Performance of containment penetrations under severe accident loadings

The paper provides a summary of efforts to date to better understand the leakage behavior of containment penetrations when subjected to severe accident conditions. The research activities discussed herein are a part of the Containment Integrity Programs, which are managed by Sandia National Laboratories for the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission. Past containment penetration research topics, which are briefly described, include testing of typical compression seals and gaskets, electrical penetration assemblies, and a personnel airlock, as well as an investigation of leakage due to ovalization of penetration sleeves. The primary focus of the paper is on recent or ongoing research programs on the behavior of inflatable seals, bellows, and of pressure unseating equipment hatches.     

Leakage potential of LWR containment penetrations under severe accident conditions

This paper is an overview of a Sandia National Laboratories, Albuquerque (SNLA) study of the performance of mechanical penetrations in light-water reactor (LWR) containment buildings that are subjected to severe accident environments. The study is concerned with modes of failure as well as the magnitude of leakage. The following tests have been completed, are under way, or are planned: (a) seals and gaskets have been tested to register the effects of radiation aging, thermal aging, seal geometry, and squeeze on seal and gasket materials in severe accident environments; (b) the performance of a full-scale airlock will be evaluated at severe accident temperature and pressure levels; (c) personnel airlock and equipment hatch tests were made on a model of a steel containment building; and (d) tests of mechanical penetrations are planned as part of a test on a model of a reinforced concrete building. This program is part of an overall US Nuclear Regulatory Commission (USNRC) effort to evaluate the integrity of LWR containment buildings.     

Analysis of the primary containment response using a hydrodynamic-elastic-plastic computer code

The dynamic response of the primary reactor containment system to a hypothetical core disruptive accident (HCDA) is determined from the basic equations of mass, momentum, and energy, and the equations of state of the medium. These equations are first expressed in material coordinates and then set into finite difference form solved numerically on the computer using a hydrodynamic-elastic-plastic computer code, REXCO-HEP developed at ANL. Propagation of pressure waves, loads imposed on different parts of the reactor components, and the resulting deformations are determined at every time step throughout the sequence of the calculation. As a sample calculation, the code was applied to analyze the response of the FFTF reactor to a 150 MWsec HCDA. The mathematical model is described in detail, particularly in the areas of modeling reactor internals and extending the time range to cover the entire excursion phenomenon. Finally, the results obtained from the computer analysis are discussed in detail.     

ASTEC and ICARE/CATHARE modelling improvement for VVERs

ASTEC and ICARE/CATHARE computer codes, developed by IRSN (France) (the former with GRS, Germany), are used in RRC KI (Russia) for the analyses of accident transients on VVER-type NPPs. The latest versions of the codes were continuously improved and validated to provide a better understanding of the main processes during hypothetical severe accidents on VVERs.This paper describes modelling improvements for VVERs carried out recently in the ICARE common part of the above codes. These actions concern the important models of fuel rod cladding mechanical behaviour and oxidation in steam at high and very high temperatures. The existing models were improved basing on the experience in the field and latest literature data sources for Zr + 1%Nb material used for manufacture of VVERs fuel rod claddings.Best-fitted correlations for the Zr alloy oxidation through a broad temperature range were established, along with recommendations on model application in clad geometry and starvation conditions. A model for the creep velocity was chosen for the clad mechanical model and some cladding burst criteria were established as a function of temperature.After verification of modelling improvements on Separate Effect Tests, validation was carried out on integral bundle tests such as QUENCH, CODEX-CT, PARAMETER-SF (the application to the CORA-VVER experiments is not described in the present paper) and on the Paks-2 cleaning tank incident. The comparison of updated code results with experimental data demonstrated very good numerical predictions, which increases the level of code applicability to VVER-type materials.     

Failure mechanisms of LWR steel containment buildings subject to severe accident loadings

The potential failure mechanisms in LWR steel containment buildings subject to quasi-static pressurization and elevated temperature are identified. For each failure mechanism, the relevant structural response measures are discussed. For mechanisms involving leakage, the importance of seal performance is also discussed. Criteria that can be used to evaluate threshold environments are presented for several failure mechanisms. Results of tests on scale models and seal tests that support the criteria are referenced.     

State-of-the-art computer code RELAP5 validation with RBMK-related separate phenomena data

Validation of the RBMK model, developed by employing best estimate system computer code RELAP5 is performed by employing the data from NPPs operation or from integral and separate effects facilities.Validation of the models on the basis of separate phenomena is necessary to perform due to the fact that RELAP5 code has been developed for PWRs, which operate at different conditions (pressure, temperature, coolant void fraction, etc.) from RBMKs. In addition to that, there is a number of phenomena specific for RBMK type reactors (oscillatory flow rate behaviour in parallel channels, flow stagnation in channels, stratification in long horizontal piping, etc.), which have not been studied during RELAP5 validation for PWRs.In the paper, RELAP5 models for separate effects related to RBMK-1500 are presented and modelling of transients is performed. Obtained results are compared with experimental data.     

Experiments to evaluate behavior of containment piping bellows under severe accident conditions

Bellows are an integral part of the containment pressure boundary in nuclear power plants. They are used at piping penetrations to allow relative movement between piping and the containment wall. In a severe accident they may be subjected to high pressure and temperature and a combination of axial and lateral deflections. A test program to determine the leak-tight capacity of containment penetration bellows is being conducted at Sandia National Laboratories, Albuquerque, NM. Several different bellows geometries representative of actual containment bellows are being subjected to extreme deflections along with pressure and temperature loads. The bellows geometries and loading conditions are described along with the testing apparatus and procedures. A total of 13 tests have been conducted. The tests showed that bellows are capable of withstanding relatively large deformations up to or near the point of full compression before developing leakage. The test data are presented and discussed.     

Investigation of ALPHA experiment by severe accident analysis code SAMPSON

The severe accident analysis code SAMPSON is adopted in this work to evaluate its capability of reproducing the complex gap cooling phenomenon. The ALPHA experiment is adopted for validation, where molten aluminum oxide (Al₂O₃) produced by a thermite reaction is poured into a water filled hemispherical vessel at the ambient pressure of approximately 1.3 MPa. The spreading and cooling of the debris that has relocated into the pressure vessel lower plenum are simulated, including the analysis of the RPV failure. The model included in the code to simulate the water penetration inside the gap is evaluated and improvements are proposed. The importance of the introduction of some mechanistic approach to describe the gap formation and evolution is underlined where the results show its necessity in order to correctly reproduce the experimental trends.     

A generic approach for steel containment vessel success criteria for severe accident loads

Safety has been defined as the foremost design criterion for the Heavy Water New Production Reactor (NPR-HWR) by the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE), Office of New Production Reactors (NP). The DOE-NP issued the Deterministic Severe Accident Criteria (DSAC) concept to guide the design of the NPR-HWR containment for resistance to severe accidents. The DSAC concept provides for a generic approach for containment vessel success criteria to predict the threshold of containment failure under severe accident loads. This concept consists of two parts: (1) Problem Statements and (2) Success Criteria. This paper is limited to a discussion of a generic approach for steel containment vessel success criteria. These criteria define acceptable containment response measures and limits for each problem statement. The criteria are based on the “best estimate” of failure with no conservatism. Rather, conservatism, if required, is to be provided in the problem statements prepared by the designer and/or the regulatory authorities. The success criteria are presented on a multi-tiered basis for static pressure and temperature loadings, dynamic loadings, and missiles that may impact the containment. Within the static pressure and temperature loadings and the dynamic loadings, the criteria are separated into elastic analysis success criteria and inelastic analysis success criteria. Each of these areas, in turn, defines limits on either the stress or strain measures as well as on measures for buckling and displacements. The rationale upon which these criteria are based is contained in referenced documents. Rigorous validation of the criteria by comparison with results from analytical or experimental programs and application of the criteria to a containment design remain as future tasks.     

Effect of steam environment on severe core damage behaviour for VVER-1000 with the ASTEC V1 code

Severe accident studies for very low frequency events for VVER-1000 (V320) are carried out to estimate in-vessel damage progression under steam-rich and starved conditions. The analyses with code ASTEC, jointly developed by IRSN (France) and GRS, Germany), have shown the influence of steam environment on core heat-up followed by material relocation, hydrogen production, vessel failure and aerosol generation along with release to containment. Hydro-accumulator injection for studied transients also gives rise to a steam-rich environment enhancing the material oxidation depending on the injection time and period. The generated information along with PSA-Level 2 is helpful to decide Plant Damage State (PDS) and fruitfully develop accident management strategies for the plant.     

Simulation of containment thermal-hydraulics in the Marviken Blowdown 16 experiment with ASTEC and CONTAIN codes

The boiling heavy water reactor Blowdown 16 experiment, which was performed in the Marviken experimental facility, was simulated with the ASTEC and CONTAIN codes. The main purpose of the work was the assessment of the codes for simulating thermal-hydraulic phenomena in a BWR containment at accident conditions. Simulated pressures, atmosphere temperatures and wetwell pool masses are compared to experimental measurements. The results show that both codes satisfactorily reproduced the overall containment thermal-hydraulic behaviour. The simulations also allow a more detailed understanding of the governing mechanisms during the performed experiment.     

An integral model for a severe accident at a nuclear plant with a containment

Translated from Atomnaya Énergiya, Vol. 71, No. 1, pp. 8–13, July, 1991     

Integral large scale experiments on hydrogen combustion for severe accident code validation-HYCOM

A joint research project was carried out in the EU Fifth Framework Programme, concerning hydrogen risk in a nuclear power plant. The goals were: Firstly, to create a new data base of results on hydrogen combustion experiments in the slow to turbulent combustion regimes. Secondly, to validate the partners CFD and lumped parameter codes on the experimental data, and to evaluate suitable parameter sets for application calculations. Thirdly, to conduct a benchmark exercise by applying the codes to the full scale analysis of a postulated hydrogen combustion scenario in a light water reactor containment after a core melt accident. The paper describes the work programme of the project and the partners activities. Significant progress has been made in the experimental area, where test series in medium and large scale facilities have been carried out with the focus on specific effects of scale, multi-compartent geometry, heat losses and venting. The data were used for the validation of the partners CFD and lumped parameter codes, which included blind predictive calculations and pre- and post-test intercomparison exercises. Finally, a benchmark exercise was conducted by applying the codes to the full scale analysis of a hydrogen combustion scenario. The comparison and assessment of the results of the validation phase and of the challenging containment calculation exercise allows a deep insight in the quality, capabilities and limits of the CFD and the lumped parameter tools which are currently in use at various research laboratories.     

Investigation of ex-vessel core catcher for SBO accident in VVER-1000/V528 containment using MELCOR code

Nuclear Science and Techniques - An S-band high-gradient accelerating structure is designed for a proton therapy linear accelerator (linac) to accommodate the new development of compact,...     

Efficacy assessment of independent severe accident mitigation measures in OPR1000 using MELCOR code

In-vessel and ex-vessel mitigation strategies have been revisited to improve the severe accident management (SAM) for operating nuclear power plants. Because independent mitigation measures tend to produce positive and adverse effects simultaneously, it is necessary to investigate the efficacy of individual measures by means of proper quantification. Thus, in the present study we investigated the overall efficacy of existing SA mitigation strategies prepared for the Optimized Power Reactor 1000 MWe (OPR1000) by means of MELCOR 1.8.6 code. The numerical evaluation showed that the Mitigation-01, feeding water into the steam generators, is the most effective among the other mitigations. In addition, Mitigation-02, reactor coolant system depressurization, could not mitigate the SA sufficiently when applied individually. Among the four ex-vessel mitigation strategies, execution of containment spray was effective in removing most of the aerosol fission product but also intensified hydrogen combustion by increasing the partial hydrogen pressure owing to steam condensation. Mitigation-07, operation of passive autocatalytic recombiners (PARs), could reduce the hydrogen concentration, though the catalytic reaction was predicted to increase the containment pressure. In conclusion, this study suggests that mitigation measures should be carefully selected, and that counteracting measures should be prepared to minimize potential adverse effects.     

Stepwise integral scaling method for severe accident analysis and its application to corium dispersion in direct containment heating

Accident sequences which lead to severe core damage and to possible radioactive fission products into the environment have a very low probability. However, the interest in this area increased significantly due to the occurrence of the small break loss-of-coolant accident at TM1–2 which led to partial core damage, and of the Chernobyl accident in the former USSR which led to extensive core disassembly and significant release of fission products over several countries. In particular, the latter accident raised the international concern over the potential consequences of severe accidents in nuclear reactor systems. One of the significant shortcomings in the analyses of severe accidents is the lack of well-established and reliable scaling criteria for various multiphase flow phenomena. However, the scaling criteria are essential to the severe accident, because the full scale tests are basically impossible to perform. They are required for (1) designing scaled down or simulation experiments, (2) evaluating data and extrapolating the data to prototypic conditions, and (3) developing correctly scaled physical models and correlations. In view of this, a new scaling method is developed for the analysis of severe accidents. Its approach is quite different from the conventional methods. In order to demonstrate its applicability, this new stepwise integral scaling method has been applied to the analysis of the corium dispersion problem in the direct containment heating.     

Thermal-hydraulic and stress analysis of AP1000 reactor containment during LOCA in dry cooling mode

Some kinds of break in the reactor coolant system may cause the coolant to exit rapidly from the failure site,which leads to the loss of coolant accident (LOCA).In this paper,a stress analysis of an AP1000 reactor containment is performed in an LOCA,with the passive containment cooling system (PCCS) being available and not available for cooling the wall's containment.The variations in the mechanical properties of the wall's containment,including elastic modulus,strength,and stress,are analyzed using the ABAQUS code.A general two-phase model is applied for modeling thermal-hydraulic behavior inside the containment.Obtained pressure and temperature from thermal-hydraulic models are considered as boundary conditions of the ABAQUS code to obtain distributions of temperature and stress across steel shell of the containment in the accident.The results indicate that if the PCCS fails,the peak pressure inside the containment exceeds the design value.However,the stress would still be lower than the yield stress value,and no risk would threaten the integrity of the containment.