Comparative study of turbines for wave energy conversion

IlltnductionSeveral of the wave energy devices cuntiy stUdiedin the United kingdom, Japan, POhogal, India and othercountries make use of the principle of the oscillatingwater-air coltUnn for convening wave energy to lowPneqmatic energy Which in tUrn can be converted intomechAncal energy. In this case, the developmellt of a bidirechonal air theme has come lip as an importantProblem. So far, a number of self-rechfying air onnesWith different configurations have been ProPOsed, and a; Wells…     

A review of impulse turbines for wave energy conversion

Oscillating Water Column based wave energy plants convert wave energy into low pressure pnuematic power in the form of bi-directional air flows. Air turbines which are capable of rotating uni-directionally in bi-directional air flow, otherwise also known as self-rectifying turbines, are used to extract mechanical shaft power which is further converted into electrical power by a generator. This paper reviews the state of the art in self-rectifying impulse air turbines. New results on optimum parameters for the fixed-guide-vane impulse turbine are also presented. Starting characteristics and conversion efficiencies of two types of impulse turbines are compared with the well known Wells turbine.     

Impulse turbine with 3D guide vanes for wave energy conversion

In this study, in order to achieve further improvement of the performance of an impulse turbine with fixed guide vanes for wave energy conversion, the effect of guide vane shape on the performance was investigated by experiment. The investigation was performed by model testing under steady flow condition. As a result, it was found that the efficiency of the turbine with 3D guide vanes are slightly superior to that of the turbine with 2D guide vanes because of the increase of torque by means of 3D guide vane, though pressure drop across the turbine for the 3D case is slightly higher than that for the 2D case.     

Computed effect of guide vane shape on performance of impulse turbine for wave energy conversion

This paper deals with the computational fluid dynamics (CFD) analysis on effect of guide vane shape on performance of impulse turbine for wave energy conversion. Initially, experiments have been conducted on the impulse turbine to validate the present CFD method and to analyse the aerodynamics in rotor and guide vanes, which demonstrates the necessity to improve the guide vanes shape. The results showed that the downstream guide vanes make considerable total pressure drop leads low performance of the turbine and hence three‐dimensional (3‐D) inlet and downstream guide vanes have been designed based on well‐known vortex theory to improve the efficiency of the turbine. In order to prove the improvement in efficiency due to 3‐D guide vanes, CFD analysis has been made on impulse turbine with 2‐D and 3‐D guide vanes for various flow coefficients. As a result, it is seen that the present CFD model can predict the experimental values with reasonable accuracy. Also, it is showed from the numerical results that the efficiency of the turbine can be improved by average of 4.5 percentage points by incorporating 3‐D guide vanes instead of 2‐D guide vanes. The physical reason for improvement in efficiency of the turbine due to 3‐D guide vanes has been explained with the CFD flow insight pictures. As the turbine operates in fluctuating flow conditions, the performance of the turbine with 2‐D and 3‐D guide vanes have been calculated numerically using quasi‐steady analysis. Furthermore, the performance of the turbine has been predicted for one year based on Irish wave climate to show the feasibility of using 3‐D guide vanes in actual sea wave conditions. Copyright © 2005 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Effect of end plates on the performence of a wells turbine for wave energy conversion

In order to improve the performance of the Wells turbine for wave energy conversion,the effect of end plates onthe turbine characteristics has been investigated experimentally by model testing under steady flow conditions.The end plate attached to the tip of the original rotor blade is slightly larger than the original blade profile.Thecharacteristics of the Wells turbine with end plates have been compared with those of the original Wells turbine,i.e.,the turbine without end plate.As a result, it has been concluded that the characteristics of the Wells turbinewith end plates are superior to those of the original Wells turbine and the characteristics are dependent on the sizeand position of end plate. Furthermore, the effect of annular plate on the turbine performance,which encircles theturbine and is attached to the tip,was investigated as an additional experiment.However,its device was not effec-tive in improving the turbine characteristics.     

Comparison of Performances of Turbines for Wave Energy Conversion

The Wells turbine for a wave power generator is a self-rectifying air turbine that is available for an energy conversion in an oscillating water-air column without any rectifying valve. The objective of this paper is to compare the performances of the Wells turbines in which the profile of blade are NACA0020, NACA0015, CA9 and HSIM15-262123-1576 in the small-scale model testing. The running characteristics in the steady flow, the start and running characteristics in the sinusoidal flow and the hysteretic characteristics in the sinusoidal flow were investigated for four kinds of turbine. As a conclusion, the turbine in which the profile of blade is NACA0020 has the best performances among 4 turbines for the running and starting characteristics in the small-scale model testing.     

Design and performance analysis of impulse turbine for a wave energy power plant

Wave energy is the most abundant source of renewable energy in the World. For the last two decades, engineers have been investigating and defining different methods for power extraction from wave motion. Two different turbines, namely Wells turbine and impulse turbine with guide vanes, are most commonly used around the world for wave energy power generation. The ultimate goal is to optimize the performance of the turbine under actual sea conditions. The total research effort has several strands; there is the manufacture and experimental testing of new turbines using the Wave Energy Research Team's (WERT) 0.6 m turbine test rig, the theoretical and computational analysis of the present impulse turbine using a commercial software package and finally the prediction of the performance of the turbine in a representative wave power device under real sea conditions using numerical simulation. Also, the WERT 0.6 m turbine test rig was upgraded with a data acquisition and control system to test the turbine in the laboratory under real sea conditions using the computer control system. As a result, it is proven experimentally and numerically that the turbine efficiency has been raised by 7% by reducing the hub‐to‐tip ratio from 0.7 to 0.6. Effect of tip clearance on performance of the turbine has been studied numerically and designed tip clearance ratio of 1% has been validated. From the numerical simulation studies, it is computed that the mean conversion efficiency is reduced around 5% and 4.58% due to compressible flow and damping effects inside OWC device. Copyright © 2005 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

A modified Wells turbine for wave energy conversion

The method of wave energy conversion utilises an oscillating water column (OWC). The OWC converts wave energy into low-pressure pneumatic energy in the form of bi-directional airflow. Wells turbine with its zero blade pitch setting has been used to convert this pneumatic power into uni-directional mechanical shaft power. Measurements in OWC based wave energy plants in India and Japan show that the airflow velocity is not equal in both directions. The velocity is more when the airflows out to the atmosphere (exhalation) than in the reverse direction. It may be advantageous to set the rotor blade pitch asymmetrically at a positive pitch so as to achieve a higher mean efficiency in a wave cycle. Towards this objective, performance characteristics of a turbine with different blade setting angles in steady flow were found by experimentation. Quasi-steady analysis was then used to predict the mean efficiency for a certain variation of air velocity with time. This variation with time was taken as pseudo-sinusoidal wherein the positive part of the cycle was taken as a half sine-wave whose amplitude is greater than that of the negative half sine-wave. Such a variation is representative of what happens in reality. For exhalation velocity amplitude to inhalation velocity ratios 0.8 and 0.6, a rotor blade setting angle of 2° was found to be optimum.     

Effects of blade geometry on performance of wells turbine for wave power conversion

IntroductionThe fossil fuel energy with the problem of airpollution might run out by the middle of the 21stcentury. So many researchers have studied forscores of years on alternative, renewable energysources11] such as tidal, wave, salinity gradient,current, wind and solar energy.The energy density level of waves is higherthan the other energy sources stated above. Thereare various techniques for extraction of energyfrom waves[2]. Several of the wave energydevices using the principle of an os…     

Effects of Hub-To-Tip Ratio and Tip Clearance on Hysteretic Characteristics of Wells Turbine for Wave Power Conversion

A Wells turbine for wave power conversion has hysteretic characteristics in a reciprocating flow. The hysteretic loop is opposite to the well-known dynamic stall of an airfoil. In this paper, the mechanism of the hysteretic behavior was elucidated by an unsteady 3-dimensional Navier-Stokes numerical simulation. It was found that the hysteretic behavior was associated with a streamwise vortical flow appearing near the blade suction surface. The effects of hub-to-tip ratio and tip clearance on the hysteretic characteristics of the Wells turbine have also been discussed in this paper.     

A twin unidirectional impulse turbine topology for OWC based wave energy plants

Experimental results from near shore bottom standing OWC based wave energy plants in Japan and India have now been available for about a decade. Historically the weakest link in the conversion efficiency of OWC based wave energy plants built so far has been the bidirectional turbine. This is possibly because a single turbine has been required to deliver power when the plant is exposed to random incident wave excitation varying by a factor of 10. A new topology that uses twin unidirectional turbines (which features a high efficiency spanning a broad range) is proposed. Using the Indian Wave Energy plant as a case study, it is shown that the power output from such a module considerably exceeds existing optimal configurations including those based on a fixed guide vane impulse turbine, linked guide vane impulse turbine or a Well's turbine. A wave to wire efficiency of the order of 50% over the incident range is shown to be feasible in a credible manner by showing the output at all stages of the conversion process. A frequency domain technique is used to compute the OWC efficiency and a time domain approach used for the power module with the turbine pressure being the pivotal variable.     

Application of Numerical Simulation Method to Predict the Performance of Wave Energy Device with Impulse Turbine

This paper presents the work carried out to predict the behavior of a 0.6 m Impulse turbine with fixed guide vanes with 0.6 hub-to-tip (H/T) ratio under real sea conditions. In order to predict the true performance of the actual Oscillating Water Column (OWC), the numerical technique has been fine tuned by incorporating the compressibility effect. Water surface elevation verses time history based on Pierson Moskowitz Spectra was used as the input data. Standard numerical techniques were employed to solve the non-linear behavior of the sea waves. The effect due to compressibility inside the air chamber and turbine performance under unsteady and irregular flow condition has been analyzed numerically. Considering the quasi-steady assumptions, unidirectional steady flow experimental data was used to simulate the turbine characteristics under irregular unsteady flow conditions. The results show that the performance of this type of turbine is quite stable and efficiency of air chamber and the mean conversion     

Wells turbine for wave energy conversion: a review

In the past 20 years, the use of wave energy systems has significantly increased, generally depending on the oscillating water column concept. Wells turbine is one of the most efficient oscillating water column technologies. This article provides an updated and a comprehensive account of the state‐of‐the‐art research on Wells turbine. Hence, it draws a roadmap for the contemporary challenges, which may hinder future reliance on such systems in the renewable energy sector. In particular, the article is concerned with the research directions and methodologies, which aim at enhancing the performance and efficiency of Wells turbine. The article also provides a thorough discussion of the use of CFD for performance modeling and design optimization of Wells turbine. It is found that a numerical model using the CFD code can be employed successfully to calculate the performance characteristics of W‐T as well as other experimental and analytical methods. The increase of research papers about CFD, especially in the last 5 years, indicates that there is a trend that considerably depends on the CFD method. Copyright © 2016 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Performance of Wells Turbine with Guide Vanes for Wave Energy Conversion

ＰｅｒｆｏｒｍａｎｃｅｏｆＷｅｌｌｓＴｕｒｂｉｎｅｗｉｔｈＧｕｉｄｅＶａｎｅｓｆｏｒＷａｖｅＥｎｅｒｇｙＣｏｎｖｅｒｓｉｏｎＭａｎａｂｕＴａｋａｏ；ＴｏｓｈｉａｋｉＳｅｔｏｇｕｃｈｉ；ＫｅｎｊｉＫａｎｅｋｏ（ＤｅｐａｒｔｍｅｎｔｏｆＭｅｃｈａｎｉｃａ...     

Hysteretic characteristics of Wells turbine for wave power conversion

A Wells turbine blade for wave power conversion has hysteretic characteristics in a reciprocating flow. The hysteretic loop is opposite to the well-known dynamic stall of an airfoil. In this paper, the mechanism of the hysteretic behavior was elucidated by an unsteady 3-dimensional Navier-Stokes numerical simulation. It was found that the hysteretic behavior was associated with a streamwise vortical flow appearing near the blade suction surface. And also the effects of solidity, setting angle and blade thickness on the hysteretic characteristics of the Wells turbine have been discussed.     

Multiple surrogate based optimization of a bidirectional impulse turbine for wave energy conversion

Oscillating water column based wave energy extracting system has a low efficiency due to the poor performance of its principal power extracting component, the bidirectional turbine. In the present work, flow over a bidirectional impulse turbine was simulated using CFD technique and optimized using multiple surrogates approach. The surrogates being problem dependent may produce unreliable results, if a wrong surrogate is selected. Hence, multiple surrogates such as response surface approximation, radial basis function, Kriging and weighted average surrogates were incorporated in this problem. Same design points were used to generate multiple optima via multiple surrogates to enhance the robustness of the optimization process. Numbers of guide vanes and rotor blades were chosen as the design variables, and the objective was to maximize the blade efficiency. Reynolds-averaged Navier–Stokes equations were solved for analyzing the flow physics. The computed results were used to train the surrogates and find the optimal points via hybrid genetic algorithm. The surrogates were further applied to find the optimal flow parameters by changing flow velocity and turbine speed. The relative efficiency enhancement through our present approach was about 16%. Detailed methodologies, analysis of the results and surrogate applicability have been presented in this paper.     

Computed effects of tip clearance on performance of impulse turbine for wave energy conversion

This paper depicts numerical analysis on Impulse turbine with fixed guide vanes for wave energy conversion. From the previous investigations, it is found that one of the reasons for the mismatch between computed and experimental data is due to neglecting tip clearance ef fect. Hence, a 3-D model with tip clearance has been generated to predict the internal flow and performance of the turbine. As a result, it is found that the comparison between computed and experimental data is good, quantitatively and qualitatively. Computation has been carried out for various tip clearances to understand the physics of tip leakage flow and effect of tip clearance on performance of such unconventional turbine. It is predicted that the turbine with 0.25% tip clearance performs almost similar to the case of without tip clearance for the entire flow coefficients. The designed value of 1% tip clearance has been validated numerically and computed that the efficiency of the turbine has been reduced around 4%, due to tip clearance flow at higher flow coefficients.     

Computational analysis of performance and flow investigation on wells turbine for wave energy conversion

Wells turbine is a self-rectifying airflow turbine capable of converting pneumatic power of the periodically reversing air stream in oscillating water column into mechanical energy. This paper reports the computational analysis on performance and aerodynamics of Wells turbine with the NACA 0021 constant chord blades. Studies have been made at various flow coefficients covering the entire range of flow coefficients over which the turbine is operable. The present computational model can predict the performance and aerodynamics of the turbine quantitatively and qualitatively. The model also predicted the flow coefficient at which the turbine stalls, with reasonable accuracy.     

Enhancing the energy efficiency of the impulse turbine of a wave energy plant

The power take-off mechanism of the oscillating water column based Indian wave energy plant is based on an impulse turbine-permanent magnet synchronous generator (PMSG) set. The MATLAB based simulation of the dynamic model of this power module, considering the plant's operation on the stand-alone mode, is developed incorporating a machine variable model for the PMSG used. It is shown that the energy efficiency of the impulse turbine can be substantially increased by adjusting the load resistance dynamically, as a function of the input differential pressure.     

Wells turbine blade profile optimization for better wave energy capture

Despite the fact that wave energy is available at no cost, it is always desired to harvest the maximum possible amount of this energy. The axial flow air turbines are commonly used with oscillating water column devices as a power take‐off system. The present work introduces a blade profile optimization technique that improves the air turbine performance while considering the complex 3D flow phenomena. This technique produces non‐standard blade profiles from the coordinates of the standard ones. It implements a multi‐objective optimization algorithm in order to define the optimum blade profile. The proposed optimization technique was successfully applied to a biplane Wells turbine in the present work. It produced an optimum blade profile that improves the turbine torque by up to 9.3%, reduces the turbine damping coefficient by 10%, and increases the turbine operating range by 5%. The optimized profile increases the annual average turbine power by up to 3.6% under typical sea conditions. Moreover, new blade profiles were produced from the wind turbine airfoil data and investigated for use with the biplane Wells turbine. The present work showed that two of these profiles could be used with low wave energy seas. Copyright © 2017 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.