Comparison of HCF life prediction methods based on different critical planes under multiaxial variable amplitude loading

High‐cycle fatigue life prediction methods based on different critical planes, including the maximum shear stress (MSS) plane, the weighted average shear stress plane and the Maximum Variance shear stress plane, are compared by two multiaxial cycle counting methods, i.e. the main and auxiliary channels (MAC) counting and the relative equivalent stress counting. A modified damage model is used to calculate the multiaxial fatigue damage. Compared with the experimental lives for 7075‐T651 aluminium alloy, the predicted results show that the MSS method together with MAC counting is suitable for the multiaxial fatigue life prediction.     

Multiaxial notch fatigue life prediction based on the dominated loading control mode under variable amplitude loading

A new calculation approach is suggested to the fatigue life evaluation of notched specimens under multiaxial variable amplitude loading. Within this suggested approach, if the computed uniaxial fatigue damage by the pure torsional loading path is larger than that by the axial tension–compression loading path, a shear strain‐based multiaxial fatigue damage parameter is assigned to calculate multiaxial fatigue damage; otherwise, an axial strain‐based multiaxial fatigue damage parameter is assigned to calculate multiaxial fatigue damage. Furthermore, the presented method employs shear strain‐based and axial strain‐based multiaxial fatigue damage parameters in substitution of equivalent strain amplitude to consider the influence of nonproportional additional hardening. The experimental data of GH4169 superalloy and 7050‐T7451 aluminium alloy notched components are used to illustrate the presented multiaxial fatigue lifetime estimation approach for notched components, and the results reveal that estimations are accurate.     

Evaluation of fatigue life for titanium alloy TC4 under variable amplitude multiaxial loading

Fatigue tests under variable amplitude multiaxial loading were conducted on titanium alloy TC4 tubular specimens. A method to estimate the fatigue life under variable amplitude multiaxial loading has been proposed. Multiaxial fatigue parameter based on Wu–Hu–Song approach and rainflow cycle counting and Miner–Palmgren rule were applied in this method. The capability of fatigue life prediction for the proposed method was checked against the test data of TC4 alloy under variable amplitude multiaxial loading. The prediction results are all within a factor of two scatter band of the test results.     

Estimating fatigue damage under variable amplitude multiaxial fatigue loading

The present paper is concerned with the use of the modified Wöhler curve method (MWCM) to estimate both lifetime and high‐cycle fatigue strength of plain engineering materials subjected to complex load histories resulting, at critical locations, in variable amplitude (VA) multiaxial stress states. In more detail, when employed to address the constant amplitude (CA) problem, the MWCM postulates that fatigue damage reaches its maximum value on that material plane (i.e. the so‐called critical plane) experiencing the maximum shear stress amplitude, fatigue strength depending on the ratio between the normal and shear stress components relative to the critical plane itself. To extend the use of the above criterion to those situations involving VA loadings, the MWCM is suggested here as being applied by defining the critical plane through that direction experiencing the maximum variance of the resolved shear stress. Such a direction is used also to perform the cycle counting: because the resolved shear stress is a monodimensional quantity, stress cycles are directly counted by the classical rain‐flow method. The degree of multiaxiality and non‐proportionality of the time‐variable stress state at the assumed critical sites instead is suggested as being measured through a suitable stress ratio which accounts for the mean value and the variance of the stress perpendicular to the critical plane as well as for the variance of the shear stress resolved along the direction experiencing the maximum variance of the resolved shear stress. Accuracy and reliability of the proposed approach was checked by using several experimental results taken from the literature. The performed validation exercise seems to strongly support the idea that the approach formalized in the present paper is a powerful engineering tool suitable for estimating fatigue damage under VA multiaxial fatigue loading, and this holds true not only in the medium‐cycle, but also in the high‐cycle fatigue regime.     

Use of an energy‐based/critical plane model to assess fatigue life under low‐cycle multiaxial cycles

For engineering components subjected to multiaxial loading, fatigue life prediction is crucial for guaranteeing their structural security and economic feasibility. In this respect, energy‐based models, integrating the stress and strain components, are widely used because of their availability in fatigue prediction. Through employing the plastic strain energy concept and critical plane approach, a new energy‐based model is proposed in this paper to evaluate the low‐cycle fatigue life, in which the critical plane is defined as the maximum damage plane. In the proposed model, a newly defined NP factor κ^*  is used to quantify the nonproportional (NP) effect so that the damage parameter can be conveniently calculated. Moreover, a simple estimation method of weight coefficient is developed, which can reflect different contributions of shear and normal plastic strain energy on total fatigue damage. Experimental data of 10 kinds of materials are employed to assess the effectiveness of this model as well as three other energy‐based models.     

Fatigue assessment of metallic components under uniaxial and multiaxial variable amplitude loading

In the present paper, the fatigue lifetime of metallic structural components subjected to variable amplitude loading is evaluated by applying 2 different multiaxial high‐cycle fatigue criteria. Such criteria, proposed by some of the present authors, are based on the critical plane approach and aim at reducing a given multiaxial stress state to an equivalent uniaxial stress condition. In particular, the procedure employed by both criteria consists of the following 3 steps: (1) definition of the critical plane; (2) counting of loading cycles; and (3) estimation of fatigue damage. Finally, the previous criteria are validated by comparing the theoretical results with experimental data related to smooth metallic specimens subjected to uniaxial and multiaxial variable amplitude loading.     

An improved critical plane and cycle counting method to assess damage under variable amplitude multiaxial fatigue loading

The plane with the maximum variance of the resolved shear stress is taken as the critical plane. Two algorithms are used along with the maximum variance method (MVM) to determine the orientation of the critical plane. The maximum variance of the normal stress on the potential critical planes is calculated to determine the one experiencing the maximum extent of fatigue damage. A new multiaxial cycle counting method is proposed to count cycles on the critical plane. The modified Wöhler curve method is used to assess fatigue damage. About 200 experimental results were collected from the technical literature to validate the approaches being proposed. The results show that the improved design technique being proposed is successful in assessing fatigue damage under variable amplitude multiaxial cyclic loading.     

Low‐cycle fatigue life prediction of various metallic materials under multiaxial loading

This paper proposed a simple life prediction model for assessing fatigue lives of metallic materials subjected to multiaxial low‐cycle fatigue (LCF) loading. This proposed model consists of the maximum shear strain range, the normal strain range and the maximum normal stress on the maximum shear strain range plane. Additional cyclic hardening developed during non‐proportional loading is included in the normal stress and strain terms. A computer‐based procedure for multiaxial fatigue life prediction incorporating critical plane damage parameters is presented as well. The accuracy and reliability of the proposed model are systematically checked by using about 300 test data through testing nine kinds of material under both zero and non‐zero mean stress multiaxial loading paths.     

A weight function-critical plane approach for low-cycle fatigue under variable amplitude multiaxial loading

Low‐cycle fatigue data of type 304 stainless steel obtained under axial‐torsional loading of variable amplitudes are analyzed using four multiaxial fatigue parameters: SWT, KBM, FS and LKN. Rainflow cycle counting and Morrow's plastic work interaction rule are used to calculate fatigue damage. The performance of a fatigue model is dependent on the fatigue parameter, the critical plane and the damage accumulation rule employed in the model. The conservatism and non‐conservatism of predicted lives are examined for some combinations of these variables. A new critical plane called the weight function‐critical plane is introduced for variable amplitude loading. This approach is found to improve the KBM‐based life predictions.     

Fatigue analysis of ductile and brittle behaving steels under variable amplitude multiaxial loading

The analysis of fatigue behavior under multiaxial variable amplitude stress states, despite its wide applicability, has not been fully studied. Issues such as varying degrees of nonproportionality of the load history, cycle counting, damage accumulation, failure behavior of the material, and mean stress fluctuations which can significantly affect the results of these analyses have not been well understood. In this study, a methodology for the analysis of fatigue behavior under multiaxial variable amplitude loading conditions is employed which accounts for the aforementioned issues. At its core, the applied methodology uses critical plane analysis based on the failure behavior of each material to assess the fatigue damage. In order to evaluate the performance of the analysis method, axial, torsional, and combined axial‐torsional variable amplitude tests were performed on one ductile and one brittle behaving steel. The applied methodology resulted in close estimation of the experimental fatigue life for both ductile and brittle behaving steels.     

A novel engineering method based on the critical plane concept to estimate the lifetime of weldments subjected to variable amplitude multiaxial fatigue loading

This paper summarizes an attempt at proposing a new engineering method suitable for estimating the fatigue lifetime of steel‐ and aluminium‐welded connections subjected to variable amplitude multiaxial fatigue loading. In particular, the proposed approach is based on the use of the so‐called Modified Wöhler Curve Method (MWCM), i.e. a bi‐parametrical critical plane approach, whose accuracy has been checked so far solely in addressing the constant amplitude multiaxial fatigue problem. In order to extend the use of our criterion to variable amplitude situations, the critical plane is suggested here as being determined by taking full advantage of the maximum variance concept, that is, such a plane is assumed to be the one containing the direction along which the variance of the resolved shear stress reaches its maximum value. The main advantage of such a strategy is that the cycle counting can directly be performed by considering the shear stress resolved along the maximum variance direction: by so doing, the problem is greatly simplified, allowing those well‐established cycle counting methods specifically devised to address the uniaxial variable amplitude problem to be extended to those situations involving multiaxial fatigue loading. The validity of the proposed methodology was checked by using two different datasets taken from the literature and generated by testing both steel and aluminium tube‐to‐plate welded connections subjected to in‐phase and 90° out‐of‐phase variable amplitude bending and torsion. This new fatigue life assessment technique was seen to be highly accurate allowing the estimates to fall within the calibration scatter bands not only when the constants in the governing equations were calculated by using the experimental uniaxial and torsional fully reversed fatigue curves, but also when they were determined by using the reference curves supplied, for the investigated geometry, by the available standard codes. These results seem to strongly support the idea that, thanks to its peculiar features, our method can be considered as an effective engineering approach capable of performing multiaxial fatigue assessment under variable amplitude loading which fully complies with the recommendations of the available standard codes.     

An improved multiaxial high‐cycle fatigue criterion based on critical plane approach

Several groups of fatigue damage parameters are discussed and then an improved multiaxial high‐cycle fatigue criterion based on critical plane defined by the plane of maximum shear stress range is presented in this paper. A compromising solution to consider the mean normal stress acting on the critical plane is also proposed. The new fatigue criterion extends the range of metallic materials which is valid for the ratio 1.25 < f_?1/t_?1 < 2. The predictions based on the presented model show a good agreement with test data.     

Multiaxial notch fatigue life prediction based on pseudo stress correction and finite element analysis under variable amplitude loading

A new computational methodology is proposed for fatigue life prediction of notched components subjected to variable amplitude multiaxial loading. In the proposed methodology, an estimation method of non‐proportionality factor (F) proposed by authors in the case of constant amplitude multiaxial loading is extended and applied to variable amplitude multiaxial loading by using Wang‐Brown's reversal counting approach. The pseudo stress correction method integrated with linear elastic finite element analysis is utilized to calculate the local elastic‐plastic stress and strain responses at the notch root. For whole local strain history, the plane with weight‐averaged maximum shear strain range is defined as the critical plane in this study. Based on the defined critical plane, a multiaxial fatigue damage model combined with Miner's linear cumulative damage law is used to predict fatigue life. The experimentally obtained fatigue data for 7050‐T7451 aluminium alloy notched shaft specimens under constant and variable amplitude multiaxial loadings are used to verify the proposed methodology and equivalent strain‐based methodology. The results show that the proposed methodology is superior to equivalent strain‐based methodology.     

A high-cycle fatigue life model for variable amplitude multiaxial loading

A high‐cycle fatigue life model for structures subjected to variable amplitude multiaxial loading is presented in this paper. It treats any kind of repeated blocks of variable amplitude multiaxial loading without using a cycle counting method. This model based on a mesoscopic approach is characterized by the following features: (i) the choice of a damage factor related to the accumulated mesoscopic plastic strain per stabilised cycle; (ii) the use of a mesoscopic mechanical behaviour taking into account the fatigue mechanisms such as plasticity and void growth. This behaviour is a von Mises elastoplastic model with linear kinematic hardening and hydrostatic stress dependent yield stress. The fatigue life model has six parameters identified with one SN curve and two fatigue limits. In‐phase and out‐of‐phase experimental tests from the literature are simulated. The predicted fatigue lives are compared to experimental ones.     

Proportional/nonproportional constant/variable amplitude multiaxial notch fatigue: cyclic plasticity,non‐zero mean stresses,and critical distance/plane

This paper deals with the formulation and experimental validation of a novel fatigue lifetime estimation technique suitable for assessing the extent of damage in notched metallic materials subjected to in‐service proportional/nonproportional constant/variable amplitude multiaxial load histories. The methodology being formulated makes use of the Modified Manson‐Coffin Curve Method, the Shear Strain–Maximum Variance Method, and the elasto‐plastic Theory of Critical Distances, with the latter theory being applied in the form of the Point Method. The accuracy and reliability of our novel fatigue lifetime estimation technique were checked against a large number of experimental results we generated by testing, under proportional/nonproportional constant/variable amplitude axial‐torsional loading, V‐notched cylindrical specimens made of unalloyed medium‐carbon steel En8 (080M40). Specific experimental trials were run to investigate also the effect of non‐zero mean stresses as well as of different frequencies between the axial and torsional stress/strain components. This systematic validation exercise allowed us to demonstrate that our novel multiaxial fatigue assessment methodology is remarkably accurate, with the estimates falling within an error factor of 2. By modelling the cyclic elasto‐plastic behaviour of metals explicitly, the design methodology being formulated and validated in the present paper offers a complete solution to the problem of estimating multiaxial fatigue lifetime of notched metallic materials, with this holding true independently of sharpness of the stress/strain raiser and complexity of the load history.     

A critical plane‐energy model for multiaxial fatigue life prediction

A new critical plane‐energy model is proposed in this paper for multiaxial fatigue life prediction of metals. A brief review of existing methods, especially on the critical plane‐based and energy‐based methods, is given first. Special focus is on the Liu–Mahadevan critical plane approach, which has been shown to work for both brittle and ductile metals. One potential drawback of the Liu–Mahadevan model is that it needs an empirical calibration parameter for non‐proportional multiaxial loadings because only the strain terms are used and the out‐of‐phase hardening cannot be explicitly considered. An energy‐based model using the Liu–Mahadevan concept is proposed with the help of the Mróz–Garud plasticity model. Thus, the empirical calibration for non‐proportional loading is not needed because the out‐of‐phase hardening is naturally included in the stress calculation. The model predictions are compared with experimental data from open literature, and the proposed model is shown to work for both proportional and non‐proportional multiaxial loadings without the empirical calibration.     

Fatigue life prediction based on equivalent stresses for laser beam welded 6156 Al‐alloy joints under variable amplitude loading

In the present work, a simple fatigue life prediction approach is proposed using fracture mechanics for laser beam welded Al‐alloy joints under variable amplitude loading. In the proposed approach, variable amplitude loading sequence is transformed into an equivalent constant amplitude loading using the root mean square model. The crack growth driving force K^* is chosen to describe the fatigue crack growth rate. The influences of residual stress and its relaxation on fatigue life are taken into account in the proposed approach. The fatigue lives are also predicted using the traditional approach based on the S‐N curves and the rainflow counting method. The predicted results show that the proposed approach is better than the traditional approach.     

Criteria of multiaxial random fatigue based on stress,strain and energy parameters of damage in the critical plane

In this paper generalized criteria of multiaxial random fatigue based on stress, strain and strain energy density parameters in the critical plane have been discussed. The proposed criteria reduce multiaxial state of stress to the equivalent uniaxial tension–compression or alternating bending. Relations between the coefficients occurring in the considered criteria have been derived. Thus, it is possible to take into account fatigue properties of materials under simple loading states during determination of the multiaxial fatigue life. Presented models have successfully correlated fatigue lives of cast iron GGG40 and steel 18G2A specimens under constant amplitude in‐phase and out‐of‐phase loadings including different frequencies.     

Determination of the critical plane by a weight-function method based on the maximum shear stress plane under multiaxial high-cycle loading

A weight function method for the determination of the critical plane is here proposed for the case of specimens under combined bending and torsion in the high cycle fatigue regime. The critical plane is assumed to be coincident with the mean maximum absolute shear stress plane, which is calculated by averaging the instantaneous angle between the specimen axis and the normal to the maximum absolute shear stress plane. Two kinds of weight functions are proposed to determine such a plane. The proposed method to determine the critical plane is verified by employing fatigue data available in the literature in terms of experimental fracture planes, and the multiaxial fatigue life is also predicted by a reformulation of the criterion proposed by Carpinteri et al. to verify the determined critical plane. The results show that the proposed method can be applied to determine the critical plane under both constant and variable amplitude loading.     

Online multiaxial fatigue damage evaluation method by real‐time cycle counting and energy‐based critical plane criterion

To realize online multiaxial fatigue damage assessment for the mechanical components in service, an online multiaxial cycle counting method is proposed coupled with the segment processing technique and Wang‐Brow's relative equivalent strain concept. Meanwhile, considering all the stress and strain components, which contribute to the fatigue damage on the critical plane, a multiaxial fatigue damage model without any weight coefficients is also proposed in an equivalent form of shear strain energy. Then, an online fatigue damage evaluation method for multiaxial random loading is developed by combining with the proposed damage model and online cycle counting method. The experimental results showed that the proposed online cycle counting method can be successfully applied to the calculation of multiaxial fatigue damage under random loading. Moreover, the proposed online multiaxial fatigue damage evaluation method can provide satisfactory predictions.