Predicting variability of ageing and toughness in beef M. Longissimus lumborum et thoracis

The object of this study was to determine muscle characteristics which might predict meat toughness. Eleven Charolais cattle were slaughtered at approximately 26 months of age and the Longissimus lumborum et thoracis muscle was taken 1 hr post mortem and stored at 12 °C for 24 hr and then at 4 °C.

The average half-life for ageing in these raw muscles was 4.6 days but the toughness varied widely between the animals. Toughness varied 3-fold and the rate of ageing varied 20-fold between animals.

Correlations were done to determine which characteristics might explain this variability. Toughness was correlated positively with increase in oxidative status of muscle and the initial levels of calpastatin. Toughness was correlated negatively with the initial levels of μ- and m-calpains and cysteine and serine proteinase inhibitors, the initial pH values and the rates of their decline. The rates of ageing were highly correlated positively with the initial levels of proteinase inhibitors and the rates of decline of calpastatin and negatively with the ultimate amounts of expressible juice.

There was a wide variability in tenderness in M. Longissimus lumborum et thoracis from similar animals. Variations in metabolism and enzyme activity controlled by inhibitors and calpains appear to be largely responsible for this variability.     

Sarcomere shortening of prerigor muscles and its influence on drip loss

Detailed studies of muscle shortening post mortem at incubation temperatures between −2°C and +38°C revealed that the sarcomeres in unrestrained, excised red bovine muscle (M. sternomandibularis) shortened less than 10 % in the prerigor state between 6°C and 18°C. Below 6°C, sarcomeres contracted up to 70%. Between 20°C and 38°C sarcomere shortening of 40% was observed. In the red porcine M. cleidooccipitalis the minimum of shortening was measured at about 10°C, a higher degree of shortening—up to 50%—being obtained above and below this temperature. The drip loss of both muscle types increased linearly with increasing prerigor shortening.

This latter relationship is discussed with regard to changes within the muscle post mortem. The influence of three events on water movement from the interfilamental space into the interfibrillar fluid and from there into the extracellular space is critically evaluated. These events are: (1) the prerigor contraction of sarcomeres depending on the temperature of storage, (2) the changes due to the falling pH post mortem and (3) the onset of rigor mortis, with its irreversible association of actin and myosin.     

The effects of residual oxygen concentration and temperature on the degradation of the colour of beef packaged under oxygen-depleted atmospheres

Samples of beef longissimus dorsi (LD), approximately 5 × 5 × 1 cm, were packaged in pairs under 10 litre volumes of N₂ or CO₂ containing O₂ at concentrations between 100 and 1000 ppm. The packaged samples were stored at temperatures of 5, 1, 0 or −1·5°C, for times between 4 and 48 h. Samples of beef psoas major (PM) were packaged under N₂ or CO₂ containing O₂ at between 100 and 600 ppm, and stored at −1·5°C for 24 or 48 h. After storage, each sample was assessed for colour deterioration and discoloration, and for the fraction of metmyoglobin in the surface pigment.

The results obtained with N₂ and CO₂ atmospheres were similar. The colours of all LD samples had deteriorated after 4 h storage at 5 or 1°C, although the degree of deterioration increased with increasing O₂ concentration. All LD samples stored for 12 h at 5 or 1°C were extensively discoloured, with metmyoglobin fractions generally exceeding 60%, but those stored at −1·5°C for 48 h or less, under O₂ concentrations ≤ 400 ppm had undergraded colours. The colours of some LD samples stored at −1·5°C under about 600 ppm of O₂ were also undergraded, but the colours of samples stored under 800 or 1000 ppm had deteriorated by 24 h. The colours of LD samples stored at 0°C under > 200 ppm had deteriorated after 24 h storage, and the colours of samples stored under 100 ppm O₂ had deteriorated after 48 h storage. All PM samples were wholly discoloured after storage at −1·5°C. Evidently, the colour of beef muscle of high colour stability is resistant to degradation by atmospheres containing < 600 ppm of O₂ when the meat is stored at sub-zero temperatures, but not when the storage temperature is at or above 0°C. Beef muscle of low colour stability, such as the PM, will discolour at all low concentrations of O₂ irrespective of the storage temperature.     

Calpains from thaw rigor muscle

Pre-rigor beef M. Longissimus lumborum and diaphragma were frozen at −70 °C and thawed at different temperatures and the activities of extracted calpains and the toughness of heated meat compared with those in chilled muscle.

Fresh muscle contained about 14 μg of μ-calpain/g and was unaffected by freezing, but was reduced after thawing. Rapid thawing at 30 °C for 20 min reduced the μ-calpain to 14%. When cooked from the frozen state, extensive shortening occurred and tender meat was obtained.

By storing at −3 °C for 1 day, thaw-shortening was prevented, but tougher meat obtained. The μ-calpain decreased to 70% whilst the m-calpain was unaffected. Toughness decreased after further storage at −3 °C, as did the μ-calpain. The latter changes were similar to those during development of rigor mortis and ageing of non-shortened meat stored at 4 °C. Variation in calpain activity, rather than in sarcomere length, are likely to be the cause of toughness variation in thaw rigor muscle.     

The effect of chilling, electrical stimulation and conditioning on pork eating quality

The effect of three different post-slaughter treatments and subsequent conditioning times on the eating quality of pork was studied, using a total of 72 pigs (80–90 kg live wt). The treatments were: (A) holding in air at > 10°C for 3 h, followed by chilling in air at 1°C; (B) chilling in air at 1°C; (C) high voltage electrical stimulation (ES) at 20 min post-slaughter, followed by Treatment B. The quality attributes were measured in M. longissimus thoracis et lumborum (LTL) and in M. semimembranosus (Sm).

There was little difference in cooling rate between the three treatments; the major effect on quality came from the use of ES in Treatment C. ES reduced pH at 45 min by approximately 0·3 units, and achieved pH values at 3 h post-slaughter of 5·64 (LTL) and 5·87 (Sm) but did not produce PSE meat. Drip losses were generally low, but were slightly higher with Treatment C. By all three instrumental texture parameters, LTL from Treatment C was significantly more tender than from A and B at 4, 7 and 12 days post-slaughter, suggesting that either some cold toughening with A and B was overcome by ES in treatment C or that ES had some other beneficial action. Conditioning at 1°C improved the tenderness of LTL from 4 to 7 days and further to 12 days. Taste panelling of loin chops and Sm roasts confirmed that Treatment C gave significantly more tender meat than A and B, and that ageing from 4 to 7 days and further to 12 days significantly improved tenderness. High voltage electrical stimulation at 20 min post-slaughter followed by cooling in air at 1°C (Treatment C) produced loin muscle which was more tender at 4 days than at 12 days with the other treatments.     

Secondary sexual development (Masculinity) of bovine males: 2. Influence on certain meat quality characteristics

Differences in meat quality traits between bulls with secondary sexual development (bulls(+), n = 10), those without this development (bulls(−), n = 10) and steers (n = 10) were investigated. All animals had no permanent incisors (A-age group). Significant differences (P < 0·05) between bulls(+) and bulls(−) were found for the cooking loss percentage of the M. splenius (27·83% versus 31·11%, respectively), iron content of the M. splenius (56·02μg/g versus 49·43μg/g, respectively) and total collagen content of the M. splenius (3·74 versus 4·73 measured as Hyp N/Tot N x 1000, respectively). Drip loss of the wingrib cut (4·01% versus 5·18%, respectively) was also significantly different between bulls(+) and bulls(−). For the M. longissimus thoracis, no significant (P < 0·05) differences in any of the quality-indicating parameters investigated could be found. It is concluded that the M. splenius can be used as an indicator muscle for masculinity, based on meat quality attributes. This is supported by the correlation coefficients obtained between masculinity and the intramuscular collagen content of the M. splenius (r = −0·55) and the iron content of the M. splenius (r = 0·46). For all the other quality attributes investigated, non-significant (P > 0·05) differences between the three sex condition groups were found. It is concluded that the influence of masculinity on meat quality traits of young bulls is of little practical importance in a classification and grading system.     

Spray chilling of lamb carcasses

Two spray-chilling treatments were developed to improve appearance and reduce weight loss during lamb chilling. Rates of cooling and weight loss and meat quality were compared to conventionally chilled carcasses.

The first treatment was an intermittent spray during the first 3 h of chilling. The second consisted of only two sprays at 2 h and 10 h post mortem. The conventional control was a two-stage process, with air at 10°C and 1 m/s up to 10 h post mortem, followed by air at 0°C and 1 m/s for a further 14 h.

Both treatments significantly reduced weight loss at 24 h post mortem compared to conventional, from 2·20% to 0·86% and 1·20%, respectively. During a further 4 days storage, the savings were maintained, with weight losses being 3·97%, 2·97% and 3·19%, respectively.

There were small (<1 h) but significantly reductions in the cooling times of spray-chilled loins and legs, attributed to sustained evaporative cooling of the continually wetted surfaces.

No effects on texture or drip loss and only slight effects on surface lean and fat colour were found. Variation in texture between animals within treatments was far greater than between treatments and could not be accounted for by variations in cooling rates.     

Variation in haem pigment concentration and colour in meat from British pigs

Variation in chemically determined total haem pigment concentration and instrumentally determined colour was examined in 223 samples of M. longissimus dorsi (LD) representative of the majority of slaughter pigs currently produced in the UK. Whether pigs were sired by White (Large White or Landrace) or Meat-line boars did not affect any measured characteristic but source breeding company influenced total haem pigment concentration (P < 0·01). Haem pigment concentration was higher in muscles from gilts, compared with castrates, boars being intermediate. Gilts also had darker muscles, based on EEL Reflectance values (P < 0·05), and lower hue values (P < 0·05). When compared with animals fed ad-libitum, restricted-fed pigs had higher concentrations of muscle haem pigment (P < 0·001) and this resulted in meat that was slightly darker (P < 0·05), despite having lower ultimate pH (pHu) (P < 0·05), and had a lower hue value (P < 0·001). Measurements of reflectance, total soluble protein and pHu indicated that differences in the incidence of potentially pale, soft, exudative or dark, firm, dry muscle were unlikely to be important contributors to variation in the colour of the meat in this study.     

The influence of high post-mortem temperature and differing ultimate pH on the course of rigor and ageing in pig Longissimus dorsi muscle

This study was performed in order to assess the effect of temperature and differing ultimate pH (pH_u, 24 h post mortem) on the development of rigor mortis in pig Longissimus dorsi muscle. The rigor development (isometric tension and shortening) was measured continuously during the first 24 h post mortem, using an apparatus wherein muscle strips were held at constant temperatures of 12 or 35°C. pH_u was manipulated by adrenaline injections preslaughter.

The rates of pH fall, adenosine triphosphate (ATP) and creatine phosphate (CP) breakdown were markedly increased at 35°C compared to 12°C. For both temperatures, no delay phase was observed with regard to the development of shortening. Rigor resulted in higher maximum isometric tension and shortening and in shorter time needed to reach maximum values at 35°C than at 12°C. The results are discussed in connection with pH, ATP and CP data. The extent of ageing from 2 to 4 days post mortem, estimated through myofibrillar length determinations, was higher for 12°C than for 35°C.

pH_u affected significantly most of the traits under study, but its effect depended in some cases upon the rigor temperature. At 12°C, the traits related to the kinetics of rigor development were significantly affected by pH_u, but this was not the case at 35°C. Maximum isometric tension was significantly related to pH_u at 35°C (r = 0·86, P < 0·001), but such a relationship was not found at 12°C. Myofibrillar lengths were significantly affected by pH_u, but in an opposite manner from one temperature to another. A positive relationship was found at 12°C and a negative one at 35°C.

These results illustrate the importance of the interaction between the extent of pH fall and temperature with regard to post-mortem changes in pig muscle.     

The storage life of chilled pork packaged under carbon dioxide

Pork cuts of longissimus dorsi muscle with overlaying fat and skin were packed under vacuum in film of low oxygen transmission rate, or under CO₂ in gas impermeable aluminium foil laminate. Cuts were stored at +3 or −1·5°C. Vacuum packaged cuts were grossly spoiled by Brochothrix thermosphacta after 2 weeks' storage at 3°C and after 5 weeks at −1·5°C. Cuts packaged under CO₂ were grossly spoiled by B. thermosphacta after 5·5 weeks' storage at 3°C. Growth of B. thermosphacta was suppressed when CO₂ packaged cuts were stored at −1·5°C. At that temperature, slow growth of enterobacteria was detected after a lag of about 18 weeks. The enterobacteria caused gross spoilage of an increasing proportion of cuts between 18 and 26 weeks. Muscle tissue with pale, soft, exudative (PSE) characteristics tended to lose colour after long storage periods, apparently because of loss of myogglobin with exudate. Until spoilage, the eating qualities of pork appeared little affected by prolonged storage.     

Muscle composition of steers treated with the β-agonist, cimaterol

The effect of the β-adrenergic agonist, cimaterol, on the nature and amount of collagen in three individual muscles (Longissimus dorsi, Vastus lateralis and Semitendinosus) from young steers was investigated.

β-Agonist-treated animals showed similar rates of liveweight gain to those of control animals but the weight and protein content of the Longissimus dorsi and Vastus lateralis muscles were significantly increased (muscle weights 1216 versus 1494 g, P < 0·05; 514 versus 642 g, P < 0·01, respectively, for control and cimaterol animals). The Semitendinosus muscle, however, showed no significant increase in weight or protein content (P > 0·05).

The total collagen content and the proportion of heat-soluble collagen varied considerably between muscles, but no significant muscle × treatment interactions were detected (P > 0·05). Cimaterol treatment reduced total muscle collagen content (controls 15·2, cimaterol 12·5mg/g fresh tissue, P < 0·05) and also reduced the percentage of heat-soluble collagen (controls 18·9%, cimaterol 13·0%, P < 0·05).     

Tenderness of pork muscles as influenced by chilling rate and altered carcass suspension

Tenderness improvements in porcine muscles (M. longissimus dorsi, LD; M. semimembranosus, SM; M. biceps femoris, BF) were evaluated in a total of 72 carcasses by using combinations of three different chilling rates (fast, delayed fast, slow) and two different suspension methods (Achilles tendon, pelvic bone).

Tenderness was improved by fast chilling in LD, SM and BF by the pelvic suspension as compared to conventional suspension in the Achilles tendon (P < 0·05). The lengthening of the sarcomeres in SM and BF as produced by pelvic suspension exceeded those found in LD, without having proportional additional effect on the tenderness. While the pelvic-induced tenderization did not change significantly by delayed fast chilling, additional tenderization in BF and SM was obtained by combining pelvic suspension with slow chilling. In conventionally suspended sides, tenderness was unaffected by delayed fast chilling—with slow chilling, however, improvements were observed in LD and SM to a similar extent as obtained by the pelvic suspension. In the LD muscle, the tenderizing effect produced by treatments was largest in muscles having pH values 45 min post stunning above 6·1 (P < 0·05).     

Development of backfat and individual fat layers in the pig and its relationship with carcass lean

The development of backfat (total and individual layers) was monitored in 140 Yorkshire pigs (71 castrates and 69 gilts) during a growing period extending from 14·5 kg to 137·0 kg live weight using a serial slaughter procedure. The allometric coefficient (b) for fat thickness was calculated at several locations extending from the shoulder to the M. gluteus medius at the mid-line and lateral to the mid-line. The relationships between backfat (total and individual layers) and the yield of trimmed boneless meat were also obtained from 80 carcasses.

Total backfat was the thickest at the shoulder, decreased gradually to the last rib, increased at the maximum loin, decreased to the middle of the M. gluteus medius and then increased posterior to the M. gluteus medius. The development of total backfat relative to weight at slaughter was generally slowest at the shoulder (b = 0·555−0·767), most rapid in the region extending from the 5/6 last rib to the last rib b = 0·729−0·810) and intermediate at the loin and in the region of the M. gluteus medius (b = 0·609−0·834). The development of the middle fat layer (b = 0·609−1·107) was more rapid than that of the outer layer (b = 0·500−0·817), the inner layer being intermediate (b = 0·515−0·966). Consistent with the rate of development observed for the individual fat layers, at light weights, the outer layer was usually more predominant, particularly at positions above the M. longissimus, whereas, at heavier weights, the middle layer became predominant.

It was observed that backfat (total or individual layers) measurements, which were the most precise predictors of yield of trimmed boneless meat, that is, measurements from the 5/6 last rib to the last rib (RSE = 4·6−3·1), also had the most rapid rate of development. Furthermore, the middle layer of backfat which exhibited the fastest rate of development of all three individual layers (b = 0·609−1·107), also contributed the most to the observed precision (RSE = 4·6−3·1).     

Comparison of sensory characteristics and fatty acid composition between Wagyu crossbred and Angus steers

Angus (n = 10) and crossbred (3/4 and 7/8) Wagyu (n = 10) steers were fed a diet according to typical Japanese standards for 552 days. The steers were fed to gain approximately 0·90 kg/head/day. Fatty acid composition was determined for subcutaneous and intramuscular adipose tissue, and M. longissimus dorsi muscle. Trained sensory evaluation and a consumer triangle test were performed on M. longissimus dorsi muscle steaks. For subcutaneous and intramuscular tissue. Wagyu adipose tissue possessed higher (P < 0·05) percentages of 14:1, 16:1 and 18:1 and a lower (P < 0·05) percentage of 16:0 and 18:0 than corresponding tissues from Angus steers. Trained sensory panel analysis revealed no differences (P < 0·05) in any of the sensory traits between steaks from Wagyu crossbred and Angus steers. However, a consumer triangle test indicated that consumers can detect a difference between breeds.     

The effect of post-exsanguination infusion on the composition, exudation, color and post-mortem metabolic changes in lamb

Twenty-four lamb carcasses were assigned to three treatment groups: (1) control (Ctr), (2) infused with 10% (vol/wt) of a tenderizing blend (NCa), and (3) NCa plus 0·015 CaCl₂ (WCa). Results indicated that the infused carcass solution was retained in the following order: shoulder > lion > leg. Infusion had no effect (P > 0·05) on drip and cooking losses in refrigerated samples. Samples frozen and then thawed from infused carcasses had greater thaw drip (P < 0·05) and cooking losses (P < 0·01) than control samples. The amounts of drip and cooking losses were in the order: WCa > NCa > Ctr. Frozen storage preserved the red color but lowered the lightness and yellowness of ovine muscles; the opposite effect was observed following refrigerated storage. Infused samples were lighter and yellower than control in both fresh and frozen samples (P < 0·01). WCa had less red color (P < 0·01) than NCa and Ctr at all times and storage conditions. Infusion lowered (P < 0·05) the temperature of carcasses over the first 3 h postmortem (pm) compared with Ctr. The rate of glycolysis was higher in infraspinatus (IS) than in longissimus thoracis et lumborum muscle (LTL or longissimus). In both IS and LTL, glycolysis was completed within the first 6 h postmortem in NCa, whereas in Ctr and WCa, it took 12–24 h for glycolysis to be completed. The rate of glycolysis was in the order: NCa > WCa > Ctr.     

Sources and properties of some organisms isolated in two abattoirs

A wide range of organisms was isolated and identified from a number of sites in two abattoirs. Heavily contaminated sites were the water supply to the lairage in one abattoir and animal hair, blood, rumen contents and soil and faecal material from hooves in both abattoirs. Few catalase negative organisms were isolated but other Gram positive organisms included Bacillus spp., coryneforms, M. thermosphactum and coagulase negative cocci. Gram negative organisms were widely distributed in the abattoirs, Pseudomonas spp. being present at most sites, while members of the family Enterobacteriaceae were isolated from all sites except carcass wash water and air samples in the lairages and a boning room.

In pure culture 17 of 54 isolates spoiled meat in air at 4°C and 47 at 15°C but under simulated vacuum-package conditions only 7 of 28 at 4°C and 14 of 28 at 15°C gave some indication of spoilage abilities.

None of the 10 isolates tested showed marked resistance to chlorine at 20 ppm.     

The influence of cooking rate and holding time on beef chuck and round flavor

Steaks from seven muscles from 10 beef carcasses were cooked quickly or slowly and held 0 or 1 h to explore the influence of cooking rate and holding time on beef flavor. Moisture, ash, pH, and heme–iron concentration were determined for each muscle. Trained sensory panels evaluated the steaks for tenderness, juiciness, connective tissue, and off-flavor intensity in addition to identifying specific off-flavors. Off-flavor intensity was lowest when beef was cooked slowly (on a 149 °C gas grill instead of a 249 °C grill) and when it was held for 1 h prior to sensory evaluation. The M. infraspinatus had the least intense off-flavor and the M. vastus intermedius had the most intense off-flavor. Slow cooking or holding for 1 h prior to consumption reduced the intensity of off-flavor in value cuts from the beef chuck and round while chemical characteristics did not contribute to off-flavor in this study.     

Temperature shows greater impact on bovine Longissimus dorsi muscle glycogen debranching enzyme activity than does salt concentration

The degradation of glycogen progresses by the co-operation of two enzymes: glycogen phosphorylase (phosphorylase) and glycogen debranching enzyme (GDE). We studied the effect of temperature (4–42 °C) and salt concentration (0–3% NaCl) on bovine M. longissimus dorsi GDE activity. GDE activity (n = 4) decreased significantly with decreasing temperature from about 40–4 °C. GDE exhibited 52% activity at 25 °C and 11% at 4 °C compared to its optimum activity measured at 39 °C. In rapidly chilled meat, the reduction in GDE activity may substantially delay the rate of glycolysis. However, residual GDE activity at 4 °C seems sufficient to enable the attainment of normal ultimate pH if the available time is long enough. An increase in salt concentration from 0% to 2% and to 3% induced a significant (P < 0.001) increase in the ultimate pH of ground bovine meat (n = 6), but showed no effect on GDE activity.     

Variation in light scattering and water-holding capacity along the porcine Longissimus dorsi muscle

The meat quality of M. longissimus muscle was evaluated in 851 pigs by using the Fibre Optic Probe (FOP) at three sites in the muscle and in both halves of the carcass. A systematic difference between sites was found, with the lowest light scattering (indicating the best meat quality) in the mid-part of the muscle and higher light scattering in the anterior and posterior parts. A non-systematic variation was also observed, with the opposite pattern in some animals, even though it was not frequent. A negative influence of the shackling was found, yielding higher FOP values in the shackled half.

Drip loss measurements in the Longissimus muscle, taken from another 100 pig carcasses, were evaluated using three methods. Drip loss, too, showed a considerable variation along the Longissimus muscle, with minimum losses around the last rib. Repeatability estimates, calculated from two non-consecutive pieces of the Longissimus dorsi muscle from each carcass, varied from 0·4 when keeping samples vacuum packed for 2 days, to 0·5 when the samples were either kept in plain plastic bags for 2 days or in a meat container with a squared inset for 1 or 2 days.     

The effects of electrical stimulation and ageing on beef tenderness

Seventeen beef carcasses from cattle with a range of breeds, ages and body conditions were used in this trial. The four treatments applied to each carcass were control (C), electrical stimulation (ES), ageing for 28 days (A) and electrical stimulation plus ageing for 28 days (ES + A). Post-mortem muscle pH was measured at 0, 0·5, 4 and 24h post-stimulation. Significantly lower muscle pH values (P < 0·01) were achieved by the stimulated carcass side sompared to the unstimulated side at 0·5 (pH 6·47 vs. 6·91) and 4 h (pH 5·96 vs. 6·44) post-stimulation.

Warner-Bratzler shear and taste panel methods were used to assess the tenderness of Longissimus dorsi muscle samples from each of the four treatments. The ES, A and ES + A treatments were significantly more tender (P < 0·01) than the control treatment. The ES and the A treatments resulted in a similar improvement in tenderness compared to the control. The ES + A treatment was significantly more tender (P < 0·01) than the ES treatment alone, but there was no significant difference in tenderness between the A and the ES + A treatments.