Experimental evaluation of miniature plate DMAs (mini-plate DMAs) for future ultrafine particle (UFP) sensor network

Two iPhone-sized differential mobility analyzers (DMAs) in the parallel-plate configuration (i.e., mini-plate DMAs) were designed and their performance was calibrated in this study in order to gain the instructive knowledge for the future mini-plate DMA design and to have a well-calibrated mini-plate DMA for the ultrafine particle (UFP) sensor network. The performance of mini-plate DMAs was calibrated using the tandem DMA (TDMA) technique. The experimental transfer functions of prototypes at different particle sizes and under various combinational conditions of aerosol and sheath flow rates were derived from the TDMA data. It is concluded that mini-plate DMAs performed reasonably well for UFP sizing. It was also found that the sizing resolution of mini-plate DMAs is closer to the aerosol-to-sheath flow rate ratio when the percentage of aerosol slit opening in length was increased (relative to the width of aerosol classification zone). A new concept of “effective sheath flow rate” was introduced to better interpret the experimental observation on the area and FWHM (full width at half maximum) data of measured DMA transfer functions. Based on the experimental data, we proposed a modified equation for mini-plate DMAs to better calculate the voltage required to size particles of a given electrical mobility.

Copyright © 2016 American Association for Aerosol Research     

Assessment of a Cylindrical and a Rectangular Plate Differential Mobility Analyzer for Size Fractionation of Nanoparticles at High-Aerosol Flow Rates

An existing differential mobility analyzer (DMA) of cylindrical electrodes and a novel DMA of rectangular plate electrodes are demonstrated for size fractionation of nanoparticles at high-aerosol flow rates in this work. The two DMAs are capable of delivering monodisperse size selected nanoparticles (SMPS σ_g < 1.1) at gas flow rates ranging from 200 slm to 500 slm. At an aerosol flow rate of 200 slm, the maximum attainable particle mean size is of about 20 nm for the cylindrical DMA and of nearly 50 nm for the rectangular plate DMA. The number concentration of the monodisperse nanoparticles delivered by the high-flow DMAs spans from 10⁴ cm^?3 to 10⁶ cm^?3 depending upon the particle mean size and particle size dispersion.

Copyright 2014 American Association for Aerosol Research     

Modification of the TSI 3081 differential mobility analyzer to include three monodisperse outlets: Comparison between experimental and theoretical performance

Differential mobility analyzers (DMAs) are widely used to determine the size of aerosol particles, and to probe their size-dependent physicochemical properties when two are employed in tandem. A limitation of tandem DMA (TDMA) systems is their long measuring cycle when the properties of more than one monodisperse population of particles need to be probed. In this work, we propose a simple modification of the classical cylindrical DMA by including three monodisperse-particle outlets in its central electrode (namely, the 3MO-DMA), with the objective of using it as the first DMA in TDMA systems for reducing their measuring cycle. The performance of the 3MO-DMA at different flow conditions was evaluated using laboratory-generated aerosol particles, and compared with theoretical predictions. The theory predicted accurately (i.e., within 3%) the geometric mean diameters of the three distinct populations, as well as the resolutions of the first and the third outlet, under all experimental conditions. For the second outlet, the resolution was 10% to 74% lower than that predicted theoretically depending on the sheath-to-aerosol flow ratio. Nevertheless, the geometric standard deviation of the monodisperse aerosol from all the outlets was less than 1.09, which is sufficient for using the 3MO-DMA designed and tested in this work as a first DMA to produce a monodisperse aerosol flow containing three distinct particle populations in TDMA systems.

Copyright © 2016 American Association for Aerosol Research     

Accuracy of recovered moments for narrow mobility distributions obtained with commonly used inversion algorithms for mobility size spectrometers

Aerosol mobility size spectrometers are commonly used to measure size distributions of submicrometer aerosol particles. Commonly used data inversion algorithms for these instruments assume that the measured mobility distribution is broad relative to the DMA transfer function. This article theoretically examines errors that are incurred for input distributions of any width with an emphasis on those with mobility widths comparable to that of the DMA's transfer function. Our analysis is valid in the limit of slow scan rates, and is applicable to the interpretation of measurements such as those obtained with tandem differential mobility analyzers as well as broader distributions. The analysis leads to expressions that show the relationship between the inverted number concentration, mean size, and standard deviation and true values of those parameters. For narrow distributions (e.g., for a mobility distribution produced by a DMA with a 1:10 aerosol:sheath air flow ratio) under typical operating conditions, number concentrations and mean mobility obtained with inversion algorithms are accurate to within 0.5% and 1.0%, respectively. This corresponds to mean diameter retrieval errors of 1.0% for large particles and 0.5% for small (kinetic regime) particles. The widths (i.e., relative mobility variance) of the inverted distributions, however, significantly exceed the true values.

Copyright © 2018 American Association for Aerosol Research     

Characterization of the TSI model 3086 differential mobility analyzer for classifying aerosols down to 1 nm

Measurement systems for particle sizing starting at 1 nm are used to bridge the gap between mass spectrometer measurements and traditional aerosol sizing methods, and thus to enable measurement of the complete size distribution from molecules and clusters to large particles. Such a measurement can be made using a scanning mobility particle sizer equipped with a diethylene glycol growth engine (e.g., TSI Model 3777 Nano Enhancer) along with a condensation particle counter, and a differential mobility analyzer (DMA) appropriate for such small sizes. Previous researchers have used high-resolution DMA (HRDMA) and also the TSI Nano-DMA (Model 3085) in such a scanning mobility particle sizer system. In this study, we evaluate the performance of the recently introduced TSI 1 nm-DMA (Model 3086). The transfer function was characterized using 1–2 nm monomobile molecular ion standards. The same measurements were repeated on a TSI Nano-DMA, with good agreement to previously published values. From the measured transfer function, the resolution of each DMA model was determined as a function of particle size and sheath flow rate. Resolution of the TSI 3086 in the 1–2 nm range was 10–25% higher than the TSI 3085. Measured resolutions of the TSI 3086 were 10–20% lower than theoretically predicted values, whereas those of the Model 3085 were 0–10% lower.

Copyright © 2018 TSI Inc.     

Calibration of a particle mass spectrometer using polydispersed aerosol particles

Routine calibrations of online aerosol chemical composition analyzers are important for assessing data quality during field measurements. The combination of a differential mobility analyzer (DMA) and condensation particle counter (CPC) is a reliable, conventional method for calibrations. However, some logistical issues arise, including the use of radioactive material, quality control, and deployment costs. Herein, we propose a new, simple calibration method for a particle mass spectrometer using polydispersed aerosol particles combined with an optical particle sizer. We used a laser-induced incandescence–mass spectrometric analyzer (LII-MS) to test the new method. Polydispersed aerosol particles of selected chemical compounds (ammonium sulfate and potassium nitrate) were generated by an aerosol atomizer. The LII section was used as an optical particle sizer for measuring number/volume size distributions of polydispersed aerosol particles. The calibration of the MS section was performed based on the mass concentrations of polydispersed aerosol particles estimated from the integration of the volume size distributions. The accuracy of the particle sizing for each compound is a key issue and was evaluated by measuring optical pulse height distributions for monodispersed ammonium sulfate and potassium nitrate particles as well as polystyrene latex particles. A comparison of the proposed method with the conventional DMA-CPC method and its potential uncertainties are discussed.

Copyright © 2018 American Association for Aerosol Research     

Determination of the Mean Mobility of Aerosol Nanoparticles Classified by Differential Mobility Analyzers

MonteCarlo simulations of diffusive particle trajectories, as well as Stolzenburg's model calculations, have shown that the mean mobility of the particles classified by a differential mobility analyzer (DMA) at a given applied voltage may differ from the theoretical one inferred from the Knutson–Whitby equation if the particles are withdrawn from the tails of the particle mobility distribution. In this case, the true mean mobility, defined as the mean mobility of the particles classified at the specified voltage, can be precisely measured by a second DMA operating in series with the first one (tandem DMA). However, if particles are extracted from the central part of the distribution, their mobility can be correctly measured with a single DMA. Besides showing the importance of the usage of the tandem DMA technique for accurate measurements of mobility, this article provides an analytical expression which, if the mobility distribution of the polydisperse aerosol fed to the DMA is known, allows an accurate estimation of the true (mean) mobility of the classified particles.

Copyright 2014 American Association for Aerosol Research     

Portable Planar DMA: Development and Tests

A novel high-resolution planar and portable differential mobility analyzer (DMA) has been designed and built (Nano-ID® PMC500, Naneum, Canterbury, UK). Finite element multi-physics numerical modeling was employed to optimize the geometry of the DMA and to find a regime for high resolution within the confines of a portable instrument. The numerical approach for solving the Navier–Stokes equation was verified by comparison of calculated data to experimental values. The PMC500 was calibrated and tested with different monodisperse aerosol challenges. The PMC500 portable DMA is shown to have good sizing accuracy and resolution, similar in performance to commercially available desktop instruments.

Copyright 2014 American Association for Aerosol Research     

Loss processes affecting submicrometer particles in a house heavily affected by road traffic emissions

The fraction of outdoor aerosol that penetrates into indoor environments plays an important role in determining the contribution of outdoor particles to the total lung dose of particles in human exposure. The objective of this study was to investigate the physical processes affecting migration of outdoor traffic particles into indoor environments. Particle number size distributions were measured by a fast mobility particle sizer system in both indoor and outdoor environments of a house located in close proximity to a busy street in Bologna (Italy) in the period February–April 2012. Indoor to outdoor (I/O) ratios for submicron particle number concentrations showed strong dependence on particle size and meteorological conditions. The loss rates of particles due to deposition, coagulation, and evaporation were determined using dynamic mass balance and coagulation models. Higher loss rates were found for small particles (nucleation and Aitken mode) indoors than for larger particles (accumulation mode). The coagulation and evaporation processes made a significant contribution to the loss of traffic nanoparticles indoors, especially during the day time. Application of positive matrix factorization to the indoor and outdoor particle size distributions showed a substantial loss of traffic-generated nucleation mode particles in the indoor environment, with evaporation playing a major role.

Copyright © 2017 American Association for Aerosol Research     

Characterization of a Herrmann-type high-resolution differential mobility analyzer

Aerosol instrument characterization and verification for nanometer-sized particles requires well-established generation and classification instruments. A precise size selection of sub-3-nm charged aerosol particles requires a differential mobility analyzer (DMA), specially designed for the sub-3-nm size range. In this study, a Herrmann-type high-resolution DMA developed at Yale University was characterized in various operation conditions. A relation between sheath flow rate and tetraheptylammonium ion (C₂₈H₆₀N⁺, THA⁺, 1.47 nm, mobility equivalent diameter) was established. The maximum particle size that the DMA was able to classify was 2.9 nm with the highest sheath flow rate of 1427 liters per minute (Lpm), and 6.5 nm with the lowest stable sheath flow rate of 215 Lpm, restricted by the maximum and minimum flow rates provided by our blower. Resolution and transmission of DMA are reported for tetrapropylammonium (C₁₂H₂₈N⁺, TPA⁺, 1.16 nm), THA⁺, and THA₂Br⁺ (1.78 nm) ions measured with two different central electrodes and five different sheath flow rates. The transmission varied between 0.01 and 0.22, and the resolution varied between 10.8 and 51.9, depending on the operation conditions.

Copyright © 2016 American Association for Aerosol Research     

Methodology to quantify the ratio of multiple-to single-charged fractions acquired in aerosol neutralizers

A methodology for the quantification of the ratio of multiple- to single-charged fractions acquired in aerosol neutralizers is presented. These quantities are necessary for an accurate monodisperse calibration of aerosol instrumentation. A tandem Differential Mobility Analyzer (DMA) setup is required, with the second DMA scanning the electrical mobility spectra classified in the first DMA. In contrast to previous studies on the quantification of bipolar charge distribution utilizing tandem DMA schemes, the methodology targets at the direct determination of the multiple- to single-charge fractions and does so through the analysis of the raw signal instead of the inverted size distributions, thus circumventing errors associated with the assumptions in the DMA data inversion. The proposed methodology is employed for the characterization of different types of aerosols commonly employed for instrument calibration. Spherical liquid particles (emery oil and dioctyl sebacate) were found to acquire lower multiple charge fractions than those suggested by the commonly employed regression fits of Wiedensohler, which was published in the year 1988 in the Journal of Aerosol Science (vol. 19, pp. 387–389), but still within the range of values reported in the literature. Diffusion flame soot and spark generated graphite particles, produced by a miniCAST 6203C burner and a PALAS DNP 3000, respectively, exhibited higher fraction of multiple charges, in good agreement with previous work on agglomerates. The use of a soft X-ray bipolar charger (TSI 3088) yielded systematically higher multiple fractions of positive charges compared to a ⁸⁵Kr neutralizer (TSI 3077A), confirming the importance of direct photoionization charging on the former.

Copyright © 2016 American Association for Aerosol Research     

Influence of surfactants on growth of individual aqueous coarse mode aerosol particles

Understanding the links between aerosol and cloud and radiative properties remains a large uncertainty in predicting Earth's changing energy budget. Surfactants are observed in ambient atmospheric aerosol particles, and their effect on cloud droplet growth is a mechanism that was, until recently, neglected in model calculations of particle activation and droplet growth. In this study, coarse mode aqueous aerosol particles were created containing the surfactant Igepal CA-630 and NaCl. The evaporation and condensation of these individual aqueous particles were investigated using an aerosol optical trap combined with Raman spectroscopy. For a relative humidity (RH) change from 70% to 80%, droplets containing both Igepal and NaCl at atmospheric concentrations exhibited on average more than 4% larger changes in droplet radii, compared to droplets containing NaCl only. This indicates enhanced water uptake in the presence of surfactants, but this result is unexpected based on the standard calculation of the effect of surfactants, using surface tension reduction and/or hygroscopicity changes, for particles of this size. One implication of these results is that in periods with increasing RH, surfactant-containing aqueous particles may grow larger than similarly sized aqueous NaCl particles without surfactants, thus shifting atmospheric particle size distributions, influencing particle growth, and affecting aerosol loading, visibility, and radiative forcing.

Copyright © 2018 American Association for Aerosol Research     

Numerical modeling of the performance of high flow DMAs to classify sub-2 nm particles

While there are several computational studies on differential mobility analyzers (DMA), there is none for high flow DMA to classify nanoparticles less than 3?nm. A specific design of a high flow DMA, a half mini DMA, is investigated to predict its performance through numerical modeling in the incompressible flow regime. The governing equations for flow field, electric field and aerosol transport are solved using COMSOL 5.3. The transfer function of the half mini DMA is compared with that of a nano DMA (TSI 3085). The results show that both the height of the transfer function and resolution (R) of the half mini DMA are much better than those of nano DMA in sub-2?nm particle size range. Finally, the transfer function of half mini DMA is evaluated for different values of aerosol flow rate to the sheath flow rate (q/Q). Comparison of the simulated transfer function with existing models from Knutson–Whitby and Stolzenburg is also elucidated. It is found that the former model overestimates the resolution; whereas the latter is close to the simulation results for q/Q above 0.067. This work provides a useful method to study the flow regimes and transfer function of a high flow DMA.

Copyright © 2018 American Association for Aerosol Research     

An integrative model for the filtration efficiencies in realistic tests with consideration of the filtration velocity profile and challenging particle size distribution

Many well-established models can be applied to calculate the filtration efficiencies. In these models the filtration velocity and challenging particle size are assumed to be known accurately. However, in realistic filtration tests, the filtration velocity has profiles dependent on the filter holder geometry and experimental conditions; the challenging particles have size distributions dependent on the instruments and operation conditions. These factors can potentially affect the measured filtration efficiency and lead to discrepancies with the models.

This study aims to develop an integrative model to predict the filtration efficiencies in realistic tests by incorporating the effects of the filtration velocity profile and challenging particle size distribution classified by a differential mobility analyzer (DMA) into the existing filtration models. Face velocity profile is modeled with fluid mechanics simulations; the initial generated particle size distribution, the particle charging status and the DMA transfer function are modeled to obtain the challenging particle size distribution. These results are then fed into the filtration models. Simulated results are compared with experimental ones to verify the model accuracy. This model can be used to reduce filtration test artifacts and to improve the experimental procedure.

The results reveal that the face velocity upstream the filter exhibits high degree of homogeneity not affecting the filtration efficiency if the filter pressure drop is not very low. The generated particle size distribution and the DMA selection size window could influence the challenging particle size distribution and therefore the measured filtration efficiency.

Copyright © 2017 American Association for Aerosol Research     

Charge distribution uncertainty in differential mobility analysis of aerosols

The inference of particle size distributions from differential mobility analyzer (DMA) data requires knowledge of the charge distribution on the particles being measured. The charge distribution produced by a bipolar aerosol charger depends on the properties of the ions produced in the charger, and on the kinetics of charge transfer from molecular ions or ion clusters to the particles. A single parameterization of a theoretically predicted charge distribution is employed in most DMA analyses regardless of the atmospheric conditions being probed. Deviations of the actual charge distribution from that assumed in the data analysis will bias the estimated particle size distribution. We examine these potential biases by modeling measurements and data inversion using charge distributions calculated for a range of atmospheric conditions. Moreover, simulations were performed using the ion-to-particle flux coefficients predicted for a range of properties of both the particles and ions. To probe the biases over the full range of particle sizes, the measurements were simulated through an atmospheric new particle formation event. The differences between the actual charge distribution and that according to the commonly used parametrization resulted in biases as large as a factor of 5 for nucleation-mode particles, and up to 80% for larger particles. Incorrect estimates of the relative permittivity of the particles or not accounting for the temperature and pressure effects for measurements at 10 km altitude produced biases in excess of 50%; three-fold biases result from erroneous estimates of the ion mobility distribution. We further report on the effects of the relative permittivity of the ions, the relative concentrations of negative and positive ions, and truncation of the number of charge states considered in the inversion.

Copyright © 2017 American Association for Aerosol Research     

Intercomparison of a portable and two stationary mobility particle sizers for nanoscale aerosol measurements

During occupational exposure studies, the use of conventional scanning mobility particle sizers (SMPS) provides high quality data but may convey transport and application limitations. New instruments aiming to overcome these limitations are being currently developed. The purpose of the present study was to compare the performance of the novel portable NanoScan SMPS TSI 3910 with that of two stationary SMPS instruments and one ultrafine condensation particle counter (UCPC) in a controlled atmosphere and for different particle types and concentrations.

The results show that NanoScan tends to overestimate particle number concentrations with regard to the UCPC, particularly for agglomerated particles (ZnO, spark generated soot and diesel soot particles) with relative differences >20%. The best agreements between the internal reference values and measured number concentrations were obtained when measuring compact and spherical particles (NaCl and DEHS particles). With regard to particle diameter (modal size), results from NanoScan were comparable < [± 20%] to those measured by SMPSs for most of the aerosols measured.

The findings of this study show that mobility particle sizers using unipolar and bipolar charging may be affected differently by particle size, morphologies, particle composition and concentration. While the sizing accuracy of the NanoScan SMPS was mostly within ±25%, it may miscount total particle number concentration by more than 50% (especially for agglomerated particles), thus making it unsuitable for occupational exposure assessments where high degree of accuracy is required (e.g., in tier 3). However, can be a useful instrument to obtain an estimate of the aerosol size distribution in indoor and workplace air, e.g., in tier 2.     

Sampling and dilution of nanoparticles at high temperature

Sampling and dilution of flame-generated, fractal-like ZrO₂ aerosols is investigated by aerosol mass/mobility measurements and microscopy. Two broadly used sampler configurations, a straight-tube (ST) and a hole-in-a-tube (HiaT), at three different in-flow orientations and hole diameters are evaluated. The mobility size distributions, mass-mobility exponent, D_fm, prefactor, k_fm, and average primary particle diameter are obtained at 10–60 cm height above the burner (HAB) of fuel-rich (hot) and fuel-lean (cold) spray flames by differential mobility analyzer (DMA) and aerosol particle mass (APM) measurements using a recent power law for fractal-like particles. The primary particle diameter, agglomerate size distributions, and corresponding standard deviations from aerosol measurements are compared to those by counting images of particles collected by thermophoretic sampling along the flame centerline. Once new particle formation is completed in the flame, both sampler configurations result in nearly identical particle size distributions. Furthermore, all HiaT samplers result in similar mobility size distributions at all orientations, regardless of hole size. Sampling using a downstream in-flow hole orientation results in slightly larger Sauter mean diameters than those obtained by upstream or sidestream ones, especially for the cold flame. Additionally, a correlation is developed by Discrete Element Modeling (DEM) for the agglomerate D_fm evolution to its asymptotic value of 2.2 as function of the average number of primary particles per agglomerate, n_va, or the relative particle density with pre-exponential constant k_fm = 1.18, regardless of primary particle size. This is in good agreement with an experimentally obtained correlation in terms of relative particle density as well as with experimental data for ZrO₂, Ag, and Cu nanoparticles.

© 2016 American Association for Aerosol Research     

A water-based fast integrated mobility spectrometer (WFIMS) with enhanced dynamic size range

A water-based fast integrated mobility spectrometer (WFIMS) with enhanced dynamic size range is developed. The WFIMS builds on two established technologies: the fast integrated mobility spectrometer and laminar flow water-based condensation methodology. Inside WFIMS, particles of differing electrical mobility are separated in a drift tube and subsequently enlarged through water condensation. Particle size and concentration are measured via digital imaging at a frame rate of 10 Hz. By measuring particles of different mobilities simultaneously, the WFIMS resolves particle diameters ranging from 8 to 580 nm within 1 s or less. The performance of WFIMS was characterized with differential mobility analyzer (DMA) classified (NH₄)₂SO₂ particles with diameters ranging from 8 to 265 nm. The mean particle diameters measured by WFIMS were found to be in excellent agreement with DMA centroid diameters. Furthermore, detection efficiency of WFIMS was characterized using a condensation particle counter as a reference and is nearly 100% for particles with diameter greater than 8 nm. In general, measured and simulated WFIMS mobility resolutions are in good agreement. However, some deviations are observed at low particle mobilities, likely due to the non-idealities of the WFIMS electric field.

Copyright © 2017 American Association for Aerosol Research     

Evaporation rate of particles in the vaporizer of the Aerodyne aerosol mass spectrometer

We present calculations for evaporation rates of particles collected on the vaporizer of the Aerodyne aerosol mass spectrometer (AMS). These calculations provide insight on certain observed phenomena associated with the size-resolved mass spectrum (MS), because the time width of the MS signal from a particle can be limited by its evaporation rate upon contact with the vaporizer. We show that the counterintuitive weak dependence of observed MS signal widths (evaporation rates) on particle volatility is due to suppression of evaporation rates induced by latent heat release, which is more prominent at high volatilities. The same physics is responsible for the observed diminishing returns associated with increasing the vaporizer temperature to achieve narrower single particle pulses. We also show that the vaporizer typical operating temperature of 600°C is sufficient to evaporate extremely low volatility organic compounds (ELVOCs) rapidly enough to obtain reliable measurements for particles smaller than approximately 600 nm. However, the sizing resolution is compromised for large (near-micron) sizes regardless of particle volatility. Finally, our calculations indicate that the observed delayed particle signals, which lead to an artificial tail in AMS mass distributions, are not due to slow evaporation of particles deposited on a surface with lower temperature than the vaporizer, but particles bouncing in the ionizer cage and finally depositing on the vaporizer.

Copyright © 2017 American Association for Aerosol Research     

Performance Evaluation of the Brechtel Mfg. Humidified Tandem Differential Mobility Analyzer (BMI HTDMA) for Studying Hygroscopic Properties of Aerosol Particles

The Tandem Differential Mobility Analyzer (TDMA) technique coupled with aerosol humidification has been widely used for studying aerosol hygroscopicity. In this study, we evaluate the performance of a commercial Humidified TDMA (BMI HTDMA, Model 3002) with respect to DMA sizing, relative humidity (RH) control, and growth factor (GF) measurements. Unique features of this particular HTDMA include a diffusion-based particle humidifier, a DMA design allowing selection of particles up to 2 μm diameter at only 5600 volts, and the ability to study the complete deliquescence and efflorescence cycle. The sizing agreement between DMA 1 and 2 was within 2% over the 35 to 500 nm diameter range. The measured TDMA responses agreed well with theoretical calculations. The RH control and stability were tested at a suburban field site in Hong Kong. The system achieved RH equilibrium in less than 4 min when changing the RH set point. With indoor temperature changes of less than 1°C per hour, the RH control of the system was very stable at 90%, within 1% RH deviation, as confirmed by GF measurements on ammonium sulfate (AS) aerosols performed on separate days. The hygroscopic properties of various pure aerosols were examined and the results agreed well with model predictions. The application of the BMI HTDMA for field measurements was also demonstrated. Two modes were resolved from the GF distributions at 90% RH and variable hygroscopic growth with changing RH was observed.

Copyright 2014 American Association for Aerosol Research