A farm-level evaluation of nitrogen and phosphorus fertilizer use and planting density for pearl millet production in Niger

Mineral fertilizer use is increasing in West Africa though little information is available on yield response in farmers' fields. Farmers in this region plant at low density (average 5,000 pockets ha^–1, 3 plants pocket^–1), which can affect fertilizer use efficiency. A study was conducted with 20 farmers in Niger to assess the response of pearl millet [Pennisetum glaucum (L.) R. Br.] to phosphorus and nitrogen fertilizers under farm conditions. In each field, treatments included control, single superphosphate (SSP) only, SSP plus N (point placed near plant), and either SSP or partially acidulated phosphate rock (PAPR) plus N broadcast. N and P were applied at 30 kg N ha^–1 and 30 kg P₂O₅ ha^–1. Farmers were allowed to plant, weed, etc., as they wished and they planted at densities ranging from 2,000 to 12,000 pockets ha^–1. In the absence of fertilizer, increasing density from 2,000 to 7,000 pockets ha^–1 increased yield by 400%. A strong interaction was found between fertilizer use and density. Farmers planting at densities less than 3,500 pockets ha^–1 had average yields of 317 kg grain ha^–1 while those planting at densities higher than 6,500 pockets ha^–1 showed average yields of 977 grain ha^–1. Though phosphate alone increased yields significantly at all densities, little response to fertilizer N was found at densities below 6,000 pockets ha^–1. Significant residual responses in 1987 and 1988 were found to P applied in high-density plots in 1986. Depending on fertilizer and grain prices, analysis showed that fertilizer use must be be combined with high plant density (10,000 pockets ha^–1) or no economic benefit from fertilizer use will be realized.     

Phosphorus seed coating increases phosphorus uptake,early growth and yield of pearl millet (Pennisetum glaucum (L.) R. Br.) grown on an acid sandy soil in Niger,West Africa

In pot and field experiments conducted in 1990 and 1991 on an acid sandy, phosphorus (P) deficient soil in Niger, West Africa, the effect of seed coating on seedling emergence, early growth and grain yield of pearl millet (Pennisetum glaucum (L.) R. Br.) was studied. Seeds of pearl millet were coated with different rates (0; 0.5; 1.0; 2.0; 5.0; 10.0 mg P seed^–1) and types of P fertilizers (single superphosphate, ammonium dihydrogen phosphate; monocalcium phosphate, sodium dihydrogen phosphate and sodium triphosphate). Seedling emergence was generally reduced at coating rates higher than 0.5 mg P seed^–1 and prevented with single superphosphate and sodium triphosphate at rates higher than 5 mg P seed^–1. No correlation was found between the pH and osmomolity of the coatings and final emergence of millet seedlings. The most favourable effect on plant growth and P content was achieved with ammonium dihydrogen phosphate (AHP) as seed coating. This was attributed to the enhancement effect of ammonium on P uptake. Compared to the untreated control dry matter production at 20 days after planting (DAP) was increased by 280%, P content per plant by 330%, total biomass at maturity by 30% and grain yield by 45%. Although seed coating with AHP may be harmful to seedlings emergence, it represents a suitable method to enhance early growth and increase yield of pearl millet.     

An empirical analysis of the simultaneous effects of nitrogen, phosphorus and potassium in millet production on spatially variable fields in SW Niger

Low soil fertility is a major constraint for increasing millet production on the acid sandy soils of the West African Sahel. On these soils, all three macronutrients: nitrogen (N), phosphate (P) and potassium (K), may be expected to limit crop yields. The important question is therefore: which of them is the most critical and would, if applied in small amounts, increase yields significantly? This paper addresses this question with an empirical approach, thus avoiding the commonly observed difficulty in the interpretation of agronomic research, caused by the extreme local soil variability which characterizes Sahelian coversands. We actually exploit soil variability by using novel non-parametric techniques for data exploration in combination with spatial methods of parametric model estimation. Apart from N, P and K, the effects of surface crusting, local topography, manure levels, farmer behaviour and spatial dependence are taken into account, since these may confound the true effects of N, P and K. A quadratic formulation conforms best to the data and explains 81 percent of the yield variation. The equation highlights the importance of interactions among variables and thus confirms the possible impact of native soil conditions on the outcome of fertilizer treatments in experimental research. The results of much earlier, multi-year, research are confirmed remarkably well by this single year study. In addition, a spatially explicit assessment on the crop response to increasing nutrient levels highlights that blanket fertilizer applications are inefficient, because yield increases in some places will be accompanied by yield decreases at other sites. Cash-constrained farmers therefore have to resort to precision farming techniques to maximize returns from minimal external input packages. However, a large part of the good explanation of millet yield variability over space derives from spatial autocorrelation, and not directly from topsoil N, P and K. This calls for further research on the factors that affect millet yield and on the characterization and classification of sites, followed by experimental work to design site-specific fertilizer technologies.     

The effect of crop residue and fertilizer use on pearl millet yields in Niger

A field study was conducted over a 4-year period in Niger, West Africa, to determine the effects of crop residue (CR), fertilizer, or a combination of crop residue and fertilizer (CRF) on yields of pearl millet (Pennisetum glaucum [L.] R. Br.). Despite a decline in yields of control plots (initial yields were 280 kg grain ha^–1 declining to 75 kg grain ha^–1 over 4 years), yields of fertilizer plots were maintained at 800–1,000 kg grain ha^–1. Continued application of CR slowly augmented yields to levels similar to those of the fertilized plots. The effects of CR and fertilizer were approximately additive in the CRF plots. Addition of CR and fertilizer increased soil water use over the control by 57 mm to 268 mm in an average season and helped trap wind-blown soil. These plots tended to exhibit slightly higher soil pH and lower Al saturation than did the fertilized treatments. Return of CR to the soil resulted in significantly reduced export of most plant nutrients, especially Ca, Mg, and K.     

Effect of planting technique and amendment type on pearl millet yield, nutrient uptake, and water use on degraded land in Niger

Due to increased population pressure and limited availability of fertile land, farmers on desert fringes increasingly rely on marginal land for agricultural production, which they have learned to rehabilitate with different technologies for soils and water conservation. One such method is the indigenous zai technique used in the Sahel. It combines water harvesting and targeted application of organic amendments by the use of small pits dug into the hardened soil. To study the resource use efficiency of this technique, experiments were conducted 1999–2000, on-station at ICRISAT in Niger, and on-farm at two locations on degraded lands. On-station, the effect of application rate of millet straw and cattle manure on millet dry matter production was studied. On-farm, the effects of organic amendment type (millet straw and cattle manure, at the rate of 300 g per plant) and water harvesting (with and without water harvesting) on millet grain yield, dry matter production, and water use were studied. First, the comparison of zai vs. flat planting, both unamended, resulted in a 3- to 4-fold (in one case, even 19-fold) increase in grain yield on-farm in both years, which points to the yield effects of improved water harvesting in the zai alone. Zai improved the water use efficiency by a factor of about 2. The yields increased further with the application of organic amendments. Manure resulted in 2–68 times better grain yields than no amendment and 2–7 times better grain yields than millet straw (higher on the more degraded soils). Millet dry matter produced per unit of manure N or K was higher than that of millet straw, a tendency that was similar for all rates of application. Zai improved nutrient uptake in the range of 43–64% for N, 50–87% for P and 58–66% for K. Zai increased grain yield produced per unit N (8 vs. 5 kg kg⁻¹) and K (10 vs. 6 kg kg⁻¹) compared to flat; so is the effect of cattle manure compared to millet straw (9 vs. 4 kg kg⁻¹, and 14 vs. 3 kg kg⁻¹), respectively, Therefore zai shows a good potential for increasing agronomic efficiency and nutrient use efficiency. Increasing the rate of cattle manure application from 1 to 3 t ha⁻¹ increased the yield by 115% TDM, but increasing the manure application rate further from 3 to 5 t ha⁻¹ only gave an additional 12% yield increase, which shows that optimum application rates are around 3t ha⁻¹.     

Evaluation of application timing in fertilizer micro-dosing technology on millet production in Niger,West Africa

Micro-dosing technology has been developed by the International Crops Research Institute for the Semi-Arid Tropics (ICRISAT) and its partners to help subsistence farmers in the Sahel improve inorganic fertilizer application. However, the ICRISAT's recommendations regarding fertilizer application through this technology are only applicable at sowing and do not allow any flexibility in terms of labor and/or capital management. In rural areas, fertilizer cannot always be applied at sowing due to financial and labor constraints. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the effect of the timing of fertilizer application on millet production. A 2-year on-station experiment and a 1-year on-farm field experiment were conducted in the western region of Niger, West Africa. Even under the heterogeneous climatic conditions of the region during our experimental period, the results showed that the trend was the same as observed in previous studies: millet production improved through fertilizer application compared to the control (without fertilizer). The harvest index was also higher compared to that of the control. This increased production was consistently the same for all application timings. The marginal value–cost ratio on the investment calculated using a budgeting analysis for the on-farm experiment showed that – regardless of application timing – millet farmers who fertilized their fields with inorganic fertilizer made more profit than those who did not (control). This was also true for farmers who were unable to fertilize at sowing – delayed application was still the more profitable option relative to the no fertilizer control. Our results indicate that small subsistence farmers can be offered more options for inorganic fertilizer application timing using the micro-dosing technology. Delayed inorganic fertilizer application can help small farmers who are often labor constrained at the sowing period improve their yields as well as their economic returns.

Phosphate fertilization in intensive annual cropping with wheatgreen gram (or cowpea) — pearl millet

In a four year study on a wheat-green gram (or cowpea) — pearl millet intensive cropping system a total production of 9–10 tonnes of wheat equivalents per year removed 29–30kg P ha^–1. If only 26 kg P ha^–1 was used then total grain production as well as P uptake, was highest when all the P was applied to wheat. Only when amounts larger than 26 kg P ha^–1 were applied was it justified to apply P to pearl millet and green gram (or cowpea). Productivity of the cropping system increased up to 58.5 kg P ha^–1 and at this level two thirds of P was applied to wheat, while pearl millet and green gram or cowpea received the remaining one-third. A positive P balance in soil was observed only when 26 k P ha^–1 yr^–1 or more was applied.Pressure of growing population and per capita diminution or arable land has focussed attention on multiple cropping systems in many Asian countries [1, 2]. In North-Western India the cropping system changed from a single rainy (July–October) or winter (November–April) crop a year prior to the 1960's to two-crops-a-year (both a rainy season and winter crop) in the 1970.s and then in the late 1970's a third summer (May–June) crop was also included. Wheat — green gram (or cowpea) — pearl millet is such a three-crops-a-year multiple cropping system.Phosphate is the costliest major plant nutrient in India and farmers following multiple cropping systems are keen to know the way the phosphate should be apportioned to different crops in a cropping system particularly when small amounts of P are applied. Such information can come only from long-term P fertilization experiments [3, 4]. The objective of the present experiment on a wheat-green gram (or cowpea) — pearl millet multiple cropping system was to study the direct and residual effects of P applied to one crop on the other crops grown in succession and to find the best possible way in which a limited amount of P could be apportioned between the different crops in the rotation. An attempt has also been made to work out the P balance in soil.     

Nitrogen fixation of and N transfer from cowpea, mungbean and groundnut when intercropped with maize

Grain legumes are used widely in intercropping systems. However, quantitative and comparative data available as to their N₂ fixation and N beneficial effect on the companion crop in intercropping systems are scarce. Hence, studies were conducted to ascertain the above when cowpea (Vigna unguiculata L.), mungbean (Vigna radiata L.) and groundnut (Arachis hypogaea L.) were intercropped with maize. The study was¹⁵N-aided and made outdoors in basins (30 L) filled with 38 kg of soil.¹⁵N labelling was effected by incorporating¹⁵N-tagged plant material or applying¹⁵N-labelled fertilizer along with sucrose to stabilize¹⁵N enrichment in the soil during the experimental period. Intercropped groundnut fixed the highest amount of nitrogen from the atmosphere (i.e. 552 mg plant^–1), deriving 85% of its N from the atmosphere. Intercropped cowpea and mungbean fixed 161 and 197 mg N plant^–1, obtaining 81% and 78% of their N content from the atmosphere, respectively. The proportion of N derived by maize from the associated legume varied from 7-11% for mungbean, 11–20% for cowpea and 12–26% for groundnut which amounted to about 19–22, 29–45 and 33–60 mg N maize plant^–1, respectively. The high nitrogen fixation potential of groundnut in dual stands and its relatively low harvest index for N have apparently contributed to greater N-benefical effect on the associated crop.     

Simulated weather variables effects on millet fertilized with phosphate rock in the Sahel

The Sudano–Sahelian agroecological zone is characterized by low and variable rainfall regimes and P deficiency. The present study complements previous research efforts and the objective was (i) to use the Newhall Simulation Model (NSM) to characterize three ICRISAT research sites, and (ii) to use output of NSM to develop an empirical model to guide efficient use of rainfall and fertilizers. The results show that length of the periods that rainfall exceeded evapotranspiration was larger in Bengou than in Gobery and Sadoré. Total positive moisture balance during the three growing seasons was 85.7 mm at Bengou and 19.7 mm at Sadoré. The model explained 52% of the variability in millet yields based on curvilinear response to P fertilizer, standardized May–June (R_mj) rainfall, and the number of wet days in the year (BW₃). Yields appear more sensitive to BW₃ than to R_mj. Their respective elasticity coefficients (E _c ) were 0.62 and 0.09. Assessment of the model using R²=0.76 and the D-index = 0.85 showed reasonable agreement between model estimation and actual field yields. The study demonstrates the application of simulation models as a cost-effective means in terms of time and funds to agronomic research.     

Direct and residual fertilizer phosphorus effects on yield and phosphorus efficiency of upland rice in an Ultisol

Phosphorus (P) deficiency is one of the major limiting factors for crop production in highly weathered soils in the humid zone of West Africa. Very few studies have evaluated the residual value of fertilizer P to rice in these soils. Field experiments were conducted for three years (1993–1995) to determine the response of four upland rice cultivars to fertilizer P applied at 0, 45, 90, 145 and 180 kg P ha^-1 only once in 1993, and to fertilizer P residues in 1994 and 1995. The soil at the experimental site, in the humid forest zone of Ivory Coast (West Africa), was an Ultisol, low in available P. Grain yields of the rice cultivars were significantly increased by fertilizer P in 1993, and by the fertilizer P residues in 1994 and 1995 although the magnitude of response decreased with time since the fertilizer was applied. The cultivars differed in cumulative agronomic and physiological efficiencies, and the efficiencies were higher at the lower rates of P. The amounts of total P removed in three successive crops were similar for all the four rice cultivars although P harvest index was 10–12% higher in the P efficient than inefficient cultivars. The results suggest that the differences observed in the P efficiency of rice cultivars are due to differences in the internal efficiency of P. This revised version was published online in August 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Yield response and nitrogen uptake of pearl millet (Pennisetum americanum (L.) Leeke) cultivars to nitrogen application in the savanna region of Nigeria

Field experiments were carried out during the wet seasons (May to September) of 1980 and 1981 in order to determine the response of five pearl millet cultivars to nitrogen fertilization in savanna region of Nigeria. There were varietal differences in yield and nitrogen uptake in response to nitrogen rates. Most cultivars responded significantly up to 75 kg N ha^–1. Hybrid outyielded other cultivars at both locations each year. Nitrogen use efficiency was highest with the Hybrid, compared to other cultivars.     

Yield and yield components of cowpea (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Vigna unguiculata</Emphasis> (L.) Walp.) as influenced by Sokoto phosphate rock and placement methods in the semi-arid zone of Nigeria

Phosphate rock with proper management could be a sustainable source of phosphorus for increased cowpea production on the Entisols of Sokoto Semi-arid zone. Therefore, field experiments were conducted in 2004 and 2005 rainy seasons to determine the influence of Sokoto phosphate rock (SPR) and placement methods on the yield of cowpea varieties. Treatments consisted of factorial combination of two varieties (Ba’adare and IAR48), three levels of SPR (25, 50 and 75 kg SPR ha⁻¹) along with a control (0 kg SPR ha⁻¹) and three placement methods (plough sole, broadcast and side-band) laid out in a randomized complete block design replicated 3 times. Results of phosphate rock and placement methods are presented in this paper. The study indicated significant (P < 0.01) response to applied SPR compared to control (1074 kg grain ha⁻¹) in most parameters studied. Application of 25 kg SPR ha⁻¹ significantly (P < 0.05) influenced higher pod yield and number of pods plant⁻¹ only in 2004 trial. But, shelling percentage, grain yield, stover yield, 1000-grain weight, harvest index (HI) and number of seeds pods⁻¹ were not influenced by SPR levels. Significantly (P < 0.05) higher pod yield in 2004, grain yield, 1000-grain weight and number of pods per plant in 2004 and 2005, HI, shelling percentage and number of seeds pod⁻¹ in 2005, were observed in plough-sole than broadcast and band-side methods of fertilizer placement. Therefore, from this study, it was concluded that SPR could be directly used as a source of P to sustain cowpea production (1527 kg grain ha⁻¹ with 25 kg SPR compared to 1074 kg ha⁻¹with 0 kg SPR). Application of 25 kg SPR ha⁻¹ (3.74 kg P ha⁻¹) using plough-sole method of fertilizer placement was most efficient under Sokoto semi-arid condition.     

油菜素内酯对施用苯磺隆后杂草防效及谷子产量的影响

[目的]明确油菜素内酯(BR)影响苯磺隆在谷田杂草防效及谷子产量方面的作用.[方法]在大田条件下,谷子3～5叶期时叶面喷施3个不同浓度的苯磺隆,喷施等量清水为对照,施药后3d喷施不同浓度的油菜素内酯,分别于施药后7、14、21、35 d调查杂草株防效及鲜质量防效,谷子收获后进行考种测产.[结果]随着单用苯磺隆浓度升高,...     

Response of maize (Zea mays) to phosphorus application on basaltic soils in Northwestern Cameroon

A field trial was conducted on two P sorptive, basaltic soils commonly used for maize production in Northwestern Cameroon. The objective was to determine the maintenance P rates required for adequate P supply in the soils for maize after initial capital dressing applications of P (0, 22, 44, 88 and 132 kg ha^-1) in 1991. These were followed by three supplementary P rates – 0, 44 and 88 kg ha^-1 in 1992. Three crops of maize (cv COCA) were grown to monitor the availability of the residual P. Experimental design was randomized complete block with four replications in 1991 and a split-plot in 1992 and 1993. The soils at the experimental sites were rich in organic P which formed 67% and 57% of total P at Mfonta and Babungo respectively. Laboratory P sorption studies indicated high P requirements by the basaltic soils used in the study. The amounts of P sorbed to attain 0.2 ug g^-1 in soil solution were 1200 ug g^-1 at Mfonta and 600 ug g^-1 at Babungo. In spite of these high P sorption capacities, significant responses to small rates of P application were observed. It was concluded that a sizable proportion of P released from organic P mineralization was used to satisfy P sorption capacity of the soils, resulting in maize response to small rates of fertilizer P application. Residual P effects on maize yield were related to applied P. Bray 1 extractable soil P was weakly related to grain yields (r = 0.136 at Mfonta and r = 0.186 at Babungo). A critical value of 5.5 mg kg^-1 Bray 2 extractable P in the soil was established for maize at Mfonta site. About 44 kg P ha^-1 was recommended for maize at this site when Bray 2 soil P test was below this critical value.     

Effect of liming and carbofuran on groundnut yield in sandy soils in Niger

One of the constraints to groundnut production in sandy soils of Niger is crop growth variability. In early 1989, a trial on the effect of lime and carbofuran on soil pH, Al toxicity, nematode population and groundnut yield was initiated to study crop growth variability. Groundnut was sown in the 1989 rainy season, followed by pearl millet (Pennisatum glaucum) in the 1989–90 dry season and again groundnut in the 1990–91 rainy, and dry seasons. In 1989 the carbofuran treatment increased the pod yield. Lime application did not change the pH and exchangeable Al⁺⁺⁺ contents in the soil and did not increase groundnut yield. In the 1990–91 rainy and dry season, however, the application of 10 t ha^–1 of lime increased pH, decreased exchangeable Al⁺⁺⁺, improved crop growth and increased the yield of groundnut to the same level as was achieved by the carbofuran treatment. Application of lime did not affect the nematode population, which were reduced by the carbofuran.International Crops Research Institute for the Semi-Arid Tropics (ICRISAT); Submitted as ICRISAT Journal Article No 1228(via Paris)     

The effect of nitrogen,phosphorus and potassium fertilizer applications on the seed yield of sunflower (Helianthus annuus L.) grown on sandy soils and the prediction of phosphorus and potassium responses by soil tests

The nitrogen, phosphorus and potassium requirement of sunflower was evaluated when the crop was grown on siliceous sands overlying clay in the south east of South Australia. Of the seven sites used in the investigation, significant seed yield responses to phosphorus were recorded at two, while at a further two sites seed yields were increased by potassium additions. Nitrogen applications did not significantly increase seed yields at any site but decreased seed yields at two. This lack of nitrogen response was attributed to the sites having been long term legume pastures prior to the sunflower crops.Oil concentrations of sunflower seed ranged from 40.6% to 45.3% between sites, but fertilizer treatment had no significant effect.Critical nutrient ranges for both soil (Colwell) extractable phosphorus and potassium were derived at maximum seed yield. These were 16–20 mg kg^–1 for extractable phosphorus and 70–80 mg kg^–1 for extractable potassium.     

Impact of Ozone on Morphological,Physiological, and Biochemical Changes in Cow Pea (Vigna unguiculata [L.] Walp.)

Morphological and biochemical responses to Acute Ozone Exposure (AOE) by Vigna unguiculata (L.) Walp. cultivar variety CO6 was studied. Plants were grown in controlled conditions and exposed to ozone at 40, 50, 60, 70, and 80 ppbv (T₁-T₅) for 15 min twice a day. Variation among shoot and root length, shoot-root ratio, fresh (FW), dry (DW) weight, leaf area (LA), leaf area ratio (LAR), number of guard cells (G), epidermal cells (E) (abaxial and adaxial), stomatal index (SI), chlorophyll a and b, total chlorophyll (TC), chlorophyll a/b ratio, chlorophyll protein ratio (CPR), ascorbic acid (AA), total phenol (TP), Proline (Pro), nitrate reductase activity (NRA) and Urease activity (UA) were measured in control and ozone-treated plants. The ozone treatment resulted in increase in dry weight, shoot length, leaf area, and number of epidermal cells, stomata and total chlorophyll on exposure up to 60 ppbv. Nitrate Reductase (EC: 1.6.6.3) and Urease (EC: 3.5.15) activities were inhibited by ozone.     

Simulating phosphorus responses in annual crops using APSIM: model evaluation on contrasting soil types

Crop simulation models have been used successfully to evaluate many systems and the impact of change on these systems, e.g. for climatic risk and the use of alternative management options, including the use of nitrogen fertilisers. However, for low input systems in tropical and subtropical regions where organic inputs rather than fertilisers are the predominant nutrient management option and other nutrients besides nitrogen (particular phosphorus) constrain crop growth, these models are not up to the task. This paper describes progress towards developing a capability to simulate response to phosphorus (P) within the APSIM (Agricultural Production Systems Simulator) framework. It reports the development of the P routines based on maize crops grown in semi-arid eastern Kenya, and validation in contrasting soils in western Kenya and South-western Colombia to demonstrate the robustness of the routines. The creation of this capability required: (1) a new module (APSIM SoilP) that simulates the dynamics of P in soil and is able to account for effectiveness of alternative fertiliser management (i.e. water-soluble versus rock phosphate sources, placement effects); (2) a link to the modules simulating the dynamics of carbon and nitrogen in soil organic matter, crop residues, etc., in order that the P present in such materials can be accounted for; and (3) modification to crop modules to represent the P uptake process, estimation of the P stress in the crop, and consequent restrictions to the plant growth processes of photosynthesis, leaf expansion, phenology and grain filling. Modelling results show that the P routines in APSIM can be specified to produce output that matches multi-season rotations of different crops, on a contrasting soil type to previous evaluations, with very few changes to the parameterization files. Model performance in predicting the growth of maize and bean crops grown in rotation on an Andisol with different sources and rates of P was good (75–87% of variance could be explained). This is the first published example of extending APSIM P routines to another crop (beans) from maize. Dr R. J. Delve has recently left CIAT and joined Catholic Relief Services, Kenya.     

Development and evaluation of an improved soil test for phosphorus. 2. Comparison of the Olsen and mixed cation-anion exchange resin tests for predicting the yield of ryegrass grown in pots

A glasshouse experiment was conducted on four soils contrasting in P sorption capacity and exchangeable Ca content with perennial ryegrass using six phosphate rock (PR) sources and a soluble P source applied at four rates (including a control). After three harvests (11 weeks) replicate pots of each treatment were destructively sampled and Olsen P and mixed cation-anion exchange resin (Resin P) extractions carried out. The remaining replicated treatments were harvested another seven times (during 41 weeks). Yields (for the last seven harvests) were expressed as percentages of the maximum yield attainable with MCP.In general, the Resin P test extracted more than twice as much P as the Olsen test. There was a significant increase in Resin P with an increase in the amount of each P source in all four soils, but Olsen P values were not significantly different for soils treated with different rates of each phosphate rock. The abilities of the Olsen and mixed resin soil P tests to predict the cumulative dry matter yield from 7 harvests and the relative yield of ryegrass were compared. Correlations between measured yield (for the last 7 harvests) and soil test for each soil, and relative yield and soil test for all four soils were assessed by regression analysis using Mitscherlich-type models.When dry matter yields were regressed separately against soil test values for each soil, the Resin P consistently accounted for 18–28% more of the variation in yield than did Olsen P. For Resin P a single function was not significantly different from the separate functions fitted to MCP and PR treatments. However, for Olsen P the separate functions for the MCP and PR treatments varied significantly from the single fitted function. The Resin P test (R² = 0.84) was a better predictor of relative yields over this range of soils than the Olsen test (R² = 0.75). Two regression models based on the regression of relative yield for MCP treatments against either Olsen or Resin were developed. These models were then fitted to the relative yield data on soils fertilized with PRs only. The Olsen P model was found to be a poorer predictor (R² = 0.41) than the Resin P model (R² = 0.73) because it underestimated the observed yield of the PR treatments.     

Predicting plant yields using soil testing for phosphorus: Effects of error in the estimation of the maximum yield on interseasonal comparisons of yield prediction

Results from long-term field experiments in south-western Australia are presented in the form of relationships between yield, expressed as a percentage of the maximum yield, and soil test for phosphorus (P) values. Maximum yields were not always indicated by well defined yield plateaux. Different methods have been used to estimate the maximum yield value which is used to calculate yield as a percentage of the maximum yield so as to remove interseasonal variation. For all of these methods and for the same site, the same P fertilizer (superphosphate), and the same plant species, the relationship between yield and soil test P differed for different years. Consequently fertilizer recommendations based on the assumption that this relationship is constant are likely to be incorrect. We therefore question the validity of the common practice in soil testing programmes of using percentage yield values to remove interseasonal variation.