Carbon deposition behavior in steam reforming of bio-oil model compound for hydrogen production

Catalyst deactivation caused by coke formation is a bottleneck in steam reforming of bio-oil for hydrogen production. The investigation of carbon deposition behavior can make a contribution to the improvement of catalyst and the knowledge of reaction mechanism. In this paper, m-cresol (C₇H₈O, one of the organic compounds present in bio-oil) was chosen as model compound. The experiment was carried out on a commercial Ni/MgO catalyst. As a comparative test, m-cresol decomposition showed carbon deposition can be formed more easily under higher temperature. In steam reforming process, for the competition of carbon deposition and carbon elimination, a peak value of coking formation rate was obtained in a broad range of temperature (575–900 °C). The increase of steam to carbon ratio can favor the carbon elimination. Final coking formation rate curve was determined under optimal reaction conditions and the results showed the severity of carbon deposition maintained a very low level during the entire reaction time. Based on the distribution of reforming products, high temperature and sufficient water feeding can favor the carbon conversion from solid and liquid phase to gaseous phase. Unreacted m-cresol is the main organic compound detected in liquid condensate. Some secondary reactions can be deduced through the other compounds detected. The carbon deposition state on catalyst surface can be in the form of nanofiber, but their concrete shapes can be different due to different reaction conditions.     

Biohydrogen production from Imperata cylindrica bio-oil using non-stoichiometric and thermodynamic model

This paper presents a non-stoichiometric and thermodynamic model for steam reforming of Imperata cylindrica bio-oil for biohydrogen production. Thermodynamic analyses of major bio-oil components such as formic acid, propanoic acid, oleic acid, hexadecanoic acid and octanol produced from fast pyrolysis of I. cylindrica was examined. Sensitivity analyses of the operating conditions; temperature (100–1000 °C), pressure (1–10 atm) and steam to fuel ratio (1–10) were determined. The results showed an increase in biohydrogen yield with increasing temperature although the effect of pressure was negligible. Furthermore, increase in steam to fuel ratio favoured biohydrogen production. Maximum yield of 60 ± 10% at 500–810 °C temperature range and steam to fuel ratio 5–9 was obtained for formic acid, propanoic acid and octanol. The heavier components hexadecanoic and oleic acid maximum hydrogen yield are 40% (740 °C and S/F = 9) and 43% (810 °C and S/F = 8) respectively. However, the effect of pressure on biohydrogen yield at the selected reforming temperatures was negligible. Overall, the results of the study demonstrate that the non-stoichiometry and thermodynamic model can successfully predict biohydrogen yield as well as the composition of gas mixtures from the gasification and steam reforming of bio-oil from biomass resources. This will serve as a useful guide for further experimental works and process development.     

Thermodynamic analysis of aqueous phase reforming of three model compounds in bio-oil for hydrogen production

Thermodynamic analysis with Gibbs free energy minimization was performed for aqueous phase reforming of methanol, acetic acid, and ethylene glycol as model compounds for hydrogen production from bio-oil. The effects of the temperature (340-660 K) and pressure ratio Psys/PH₂O (0.1-2.0) on the selectivity of H₂ and CH₄, formation of solid carbon, and conversion of model compounds were analyzed. The influences of CaO and O₂ addition on the formation of H₂, CH₄, and CO₂ in the gas phase and solid phase carbon, CaCO₃, and Ca(OH)₂ were also investigated. With methanation and carbon formation, the conversion of the model compounds was >99.99% with no carbon formation, and methanation was thermodynamically favored over hydrogen production. H₂ selectivity was greatly improved when methanation was suppressed, but most of the inlet model compounds formed solid carbon. After suppressing both methanation and carbon formation, aqueous phase reforming of methanol, acetic acid and ethylene glycol at 500 K and with Psys/PH₂O = 1.1 gave H₂ selectivity of 74.98%, 66.64% and 71.38%, respectively. These were similar to the maximum stoichiometric hydrogen selectivity of 75.00% (methanol), 66.67% (acetic acid), and 71.43% (ethylene glycol). At 500 K and 2.90 MPa, as the molar ratio of CaO/BMCs increased, the normalized variation in H₂ increased and that for CH₄ decreased. Formation of solid carbon was effectively suppressed by addition of O₂, but this was at the expense of H₂ formation. With the O₂/BMCs molar ratio regulated at 1.0, oxidation and CO₂ capture increased the normalized variation in H₂ to 33.33% (methanol), 50.00% (acetic acid), and 60.00% (ethylene glycol), and the formation of solid carbon decreased to zero.     

Thermodynamic analysis of hydrogen production via steam reforming of selected components of aqueous bio-oil fraction

This work presents thermodynamics analysis of hydrogen production via steam reforming of bio-oil components. The model compounds, acetic acid, ethylene glycol and acetone, representatives of the major classes of components present in the aqueous fraction of bio-oil were used for the study. The equilibrium product compositions were investigated in a broad range of conditions like temperature (400–1300 K), steam to fuel ratio (1–9) and pressure (1–20 atm). Any of the three model compounds can be fully reformed even at low temperatures producing hydrogen with maximum yield ranging from 80% to 90% at 900 K. Steam to fuel ratio positively affect the hydrogen content over the entire range of temperature studied. Conversely, higher pressure decreases the hydrogen yield. The formation of solid carbon (graphite) does not constitute a problem provided that reforming temperatures higher than 600 K and steam to fuel ratios higher than 4 for acetic acid and ethylene glycol and 6 for acetone are to be used. Thermal decomposition of the bio-oil components is thermodynamically feasible, forming a mixture containing _C(s)${\mathrm{C}}_{(\mathrm{s})}$, CH₄, H₂, CO, CO₂, and H₂O at various proportions depending on the specific nature of the compound and the temperature. Material and energy balances of complete reforming system demonstrated that the production of 1 kmol/s hydrogen from bio-oil steam reforming requires almost the same amount of energy as with natural gas reforming.     

Sustainable hydrogen production from steam reforming of bio-oil model compound based on carbon deposition/elimination

Steam reforming of crude bio-oil or some heavy component present in bio-oil is a great challenge for sustainable hydrogen production due to the extensive coke formation and catalyst deactivation. Catalyst regeneration will be an unavoidable operation in this process. In this paper, m-cresol (a model compound derived from bio-oil) was steam reformed on commercial Ni-based catalyst. Two conventional carbon elimination methods for coked catalyst were applied and the results showed that sustainable hydrogen production can be obtained based on carbon deposition/elimination. The carbon deposition can be gasified easily under certain temperature. The activity of regenerated catalyst samples can be nearly recovered as the fresh ones. Under the reaction conditions of 850 °C and steam to carbon ratio 5:1, >66% hydrogen mole fraction, >81% hydrogen yield, and >97% carbon conversion can be achieved based on regenerated catalyst. Catalyst characterization indicated that the loss of active metal can be considered as the main reason for tiny activity drop. Ni redispersion and Fe contamination may be another two factors that influence catalyst activity.     

Hydrogen production from bio-oil: A thermodynamic analysis of sorption-enhanced chemical looping steam reforming

The steam reforming of pyrolysis bio-oil is one proposed route to low carbon hydrogen production, which may be enhanced by combination with advanced steam reforming techniques. The advanced reforming of bio-oil is investigated via a thermodynamic analysis based on the minimisation of Gibbs Energy. Conventional steam reforming (C-SR) is assessed alongside sorption-enhanced steam reforming (SE-SR), chemical looping steam reforming (CLSR) and sorption-enhanced chemical looping steam reforming (SE-CLSR). The selected CO₂ sorbent is CaO(s) and oxygen transfer material (OTM) is Ni/NiO. PEFB bio-oil is modelled as a surrogate mixture and two common model compounds, acetic acid and furfural, are also considered. A process comparison highlights the advantages of sorption-enhancement and chemical looping, including improved purity and yield, and reductions in carbon deposition and process net energy balance.The operating regime of SE-CLSR is evaluated in order to assess the impact of S/C ratio, NiO/C ratio, CaO/C ratio and temperature. Autothermal operation can be achieved for S/C ratios between 1 and 3. In autothermal operation at 30 bar, S/C ratio of 2 gives a yield of 11.8 wt%, and hydrogen purity of 96.9 mol%. Alternatively, if autothermal operation is not a priority, the yield can be improved by reducing the quantity of OTM. The thermodynamic analysis highlights the role of advanced reforming techniques in enhancing the potential of bio-oil as a source of hydrogen.     

Mechanistic study of bio-oil catalytic steam reforming for hydrogen production: Acetic acid decomposition

To clarify the understanding of the mechanism of bio-oil catalytic steam reforming, we selected acetic acid as a typical bio-oil model compound to study its detailed behavior in decomposition over an active stepped Ni surface by density functional theory calculations. The adsorption geometries and energies of various intermediates were reported. Linear correlations between the adsorption energy and the number of hydrogen atoms removed for CH_xCOOH, CH_xCOO, and CH_x species (x = 1–3) were found, with increments of ?1.56, ?0.81, and ?1.80 eV, respectively. Thirty-seven possible elementary reactions of acetic acid decomposition were proposed, and their activation energies, reaction energies, rate constants, and equilibrium constants were calculated. Acetic acid dissociation likely started via α-carbon dehydrogenation, OH dehydrogenation, and dehydroxylation. Combined with microkinetic modeling, the most preferable decomposition pathway was suggested as CH₃COOH → CH₃CO → CO + CH₃. The rate-determining step was CH₃COOH dehydroxylation to CH₃CO with an activation energy of 0.68 eV and a rate constant of 3.82 × 10⁸ s^?1. The formation of CH₃COO was dominant at high temperatures, whereas its decomposition occurred with difficulty.     

Thermodynamic analysis of hydrogen production via autothermal steam reforming of selected components of aqueous bio-oil fraction

From a technical and economic point of view, autothermal steam reforming offers many advantages, as it minimizes heat load demand in the reformer. Bio-oil, the liquid product of biomass pyrolysis, can be effectively converted to a hydrogen-rich stream. Autothermal steam reforming of selected compounds of bio-oil was investigated using thermodynamic analysis. Equilibrium calculations employing Gibbs free energy minimization were performed for acetic acid, acetone and ethylene glycol in a broad range of temperature (400–1300 K), steam to fuel ratio (1–9) and pressure (1–20 atm) values. The optimal O₂/fuel ratio to achieve thermoneutral conditions was calculated under all operating conditions. Hydrogen-rich gas is produced at temperatures higher than 700 K with the maximum yield attained at 900 K. The ratio of steam to fuel and the pressure determine to a great extent the equilibrium hydrogen concentration. The heat demand of the reformer, as expressed by the required amount of oxygen, varies with temperature, steam to fuel ratio and pressure, as well as the type of oxygenate compound used. When the required oxygen enters the system at the reforming temperature, autothermal steam reforming results in hydrogen yield around 20% lower than the yield by steam reforming because part of the organic feed is consumed in the combustion reaction. Autothermicity was also calculated for the whole cycle, including preheating of the organic feed to the reactor temperature and the reforming reaction itself. The oxygen demand in such a case is much higher, while the amount of hydrogen produced is drastically reduced.     

Thermodynamic analysis of propane dry and steam reforming for synthesis gas or hydrogen production

Thermodynamics was applied to investigate propane dry reforming (DR) and steam reforming (SR). Equilibrium calculations employing the Gibbs free energy minimization were performed upon a wide range of pressure (1–5 atm), temperature (700–1100 K), carbon dioxide to propane ratio (CPR, 1–12) and water to propane ratio (WPR, 1–18). From a thermodynamic perspective, it is demonstrated that DR is promising for production of synthesis gas with low hydrogen content, as opposite to SR which favours generation of synthesis gas with high hydrogen content. Complete conversion of propane was obtained for the range of pressure, temperature, CPR and WPR considered in this study. Atmospheric pressure is shown to be preferable for both DR and SR. Approximately 10 mol of synthesis gas can be produced per mole of propane at a temperature greater than 1000 K from DR when CPR is higher than 6. The optimum conditions for synthesis gas production from DR are found to be 975 K (CPR = 3) for a H₂/CO ratio of 1 and 1100 K (CPR = 1) for a H₂/CO ratio of 2. The greatest CO₂ conversion (95%) can be obtained also at 1100 K and CPR = 1. Preferential conditions for hydrogen production from SR are achieved with the temperatures between 925 and 975 K and WPRs of 12–18. The maximum number of moles of hydrogen produced is 9.1 (925 K and WPR = 18). Under conditions that favour hydrogen production, methane and carbon formation can be eliminated to negligible level.     

Thermodynamic analysis of steam reforming and oxidative steam reforming of propane and butane for hydrogen production

Thermodynamic analyses of cracking, partial oxidation (POX), steam reforming (SR) and oxidative steam reforming (OSR) of butane and propane (for comparison) were performed using the Gibbs free energy minimization method under the reaction conditions of T = 250–1000 °C, steam-to-carbon ratio (S/C) of 0.5–5 and O₂/HC (hydrocarbon) ratio of 0–2.4. The simulations for the cracking and POX processes showed that olefins and acetylene can be easily generated through the cracking reactions and can be removed by adding an appropriate amount of oxygen. For SR and OSR of propane and butane, predicted carbon formation only occurred at low S/C ratios (<2) with the maximum level of carbon formation at 550–650 °C. For the thermal-neutral conditions, the TN temperatures decrease with the increase of the S/C ratio (except for O/C = 0.6) and the decrease of the O/C ratio. The simulated results for SR or OSR of propane and butane are very close under the investigated conditions.     

Thermodynamic analysis of steam reforming of ethanol and glycerine for hydrogen production

In the past few years there has been a growing interest in environmentally clean renewable sources for hydrogen production. In this context new technologies have been developed for ethanol and glycerine reforming. Hydrogen production varies significantly according to the operating conditions such as pressure, temperature and feed reactants ratio. The thermodynamic analysis provides important knowledge about the effects of those variables on the process of ethanol and glycerine reforming. The present work was aimed at analyzing the thermodynamic steam reforming of ethanol and glycerine, using Gibbs free energy minimization using actual temperature and pressure data found in the literature. The nonlinear programming model was implemented in GAMS^® and the CONOPT2 solver was used to solve the equations. The ideality in gaseous phase and the formation of solid carbon was considered. The methodology used reproduced the most relevant papers involving experimental studies and thermodynamic analysis.     

Catalytic steam reforming of bio-oil

Hydrogen and synthesis gas can be produced in an environmentally friendly and sustainable way through steam reforming (SR) of bio-oil and this review presents the state-of-the-art of SR of bio-oil and model compounds hereof. The possible reactions, which can occur in the SR process and the influence of operating conditions will be presented along with the catalysts and processes investigated in the literature.     

Thermodynamic analysis of hydrogen production from glycerol autothermal reforming

In this work, thermodynamics was applied to investigate the glycerol autothermal reforming to generate hydrogen for fuel cell application. Equilibrium calculations employing the Gibbs free energy minimization were performed in a wide range of temperature (700–1000 K), steam to glycerol ratio (1–12) and oxygen to glycerol ratio (0.0–3.0). Results show that the most favorable conditions for hydrogen production are achieved with the temperatures, steam to glycerol ratios and oxygen to glycerol ratios of 900–1000 K, 9–12 and 0.0–0.4, respectively. Further, it is demonstrated that thermoneutral conditions (steam to glycerol ratio 9–12) can be obtained at oxygen to glycerol ratios of around 0.36 (at 900 K) and 0.38–0.39 (at 1000 K). Under these thermoneutral conditions, the maximum number of moles of hydrogen produced are 5.62 (900 K) and 5.43 (1000 K) with a steam to glycerol ratio of 12. Also, it should be noted that methane and carbon formation can be effectively eliminated.     

Distributed production of hydrogen by auto-thermal reforming of fast pyrolysis bio-oil

We demonstrated an auto-thermal reforming process for producing hydrogen from biomass pyrolysis liquids. Using a noble metal catalyst (0.5% Pt/Al₂O₃ from BASF) at a methane-equivalent space velocity of around 2000 h⁻¹, a reformer temperature of 800 °C–850 °C, a steam-to-carbon ratio of 2.8–4.0, and an oxygen-to-carbon ratio of 0.9–1.1, we produced 9–11 g of hydrogen per 100 g of fast pyrolysis bio-oil, which corresponds to 70%–83% of the stoichiometric potential. The elemental composition of bio-oil and the bio-oil carbon-to-gas conversion, which ranged from 70% to 89%, had the most significant impact on the yield of hydrogen. Because of incomplete volatility the remaining 11%–30% of bio-oil carbon formed deposits in the evaporator. Assuming the same process efficiency as that in the laboratory unit, the cost of hydrogen production in a 1500 kg/day plant was estimated at $4.26/kg with the feedstock, fast pyrolysis bio-oil, contributing 56.3% of the production cost.     

Nickel catalyst auto-reduction during steam reforming of bio-oil model compound acetic acid

Transition metal catalysts widely used in refineries are provided as oxides and require pre-reduction to become activated. The auto-reduction of a NiO/Al₂O₃ catalyst with acetic acid (HAc) followed by HAc steam reforming was investigated in a packed bed reactor. Effects of temperature and molar steam to carbon ratio (S/C) on reduction kinetics and catalyst performance were analysed. Results showed that a steady steam reforming regime along with complete NiO reduction could be obtained after a coexistence stage of reduction and reforming. A 2D nucleation and nuclei growth model fitted the NiO auto-reduction. The maximum reduction rate constant was attained at S/C = 2. Steam reforming activity of the auto-reduced catalyst was just below that of the H₂-reduced catalyst, probably attributed to denser carbon filament formation and larger loss of active Ni. Despite this, a H₂ yield of 76.4% of the equilibrium value and HAc conversion of 88.97% were achieved at 750 °C and S/C = 3.     

Thermodynamic analyses of adsorption-enhanced steam reforming of glycerol for hydrogen production

A non-stoichiometric thermodynamic analysis is performed on the adsorption-enhanced steam reforming of glycerol for hydrogen production based on the principle of minimising the Gibbs free energy. The effects of temperature (600–1000 K), pressure (1–4 bar), water to glycerol feed ratio (3:1–12:1), percentage of CO₂ adsorption (0–99%) and molar ratio of carrier gas to feed reactants (1:1–5:1) on the reforming reactions and carbon formation are examined. The results show that the use of a CO₂ adsorbent enhances glycerol conversion to hydrogen and the maximum number of moles of hydrogen produced per mole of glycerol can be increased from 6 to 7 due to the CO₂ adsorption. The analyses suggest that the most favourable temperature for steam–glycerol reforming is between 800 and 850 K in the presence of a CO₂ adsorbent, which is about 100 K lower than that for reforming without CO₂ adsorption. Although high pressures are favourable for CO₂ adsorption, a lower operating pressure gives a higher overall hydrogen conversion. The most favourable water to glycerol feed ratio is found to be 9.0 above which the benefit becomes marginal. Carbon formation could occur at low water to glycerol feed ratios, and the use of a CO₂ adsorbent can suppress the formation reaction and substantially reduce the lower limit of the water to glycerol feed ratio for carbon formation.     

Thermodynamic analysis of hydrogen production by autothermal reforming of ethanol

Ethanol steam reforming (ESR) is a strong endothermic reaction and ideally it only produces hydrogen and carbon dioxide.     

Steam reforming of technical bioethanol for hydrogen production

Essentially all work on ethanol steam reforming so far has been carried out using simulated bioethanol feedstocks, which means pure ethanol mixed with water. However, technical bioethanol consists of a lot of different components including sugars, which cannot be easily vaporized and steam reformed. For ethanol steam reforming to be of practical interest, it is important to avoid the energy-intensive purification steps to fuel grade ethanol. Therefore, it is imperative to analyze how technical bioethanol, with the relevant impurities, reacts during the steam reforming process. We show how three different distillation fractions of technical 2nd generation bioethanol, produced in a pilot plant, influence the performance of nickel- and ruthenium-based catalysts during steam reforming, and we discuss what is required to obtain high activity and long catalyst lifetime. We conclude that the use of technical bioethanol will result in a faster catalyst deactivation than what is observed when using pure ethanol–water mixtures because of contaminants remaining in the feed. However, the initial activity of the catalysts are not affected by this, hence it is important to not only focus on catalyst activity but rather on the lifetime of the catalyst.     

Hydrogen production by steam reforming of bio-oil/bio-ethanol mixtures in a continuous thermal-catalytic process

The feasibility of the steam reforming of bio-oil aqueous fraction and bio-ethanol mixtures has been studied in a continuous process with two in-line steps: thermal step at 300 °C (for the controlled deposition of pyrolytic lignin during the heating of the bio-oil/bio-ethanol feed) followed by steam reforming in a fluidized bed reactor on a Ni/α-Al₂O₃ catalyst. The effect of bio-ethanol content in the feed has been analyzed in both the thermal and reforming steps, and the suitable range of operating conditions (temperature and space-time) has been determined for obtaining a high and steady hydrogen yield. Higher ethanol content in the mixture feed improves the reaction indices and reduces coke deposition. Operating conditions of 700 °C and space-times higher than 0.23 g_catalyst h (g_bio-oil+EtOH)⁻¹ are suitable for attaining almost fully conversion of oxygenates (bio-oil and ethanol) and hydrogen yields above 93%, with low catalyst deactivation.     

Thermodynamic analysis and heat integration for hydrogen production from bio-butanol for SOFC application: Steam reforming vs. autothermal reforming

Thermodynamic analysis of hydrogen production by steam reforming and autothermal reforming of bio-butanol was investigated for solid oxide fuel cell applications. The effects of reformer operating conditions, e.g., reformer temperature, steam to carbon molar ratio, and oxygen to carbon molar ratio, were investigated with the objective to maximize hydrogen production and to reduce utility requirements of the process and based on which favorable conditions of reformer were proposed. Process flow diagram for steam reforming and autothermal reforming integrated with solid oxide fuel cell was developed. Heat integration with pinch analysis method was carried out for both the processes at favorable reformer conditions. Power generation, electrical efficiency, useful energy for co-generation application, and utility requirements for both the processes were compared.