The effect of microstructures on fatigue crack growth in Q345 steel welded joint

It is a traditional that the fatigue crack growth behavior is sensitive to microstructure in threshold regime, while it is sensitive to R‐ratio in Paris regime. Fatigue test is carried out for welded joints of a Q345 steel where the compact tension specimens with 3.8 and 12.5 mm thickness are used, and comparisons of fatigue crack growth behavior between base metal and a few different locations in the welded joint are considered in Paris regime. Welding residual stresses are removed by heat treatment to focus the study on the microstructural effect. It is shown that fatigue crack growth rate (FCGR) in the base metal is not sensitive to R‐ratio, but the FCGR increases in the overheated zone, the fusion zone and the weld metal zone with R‐ratio increasing. To the low R‐ratio, FCGR in the three zones is smaller than that in the base metal, but they approximate the same with base metal under the high R‐ratio. The mechanism of fatigue crack growth is analyzed through crack path in microstructures and SEM fractograph. The coarse‐grained ferrite in the base metal is of benefit to relaxation of the average stress at the crack tip, and the fatigue crack growth predicts branching and deflection within above different locations in the welded joint. These tortuous crack paths with crack branching and deflection will promote crack closure as well as crack‐tip stress shielding and then resulted in higher crack growth resistance.     

Mechanisms for corrosion fatigue crack propagation

ABSTRACT The corrosion fatigue crack growth (FCG) behaviour, the effect of applied potential on corrosion FCG rates, and the fracture surfaces were studied for high‐strength low‐alloy steels, titanium alloys, and magnesium alloys. During investigation of the effect of applied potential on corrosion FCG rates, polarization was switched on for a time period in which it was possible to register the change in the crack growth rate corresponding to the open‐circuit potential and to measure the crack growth rate under polarization. Due to the higher resolution of the crack extension measurement technique, the time rarely exceeded 300 s. This approach made possible the observation of a non‐single mode effect of cathodic polarization on corrosion FCG rates. Cathodic polarization accelerated crack growth when the maximum stress intensity (K_max) exceeded a certain well‐defined critical value characteristic for a given material‐solution combination. When K_max was lower than the critical value, the same cathodic polarization, with all other conditions (specimen, solution, pH, loading frequency, stress ratio, temperature, etc.) being equal, retarded or had no influence on crack growth. The results and fractographic observations suggested that the acceleration in crack growth under cathodic polarization was due to hydrogen‐induced cracking (HIC). Therefore, critical values of K_max, as well as the stress intensity range (ΔK) were regarded as corresponding to the onset of corrosion FCG according to the HIC mechanism and designated as K_HIC and ΔK_HIC. HIC was the main mechanism of corrosion FCG at K_max > K_HIC (ΔK > ΔK_HIC). For most of the material‐solution combinations investigated, stress‐assisted dissolution played a dominant role in the corrosion fatigue crack propagation at K_max < K_HIC (ΔK < ΔK_HIC).     

Prediction of fatigue crack growth under constant amplitude loading and a single overload based on elasto-plastic crack tip stresses and strains

It is generally accepted that the fatigue crack growth (FCG) depends mainly on the stress intensity factor range (ΔK) and the maximum stress intensity factor (K_max). The two parameters are usually combined into one expression called often as the driving force and many various driving forces have been proposed up to date. The driving force can be successful as long as the stress intensity factors are appropriately correlated with the actual elasto-plastic crack tip stress-strain field. However, the correlation between the stress intensity factors and the crack tip stress-strain field is often influenced by residual stresses induced in due course.A two-parameter (ΔK_tot, K_max,tot) driving force based on the elasto-plastic crack tip stress-strain history has been proposed. The applied stress intensity factors (ΔK_appl, K_max,appl) were modified to the total stress intensity factors (ΔK_tot, K_max,tot) in order to account for the effect of the local crack tip stresses and strains on fatigue crack growth. The FCG was predicted by simulating the stress-strain response in the material volume adjacent to the crack tip and estimating the accumulated fatigue damage. The fatigue crack growth was regarded as a process of successive crack re-initiations in the crack tip region. The model was developed to predict the effect of the mean and residual stresses induced by the cyclic loading. The effect of variable amplitude loadings on FCG can be also quantified on the basis of the proposed model. A two-parameter driving force in the form of: was derived based on the local stresses and strains at the crack tip and the Smith-Watson-Topper (SWT) fatigue damage parameter: D = σ_maxΔε/2. The effect of the internal (residual) stress induced by the reversed cyclic plasticity manifested itself in the change of the resultant (total) stress intensity factors controlling the fatigue crack growth.The model was verified using experimental fatigue crack growth data for aluminum alloy 7075-T6 obtained under constant amplitude loading and a single overload.     

Elastic correction of fatigue crack growth laws

Fatigue crack growth (FCG) is usually studied assuming that ΔK is the driving parameter. An effective ΔK is considered in the presence of crack closure. However, after crack opening, there is an elastic regime that does not contribute to FCG. The objective here is to quantify this elastic range of ΔK, ΔK_el, for different loading conditions and material properties. The yield stress was found to be the most important material parameter, followed by the hardening exponent. A linear decrease of ΔK_el with ΔK was found for the 7050‐T6, 6082‐T6, and 6016‐T4 aluminium alloys, while the 304L stainless steel presented a slight increase. On the other hand, the increase of K_max was found to increase the elastic fatigue range. Relatively high values of elastic range were obtained for the plane strain state, compared with the plane stress state.     

Fatigue behaviour of friction stir welded AA2024‐T3 alloy: longitudinal and transverse crack growth

The fatigue crack growth properties of friction stir welded joints of 2024‐T3 aluminium alloy have been studied under constant load amplitude (increasing‐ΔK), with special emphasis on the residual stress (inverse weight function) effects on longitudinal and transverse crack growth rate predictions (Glinka's method). In general, welded joints were more resistant to longitudinally growing fatigue cracks than the parent material at threshold ΔK values, when beneficial thermal residual stresses decelerated crack growth rate, while the opposite behaviour was observed next to K_C instability, basically due to monotonic fracture modes intercepting fatigue crack growth in weld microstructures. As a result, fatigue crack growth rate (FCGR) predictions were conservative at lower propagation rates and non‐conservative for faster cracks. Regarding transverse cracks, intense compressive residual stresses rendered welded plates more fatigue resistant than neat parent plate. However, once the crack tip entered the more brittle weld region substantial acceleration of FCGR occurred due to operative monotonic tensile modes of fracture, leading to non‐conservative crack growth rate predictions next to K_C instability. At threshold ΔK values non‐conservative predictions values resulted from residual stress relaxation. Improvements on predicted FCGR values were strongly dependent on how the progressive plastic relaxation of the residual stress field was considered.     

Effect of sudden load decrease on the fatigue crack growth in cold drawn prestressing steel

This paper analyzes the overload retardation effect (ORE) on the fatigue crack growth (FCG) of cold drawn prestressing steel when different loading sequences are used. The ORE is more intense for elevated load decrease or for low initial stress intensity factor (SIF) range ΔK₀. A transient stage can be observed in the Paris curve (da/dN–ΔK) when the K_maxΔK value suddenly decreases, associated with the ORE and with the evolution of the plastic zone and compressive residual stresses near the crack tip. In tests with K_max decrease, a small zone appears related to FCG initiation, with a fatigue fractography resembling the tearing topography surface (TTS) mode, and associated with a decrease of crack tip opening displacement (CTOD).     

Effects of stress ratio and temperature on fatigue crack growth in a Ti–6Al–4V alloy

Fatigue thresholds and fatigue crack growth (FCG) rates in corner notched specimens of a forged Ti–6Al–4V aero-engine disk material were investigated at room temperature and 350 °C. The threshold stress intensity range, ΔK_th, was determined by a method involving a step change in stress ratio (the ‘jump in’ method). It was found that for three high stress ratios (R=0.7–0.9), where crack closure effects are widely accepted to be negligible, there were similar ΔK_th values at room temperature and 350 °C under the same R. For a given temperature, ΔK_th was observed to decrease from 3.1 to 2.1 MPam with R increasing from 0.7 to 0.9. The fatigue crack growth rate was influenced by increasing temperature. For high stress ratios, FCG rate at 350 °C was higher than that at room temperature under the same ΔK. For a low stress ratio (R=0.01), higher temperature led to higher FCG rates in the near-threshold regime, but showed almost no effect at higher ΔK. The influence of stress ratio and temperature on threshold and FCG rates was analysed in terms of a K_max effect and the implication of this effect, or related mechanisms, are discussed. In light of this, an equation incorporating the effects of the K_max and fatigue threshold, is proposed to describe FCG rates in the near-threshold and Paris regimes for both temperatures. The predictions compare favourably with experimental data.     

Macromechanics study of stable fatigue crack growth in Al–Cu–Li–Mg–Ag alloy

This study was made on a fresh variety of Al–Li base alloy to investigate the role of ageing precipitates and microstructure dimensions in the fatigue crack growth resistance. The fatigue crack growth rate was measured in three different states of the material (i.e. base metal in T8 condition, friction stir weld and laser beam weld in full‐aged condition). Metallurgical analysis showed that the base metal in T8 temper is precipitation hardened by an equivalent amount of δ′ (AL₃Li), T₁ (AI₂CuLi) and θ′ (AI₂Cu) precipitates. The friction stir weld retained the morphology of strengthening precipitate; however, coarsening of Cu containing precipitates has occurred. On the other hand, laser beam weld showed a different type of CuAl phase morphology, which is characteristic of cast metal. The results of fatigue tests confirmed that fatigue crack growth resistance largely depends on microstructural features, specifically the strengthening phases. The fatigue crack resistance was in the order of base metal > laser beam weldment > friction stir weldment. The CuAl phase played a vital role in the crack closure of the laser beam weldment, thus enhancing the fatigue life as compared with the friction stir weldment, which was evident from the plot between log of da/dN (crack growth in each cycle) and log of ΔK (stress intensity range).     

Generation and analysis of FCG data using a single specimen and Kmax–ΔK testing matrix

A custom method to generate fatigue crack growth (FCG) data requires testing of multiple specimens at different load ratios, R, and the application of a load shedding procedure from pre-cracking level to threshold. In this paper, a novel method of testing has been investigated which utilizing a single specimen and a testing matrix in terms of K_max and ΔK values corresponding to predetermined R-ratios for which FCG data are recorded. Automatic K-controlled tests on 2324-T39 Al alloy were conducted using both increasing and decreasing ΔK procedures while K_max was kept constant. Results show that the increasing ΔK procedure gives less scatter than decreasing ΔK procedure. Also, fatigue crack growth curves near the threshold region obtained from increasing ΔK are above the curves obtained from decreasing ΔK procedure. These differences are explained by means of interaction between cyclic plastic zones and their effect on fatigue damage. The procedure with increasing ΔK demonstrated minimal interaction effects and hence it is recommended for efficient FCG data generation. The proposed procedure reduces testing time, the overall scatter associated with multiple samples and eliminates possible uncertainty linked to the load shedding procedure and its effects on threshold.     

Examination of fatigue crack driving force parameter

Most of the previous parameters that utilized as a crack driving force were established in modifying the parameter K_op in Elber's effective SIF range ΔK_eff(=K_max?K_op). However, the parameters that replaced the traditional parameter K_op were based on different measurements or theoretical calculations, so it is difficult to distinguish their differences. This paper focuses on the physical meaning of compliance changes caused by plastic deformation at the crack tip; the tests were carried out under different amplitude loading for structural steel. Based on these test results, differences of several parameter ΔK_eff in literature are analysed and an improved two‐parameter driving force ΔK_drive(=(K_max)ⁿ(ΔK^∧)^1‐n) has been proposed. Experimental data for several different types of materials taken from literature were used in the analyses. Presented results indicate that the ΔK_drive parameter was equally effective or better than ΔK(=K_max?K_min), ΔK_eff(=K_max?K_op) and ΔK*(= (K_max)^α(ΔK⁺)^1?α) in correlating and predicting the R‐ratio effects on fatigue crack growth rate.     

A two parameter driving force for fatigue crack growth analysis

A model for fatigue crack growth (FCG) analysis based on the elastic–plastic crack tip stress–strain history was proposed. The fatigue crack growth was predicted by simulating the stress–strain response in the material volume adjacent to the crack tip and estimating the accumulated fatigue damage. The fatigue crack growth was regarded as a process of successive crack re-initiation in the crack tip region. The model was developed to predict the effect of the mean stress including the influence of the applied compressive stress. A fatigue crack growth expression was derived using both the plane strain and plane stress state assumption. It was found that the FCG was controlled by a two parameter driving force in the form of: . The driving force was derived on the basis of the local stresses and strains at the crack tip using the Smith–Watson–Topper (SWT) fatigue damage parameter: D=σ_maxΔε/2.The effect of the internal (residual) stress induced by the reversed cyclic plasticity was accounted for the subsequent analysis. Experimental fatigue crack growth data sets for two aluminum alloys (7075-T6 and 2024-T351) and one steel alloy (4340) were used for the verification of the model.     

Multiple mechanisms controlling fatigue crack growth

Recognizing that fatigue is a two‐parameter problem requiring two load parameters to define cyclic loads unambiguously, a unified approach has been developed to account for crack growth behaviour in terms of ΔK and K_max . Since both driving forces govern the crack growth rate, any analysis based on either ΔK or K_max will provide only partial information about the fatigue behavior of materials. It is shown that ΔK–K_max plots and the associated crack growth trajectory maps reflect the basic mechanisms that contribute to crack growth in a material. These plots also provide a convenient basis to recognize the changes in the micromechanisms that can occur as a function of load ratio or crack growth rate, or both. Taking examples from the literature, crack growth trajectory maps are provided showing such changes in the governing mechanisms of crack growth. It is shown that the ΔK–K_max approach is not an alternative to crack closure models, but it reflects the intrinsic material behaviour that must be understood before reliable crack prediction models can be developed.     

Fatigue crack growth property of laser beam welded 6156 aluminium alloy

Fatigue crack growth behaviours in different welding zones of laser beam welded specimens were investigated using central crack tension specimens for 6156 aluminium alloy under constant amplitude loading at nominal applied stress ratio R = 0.5, 0.06, ?1. The experimental results showed that base metal (BM) exhibited superior fatigue crack resistance compared to weld metal (WM) and heat‐affected zone (HAZ). Crack growth resistance of WM was the lowest. The exponent m values for BM and HAZ at different stress ratios are close and around 2.6, while m for WM at different stress ratio is around 4.7. The discrepancy between crack growth rates for WM and BM is more evident with increasing stress ratio, while it is a little change for HAZ and BM. Change of the microstructure in WM deteriorates the resistance of fatigue crack growth compared to BM. It was mainly due to grain boundary liquation and dissolving of second‐phase particles in the weld region. It was also found that the variety of fatigue crack resistance for different welding zones is in conformity with the change of hardness. BM with the highest hardness exhibited the maximum resistance for fatigue crack, and WM with the lowest hardness exhibited the minimum fatigue crack resistance.     

Effect of residual stresses on ductile crack growth resistance

It is well known that residual stresses influence the ductile fracture behaviour. In this paper, a numerical study was performed to assess the effect of residual stresses on ductile crack growth resistance of a typical pipeline steel. A modified boundary layer model was employed for the analysis under plane strain, Mode I loading condition. The residual stress fields were introduced into the finite element model by the eigenstrain method. A sharp crack was embedded in the center of the weld region. The complete Gurson model has been applied to simulate the ductile fracture by microvoid nucleation, growth and coalescence. Results show that tensile residual stresses can significantly reduce the crack growth resistance when the crack growth is small compared with the length scale of the tensile residual stress field. With the crack growth, the effect of residual stresses on the crack growth resistance tends to diminish. The effect of residual stress on ductile crack growth resistance seems independent of the size of geometrically similar welds. When normalized by the weld zone size, the ductile crack growth resistance collapses into one curve, which can be used to assess the structural integrity and evaluate the effect of residual stresses. It has also been found that the effect of residual stresses on crack growth resistance depends on the initial void volume fraction f₀, hardening exponent n and T-stress.     

A fracture mechanics analysis on the fatigue behaviour of cruciform joints of duplex stainless steel

The paper presents the results of an experimental and numerical study on the fatigue behaviour of cruciform load carrying joints made from the duplex stainless steel and failing from the weld root through the weld metal. Fatigue crack growth (FCG) data, obtained in specimens of the weld metal, are presented, as well as threshold data, both obtained for R= 0 and 0.5. The influence of stress ratio is discussed, and the FCGR results are compared with data for low carbon structural steels. S–N data were obtained in the joints, both for R= 0.05 and 0.5, and the fatigue cracking mechanisms were analysed in detail with the SEM. It was found that the cracks propagated very early in the lifetime of the joints, under mixed mode conditions (I + II), but the mode I component was found to be predominant over mode II. The geometries of the cracks were defined in detail from measurements taken in the fracture surfaces. A 2D FE analysis was carried out for the mixed mode inclined cracks obtained at the weld root, and the J‐integral formulations were obtained as a function of crack length and crack propagation angle. The values of the crack propagation angle, θ_i, were obtained for the J_max conditions, and it was found that, in the fatigue tests, the cracks propagated in directions very close to the predicted directions of maximum J. K_I and K_II formulations were obtained, and the K_I data were compared with the formulations given in the PD6493 (BS7910) document, and some differences were found. A more general formulation for K under mixed mode conditions was derived. The derived K solutions were applied to predict the fatigue lives of the joints under crack propagation, and an extremely good agreement was found with the experimental results obtained in the fatigue tests.     

Crack growth behavior and fatigue-life prediction based on worst-case near-threshold data of a large crack for 9310 steel

ABSTRACT Both experimental and analytical investigations were conducted to study crack initiation and growth of small cracks, near‐threshold growth behavior of large cracks at constant R‐ratio/decreasing ΔK and constant K_max/decreasing ΔK, respectively, for 9310 steel. The results showed that a pronounced small‐crack effect was not observed even at R = ?1, small cracks initiated by a slip mechanism at strong slip sites. Worst‐case near‐threshold testing results for large cracks under several K_max values showed that an effect of K_max on the near‐threshold behavior does not exist in the present investigation. A worst‐case near‐threshold test for a large crack, i.e. constant K_max/decreasing ΔK test, can give a conservative prediction of growth behavior of naturally initiated small cracks. Using the worst‐case near‐threshold data for a large crack and crack‐tip constraint factor equations defined in the paper, Newman's total fatigue‐life prediction method was improved. The fatigue lives predicted by the improved method were in reasonable agreement with the experiments. A three‐dimensional (3D) weight function method was used to calculate stress‐intensity factors for a surface crack at a notch of the present SENT specimen (with r/w = 1/8) by using a finite‐element reference solution. The results were verified by limited finite‐element solutions, and agreed well with those calculated by Newman's stress‐intensity factor equations when the stress concentration factor of the present specimen was used in the equations.     

Fatigue crack growth testing at negative stress ratios: discussion on the comparability of testing results

It is an accepted fact in fatigue community that compressive loads contribute to fatigue crack growth. Evidences range from fatigue crack growth under fully compressive loads to effects of compressive underloads to negative stress ratio loading. Because the crack closes under compression and the crack flanks transmit compressive stresses, the loading situation is completely different to those of tensile loading. The present paper addresses the comparability of crack growth testing procedures at negative stress ratios. It reveals that compressive loading at the crack tip differs in different specimens for an equal maximum stress intensity factor K_max and negative stress ratio R. Furthermore, the crack length can significantly influence the loading conditions at the crack tip for tension–compression loading. Depending on the specimen type and crack length, a negative force ratio may lead to a change of algebraic sign of the stresses at the crack tip or not. As a consequence, the comparability of available literature results for R ≤ 0 tests is not ensured. Proposals to improve the comparability of tension–compression crack growth testing will be given.     

Effect of residual stresses on crack behaviour in single edge bending specimens

Residual stresses due to manufacturing processes, such as welding, change the load bearing capacity of cracked components. The effects of residual stresses on crack behaviour in single edge bending specimens were investigated using Finite element analyses. Three parameters (J, Q and R) were used to study the crack behaviour. The J‐integral predicts the size scale over which large stresses and strains exist, the constraint parameter Q describes the crack‐tip constraint as a result of geometry, loading mode and crack depth and the constraint parameter R is used to describe the constraint resulting from residual stresses. To carry out a systematic investigation on the effect of residual stresses on the J‐integral and crack‐tip constraints, models under different combinations of residual stresses and external loads with different crack depths were analysed. It has been shown that the crack‐tip constraint R increased by tensile residual stresses around the crack‐tip. On the other hand, the constraint parameter R decreased and tended to zero at high external load levels.     

The importance of compressive stresses on fatigue crack propagation rate

This paper is concerned with the importance of compressive stresses on crack propagation rate. In a previous paper, namely ‘Crack Closure Inadequacy at Negative Stress Ratios’, Int. Journal of Fatigue, 26, 2004, pp. 241–252, was demonstrated the inadequacy of the crack closure concept and ΔK_eff, at a negative stress ratio, R=−1, to predict crack propagation rate. It that paper was verified that, at negative stress ratios, crack closure changes with P_max, for the same R ratio. The main conclusion was about plastic properties and mainly cyclic plastic properties, the Bauschinger effect included, on crack propagation when compressive stresses exist. It was then suggested that in the place of the crack closure concept, another concept based on plasticity should be used to explain fatigue crack propagation.In this paper, instead of working with the same negative R ratio (R=−1), a study on the behavior of crack propagation rate as a function of R ratio, from negative to positive stress ratios, is made. Both the effect of P_max and of R ratio is taken into consideration. Measurements of roughness and of crack opening loads are made, in order to verify their influence on crack propagation rate. Different materials, in order to cover different cyclic plastic properties and different sensitivities to roughness are studied (Ck45-cyclic hardening; Ti6Al4V-cyclic softening, and aluminum, Al 7175-cyclically neutral) are studied. Aluminium alloys and titanium alloys are considered to be sensitive to roughness induced crack closure (RICC) while steels are more dependent on plastic properties (PICC).In this study it is emphasized the importance of the compressive part of the cycle, and of cyclic plastic properties, on crack propagation rate. It is reassessed the inadequacy of crack closure concept and ΔK_eff to describe crack propagation rate, at negative stress ratios. It is also verified that models based solely on extrinsic properties of materials, like da/dN−ΔK or da/dN−ΔK (K_max) should also incorporate intrinsic properties of the materials in order to properly correlate fatigue crack growth.     

On assumptions associated with ΔKeff and their implications on FCG predictions

In this paper, an assessment of commonly used assumptions associated with ΔK_eff and their implications on FCG predictions in light of existing experimental and numerical data is presented. In particular, the following assumptions are examined: (1). ΔK_eff fully describes cyclic stresses and strains at the crack-tip vicinity. (2). K_op can be determined experimentally or numerically with certain accuracy. (3). Overload alters K_op but not K_max and associated σ_max at the crack-tip ‘process zone’. (4). Contact of crack faces curtails the crack driving force in terms of ΔK_eff.The analysis indicates that there is insufficient support to justify the above assumptions. In contrary, the analysis demonstrates that a two-parameter fatigue crack driving force in terms of ΔK and K_max, which accounts for both applied and the internal stresses should be used in FCG analyses and predictions.