrial chemicals produced by heterogeneous catalysis. As with the original ammonia catalyst (Fe/K/Al₂O₃), so with methanol, the original methanol synthesis catalyst, ZnO, was discovered by Alwin Mittasch. This was translated into an industrial process in which methanol was produced from CO/H₂ at 400?°C and 200 atm. Again, as with the ammonia catalyst where the final catalyst which is currently used was achieved only after exhaustive screening of putative “promoters”, so with methanol, exhaustive screening of additives was undertaken to promote the activity of the ZnO. Early successful promoters were Al₂O₃ and Cr₂O₃ which enhanced the stability of the ZnO but not its activity. The addition of CuO was found to increase the activity of the ZnO but the catalyst so produced was short lived. Current methanol synthesis catalysts are fundamentally Cu/ZnO/Al₂O₃, having high CuO contents of?~60?% with ZnO?~?30?% and Al₂O₃?~?10?%. Far from promoting the activity of the ZnO by incorporation of CuO, the active component of these Cu/ZnO/Al₂O₃ catalysts is Cu metal with the ZnO simply being involved as the preferred support. Other supports for the Cu metal, e.g. Al₂O₃, MgO, MnO, Cr₂O₃, ZrO₂ and even SiO₂ can also be used. In all of these catalysts the activity scales with the Cu metal area. The original feed has now changed from CO/H₂ to CO/CO₂/H₂ (10:10:80), radiolabelling studies having provided the unlikely discovery that it is the CO₂ molecule which is hydrogenated to methanol; the CO molecule acts as a reducing agent. The CO₂ is transformed to methanol on the Cu through the intermediacy of an adsorbed formate species. These Cu/ZnO/Al₂O₃ catalysts now operate at?~230° and between 50 and 100 atm. This important step change in the activity of methanol synthesis has resulted in a significant reduction in the energy required to produce methanol. The “step change” however has been incremental. It has been obtained on the basis of fundamental knowledge provided by a combination of surface science techniques, e.g. LEED, scanning tunnelling microscope, TPD, temperature programmed reaction spectroscopy, combined with catalytic mechanistic studies, including radiolabelling studies and chemisorption studies including reactive chemisorption studies, e.g. N₂O reactive frontal chromatography.     

Methylcyclohexane conversion over ZSM-11 zeolite

The effect of various modifiers on the performance of a commercial Cu/ZnO/Al₂O₃ catalyst in methanol synthesis from CO₂/H₂ and CO/H₂ at 523 K and 30 bar has been studied. Several modifiers improved significantly the rate of methanol formation from CO₂/H₂, while all modified catalysts showed decreased rates for the synthesis from CO/H₂ in comparison with the unmodified Cu/ZnO/Al₂O₃ catalyst. The synthesis rates from both CO₂/H₂ and CO/H₂ correlated with the oxygen coverage of copper surface measured after the reaction by N₂O titration.     

CO2 Hydrogenation to Methanol Over Cu/ZnO/Al2O3 Catalysts Prepared by a Novel Gel-Network-Coprecipitation Method

A novel gel-network-coprecipitation process has been developed to prepare ultrafine Cu/ZnO/Al₂O₃ catalysts for methanol synthesis from CO₂ hydrogenation. It is demonstrated that the gel-network-coprecipitation method can allow the preparation of the ultrafine Cu/ZnO/Al₂O₃ catalysts by homogeneous coprecipitation of the metal nitrate salts in the gel network formed by gelatin solution, which makes the metallic copper in the reduced catalyst exist in much smaller crystallite size and exhibit a much higher metallic copper-specific surface area. The effect of the gel concentration of gelatin on the structure, morphology and catalytic properties of the Cu/ZnO/Al₂O₃ catalysts for methanol synthesis from hydrogenation of carbon dioxide was investigated. The Cu/ZnO/Al₂O₃ catalysts prepared by the gel-network-coprecipitation method exhibit a high catalytic activity and selectivity in CO₂ hydrogenation to methanol.     

On the mechanism of methanol synthesis and the water-gas shift reaction on ZnO

Zinc oxide catalyses both methanol synthesis and the forward and ‘everse water-gas shift reaction (f- and r- WGSR). Copper also catalyses both reactions, but at lower temperatures than ZnO. Presently the combination of Cu and ZnO stabilized by Al₂O₃ is the preferred catalyst for methanol synthesis and for the f- and r- WGSR. On Cu, the mechanism of methanol synthesis is by hydrogenation of an adsorbed bidentate formate [1] (the most stable adsorbed species in methanol synthesis), while the f- and r- WGSR proceeds by a redox mechanism. The f-WGSR proceeds by H₂O oxidizing the Cu and CO, reducing the adsorbed oxide and the r-WGSR proceeds by CO₂ oxidising the Cu and H₂, reducing it [2–5]. Here we show that the mechanisms of both reactions are subtly different on ZnO. While methanol is shown to be formed on ZnO through a formate intermediate, it is a monodentate formate species which is the intermediate; the f- and r-WGS reactions also proceed through a formate – a bidentate formate - in sharp contrast to the mechanism on Cu.     

Dehydrogenation of cyclohexanol on Cu–ZnO/SiO2 catalysts: The role of copper species

For the dehydrogenation of cyclohexanol a series of Cu–ZnO/SiO₂ catalysts with various Cu to ZnO molar ratios was prepared using the impregnation method, with the loading of copper fixed at 9.5 at.%. The catalysts were characterized by XPS, H₂–N₂O titration, BET, H₂-TPR, NH₃-TPD and XRD techniques. The results indicate that the addition of ZnO can improve the dispersion of copper species on reduced Cu–ZnO/SiO₂ (CZS) catalysts. Cu⁰ and Cu⁺ species were found on the reduced CZS catalysts surface, and the amount of Cu⁺ increased with the content of ZnO increasing. The addition of ZnO increased the acidity of the CZS catalysts. However, only Cu⁰ species can be found on the reduced Cu/SiO₂ (CS) catalyst surface. According to the reaction results, we found that the selectivity to phenol was related to the amount of Cu⁺ species, the Cu⁺ species should be the active sites for the production of phenol, the Cu⁰ is responsible for cyclohexanol dehydrogenation to cyclohexanone.     

Rideal-type reaction of formate species with alcohol: A key step in new low-temperature methanol synthesis method

In situ diffuse reflectance infrared Fourier transform spectroscopy (DRIFTS) was used to study the reaction mechanism of the formate adsorbed species with ethanol to form the ethyl formate on Cu/ZnO catalyst surface in a novel low-temperature methanol synthesis process. The results indicate that the formate adsorbed species were firstly formed by CO/CO₂/H₂ adsorbed on Cu/ZnO catalyst, followed by rapid reaction with ethanol to form ethyl formate. It was found that the species reacted with formate adsorbed species were ethanol in gas phase rather than adsorbed ethoxy species. The reaction of the adsorbed formate species with ethanol on Cu/ZnO catalyst surface proceeded according to Rideal-type mechanism, not Langmuir–Hinshelwood mechanism.