Influence of Electrical Stimulation, Cooling Rates and Aging on the Shear Force Values of Chilled Lamb

An investigation using high voltage (800 VRMS, 1140 V peak at 14.3 Hz) electrical stimulation (ES) showed that lambs should be stimulated within 30 min of slaughter for 60–120 sec for maximum effect on Warner-Bratzler shear force values. Shear force values of lamb muscles chilled at different rates were significantly (P<0.001) reduced by ES, compared with nonstimulated controls. However, aging at temperatures between 0° and 9°C, for only 2–3 days, educed shear force values of nonstimulated lamb subjected to moderate chilling rates to those of ES samples at 1 day postmortem. Increasing aging temperature significantly (P<0.001) increased aging rate but duration of aging had the greater effect.     

The influence of temperature on shortening and rigor onset in beef muscle

At sufficient ATP concentration and temperatures below about 15°C, pre-rigor beef muscles (neck muscles) contract; this phenomenon is known as cold shortening. There is also a contracture at higher temperatures occurring just before rigor onset which is called rigor shortening. While rigor shortening starts in neck muscles at pH around 6·3–6·0 and at about 2 μMol ATP/g muscle, cold shortening can begin at pH around 7·0 and the full ATP concentration (4 μMol ATP/g) in the muscle. Shortening can take place as long as there is no irreversible formation of the actomyosin complex in the muscle, i.e. before rigor onset occurs, which can be measured by intermittent loading of the muscle. The degree of extensibility which follows starts to decrease at the moment of rigor onset. This irreversible loss of extensibility at temperatures between the freezing point (?1°C) and physiological temperatures (38°C) starts at various pH values and ATP concentrations in the muscle. At 38°C the rigor onset occurs at pH 6·25 and about 2 μMol ATP/g muscle, dropping at 15°C to pH 5·75 and 1 μMol ATP/g muscle. At 0°C, as at all temperatures below 10°C, the loss of extensibility at medium loads (about 250 g/cm²) begins shortly after cold shortening. This loss of extensibility is reversible by increasing the load or raising the temperature. The irreversible loss, or rigor onset, however, occurs at 0°C with pH of 6·1–6·2 and 1·8–2·0 μMol ATP/g muscle. Thus, the onset of rigor is influenced by more than one factor. Temperature, pH and ATP concentration each play a rôle.Maximum loss of extensibility or completion of rigor is reached between 10°C and 38°C at pH 5·5–5·6 and less than 0·5 μMol ATP/g muscle. At 0°C the completion of rigor takes place at pH 6·0, but still at 0·5 μMol ATP/g muscle. The latter fact shows that the completion of rigor is solely dependent on the ATP concentration in the muscle; nevertheless, the pH of rigor completion is higher in the extreme cold shortening range. This is apparently due to a different pH/ATP relationship in muscles at low temperatures.The results are discussed in terms of changes in the concentration of Ca²⁺ ions and ATP.The results are of particular interest for the handling of hot-boned meat; that is, for both the cooling of pre-rigor muscle and the use of hot-boned meat for processing.     

Effect of Electrical Stimulation on the Tenderization of Mutton by Aging

The effect of high voltage electrical stimulation (800V RMS, 10 ms pulse width, 14.3 Hz for 90 sec) on the tenderization due to aging of meat at 0— 1°C has been studied by obtaining Warner-Bratzler shear force deformation curves of cooked longissimus dorsi and semimembranosus muscles from young and old sheep. For muscles restrained from myofibrillar shortening stimulation did not result in any significant improvement in shear parameters nor was the aging process affected. For muscles able to shorten, stimulation produced a substantial reduction in shear force values to the level obtained for restrained muscle. Shear force measurements on samples pressure-heat treated, to minimize myofibrillar strength, indicated that major structural changes in connective tissue, due to electrical stimulation, were unlikely.     

The influence of high temperature, type of muscle and electrical stimulation on the course of rigor, ageing and tenderness of beef muscles

The course of rigor mortis (rigor), ageing and tenderness has been evaluated for three beef muscles; M. biceps femoris (BF), M. semimembranosus (SM) and M. semitendinosus (ST), when entering rigor at constant temperatures of 15 and 37°C respectively, with and without electrical stimulation (ES/NS) (85 V, 14 Hz and 32 s). The course of post-mortem changes has been registered by isometric tension, by shortening of unrestrained muscle strips and by following the pH decline and the changes in metabolites, such as ATP and CP. Ageing at +4°C was recorded by measuring Warner-Bratzler (W-B) shear values 2, 8 and 15 days post mortem. On the last occasion, the sensory properties of the cooked meat were also evaluated. Maximum shortening and isometric tension were higher at 37°C as compared to 15°C, whereas ES did not reduce rigor shortening. A high correlation between maximum shortening and the ATP-level at the onset of the shortening rapid phase was found (r = 0·77(???)), which could explain the greater shortening obtained at 37°C compared to 15°C. Rigor shortening is an important phenomenon governing meat tenderness as tenderness is highly affected by rigor temperature but not by ES. This was the case for muscles SM and ST but not for BF muscle. Even though tenderness was measured after ageing (15 days post mortem), shortening during rigor seems to be more important for toughness when rigor mortis occurs at 37°C than any suggested tenderizing effect due to increased proteolysis in this temperature region.     

Effect of muscle restraint on sheep meat tenderness with rigor mortis at 18°C

The effect on shear force of skeletal restraint and removing muscles from lamb m. longissimus thoracis et lumborum (LT) immediately after slaughter and electrical stimulation was undertaken at a rigor temperature of 18°C (n=15). The temperature of 18°C was achieved through chilling of electrically stimulated sheep carcasses in air at 12°C, air flow 1-1.5 ms(-2). In other groups, the muscle was removed at 2.5 h post-mortem and either wrapped or left non-wrapped before being placed back on the carcass to follow carcass cooling regimes. Following rigor mortis, the meat was aged for 0, 16, 40 and 65 h at 15°C and frozen. For the non-stimulated samples, the meat was aged for 0, 12, 36 and 60 h before being frozen. The frozen meat was cooked to 75°C in an 85°C water bath and shear force values obtained from a 1 × 1 cm cross-section. Commencement of ageing was considered to take place at rigor mortis and this was taken as zero aged meat. There were no significant differences in the rate of tenderisation and initial shear force for all treatments. The 23% cook loss was similar for all wrapped and non-wrapped situations and the values decreased slightly with longer ageing durations. Wrapping was shown to mimic meat left intact on the carcass, as it prevented significant prerigor shortening. Such techniques allows muscles to be removed and placed in a controlled temperature environment to enable precise studies of ageing processes.     

Some Effects on the Mechanical Properties of Meat Produced by Cooking at Temperatures between 50° and 60°C

Peak force (PF) shear values obtained for stretched muscles from beef animals of three ages (2–3 months, 2–6 year and 12–17 years) decreased when heated for 1 hr at temperatures above 50°, 55° and 60°C respectively. PF values obtained for veal muscles were unaffected by heating at 50°C for up to 8 hr but rapidly decreased with increased time of heating at 55° or 60°C. The decrease in shear values with heating time was still evident after the connective tissue contribution was eliminated by a further cook at 80°C. Samples from the oldest animals required 24–48 hr at 60°C to produce a large decrease in the connective tissue contribution. Tenderization by prolonged cooking at 50–60°C was achieved by accelerated aging of the myofibrillar structure and, at ≥ 55°C, by a weakening of the collagenous connective tissue also.     

Pre-slaughter stress arising from on-farm handling and its interactions with electrical stimulation on tenderness of lambs

The effect of electrical stimulation of lamb carcasses (n=269) or its absence (n=257) on shear force of m. longissimus thoracis et lumborum (LT) was monitored during ageing in pasture-fed merino lambs (n=526). The lambs were slaughtered on four different days allowing durations of between one to 10 days of recovery from pre-slaughter handling (yarding, weighing and crutching) that affected ultimate pH (pH(u)). The right LT was removed 20-40min post-slaughter, tightly-wrapped in cling film (prevents the muscle cross-section increasing and thus minimising shortening) and rapidly cooled to 15°C to enter rigor mortis and age. At 0, 4, 24 and 72h post-slaughter, pH measurements and samples for shear force measurement were taken. Pre-slaughter handling had a significant negative effect on pH(u) and several days recovery were required for pH(u) to reach values associated with optimal meat quality as reflected by pH(u). Lambs with one and three days recovery (no significant difference between them) had a pH(u)>5.7 in 50% of the muscles and 19.4%>pH(u) 5.8. Whereas, in lambs with 8-10 days recovery (no significant difference between them), only 8% had a pH(u)>5.7 and 3.1%>pH(u) 5.8. Within each slaughter day electrically stimulated lambs were always more tender than non-stimulated lambs. For non-stimulated muscles at 72h, shear force values >40N occurred for 11.2% of the muscles: for electrically stimulated muscles at 72h, shear force values >40N occurred for 1.9% of the muscles. The rates of tenderisation were slower for intermediate pH(u) values resulting in higher shear force values at all ageing durations. With ageing at 72h for intermediate pH(u), non-stimulated muscles (n=38) 17.64% were >40N and for stimulated muscles (n=34), 7.9% were >40N.     

Changes in the Tenderness of Meat Cooked at 50–65°C

Warner-Bratzler (WB) shear force values obtained for stretched veal muscles decreased as cooking temperatures were increased from 50 to 60°C. Increased proteolytic enzyme activity at these temperatures to give accelerated aging did not appear to explain the effects since there was still a substantial decrease in shear force with increase in cooking temperature from 50 to 60°C, even when well aged (7 wk at 5–6°C) meat and meat cooked for 24 hr was used. A more likely explanation was that, even at these relatively low temperatures, changes in connective tissue were involved since (a) the magnitude and direction of the change in shear force with increasing temperature was dependent on animal age and cooking time; (b) the effect of recooking at 80°C was dependent on animal age; and (c) the effects of increasing the cooking temperature and/or time on adhesion between the meat fibres was significantly greater for the samples from the younger animals.     

High and low rigor temperature effects on sheep meat tenderness and ageing

Immediately after electrical stimulation, the paired m. longissimus thoracis et lumborum (LT) of 40 sheep were boned out and wrapped tightly with a polyethylene cling film. One of the paired LT's was chilled in 15°C air to reach a rigor mortis (rigor) temperature of 18°C and the other side was placed in a water bath at 35°C and achieved rigor at this temperature. Wrapping reduced rigor shortening and mimicked meat left on the carcass. After rigor, the meat was aged at 15°C for 0, 8, 26 and 72 h and then frozen. The frozen meat was cooked to 75°C in an 85°C water bath and shear force values obtained from a 1×1 cm cross-section. The shear force values of meat for 18 and 35°C rigor were similar at zero ageing, but as ageing progressed, the 18 rigor meat aged faster and became more tender than meat that went into rigor at 35°C (P<0.001). The mean sarcomere length values of meat samples for 18 and 35°C rigor at each ageing time were significantly different (P<0.001), the samples at 35°C being shorter. When the short sarcomere length values and corresponding shear force values were removed for further data analysis, the shear force values for the 35°C rigor were still significantly greater. Thus the toughness of 35°C meat was not a consequence of muscle shortening and appears to be due to both a faster rate of tenderisation and the meat tenderising to a greater extent at the lower temperature. The cook loss at 35°C rigor (30.5%) was greater than that at 18°C rigor (28.4%) (P<0.01) and the colour Hunter L values were higher at 35°C (P<0.01) compared with 18°C, but there were no significant differences in a or b values.     

Effects of Electrical Stimulation, Aging, and Blade Tenderization on Hot-Boned Beef Psoas major and Triceps brachii Muscles

Forty-six steer carcasses were used to evaluate shear force values (SFV) for triceps brachii (TB) and psoas major (PM) muscles from sides assigned to three treatments: (1) chilled at 2–4°C for 48 hr (C); (2) hot boned 2 hr postmortem (HB); and (3) electrically stimulated 1 hr postmortem and hot boned 2 hr postmortem (ESHB). Some steaks were cut and frozen immediately after muscle excision or after 6 days of aging, and some were blade tenderized. HB and ESHB steaks had equal or smaller SFV relative to C after aging the TB and PM muscles; however, this was not true when TB steaks were cut after muscle excision. Electrical stimulation or blade tenderization did not improve HB.     

Effect of rigor temperature on muscle shortening and tenderisation of restrained and unrestrained beef m. longissimus thoracicus et lumborum

Pairs of muscularis longissimus thoracicus et lumborum (LTL) from young bulls were removed within 1h of slaughter. Small portions of the muscles were placed in a rigormeter to continously follow the isometric tension and isotonic shortening developed, at constant temperatures of 15, 20, 25, 30 and 35°C, as the muscle went into rigor. The bulk LTL was placed in water baths at the same temperature. One of the bulk pairs was tightly restrained by wrapping, to reduce muscle shortening, the other was unrestrained free to shorten. For the bulk samples, shear values were measured using a Warner-Bratzler instrument (1, 7 and 14 days post mortem), and sensory attributes were measured using a sensory panel (7 and 14 days post mortem). Minimum tension and shortening occurred at 15°C. The activation energy for the muscle shortening process was larger than for the isometric tension process. This indicates that the isometric tension data, collected during rigor, does not solely reflect muscle shortening. Thus, a counteracting process that decreases the tension response, most likely ageing is simultaneously detected. Meat that went into rigor at 15°C had least shortening and was always more tender than meat going into rigor at higher temperatures. For meat entering rigor at temperatures higher than 15°C, restraining of the muscle by wrapping, significantly (p<0.05) decreased the amount of muscle shortening and resulted in an improved meat tenderness (p<0.001). It was also observed that at rigor temperatures higher than 15°C the meat tenderness is affected negatively by a reduced ageing capacity. It therefore appears that muscle shortening and enzyme activity both affect tenderness and that both are highly affected by rigor temperature and have the greatest beneficial effect at a rigor temperature of 15°C.     

The protective effect of electrical stimulation and wrapping on beef tenderness at high pre rigor temperatures

A three factorial experimental design involving electrical stimulation (ES/NES), wrapping (wrapped/unwrapped) and pre rigor temperature (15 °C or 35 °C) was applied to 70 beef M. longissimus lumborum muscles to obtain a wide variation in shear force and drip loss. The shear force of all treatment groups decreased during ageing. As anticipated, wrapping and electrical stimulation had positive effects on shear force. However, high pre rigor temperature (35 °C) did not result in higher shear force values if the muscles were electrically stimulated, wrapped or both. The results suggested that electrical stimulation protects against the negative effects of high pre rigor temperatures. The drip loss of all treatment groups increased during ageing in a manner that was unrelated to treatment but was correlated to tenderness (r² = 0.70; p < 0.0001). It was concluded that the application of electrical stimulation, whatever the pre rigor temperature, protects beef from toughening through the prevention of rigor shortening and the avoidance of inhibition of ageing enzymes.     

rigor mortis in beef sternomandibularis muscle at 37°c

Beef Sternomandibularis muscle, restrained from shortening, was more tender if it entered rigor at 37°C than at 15°C. Raising the pre-rigor holding temperature of unrestrained muscle above 15°C resulted in progressively greater shortening above 28°C, and greater tenderness, particularly between 34 and 37°C. Muscles allowed to shorten during rigor at 37°C were actually more tender than if restrained. In M. rectus abdominis, the muscles shortened at 37°C were a little tougher, but much less so than the degree of shortening would indicate. A study of the time course of tenderness changes, and other evidence, indicated that these effects were not due to ageing. Muscles which went into rigor at 37°C showed a slightly higher cooking loss than the 15°C controls and were softer, and usually paler in colour. There was an increased tendency of fibres to slip over each other. Loading experiments with raw muscle strips showed that where rigor occurred at 37°C, the strips yielded and “flowed” at lower loads than the 15°C controls. The various physical changes described indicate that rigor at 37°C differs considerably from rigor at lower temperatures. Some of the changes appear to be a mild form of the “pale soft exudative” condition seen in pork.     

Influence of Postmortem Changes in Bovine Muscle on the Water-Holding Capacity of Beef. Postmortem Storage of Muscle at Various Temperatures Between 0 and 30°C

Bovine neck muscles were incubated between 0° and 30°C soon after slaughter. At different times postmortem biochemical and physical parameters and cooking loss in homogenates with or without salt were measured. The rate of pH fall in muscle depends on the incubation temperature. At 0.5°C the pH drops fast at first, leveling off afterwards but between 7° and 14°C there is an initial lag period of 2-3 hr. At 30°C no lag phase occurs. The increased rate of postmortem metabolism at 0.5°C is accompanied by cold shortening which occurs before onset of rigor and is followed by little rigor shortening. Above 16°C rigor shortening increases with rising temperature without prerigor contraction. Neither shortening nor development of rigor have an immediate influence of WHC of muscle and unsalted muscle homogenates; the small decrease of WHC postmortem is due to pH fall only and independent of temperature. Salted homogenates prepared from muscles at different time postmortem show above pH 6.0 a similar relationship between pH and WHC. At the onset of rigor mortis (pH 5.9), however, the WHC of the salted homogenate decreases strongly. The practical consequences of these results with regard to processing of beef are discussed.     

Effects of rigor temperature and electrical stimulation on venison quality

The effects of rigor temperature and electrical stimulation on venison quality were assessed using venison longissimus dorsi muscle. In the first trial, effect of rigor temperature (0, 15, 25, 30, 35 and 42 °C) and time post-mortem (at rigor, 3, 7 and 14 days) on drip and cooking losses, % expressible water (water holding capacity, WHC), sarcomere length, protein solubility, meat tenderness and colour were investigated. In the second trial, the effects of rigor temperature (15 and 35 °C), electric stimulation (stimulated or not stimulated) and time (at rigor, 3 and 6 weeks post-mortem) on tenderness and colour were further investigated. Results of the first trial showed no clearly established trends of the effect of rigor temperature and time on the cooking and drip losses and protein solubility except venison muscles that went into rigor at 42 °C tended to have higher drip loss and lower protein solubilities compared to muscles that went into rigor at the other temperatures. Venison water holding capacity (WHC) decreased with the increase in rigor temperature (P < 0.001) and venison became more tender with time post-mortem. Venison colour improved with increasing rigor temperature. During display, samples that went into rigor at 15, 25 and 35 °C had the lowest and those at 0 and 42 °C had the highest rate of change of redness (a^*) value with time. In the second trial, tenderness was improved by stimulation (P = 0.01). Redness (a^*) values were affected by rigor temperature (P < 0.01) and post-mortem time (P < 0.001) but not by electrical stimulation. It is concluded that venison tenderness can be improved via the manipulation of rigor temperature to obtain acceptable level of tenderness early post-mortem with less damaging effect on colour stability.     

Development of Muscle Thermal Rigorometer and Characterization of Heat-induced Muscle Shortening of Tilapia

A muscle thermal rigorometer was constructed, allowing muscle shortenings induced by dynamic heating or isothermal aging to be monitored. Operating isothermally like a traditional rigorometer at 10 °C, postmortem dorsal muscle shortening (S_10°C) developing from 0% to 10% of its initial length in corresponding to RI_fiber along fiber‐direction developing from 0% to 100% within 16 h was monitored for freshwater tilapia. Monitoring meat cooking in the dynamic heating mode, heat‐induced shortenings could be observed for all muscle samples possessing different degrees of rigor induced by 10°C aging. The heat‐induced shortening (S_dynamic) plus its 10°C aging shortening (S_10°C) for each sample was the same, S_overall= S_10°C+ S_dynamic= 10%. Their heat‐induced shortening peak temperatures (Ts) from 30°C to 48°C were inversely correlated with the sample RI_fiber from 0% to near 100%. These findings together with an additional calcium/adenosine triphosphate (ATP) model studies showed that the ATPase related myofibrillar contractile system was responsible for these low‐temperature cooking shortenings, which along with Ts values could thus be adopted as new rigor indices.     

The influence of low temperature, type of muscle and electrical stimulation on the course of rigor mortis, ageing and tenderness of beef muscles

The course of rigor mortis, ageing and tenderness have been evaluated for two beef muscles, M. semimembranosus (SM) and M. longissimus dorsi (LD), when entering rigor at constant temperatures in the cold-shortening region (1, 4, 7 and 10°C). The influence of electrical stimulation (ES) was also examined. Post-mortem changes were registered by shortening and isometric tension and by following the decline of pH, ATP and creatine phosphate. The effect of ageing on tenderness was recorded by measuring shear-force (2, 8 and 15 days post mortem) and the sensory properties were assessed 15 days post mortem. It was found that shortening increased with decreasing temperature, resulting in decreased tenderness. Tenderness for LD, but not for SM, was improved by ES at 1 and 4°C, whereas ES did not give rise to any decrease in the degree of shortening during rigor mortis development. This suggests that ES influences tenderization more than it prevents cold-shortening. The samples with a pre-rigor mortis temperature of 1°C could not be tenderized, when stored up to 15 days, whereas this was the case for the muscles entering rigor mortis at the other higher temperatures. The results show that under the conditions used in this study, the course of rigor mortis is more important for the ultimate tenderness than the course of ageing.     

Effect of Freezing of Beef on Subsequent Postmortem Aging and Shear Force

Seventy-two steaks were used to determine effects of freezing postrigor muscle on aging of meat and shear force. Steaks were removed from each carcass 24 hr postmortem and aged at 2°C for 2 or 6 days; or frozen at ? 30°C for 27 days, thawed 24 hr and aged 2 or 6 days at 2°C. After aging, steaks were cooked and shear force determinations made. Aging of meat reduced shear force values; however, meat aged after freezing had lower (P < 0.03) shear force values than meat aged before freezing. Meat cooked after freezing had greater (P < 0.05) cooking losses. Freezing enhances the aging process and improves shear values of meat.     

The effect of high and low voltage electrical stimulation on beef quality

Meat bulls were assigned to three treatment groups—high voltage intermittent electrical stimulation, low voltage electrical stimulation and no stimulation.Both stimulation methods resulted in a significantly more rapid pH fall in the longissimus and adductor muscles during the first 8 h post mortem. Carcass cooling rates were relatively slow, since temperatures of the longissimus and adductor muscles were 15°C, respectively, at 8 h post mortem.Samples of stimulated longissimus, cut at 24h post mortem and vacuum stored at 3°C for 6 days, had a brighter red colour, higher drip and heating loss, lower shear force values and scored better in taste panels, compared with samples from control carcasses. No significant differences were observed between high and low voltage electrical stimulation in quality traits measured.Although the combined result of pH and temperature measurements during the first 8 h post mortem suggest an absence of cold shortening conditions in control carcasses, a lower sarcomere length was found in samples of the longissimus muscle taken from these carcasses at 24 h post mortem.     

The tenderising effect of electrical stimulation of beef carcasses

Electrical stimulation (ES) of beef carcasses soon after death has an accelerated tenderising effect on the musculature, under conditions of slow cooling (8 h at 16°C and then storage in still air at 1°C). The effect is large in the LD muscles, reducing the shear force on day 1 of storage from 11 to 6 kg; on day 14, the difference is still 3·3 kg. These differences would be detected by taste panels. The St muscles show a similar, but less pronounced, effect which would probably not be detected by taste panels. The accelerated tenderisation due to ES can be accounted for by the higher temperatures obtaining in stimulated muscles at the onset of rigor. Rapid cooling soon after death reduces the effect almost to zero. Hence, the extra tenderisation cannot be due to muscle damage during ES. Histological examination shows that stimulated muscles have longer sarcomeres than the controls; they do not exhibit damage. However, with slow cooling, irregular bands of denatured sarcoplasmic protein are deposited within the fibres of stimulated muscles, similar to those found in PSE pig muscles. There is also some shortening of sarcomeres in the region of the bands. The protein is deposited on the myofibrillar surfaces. In spite of the PSE-like appearance, there is no significant increase in drip from the stimulated muscles at 48 h after death.