Femoral stem wear in cemented total hip replacement

The great success of cemented total hip replacement to treat patients with endstage osteoarthritis and osteonecrosis has been well documented. However, its long-term survivorship has been compromised by progressive development of aseptic loosening, and few hip prostheses could survive beyond 25 years. Aseptic loosening is mainly attributed to bone resorption which is activated by an in-vivo macrophage response to particulate debris generated by wear of the hip prosthesis. Theoretically, wear can occur not only at the articulating head-cup interface but also at other load-bearing surfaces, such as the stem-cement interface. Recently, great progress has been made in reducing wear at the head-cup interface through the introduction of new materials and improved manufacture; consequently femoral stem wear is considered to be playing an increasingly significant role in the overall wear of cemented total hip replacement. In this review article, the clinical incidences of femoral stem wear are comprehensively introduced, and its significance is highlighted as a source of generation of wear debris and corrosion products. Additionally, the relationship between femoral stem surface finish and femoral stem wear is discussed and the primary attempts to reproduce femoral stem wear through in-vitro wear testing are summarized. Furthermore, the initiation and propagation processes of femoral stem wear are also proposed and a better understanding of the issue is considered to be essential to reduce femoral stem wear and to improve the functionality of cemented total hip replacement.     

Understanding initiation and propagation of fretting wear on the femoral stem in total hip replacement

The femoral stem–bone cement interface in total hip replacement is supposed to experience low amplitude oscillatory micromotion under physiological loading, consequently leading to fretting wear on the stem surface, which nowadays is considered to play an important part in the overall wear of cemented prosthesis. However, initiation and propagation of fretting wear has been poorly documented and a better understanding concerning this issue has not been established as yet. This present study, on the basis of a profound surface investigation of a polished Exeter V40? femoral stem and Simplex P bone cement obtained from an in vitro wear simulation, demonstrated that the edges of the micropores in the cement surface matched pretty well to the boundaries of the worn areas on the stem surface. This would indicate that these micropores contributed significantly to the fretting process at the stem–cement interface.     

Reproduction of fretting wear at the stem-cement interface in total hip replacement

The stem-cement interface experiences fretting wear in vivo due to low-amplitude oscillatory micromotion under physiological loading, as a consequence it is considered to play an important part in the overall wear of cemented total hip replacement. Despite its potential significance, in-vitro simulation to reproduce fretting wear has seldom been attempted and even then with only limited success. In the present study, fretting wear was successfully reproduced at the stem-cement interface through an in-vitro wear simulation, which was performed in part with reference to ISO 7206-4: 2002. The wear locations compared well with the results of retrieval studies. There was no evidence of bone cement transfer films on the stem surface and no fatigue cracks in the cement mantle. The cement surface was severely damaged in those areas in contact with the fretting zones on the stem surface, with retention of cement debris in the micropores. Furthermore, it was suggested that these micropores contributed to initiation and propagation of fretting wear. This study gave scope for further comparative study of the influence of stem geometry, stem surface finish, and bone cement brand on generation of fretting wear.     

The contribution of the micropores in bone cement surface to generation of femoral stem wear in total hip replacement

Although cemented total hip replacement has long been recognized as a situation that can lead to wear, the wear generated on the femoral stem has not been well documented, especially with regard to how this wear is initiated and propagated. This present work aimed to further investigate this issue based on a comprehensive study on surface morphology of the femoral stem and the bone cement, which were collected from seven in vitro wear simulations. It was shown that the wear locations on the stem surface compared well with the results of retrieval studies, and the boundaries of the worn areas matched well the edges of the micropores present in the bone cement surface. This indicated that the micropores could potentially contribute to the generation of femoral stem wear. In addition, metallic debris was detected around the micropores from the simulation with increased loading cycles. However, no evidence of macro-cracks was observed across the cement mantle in spite of the presence of micro-cracks initiated at the edge of the micropores. This study demonstrated a possible cause for progression of femoral stem wear and it may have an important bearing on the long term durability of cemented hip prosthesis.     

The influence of bone and bone cement debris on counterface roughness in sliding wear tests of ultra-high molecular weight polyethylene on stainless steel

Studies of explanted hip prostheses have shown high wear rates of ultra-high molecular weight polyethylene (UHMWPE) acetabular cups and roughening of the surface of the metallic femoral head. Bone and bone cement particles have also been found in the articulating surfaces of some joints. It has been proposed that bone or bone cement particles may cause scratching and deterioration in the surface finish of metallic femoral heads, thus producing increased wear rates and excessive amounts of wear debris. Sliding wear tests of UHMWPE pins on stainless steel have been performed with particles of different types of bone and bone cement added. Damage to the stainless steel counterface and the motion of particles through the interface have been studied. Particles of bone cement with zirconium and barium sulphate additives and particles of cortical bone scratched the stainless steel counterface. The cement particles with zirconium additive produced significantly greater surface damage. The number of particles entering the contact and embedding in the UHMWPE pin was dependent on particle size and geometry, surface roughness and contact stress. Particles are likely to cause surface roughening and increased wear rates in artificial joints.     

An analysis of the in vivo deterioration of Co-Cr-Mo implants through wear and corrosion

The degradation of Co-Cr-Mo ASTM F75-92 hip implants after a harvesting period of 81 months in sheep was investigated. Hip prostheses and tissue samples were obtained from a medical study involving total hip arthroplasty of the cemented type in 12 sheep. Upon euthanasia, the explants were retrieved for analyses of the surfaces and evidence of degradation, while tissue samples from the interface regions were harvested for chemical analysis and evidence of Co, Cr, and Mo contents. Clear evidence of wear and corrosion was detected. Results also indicated that the modes of metal transport through the poly(methyl methacrylate) bone cement play an important role as the surface degradation mechanisms of the metal. The results are being discussed in terms of electrochemical and triboelectrochemical behaviour of the Co-Cr-Mo alloy.     

Properties of composite specimens of old and new bone cement

The most common cause of failure of a total hip replacement is aseptic loosening of an implant. In a number of cases, the cement-bone interface of at least one component is not compromised. In cases of aseptic cup loosening, removal of a well-fixed femoral stem may be undertaken to facilitate exposure of the acetabulum for cup revision, and the surgeon may choose to leave the functional cement-bone interfaces in the femur undisturbed. After cup revision, new cement is pressurized within the old cement mantle and a stem is cemented into this 'old-new cement' composite. Retaining the old cement mantle is an attractive option as it reduces the duration of surgery, minimizes bleeding, and preserves the bone stock. Excellent results have been shown with this technique of 'in-cement femoral revision' using a double-tapered polished stem. While considerable literature is available on the short- and long-term properties of PMMA bone cement, very little is known about the mechanical properties of old-new composite cement specimens where the old cement is more than a few days old. This paper tests the properties of such old-new composite specimens where the 'old' cement is aged between 3.3 and 17.7 years, better reflecting clinical situations.     

Reduced stress shielding with limited micromotions using a carbon fibre composite biomimetic hip stem: a finite element model

Total hip arthroplasty (THA) enjoys excellent rates of success in older patients, but younger patients are still at risk of aseptic loosening and bone resorption from stress shielding. One solution to the stress shielding problem is to use a hip stem with mechanical properties matching those of cortical bone. The objective of the present study was to investigate numerically the biomechanical performance of such a biomimetic hip stem based on a hydroxyapatite (HA)-coated carbon fibre composite. A finite element model (FEM) of the biomimetic stem was constructed. Contact elements were studied to model the bone-implant interface in a non-osseointegrated and osseointegrated state in the best way. Three static load cases representing slow walking, stair climbing, and gait in a healthy individual were considered. Stress shielding and bone-implant interface micromotions were evaluated and compared with the results of a similar FEM based on titanium alloy (Ti-6Al-4V). The composite stems allowed for reduced stress shielding when compared with a traditional Ti-6Al-4V stem. Micromotions were slightly higher with the composite stem, but remained below 40 microm on most of the HA-coated surface. It is concluded that a biomimetic composite stem might offer a better compromise between stress shielding and micromotions than the Ti-6Al-4V stem with the same external geometry.     

Interface biomechanics of the Anca Dual fit hip stem: an in vitro experimental study

The Anca Dual Fit hip stem (Cremascoli Wright, Milan, Italy) is a partially cemented stem developed to overcome the drawbacks of both cemented and uncemented fixations. Its design was based on the hypothesis that partial cementing would ensure the primary stability necessary to allow bone ingrowth on the cement-free stem surfaces. At the same time, the limitation of the cement to the proximal regions would prevent stress-shielding by increasing proximal load transfer. After finite element (FE) simulations and in vitro primary stability assessment, an analysis of the long-term stability of the Anca Dual Fit stem was necessary to conclude the preclinical testing. Three stems were implanted in composite femurs and subjected to testing for 1 x 10(6) cycles, each cycle reproducing the activity of stair climbing. The simulation was designed so as to replicate the physiological loading in a simplified, yet relevant way for this test. Various measurements were collected before, during and after the test in order to give exhaustive information on the response of the implant to long-term, cyclic loading. The present study confirmed the positive results of previous investigations, and proved that the Anca Dual Fit stem has excellent long-term stability; therefore successful clinical outcomes are predicted.     

An investigation into the fixation of hip replacements.

This paper describes an experimental study of hip prosthesis stems fixed with bone cement in model femora and subjected to cyclic loading. Loosening of the stems did not occur due to fatigue of the bone cement, even when reduction of medial support from the calcar had been simulated. Measurement of stresses in the cement layer and comparison with published properties of bone cement indicated that fatigue failure was not likely under the experimental conditions. Fatigue failure of cement could not be solely regarded as initiating loosening. It is concluded that the results uphold theories that biological factors must also contribute to the initiation of loosening, rather than being a response to mechanical failure.     

An in-vitro investigation into the cement pressurization achieved during insertion of four different femoral stems

Adequate cement pressurization during stem insertion improves the interdigitation of cement into bone. This increases the strength of the cement-bone interface, thus contributing to the reduction of the incidence of aseptic loosening, the commonest cause of revision surgery. This in-vitro study compared the cement pressurization achieved during insertion of four different stems of equivalent sizes: the Elite Plus (DePuy, UK), C-Stem (DePuy, UK), Exeter (Stryker, USA), and CPS-Plus (Plus Orthopedics, Switzerland). The maximum pressures attained at the time of stem insertion were recorded at proximal, mid and distal stem levels. The Elite Plus generated significantly higher distal pressures than the other stems. The CPS-Plus generated significantly greater proximal cement pressures than the Elite Plus, C-Stem, and Exeter prostheses. The triple taper of the C-Stem increased the cement pressurization medial to the stem. The stem shape and the presence or absence of a proximal stem centralizer affect cement pressurization. The presence of a proximal stem centralizer, a large stem volume, and a lateral-medial taper are all factors associated with increased cement pressurization during stem insertion.     

Finite element analysis of the long-term fixation strength of cemented ceramic cups

Clinical studies have shown that adequate fixation of ceramic cups using bone cement is difficult to achieve. As the cement-ceramic bond strength is low, a satisfactory fixation strength requires a cup design that allows mechanical interlocking, although such a design will probably promote cement cracking and therefore cup loosening in the long term. An investigation has been carried out to establish whether a cemented ceramic cup can be designed in such a way that both a satisfactory initial fixation strength is obtained and cement cracking is reduced to levels found around PE cups functioning well in vivo. By means of finite element analysis, the fatigue loading of three geometrically different cemented acetabular cups, with ceramic and PE material properties, has been simulated, and the severity of the crack patterns produced in the cement has been analysed. Furthermore, the fixation strength has been analysed by simulating a pull-out test prior to and after fatigue testing. All ceramic cups produced much larger amounts of cement damage during fatigue testing than any PE cup, caused by stress concentrations in the cement that were attributable to the high stiffness of the ceramic. Even a completely smooth ceramic cup produced more damage than a sharp-grooved PE cup. Owing to the excessive cement cracking, the fixation strength of the ceramic cups dropped after fatigue loading. It is concluded that cemented ceramic cups have an increased risk of long-term mechanical failure by comparison with PE cups, and that a ceramic cup design that combines sufficient fixation strength with low cement failure may be difficult to achieve.     

Development of a computer model to predict pressure generation around hip replacement stems

Cemented fixation of hip replacements is the elective choice of many orthopaedic surgeons. The cement is an acrylic polymer which grouts the prostheses into the medullary cavity of the femur. Cement pressure is accepted as a significant parameter in determining the strength of cement/bone interfaces and hence preventing loosening of the prostheses. The aim of this work was to allow optimal design of the intramedullary stem of a hip prosthesis through knowledge of the flow characteristics of curing bone cement which can be used to predict pressures achieved during insertion of the femoral stem. The viscosity of the cement is a vital property determining the cement flow and hence cement interdigitation into bone. The apparent viscosities, nu(a), of three commercial bone cements were determined with respect to time by extrusion of the curing cement through a parallel die of known geometry under selected pressures. Theoretical models were developed and implemented in a computer program to describe cement flow in three models each of increasing complexity: (a) a simple parallel cylinder, (b) a tapered conical mandrel and (c) an actual femoral prosthesis, the latter models being complicated by extensional effects as annular areas increase. Predicted pressures were close to those measured experimentally, maximum pressures being in the range 10-160 kPa which may be compared with a threshold of 76 kPa proposed for effective interdigitation with cancellous bone. The theoretical model allows the prosthesis/bone geometry of an individual patient to be evaluated in terms of probable pressure distributions in the medullary cavity during cemented fixation and can guide stem design with reference to preparation of the medullary canal. It is proposed that these models may assist retrospective studies of failed components and contribute to implant selection, or to making informed selection from options in custom hip prosthesis designs to achieve optimum cement pressurization.     

Investigations on the wear behaviour of the temporary PMMA-based hip Spacer-G

Total hip replacement has become one of the most successful orthopaedic procedures. However, complications due to infections may give serious problems and have devastating consequences for the hip implant. The use of a temporary three-dimensional polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA) cement spacer may be an alternative to solve infections in hip implants, improving the lives of patients awaiting reimplantation. In order to evaluate their wear behaviour, five PMMA Spacer-G femoral heads were tested against five post-mortem pelves in a hip joint simulator with bovine calf serum as lubricant. The surface of the worn spacers was characterized by scanning electron microscopy (SEM) analysis; all the samples revealed a similar morphology, showing areas characterized by different degrees of wear. Particle debris was isolated from the lubricant and PMMA particles and bone fractions were quantified. The amount of debris was found to be higher than where no-temporary prostheses were used. However, this result is acceptable since wear debris is removed by lavage irrigation when the Spacer-G is explanted. On the basis of these data, it is considered that the use of the cement Spacer-G could be a promising approach to the treatment of complicated infections of the hip joint. Therefore, Spacer-G is worthy of further research.     

A comparison of structural and mechanical properties in cancellous bone from the femoral head and acetabulum

Mechanical interlock obtained by penetration of bone cement into cancellous bone is critical to the success of cemented total hip replacement (THR). Although acetabular component loosening is an important mode of THR failure, the properties of acetabular cancellous bone relevant to cement penetration are not well characterized. Bone biopsies (9 mm diameter, 10 mm long) were taken from the articular surfaces of the acetabulum and femoral head during total hip replacement. After mechanical and chemical defatting the two groups of bone specimens were characterized using flow measurement, mechanical testing and finally serial sectioning and three-dimensional computer reconstruction. The mean permeabilities of the acetabular group (1.064 x 10(-10) m2) and femoral group (1.155 x 10(-10) m2) were calculated from the flow measurements, which used saline solution and a static pressure of 9.8 kPa. The mean Young's modulus, measured non-destructively, was 47.4 MPa for the femoral group and 116.4 MPa for the acetabular group. Three-dimensional computer reconstruction of the specimens showed no significant differences in connectivity and porosity between the groups. Results obtained using femoral head cancellous bone to investigate bone cement penetration and fixation are directly relevant to fixation in the acetabulum.     

Fretting corrosion of orthopaedic implant materials by bone cement

Debonding of bone cement from the stem of the femoral component of a hip prosthesis can result in local tangential oscillatory movement, i.e. fretting, between the two contacting materials as the limb is moved. Patches where such rubbing has occurred are frequently seen on removed implants. Fretting fatigue experiments have been carried out in Hanks solution on austenitic stainless steel and Ti-6Al-4V (IMI 318) with bridges of bone cement clamped to the specimens. Fretting appears to have little effect on the fatigue life of either material but the scanning electron microscope reveals the formation of thick oxide layers which subsequently give rise to loose debris particles by a process of delamination. Further experiments carried out in Hanks solution in an electrolytic cell have shown that there are potential changes when a bone cement rider is fretted against a stainless steel or titanium alloy plate although the change in potential is only one tenth that obtained with a metal-on-metal contact. Fretting by bone cement appears to be producing damage to the metal surfaces which manifests itself as mild wear rather than a diminution in fatigue strength.     

Wear and bending strain characteristics of artificial hip joint with non-glued stem and UHMWPE femur

The aim of this study was to experimentally assess the effects of loosening between the stem of a cementless artificial hip joint and the femur on the wear and bending strain of the stem during the initial embedding term. The behavior of an ultrahigh-molecular-weight polyethylene (UHMWPE) femur model with this stem was then investigated. The interface between the stem and the UHMWPE femur model is either glued or not glued. Evaluation of differences between the two gluing conditions was conducted using testing equipment equipped with a reciprocating stage for an artificial hip joint. Total wear between the Co–Cr alloy head and UHMWPE socket was measured using a laser displacement meter installed in the axis direction on a main shaft of the tester. We measured the bending strain waveforms of the flexural direction, which was shown by three strain gauges on the upper, middle and lower part of the stem. The present results indicate that the rate of wear was markedly greater for non-glued stems than for the glued stems. In addition, the results indicate that the bending strain in the upper part of the non-glued stem tended to reach the maximum value of bending strain immediately after the femur model section stood upright, whereas the bending strain in the upper and middle of the glued stem tended to reach the maximum value of bending strain immediately before the femur model section stood upright. Furthermore, when the non-glued and glued stems had the same value of bending strain, the average amplitude was smaller for the non-glued stem than for the glued stem by 2–3 dB.     

Prediction of scratch resistance of cobalt chromium alloy bearing surface, articulating against ultra-high molecular weight polyethylene, due to third-body wear particles

The entrapment of abrasive particles within the articulation between a cobalt chromium alloy (CoCrMo) femoral component and an ultra-high molecular weight polyethylene (UHMWPE) cup of artificial hip joints or tibial inserts of artificial knee joints usually scratches the metallic bearing surface and consequently increases the surface roughness. This has been recognized as one of the main causes of excessive polyethylene wear, leading to osteolysis and loosening of the prosthetic components. The purpose of this study was to use the finite element method to investigate the resistance of the cobalt chromium alloy bearing surface to plastic deformation, as a first approximation to causing scratches, due to various entrapped debris such as bone, CoCrMo and ZrO2 (contained in radiopaque polymethyl methacrylate cement). A simple axisymmetric micro contact mechanics model was developed, where a spherical third-body wear particle was indented between the two bearing surfaces, modelled as two solid cylinders of a given diameter, under the contact pressure determined from macro-models representing either hip or knee implants. The deformation of both the wear particle and the bearing surfaces was modelled and was treated as elastic-plastic. The indented peak-to-valley height on the CoCrMo bearing surface from the finite element model was found to be in good agreement with that reported in a previous study when the third-body wear particle was assumed to be rigid. Under the physiological contact pressure experienced in both hip and knee implants, ZrO2 wear particles were found to be fully embedded within the UHMWPE bearing surface, and the maximum von Mises stresses within the CoCrMo bearing surface reached the corresponding yield strength. Consequently, the CoCrMo bearing surface was deformed plastically and the corresponding peak-to-valley height (surface roughness) was found to increase with both the hardness and the size of the wear particle. Even in the case of CoCrMo wear particles, with similar mechanical properties to those of the CoCrMo bearing surface, a significant plastic deformation of the bearing surface was also noted; this highlighted the importance of considering the deformation of the wear particles. These findings support the hypotheses made by clinical studies on the contribution of entrapped debris to increased surface roughness of CoCrMo femoral bearing surfaces.     

Three-body wear of UHMWPE acetabular cups by PMMA particles against CoCr, alumina and zirconia heads in a hip joint simulator

Three-body abrasive wear of ultra-high molecular weight polyethylene (UHMWPE) acetabular cups by loose polymethyl methacrylate (PMMA) bone cement particles is an important mechanism responsible for elevated wear debris generation in total hip arthroplasty. The resistance of the femoral head material to third-body damage has been considered critical for the wear performance of the polyethylene component. This study examines the effect of loose bone cement particles on the wear rate of UHMWPE acetabular cups against both metal and ceramic counterfaces in a hip joint simulator. Against the CoCr head, the UHMWPE cup showed a strong dependence of wear rate on the concentration of the PMMA particles in the lubricant. At a concentration less than 5 g/l, the presence of the PMMA particles had no detrimental effect on the wear rate; higher concentrations of the PMMA particles greater than 5 g/l led to an accelerated wear of the acetabular cups. Mild scratching damage was observed on the CoCr heads after testing with all PMMA-containing lubricants. However, no increased UHMWPE wear rate was found against these damaged femoral heads in a fresh lubricant without PMMA particles, indicating that femoral head scratching was not a major cause for the elevated wear observed under the three-body abrasive conditions. Against both alumina and zirconia ceramic heads, the wear rate of the UHMWPE was independent of the concentration of the PMMA particles. It was observed that a significant portion of the CoCr heads was covered with loose patches of PMMA particles. The higher the concentration of the PMMA particles, the greater the area of the head covered with PMMA particles. The attachment of PMMA particles to the ceramic heads was much reduced compared to the CoCr heads. It is therefore concluded that ceramic femoral heads are effective against potential run-away wear of the UHMWPE acetabular cups when an excessive amount of loose PMMA particles are present in the lubricant.     

An investigation into the effect of cyclic loading and frequency on the temperature of PMMA bone cement in hip prostheses

A titanium alloy hip prosthesis was inserted in a Tufnol tube representing the upper part of the femur. The prosthesis was cemented in the model femur using PMMA bone cement. Five thermocouples were embedded in the bone cement and the assembly was subjected to cyclic loading with a range of 0.3-4.5 kN at a frequency of 6 Hz. Temperature measurements over a 48 hour period indicated that the temperature rise in the bone cement was less than 4 degrees C. It is concluded that such tests can be carried out at 6 Hz without significantly affecting the mechanical properties of PMMA bone cement.