Clinical use of bone allografts

Modern techniques of bone allograft surgery provide a treatment modality for management of difficult skeletal defects. In oncological limb-salvage surgery, allograft reconstructions permit re-establishment of skeletal continuity and function after a wide resection of bone tumour. Bone allografts are increasingly used in salvage of difficult bone stock deficiencies following failed total joint replacements. Union between the allograft and the host bone takes place slowly and the use of autogenous bone graft at the graft-host junction is recommended for induction of repair. Internal repair (revascularization and substitution of the original graft bone with new host bone) also progresses slowly and seems to be confined only to the superficial surface and the ends of the graft. Biomechanically, a massive allograft may serve a structural function in the absence of advanced revascularization and creeping substitution processes. Infection of an allograft is a disastrous complication, whereas non-union of the graft-host junction and fracture of the graft are amenable to surgical treatment. Osteochondral allografts tend to show gradual deterioration of the articular cartilage with time, necessitating occasionally late resurfacing arthroplasty. It is evident that there is more active immune response to osteochondral grafts than was thought previously. Bone allografts induce cell-mediated and antibody-mediated cytotoxicity specific for donor antigens similar to that seen after organ transplantations. Not only the basic mechanisms of bone allograft rejection but also the clinical features of bone allograft rejection are poorly characterized. Clinically, new non-invasive imaging techniques should be applied in determining the metabolic activity of bone in order to find the optimal loading of healing allografts. Although the clinical results of massive bone allografts are still not completely predictable, the method has proved to be a technically and biologically feasible alternative for non-biological skeletal reconstructions.     

The Ranawat Award. Histology of nine structural bone grafts used in total knee arthroplasty

The cross section radiographs and histology of nine bone grafts were examined to determine whether grafts are durable enough to support a total knee implant when the load is shared by host bone, graft bone, and a stemmed component. All cases had cemented total knee arthroplasties with stemmed components adjacent to bulk grafts. The cases included autografts and allografts, which had been in situ for an average of 41 months (range, 20-62 months). Seven of the grafts were retrieved postmortem from three patients (four knees), and two were retrieved at revision surgery from one patient. The allografts all were intact, but had not revascularized. The autografts were viable bone. New bone was being laid down on the dead graft bone at the periphery of the allografts. No change in the bone to cement interface, no graft collapse, no development of radiolucent lines, and no component loosening occurred in these cases. The promising clinical results of bone grafts in total knee arthroplasties were confirmed by the examination of these grafts at the cellular level. Using stemmed components in bone grafted knee reconstructions may have increased graft durability and protected the grafts from fatigue failure.     

Haptoglobin polymorphism, iron metabolism and mortality in HIV infection

Simultaneous ACL and PCL ruptures are rare but serious injuries resulting in distinct instability of the knee joint followed by an early degenerative arthritis. This combined trauma, which is often accompanied by additional ligament lesions, originates from a knee dislocation. While the conservative treatment of this complex instability is abandoned, the operative procedures are not yet standardised. The timing of the cruciate ligament reconstruction depends on the additional injuries, but generally the postprimary treatment is performed. Autografts and allografts, which can be also combined, are available for the reconstruction of the cruciate ligaments. The arthroscopic assisted operation starts with the drilling of all tibial and femoral tunnels using standard ACL and PCL arthroscopic instruments. The PCL is positioned after the graft has been transported into the joint through an anterolateral port, the ACL graft is positioned through the tibial drill hole and both are anchored first on the femoral and then on the tibial site i.e. with interference screws. In the postoperative rehabilitation neither immobilisation nor brace are used and progressive range of motion is allowed. The arthroscopic assisted reconstructions of the ACL and increasingly of the PCL are becoming standard procedures, but the technically difficult combined ACL/PCL reconstruction is restricted to a small number of arthroscopists. The first clinical results demonstrate, that the arthroscopic operation is comparable to the open reconstruction.     

Articular cartilage transplantation

This report describes the biopsy findings in four of 30 patients treated with cadaver osteochondral shell allografts for osteoarthritis in the knee. This study demonstrates that graft cartilage cells can survive in excess of 25 months, and that host bone can completely replace graft bone by creeping substitution. An inflammatory reaction in synovium and bone marrow was found in only one of four cases. Graft failure was related to prolonged down time of donor cartilage in one case and mechanical factors related to osteoarthritis in the apposing femoral surface in other cases. The clinical success of these grafts is attributed to the prolonged viability of cartilage cells, the capacity of host bone to join graft cartilage without histologic reaction, and the host's immunologic tolerance, which obviates the need for immunosuppressive therapy.     

A comparison of patellar tendon autograft and allograft used for anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction in the goat model

Similar-sized patellar tendon autografts and fresh-frozen allografts were used to reconstruct the anterior cruciate ligament of one knee in 40 female goats. Evaluations of the reconstructions and contralateral controls at the 6-week and 6-month postoperative periods included anterior-posterior translation, mechanical properties determined during tensile failure tests, measurement of cross-sectional area, histology, collagen fibril size and area distribution, and associated articular cartilage degenerative changes. Six months after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction, the autografts demonstrated a smaller increase in anterior-posterior displacement, values of maximum force to failure two times greater, a significant increase in cross-sectional area, a more rapid loss of large-diameter collagen fibrils, and an increased density and number of small-diameter collagen fibrils compared to the allografts. Clinical significance. More surgeons are allowing their patients to return to running and sports 6 months after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. While the structural and material properties of autografts and allografts at time zero are similar, in the goat model during the first 6 months they differ. The allografts demonstrate a greater decrease in their implantation structural properties, a slower rate of biologic incorporation, and the prolonged presence of an inflammatory response. At 6 months the autograft demonstrates a more robust biologic response, improved stability, and increased strength to failure values.     

Carbon-fiber implants for knee ligament reconstruction. 10-year results

The retrospective results of carbon prostheses for knee ligament reconstruction in 120 patients, as established by questionnaire, are reported at 10 +/- 2 years follow-up. Eighty patients could also be reviewed clinically. Some 60% of the patients showed good subjective function at reduced activity level. Complications were seen in 72.5% of the patients with rupture of the carbon prosthesis and in 68% of those with synovitis. X-ray showed osteoarthritis in up to 59% of the patients. Carbon prostheses for collateral ligament reconstruction (85% medial, 5.8% lateral) were successful in 75% of cases. Activity and time seem to be less responsible for failure of the carbon prostheses than the features of growing in. Destruction of the knee joint over time is due to reactive synovitis and catabolic enzyme reaction and correlates with joint effusion and pain. If these problems appear, (arthroscopic) resection of the synovia is indicated to interrupt the circulus vitiosus.     

Structural allograft in two-stage revisions for failed septic hip arthroplasty

We report 11 patients having revision of total hip arthroplasty using massive structural allografts for failure due to sepsis and associated bone loss. All patients had a two-stage reconstruction and the mean follow-up was 47.8 months (24 to 72). Positive cultures were obtained at the first stage in nine of the 11 patients, with Staphylococcus epidermidis being the most common organism. The other two patients had draining sinuses with negative cultures. There was no recurrence of infection in any patient. The mean increase in the modified Harris hip score was 45 and all the grafts appeared to have united to host bone. Two patients required additional procedures, but only one was related to the allograft. Complications included an incomplete sciatic nerve palsy and one case of graft resorption. Our results support the use of massive allografts in failed septic hip arthroplasty in which there is associated bone loss.     

Minimally invasive knee joint surgery

The treatment of knee joint injuries has seen a marked development. Arthroscopy is standard for diagnostic purposes, for meniscus resection and meniscus refixation. Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction may be performed mini-invasive by arthroscopic or mini-open technique with comparable result. Drill guide systems and fixation techniques allow for precise and stable graft placement. Posterior cruciate ligament surgery is presently undergoing a similar process of optimisation as ACL surgery has some years ago. The surgical trauma of intraarticular fracture reconstruction was also reduced significantly. Retrograde nailing, percutaneous plating and specific exposures to distal femur and proximal tibia fractures have been established. Percutaneous osteosynthesis controlled by arthroscopy or fluoroscopy is widely used for B-fractures of the tibial plateau. Injectable bone mineral cement adds to reduced trauma of surgical treatment of these fractures. Mini-invasive knee surgery will develop rapidly in the coming years.     

Septic arthritis of the knee following anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: results of a survey of sports medicine fellowship directors

To determine the incidence of joint sepsis following anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction and the prevailing attitudes toward its treatment, we surveyed the directors of Sports Medicine Fellowship programs about their practices in treating and preventing this complication. Of the 74 surgeons surveyed, 61 (82%) responded. These 61 surgeons performed an average of 98 ACL reconstructions yearly; 31 (51 %) routinely used a drain after ACL surgery, 18 (30%) had treated an ACL infection within the past 2 years, and 26 (43%) had treated an infection within the past 5 years. There was no significant difference in the number of infections and the surgeons' case load, graft choice, or method of reconstruction. Fifty-two surgeons (85%) selected culture-specific intravenous (IV) antibiotics and surgical irrigation of the joint with graft retention as initial treatment for the infected patellar tendon autograft, and 39 (64%) chose this regimen to treat the infected allograft. For the resistant infection unresponsive to initial treatment, IV antibiotics with surgical irrigation and graft retention were also selected as the most common treatment combination for 25 (39%) of the 61 respondents. After graft removal, the earliest a revision procedure would be considered was 6 to 9 months. The results of this survey confirm the widely held belief that septic arthritis of the knee is a relatively rare complication following ACL reconstruction. Once an infection is encountered, culture-specific IV antibiotics and surgical joint irrigation with graft retention are recommended as initial treatment. Graft excision and hardware removal is considered only for those infections resistant to initial treatment and for the infected allograft.     

Efficacy of perichondrium and a trabecular demineralized bone matrix for generating cartilage

A pedicled auricular perichondrial flap wrapped around trabecular demineralized bovine bone matrix can generate an autologous cartilage graft. In earlier experimental studies, it was demonstrated that this graft could be used for nasal and cricoid reconstruction. It was assumed that the vascularization of the perichondrial flap was obligatory, but it was never proven that the flap should be pedicled. Moreover, for clinical use, the dimensions of the auricle would set restrictions to the size of the graft generated. Therefore, the possibility to generate cartilage with a composite graft of a free perichondrial flap wrapped around demineralized bovine bone matrix, by using young New Zealand White rabbits, was studied. This composite graft was implanted at poorly (subcutaneously in the abdominal wall; n = 12), fairly (subcutaneously in the pinna; n = 12), and well-vascularized sites (quadriceps muscle; n = 12). As a control, trabecular demineralized bovine bone matrix was implanted without perichondrial cover. Half of these grafts (n = 6) were harvested after 3 weeks, and the remaining grafts (n = 6) after 6 weeks of implantation. In histologic sections of these grafts, the incidence of cartilage formation was scored. Furthermore, the amount of newly formed cartilage was calculated by computerized histomorphometry. Trabecular demineralized bovine bone matrix without perichondrial cover demonstrated early resorption; no cartilage or bone was formed. In demineralized bovine bone matrix wrapped in perichondrium, early cartilage formed after 3 weeks at well- and fairly vascularized sites. No cartilage could be detected in grafts placed at a poorly vascularized site after 3 weeks; minimal cartilage formed after 6 weeks. In summary, the highest incidence of cartilage formed when trabecular demineralized bovine bone matrix was wrapped either in a pedicled auricular perichondrial flap or in a free perichondrial flap, which was placed at a well-vascularized site. Second, a significantly higher percentage of the total area of the graft was cartilaginized at well-vascularized sites after 3 weeks. The newly generated cartilage contained collagen type II and proteoglycans with hyaluronic acid binding regions, whereas collagen type I was absent, indicating the presence of hyaline cartilage. This study demonstrates that new cartilage suitable for a graft can be generated by free perichondrial flaps, provided that the site of implantation is well vascularized. Consequently, the size of such a graft is no longer limited to the dimensions of the auricle.     

Newer knowledge of the immunology of bone and cartilage

By the use of modern techniques, the nature of the immunological response to bone and cartilage grafts is becoming clear. Fresh bone, whether cancellous or cortical, will elicit a cell-mediated immunological response; removal of the bone marrow has little effect in reducing immunogenicity. Antibodies against cellular components of the graft are detectable in the recipient only when host and donor have a disparity for the major histocompatibility (H) antigen. Treatment of bone grafts, for the bone bank, by freezing removes their immunogenicity with regard to antibody production but leaves them capable of stimulating the cellmediated immune response. Freeze drying, on the other hand, impairs immunogenicity for both types of responses. Cartilage, grafted alone, is probably non-antigenic as far as both immune responses are concerned and, although there have been a few reports of stimulation of CMI and antibody production by cartilage, these have not been confirmed. Cartilage cells do, however, possess antigens of the major H-antigen system. The cartilage graft is therefore antigenic but only feebly immunogenic, as the matrix proteoglycans protect the cells from the afferent arm of the immune response. Osteoarticular allografts, consisting of both bone and cartilage, sensitize the host due to their bone components. The effect of the immune response upon the bone allograft is to destroy the graft-derived first phase of osteogenesis which, in turn, leads to a poor or non-existent host phase of new bone formation in most allografts. The exact effector mechanism by means of which this destruction is brought about is not known. Bone grafts may be protected from the immune response by use of immunosuppressive measures. Cartilage enjoys a considerable measure of protection from immunological effectors by virtue of its matrix. If this breaks down then the cartilage can become permeable to antibodies. It is suggested that "lymphokines," produced by sensitized lymphocytes, may play some role in destroying the cartilage graft.     

Meniscal allograft transplantation for unicompartmental arthritis of the knee

Sixty-seven meniscal allografts were transplanted in the knees of 63 patients between 1988 and 1994. Before surgery, all patients experienced refractory disabling knee pain secondary to a prior total meniscectomy with advanced unicompartmental osteoarthritic changes as verified by arthroscopy. At a mean followup of 31 months (range, 1.0-5.5 years), 58 knees (86.6%) attained a good to excellent results-Twenty-one knees received isolated meniscal allografts, with 19 achieving good to excellent results (90.5%). Five knees received a medial or lateral meniscal allograft with an anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction, and 4 (80.0%) obtained good to excellent results. Thirty-four knees received a meniscal allograft in combination with either a valgus high tibial osteotomy, varus high tibial osteotomy, or varus distal femoral osteotomy to correct for preoperative varus or valgus deformities, with 29 (85.3%) attaining good to excellent results. The remaining 7 knees underwent a combined medial meniscal allograft, valgus high tibial osteotomy, and anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with 6 (85.7%) attaining good to excellent results. The most frequent complication was a traumatic posterior horn tear in 6 knees at a mean of 21 months after surgery (range, 9-43 months), most likely the consequence of unsuccessful healing of the posterior horn of the graft.     

Reoperations of total hip prosthesis with acetabular reconstruction using bone allografts]

Detachment of the acetabular segment is the most important long-term problem with total hip prostheses. We analyzed long-term outcome in our first 48 acetabular reconstructions with cryopreserved allografts. Among the 48 hips operated on with this technique, 38 were reassessed after a mean follow-up of 7 years 3 months (range 5 years-9 years 6 months). Mean age of the population at surgery was 63 years. There were two predominant etiologies: sequelae of chronic hip luxation and primary osteoarthrosis of the hip. In 10 cases with massive destruction, the Müller ring was used to stabilize the allograft. Results were assessed at 6 months, 2 years, 4 years and at longest follow-up using the Merle d'Aubigné clinical assessment scale. For the radiographic assessment, the Ranawat criteria were used to evaluate the alignment of the reconstruction. Clinically, patient comfort was improved in all cases with significant pain relief. Radiologically, mean acetabular ascention was 5 mm and mean medialization was 3.5 mm. A rim was observed in 24 cases including 19 measuring less than 2 cm. Acetabular loosening was evidenced in the 5 other cases where the rim measured more than 2 mm. In 4 of these 5 cases, the acetabulum had migrated to a new setting. The radiographic image then remained unchanged. Analysis of our 38 first cases showed that bone allografts with cimented acetabulum, sometimes with a stabilizing ring, is one of the possible solutions for difficult acetabular reconstructions. However, after a 7 years 3 months follow-up, we have had five (13%) aseptic displacements including one case requiring reoperation. In the 33 stable joints (87%) with good results reconstruction has achieved a nearly perfect anatomic position, similar to first intention arthroplasty with the use of perfectly stabilized bone grafts with a maximal acetabular surface. Our follow-up is longer than most published in the literature. However, the migration rate of 13% it is still too short to draw any conclusion concerning the long-term outcome in our patients, despite their older age and reduced physical activity compared with primary hip arthroplasty patients.     

Golden standard: patellar tendon-plasty--technique and management of postoperative complications]

ACL reconstruction with a patellar tendon autograft has reached a high grade of perfection. Surgery can be performed mini-open or arthroscopically, both techniques are presently equal in morbidity and results. The optimal insertion areas for the graft have been defined and can be controlled intra- and postoperatively by radiographs. The bone blocks of the graft allow for stable fixation and an aggressive functional rehabilitation program stressing active full extension of the joint. Disadvantages are a certain donor site morbidity and a rate of restrictions in range-of-motion. The management of arthrofibrosis should address the pathogenesis. Localized arthrofibrosis is caused by a mechanical conflict in the knee and removal of the mechanical block will usually solve the problem. Generalized arthrofibrosis is a complex process involving the entire joint and resulting in a wide-spread proliferative reaction of the connective tissue. The surgical management must be more complex involving open debridement and capsulotomies.     

Cell survival following bone-anterior cruciate ligament-bone allograft transplantation: DNA fingerprints, segregation, and collagen morphological analysis of multiple markers in the canine model

Bone-anterior cruciate ligament-bone allograft transplantation has become recognized as a potential solution to reconstruction of the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL). The purpose of this study was to determine the time-dependent fibrocyte donor cell survival rate after cryopreserved bone-ACL-bone allograft transplantation. Additionally, bony incorporation of the pediculated bone plugs was examined. The ability to successfully transplant allogenous ACL fibrocytes and have them survive has not previously been documented. In this study, DNA fingerprints identified and documented the survival rate of the cellular DNA in transplanted ACL allografts for ACL re-construction in the knee joints of 10 skeletally mature dogs. At 4, 8, 26 and 52 weeks after ACL allograft transplantation, DNA probes, H & E, Giemsa, Goldner, PAS and polarized light staining was done to demonstrate the time-dependent changes in the allografts after transplantation. At 4 weeks host fibrocytes began to grow into the graft; however, histologically the cells could not be distinguished as to host or donor origin. After 4 weeks the DNA pattern reflected only the band pattern of the host. This reveals the early cellular infiltration activity of the host into the ACL allograft, also demonstrated in the light microscopy stainings. The survival rate of transplanted allogenous ACL fibrocytes had not been documented before this study. There is no evidence that ACL allograft cells survive in the intra-articular environment of the host's knee. Within 4 weeks ACL allografts became completely repopulated with host cells. The cells that migrate early into the ACL allografts are probably of synovial origin because they are present before revascularization and collagen reorganization occur. We conclude from this study that viable cells in transplanted ACL allografts did not survive longer than 4 weeks after intra-articular transplantation. Advances in molecular biology may offer new approaches to alter or stimulate fibrocyte population and function in the transplanted ACL allograft used for ACL reconstruction. New methods to maintain the viability of donor cells may be necessary to improve the biomechanical and histological properties of autografts or allografts for ACL reconstruction.     

Contents of total and protein-bound carbohydrates are low in leukemic leukocytes from patients with acute myelogenous leukemia

The successful approach to the failed knee with bone deficiency is dependent upon thorough planning prior to surgery in order to have the resources available in terms of adequate bone allograft and suitable revision implants. The approximate size of bone stock deficiency can be calculated from preoperative radiographs and similarly ligamentous incompetence can often be diagnosed clinically prior to surgery. Smaller defects of up to 1 to 1.5 cm in depth and localized in the main to a single side of the tibial plateau or to a single femoral condyle can be dealt with using smaller grafts that may be local autograft or allograft, or modular wedges. Larger tibial defects can be compensated for using conventional revision systems by thicker polyethylene and augmented baseplates, but once the flexion-extension gap reaches approximately 40 mm this is no longer possible and structural graft or customized componentry becomes necessary. Femoral defects larger than about 1 cm that cannot be made up by augments necessitate grafting. The need to use a large proximal tibial allograft also may dictate the operative approach used to expose the joint, especially in the situation of a multiply-operated tight knee. In such cases the use of a quadriceps turndown may be more advisable than the use of a tibial tubercle osteotomy as the osteotomy may well not have an adequate bed to heal to following the reconstruction. Several series have reported cases of patellar tendon avulsion and the clinical results following this complication usually are not satisfactory. Preoperatively it is important to identify, if possible, the case that is likely to require a more extended approach because of a tight soft tissue envelope. The reports of results of series of revision total knee arthroplasty in the setting of significant bone loss are at present confined to short-term followup. The clinical results of these series are satisfactory at this early point in time, but decision regarding the durability of reconstructions requiring major structural allografting awaits longer-term study. Of concern is the devastating complication of infection following such revision surgery, the risk of which is amplified in the setting of prior infection. In addition, the long-term viability of major structural grafts in the setting of loading is uncertain as the risk of graft collapse in the process of incorporation is not known. Notwithstanding these concerns, major grafting is sometimes the only recourse to achieve satisfactory revision of a failed arthroplasty. The use of such major grafts is therefore cautiously supported and because of the risks inherent in such surgery we believe that such surgery should be carried out in the setting of specialist interest units.     

Reimplantation of autoclaved tumour bone in limb salvage surgery

This is a prospective clinical study of 7 patients with malignant bone tumours who were treated by resection of the tumour, followed with reconstruction by reimplantation of the resected autoclaved tumour bone. There were 3 male and 4 female patients between 10 and 36 years of age. All the tumours were Stage IIB. Five of the 7 were in the region of the knee joint. Histologically, 5 were osteosarcomas, 1 a recurrent chondrosarcoma and 1 a recurrent Ewing's sarcoma. All the patients were treated by en bloc resection of the tumour with wide margins. The resected length ranged from 13 cm to 28 cm. After removal of soft tissue and cartilage, the resected bone segment was autoclaved for 5 min at 132 degrees C and 29 pounds per square inch pressure (0.2 mega Pascal). This autoclaved segment of bone was then reimplanted and fixed with an appropriate implant. The average follow-up was 20 months with a range of 14 to 27 months. None of the tumours recurred and, at the most recent follow-up, all the patients were alive, 6 with no evidence of disease and one with a lung metastasis. Six of the 7 patients were available for radiological assessment. Solid bone union was seen in 4 patients, delayed union in 1 and nonunion in 1. This method of reconstruction using an autoclaved tumour bone graft is useful in countries where facilities for allograft or tumour prostheses are not available owing to financial, technical or sociocultural reasons.     

The effects of an artificial meniscus substitute in a knee joint with a resected anterior cruciate ligament. An experimental study in rabbits

A Dacron meniscus prosthesis was substituted for the medial meniscus in an anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) resected rabbit knee. At three months, the joints were evaluated biomechanically, with gross and histologic inspection. In a paired comparison with the contralateral knee, differences between ACL resection with intact, incised, or resected medial menisci were evaluated. Knees with intact menisci and ligaments served as controls. Because of cartilage destruction, soft-tissue hypertrophy, and increased anterior laxity, joint stiffness was less than normal in all ACL-resected knees. Ingrowth and stable fixation, especially of the posterior horns of the prostheses and the incised menisci, were rare. Almost all normal menisci had ruptured in the same area. Anterior cruciate ligament resection led to severe osteoarthrosis in both compartments, regardless of initial meniscal treatment. Knees with prostheses had the same incidence and severity of osteoarthrosis as knees with meniscus resection. Anterior cruciate ligament resection alone induced excessive osteoarthrosis and synovitis and diminished the effects of different meniscal treatments three months earlier.     

All-inside anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction using semitendinosus tendon and soft threaded biodegradable interference screw fixation

A modification of anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction using a minimally invasive and endoscopic all-inside technique is presented. Both the femoral and tibial socket are approached through the joint so that there is no open tibial tunnel, which otherwise often causes significant pain and discomfort during early rehabilitation. The autologous semitendinosus tendon is harvested with a bone plug attached to its tibial insertion. The triple-stranded semitendinosus tendon is looped around the adjacent bone plug and fixed at the original tibial attachment site of the ACL using a soft threaded biodegradable poly-(D,L-lactide) interference screw. The screw is inserted endoscopically in an inside-out direction. In the femoral socket the graft is fixed without a bone plug directly to the tunnel wall using the biodegradable screw. The free part of the graft is thus not longer than the intra-articular distance, which may increase stiffness of the construct.     

The effects of knee reconstruction on combined anterior cruciate ligament and anterolateral capsular deficiencies

We tested the effect of intraarticular reconstructions of the anterior cruciate ligament alone and in combination with extraarticular reconstructions in 10 cadaveric knees. These knees had anterior cruciate ligament deficiency alone or in combination with anterolateral capsuloligamentous deficiencies. In the knees with combined injury, intraarticular reconstruction returned anterior stability to levels not significantly different from levels found for the knees deficient in the anterior cruciate ligament alone and treated with this procedure. After intraarticular reconstruction, rotational stability of the knee with combined injuries failed to return to the levels seen in the knee with isolated anterior cruciate ligament deficiencies that underwent the same treatment. When a tenodesis with either 0 N or 22 N of tension was added to the intraarticular reconstruction in the knee with combined injuries, we found that excessive internal rotation significantly decreased at all angles of flexion, except at full extension with 0 N of tension. In addition, the extraarticular reconstruction with 22 N of tension in the tenodesis overconstrained the knee in internal rotation between 30 degrees and 90 degrees of knee flexion. The tenodesis with 0 N of tension overconstrained the knee at only 60 degrees and 90 degrees of flexion. These results suggest extraarticular reconstruction as an adjunct to the intraarticular operation for the knee with anterior cruciate ligament and anterolateral structural injuries. The results also suggest that the surgeon can affect anterior and rotational laxity by adjusting the tension in the tenodesis.