EvoSite: Evolution-Based Model for Site Layout Planning

Appropriate site layout of temporary facilities is crucial for enhancing the productivity and safety on construction sites. Site layout planning, however, is a complex problem, and researchers have attempted to solve it using a variety of optimization-based and heuristic-based techniques. In this paper, a genetic-algorithm-based model for site layout planning is presented. The advantages of the model stem from three main characteristics: (1) It applies to any user-defined site shape; (2) it accounts for the user preference in the relative closeness among the facilities; and (3) it incorporates a genetic algorithm procedure to search for the optimum layout in a manner that simulates natural evolution. Based on the proposed model, a comprehensive system for site layout planning (EvoSite) is developed. EvoSite uses an intuitive spreadsheet representation of the site and the facilities, and automates the evolution of layout solutions. Details of model development and implementation are described, and an example application is presented to demonstrate the capabilities of the EvoSite system. The advantages, limitations, and future extensions of EvoSite are then discussed.     

Trade-off between Safety and Cost in Planning Construction Site Layouts

Planning construction site layouts involves identifying the positions of temporary facilities on site, and accordingly it has a significant impact on the safety and efficiency of construction operations. Although available models are capable of minimizing the travel cost of resources on site, they do not consider safety as an important and separate objective in the optimization of site layouts. This paper presents the development of an expanded site layout planning model that is capable of maximizing construction safety and minimizing the travel cost of resources on site, simultaneously. The model incorporates newly developed concepts and performance criteria that enable the quantification of construction safety and travel cost of resources on site. The present model is developed in three main phases: (1) formulating decision variables and optimization objectives in this site layout planning problem; (2) identifying and satisfying all practical constraints in this optimization problem; and (3) implementing the model as a multiobjective genetic algorithm. An application example is analyzed to illustrate the use of the model and demonstrate its capabilities in optimizing construction site layouts and generating optimal trade-offs between safety and travel cost of resources on site.     

Dynamic Site Layout Planning Using Approximate Dynamic Programming

Dynamic site layout planning requires identifying and updating the positions of all temporary construction facilities such as offices, storage areas, and workshops over the entire project duration. Existing models do not guarantee global optimal solutions because they focus on optimizing the planning and layout of successive construction stages in a chronological order, without considering the future implications of layout decisions made in early stages. This paper presents the development of an approximate dynamic programming model that is capable of searching for and identifying global optimal dynamic site layout plans. The model applies the concepts of approximate dynamic programming to estimate the future effects of layout decisions in early stages on future decisions in later stages. The model is developed in three main phases: (1) formulating the decision variables, geometric constraints, and objective function of the dynamic site layout planning problem; (2) modeling the problem using approximate dynamic programming; and (3) implementing and evaluating the performance of the model. An evaluation example is analyzed to illustrate the use of the model and demonstrate its capabilities in generating global optimal solution for dynamic site layout planning of construction projects.     

Genetic Algorithm for Optimizing Supply Locations around Tower Crane

Site layout planning is a complicated issue because of the vast number of trades and interrelated planning constraints. To unfold its complexity, this paper aims to confine the study to a particularly defined area of construction: the structural concrete-frame construction stage of public housing projects. In this study, optimization of the tower crane and supply locations is targeted, as they are the major site facilities for high-rise building construction. A site layout genetic algorithm model is developed and a practical example is presented. The optimization results of the example are very promising and demonstrate the application value of the model.     

Genetic Algorithm for Solving Site Layout Problem with Unequal-Size and Constrained Facilities

This paper presents an investigation of the applicability of a genetic approach for solving the construction site layout problem. This problem involves coordinating the use of limited site space to accommodate temporary facilities so that transportation cost of materials is minimized. The layout problem considered in this paper is characterized by affinity weights used to model transportation costs between facilities and by geometric constraints that limit their relative positions on site. The proposed genetic algorithm generates an initial population of layouts through a sequence of mutation operations and evolves the layouts of this population through a sequence of genetic operations aiming at finding an optimal layout. The paper concludes with examples illustrating the strength and limitations of the proposed algorithm in the cases of (1) loosely versus tightly constrained layouts with equal levels of interaction between facilities; (2) loosely versus tightly packed layouts with variable levels of interactions between facilities; and (3) loosely versus tightly constrained layouts. In most problems considered where the total-objects-to-site-area ratio did not exceed 60%, the algorithm returned close to optimal solutions in a reasonable time.     

Comparison of Using Mixed-Integer Programming and Genetic Algorithms for Construction Site Facility Layout Planning

The use of modular construction has gained wide acceptance in the industry. For a specific construction facility layout problem such as site precast standardized modular units, it requires the establishment of an on-site precast yard. Arranging the precast facilities within a construction site presents real challenge to site management. This complex task is further augmented with the involvement of several resources and different transport costs. A genetic algorithm (GA) model was developed for the search of a near-optimal layout solution. Another approach using mixed-integer programming (MIP) has been developed to generate optimal facility layout. These two approaches are applied to solve with an example in this paper to demonstrate that the solution quality of MIP outperforms that of GA. Further, another scenario with additional location constraints can also be solved readily by MIP, which, however, if modeled by GA, the solution process would be complicated. The study has highlighted that MIP can perform better than GA in site facility layout problems in which the site facilities and locations can be represented by a set of integer variables.     

Minimizing Construction-Related Security Risks during Airport Expansion Projects

Airport expansion projects often require the presence of construction personnel, material, and equipment near airport secure areas/facilities, leading to an increase in the level of risk to airport security. Construction planners and airport operators need to carefully study this challenge and implement active measures in order to minimize construction-related security breaches and comply with all relevant Federal Aviation Administration guidelines. This paper presents the development of an advanced multiobjective optimization model for planning airport construction site layouts that is capable of minimizing construction-related security breaches while simultaneously minimizing site layout costs. The model incorporates newly developed criteria and performance metrics that enable evaluating and maximizing the construction-related security level in operating airports. The model is developed using a multiobjective genetic algorithm, and an application example is analyzed to demonstrate the use of the model and its unique capability of generating a wide spectrum of optimal trade-offs between construction-related airport security and site layout costs.     

Conjoining MMAS to GA to Solve Construction Site Layout Planning Problem

An optimal construction site layout planning (CSLP) is vital for project management. It can reduce the transportation flows and thus the costs of a project. Genetic algorithm (GA) is the most used algorithm to solve site layout problems, but randomly generated initial population in GA will decrease solution quality. Max-min ant system (MMAS) can offer a better initial population than the randomly generated initial population at the beginning of GA. In this study, a modified GA (MMAS-GA) formed by conjoining MMAS to the step of initialization of GA is proposed to solve CSLP problems. In order to reveal the computational capability of MMAS-GA to solve CSLP problems, the results of MMAS-GA and traditional GA are compared by solving an equal-area CSLP problem. The results showed that the proposed MMAS-GA algorithm provided a better optimal solution under the objective function of minimizing the transportation flows between the site facilities. The proposed MMAS-GA algorithm could assist project managers and planners to design optimal construction site layout, and thus to reduce construction costs.     

Improvement Algorithm for Limited Space Scheduling

Selecting construction methods, scheduling activities, and planning the use of site space are key to constructing a project efficiently. Site layout and activity scheduling have been tackled as independent problems. Their interdependence is often ignored at the planning stage and may be dealt with—if at all—when construction is underway. Problems that may have had easy solutions if dealt with earlier, may then be expensive to remedy. This paper addresses the combined problem termed “space scheduling” and presents an algorithmic time-space trade-off model for adjusting activity durations and start dates to decrease the need for space over congested time periods. The model characterizes resource space requirements over time and establishes a time-space relationship for each activity in the schedule, based on alternative resource levels. An example illustrates the presented algorithm that generates a feasible space schedule.     

Minimizing Construction-Related Hazards in Airport Expansion Projects

Airport expansion projects often require the presence and movement of construction labor and equipment near critical airport traffic areas. This close proximity between construction activities and airport operations needs to be carefully considered during the planning of construction site layouts in order to minimize and eliminate all potential construction-related hazards to aviation safety. This paper presents the development of a multiobjective optimization model for planning airport construction site layouts that is capable of minimizing construction-related hazards and minimizing site layout costs, simultaneously. The model incorporates newly developed optimization functions and metrics that enable: (1) maximizing the control of hazardous construction debris near airport traffic areas; (2) minimizing site layout costs including the travel cost of construction resources and the cost of debris control measures on airport sites; and (3) satisfying all operational safety constraints required by the federal aviation administration as well as other practical site layout constraints. The model is implemented using a multiobjective genetic algorithm and an application example is analyzed to demonstrate the use of the model and its capabilities in optimizing construction site layouts in airport expansion projects.     

Particle Swarm Optimization for Construction Site Unequal-Area Layout

Layout of temporary facilities on a construction site is essential to enhancing productivity and safety, and is a complex issue due to the unique nature of construction. This paper proposes a particle swarm optimization (PSO)-based methodology to solve the construction site unequal-area facility layout problem. A priority-based particle representation of the candidate solutions to the layout problem is proposed. The particle-represented solution in terms of priorities should be transformed to the specific layout plan with consideration of nonoverlap and geometric constraints. In addition, a modified solution space boundary handling approach is proposed for controlling particle updating with regard to the priority value range. Computational experiments are carried out to justify the efficiency of the proposed method and investigate its underlying performances. This study aims at providing an alternative and effective means for solving the construction site unequal-area layout problem by utilizing the PSO algorithm.     

Optimizing Airport Construction Site Layouts to Minimize Wildlife Hazards

Construction operations in airport expansion projects often attract wildlife species to critical airport traffic areas leading to an increase in the risk of wildlife–aircraft collision accidents. Airport operators and construction planners need to carefully consider and minimize these wildlife hazards during the planning of construction site layouts in order to comply with Federal Aviation Administration recommendations. This paper presents the development of an advanced optimization model for planning airport construction site layouts that is capable of minimizing the hazards of wildlife attractants and minimizing the site layout costs, simultaneously. The model incorporates newly developed concepts and performance criteria that enable (1) quantifying, controlling, and minimizing the hazards of construction-related wildlife attractants near airport traffic areas; and (2) minimizing the travel cost of construction resources and the cost of devices installed to control wildlife on airport construction sites, while complying with all relevant aviation safety constraints. The model is developed using a multiobjective genetic algorithm and an application example is analyzed to demonstrate the use of the model in optimizing airport construction site layouts and its unique capability of generating optimal trade-offs between wildlife control and site layout costs.     

Site Layout Planning using Nonstructural Fuzzy Decision Support System

Site layout planning can affect productivity and is crucial to project success. However, as construction is heterogeneous in the nature of its organizations, project designs, time constraints, environmental effects, etc., site layout planning for each project becomes unique. Affected by many uncertainties (variables) and variations, site layout planning is a typical multiobjective problem. To facilitate the decision-making process for these problems, a nonstructural fuzzy decision support system (NSFDSS) is proposed. NSFDSS integrates both experts’ judgment and computer decision modeling, making it suitable for the appraisal of complicated construction problems. The system allows assessments based on pairwise comparisons of alternatives using semantic operators that can provide a reliable assessment result even under the condition of insufficient precise information.     

Computer-Aided Site Layout Planning

This paper presents an interactive computer-aided site layout model to support site planning in a computer-aided design (CAD) environment and expands upon a model presented earlier by the writers. The developed model performs its task at two levels: Site representation, and site space analysis and allocation. The site representation is carried out using an open architecture supported by object-based concepts. The model offers three tiers of objects: (1) site objects, (2) construction objects, and (3) constraint objects. This structure facilitates the creation of new objects and reuse of domain knowledge, which allows for the gradual expansion and enrichment of the model’s knowledge base. At the space analysis and allocation level, the model introduces a geometric reasoning approach to analyze site space for finding an optimum or near-optimum location for facilities. This feature facilitates easy visualization of the site planning process and encourages user participation. The model is structured in three main modules: Database, Project Module, and Layout Control Module. The functionality of each module, along with their interconnectivity is described. The model is implemented using Visual Basic for Applications in AutoCAD environment and Microsoft Access. A numerical example of an actual site layout is presented to illustrate the functionality of the developed model.     

New Mathematical Optimization Model for Construction Site Layout

Layout of temporary construction facilities (objects) is an important activity during the planning process of construction projects. The construction area layout is a complex problem whose solution requires the use of analytical models. Existing popular models employ genetic algorithms that have proven to be useful tools in generating near optimal site layouts. This paper presents an alternative approach based on mathematical optimization that offers several important features and generates a global optimal solution. The construction area consists of an unavailable area that includes existing facilities (sites) and available area in which the objects can be located. The available area is divided into regions that are formulated using binary variables. The locations of the objects are determined by optimizing an objective function subject to a variety of physical and functional constraints. The objective function minimizes the total weighted distance between the objects and the sites as well as among the objects (if desired). The distance can be expressed as Euclidean or Manhattan distance. Constraints that ensure objects do not overlap are developed. The new approach, which considers a continuous space in locating the objects simultaneously, offers such capabilities as accommodating object adjacency constraints, facility proximity constraints, object–region constraints, flexible orientation of objects, visibility constraints, and nonrectangular objects, regions, and construction areas. Application of the model is illustrated using two examples involving single and multiple objects. The proposed model is efficient and easy to apply, and as such should be of interest to construction engineers and practitioners.     

Genetic Algorithms for Construction Site Layout in Project Planning

Construction site layout is concerned with the existence, positioning, and timing of the temporary facilities that are used to carry out a construction project. Typically these problems are very complicated to formulate and difficult to solve. They are, however, very important to virtually any construction project, since the site layout can significantly affect the cost of the project. This paper describes the general site layout problem from both a theoretical and a practical point of view. It proposes genetic algorithms as a possible solution technique and includes a theoretical example of positioning temporary facilities. This is extended to a practical problem in which the cost of movement is modeled realistically using an augmented genetic algorithm. Some preliminary conclusions are drawn for the application of genetic algorithms to construction site layout problems.     

Nondominated Archiving Multicolony Ant Algorithm in Time–Cost Trade-Off Optimization

Time–cost trade-off analysis is addressed as an important aspect of any construction project planning and control. Nonexistence of a unique solution makes the time–cost trade-off problems very difficult to tackle. As a combinatorial optimization problem one may apply heuristics or mathematical programming techniques to solve time–cost trade-off problems. In this paper, a new multicolony ant algorithm is developed and used to solve the time–cost multiobjective optimization problem. Pareto archiving together with innovative solution exchange strategy are introduced which are highly efficient in developing the Pareto front and set of nondominated solutions in a time–cost optimization problem. An 18-activity time–cost problem is used to evaluate the performance of the proposed algorithm. Results show that the proposed algorithm outperforms the well-known weighted method to develop the nondominated solutions in a combinatorial optimization problem. The paper is more relevant to researchers who are interested in developing new quantitative methods and/or algorithms for managing construction projects.     

Optimization Research: Enhancing the Robustness of Large-Scale Multiobjective Optimization in Construction

Many construction planning problems require optimizing multiple and conflicting project objectives such as minimizing construction time and cost while maximizing safety, quality, and sustainability. To enable the optimization of these construction problems, a number of research studies focused on developing multiobjective optimization algorithms (MOAs). The robustness of these algorithms needs further research to ensure an efficient and effective optimization of large-scale real-life construction problems. This paper presents a review of current research efforts in the field of construction multiobjective optimization and two case studies that illustrate methods for enhancing the robustness of MOAs. The first case study utilizes a multiobjective genetic algorithm (MOGA) and an analytical optimization algorithm to optimize the planning of postdisaster temporary housing projects. The second case study utilizes a MOGA and parallel computing to optimize the planning of construction resource utilization in large-scale infrastructure projects. The paper also presents practical recommendations based on the main findings of the analyzed case studies to enhance the robustness of multiobjective optimization in construction engineering and management.     

KB-GA-Based Hybrid System for Layout Planning of Multistory Buildings

Layout planning of multistory buildings requires multidisciplinary participation in the decision-making process, which is governed by intuition, creativity, and experience of the designers, and available information. Optimization techniques are rarely applied to the layout planning stage. The present study aims at a hybrid approach by combining knowledge based system and a genetic algorithm (GA)-based optimization technique by employing them for suitable tasks, in order to take specific advantages of respective techniques, i.e., the domain dependent part is isolated and developed as a knowledge-based (KB) system, while the knowledge lean part is handled by the adaptive search techniques. The main issue to be addressed while developing an integrated system is to identify the role of individual approaches and the interactions among them. This paper outlines this concept through an integrated hybrid system GALOP for optimal layout planning of multistory office buildings. A multiobjective GA-based optimization technique produces a set of optimal solutions, from which a designer can select the final design.     

On Site Performance Improvement Programs

The paper presents the various phases in a comprehensive On Site Performance Improvement Program (OSPIP) of a medium size construction project which includes: problem identification; data collection; data analysis and planning the change content; planning the change process; and measuring and evaluating the results. Methods, techniques, and means to put the various program phases into practice are examined, and the problems likely to be encountered are discussed. An OSPIP case study of a medium size construction project is described in detail. It deals with production rate, safety, and manpower turnover problems, improvement plans to overcome them, and how implementation was realized in each of the problem areas. The paper suggests that OSPIP in medium size projects is not only economically feasible and worthwhile, but highly recommendable.