A mechanistic study of enantiomeric separation with vancomycin and balhimycin as chiral selectors by capillary electrophoresis. Dimerization and enantioselectivity

The role of the sugar moiety of glycopeptide antibiotics in chiral recognition was investigated with capillary electrophoresis. Two glycopeptide antibiotics, vancomycin and balhimycin, were employed as models since they possess the same aglycon and almost identical sugar moieties, however, with different attachment sites to the aglycon. The observed enantioselectivity of balhimycin for dansylated alpha-amino acids is 2.6 times higher than that of vancomycin. Blocking of the sugar amino group of balhimycin by N-carbamoylation reaction with KOCN led to a significantly decreased enantioselectivity compared to vancomycin, which remained almost the same upon carbamoylation. These results suggest a major role of the amino sugar together with its site of attachment to the aglycon. A dimerization-based mechanism is proposed to explain this phenomenon due to the fact that the dimerization properties of glycopeptides are similarly related to their glycosylation patterns; e.g., the dimerization constant of balhimycin is 78 times higher than that of vancomycin. Furthermore, the dimerization of glycopeptides promotes their affinity to carboxyl-containing ligands via cooperativity effects between the dimerization and the formation of glycopeptide-ligand complexes. The higher dimer stability probably leads to a more favorable conformation for chiral recognition. Thus, it is concluded that a weakened dimerization of N-carbamoylated balhimycin results in a decreased enantioselectivity.     

Direct resolution of optically active isomers on chiral packings containing ergoline skeletons. 5. Enantioseparation of amino Acid derivatives

A new procedure for ergot alkaloid-based chiral stationary phase preparation is described. Synthesis is based on bonding the allyl derivative of terguride to mercaptopropylsilanized silica gel. The packing exhibits higher content of chiral selector, stability, reproducibility, and enantioselectivity toward amino acids compared to that previously studied. The chromatographic behavior of amino acids with different side chains and substituent groups is investigated in order to obtain a deeper insight into the enantiodiscriminative mechanism as well as to determine the limitations and strengths of terguride as a chiral selector for this class of compounds. A variety of factors, including mobile phase parameters such as pH, ionic strength, content and nature of organic modifier, and temperature, are examined.     

Theory and use of the pseudophase model in gas-liquid chromatographic enantiomeric separations

The theory and use of the "three-phase" model in enantioselective gas-liquid chromatography utilizing a methylated cyclodextrin/polysiloxane stationary phase is presented for the first time. Equations are derived that account for all three partition equilibria in the system, including partitioning between the gas mobile phase and both stationary-phase components and the analyte equilibrium between the polysiloxane and cyclodextrin pseudophase. The separation of the retention contributions from the achiral and chiral parts of the stationary phase can be easily accomplished. Also, it allows the direct examination of the two contributions to enantioselctivity, i.e., that which occurs completely in the liquid stationary phase versus the direct transfer of the chiral analyte in the gas phase to the dissolved chiral selector. Six compounds were studied to verify the model: 1-phenylethanol, alpha-ionone, 3-methyl-1-indanone, o-(chloromethyl)phenyl sulfoxide, o-(bromomethyl)phenyl sulfoxide, and ethyl p-tolylsulfonate. Generally, the cyclodextrin component of the stationary phase contributes to retention more than the bulk liquid polysiloxane. This may be an important requirement for effective GC chiral stationary phases. In addition, the roles of enthalpy and entropy toward enantiorecognition by this stationary phase were examined. While enantiomeric differences in both enthalpy and entropy provide chiral discrimination, the contribution of entropy appears to be more significant in this regard. The three-phase model may be applied to any gas-liquid chromatography stationary phase involving a pseudophase.     

Retention and selectivity of teicoplanin stationary phases after copper complexation and isotopic exchange

Teicoplanin is a macrocyclic glycopeptide that is highly effective as a chiral selector for LC enantiomeric separations. Two possible interaction paths were investigated and related to solute retention and selectivity: (1) interactions with the only teicoplanin amine group and (2) role of hydrogen bonding interactions. Mobile phases containing 0.5 and 5 mM copper ions were used to try to block the amine group. In the presence of copper ions, it was found that the teicoplanin stationary phase has a decreased ability to separate most underivatized racemic amino acids. However, it maintained its ability to separate enantiomers that were not alpha-amino acids. It is established that there is little copper-teicoplanin complex formation. The effect of Cu2+ on the enantioseparation of some alpha-amino acids appears to be due to the fact that these solutes are good bidentate ligands and form complexes with copper ions in the mobile phase. Isotopic exchange with deuterium oxide was performed using acetonitrile-heavy water mobile phases. It was found that the retention times of all amino acids were lower with deuterated mobile phases. The retention times of polar or apolar molecules without amine groups were higher with deuterated mobiles phases. In all cases, the enantioselectivity factors were unaffected by the deuterium exchange. It is proposed that the electrostatic interactions are decreased in the deuterated mobile phases and the solute-accessible stationary-phase volume is somewhat swollen by deuterium oxide. The balance of these effects is a decrease in the amino acid retention times and an increase in the apolar solute retention time. The enantioselectivity factors of all of the molecules remain unchanged because all of the interactions are changed equally. We propose a new global quality criterion (the E factor) for comparing and evaluating enantiomeric separations.     

Introducing Enantioselective Ultrahigh-Pressure Liquid Chromatography (eUHPLC): Theoretical Inspections and Ultrafast Separations on a New Sub-2-μm Whelk-O1 Stationary Phase

A new chiral stationary phase for ultrahigh-pressure liquid chromatography (UHPLC) applications was prepared by covalent attachment of the Whelk-O1 selector to spherical, high-surface-area 1.7-μm porous silica particles. Columns of varying dimensions (lengths of 50, 75, 100, and 150 mm and internal diameters of 3.0 or 4.6 mm) were packed and characterized in terms of permeability, efficiency, retention, and enantioselectivity, using both organic and water-rich mobile phases. A conventional HPLC Whelk-O1 column based on 5.0-μm porous silica particles and packed in a 250 mm × 4.6 mm column was used as a reference. Van Deemter curves, generated with low-molecular-weight solutes on a 100 mm × 4.6 mm column packed with the 1.7-μm particles, showed H(min) (μm) and μ(opt) (mm/s) values of 4.10 and 5.22 under normal-phase and 3.74 and 4.34 under reversed-phase elution conditions. The flat C term of the van Deemter curves observed with the 1.7-μm particles allowed the use of higher-than-optimal flow rates without significant efficiency loss. Kinetic plots constructed from van Deemter data confirmed the ability of the column packed with the 1.7-μm particles to afford subminute separations with good efficiency and its superior performances in the high-speed regime, compared to the column packed with 5.0-μm particles. Resolutions in the time scale of seconds were obtained using a 50-mm-long column in the normal phase or polar organic mode. The intrinsic kinetic performances of 1.7-μm silica particles are retained in the Whelk-O1 chiral stationary phase, clearly demonstrating the potentials of enantioselective UHPLC in terms of high speed, throughput, and resolution.     

Empirical procedure that uses molecular structure to predict enantioselectivity of chiral stationary phases.

A total of 121 racemic compounds were separated in the normal-phase mode on a (S)-(1-naphthylethyl)carbamoylated beta-cyclodextrin (S-NEC-beta-CD) bonded phase and 74 on the R equivalent (R-NEC) chiral stationary phase (CSP). All compounds are of the type that have four substituents on a stereogenic center, rather than an "axis of chirality". It is shown that the binary solvent pair used as the mobile phase has a significant influence on chiral recognition. However, the proportions of the components of a specific pair have little effect. From the results, the individual contributions to chiral recognition by these CSPs were estimated for 81 different substituents of the stereogenic center. Varying the arrangement of these 81 substituents could produce over 1.6 million compounds. Hydrogen was chosen as the reference substituent and was assigned a 0 cal/mol free energy. The chiral recognition increased when sp2-hybridized carbons were connected to the stereogenic center. Conversely, sp3-hybridized carbons decreased the enantioselectivity. Amido groups increased the chiral recognition, especially when associated with pi-acid (3,5-dinitrobenzoyl) or pi-basic (naphthyl) groups. This approach does not allow one to know which enantiomer elutes first. However, the "substituent energy" list for chiral compounds can be used to obtain an estimated value for the enantioselectivity of a compound by adding the energy contributions of the four substituents connected to the stereogenic center. In this way one can predict a priori whether or not a compound will separate on a CSP and estimate its separation factor (alpha). Theoretically, this approach can be used for most CSPs, provided a sufficient data base is generated on them.     

A study of the enthalpy and entropy contributions of the stationary phase in reversed-phase liquid chromatography

The goal of this study was to elucidate the roles played by the stationary and mobile phases in retention in reversed-phase liquid chromatography (RPLC) in terms of their individual enthalpic and entropic contribution to the Gibbs free energy of retention. The experimental approach involved measuring standard enthalpies of transfer of alkylbenzenes from typical mobile phases used in RPLC (methanol/water and acetonitrile/water mixtures), as well as from n-hexadecane (a simple analogue of the stationary phase) to the gas phase, using high-precision headspace gas chromatography. By combining the measured enthalpies with independently measured free energies of transfer, the entropies of transfer were obtained. This allowed us to examine more fully the contribution that each phase makes to the overall retention. It was found that the standard enthalpy of retention in RPLC (i.e., solute transfer from the mobile phase to the stationary phase) is favorable, due to the large and favorable stationary-phase contribution, which actually overcomes an unfavorable mobile-phase contribution to the enthalpy of retention. Further, the net free energy of retention is favorable due to the favorable enthalpic contribution to retention, which arises from the net interactions in the stationary phase. Entropic contributions to retention are not controlling. Therefore, to a great extent, retention is due to enthalpically dominated lipophilic interaction of nonpolar solutes with the stationary phase and not from solvophobic processes in the mobile phase. Further, our enthalpy data support a "partition-like" mechanism of retention rather than an "adsorption-like" mechanism. These results indicate that the stationary phase plays a very significant role in the overall retention process. Our conclusions are in direct contrast to the solvophobic model that has been used extensively to interpret retention in RPLC.     

色氨酸在自制牛血清白蛋白手性柱上的拆分

利用三氯聚氰活化的氨丙基硅胶与牛血清白蛋白反应,快速而经济地制得牛血清白蛋白手性固定相。在反相模式下,将该手性固定相用于色氨酸的拆分,系统探讨了流动相pH值、柱温、有机修饰剂的种类及含量等对手性拆分的影响。色氨酸在自制牛血清白蛋白手性柱上得到了理想的拆分,分离因子可达4.33。     

Comparative study of hydrocarbon, fluorocarbon, and aromatic bonded RP-HPLC stationary phases by linear solvation energy relationships.

The retention properties of eight alkyl, aromatic, and fluorinated reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography bonded phases were characterized through the use of linear solvation energy relationships (LSERs). The stationary phases were investigated in a series of methanol/water mobile phases. LSER results show that solute molecular size and hydrogen bond acceptor basicity under all conditions are the two dominant retention controlling factors and that these two factors are linearly correlated when either different stationary phases at a fixed mobile-phase composition or different mobile-phase compositions at a fixed stationary phase are considered. The large variation in the dependence of retention on solute molecular volume as only the stationary phase is changed indicates that the dispersive interactions between nonpolar solutes and the stationary phase are quite significant relative to the energy of the mobile-phase cavity formation process. PCA results indicate that one PCA factor is required to explain the data when stationary phases of the same chemical nature (alkyl, aromatic, and fluoroalkyl phases) are individually considered. However, three PCA factors are not quite sufficient to explain the whole data set for the three classes of stationary phases. Despite this, the average standard deviation obtained by the use of these principal component factors are significantly smaller than the average standard deviation obtained by the LSER approach. In addition, selectivities predicted through the LSER equation are not in complete agreement with experimental results. These results show that the LSER model does not properly account for all molecular interactions involved in RP-HPLC. The failure could reside in the V2 solute parameter used to account for both dispersive and cohesive interactions since "shape selectivity" predictions for a pair of structural isomers are very bad.     

Empirical observations and mechanistic insights on the first boron-containing chiral selector for LC and supercritical fluid chromatography

Boromycin is a macrodiolide that exists as a hydrophobic B?eseken complex formed from boric acid and a chiral polyhydroxy macrocyclic ligand. It was covalently bonded to silica gel through a urea linkage to an attached d-valine ester. When evaluated as a chiral stationary phase, it shows pronounced enantioselectivity toward primary amine-containing racemates, separating 98% of those tested. The selectivity is most pronounced in the presence of organic solvents and supercritical CO2 + methanol. The enantioselective binding site and mechanistic factors are examined. Analytes can be complexed as either the free base or their protonated analogues, with the free base being more strongly associated with the chiral selector.     

Heterogeneous adsorption of 1-indanol on cellulose tribenzoate and adsorption energy distribution of the two enantiomers

The distributions of the adsorption energies (AED) of two enantiomers, (R)-1- indanol and (S)-1-indanol, on a chiral stationary phase were measured and the results are discussed. The chiral phase used is made of cellulose tribenzoate coated on porous silica. The AEDs were determined using the expectation maximization method, a numerical method that uses directly the raw experimental isotherm data, inverts this set of data into an AED, and introduces no arbitrary information in the calculation. However, it uses the Langmuir equation as the local isotherm. The experimental data fit very well to the bi-Langmuir isotherm model for the more retained enantiomer. Our results show that the AEDs of these two enantiomers have no energy modes that would be identical (same mean energy, mode profile, and mode area), in contrast to numerous cases previously studied, e.g., that of the beta-blockers on a Cel7A column. This indicates a significantly different retention mechanism.     

Effects of Mobile-Phase Composition and Temperature on the Selectivity of Poly(N-isopropylacrylamide)-Bonded Silica Gel in Reversed-Phase Liquid Chromatography

We developed a simple preparation method for poly(N-isopropylacrylamide) (poly(NIPAM))-bonded silica using a water-organic two-phase system to directly copolymerize N-isopropylacrylamide with 3-(methacryloxy)propyl moieties on the silica surfaces. The stationary phase showed a phase transition with the change in temperature or in methanol content, resulting in notable changes in selectivity which cannot be expected with alkyl-type stationary phases. The packing material showed an increase in retention and column efficiency with the increase in temperature between 30 and 40 °C or in methanol content between 10 and 20%. The temperature-responsive properties were reduced with the increase in methanol content of the mobile phase and lost at 40% or higher. Significant changes in retention selectivity by the addition of methanol were observed for benzene derivatives below the transition temperature of poly(NIPAM). The preferential retention of hydrogen bond acceptors was observed at low temperatures in the mobile phase of low methanol content, while dominant contribution of the hydrophobic interaction to the retention of solutes was observed at the higher temperature in aqueous mobile phase or at the higher methanol concentration. The temperature increase brought about similar changes in retention behavior of the poly(NIPAM)-bonded silica packing materials to the addition of methanol to the mobile phase.     

Temperature-Responsive Chromatography Using Poly(N-isopropylacrylamide)-Modified Silica

A new concept in chromatography is proposed that utilizes a temperature-responsive surface with a constant aqueous mobile phase. The surface of the silica stationary phase in high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) has been modified with temperature-responsive polymers to exhibit temperature-controlled hydrophilic/hydrophobic changes. Poly(N-isopropylacrylamide) (PIPAAm) was grafted onto (aminopropyl)silica using an activated ester-amine coupling method. These grafted silica surfaces show hydrophilic properties at lower temperatures which, as temperature increases, transform to hydrophobic surface properties. The elution profile of five mixed steroids on an HPLC column packed with this material depends largely on the temperature of the aqueous mobile phase. Retention times increase with increasing temperature without any change in the eluent. Changes in the retention times of hydrophobic steroids were larger than those for hydrophilic steroids. The temperature-responsive interaction between PIPAAm-modified silica and these steroids is proposed to result from changes in the surface properties of the HPLC stationary phase by the transition of hydrophilic/hydrophobic surface-grafted IPAAm polymers. We demonstrate a novel and useful new chromatography system in which surface properties and the resulting function of the HPLC stationary phase are controlled by external temperature changes. This method should be effective in biological and biomedical separations of peptides and proteins using only aqueous mobile phases.     

Geometrical model for the retention of fullerenes in high-performance liquid chromatography

In high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) using a poly(octadecylsiloxane) as a stationary phase, methanol as a mobile phase, C(60) and C(70) fullerenes as solutes, and water as a mobile phase modifier, a study on the surface tension effect of water on fullerene retention was carried out by varying the water concentration [W] and the column temperature T. The thermodynamic parameters for fullerene transfer from the mobile to the stationary phase were determined from linear van't Hoff plots. An enthalpy-entropy compensation revealed that the types of interactions between fullerenes and the stationary phase were independent of the fullerene structure and the mobile phase composition. An analysis of the experimental variations of the retention factor and the selectivity values with [W] was performed using a novel geometrical model. It was shown that the increase in fullerene retention accompanying the water concentration was due to the increased effects of surface tension. This brought about an increase in the interactions between fullerene and the stationary phase, explaining the observed thermodynamic parameter trends over the water concentration range. The theoretical model provided an estimation of the radius of fullerene which was found for C(60) to be equal to 3.3 ? and an activation energy during the transfer equal to 9.8 kJ/mol.     

A thermodynamic study of the temperature-dependent elution order of cyclic alpha-amino acid enantiomers on a copper(II)-D-penicillamine chiral stationary phase

The reversal of the elution order of cyclic alpha-amino acid enantiomers as a function of the temperature on a copper(II)-N,S-dioctyl-D-penicillamine ligand-exchange column is described. The thermodynamic parameters accounting for the retention and the separation of analytes were determined by means of van't Hoff plots. The influence of different chromatographic conditions on these parameters was investigated, showing little effect of the Cu(II) concentration in the eluent but strong influence of the organic modifier content on the separation. Further, the pH of the mobile phase was found to be a determining factor for the retention of the analytes. Based on these findings, a separation mechanism is postulated comprising the importance of complex formation for primary docking at the stationary phase, while hydrophobic interactions are crucial for chiral discrimination.     

An alternative procedure to screen mixture combinatorial libraries for selectors for chiral chromatography

An alternative process for the analysis of mixture library components for their potential as selectors for chiral chromatography is described. The procedure involves the immobilization of each enantiomer of the target racemic analyte to silica gel, followed by incubation of each resulting stationary phase with a mixture library. The adsorbed library components on the two stationary phases are then analyzed by reversed-phase liquid chromatography. A comparison of the resulting two chromatograms is made. Any peak of identical retention time but with a significant difference in intensity in the two chromatograms indicates that this component is most likely a chiral selector. Its chemical structure is then determined by LC-MS or LC-MS-MS. This new screening method significantly increases the efficiency of chiral selector determination by eliminating the need for multilibrary syntheses, as opposed to our previous method. This technique should also allow for the screening of much larger libraries as compared to our previous work.     

Retention mechanism in reversed-phase liquid chromatography: a molecular perspective

A detailed, molecular-level understanding of the retention mechanism in reversed-phase liquid chromatography (RPLC) has eluded analytical chemists for decades. Through validated, particle-based Monte Carlo simulations of a model RPLC system consisting of dimethyloctadecylsilanes at a coverage of 2.9 micro mol/m2 on an explicit silica substrate with unprotected residual silanols in contact with a water/methanol mobile phase, we show that the molecular-level retention processes for nonpolar and polar analytes, such as alkanes and alcohols, are much more complex than what has been previously deduced from thermodynamic and theoretical arguments. In contrast to some previous assumptions, the simulations indicate that both partitioning and adsorption play a key role in the separation process and that the stationary phase in RPLC behaves substantially different from a bulk hydrocarbon phase. The retention of nonpolar methylene segments is dominated by lipophilic interactions with the retentive phase, while solvophilic interactions are more important for the retention of the polar hydroxyl group.     

Influence of charge regulation in electrostatic interaction chromatography of proteins

Recently, the "slab model" was proposed to describe the interaction between a protein and the charged stationary phase surface in electrostatic interaction chromatography. The model is based on the solution of the linearized Poisson-Boltzmann equation for a system consisting of two charged planar surfaces in contact with an electrolyte solution. In the model it is assumed that the charge densities of both the protein and the stationary phase are constant during the adsorption process. However, as the protein comes close to the oppositely charged stationary phase surface, the protein net charge will change due to the electrical field from the stationary phase. In this paper, the theory for charge regulation is applied to the original slab model, and simple algebraic equations are developed in order to include the effect of charge regulation on the capacity factor. A large body of retention data are reanalyzed with the new model, and it is found that there is good agreement between the chromatographically and titrimetrically obtained protein net charge. An interesting consequence of charge regulation is that it gives a contribution to the retention of proteins with zero net charge and even to proteins with the same sign of charge as the stationary phase.     

Application of cyclam-capped beta-cyclodextrin-bonded silica particles as a chiral stationary phase in capillary electrochromatography for enantiomeric separations

Two novel types of substituted cyclam-capped beta-cyclodextrin (beta-CD)-bonded silica particles have been prepared and used as chiral stationary phases in capillary electrochromatography (CEC). The two stationary phases have a chiral selector with three recognition sites: beta-CD, cyclam, and the latter's sidearm. They exhibit excellent enantioselectivities in CEC for a wide range of compounds as a result of the cooperative functioning of the anchored beta-CD and cyclam. After inclusion of the metal ion (Ni2+) from the running buffer into the substituted cyclams and their sidearm ligands, the bonded stationary phases become positively charged and can provide extra electrostatic interactions with ionizable solutes and enhance the dipolar interactions with some polar neutral solutes. This enhances the host-guest interaction with some solutes and improves chiral recognition and enantioselectivity. These new types of stationary phases exhibit great potential for fast chiral separations in CEC.     

色氨酸在自制人血清白蛋白手性柱上的拆分及手性识别机理研究

人血清白蛋白与三氯聚氰活化的氨丙基硅胶反应,制得人血清白蛋白键合手性固定相。反相模式下,色氨酸在该手性固定相上获得理想的拆分,分离因子可达3.51,分离度达5.49。探讨了流动相p H值、有机修饰剂、柱温等对手性拆分的影响。通过前沿分析法对色谱保留机理进行了探讨。