Peel Adhesion of Solid Films-The Surface and Bulk Effects

The peel strength of rubber and paint films has been measured over a range of peeling velocities using a dead weight method. At low peel rates the peel force is fairly constant but rises rapidly at higher peeling speeds.

Experiments show that the peel strength is a function both of the energy of interfacial bonds which must be broken as peeling proceeds and of bulk energy losses in a viscoelastic peeling material.

The interfacial effect has two components: an equilibrium surface force which accounts for the peel strength at low velocities, and a viscous peeling force which depends on the peeling rate. This viscous interfacial force explains the increase in peel strength of purely elastic films at higher peeling velocities.

The energy loss in the bulk of the peeling film introduces two additional effects: a magnification of the peel strength in steady peeling over a certain velocity range, and a slowing down or stopping of peeling as transient relaxation occurs shortly after the application of the peel force.     

Interfacial and Bulk Contributions to Peeling Energy

Thin polyurethane films, having low adhesion to dried protein, were developed as candidate materials for non-adhesive surgical dressings. In order to model wound-adhesion, gelatine was cast from solution on to the film and allowed to dry. The film was peeled from the gelatine at 180° peel angle, and the peel force measured as a function of the temperature of test. The dynamic mechanical properties of the films were measured over the range -90°C to 110°C and values of tan δ were determined at the temperatures employed for peeling. Thus, a correlation was obtained between peeling energy and tan δ for each of eight films.

The generalised theory of fracture mechanics states that the adhesive failure energy is given by the product of an interfacial energy term and a “loss function” involving the hysteresis ratio of the material. If the strains are small the hysteresis ratio is proportional to tan δ. The experimental results show excellent agreement with the theory, but the interfacial term turns out to be much greater than the true interfacial energy (or thermo-dynamic work of adhesion). The reason for this result is discussed.     

Effect of Peel Load on Stringiness Phenomena and Peel Speed of Pressure-Sensitive Adhesive Tape

The factors governing interfacial separation in lightly cross-linked polymer adhesives at low pulling rates as demonstrated by their stringiness phenomenon are investigated.

Cohesive failure and adhesive/substrate interfacial separation of uncross-linked polymer adhesives have been adequately explained. However, in lightly cross-linked polymer adhesives, where cohesive failure cannot occur because there is no viscous flow, there are two regions of interfacial separation at low rate and this phemonenon cannot be readily explained by present viscoelastic theories.

Investigation of the stringiness phenomenon of peeling pressure-sensitive adhesive tapes at constant loads shows that two peeling speeds exist for any peeling load up to the vicinity of 200 g/25 mm. Also it is clear that stringiness structure differs greatly at each peeling speed. The stringiness phenomenon of each of these two regions is analyzed using Miyagi's observation apparatus. These two measurements are then reversed and a comparison shows that the two peeling speeds correspond to each steady peeling region.

This field of investigation, when added to the present viscoelastic property studies, should lead to a new peeling adhesive theory which, in turn, may lead to the development of new high peel force pressure-sensitive adhesives.     

Peel Strength of Aluminium-Aluminium Joints Bonded by Adhesive Based on Carboxylated Nitrile Rubber-Chlorobutyl Rubber Blend

The peel strength of aluminium-aluminium joints bonded by an adhesive based on carboxylated nitrile rubber and chlorobutyl rubber was found to depend on surface topography and use of a silane primer. Anodization causes a marginal increase in bond strength while the silane primer improves the adhesive joint strength remarkably.

The peel strength was also found to be dependent on test conditions (test rate and temperature). The threshold peel strength value obtained by measurements at low peel rate and high test temperature was found to depend on the type of failure during peeling (cohesive or interfacial) which, in turn, is controlled by the presence of silica filler in the adhesive. Two different threshold values of peel strength were obtained: 60 N/m for interfacial failure (in silica-filled adhesive), 140 N/m for cohesive failure (in unfilled adhesive).     

Protocols for the Measurement of Adhesive Fracture Toughness by Peel Tests

This article reports on the work of the European Structural Integrity Society Technical Committee 4 (ESIS TC4) and its activities in the development of test protocols for peel fracture. Thirteen laboratories have been working on peel test methods in ESIS TC4 since 1997 and their activities are ongoing.

The aim of the work is to develop robust and credible test methods for the determination of adhesive fracture toughness by peel tests. Several geometric configurations have been used, namely, multi-angle fixed arm peel, T-peel, and roller assisted peel in the form of a mandrel test.

The starting point of their work is an established analysis of a peel method that is often developed from a global energy approach. The adopted analysis is combined with an experimental approach in order to resolve ambiguities in the determination of adhesive fracture toughness (G_A). The test methods involve the measurement of peel strength in order to calculate the total input energy for peel (G) and the calculation of the plastic bending energy (G_P) during peel. The latter is often obtained from a measurement of the tensile behaviour of the peel arm. Adhesive fracture toughness is then G - G_P.

Four ESIS TC4 projects are described. The first relates to fixed arm peel whilst the second and third involve both fixed arm and T-peel. The fourth project combines mandrel peel and fixed arm peel. Each project uses different types of polymeric adhesives in the form of quite different laminate systems. The selection of the laminate system enables all characteristics of laminate property to be embraced, for example, thin and thick adhesive layers, polymeric, and metallic peel arms and a range of flexibility in the laminates.

The development of the enabling science required to establish the test protocols is described and software for conducting all calculations is referenced.     

Relationship Between Viscoelastic and Peeling Properties of Model Adhesives. Part 2. The Interfacial Fracture Domains

The viscoelastic and peeling properties of polybutadiene/tackifying resin compatible blends have been studied in detail. Viscoelastic properties have been described through the variations of the complex shear modulus, G*(w), as a function of frequency, W, and peeling properties through the variations of peeling force (F) as a function of peeling rate (V).

The first paper of this series presented the cohesive fracture domain and the present paper explores the interfacial fracture domain: (i) rubbery interfacial (interfacial 1); (ii) stick-slip; (iii) glassy interfacial (interfacial 2). After a general survey of the properties in the three domains we present a quantitative relationship between the peeling and linear viscoelastic properties as a function of the adhesive formulation, discussing the use of time-temperature equivalence for adhesive properties. The third part of the paper presents the trumpet model of de Gennes describing the crack shape and propagation: starting from a mechanical analysis of the peeling test, it is shown how one may calculate the variations of the peeling force as a function of peeling rate in the various interfacial fracture domains: this model defines a single interfacial fracture criterion which coexists with the cohesive fracture criterion defined earlier, whatever the fracture location.

We present as a conclusion a critical discussion of the relevance and physical meaning of such a criterion and present a new outlook for the modeling and improvement of adhesive formulations.     

Corona-discharge Treatment of Polypropylene films-Effects of Process Parameters

Corona treatment of films, mainly polypropylene (PP)-copolymers, was studied at commercial levels in a 2.7 kVA treater. The films were produced on a flat-film extruder with chill rolls. Degree of treatment was characterized by power of the generator divided by web speed and width of film (m Ws/cm²).

The effectiveness of the treatment was measured in terms of the polar and dispersion components of surface-energy, the peel adhesion of pressure sensitive tape (similar to ASTM Adhesion Ratio) and the peel adhesion of polyurethane adhesives.

The polar component of surface energy is a measure of the effectiveness of corona pretreatment. For a given degree of treatment, the polar surface energy component becomes greater as the film cooling rate increases (and the degree of crystallization falls).

A comparison of homopolymers and copolymers does, however, reveal that even where these have the same density or the same degree of crystallization one cannot count on them having equally-sized polar components.

Peel strengths of pressure-sensitive tapes and polyurethane-bonded patches confirm the influence of cooling conditions on wetting properties.

Contrary to the case for tape adhesion, the polyurethane adhesive strengths reach their maximum value at much lower treatment intensities, i.e. with much lower polar surface energy components, and thus question the validity of the ASTM tests for adhesion properties.     

Adhesion of Plasticized Polyvinyl Butyral) to Glass

A study of safety glass provides a good example of the interplay among the many physical properties involved in “adhesion”, and the relationship between adhesion and performance. This work demonstrates the value of applying known fundamentals to practical problems.

An idealized model of a windshield fracture event is described in terms of interactions among mechanical responses of the interlayer, the fracture characteristics of the glass and the high speed, low angle peel behavior.

Data on the surface energies of glass, polyvinyl butyral) and water show that at thermodynamic equilibrium a stable system comprising glass, water and polyvinyl butyral) phases, an aqueous phase must lie between the glass and PVB.

The potassium salts are shown to be effective because they are deliquescent and give solutions at equilibrium with the water in the PVB at water contents of ∼0.40% or higher. The greater the amount of salt at the interface and the higher the water content of the sheeting during lamination, the thicker the interfacial layer and delamination occurs more readily. This relationship is quantified using a modified form of the Stefan equation.

Data on diffusion of water and salt are shown to be consistent with the amount of salt at the interface required for the observed performance (∼ 3 mg KAc/m²).

Data on electrical resistivity of the interface correlate with peel force and provide convincing support for the hypothesis.     

The Effect of Moisture Content in Epoxy Film Adhesives on their Performance. III: Bulk Properties

Humidity absorbed by epoxy film adhesives during low temperature storage or exposure to atmosphere may result in reversible changes and irreversible modifications. Vacuum treatment may partially remedy the reversible changes. The consequences of vacuum drying are manifested in enhancement of both the peel and shear properties of bonded joints (Part I and Part II of this series of papers) and the thermal, physical and mechanical properties of the bulk adhesive, characterized in the present study.

Experimental results have shown that the bulk properties of structural epoxy based adhesives are highly correlated with the aging processes caused by water absorption in the prepolymerized adhesive. Applying the vacuum process is harmful to fresh unaged adhesive due to devolatization of low molecular species of the film adhesive.

The characterization of bulk properties for the purpose of following the aging and recovery processes is advantageous, since the bulk is independent of geometrical and interfacial effects which dominate in the case of property evaluation of the adhesive in a bonded joint.     

Adhesion of Pure and CaCO3 Filled Latex Films on Poly(ethylene terephthalate)

Adhesion to poly(ethylene terephthalate) of carboxylated styrene-butadiene latex films, filled with calcium carbonate particles, was studied in this work. The acid content (2, 4 or 6 wt%) the degree of crosslinking (25, 50 or 75 wt% of insoluble polymer) of the latex particles, and the percentage of filler (0, 20, 40, 60, 80 or 90wt%) were varied. A peel test at 180° was used.

It was shown that, for the lowest filler percentages (up to 60 wt%), the films were non-porous and adhesion decreased when the peel rate, the percentage of filler, the degree of crosslinking and the acid content increased. Failure was always localized at the film-support interface (except at very low peel rate). At low peel rate, stick-slip was observed. The adhesion lowering can be explained by a decrease of the energy dissipation during peeling due to a reduced mobility of the polymeric chains. At high filler percentage (80 or 90 wt%), the films became porous and the level of adhesion very low. Failure occurred in the bulk of the latex film. The peel rate dependence was reversed; adhesion increased at higher speed. Owing to its marked importance in this system, the mechanism of the stick-slip phenomenon is especially discussed.     

Comparison of Peel Tests for Metal-Polymer Laminates for Aerospace Applications

Standard peel tests for aerospace laminates based on metal-polymer systems, namely floating-roller and climbing-drum peel methods, have been accommodated in a unified theory of peeling. This theory also accommodates more basic peel tests such as T-peel and fixed-arm peel and also newer methods such as mandrel peel. These five methods have been applied to two aerospace laminate systems to critically examine their use in the determination of adhesive strength. The theory has been used to unify the outputs from the tests in terms of adhesive fracture toughness. In this way, the comparative merits of the methods can be commented on.

The validity of the standard methods has been put in doubt because of the absence of a correction for plastic bending energy and also because of the poor conformance of the peel arm to the roller system used in these methods. The unified theory and some measurements of peel-arm curvature help but not completely overcome some of these difficulties.

A further complication that arises in peel is a change in the plane of fracture. This reflects a transition from cohesive fracture in the adhesive to an adhesive fracture at the interfaces among adhesive, primer, and substrate. It is likely that such plane-of-fracture phenomena are intrinsic to evaluation of the laminate and that contemplation of cohesive fracture toughness for the adhesive cannot accommodate such events.     

Adhesion and Failure Mechanisms of a Model Hot Melt Adhesive Bonded to Polypropylene

A model hot melt adhesive (HMA) based on an ethylene/vinyl acetate copolymer (EVA), an Escorez® hydrocarbon tackifier, and a wax has been used to bond together polypropylene (PP) films to give equilibrium bonding. Peel strengths were determined over a broad range of peel rates and test temperatures. Contrary to the peel behavior of joints with simple rubbery adhesives [1], peel strengths with this semi-crystalline adhesive are not rate-temperature superposable, and multiple transitions in failure locus occur. The semi-crystalline structure of the HMA also prevents rate-temperature superposition of its dynamic moduli.

At different test temperatures, the dependence of peel strength on peel rate shows some resemblance to the dependence of the loss tangent of the bulk adhesive on frequency. This is consistent with a previous result [2] that the HMA debonding term. D, varies with the loss tangent of a HMA at the T-peel debonding frequency.

This model HMA, similar to block copolymer/tackifier blends [3], consists of two phases: an EVA-rich and a tackifier-rich phase, in its amorphous region. At a low peel rate of 8.33 × 10^-5 m/s, the peel strength shows a maximum at a temperature that corresponds to the transition temperature of the tackifier-rich phase (T₁). At a higher peel rate of 8.33 × 10^-3 m/s, the peel strength rises with increasing test temperature, but becomes essentially constant at temperature T₁'. It is believed that, to optimize the peel strength of a HMA at ambient temperature, it is advantageous to formulate the EVA polymer (or other semi-crystalline polyolefins) with a compatible tackifier that yields a tackifier-rich phase with a transition temperature (T₁') in the vicinity of room temperature.     

Application of the Island Blister Test for Thin Film Adhesion Measurement

The island blister test has recently been proposed as an adhesion test which allows the peel of thin, well-adhered films without exceeding the tensile strength of the film. The island blister test site is a modification of the standard blister test site, consisting of a suspended membrane of film with an “island” of substrate at the film center. The membrane support and island are secured to a rigid plate and the film is pressurized, peeling the film inward off the island. A model for this inward or “annular” peel indicates that even for systems of good adhesion, peel can be initiated at low enough pressures to prevent film failure by making the center island sufficiently small relative to the size of the film.

We have fabricated island blister test sites using micromachining techniques and have used them to measure the debond energy of polymer films on various substrates. The peel data obtained from these island sites match well to the behavior predicted by a simple fracture mechanics analysis. This paper reports the fabrication of the island test sites, the experimental verification of the test, and the results of application of the test to polyimide films on metallic and polymeric substrates.     

The Adhesively Bonded Aluminium Joint: The Effect of Pretreatment on Durability

The interface in aluminium bonded structures can be revealed by ultramicrotomy and subsequently studied by transmission electron microscopy. By these means, the more usual surface pretreatments encountered, have been characterised in depth.

A similar examination has been effected following exposure of bonded joints (floating roller peel specimens) to 85% relative humidity at 70°C. Although a drop in peel performance is noted over the exposure time, interfacial examination reveals little damage to the adhesive or adherend. Possible mechanisms for bond strength reduction are discussed: subtle undermining of the alumina film and disruption of physico-chemical bonds across the interface. Both are initiated by moisture reaching the alumina film, either passing along the interface itself or travelling through the adhesive matrix. Also considered are the effects of surface pretreatment and “oxide” penetration, by the adhesive, on durability.

The effect of priming the adherend surface prior to bonding, using a heavily strontium chromate filled adhesive primer, is mentioned and its possible influence on durability is briefly discussed.     

Peeling of heterogeneous thin films: Effect of bending stiffness,adhesion energy,and level of heterogeneity

The peeling behaviour of a heterogeneous thin film bonded to a rigid substrate was investigated by using both experiments and finite element modeling. The enhancement in peel force was studied specifically for heterogeneous thin films with periodic stiff and compliant portions along the length. Peel tests with homogeneous thin films (uniform film thickness) showed that the maximum peel force can be observed before the onset of steady state peeling process. Moreover, this maximum peel force was observed to be a function of the bending stiffness of the film and adhesion energy at the film-substrate interface. For the heterogeneous thin films, maximum peel force can be observed either before the onset of steady state or when the peel front traverses from compliant to the stiff portion of the film. The three-dimensional finite element model, based on cohesive zone technique was developed, which provided further insight into the enhancement in peel force. The maximum force was shown to be dependent on the level of heterogeneity in addition to adhesion energy and bending stiffness as was observed with homogeneous films. The improvement in peel force was found to be prevalent at relatively low adhesion energy. This study may be helpful for the better design of homogeneous and heterogeneous thin film-substrate systems having improved bonding strength.     

The Effect of Sodium Ions on the Stability of the Interphase Region of Glass Fibre Reinforced Composites

The single embedded filament fragmentation and the short beam shear strength tests together with angle-resolved X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy (XPS) have been used to investigate the interfacial region of vinyl ester composites reinforced with sized AR-glass fibres, with and without amino and vinyl functional adhesion promoters.

The 7-aminopropyltriethoxysilane (APS) deposit on AR-glass is susceptible to a thermal degradation during post-cure, which has been attributed to a base catalysed equilibration of the siloxane bonds. The functional groups of APS required for resin compatibility were buried beneath the surface layers, contributing to a low bond strength, furthermore, mobile sodium ions existed within the interfacial region. Aqueous extraction prior to fabrication enhanced the composite bond strength by removing the soluble silane oligomers, the sodium ions, and exposing the organo-functional groups for co-reaction with the matrix.

The silane deposit on AR-glass is made hygroscopic by the presence of sodium ions. This increased the equilibrium moisture content of AR-glass composites, and diminished their retained short beam shear strength in contrast to the E-glass control which retained its properties after redrying.     

The Interfacial Bond Strength in Glass Fibre-Polyester Resin Composite Systems

The interfacial bond strength in glass fibre-polyester resin composites has been investigated using various experimental techniques. These included blocks of resin containing fibre (in which, depending on the geometry of the specimen, failure occurs in either a shear or tensile mode) the pullout of a fibre from a disc of resin and a short beam shear test for interlaminar shear strength determination.

Low power optical microscopy and optical retardation measurements of stress induced birefringence were used to detect the difference between intact and debonded fibre resin interfaces. The shear modulus and shear strength of the resin were obtained from torsion tests on cylindrical rods of the resin.

The single fibre shear debonding specimen and the short beam shear test are shown to be the most viable test methods but interpretation of the results is complicated by the various modes of failure possible and by the different stress states which exist in the area of the specimen where debonding starts. Stress concentration factors obtained by finite element analysis and photoelastic analysis have been applied to the results from these tests and the corrected interfacial bond strengths are in close agreement.

The real interfacial bond strengths of well bonded glass-fibre polyester resin systems is shown to be of the order of 70 MN m^-2.     

Physical Considerations in the Development of Pressure-Sensitive Adhesive Sheets

A pressure-sensitive adhesive sheet is a special kind of paper used in non-impact printers which use a heating process to apply toner to paper. As a result, it needs special characteristics that general pressure-sensitive adhesive paper for labels do not require.

One of these characteristics is that the edge of the folded paper used in non-impact printers must not incline after printing. This was done by making the degree of orientation of the fibers in the face stocks and the release liners low.

The other characteristics are that adhesive must not ooze out from the edges during the slitting or guillotining process and that the labels must not come off of the release liner by themselves during the printing process. Ooze characteristics were found to be related to the adhesive coat weight. An adhesive paper with both a high peel strength and lower adhesive coat weight was developed by studying the dynamic viscoelastic properties of adhesives and release layers. The storage modulus of the release layer concerned with the release force was also found to be related to the self-peeling tendency of the labels.

These points were considered during the development of pressure-sensitive adhesive paper used in non-impact printers which use a heating process to apply toner to paper.     

Bonding of Natural Rubber to Steel: Surface Roughness and Interlayer Structure

This paper is concerned with two aspects of the adhesion produced by the vulcanisation bonding of a simple natural rubber (N.R.) compound to mild steel. Adhesion was measured using a 45° peel test.

When the N.R. was bonded, using a proprietary bonding agent (Chemlok 205/220), to 'smooth' steel (acid etched) or to 'rough' steel (phosphated) high values of peel energy (≥ 4.5 kJm^-2), and good environmental resistance to water were obtained, with failure cohesive largely within the rubber. The highest values of peel energy (≈ 7.5 kJm^-2) were associated with a phosphated surface which consisted of plate-like crystals which directed the stresses away from the substrate in a way which produced a failure surface within the rubber which showed extensive tearing and cracking.

The nature of the layer formed in the interfacial region by interaction between bonding system and rubber was investigated using a chlorinated rubber as a 'model compound' representing the adhesive and uncompounded N.R. to represent the rubber. When a blend of the two was heated in air at 150°C, evidence was found of a solid state chemical reaction in which carbonyl groups were incorporated into the blend which became visually homogeneous. Further evidence points to the relevance of this change to adhesion in rubber-to-metal bonding.     

KINETICS OF THE HYDROLYSIS OF ACRYLONITRILE TO ACRYLAMIDE OVER RANEY COPPER

Measurements of the kinetics of the hydrolysis of acrylonitrileover Raney copper catalysts have been made in the temperature range 40 to 100°C in a tubular reactor operated differentially with and without recycle and over concentration ranges of 0-25 weight percent acrylonitrile, 0-35 weight percent acrylamide and 40-99 weight percent water.

For the concentration range 0 to 7 wt. % acrylonitrile and 0 to 7 wt. % acrylamide, data were fitted by an adsorption model of the type

A + K,CA + KCCC and at higher concentrations by the powers law expression

The activation energy for the reaction was found to be 49.2kJmol^-1. Both models showed that the product acrylamide strongly inhibits the reaction.