Impact of vacuum operation on hydrogen permeation through a palladium membrane tube

Palladium (Pd) membranes are characterized by their high permselectivity to hydrogen and easy operation, and are promising devises for separating hydrogen from hydrogen-rich gases. The membranes are normally operated with atmospheric pressure at the permeate side. Instead of this common operation, hydrogen permeation through a Pd membrane under vacuum operation at the permeate side is investigated and compared with that under normal operation. In this study, two membrane operating temperatures (320 and 380 °C), four H₂ partial pressure differences (2, 3, 4, and 5 atm) across the membrane, and four feed gases are considered. The results suggest that the vacuum operation can efficiently intensify the H₂ permeation rate. The improvement in H₂ permeation rate due to the vacuum operation can be increased up to 136%. The positive effect of the vacuum operation is especially pronounced when the gas mixtures are used as the feed gases, stemming from the effective attenuation of the concentration polarization. An increase in membrane temperature raises the H₂ permeation rate, but its influence in enhancing the H₂ permeation rate with the vacuum operation is not as significant as that without the vacuum one. It is found that the retardation effect of impurities on the mass transfer is always ranked as CO > CO₂ > N₂, regardless of with/without vacuum operation.     

Optimization of hydrogen enrichment via palladium membrane in vacuum environments using Taguchi method and normalized regression analysis

In this study, the separation of hydrogen from gas mixtures using a palladium membrane coupled with a vacuum environment on the permeate side was studied experimentally. The gas mixtures composed of H₂, N₂, and CO₂ were used as the feed. Hydrogen permeation fluxes were measured with membrane operating temperature in the range of 320–380 °C, pressures on the retentate side in the range of 2–5 atm, and vacuum pressures on the permeate side in the range of 15–51 kPa. The Taguchi method was used to design the operating conditions for the experiments based on an orthogonal array. Using the measured H₂ permeation fluxes from the Taguchi approach, the stepwise regression analysis was also employed for establishing the prediction models of H₂ permeation flux, followed by the analysis of variance (ANOVA) to identify the significance and suitability of operating conditions. Based on both the Taguchi approach and ANOVA, the H₂ permeation flux was mostly affected by the gas mixture composition, followed by the retentate side pressure, the vacuum degree, and the membrane temperature. The predicted optimal operating conditions were the gas mixture with 75% H₂ and 25% N₂, the membrane temperature of 320 °C, the retentate side pressure of 5 atm, and the vacuum degree of 51 kPa. Under these conditions, the H₂ permeation flux was 0.185 mol s^?1 m^?2. A second-order normalized regression model with a relative error of less than 7% was obtained based on the measured H₂ permeation flux.     

Hydrogen permeation enhancement in a Pd membrane tube system under various vacuum degrees

Hydrogen purification using palladium (Pd) membrane technology has been seen as a potential solution for producing pure hydrogen form hydrogen-rich gas. Compared to traditional practices of operating the permeate side of the membrane at atmospheric pressure, in this study, a vacuum is applied. The effects of various vacuum degrees applied to the permeate side of the Pd membrane are investigated and compared to the results under normal operation without a vacuum. The feed gas used for experiments consists of a mixture of hydrogen (70 vol%) and nitrogen (30 vol%). Three membrane operating temperatures (320, 350, and 380 °C), four pressure differences (2, 3, 4, and 5 atm) across the membrane, and four vacuum degrees (−15, −30, −45, and −53 kPa) applied to the permeate side are considered. For the three operating temperatures, the best improvements in the performance of hydrogen permeation are at 320 and 350 °C when a −53 kPa vacuum is applied, resulting in 79.4% and 79.1% improvements, respectively, compared to normal operations. Increasing temperatures leads to an increase in H₂ permeation both with and without a vacuum; however, best performances of H₂ permeation are observed in cases without a vacuum.     

Optimization analysis of hydrogen separation from an H2/CO2 gas mixture via a palladium membrane with a vacuum using response surface methodology

This study uses a palladium membrane to separate hydrogen from an H₂/CO₂ (90/10 vol%) gas mixture. Three different operating parameters of temperature (320–380 °C), total pressure difference (2–3.5 atm), and vacuum degree (15–49 kPa) on hydrogen are taken into account, and the experiments are designed utilizing a central composite design (CCD). Analysis of variance (ANOVA) is also used to analyze the importance and suitability of the operating factors. Both the H₂ flux and CO₂ (impurity) concentration on the permeate side are the targets in this study. The ANOVA results indicate that the influences of the three factors on the H₂ flux follow the order of vacuum degree, temperature, and total pressure difference. However, for CO₂ transport across the membrane, the parameters rank as total pressure difference > vacuum degree > temperature. The predictions of the maximum H₂ flux and minimum CO₂ concentration by the response surface methodology are close to those by experiments. The maximum H₂ flux is 0.2163 mol s^?1 m^?2, occurring at 380 °C, 3.5 atm total pressure difference, and 49 kPa vacuum degree. Meanwhile, the minimum CO₂ concentration in the permeate stream is t 643.58 ppm with the operations of 320 °C, 2 atm total pressure difference, and 15 kPa vacuum degree. The operation with a vacuum can significantly intensify H₂ permeation, but it also facilitates CO₂ diffusion across the Pd membrane. Therefore, a compromise between the H₂ flux and the impurity in the treated gas should be taken into account, depending on the requirement of the gas product.     

Pd–Ag thin film membrane for H2 separation. Part 2. Carbon and oxygen diffusion in the presence of CO/CO2 in the feed and effect on the H2 permeability

The effect of CO and CO₂ on the performance and stability of Pd–Ag thin film membranes prepared by electroless plating deposition (EPD) was investigated, observing the presence of dissociation to carbon and oxygen which slowly diffuse in the membrane influencing also H₂ permeability. The effect of the two carbon oxides was investigated both separately and combined in the 400–450 °C temperature range over long-term cumulative experiments (up to over 350 h) on a membrane that already worked for over 350 h in H₂ or H₂–N₂ mixtures. An increase of the H₂ permeation flux was observed feeding only CO₂ in the range 10–20%. This effect was interpreted as deriving from the facilitated H₂ flux caused from oxygen diffusion (deriving from CO₂ dissociation) in the membrane. CO induces instead a partial inhibition on the H₂ flux deriving from the negative effect of CO competitive chemisorption as well as C diffusion in the membrane, which overcome the positive effect associated to oxygen diffusion in the membrane. Carbon and oxygen diffuse through the membrane with a rate two order of magnitude lower than hydrogen, and recombinate at the permeate side forming CO, CO₂ and CH₄ which amount increases with time-on-stream. The effect is reversible and not associated with the creation of cracks or defects in the membrane, as supported by leak tests.     

High temperature H2/CO2 separation using cobalt oxide silica membranes

In this work high quality cobalt oxide silica membranes were synthesized on alumina supports using a sol–gel, dip coating method. The membranes were subsequently connected into a steel module using a graphite based proprietary sealing method. The sealed membranes were tested for single gas permeance of He, H₂, N₂ and CO₂ at temperatures up to 600 °C and feed pressures up to 600 kPa. Pressure tests confirmed that the sealing system was effective as no gas leaks were observed during testing. A H₂ permeance of 1.9 × 10⁻⁷ mol m⁻² s⁻¹ Pa⁻¹ was measured in conjunction with a H₂/CO₂ permselectivity of more than 1500, suggesting that the membranes had a very narrow pore size distribution and an average pore diameter of approximately 3 Å. The high temperature testing demonstrated that the incorporation of cobalt oxide into the silica matrix produced a structure with a higher thermal stability, able to resist thermally induced densification up to at least 600 °C. Furthermore, the membranes were tested for H₂/CO₂ binary feed mixtures between 400 and 600 °C. At these conditions, the reverse of the water gas shift reaction occurred, inadvertently generating CO and water which increased as a function of CO₂ feed concentration. The purity of H₂ in the permeate stream significantly decreased for CO₂ feed concentrations in excess of 50 vol%. However, the gas mixtures (H₂, CO₂, CO and water) had a more profound effect on the H₂ permeate flow rates which significantly decreased, almost exponentially as the CO₂ feed concentration increased.     

CO2 methanation combined with NH3 decomposition by in situ H2 separation using a Pd membrane reactor

Combination of the reactions by means of membrane separation techniques are of interest. The CO₂ methanation was combined with NH₃ decomposition by in situ H₂ separation through a Pd membrane. The CO₂ methanation reaction in the permeate side was found to significantly enhance the H₂ removal rate of Pd membrane compared to the use of sweep gas. The reaction rate of CO₂ methanation was not influenced by H₂ supply through the Pd membrane in contrast to NH₃ decomposition in the retentate side. However, the CH₄ selectivity could be improved by using a membrane separation technique. This would be caused by the active dissociated H species which might immediately react with adsorbed CO species on the catalysts to CH₄ before those CO species desorbed. From the reactor configuration tests, the countercurrent mode showed higher H₂ removal rate in the combined reaction at 673 K compared to the cocurrent mode but the reaction rate in CO₂ methanation should be improved to maximize the perfomance of membrane reactor.     

Thermal stability and effect of typical water gas shift reactant composition on H2 permeability through a Pd-YSZ-PSS composite membrane

This work comprises a study of hydrogen separation with a composite Pd-YSZ-PSS membrane from mixtures of H₂, N₂, CO and CO₂, typical of a water gas shift reactor. The Pd layer is extended over a tubular porous stainless steel support (PSS) with an intermediate layer of yttria-stabilized-zirconia (YSZ). YSZ and Pd layers were incorporated over the PSS using Atmospheric Plasma Spraying and Electroless Plating techniques, respectively. The Pd and YSZ thickness values are 13.8 and 100 μm, respectively, and the Pd layer is fully dense. Permeation measurements with pure, binary and ternary gases at different temperatures (350–450 °C), trans-membrane pressures (0–2.5 bar) and gas composition have been carried out. Moreover, thermal stability of the membrane was also checked by repeating permeation measurements after several cycles of heating and cooling the system. Membrane hydrogen permeances were calculated using Sieverts' law, obtaining values in the range of 4·10⁻⁵–4·10⁻⁴ mol m⁻² s⁻¹ Pa^−0.5. The activation energy of the permeance was also calculated using Arrhenius' equation, obtaining a value of 16.4 kJ/mol. In spite of hydrogen selectivity being 100% for all experiments, the hydrogen permeability was affected by the composition of feed gas. Thus, a significant depletion in H₂ permeate flux was observed when other gases were in the mixture, especially CO, being also more or less significant depending on gas composition.     

Evaluation of two gas membrane modules for fermentative hydrogen separation

The ability of (dimethyl siloxane) (PDMS) and SAPO 34 membrane modules to separate a H₂/CO₂ gas mixture was investigated in a continuous permeation system in order to decide if they were suitable to be coupled to a biological hydrogen production process. Permeation studies were carried out at relatively low feed pressures ranging from 110 to 180 kPa. The separation ability of SAPO 34 membrane module appeared to be overestimated since the effect concentration polarization phenomena was not taken into consideration in the permeation parameter estimation. On the other hand, the PDMS membrane was the most suitable to separate the binary gas mixture. This membrane reached a maximum CO₂/H₂ separation selectivity of 6.1 at 120 kPa of feed pressure. The pressure dependence of CO₂ and H₂ permeability was not considerable and only an apparent slight decrease was observed for CO₂ and H₂. The mean values of permeability coefficients for CO₂ and H₂ were 3285 ± 160 and 569 ± 65 Barrer, respectively. The operational feed pressure found to be more adequate to operate initially the PDMS membrane module coupled to the fermentation system was 180 kPa, at 296 K. In these conditions it was possible to achieve an acceptable CO₂/H₂ separation selectivity of 5.8 and a sufficient recovery of the CO₂ in the permeate stream.     

H2 PSA purifier for CO removal from hydrogen mixtures

A two-bed PSA purifier was developed to produce high purity hydrogen for fuel cell applications. Two types of hydrogen-rich mixtures produced from coal off-gas were used. Feed 1 consisted of a 99% H₂ mixture (H₂:CO:CO₂:N₂ = 99:0.1:0.05:0.85 vol.%) containing 0.1% CO while Feed 2 was a 95% H₂ mixture (H₂:CO:CO₂:CH₄:N₂ = 95:0.3:0.1:0.05:4.55 vol.%) containing 0.3% CO. An increase in the P/F ratio and adsorption pressure led to an almost linear decrease in H₂ recovery with increasing purity. However, a sharp drop in CO concentration occurred at a specific operating range in both feeds. The feed was purified to 1.1 ppm CO with 99.99+% H₂ purity and 80.0% recovery under 6.5 bar and 0.15 P/F ratio while CO in Feed 2 could be reduced to 6.7 ppm with 99.96% H₂ purity and 78.4% recovery. The PVSA process, which combined vacuum and purge steps, could improve recovery by about 10% compared to the PSA process.     

A CFD study on H2-permeable membrane reactor for methane CO2 reforming: Effect of catalyst bed volume

A 2D axisymmetric model is developed for a H₂-permeable membrane reactor for methane CO₂ reforming. The effect of catalyst bed volume on CH₄ conversion and H₂ permeation rate is investigated. The simulation results indicate that catalyst bed volume with a shell radius of 9 mm is optimal for a tubular Vycor glass membrane with a diameter of 10 mm and H₂ permeance of 2x10⁻⁶ mol/m²/Pa/s. The concentration polarization at the retentate side and the accumulation of H₂ at permeate side make it hard to extract the H₂ production at the zone far from the membrane surface. Though increasing pressure at the retentate side enhances H₂ permeation, CH₄ conversion is even decreased due to unfavorable thermodynamics. And increasing sweep gas flow rate at permeate side benefits to both CH₄ conversion and H₂ permeation. This work highlights the importance of determining the optimal catalyst bed volume to match the membrane in the design of membrane reactors.     

Hydrogen permeation through a Pd-based membrane and RWGS conversion in H2/CO2, H2/N2/CO2 and H2/H2O/CO2 mixtures

This study investigated the effect of gases such as CO₂, N₂, H₂O on hydrogen permeation through a Pd-based membrane −0.012 m² – in a bench-scale reactor. Different mixtures were chosen of H₂/CO₂, H₂/N₂/CO₂ and H₂/H₂O/CO₂ at temperatures of 593–723 K and a hydrogen partial pressure of 150 kPa. Operating conditions were determined to minimize H₂ loss due to the reverse water gas shift (RWGS) reaction. It was found that the feed flow rate had an important effect on hydrogen recovery (HR). Furthermore, an identification of the inhibition factors to permeability was determined. Additionally, under the selected conditions, the maximum hydrogen permeation was determined in pure H₂ and the H₂/CO₂ mixtures. The best operating conditions to separate hydrogen from the mixtures were identified.     

High pressure palladium membrane reactor for the high temperature water-gas shift reaction

The water-gas shift (WGS) catalytic membrane reactor (CMR) incorporating a composite Pd-membrane and operating at elevated temperatures and pressures can greatly contribute to the efficiency enhancement of several methods of H₂ production and green power generation. To this end, mixed gas permeation experiments and WGS CMR experiments have been conducted with a porous Inconel supported, electroless plated Pd-membrane to better understand the functioning and capabilities of those processes. Binary mixtures of H₂/He, H₂/CO₂, and a ternary mixture of H₂, CO₂ and CO were separated by the composite membrane at 350, 400, and 450 °C, 14.4 bar (P_tube = 1 bar), and space velocities up to 45,000 h⁻¹. H₂ permeation inhibition caused by reversible surface binding was observed due to the presence of both CO and CO₂ in the mixtures and membrane inhibition coefficients were estimated. Furthermore, WGS CMR experiments were conducted with a CO and steam feed at 14.4 bar (P_tube = 1 bar), H₂O/CO ratios of 1.1-2.6, and GHSVs of up to 2900 h⁻¹, considering the effect of the H₂O/CO ratio as well as temperature on the reactor performance. Experiments were also conducted with a simulated syngas feed at 14.0 bar (P_tube  = 1 bar), and 400-450 °C, assessing the effect of the space velocity on the reactor performance. A maximum CO conversion of 98.2% was achieved with a H₂ recovery of 81.2% at 450 °C. An optimal operating temperature for high CO conversion was identified at approximately 450 °C, and high CO conversion and H₂ recovery were achieved at 450 °C with high throughput, made possible by the 14.4 bar reaction pressure.     

H2 production via water gas shift in a composite Pd membrane reactor prepared by the pore-plating method

In this work, H₂ production via catalytic water gas shift reaction in a composite Pd membrane reactor prepared by the ELP “pore-plating” method has been carried out. A completely dense membrane with a Pd thickness of about 10.2 μm over oxidized porous stainless steel support has been prepared. Firstly, permeation measurements with pure gases (H₂ and N₂) and mixtures (H₂ with N_2, CO or CO₂) at four different temperatures (ranging from 350 to 450 °C) and trans-membrane pressure differences up to 2.5 bar have been carried out. The hydrogen permeance when feeding pure hydrogen is within the range 2.68–3.96·10⁻⁴ mol m⁻² s⁻¹ Pa^−0.5, while it decreases until 0.66–1.35·10⁻⁴ mol m⁻² s⁻¹ Pa^−0.5 for gas mixtures. Furthermore, the membrane has been also tested in a WGS membrane reactor packed with a commercial oxide Fe–Cr catalyst by using a typical methane reformer outlet (dry basis: 70%H₂–18%CO–12%CO₂) and a stoichiometric H₂O/CO ratio. The performance of the reactor was evaluated in terms of CO conversion at different temperatures (ranging from 350 °C to 400 °C) and trans-membrane pressures (from 2.0 to 3.0 bar), at fixed gas hourly space velocity (GHSV) of 5000 h⁻¹. At these conditions, the membrane maintained its integrity and the membrane reactor was able to achieve up to the 59% of CO conversion as compared with 32% of CO conversion reached with conventional packed-bed reactor at the same operating conditions.     

CFD modeling of hydrogen separation through Pd-based membrane

Hydrogen separation through palladium-based membranes is one of the most promising technologies to produce H₂ gas. The main purpose of this work is to comprehensively study the impact of different parameters on hydrogen diffusion flux (J_H2) through a Pd–Ag membrane. The effect of implementing sweep gas on J_H2 is investigated along with two methods of applying pressure difference, namely pressurized method, and vacuum method. Also, the effect of species mole fraction for three binary mixtures (H₂/N₂, H₂/CO_2, and H₂/CO) is examined. A CFD model is developed and used to perform the study. Experimental data from the literature are used to validate the CFD model, and the results showed good agreement with the experimental data. The results revealed that implementing sweep-gas could significantly improve the hydrogen diffusion flux (by 25%) at the law-pressure difference. Moreover, it turns out that the vacuum method is more effective than the pressurized method, where it results in J_H2 greater than the pressurized method by 15–36%. Furthermore, the CFD results showed that more hydrogen gas can be extracted from a binary mixture of H₂/N₂ (0.93 mol/m².s) than of CO (0.90 mol/m².s) and H₂/CO₂ (0.81 mol/m².s).     

Bench-scale WGS membrane reactor for CO2 capture with co-production of H2

This study investigated the water-gas shift reaction in a bench-scale membrane reactor (M-WGS), where three supported Pd membranes of 44 cm in length and ca. 6 μm in thickness were used, reaching a total membrane surface area of 580.6 cm². The WGS reaction was studied with the syngas mixture: 4.0% CO, 19.2% CO₂, 15.4% H₂O, 1.2% CH₄ and 60.1% H₂, under high temperature/pressure conditions: T = 673 K, p_feed = 20–35 bar(a), p_perm = 15 bar(a), mimicking CO₂ capture with co-production of H₂ in a natural gas fired power plant. High reaction pressure and high permeation of Pd membranes allowed for near complete CO conversion and H₂ recovery. Both the membranes and the membrane reactor demonstrated a long-term stability under the investigated conditions, indicating the potential of M-WGS to substitute conventional systems.     

An improvement of the hydrogen permeability of C/Al2O3 membranes by palladium deposition into the pores

The development of compact hydrogen separator based on membrane technology is of key importance for hydrogen energy utilization, and the Pd-modified carbon membranes with enhanced hydrogen permeability were investigated in this work. The C/Al₂O₃ membranes were prepared by coating and carbonization of polyfurfuryl alcohol, then the palladium was introduced through impregnation–precipitation and colloid impregnation methods with a PdCl₂/HCl solution and a Pd(OH)₂ colloid as the palladium resources, and the reduction was carried out with a N₂H₄ solution. The resulting Pd/C/Al₂O₃ membranes were characterized by means of SEM, EDX, XRD, XPS and TEM, and their permeation performances were tested with H₂, CO₂, N₂ and CH₄ at 25 °C. Compared with the colloid impregnation method, the impregnation–precipitation is more effective in deposition of palladium clusters inside of the carbon layer, and this kind of Pd/C/Al₂O₃ membranes exhibits excellent hydrogen permeability and permselectivity. Best hydrogen permeance, 1.9 × 10⁻⁷ mol/m² s Pa, is observed at Pd/C = 0.1 wt/wt, and the corresponding H₂/N₂, H₂/CO₂ and H₂/CH₄ permselectivities are 275, 15 and 317, respectively.     

Parametric study of membrane reactors for hydrogen production via high-temperature water gas shift reaction

This study presents numerical studies of hydrogen production performance via water gas shift reaction in membrane reactor. The pre-exponential factor in describing the hydrogen permeation flux is used as the main parameter to account for the membrane permeance variation. The operating pressure, temperature and H₂O/CO molar ratio are chosen in the 1–20 atm, 400–600 °C and 1–3 ranges, respectively. Based on the numerical simulation results three distinct CO conversion regimes exist based on the pre-exponential factor value. For low pre-exponential factors corresponding to low membrane permeance, the CO conversion approaches to that obtained from a conventional reactor without hydrogen removal. For high pre-exponential factor, high CO conversion and H₂ recovery with constant values can be obtained. For intermediate pre-exponential factor range both CO conversion and H₂ recovery vary linearly with the pre-exponential factor. In the high membrane permeation case CO conversion and H₂ recovery approach limiting values as the operating pressure increases. Increasing the H₂O/CO molar ratio results in an increase in CO conversion but decrease in H₂ recovery due to hydrogen permeation driving force reduction. As the feed rate increases in the reaction side both the CO conversion and hydrogen recovery decrease because of decreased reactant residence time. The sweep gas flow rate has a significant effect on hydrogen recovery. Low sweep gas flow rate results in low CO conversion H₂ recovery while limiting CO conversion and hydrogen recovery can be reached for the high membrane permeance and high sweep gas flow rate cases.     

Hydrogen permeation and recovery from H2–N2 gas mixtures by Pd membranes with high permeance

Hydrogen separation from H₂–N₂ gas mixtures by means of high-permeance Pd membranes is an appropriate route to gain pure hydrogen for fuel cell applications. To figure out the mass transfer phenomena of H₂ in membrane tubes, H₂ permeation and recovery characteristics of two high-permeance Pd membranes are investigated. Four important factors influencing H₂ permeation, namely, the H₂ pressure difference, H₂ concentration, the flow rate at the exit of the retentate side, and membrane temperature, are taken into account. The experimental results suggest that decreasing H₂ concentration, flow rate, and temperature reduce the permeances of the membranes and H₂ recovery, even though the H₂ pressure difference is identical. The dimensionless permeance, a permeance ratio between H₂–N₂ gas mixture and pure H₂ as feed gases, is used to evaluate the extent of concentration polarization. Within the investigated ranges of the four factors, the dimensionless permeances of the two membranes are in the ranges of 0.022–0.206 and 0.042–0.359, respectively, revealing that the concentration polarization diminishes the permeance of the membranes down to the level within two orders of magnitude. Nevertheless, over 46% of H₂ is recovered.     

A mixed electronic and protonic conducting hydrogen separation membrane with asymmetric structure

In this work, highly doped ceria with lanthanum, La_0.5Ce_0.5O_2−δ (LDC), are developed as hydrogen separation membrane material. LDC presents a mixed electronic and protonic conductivity in reducing atmosphere and good stability in moist CO₂ environment. LDC separation membranes with asymmetrical structure are fabricated by a cost-saving co-pressing method, using NiO + LDC + corn starch mixture as substrate and LDC as top membrane layer. Hydrogen permeation properties are systemically studied, including the influence of operating temperature, hydrogen partial pressure in feed stream and water vapor in both sides of the membrane on hydrogen permeating fluxes. Hydrogen permeability increases as the increasing of temperature and hydrogen partial pressure in feed gas. Using 20% H₂/N₂ (with 3% of H₂O) as feed gas and dry high purity argon as sweep gas, an acceptable flux of 2.6 × 10⁻⁸ mol cm⁻² s⁻¹ is achieved at 900 °C. The existing of water in both sides of membrane has significant effect on hydrogen permeation and the corresponding reasons are analyzed and discussed.